Free Statement - District Court of Arizona - Arizona

- .
.¤_ . »
·—
Y ,:, €;
Alcxemder Jhrig



ercent ISVHSSI ed under dia T ostrcfcode ,5260 i`rorni?$Jul @13
~ - .4 'r=» *’`*—’
evaluatrcn of 10 perceutrs granted,f0r.1eg fiexwn whreh rs,1rmrted.t¤ .45 (.,» d
‘ -·- ··»»-— 4vLt ‘· `···— = = »¥¤. `v— T ~ -¤4V ~¢-= < ·:`; :-· 1
higher evaluat1on of -20_ percent 1s_not warranted unless evidencedemonstrates leg
`’`* l‘v’el ·4leA “ eer=· -—*d '*‘‘ ~le‘ ee=¢ ;~‘
IS l1m1ted t0,30 degrees.··;;·An evaluatron of 10 percent rs grantedif the record
-»e·< ·ye~ =¤er -e:ra·e ~‘v·=e·=
evaluatiorfbf 20 perbént is iiiafraritéd iihléééj there iéiévidericebf hiideféite
= l»»· > r·=» he ‘`‘<~ he ·s e’—‘eee— V- :V= " at d‘·‘ i=¥= ‘e·i e ·=·‘ r-
atera a l f e knee.

~ :»r*
var· »·»
The · evrderree .$1¥°W§ Ph? Y6tCY?m'$..1?&.1Q1‘?¢ .°‘mdm°U.haS jmcrcascd. U? s@X?¥}iY $@9 Q.
evaluated hvihe ratrheeeeieieh e.f§eprerhher. 7; 1995-E “n. Thie.Qihereaee`ih
i · warrarrrea10 peree¤r.evahrarierr due re .rhe1rerera¤j havi¤g eheht .fe¤h1¤2éatier1.a¤d pair?
vvV· T jf inotiongt The effective date __of this_ increasedevaluation is Ju1yn13, 2000, iwhichis
ifi ’‘‘- .}.; .0 1 ‘ i of claim for increased evaluation under the rovisions of 38 CFR 3.400 1 i
‘ * 1. - _’·» . · · ; · ,r,- (~l¢1 - V rer:»:;>* -»r- . . r·,·— . : —· ..:2;; \-c~ ,.v1 ...».»_.., J .¤,, ¤~·f:*`€=r$
‘ ·’.·“‘- if { ‘~°v ·*‘» 1 l=,-e . .-’‘. 1 TX . ee,.rr
—‘raE —es: EY.} ' 1%—-L-S-crccnt disabliu ·ii:Y° Y. ‘·;V E .‘n1e’ ,c1nnt I ·_n· z 1i§.;;E§§}·?€~ ·',»’ 1 in `VVn¥ eil 0‘.· »v.tc . »j.;{_..r.Q{.i;ii »r`.
. `t_, . . 5 2 A `i** C FACTS: The statement &om Dr. Lee indicates the veteran reports his recurrentiprobleme { .} ` ;_ i
‘ 1 e»A0 ; ‘·c; , . . with his knees. e The veteran reports he can no longer participate in any activitiesthat he e * · i;
V ` i“i< C *g ·_ ` likes. He is unable_to_bikeride, play basketball, jump or even do any _kind of running, 5 .p.. 6*-;.5
l_ _. »_' gv ._ Y0 V _ ` P Mr. Jung reports chronic aching and stiffness when he wakes in the morning. He has Q he _.e" r fj_ >
_ 1 ii 1 r · problems sitting througha movie or at an extended dinner. He has pain where he points ‘ .__.
H fj ·i·· L · -to theinterior aspect of his knees and refers to the lateral region.__The veteran denies any . * °`*.` __
1 l sharp pain along the joint lines although he occasionally has a catchl 1 He denies any gross ;_ l.jlr_. ‘ _’ei; g r_..
_ ` instability otherwise. There is no locking. There is no obvious giving `wayggbut more ef?
_ he g 4 _ often chronic pain and some grinding. This record shows the veteran has affull range of '_‘__‘ Q, it ;_~ 0 y-i-
H ` A g.:`t‘ _j motion with some crepitation and lateral tightness. The examiner states, the veteran ‘°i"I_ QQ;} e_.;_ fl I 3 # ‘ ‘·r· ’e
I? ` A 1 ` » r appears to have some slight lateral subluxation. _g_i He has pain under the lateral facet to 0 "YQ
` e _ _ he - t H ge rpalpation but not on the medial side. He has anegative pivot shift. His drawer signs are _ -1;-}. ’_“ J F
s { Q —j·. _ within normal limits. The examiner states a review of his:X-rays, AP, lateral and sunrise, f — · -_-~ .
ii' .... . ...» 2, gu . Shaw a S1ight1Y.ih<>reaSed parehar height It appeare re heYe1ighr1y.i¤ the ¢%?§. h1..r
e· he Healee appears te have andefinlte iareralrilt eempreeeierr-. .He.hae ehhehehdrai. `eelereeie an
noted of the facets bilaterall but minimal osteo h icQ chan es. ‘ti= .The"assessment ·‘‘· §;;fjj‘ . -..r ;
V ·r ‘—‘ ';__'¢p2%=’·.»é*·.":..r f' .· . r * . " A rl i. r·;e*13=‘; r .2, · ··w " ‘ ‘ '·—1:v,‘f ,.·. " _. " ss? we <%A¢‘$;.;:§—¤ awe est MV".i==Zé‘ex=·-iicf--·_‘e§ jk. . - .2:* ." ‘ ;.`
" 1 »..r». 2 . ...» A if .... bilateral.arrterrer..hr1ee `pairr..wirh hpslerlyirrg hkely ehe¤r1rema1aeia.
0.1. ‘t.‘
· . . .... .. ..- r. ,. .-.....».. ..,. . ,..,.. . _ , ..... ·. ..L.,.»y.. . . . 1 ., .m€.?g,,.,...... . rrr. ·.._ ,. .¤: .,.m·*;a .r ..., .F{_r.ea,,w._{ec1,.. a . ..., Jr, ,..z,( ,,.. ,>..» _ , . ,.,_l_
-_ »; . %*r*·‘1·’· ...»» =l§¤€2‘ig·i¥$¤.;ri‘-·»;$j~¥r.$.§J;irr‘;:3;;? l- é;·e ;;.;1`,.;».r ::;;;.,3;
»··ri xw ..;».· `·»e r.’ . pearxré ·.r»‘’ i
The VA exahrrhatreh ahewethe veteran re..we11—appea¤¤g4 welhrievelepedr, .r ~
r .».#r ie..t.;·<-pehriehedé alerreeeeperatire ar»·1 .r¤r¤ iiri ri
H _‘”.·— Q rnusculaturerr He is_ab1eQto ho "oneither lfootl heeland toeior `s‘ uat and rise ibut `';` § `Muattin ,:1·.
`. ‘ :=.>rZ·;e-‘.'r. er ...,1 . ..:»>;¤:-"J." . .’ *1 ·—;~;¤4;1 .···*%¥;<.-1~=riI·¤`ii V 1 · *-·=;¤; ‘»z:~ » ;".%·,;ir2r;e;=¢·s¢%» ..·`··£-:*.9-J;*.·sr·.;·Zr.-%—··:‘·.‘=7‘ -·.,·· <_ Q —.“·
_‘1_ F a‘*— . gfifif ,_,e » provokes discomfort §zvh1le.he0,1sQ suprne fondthefexarnirririgiltableiii Therange of motion of .t. jg;. ji? ,‘‘.
-. an .i=.z=i-r.! ' ‘’.a· '‘‘= Z:i‘ *3. ’‘·;‘a ;i;? `r·· ?f==‘; e· .r—.
_ .,__ ;g,; .._·r ,··er_ j .h1S right knee rs e5_ to ,140; e,,*· There 1S tendemess laterally with pa1n,on_mot10n.j There 1si.r>.r;;s1 i‘ ·’ — ·ar= - . ¤ ~·-. ~> »rr·· .r.»err ==~·· e ··ra ~·~— . =’·· ·r--r ~·*r -er=- ; rrr » ·r~e V »»»· ·~ »‘_. .=.e ·e_; ¥ r=rr z.
e._‘r Air negative patellar gfmd, app1‘ehe11S1011,‘ and Lach11ran's_;2g;There 1S a pOS1lZ1V€ MeMu1Tay's. r ..e»
~..».· -,,·r. Q·~ v -ee-‘ ’ee`‘·“°r· r “r‘· ~i‘· · e e··· ··>’· ‘~‘' · = ·=r‘ * *e»·‘ = rrr i*‘“ ·· ’`·= r ·.*· ·2;e·i#12:?¢ Bisif
t»,e· ig, ».re _ J ..·, The impression was chondromalacra ofpatellae, e... g ._.e ».., q. -.,· i;1y· 3.1;.;;
‘·`.. .r.r.» : .- .r ~ ·.»- . :»· ·r`.. Y . `i’-
V ·‘-rr* < »’e‘r z r=#l= Y? ·.=.—. rl .‘·r» = °’j_ -e‘r .e1r ee? ·=ta· ’·¤
i ’;t‘. 1 ‘1—" 6 ·“;e·»’ : F ·‘»t .ra· i .‘”‘-’‘
.»· r‘»r—
'... ...i
.=a:..r
-V.· Q
..... -ie»’ 69 QWW Luv O O 2 63
e.’·· ‘‘t— a’‘are» ":-1
.. e. . T ~¤.L’.=»:.C‘-a? ai; r ::—@l..·.=*i·i; =hj`.e.. ·.¤.>·€>*?r?31=`·j·:. -;¤=»k·:§;e!§¤:L=·r;2;?$&1ia;T5€;1-r :.m§S·a·téérryuheez.r;r·;:.»t.g;r&;n·..»;mrq».~_-13.;,.h. _. __ _ V

»— - -. -» 1 . » ,·-1-.1 =..- 2;.:; 1";:J aT‘§¤$·1#=¤¤.'TI‘T`?T@"'I““”£ ‘ ra, ·§¥#?·"·-
Esta

T-W ¢*'?22=·é,,r.v" éwzz,-1* 1-za'? ¤¤-.,.*·;.-~& --5-‘
*", 1 - ga,. -— 1;¤¤;2g11-zrsmss;-.>D 1_·· --11;_;1.,: .,,, 1;-. 1. .
w ? *
.1,. e1 . ,..` 12C .1, , ,* ·*** · L LM -- =· - -· -1:; Mg
Alexa;] er uug
-—.—. »~~,. .
- · ‘ “~i~?m’ V’V °¤
Page 4
,

- L" ‘“‘ V “ '’’' ‘ `‘“`` °‘ V V ‘ " ` V V ‘ ``·°‘` ‘ ‘V v
<>¤dr¤m¤11¤¢1a
`;‘·’“ * ‘‘‘‘‘' ` ‘‘‘”‘ · '‘‘` ` ` ‘ ‘·
percent d1sabl1ng effect1ve T-. July 13;
»».· fw


-:.4; ·1 ,· · · `~·· · me 1- 1;,:--_·-;. -1--.1--1w <.11-- -.,1,.--- · -:;,15 -- ·. ·;,· = -r-aq,->» -·>»· ·`-- M--1 gf;
Aj 1 { V f 10 t ' ' "d {ind d' t' d ` 5260 ir "';° 1J l V 13 ·V‘’ 2000
-1--::1%-{ 1n%;s?¤{I?rr¤·-:1%,:6- ix-%.=.;;;L5€·.:?=. 1 ‘ • 2%;;::-- 1
__ ____ _QY8._l12§ 1Q1}11Q_ QQ1`0¢11_111$116$$1gH€ 1 V,11 1 _1_V __ 1}3gUQ§11}9,PO11 Q1 .1.11Pm, U .1.g11.
·<‘.-we _ ·¢g -115---::-. *1: ·. >¤;-J· ew ~¢%T- *324 *;-***-7 {Af ’, ¢~?i¤.‘~-€‘#·.* -** ·?·`:·~" V` ·Z‘
An eva1uat1on of 10 percent 1S granted for leg flex1on_wh1ch_11s 1l1n11ted1to
¤·_ -.,, ·y—-
-·=2v2‘ ;·2;¥ {1;- V ` ‘ V V
h1ghCI' €V3ll13t101'1 of 20 pGI'C€11lZ 1S I10lC warranted l1I1l€SS €V1d€I’1C6 d€I1'lOI1Sll‘&l§€S leg flGX1OI’1
~,.._r :1- . 11 1. ,,11-1 ..-, ,1.,-.11.1,. ··»’,= .-.,1....,.,.11,..,;,11,,.,..1.,11;.1.,1..111,- -4.. . 111,1,, 1, ., -. 1 -.{, ..
wh1ch 1S 111m1ted to 30 degrees. An evaluanonof 10 percent 1S granted 1f the record shows
1_ ._ 11 1_ __.11_1;,1g .,11111111-,~1- 4-1 v,,: , L. :1-1-1;;;.-- 1. .11 1:.1 .1;;,,-.·-.:p 1-;.11 ;
’ · ' ‘· V V " "". -*E·°¥’?*‘ ??“FE’·*·**·’*§1‘**““-5
~1»; 1 recurrent subluxatron or lateral mstab111ty ofthe knee Which 1S shght. A lugher
_ ,»,» ·. [email protected],1.1-.1_111;1§1..; --,_1-·_ _.-.- ..·. 1 1,.-. ,»-_r~ :1. wz; ·,—< 2--:~ ··y· . -- » -:2 r
->- · · ~ - • - · 1 h ' ' ‘ d · $-5%.-e? we ····
,»1_ €V3l\13.lZ1OI1 of p€I'CGI1t 1S HOt W31T&I1tCd ull GSS t SIC 1S CV1d€I1CC OfI1'1O €I'£lt€1.;1;-,; ·;.1;:s
>-.*1'fi;-=-=:$i_V?‘_·§?"?.,Q·3.`¥f%.·‘1¤·r‘;‘5r%‘¥.j¥`I-" ». -· s .1 .1 -- w- ‘ ·‘ -- 1,;¤ ,- ;-- . . -1,,-11: -4 F-:1, .1.,,-;;-- ;.-$1. ’L1·-‘-,,.1%,1-1-. 4 -, - 1.1,- 1;. -2,. 5-:.'=*"ée-;‘~V'¤Z,,5`1`-*4*
- 1‘.· 1-7 1-j<*§,t§ -3 ` ‘ ' ` " r ‘ ' ' ' "‘`'‘ ‘ ‘ =»$ .·ia‘3i
·1·~. ....1·. s; subluXa1i1011 OI` lateral mstablllfy ofthe kI1€€.;.·-1 ·s-. .,.~ -:·,-,‘ = e1-»·11 ·-_- :1:-;;-;-
3---;.-;-7-.11 "- · 1 1 . 1- 1 1 - .1 1- 1. - 1 , ;_;1._1 1 1 ,1 .1,, -. ·-rag.··;#·& ::-11:*--1-j1‘.j§:’,>T‘.·Z·i;·‘ ,1; 1.;.*;
1`._ 1 ’ z
Y ..;*
$1 .-. ·1;· - ·--·»,· 1 The CV1dC1‘1CB SlC1OWS tl1€ VClZ€I'8I1 S I`1ghlCkI1€C CO1'1dlt10Il h3S 11’1CI`B3S€d ll'! S€V€I’1ly S1I`lC€ he i-. ‘..¤. =
j -,—·- 1} , , _ 1 1 . 1 1 .. - 11 , 11 » 1 1 . .- :- 1 ·. .1, -1
,-.. . ....~ 1 -.. 1 -.1· - _.-. 3 ,- 1 was last evaluated by the ratmg dCC1S1OI`l of September 7, 1995.1·1Th1s mcrease 111 seventy- -,:1 .,—.`» ·=~- — --»·
1—; ¢,4q1,;_ 11~-f. 1;;-11, ;_j_ J1. J. _z. _1 ,__ 11 _ 1 v1_~ 1 . . · _ 11 - .· :1 1 _ F ·. , ;*?'X:1-*··_-- ` .1 V- , -1"K.,-,.E§§V¢,
,-_·. 1,1..; - ._ warrants a 10 percent eva1uat1on due to the veteran havmg shght subluxat10n and pam on _=-_ 1;;--
,1r1 ,-·» 1:1 .1-1.1: »··, m0t10n. The effect1ve date of th1s 1ncreased evaluat1on 1S July 13, 2000, wh1ch 1S the date- -..
` ' .7 v’1v=-i ' ‘ . _ · 1 — . V I · ` » • 1i-. M 14} `V‘
..-. _ 1-11 o 1 of claun for 1ncreased evaluatron under the prov1s1ons of 38 CFR 3.40O(q)(l)(1),·· `-»==.-= > ¤.: 1;,-- ,1;- .- -.-·;
-;:}.;.;:...1. 1 - ‘-1_;;. Jl _ ’ 111- .1 ‘_,`'*, éfijj --`.r· 1_-1,1,12..;.-.¤-.1.:.j;.1‘T·; j_- ., Vl;.‘ · ·_;-1V -·. L.-? g-11 §V_ y--1V lj---:11~;{1_;g·_1g:_.j_ ·‘_=‘g¤--YVVQ-=--j]€V· ‘>_‘ -,‘=P
_,__ ,_-, 1.1, _._. —-__— ,1. ,..,· , 1 1- .1,1_ 11-1 .1. - . 1 .. -..1-· .· -- .1 - 1- . - .-.-- ~»..=· .··,.... r _.._ ,-.»·. -- -.··,.<’, , ..-- ,1 1;-
,· ~ Y- ‘ ··.’ ‘ , V ·~ ‘· -··`~ 1 V - ` 1 1 1 ‘ 1 Y - .1 ,`1,`-1`1jJg1;.s:>..i¢‘_‘2- .1 1 .5-1 gi1j_,, _- R--. -;
5, ·1’1 1‘V,1;_2-1§ 1· · _ .’._1 ‘ `_‘’ ~ `·_1`' 1 . . V :· . · ‘ " fa 111.1-;;..- 11 -. *1 - -11 1i..j;?*.
· -.-.1 ·_ , .,1. 1‘ 1 -- 11- . -z"1.;; 1, 1 --1.11; _‘ -1 1 1.. 1. -,1-;‘...1-;, Z-.1, `’*'
J ;;__-1.-;-_.§.?f1‘,' ;;”_ j=_,;· _ 1 1* 1 . . 1: » * · · 1.. Z = .`/—.g ‘j‘-- ‘2‘,:" »'-4 " g_,-.g·§"j 7.1 _ ` ’."'i?_‘?' *-·f~·' I--. `-l"V‘· --2*
`-"*??.V.ew·§ ‘ —1-. *.,1:1 -``‘- · -‘‘‘ . V ~1.1 { ..‘~. - 1 . ; . . . ‘ ~..·‘.- . .. 1. v - 1 · ’ ‘ ‘
;11.YV,;-V‘·¤VE¥.·V>.V - . . ‘»1‘ -»-. if ‘``. · ‘.'* .’....· V1 ..1 ‘?¤·Y-V.-ZJ-? · -.'_ -· , V “ L1
t;·.- 1 -V T “*‘ 1-.. T 1-;fI-i-i;-’.;.V;12,Fii V ‘S V * ‘ IV . °1‘. . 1 - - I -V-, ..-. . - - -1 ‘.lt V *-’ .t.. I Z. ‘-.-. I .-·=.’ ` ir.-2 ‘ "-»-»t` ‘ U? -`.' . if , ,...
· 4 . __..» -1 ·-- - * > — _ ·- I ; V--¤};:_~.—. , V E = - - .V t - ‘ ‘ ‘ [ 1 V `-1e 1 ·- 0l-V -.¥°;V·* -'-V‘ Y1,. · 1,
V1` {VV.-VVVVVVV V VV V 1 V V 1 -VV-JV -V A VVj V . f - 1 _ ,-,v . 11 V", j V V·VV ; · VVVVV _ 1 Vi · ,V ’·
, ‘-`, Yr? . V » 1 ‘1’‘ J 2- - 1 ‘ ·’ .-¤ - 1 -`.° .. 1 ‘ 3 , V ‘.11 ‘-’1 . ‘ 1 . 2..-F ’C J-Q.--.¥;1V. ·.=· -”*‘ 1 `’‘` ;- -‘`. L »-1‘ E
. 1 _.; ».-‘ -. 1 i v_ -1-- - ` - - _,_,_1 1 _. _-V `_ . A ,_ - -
- ..·. 3,1 f, » ,- ..-- -= .... 1- J .- - r . · _. .- - . ..._ ..-. ·.=» - ».1- ··-.»· Z--1-. ·‘——. -_ ;. V· .. -‘ N ---1
V;i‘?€.1$ i` VViV VV 1/I .1 ‘ 1. V V‘ V I ` V- _»»’1 . --..1 .1--, ‘-11 - -·-. 1. .-.-._ . Z V ZY 131 QV`? `1...».·. ¥V. lVViVV1V ;V§EV‘VCV.-
1. 11 _1 Q {Y }_1 ‘=‘ _.VV Q; _1.._ - .1 ·-Q ‘~1£- it- 1 VV `‘-'V 1 --‘k`*.*V1°{.V1V1-}-:;V1Q1-Q.Qi;`Vg‘{f1VV ,111 C1;,V.!Y1 _-_’- 1V‘- _-V-
--‘‘ V -=_‘· ";";1i_i1-1;+, 1 ,2 1·1*;i'i%LE‘;r .‘’1‘ -‘.‘°‘ ‘ i- V1 2 -1 , ‘ : ‘ . .1,.‘ ··.· itil 1·--, ‘ iii- 1’,· _=.‘ ;;:-as-JY.-rf.?11 ; 1*1‘
‘..‘e -1 -.-- - »·-1 -i,` ‘-1`.‘.‘ -``‘ V rf gi--ft--ii·l--‘ZVé<1"i¥f--V ¤ ‘»·.-‘· ’V.- V-‘‘ V1 *
1- - 1- ..-1 11--»1~,_,--,1.1.;,.1;,-.11;.-1 . ·- --.· 1 11 1-.. _ . 1 ,1 1 .. - -11;- ;-13 -·-,1;-11-:--1¤=g .·~» - - . , .· 1 1;1 5-1--311;.;-11-11111;.. -,:.,1-* ,..-, 1, <· , 1 4;
-1-E-Q.a~,;V-1:,-;j;1·.; ,.-1.·. -.’ 1 1-1·.1 r ..-.. -,.· ;. .. .- ‘ -:11 V · J ·. . 1--- . iii:
., " ‘·‘··. . -·- 5 -.·-— t1-1-·f·.--*i&=.-i‘:¢>.i -.‘.— -‘.— < ,;*3 ·1.1 ·1·- z -- -?.1-1-‘·.,- . ¢-i·1 .’;;¤51*E i5-i »--~·‘‘ 5 - J; ~¤-V--‘Y?1 -‘-‘‘.
_11. — 1j 1;; »1’’ 5 11;-,21131;%.e,-,;;-;;:-.5-.;;:..1: ·-*.·1‘~1.1— ··.. =·- .’-.1 ` - »1*. 1 ..·. A 1,~’ i ·*‘.-
I ,.—.f ·‘, ..~.. -.-· - ·-.-¢ · ..»‘ ,·
1- - we- ye.--, sw--.- ;&., ·~*·’‘- -· ,5 J: a'¤.=·.»\*‘?.·2.1e=2¢..‘»:1z--1·::;,;§.-..11--;f¤·*;-,·;r¤·.<:: :`-4-";1‘_· .*·1 ;?·`;2§--Tr--‘¤?'· ~· .-- ·
1- V V-‘.- V ‘`V’ --`’ lV-‘1
. Y iii-1--·.i.-.--1;. iii-*-1;.; ··.— 1 *1- 1 ‘ 1 1 ;-{ -·.· --.... ·‘1--‘ J T ·,-».—.-.‘- 5* `..V- · i1.-53-1f;
..‘-- ·V‘‘-·.. J ‘--V Q .-.-- .-.1V.
J .1;*-i,·.f;i’-—.;isé;-i yr-- Y: `j.-f V`V’. - .--V -·,QS· -Y -·.* - f-L1; ·‘ ,:-1- ·--· ;.%<`<’1Zz-in-&f- -V .-‘.‘·. 1‘¤·.V ??=’ ‘.-· j 1.-‘. 3 Ci --’1 VV‘£- 1- `¤*’·-‘.V‘- i ,V
="- = -.<.. -.. 1 ?ei‘<‘ -5 ;ViV-QFSLF
v`_~ _ ·,; —;J¥;_:'.i,—g1_E';.:<1¤~§1)`,v__ - {Ewa.j1q;;i_;<%1-_:jtg.:A;-_.‘;:. r ·;:1 ,1-5-*-gui: —;~1‘.— -_,"1»j,;v..Y_,1,,.=;;;$-311;,.. .»_·~ " `Q ,3*2,**1_·1‘rz.5$·:£jg,j.1j,.;%,·Q;_€L=&;_.L;" '1`-‘- - 1 T1 1-; g.'¤‘*.;; 1` i;_' ¤;f·j1{._?;" 1_-;:GLi';’§€}~·`{i¢}{§;-QZ;‘j~ iej §}‘{_1 :1,- ;_-*‘ ?1 · 1 .1 ~· ‘- ·3.‘ f?;·{_.
-1;-$*1-1’§= ‘·='` -’. 1.--gi-‘f-1 -_-1 3-1-* V?} E -_-. ’,·1 e-‘·; - _::"’it-§::%-r
·V-‘- i - . ’¤-
1 - -Q;-¢ -1 *--· ; W V`1·- Q§" ‘_‘` ’·1'.>€e< . 1fQ- ¢;¤?i*;éV’:<1=‘_i5‘5;. ~.‘-'- ‘V`1
-· 11- - ··.=?~? -, .`·` TV? -V‘ V»·V ti ’=.{ »-‘1 ¥ -V. I
' ,-.· -‘1‘
- ,1 1__' V -1 _1 11 1_1_ 111,1, ...1 1 .--1 111 1- -. 1.11 .· .-1..;: ,.1§t,111_- .111-;-1*;;-1-%.1;.-~,;;»;.,;»_~;g--1 _111 yy- ·.1· :1--g -1-· 2 .·..-
, 11.-y1.,.1;1_111.1_ 1{11;t}'1$t&;g:_[:-'>,-1 T1_ 1 1};. *.1,;-;~§-,';_ -· ‘ 2 ‘¤1- ·· -/.' -~'1· ,_- ' :._..·¤{`1. . _ - -t·.;';;·€ ,.;;;-1- ~r--- ;¤ ·‘ "· . ,—\‘i»**-;;`i -7 rii‘,·.?1..‘§rf"1··Z· 1L2Ii'E·*?I-r1·,€‘1-<."*_.·}Z»:;‘~*:'cj>;i'> j_‘,·4;;'-">:·*¢· "··‘.¥?{:¥i`v?€ .t‘A§*;¥j?*Z;’\··‘§_YV:" §·—>¢"¥'·;J*' V""V" T" `Vj-*`· gl/*3
1.‘.;. 1..1. .»=’ V ··‘’ .-.
V ;T1--i?:*;‘V??&-VV 1-1V- T ·*,.‘ e ·V..· f¢V?l?i;é‘--YF -1. r" V--.. i- ‘‘»·
- 1·.1 11- .,.1 · fg .·.- 1 ‘=·1 ,-L ‘1-` ¢ ‘‘--..V ·--·’ -*,5 VI 1’°V- L?--37*.- ..,·.V-·.·1-
·‘.` f ‘-o;V· V- ’-V‘¥
1;`-;:X€~ég·§;;?$;¤·;i§?;;·:;§,‘g1.2 1;:1;-.5:;;’{;-1"·.. we '-`-' -272-. `— -,n_i'·.~' 1·_4;1=_-_;·T?qF¤=»-é·g:».,3-;Q!Z¥T{»-4;-{51 :1-;j1~gZ2`?§y3··--·wwgw--·==é-;z¢=¤¤¢+i€·-.¤g~v-5» ·*-~1·-- -i`»—r=j;-1; —--E?>»·a‘r_;3Y_§%~;¤‘s4%r*_—j§ %!;£,,?%?;¤@,%5;>·;??-?¤=‘;-;<¢¤y=e> -1,-- - .1 ._·1 1 .· . *7 =~‘ {
·-‘- és-? ‘‘’‘ if 3 -`V—V-1 :5-TT VV ‘‘-‘° T --·V * t-V·
_-=·- -=-·V· ‘’-V‘ ’ ‘ -
T. . 1- .,11 ‘;;g;S"~‘;¢-'·-; . -:21.15 ----- . S-~-‘;*;.iz1.-. r 1·,. #*%*5 ":¥%f'§&?T7V;--·-=;·-:-—E‘:· »‘ .- - ,·s,--.£_e . ‘ 1,
`·‘-‘ -.--- - -1 ...1--_
.-,, --· -. ---·‘ -··., 2 -e-F- .~··¤ * .*V-‘ - ..-’. ’‘-. r-.-2* ·--= 1 1.-· `.’‘’ =- V--- ‘ ·¤* T --·1· r .-*‘ aw-rr e- 1.-.·
.5; `1 ·1 ; ,- 1 -11-1 .. ,‘1r_.>=; J *5., :44,,;--1g=‘;r*.. ‘,5.;1:_i2.#;.§<.:;1$;j`ZS -1 Q;1y?é;¥F$¤-·.¤¥s饷*;;{-‘-1*1-i--if LIZ}--’. ‘1- ·=1;.¤1-1.11 1- . .¢-- `l---Q§;.Z1-
·.-»
. .1;.,11,-1. .1.. . 1;,-,-1, .;.,1,-1. · -. rr. , 1.1-1 - 1.-11-·-¤»¤,,=,1-Eqs,-11-1··s_ · eésr;-1-·,.-,1,;1-.z.¤;=-iw-a·.w»». »c»~ ¤w-¢*»%»---e·¤~¤ ---:. —--. 3%-,-..-3:
.1, ,, 1 . ,.,, .. . .1 .- .1 , , .. . r. 1 . .1...,. us,.-..1¤ m.».....1- .... ,-..,1.-w·»=f.,,»1§,. ap, s-.- we 1. aaa \»n.. -1
-.--, ‘,,`, ‘ ..‘‘‘
ii-; -V1- - 1- VV.1 ‘-‘-1 I JUNG- VA OO gz
‘VV. ` 2 6 4
3;;;:-> ,1,,.1‘ Ae" - ’ -‘ 1 ’* ‘?‘ - ‘“’£??*V’V?’*?§V`?*V5” V 2 of 2 “V‘
·1‘1‘1 =-, -,1 ----- ,1
1,.1.¤...1c.1..-,.1.....,1.1..,,1,.1 .,.. 1 .... 1.,:.-,,,1-.-1.-,1 ,-,,.-. -1. ..,. - FQ-gm,-;1»;...,» ---. 1·»;w·q·_:1-¤--;-1.1 .-1.,.-.1- 1-4--.;-.1..-11-.;.11-1-,-.»-=»,,·-y.-es--mw¢1~¤»¤g;w;;;·e··, ems-»;·y»·¤q·+-K»>¢¤-—-my--T-.-1-»¢.~~gx-»»,e;11.¤;-;;=g<;--1,»-Q.;-»-~ ·.-. .— 1. ,-1--~,,-:1-. , :¤~1
*..4.332,1; .-1·.I1?£’;`:X ’-`' :"1§ 1 ` V ,1 ,.. .4%:
‘:.-$55:21; V- .,-. 1 ·‘~--- ¤`¥<<-¤*f3--B-·¤=-*-3%irs->= -1 .· ir ‘ -‘·’

Case 2:04-cv-00429-MHM

Document 60-4

Filed 04/14/2006

Page 1 of 2

Case 2:04-cv-00429-MHM

Document 60-4

Filed 04/14/2006

Page 2 of 2