Free Memorandum - District Court of Arizona - Arizona

Pr -0 ______LODGED
" ___F`%E.CEiVED ____COPY _/___
_ + A %mM _Yé\;A_EM@E ;v\mm;___ %_ u_mq¤m+
:;;_£im< ng 5; [Q¤E2TF%|CT COURT
WW ,1»~s _ Tu ¤; , _;»»!;E_c;smrE;@»;m¤:;@¤??iii*gmiTT: § W
, ., , - ..- E¤¥%mDAE*U1;T£@' P£.B.B.lZ.9£&--.i..- ..-n
·a_LEgr+mv M W#»z~1_¤; ;;u. qgsitaee-MBH;E!3!<¤ (m ;5Laa7
A ¤ \ . EL¤··¤»;F ;· EM , . Mé ,-% __@»eT1 E£s_Imac;1;w~im¤1’;¤&¥ vEQ{& ,,__;_
_, __ __ € V _*A. %.Ig§ ue§+HQE__&@Ef_ £L·;xD-.EW\§[€fi€#E.€;`L._m “
__Dg¢i¢-LSQH &c>__z1i_&¤,___ __ __@iu,_m4cE <;&IBg§k£u @ $ q m2C7.I;:J€u;5_
.._._._...._ ._D_EE§~_Q Ti __.-. .___:é§-}E§.Q+ S QL§£@LL k A ,....“-. L
-.__-__....___ .`.. __ __ .___._._.. -._-___-.___&_CLE).E8.AI`EQH_E_·%@L¤1LREQ¢l557Z£@,--A-....-.-..~..r
% N _ , _%P&;cz;·?;f€e47.·z¢‘Q’m ; 15.y14»;¤ &¤; QEYJQQ éf M W_M _
_ w_ M _ _ W A,___,% m___hr1£m9 @&»gQm~;m¤ ¤1uFPoQTT1‘[H;fi€pQ ! _ MM-m-._~ _
.- .A £¤> Nxiizil Q0§l·l IRE--I)L.l°¢1 ra>I\.ErH?R¤_.iJ§.¤;if@K€QMYY.&fEQ§¢;.....,-- W-
% TGw: cw lj PLnew~T1£&REJ;mEsr_£¤»gzeGéT»gQ 1,J@:ygdwg?
r.ssu&·~ -41Ei IRQ {Sm 7w$.K._QQ.;$Ej >¢/ex#.·:i;N_,<1,_¢7zv€ >7%7amT Pcg2sw .1»»;Z'
N mm % ,&¢g I_g _ E:;! L@Lc;mJJ?;m“ m m_“_ _ M ”m-W A“+~_.-.m.--
W W www ,,,,,, W ,___`____®, nvi, , ,_W ,,W_ __ ,____,__iT,,, r,,i,i(,,W ii, ,,4+ ,,,. .-....._..__....._.-.
---.-._.. --.- ---.._-._---} ..-__-_-_--.-._-._,__ __M, _.-- _.-_.-._..-.-..___-_.-.- _.. ---_.-_._ .. -- --....-.- _..m+ UH.. ... ..
” lV&& m 0 @ lm1)um_ ¤ ~ BuPFc @TIH;R 5© £“ %_mW
—-V ~ ~~— —~-——-— -- sl: se··2:94—cv-OO4A¤6—dA;I: ---- +89—-Fi+ed4+/O8+2BG5-—Pag%1—0f—4¤~#~ ~~ ~-~

\}¤Jfrm, ;MM..%I___...._mmmFII_IM--.A,--+#_WIIIM -
__ I · Em»EI§£JmwB,;$;@; us;¤;mg;r;ag¤mIDIaiy;·>1L»4¤L~¤_P;gL¤gm§I
Him.}-2 " H\"> ;»l‘L€€*—-S1;\_&&Ls§”@5/[email protected].?§!5.i2€T_}*9T_P?EiP1HEH§@”Pé§l9..€B);.“w
,___ I * ·I£LBL¤§{L€&;DL?L*§LF_D, GEM! K_E,QL£!5£&G YHEQQEQ §£&~ 4 I J-
._1.uB;c;HmR ;;x.Wl<;¤9,GrO154iéZ£`LE}.&»[email protected]$@T”;éMx9&/4IȤz77/4@@;·1-.a»;z=L4aF%x¤;•6§II*.I._
a_L¤.e;&.._m;_ Wc§,w1LHI QN_(;~jJ1·1€_L1j.E:_¢;€-.f3;£~.¤;4§;____ _ I+IIMI .. % W?IA _,--.
_ I AH€m.r~.E€L1III§¢@Lg&\4Q!;\a.11$_,;5;T\;’@§QE4§IIv,QIB14tQe4·;£MQ.-h;;$_u_€?
`L I- : ¤ 04A£Z..IIi€K€& U;?riAI5Ij¢L6?L§@QYE;r~L-0;££f€._T/i£.L§2¤{4·?LIIIm- .... ._-.-I---
-_____ I Li1p._3]i}9SJ@1;~·EI;»41$II1$;3y_EQ._& [email protected].,C_H wfixwcl ¤r;0;a;a_@__M_IwI
__.§x§L - .CELE_P§E IcEIIIm'¤!~;-;\&¢L1b2 l;LJ_§_\€».4E¤_t~.-*.9-.lr!<. r—1· ·(§._LD.FH'§Q._ §L3§/9 , I --.. “.mw II
m___m_ L . g1£1(I?.L-LLCSJé:L"$£L.EQ?l.N;EP1£EQLlM£?iQ6;ré2L€{i¢L?T` E1LQIf°l!3;;v?ZE1?..,[email protected] TLQI
-_L\§Ii.BL| • I _l?L.K.&§E.5_b_1>LDm.QBQE&§fLiIIfIm.T9 E} _.- XQBQLQE! BE-QA @4_55.Q=!w§?_,Dé1émi¥w€!J_L*§*.E.P! r9§_.Ié._C@&§Q9Z€ f/L5 Imé/££LL4·/A r¤€....&B.ue·BE€.-. M.
.__-,.I¢; LIL IEE; .§QE1*’_T HM-;.G& HH _LE£Z Ayz£’i£;$id0z£y£Rg r¤_E°Lg;.A¤L3-. HL$..1ii¢£7!J7A~kL¢1.;;_. ..
_ER¤1£1y_ ~.:·. _V,P;IJ3€1`E&béAIussB.ER¤§Zfi€515II/iiuazgqlj;Ahimffnn0 00 Z`czE,£1F`Z3,A»yd .. nh
--.m-LE§._Rm§f IQR 3p*D1&‘dI$; QAIIAAI -__I u-.-- -..-__..__.______. _mI#_I IMIAAI ..,m.__-»$m
__...-- _ __ ,_ e TR1;. \;Th*[email protected]]1g€rELaL»g7lEEiIA§ HLED uhns ..En.&BEr;QYIm_¤E ¤1~£-..§¤§___- mm
I uL=.€im I-LLEF;IP~1~LL@*·.€&;Ej£;¤L`L-;i$;#-$§ ImQ.G_1'f\¤ 5“_H¤&;$;.L&£%IQ Hubégé. -fE?.Rm.51HDI IIIAIIII
W v“-mg:m31`;> cz&F1$cA1”;1wH¢a£;C1—tAL&L~Q§]¤i-bJ.&;E;_£L@IJv;0T!QH Io I\éa;c¤u»<>f;_____...
IIII I%AYI,¥ 1;.+&€xzr;mua;¤m!c;p£g¤¤.;a~o.s mq_»&s_¤_G;x;a_g¢5E w;THIp~IL1JB5us€ c€ gm; ..I`.. Im
IIJ}tJA[0il§!0$; » QP Qfkm-*1-f F F $I@i9€`(J+.DIL°~;L9_£§H !'·£T;;']HQKE`S\4LI§. QE. EVN-k§14»;C>I UAITH IQ!‘~!LH..ItkEQLAi€__
Im. TQELQMLQ T u;+§Jk;K§¤fLIIID9I€[¢2L,,I5!F~L1\§1'Er°~I If 0czI3¤dQl?€l5 .9.(L‘!10E__L1FI`$ .Ba¤_Q ..1;*55 IR§Q€§.m-__-
W,wr;»;1;m~¢I 4s¢;4TLL;sm;, JJ;m¢c5r&I¢I;»·€>,..E\ RE.Y¤¤4..$Tr:_L$,_l;¤¢·+G_T9...;¤~€:;cn1E;M ..
.--.In~~4 .mx·\‘=;E ~ \·1BU%€_DR.J.o gui&£5jfs__n&1E¤J¤5,:;4.L¤4Lxs,IIiIIIDQLJT una. 1F. V¤¤u.-l&nuE.r<...$r?Ec1A;m+
IAJ*L€EU$I 0R/J @~>4&¤>=_Qi;H L»;.tL.;_04L?£AmE_LZr'.Yw & NF
. _ __4»>».3p“1; t&;._<;.ET. 1@,sT_L¤;1·5¤;;¤;r;;:Qg¤;&@;s41w¤.·~.;.¤;es.@Qi.»·;;s;£r2WWII
.. ... -§3*..£9£.. §21nL§!é8AZéi‘.IJix nma¤;Am1%¤»A¢©s¢2©u5v--4¤age»zg¢4-.mW

’H__%QL;_ ___ PLAuJl1g;5 |)¤5cl..¤55j;@)1gALgg51ugg R 0RTH¤P • _ $H¤E‘S
cme, ¤¤~J> .'» umm];1;;r¤u.._r>L __};L4=m_¤_;_;g1;‘_;»un@t;5,;m¤¤m‘ mgmm. &¤;1uq;;;;z»¤‘i¤~r
I1—L€@g>r~· ;c~I€0 EL&·;QTL€M§;~;a1l;@»;$Hcfig. ML¤_;a ·>;r€_w;:;.·m_1m;:Ls;·n£Q;€mc¤U
_€.Ln_¤_¢§j;£E ... g;1i;~g:>;i.._;AP;$L&&`·;_9£_1`@J_¤‘.§._@B§m5_IL!;¤&·;~zI;jI;¤;La.sL“&»~&.__
A¤»·ksLz;.; »~;;;¤ »; ;s; ;>,[email protected]&&#ce>·+s»a0A PL,»24·;J3.< _1cA1“;M»»·A.1k+;;¤_;.2»m».=2;;14..1;£_m;3,__¢_ M
__.__._m»¤.-.mE~ ga su.G£c@§.O_...&@@L6;U_&;&_L¤ u4q»:_5.·—;‘2@ »?I,1¤xA*&· a1¢~74
Ire 3g¤sT;u€m6;;€E;_—IL;ow's m _.“_._“_i_____¤ M _ m____,
________ _p;gg;mg[ u. mc gngiggg got ¥ g;gs>5¤(jTn ;,m.1°1BL¤]gn·;e am F¤».~T . _
% J;%; u1uy;I$ 1 1gi ;> uQ11’ m&~ i<;¤ u;@;JAAu;¢1 a HT T
§€ E&§;_ c£ . Q»; 0JEw.,.·BmD Qc P¤m¤uLE PR0CE§$,_§f] 5T\?§{ g6§E’ET;sA_L_j@ip¤
· {Ewen an .. umu Ml. .E;¤ms¥m;gI;;.Ca·y;£H&.5.t§ UFL By;e]T1_PE),;___;__.._..mm
____ . .... ` h,D.0g, ¤ F£; gm1.$ &u~I1 E_€ 9 E~m@@e·;<_¤;*~;._q»g·2_'i? ?jczZ`é‘ {G us?. .44)
;4L~1m¤e»nLP H ms¤‘l{iAN0;jmQ1£E#m.Em CE c¤»»mI&&a1‘n;s¢;1jl&£&LL5 &,@11,.--m-“M_
1Q§ilEt]i¤)W v jWW_._____W.m m ) m- .4 n-_____m_.mm.._m_¤___M_+
-A.M_ & f 1 ;>mmz &<@L€m·;W»`[L£€%Jgw£¤@_Es;;TI;€_u5¢;£11; &,%
;¤»; __-.TI11§..[?L».»~T¤ . $E¤ER§ .u~»»z.·;[email protected];»94;?_Pjq;!~A. @ »~y2 A5u%»;ȣ , MQ 5 eug&;Js;·_¤@,r;g;g-_&_c;
m·;pI&LW ·. . @;»;@%1·=¤&E_@~;·g,gT;.€up;t;¤~;nm1LH;=yL1.L;;..g£;};_w};e;L;1i“mW@·
_A *_ ; t»¤¤E‘@’J{&;g;&;;2$ »ua,»;agE n,q F ,_13}_<;_3__1________
IJ ;¤m<<@@;riQ»,-.14ym&:;ss
_-;E~.ss11m¤;»~ .A<.0;y»>;m§szT; ¤W,l€1‘",FlLB§6
_WM_ I ! §g;@WI]5_5g; "lgo E5g;{:QgTmL3 gc,,,_.§gscA_'[:m»1 0F` ELm»¤'|`:€ S _ . LcHmr2,
_-__....--,_M__ 3 MDNQLU§iOALZgv&Ug·L@ r§il£ lE:>;§*_&iLCkt;,$mu4Tl15m€&C_+;»u»9 ;
;&M·, mmLy_g~limE@L}__ww_
1 x>J;;u¤;]3 %Q IJ;.Q_.-“_”_
M . +_ I &;;1 2y sE M ·¤»TE©
5 €m ¢¤L“1>£_ r~L¢;;LLJ_&8K&¤]`;QL_w_m
se, 2:O4 — cv—O .JD©[email protected] -• Q3 •• '!•- • ·

_ gym; gm ;u»<¢·sx;; ;IIQ&L_9g#;@ ma ggqf giéiuiiyié/£[email protected]`;+.-
w m, u© ·¤fHE,0W¤L-_lms2:2,0m; 7.£.Q25» .Lv 4 Mw*d_.
_ %
-__..__.__.._.... ._ ([email protected]&HQg 0E @!. L@B m w ~.w..% --.-..-...~.--m€
_“ _ %_ C <>P g£ H%E;mQH ¤;9_ was _mn r;;0;>_»»¢IH;; g;.LQ¤ cF M 6%
,___ Y£.0 95 IQ u; %<>;¤..¤¤»;¢>» L;. N _ “ MMM- ~ A % -.__
______ · ¤>¢m¤9kz €» Cé @4~;D n¢ % M- _ _N .- ..F M v.---M,» ” v vA.m
$ $l; ATHT“£.§;;;_ l_+ A M+ M mm +_A+..m. ..._-—
_, ,m m . , c 2J; L&4J; 1»»11a;i1&av+@1Za·»£% “ _ - m m._Wr A_M m“ M - V -
M ,G_H><· &··c· ${s;$ ¤¤L . ¢ ,» MN., Vm_..w
M _Q,;em _ __ ____ __ hem w » wqskmc-.T¤;g517 SEL.-.1.-.. _ m w k -.-.. .-..m
im _PsZ*J’&$OO3 ; Z W~#“~—-~··-~ 6!» €2tG4—cw6O4v5f6w|2¤r`1; %50cu’ri·r§FTF·T80—Fife0”·11·/O8f2OO5 PageW¢¤f¢t""‘—‘——·*"‘

Case 2:04-cv-00446-JAT

Document 180

Filed 11/08/2005

Page 1 of 4

Case 2:04-cv-00446-JAT

Document 180

Filed 11/08/2005

Page 2 of 4

Case 2:04-cv-00446-JAT

Document 180

Filed 11/08/2005

Page 3 of 4

Case 2:04-cv-00446-JAT

Document 180

Filed 11/08/2005

Page 4 of 4