Free Response to Motion - District Court of Delaware - Delaware

Case 1:04-cv-00339-JJF Document 107-2 Fnled 05/11/2005 Page 1 of 3
_ Page 288
· ( UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT ' V
FOR THE DISTRICT OF DELAWARE g_
——-———————-——---————- X .i
FEDERAL INSURANCE : CIVIL ACTION
COMPANY a/s/0 :
EZIBA.COM./AVACET, : NO. O4-339
INC., EZIBA :
SECURITIES CORP., :
P].aj.ntiff(s), : Z
V. : ,t
LIGHTHOUSE :
CONSTRUCTION, INC., :
BEc1 INC., and O'DONNELL, :
NACCARATO & :
MACINTOSH, INC., : ,f
Defendant (s) . :
..._..........______. X g-
MILLERS CAPITAL : CIVIL ACTION
INSURANCE COMPANY :
a/s/0 DEL-HOMES : NO. O4-1322-JJF jj
CATALOG GROUP, LLC, :
Plaintiff(s), :
V. : L
LIGHTHOUSE :
CONSTRUCTION, INC., : -
BECKER MORGAN GROUP, :
INC., and O‘DONNELL, :
NACCARATO & 2 `
MACINTOSH, INC., :
Defendant (s) :
and :
LIGHTHOUSE : {
CONSTRUCTION, INC., : I
Defendant and : ’
Third-Party : §
pmintiff, ; gi
v. :
EAST COAST ERECTORS, : ,?
INC., ; I
Third-Party :
De fendant . : E
-———--——-----—---———- x
E.
VOLUME 2
§
·» E
x.
F
ESQUIIG Depeeltlen SSIVICGS
d96f2ed1—584d—4f84-93f1-e11_1h0eB2'Id9 _

Case 1 :04-cv-00339-JJF Document 107-2 Fnled 05/1 1/2005 Page 2 of 3
Page 289 Page 291
k
1 Continued oral deposition of . - *“’*’,'?6RAN€F$= (¤¤·**7d);. . A E
V · 1 ROBERT C. MacLEISH, held at the law BAILE[&ASSOCIATES, 1>.A.
, OFFICES 61 c111uss1NoE1< & BAUMBERGER, 3 3 §$,,{{;;*§,S F ”MLEY· "*· ESQUM ;
4 Mill Road, Suite 301, Wilmington, DE 4 s1111e306-A g
5 19806, 01'1 M611c111y, April 11, 2005, 5 ;’,;5;1;·g*;gg°E”**°° 5
6 begimiing at 9: 15 a.m., before Debra J. E 1b¤i1=y@Jfb¤il¤y.¤¤m
7 Weaver, a Federally Approved RPR, CRR, _RePmmng me Dmndmn E
8 CSR of NJ (No. XI 01614) and Delaware Z R¤b=¤ M¤¤1¤t9¤h
9 (No. 138-RFR., Expiration 1/31/08), and a Mcmm & Mmm-[T_ p_C_
1 O Notary Public of New Jersey, Pennsylvania 9 §Y;¢§€)BERT B· H"—'— ESQUIRE é
U1 ;
1 1 and Delaware. 10 3445 rmunee 1461111, N11. 1
]_ 2 Atlanta. GA 303201276
1 1 404,266.9l71
1 3 1111111@¤1¤¤1a111-me11111¤6m
1 4 1 2 =
AND :1
1 5 1 3 §f
WI?l`ZEL&ASSOClATES. PA li
1 6 1 4 BY; NATALIE M. IPPOLJTO, Bsourmz 5
1 7 1113 can-nge 116111*, sum 201 1;.
1 8 . 1 s 1100 14161411 Gmntlggmue
W111111111;1611. ma os
1 9 1 6 $02652.1200 1
[email protected] ‘f
2 O 17
2 1 -·Represen•jng me Defendant, gg
22 asounza DEPOSITION SERVICES 12 "*“‘°°“‘E‘°°‘°“·‘"°
1880 John F. Kennedy Boulevard Z 0 M-$0 PRESENT
2 3 15th Floor 2 1 DAVE MALDNE
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19103
24 (215) 988-9191 , 24
Page 290 Page 292
1 APPEARANCES: 1 I N D E X
2 2 wmnass PAGE r.
com o1:o1~11~1oB 3 Bomaizr c. Mm:1.E.lSH
3 BY: srisvzw 1; GERBER, Bsounua 4 BY MR. 11111 300 {
1900 M¤¤‘k=¤ stm BY MR. BAILEY 399
4 1>1111111111,11111, PA 19103.3300 5 BYMS_1,m-mNE 422
5 2*5-665-20** BY M11 PINGITORE 434
6 j ;;"Qmm 6 BY Mn HILL 435
7 F°i°'“'I"‘“""°°°°‘“"*’“’ EXHIBITS
a WH'1'1'EANDWILLlAMS,LLP 8
BY; Bon 1.. rmonoius, Bsouuua MARKED DFSCIUPTION PAGE 1
9 1800 one 1.111my 1=146c 9
1>11111111e1p11111, PA 19103 0416111110-30 s1111¤6111m1 300 g;
10 2l5.B64.7000 1 0 agreement dated 1
[email protected] 6/29/95 between
1 1 1 1 East Co 1 5
-11q>1es¤1111¤g IhePl¤imiE Emewrsaind ii
12 Mmm Capital 111s111-111112 c6. 1 2 o¤1.11611¤s, 1116., 1
13 "
CHRISSINGER 2 BAUMBERGER I 3
14 ;3E“}>&\;g> BAUMBERGER. PSQWRE 14 1v111c14111131 swam F61-111 of 301
15 S . 30 Agreerrient between
\11i.ii:111·1gi1·111, me 191106 15 1'g"“`°"’*F
16 302.777,0lOO C°“"'“°“°“ °?‘d
11m1.1111111111x1w@1111¤11y11111¤1111.1>¤111 16
’ " ’ ' " "' '
17 _Rq,,.,,,,,,,,,,g,,,,[,,f,.,,,,,,,,,_ 17 11111., dated
1 14 1.1g1101611S3 c611¤111¤11611, ine. 1 8 gg;/§§.3!;=;r=s IH
1 9 - 1
1·1o1-113, CO'['I`RELL 111 LOGAN, 1>.A. 1 9 1v14¤1e1s11-32 11e¤e1d111¢d 301
20 BY; VICTORIA 1; rnrnowa Bsovm; 402/99 16
nm 1191111111 Plaza 20 ug11111611s¢ 11-0111
2 1 P.O. Box 1031 mph DEB}; jj
W111111111;11111 on 19299 2 1 osgm .91 sm,
22 $01658.6400 Bates LH
v.petrnne@l¤wtc|.eom 2 2 00504606
- -B¤p1¤4¤1¤111g me Defendant, E 3 =
9 ....... . 4..,..,.. 4 . ... .. .3. 4.......,.. 2 .~.,,. ..4 2 .,. 4 ..... . ... ... ....4.,... ....,.. ,.. ... ..,....,01 ....... . .....
, 2 (Pages 289 to 292)
Esquire Deposition Services g
p W D A d96f2ed1-584d-4fB4-93f1—e111 b0e827d9

Case 1:04-cv-00339-JJF Document 107-2 Filed 05/11/2005 Page 3 of 3
ROBERT C . MacLEISH I
_ I I- Page 353 Page 355
I A. No, I cannot. 1 MR. PINGITORE: Bob, I think
2 MR. HILL: We've been going 2 that was previously marked. ?·
3 right at an hour. Are you doing 3 MK HILL: Which exhibit is
4 okay? 4 it? =§
5 THE WITNESS: Yes. I'm 5 MR. PINGITORE: 26. .
6 okay. Thank you. 6 BY MR. HILL: `
7 (Whereupon, Deposition 7 Q. Okay. Mr. Pingitore has {_
8 Exhibit No. MacLeish-56, Standard 8 kindly helped me by producing MacLeish
9 Form of Agreement Between 9 Exhibit 26. Is that the Letter of t
1 O Contractor and Subcontractor, ` 1 O Intent?
1 1 dated 3/15/99, between Lighthouse 1 1 A. Yes, sir. ij
1 2 Construction, Inc., and East Coast 1 2 Q. And so it's the Form AIA gg
1 3 Erectors, Inc., Bates LH 1 3 A40l that's referred to in the
1 4 2703-2716, was marked for 1 4 next-to-last paragraph that I showed you
1 5 identification.) 1 5 just a moment ago that wasn't signed?
1 6 BY MR. HILL: j 1 6 A. That's correct, sir.
1 7 Q. MacLeish Exhibit Number 56 1 7 MR. BAUMZBERGER: What
1 8 is Bates numbered LH 2703 through LH 1 8 exhibit number was that?
1 9 2716. It is a Standard Form of Agreement 1 9 MR. PINGITORE: 26.
2 0 Between Contractor and Subcontractor. It 2 O MR; HILL: 26. 9
2 1 has a date ofthe 15th day ofMarch in 2 1 BY MR. HILL: -
2 2 the year 1999 between contractor 2 2 Q. I'm not sure that I want to
2 3 Lighthouse Construction, Inc., and East 2 3 make this an exhibit until I figure out
2 4 Coast Erectors, Inc. Did I read that 2 4 what it is.
n Page 354 Page 356
1 correctly? 1 I have some docmnents from,
2 A. Yes, sir. 2 I want to pronoimce this Steinle. Is
3 Q. Okay. Now, if I Hip over 3 that correct? We'll use that.
- 4 to the page that's numbered LH 2712, 4 S-T—E-I-N-L-E Construction Engineers,
5 which is the signature line for this 5 Inc. E;
6 document, it's not signed, is it? 6 MS. PETRONE: It's Steinle.
7 A. No, sir. 7 BY MR HHJL: {
8 Q. Now, do you know of any 8 Q. Are you familiar with
9 signed agreement between East Coast 9 Steinle Construction Engineers?
1 0 Erectors, Inc., and Lighthouse 1 O A. No, I am not. E;
1 1 Construction, Inc., other than Mr. 1 1 Q. Well, this looks like a
1 2 Williams' proposal that we've already 1 2 proposal to Mr. McKone dated February
1 3 identified? 1 3 18th, 1999. For the record, it's Bates
1 4 A. The only other -— no, there 1 4 numbered LH 3970 through LH 3976. Have
1 5 was no signed agreement. There was just 1 5 you seen this proposal?
1 6 a Letter of Intent that was sent to them. 1 6 A. In my review of the
1 7 Q. Okay. So can you explain 1 7 documents, yes.
1 8 why this document was never signed? 1 8 Q. Okay. Were you familiar
1 9 A. No, I cannot. 1 9 with it before reviewing the documents
2 O Q. Do you recall whether or not 2 0 prior to your deposition?
2 1 I've identified in this pile of documents 2 1 A. No.
2 2 the Letter of Intent that you just 2 2 MR. HILL: Maybe we better
" 3 referred to? 2 3 mark it as an exhibit. I'm sony. Ei
` » A. No, you have not. 2 4 (Whereupon, Deposition
18 (Pages 353 to 356)
Esquire Deposition Services
1 . . d96f2ed1-5841:1-4f84-93f1-e111h0e82`Id9

Case 1:04-cv-00339-JJF

Document 107-2

Filed 05/11/2005

Page 1 of 3

Case 1:04-cv-00339-JJF

Document 107-2

Filed 05/11/2005

Page 2 of 3

Case 1:04-cv-00339-JJF

Document 107-2

Filed 05/11/2005

Page 3 of 3