Free Redacted Document - District Court of Delaware - Delaware

Case 1 :04-cv-00360-JJF Document 220-8 Filed 08/29/2006 Page 1 of 2
$%<¤>."
0 T J/i» V- s- .· ;.V_; ,,_ ;_;. ,;.:%:,.. ..1 $1. · `»,~>»=-.»V~~ .'·" ; » I, gm
invc {Of • _ , a- 1 Lp :. ·-n ew `” *· -··:’.° ·'“” . . V ··’· me- ~ ., MQ#1 ·¤~~-·» · ;~>
· ·· fg > ·*·; · 1 ` »· .. ¤, · · · 1 ` · — ‘ ¢- Qi
pe so ~ .. t_ _c v, _ .~,.··»’ _ ~· , ____ 1,r_*4`&W { I §*·gi .,q ‘l'!’v ‘ LLA -Z •Ii>.9" MJLT
wn nc.ss`qggce;n or a
••¤• •. . • _— ·:. . ·· •• · -. .·~..; •· ,»<=.= · · /‘ ’ · ° " · ·*i"‘”‘ *5*: *· #·s:.¤ -.--1. 1;:.; »»··»¤
ass é$x@$C;$?T;é€h§é ifi to Radisson as hc weigh
_ •·>$·’• Mu- ¤:yf~;·,h_~!·'%T.i'é`· ¥§’F~':‘*.'$¢€ #: 1. eil ¤·i:···•¤; ,_ ·~ 45;·.;~~,gm =,;;g»;¤‘=‘ an- · .;:3 ... - ;,;.g_~ · ·_ ts.
38. On Jul;/21, 1997, Mr.
Storey assigned the ‘8'/0 param application and rclatcd rights to Nctccmivcs. *5
:v.», ;;>:··.=. L :1:;,:11 ·‘ ··• ;’ ' • . l ; i T . T“3`%¤~z": *.·· 1 -
‘ 1_ · 1 Ee _ · ,g= ` ‘=·-1T —», · =;-; —-— Zi » ' ·. ~
S ·‘ »' V. =~¤···=#7*'&*‘—~~··“-·*é*?$3·%e·:.»·r#·g._:s—·:.· .=·:—:¤=·=... ‘ ~ ~ , _
Q1} ‘ ’ »·/· S? — ——5~:»·e " -‘. ,
REQACTED
.
' . _, .»“.¤!v R ‘V"#` `*`£*°"-Q 'i·3·* ‘¤ :· we . 1. s g ,4 L`; i ,. ;*5 p c, . 1“..._i..>,ja.y ¤_ {», ;_·~j$- 1} ‘i*1 ·<‘··g·w·;*
h _‘ .2 J; . . ,a.\t·,. £..,• .. ;q&$·¤;·_ ¢¥·r¤J,:·»·;;::*·$.,;r··»;;·;_ W.; V; Q y ; r` T >y,v { · ~
19

Case 1 :04-cv-00360-JJF Document 220-8 Filed 08/29/2006 Page 2 of 2
-40. The *870 patent issued on Juno 30, 1998. Five days carlicr, Nctccntivcs hud filed
a continuation application, which later issued as the ‘4I2 patent, claiming priority to the original
ism application.
·.r· ~., · . .r M:. j ~» ·¤·~ t»·*é»a· ~ ~r .¤~,.‘1¤ ·~¤é·~· Tr.
41. In October, l998, Netccntives, through its patent counsel, took the highly unusual
step of filing a Petition to Make Special the ’4l2 continuation application citing, inter alia, the
*444 {Look to Book) patent.
REQACFED
‘ N ‘ i i ,.» ¤. 1QZ`»`,·.E¤,‘.Ai;1’.I**f_[,;. .r;i».‘t· tt .2; tj; -
'¤*" *`¤*"*’ i ’?" ¤ s r·= » 5 —,··¤s: ¤_ ,5;. " SM :· ·~~ · ,
· i · , :.. .3 F _é· ;t_ ;;,,;,§ ; , *.,.,,;·_ jg :_ ._ .;_»,a;~s, - »~ v :1 Q; w ·:· 4 »· .
i $t;·.=¤¤ ~ =tt =·=~= »;s· : -··s r = ¤·t¤n s;ts ·····z-· ~ ·;».·se;¢t» is · ie —»·¤-·<= = .~—, · > t
I __ ,~ _ vii,. I _ M I JSF; ,_ ,,,,._ }! .:_ _,.,_> ,7 3:, ;_ i _:·és.,;__, L¢.;;.g»:,,·..` ;•*;'—i ,~t1 ';_,t, ';· J _ ,, _ _ _:
stt.gtgem&r¤·t=N “t$E·‘éEuTi€>‘n?Y¤%
L 4 _4» · ., :.4..,}, hl ,3 V, _ i. ~_ _ " 2} _‘_; v v:4" E)-Eb-ue wg 1;,%,,} ,;,,.‘;y`. V. E n·L:_E*· ; ; · ¤—»»: ;,`,_;_,_. ,.. ..: _.:, V _ >
Ti§%`§§téat%’gtts"ammtaa¢;rneaa·5aa*ttanrinsan¤n;.
b. This intentional supcrticiali ty is demonstrated bythe failure to disclose
that Mr. Storey, the purported inventor ofthe subject matter of the ‘4l2 patent application, was a
named inventor ofthe ‘444 patent. Further,
Netcentives—; characterized the Radisson patent as “not discl0s[ing] or st¤ggest[ing]
,_ .t,i’, · ”
20

Case 1:04-cv-00360-JJF

Document 220-8

Filed 08/29/2006

Page 1 of 2

Case 1:04-cv-00360-JJF

Document 220-8

Filed 08/29/2006

Page 2 of 2