Free Motion for New Trial - District Court of Arizona - Arizona


File Size: 77.3 kB
Pages: 3
Date: December 29, 2005
File Format: PDF
State: Arizona
Category: District Court of Arizona
Author: unknown
Word Count: 1,810 Words, 14,026 Characters
Page Size: 612 x 1008 pts
URL

https://www.findforms.com/pdf_files/azd/43222/82-2.pdf

Download Motion for New Trial - District Court of Arizona ( 77.3 kB)


Preview Motion for New Trial - District Court of Arizona
CASE N0.: CIV04-0289
MONICA ORTEGA—GUERIN K CITY OF PHOENIX,
FRANK FA I/ELA AND FRANK PERA!. TA
DEi ~\‘· \Q\°`\\ @5
\BA§\_@¤»\.»;»~—;»
Case 2:04-cv-00289-I\/IHI\/I Document 82-2 Filed 12/29/2005 Page 1 of 3

lh
fh
E.
fl
Q.
E
3
fh
E
Q
tl
·‘ ' .___'· c ‘ * ’ * " · ` ·‘ ` € n- " .
‘ a' ` j . g; . . qa .11.-Axe;
_- · Y 1 g; J _·» ‘.\\;-.\\;5\ \\ `·Px ``‘· Y`.
·-‘".‘ q. ‘ * i` n . ` _ · ....... .. ,.... Y1. *5. _`·:‘-` I
---. -. · - A 2i ‘‘; ..- . . ..
__ E. " I_ - -· . . Z ·· _ .`*5._`·I·._"·I*-. " ‘·`- ‘· “ . `
`“-.:-r.; al. `* · ZF- . ; - - ·.· • ` ` 2 :
; ` ’-` Ti ‘· ·.-= H s _ . · . · · · .».
‘ Wg .‘.-· T}- -._·_` .._- Q: . `i L ‘¥ --··=-=· . ` .* . ‘ ‘ ‘ -
,i€·- ,?‘·· · -·~.‘P§>.*" . $fz§`".. · " L ° . ·· . . ‘ 1-ri . T `‘.‘ - ‘- ' ‘ · · - - .` . ` .‘ ` · .
’=E;;§g _ `-‘· ‘-ap .. : ·. ._ . _. i , _ - · - . · _ ‘ _ - 1-——·———·——·· *··
_.·.___ Eil .__·_: :· I I . I _..; in _ ,. _. l _· _. . `. . Ya
I nc U ! - .· U _ . 1- nz l— Q lj :
` .‘-_ ·;-· Z:-ZZ-I ".·’ 2 ' ‘• ‘ - ` ° ` ‘ ` ` `
` E; tif -.2;% . ‘.‘-. . ‘ * ri °l - ‘
=`-.‘ [ -`f.§]?:_¤`·- _·-=.:- -· _. i , -? ` - · ··
- 1" I _.
. " _ I___ ig;-6*
n t _ * g
E -.° 2
‘ [ 2 . in ' . .
R. rx ‘i ° ‘ > 1
¤ 0 2 0 2 2; ‘· ‘= Z |'
g · i lf /· *§Ii=;-‘· C Q
E, ,_ _ `;:LQ:_¥l*?-‘y;!? 5- > < __ _
x _Z zi` --¤¥`·;rZ··? L; ___= In m
. . .*I' .‘E"‘L`..J! _ m
Case 2:04-cv-00289-I\/IHI\/I Document 82-2 Filed 12/29/2005 Page 2 of 3

BJFYQJQJ Q_j‘_`¤¤Q_ —·—·-·-·-¤ -·-¤—¤——>-~—·LOC¤‘——.|OWU`-Ib UJ IN-I-"""¤
Q. :3`-¤: 00`AQOQ- ¤.0m-401 0·¤.1awn\.¤-0 ···‘‘‘ ‘ "9¤‘-J
2*- gm;-§>E~`¤-€+mB¤> ‘‘‘‘ · ···‘‘ 5*‘> 2
-5 LT 3-U'·--—¤l'g` - _- --.1 — .—•-3. -.
.2-'°¤>:‘*¤§¤J.*¤%§:,%~2§°?JBT?E`F%§§3§§‘i¤§Q?£’&z?-E?-E2?-@~<·¤
3 r1;>[UmO.-.·—e mm,..,.L¤ .—+:><3-m-wm: mm -‘]·wC0'·< @-*2033 *
GO qg.__m’_+:!i3-,_r;;,,._,g`·<¤J;·;.;;-Q ;~.:,:*.°é*¤:§L‘·?.’.3r¤§-ru 5.6-9 zwgwmg E'
3 _`—··' ¤-¤&¤_‘Q. - O I “* Lu —· F`- VW I _‘ - ··’ m` nh —·—
D. mj]- O O. rl; ,__ -.;*_-. : gg] 'C -1 _ 3
55 gL§_g=w= Gjggggg 5-*2+... ;,.&‘£.g Q 3 §L¤ g rg 2~.§g-@22 “;”gg2g 5
©:‘mD;-gm FD; ' m0 FU DON-UO,. ,-, ‘ Q -.¤JO ‘—-<: ,-ymr-;,
—· .» O www 00:; -. : —-GJ --3- E"' ·”DL¤ : :3 0;; —-<
·¤—•—¤>qL¤;*3 ¤."”—.*D G, . ¤ DJ m 0 -0 N .1, 3 .,1 0 - Flm
mc" _`¤ am 2-90*.-;, “`* 0 O m 30:: -1:1 0 O ,3 §‘¤"“`·· (D ·— ~3,-,-D >
§§?*`E9-$$€-“§F%?}ggQE-‘§§*’;§5-335-Q '€+§;g§=€O<% g%`“°O£’·
--.-•~— _. -. - _. Ii m "
gghgwa-ma-;g}£&gLg-1;-; 2 0 OD Q, :.*:3 E 8 iw 0 E S Q";} E-Q 03 O
gg S§Q¤_z-§§g_..§`g9.E S-/1*%-?'·3E n§3!° 2 E2 § 5* gg °é5" ggz
"' »—•-me-{ I-D N *·'* GJ QE ;_--Tm m < _. *-Q rg
U3 E.0O"*¤. -·"°' *1**3: E3-· —-;;>"*CEr9=°- D-:;0S0"'°_ -+1 mm 3
mm Umm- 0 Fl;-—·— ¤03 .;*.,0:--yn Emm-m—m3 ;--- -*--
ug 3-O--0 ag O`*‘¤J9.:r;¤, ;-mgg :.-Bmw 9»,$¤> -0. UQ 3-
W-1 mmilc:" ¤_ DUT} —- Zi UOLQ-•—·¤_`U ]'¤·¤3—'-‘_‘3:" mm UO )
;;q~q$¤_30 'E Q-Qug ·-·· CQ -. 5:.;,, .. n: 0¤¤ Q 8 Q Q ;·.g E15 2.... U
E5 3:9*;-`—-¤J3’3`6-0 ;; m :> UM 5-0`O A C 0 CT., ul 0_Q ;*..U
§“”§%’€L‘§§j;%g*”¤°*g9»§% §3m'5%§ §Q’°2H?€%.-»Q §-‘ gg-H
-+%*.3-*3-3-*¤“;Q$¤¤§¤'gg-8‘2LL2·. ~; ; —-- . —•·» .. 7
E-',§_—;E`\E'¤¤n0 §€Q.~¢E¤L2i5Q€ mg 0 Y` Q-L-O Q E ].é~< Q3 0 ,.,§- "
:1- v· ‘-’ 0 = " :r
@“-%T·‘§‘“-DQ?-$§¤-¥§»€%E*5· ¤-EQ E- -2%* .22%%°" ¤» me
rug :.v¤»%¤»¤>FL E¤>¤;»¥¤,¤.5—P rw¤-2* 2E ¤»c:> w?-z-ME E gm
-. “ _‘ _ D
F M 2é.2`¤2¤§s?·%.§`a%- @-2 E5 §€ 5 59-% T- 23
E¤*12-<¤>~2¤¤-· 9 ¤~.. ?·€2 ¤¤ E Og}? 0 mm
¤'*ET·—Q5'm ,-,5.2C-023-*H @.0 0 Q a' =·’· % ¤ ¤ Em
QQFEO03-5 0-;+.5*-SO FG ¤—— 3 qu 0 —-gw 0 $2
mq §5.*0$E§$gm:’·G"·g5` $g— Qh TUB 3 0m.E 3-' EQ2
‘ Im LQ V1- .·-+ "¤ ;+_
€§¤€%-%&,-€-¤-§®;¤§S.- ¤». 2 H 2- $09- Q :3
1 '__,-·•(;TL];;|$3·£1;;·-+¤C;;1-r‘D-r;.{j G` QC-} 8 ;‘|. ... LG 3E VD VDO-
D-ZJ‘m‘·<‘ 3 ¤_ m-¤·"¤§fT> "`- E` ‘-< O E VD 5 U
Q #¤§g.,§.¤¤§’F§g¤g;¤gS-E gi 3 ` U H ¤» Tl 3-§
m 0.,,. 2:-zujmzw-·-56m Q3 ;r _ 5- 3 0 gc,
3,.,,0300mE_m3O~q¤_ Q O0 Q I (D E D-
3 Q-igmxg @0 Q` S 5 15- CL - B 0 CL3
0-Em 2.-+m$E‘.EB D-2 — OD- 3 -0 O 0-
:> 5·¤.¤»;:r—-3;;--0é"° --m ;,-. u; 5 1 0.m
-· <-0 0 -::·m3v¤;·,-5 0 0 -4 un C
°¢‘“""¤"‘ "*5"*“°"’¤0 VD 2 5 ·¤· TS °’ 5`v·
.U~2‘0Q% E- :»;,;&· H H. `!_¤ O m 3 3-0
FU ¤J]>2$-U3";)-+0g-¤_ FD OE 3 —>· rn mg
3 Q-__nm -|¤,·D;·.--*`,,» ‘¤;3_ 0 :J
""‘ ....’“*:a"¤m mn mm 3- FD "* -·· B ~<¤—
0 00 -;¤__3,.,:130 L3 30 ZT D- 0
3 3"0¤¤L,··¤>-0 **0* 1 ...:"" "D U m O3-
3 j‘rpO;;-¤.·‘D—'·D »-+ .-•- ·`¤ ‘—- 5 w ‘*`
ggmlqwg - DQS 2/* 0 O 3 O -+§_
;·¢¤·*c;·E.C D-mt! G U 0 —+· §·-*
01;: 5 ${05 0 0 H 3'
;s•.gm§¤- `§ gi. Q- 2
·- § @3 $§§§§§§ €$`§E§JE$?§@`5 §§%¥‘@m“ @$6 QT $5 é`
QJ J3 m FD O - -¤ m I -¤ ,-L.D`D
»·?"-2** ·3-::;*:;*3-.--.2mr,w"1;.*¤~<;g¤€.¤;,—m3;.+T, [7,;...; U
3-3 rD]>D ;u·¤r'D¤_mmmm—¤Q_m3¤__O Q mr-yjm-•—n"sFD gmrb - {DOO _
0"" ¤-.0 -¤@.¤—0 *2.0 ¤75‘—--.··-~¤;;é-<'° ELO w.v·[P,g"“ D "¤"° O g¤·’·‘0. O
··_g ....··"'*'|'\'\—·,...3E,{j;|-"-fltl .m jOHOfD_'—·3`UgrD -0 2"+(‘3 uq FD$°'-mg; n.<
-¤ 3-DD" 3:.,-U, 0x 0¤»·¤§;¤ ¤_,-xm: 2,..,3 3mmO ry--..+___ O
;§ 8gQG¤¤-&‘;·§¤-E+F“E;’E0-¤`Q;l>F· E~¤5`gQ--;§::.-$3.:; Q Engg Q
` ·£=·;·rOF'°"—¤-—¤ -*F3—0 -¤¤·‘--5 "0 ·"¤* . E§_cZ.·_·BO LU 4: 3 -. Ogqmfbzz gjmmmnm - O 0T"":—-
EO*¤¤-U wg·‘-¤S·_g8`{¤¤ V`85-¤`§;E>$.¤-¤-E §··‘_B`¤mE¤.» Z £"" 3* CBO-? U1
rung-g-v—gO—:§“ g.nLg5‘m—¤q;.,qm~<§. jg;/1;;; EE0-¤ Q ¤¤u:>`g;-tg
Ln _. vu -- ZF
"`- ¤·¤ mc:-‘-”·$'“$ "°¤—-523.=¤§¤-$5r`?¤-LS-g?·“*£s-*~‘%L<%r G {Ss- ·¤
$2 SIS; $:$&%¤—- Q5?-Qswam-0;;-r%0m3~m¤£ 5,* ¤3=-¤-s“r¤
_ -·-+_ __ -. .-.0 -0 :0 — —•—,. : 0 un
QQ $$1 ¤:¥§r¤E"‘r-. ¤§¤§,-“2.$%¤»- 02-3-FwEQ,~<%;>< 3 -§3$ :2.
0g* fu 0¤.¤ 0* —- ` -··< T-'
%“° §EE 3§€LE€.§-¤ Z"`°°§L§“*21B5r’g §"¤—+€'T";'§E $$5 2 §_<3g -¤
03"-=<_.r¤ —< ·—0O§ Om D $03 -¤3`3‘ mm? O 3 O ; L2. ..,
rw - ; QJ -*· mm- *¤;»·—v¤-OW ··~_‘ ‘-Or:>3‘T¤_¤ “_" Omn-
.-+*0 C0 ·—+mO‘-(uw-gm $0 ;1- Om X mm 0 cy; """·-· gg num- O
38 n>;~».LE ggg$5~;-¤ §g§-¤80s%g· ¤-2.;:2Egg gcig E @3é.; *9
1¤n`m w3 Hm .-·—- ZJU-.¤-‘¤ ’0`—§> 85 505 $§3¤-50E ag5$`¢"::9§E $¤¤i;Q5'§ 6°§ 3 O-°-¥~"*9·~ 2
.-4.*-* —·_. ___ 000m 0;;;-eF 0 `"0 Q. < - »—-· 00`
$@222 2552036% iam-¤¤§g&§S g2*e§¥?—%§ 2%- g wg? 0
D —h < Z. _ *—· ... __ —h -· {'D ('D
I-¤·¤L¤·é?*’T. E¤‘UF¤"35m :.0 ggv-*¤‘?.§ -¥=·*¤·1O§“*¤··· 05-+E 1 UEEQ V"
M >·.·»g;¤·*·" §‘§§B$20r¤ g,i‘.*5*T‘**¤···}·*‘·*"‘·*!*"t.¤ .4LH3E?,03§ §—·—¤, '*·-' §'°Em CB
‘¤¤"D mm 3 r-s¤_` $ -0 ,.+ m DJ mmm UE UC -.m __ ··
‘·° ._ :;*_ VU __ FD O ·-•- gm;-mm -:5 F1
y`r1n¤,¤EJh3D» ;g_r.]5.'*O"¤¤.gQ gg.-•·$rDm§ Gmc}- O
SB 5*,;% ¤fg°i;§.E6“ gi3:.·G‘§5·*2`g,;· “-Eg-3:*30 kr%3§ g Qségg
-—··*· _. Mw —03 0--- 0: ·-*·.» -.r‘1¤.» F¤*3·
gm mg §¤=¤¤-M2 Mmmm-2. ¤2¤» 00*-‘·¤.»m~e0 ~·· m ¤··· ¤,¤--¤
:I‘< {DCU C|.—,qOm[ 3,.+ mOQm—· -¤QCuE_-. D UX 0 —
_:y_g__§]§ EYm§_g—$,.`$,‘ $0EQ*-;[=)_g5-BQ 5m'·;p¤.‘§S§ §§$ :7 géw-Q
OECFDB, gggdémm. Umm-m gg _c·;~.;-03;;:,, {A; 3 -%:1;
-¤:—~$. -·—°$~¤:¤¤-J 0>c>S.-§‘;'E 5 E;°*¤‘l··~‘Hf£1 :--0 ‘¤ “¤V°
gaggq 1>g- Oyeng Ewgm-M-¤;§-3 ·-¤:`§&’.c¤Q.-" z§‘ ¤—— 5*5
'¤ ""'·.-•· ‘*'¤ C OQ 53 ZE "‘ m 3 0 T"
08-Q2 inf-‘j§¤‘g D-"‘¤m-¤°·‘0 rn (;>":’—·"*D mm]? EQ-:.
0 0`¤ °"~—0'“—mr¤ 3?i0<¤>"3s1=— °~¤¤"j“ ¤5¤° E'- $00
rx._Jf"H-·¤O 2§`[y·p¤J~··‘B L¤,»·¤§,"m—01mcU ·-4-,—+·{.`mmr1 U mc
0.;-;:% W-22§§~¢»·. 5-gmwé-Eg;} 20;-2282 SEE E` Eg-
.€:¤ gg- :022-¤;= ¤»e>5%Q»w¤-¤ éwm-0a-Q ..-as EL $:5
¤—'-· -.2 O;Zll._<-.;:;3- D -2 Y‘U\¤.»OC E.--.J§¤JSf'D¤’D 3`1‘D¤- g; g_|:V<
——~J-¤5_:·» -·;m¤,-D0-cm ¤._,0¤.· N;33 <.L,-.,.D:,|.,.|: ·¤·,··§, ¤.·.0<
r\Jj;1rD5+ |""'1J1 {DU uv; D’.j*·¢:\J'\Er¤_¤°`D$ (DU-I QL`} j mmug 3 - [TTC
—·0 3-; IMAO- $5 m*¤¤J--J-—&“— :-9 ;>B·¤ '°-· " -·—
5 0*0 · -9 ·”¤¤§$r_`30§ §*n,_°‘¤3¤-E·23Q. ;—_,--g5-*m·¤L,, $0:;. f¤ QEE
' 3 |_;g`-·|{·1 rj <¤J 3 Q) (D r·D.'6rD -- _U`O
-J i' S. 3?"‘*¤OF·"»;y3 ;~_I>v~m;}F"943¤¤ >"w*—-Mqg 0.::*. 6g
(J5 In QE 6 °‘”‘£C,·-D ;;1`U%D-J ·-+ 3 V‘¤_CUC'*-'B—- (LGB 5`·—cV.
.- - . my mmm. 'O ru LD 0 _.—-pq pg,
-: 3 23 ¤>"E‘¥E¤~= -3 wwezizgm EQ-;·r§mQg wv-· 50;
“"‘ —0*'D@,., ·-* gm-LG-'Q. _. ·-¤.I1¤q;‘ -. ·-+0m —
I -5 Q,. 00 _. ;·r .00m‘0_, 0 ( _,_»· w m m
L_ -q “' -0 * ·-*•
A G m BJ _. FD mr-·`1jC.‘·€ 5:OCO GOE 5}
`Fé “% *° 2% -·Q`& ¤-sm.] “”-5 6
arg BQ. m U`-* I": rn 2
Case 2:04-cv-00289-I\/IHI\/I Document 82-2 Fnled 12/29/2005 Page 3 of 3

Case 2:04-cv-00289-MHM

Document 82-2

Filed 12/29/2005

Page 1 of 3

Case 2:04-cv-00289-MHM

Document 82-2

Filed 12/29/2005

Page 2 of 3

Case 2:04-cv-00289-MHM

Document 82-2

Filed 12/29/2005

Page 3 of 3