Free Response in Opposition to Motion - District Court of Arizona - Arizona

; A 1 ‘ A 1 4 , A 1 A __\ji_FlLED __; LODGED A
A A _ 1 ` , Y ________ FRECENED ___ COPY U
A V .?(:E/‘·»01’71"*f LEE; UUA?{l\>,_I’*i%B~S6 _ ·MAR2420g8 ‘ 1
A , .;HK`»2¤uA· $1%% masw (ch/L·‘¢><%f»¤/2E~°£ A €`}LEF*?€AU9D!STR§CT,C©URT
‘ ` _ » _ 1 e . _ eee1t=u@1 ee 1 V
—— S¤“’T*A */’*’*T AA . =- .1
. A Pos`? 0/Flacg A /2OA>< QYQC) 1 _1 _ A
A __H0l2€~¢.Q, HRYZQN,} ggggg.-3*/o0~ . f I 1 A 1 A `
» _ _jPoq7»v‘li»’*; PP.0¥I’£/{ ; 1 , _ » 1 ·» A
, __ A JZAJ U,u1.1’1&D S7`»‘?*T?$ ’ DaSTfZ»C·(· (g¤BT” A 1
.; V , e» . FOR _ "71'E. I>¢$‘ffZ»¤7` 0/· A·R`q?0M4— lr
A ..'|/J:/»»e¤TH"{ A Léé wx/A·f2x>! _ · —c;/+52 N0. que-c3·13A1$°i —P!+><·AR0S
”'¢1~‘7*“, 1 A AA
A A A — P¤Aw11.M·S RES/’¤»e$$ +0 z>$fé~¤=w+S e
1 A __ v.s,, 1 1 A__ ‘/"'O+{c>»~J' {Og 1.z»»¤g 1+.;, ébé 4
A.,, M 1 1 ‘A° _ Q e~w».w~( A Rssrwseas +¤ Pmwfw/P5 1 A
4 A __ SGT, CA-BR, €T· H'?) 1 /°>O—H pm} QR Lifrvi AT7}»¤¢g
A _ _i _ _ DQFp$A`·Hg¢\.>§. _,q,;y1; H'F{Q1/\§‘T'/,7%/Q7-
. 1 _ · A ¢>QfEM>#—1~1°$ . C¢`AlT V R€PO1a+2I2 A . A 1 AA A
A .. A 1 C0/'-WS Now; TH}, AA vp!/h~7T·’¢,· {EM °~r)·r»{ LEL “ &AJA·D-D, eA
1”@°"’€*% Am 1 H2€%¤¥ em/¤~<>2s +<> ¤>e»¢sp¤·~+@ ~
1_ ei/‘¢°¥1<¤’=’ .v%& j!»%/wi. _A +0 ‘ 1 +€_LL 1vu1*¤m4M~A R2;/¤.eséS -1-61 A
· LE ~S 1 A A A =
._ Cese 2:O3—cv—O2159-ROS-JRI Document 130 Filed O3/24/2008 Page 1 014 1 A _

» g`;D%/c%¢?H 0/Q A~\j {Jl, ?‘\·7F¤%»9'V
I- I “P¤?m~»TT»/f’ PSg;;u991»s ~_ %rr/?g COy1#‘r‘ Q£»2‘F ?}¢$é.'W·V/#Qb*v¤»J _ i
vii; T7/$£
`i'Hé. F&s>&»rf4¢ @#45 - @u1t, K»h/Z0G‘?J> ~@E ~
. q ' /’M%»~ff7»/,¤~»S ,~75%l§ c#~;Si.“ ’ fm, 4Q ’?$/€f°$€
» U U. i(¤\f~$?g A$L<$ WM C°~4(2`|` #éA·>l·’£ ((.AVf¥"€’&T°"’H/8}
¥"'*’*·'/*4-, ?é’Z°·QiZ Yi? QUYJW /‘?<>+·`¤’*? ‘é‘;{°’> B °%`Q”"’* +"€
V » VQ {WHZQ-+ |;, §¢Qg3/ /+$ ·<$ T 77—1-rg
, 1{~.isr4»¤<§Tg ”¤A1~16<#_ M»>»¤£, A~x> V,/vo'V.,A Av/Z61A·?;€i 9**%
{wm NW2 4 (-,m·»r·5&. FA2·i‘¤·/ék ru; ¤?sfs~¤>¤w+3
1 ;‘»P4,»=h,J1*Q/14 5/4¤gV;> F£&ga~1><é 2»;> BV »
A (>¤f*4~*v~#6 +¤ ”°&» `7e’*$f’< .
' Qkg/¤»¥S§'SA 'UQIYS ._ *17hé. ( ‘ `+7hS Cow?-`f" VW/v“¤?1> A LK2#h>‘I”
2`:0§—qx?-<#Q215é-RDS-J‘RI QpcQrfR§rq,t$j3®¤ v Filed.4O3/Q4/2608 PageéA¤f4 A»'A

1 A · N uv1cuJM> /-75AA) UQ VL~0uL1_£ ,
, _'*'¤V Cq~>y;‘;R _ ANI> V
Fm1Qrnrw·V#·Q%F¥»*/; www THQ U A1>2>;‘H¤eQ¥i'
*7** ‘<=·~¢T M ?"°’“"‘°* ¢—»¤[¤ W M
YJLII ~oT' A » — $$» ?#><>%5 ¤.~;1’?+ W léu;2/i£’·%T Sr/}2fs,z>QM ?¤J€ U A
` 7+43 ` /H$ 1>NWuV»v?v’Z. ‘ w ·?\’ PlZ€5Tl$·L£{_
` . l (M Wh i /kLg(,$S$ AA 01£‘ L \
_ $9géS/O,vS&V ¢¤¢>$5 4> éés/O,;s & *
` ·£»{I‘f€oQ—‘E/{3[2€/ “
Vigcwrar s>s»Q~{` /mH¤,\>: EA 4#b
. ` , 'Ti‘7‘tS W JF>$ Bq · x V
A 2:O3!cv-02159-ROS-JR? D0c%ur‘p9=n£{B Oé Filed O3/24/Zg)8 P%;1gQ3 Qf4 H

.. R£.‘$/?CT'P 17-hg Dag UL /v»A»¢<,/-{U 9gg08.A
,_ A I *IG:M¤T‘H~{ ¢,w·1-2//> A ,
I A .. A _ _ _ V A _Ac0P·i·S 0* 7771 v§!Z&6¤w(> MA-»'~$4> 77763 ,¢»=H*"’
.,/Wvac/(+} 60084. juz V . X M
_,ov<é<é,v ‘FHLAc1€rZ»< · A.
..Av~.w> svmsv r>zsrf¢¢<1— C¤.»2T' A
A AA»D§s·hQeur’ O»¢ AR.?o~q. A` - A A A
__·‘?01 w&>7’ `w»>¤W/4-»e+¤4> gwzssr-2/c—| A A A A A
_APH02U·><,_ *}Z 8;0O3‘B·U8 A , · A
_/*75. rqcrféoé A L» `»6fZ~&=// A’T?o[2»)_i*{ , A A
__O*/LIC?. 0A' TH; ·‘}T’»‘·vR~?‘·f 6£~2/Wt., A A A ~ A
.AI37$ wE57'_ ¢.‘m<>/-h~6·l0»0 , A j .
1 __f¥‘Fh>f?»v¥*¢S RRA ¤7E.é'~•>q~+S , A - ` J
Case 2iO3—cv—O2159-ROS-JRI D0curf?g6iQ3Oi/Q Filed O3/24/2008j Page4A0f4 ‘ A

Case 2:03-cv-02159-ROS-JRI

Document 130

Filed 03/24/2008

Page 1 of 4

Case 2:03-cv-02159-ROS-JRI

Document 130

Filed 03/24/2008

Page 2 of 4

Case 2:03-cv-02159-ROS-JRI

Document 130

Filed 03/24/2008

Page 3 of 4

Case 2:03-cv-02159-ROS-JRI

Document 130

Filed 03/24/2008

Page 4 of 4