Free Letter - District Court of Delaware - Delaware

Case 1:04-cv-00360-JJF

Document 234-2

Filed 09/12/2006

Page 1 of 37

EXHIBIT 11

Case 1:04-cv-00360-JJF

Document 234-2

Filed 09/12/2006

Page 2 of 37

EXHIBIT 11 TO JOINT PRETRIAL ORDER MARITZ'S DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS AND AFFINION'S OBJECTIONS

MARITZ'S DESIGNATIONS Albert, Philip H. (6/14/01) 6:25-8:21 10:12-11:25 12:5-8 12:11-15 12:17-13:23 14:11-23 15:5-10 16:9-10 16:15-20 17:3-18:2 18:9-20:5 23:21-24:6 24:24-25:24 26:9-18 27:23-25 28:8-29:4 30:15-33:20 34:6-8 35:8-37:1 37:7-13 37:21-38:8 38:14-24 39:6-19 39:25-40:6 39:21-41:1 41:4-14 41:18-20 43:9-44:3 44:6-46:6 46:11-47:22 47:25-48:16 49:13-17 50:11-16 51:1-5 53:12-16 53:20-67:16 67:25-70:11

AFFINION'S OBJECTIONS

Relevance Relevance Relevance Relevance

Relevance Relevance Relevance; legal conclusion Relevance; legal conclusion Relevance Relevance Relevance Relevance Relevance Relevance Relevance Relevance; legal conclusion Relevance; legal conclusion Relevance; legal conclusion Relevance; legal conclusion Relevance; legal conclusion Relevance; legal conclusion Relevance; legal conclusion Relevance; argumentative Relevance; legal conclusion Relevance; legal conclusion Relevance; legal conclusion Relevance; legal conclusion Relevance; legal conclusion Relevance; legal conclusion

Case 1:04-cv-00360-JJF

Document 234-2

Filed 09/12/2006

Page 3 of 37

70:20-73:11 74:18-77:8 77:16-78:22 79:21-80:23 81:16-82:6 83::13-84:6 92:8-93:10 93:20-94:2 95:14-20 101:3-103:4 103:11 103:21-104:19 104:22-105:6 113:1-12 115:18-116:20 118:16-119:8 125:20-24 127:1-128:8 128:17-129:1 129:18-130:20 134:12-139:23 156:15-160:4 Bach, Joseph (5/11/01) 5:19-6:11 7:20-8:18 9:6-:22 10:13-11:11 11:23-17:20 28:11-:22 31:1-:21 31:24-:25 32:2-:3 32:5-:6 33:17-34:17 37:8-:19 38:24-39:6 42:21-43:1 43:12-:19 44:22-45:1 46:13-:25 47:3-48:1 48:8-:25 49:9-:25 50:17-:21 2

Relevance; legal conclusion Relevance; legal conclusion Incomplete designation

Incomplete designation

Relevance Relevance Relevance Relevance; speculation Relevance; improper hypothetical

Relevance; legal conclusion; incomplete designation

Relevance Relevance Speculation

Relevance Relevance

Incomplete designation

Case 1:04-cv-00360-JJF

Document 234-2

Filed 09/12/2006

Page 4 of 37

51:13-:16 51:20-52:2 52:21-53:1 54:10-67:17 67:19-:23 68:6-:13 68:18-69:2 69:22-:25 72:1-75:17 75:23-78:10 78:13-81:18 81:22-82:5 84:16-85:15 86:14-:19 88:5-:8 88:18-:24 89:5-91:17 92:20-93:15 Bach, Joseph (4/6/06) 7:11-:18 8:10-14:5 18:21-19:5 20:5-42:1 42:6-47:12 47:19-50:5 50:18-51:2 51:19-52:19 53:3-63:9 63:15-65:17 66:2-:18 67:1-68:9 68:11-:21 69:1-:7 69:9-70:16 70:18-71:12 71:14-74:1 74:8-75:11 75:18-77:20 77:22-88:8 88:13-90:15 91:2-92:4 92:8-93:11 93:13-98:1 3

Assertion of privilege; attorney discussion; legal conclusion; relevance Lack of foundation; relevance Lack of foundation Incomplete designations Relevance; lack of foundation Lack of foundation; relevance Lack of foundation; relevance Lack of foundation; relevance Lack of foundation; legal conclusion; relevance Lack of foundation; legal conclusion; relevance Lack of foundation; legal conclusion; relevance Lack of foundation; legal conclusion; relevance Lack of foundation; legal conclusion; relevance Duplicative Duplicative Duplicative; lack of foundation Legal conclusion; relevance Legal conclusion; relevance Incomplete designation; lack of foundation; legal conclusion Lack of foundation; legal conclusion; relevance

Case 1:04-cv-00360-JJF

Document 234-2

Filed 09/12/2006

Page 5 of 37

98:3-:9 98:12-:16 98:18-104:2 104:4-:16 104:18-106:14 107:1-115:5 115:7-:20 116:8-119:18 119:20-120:5 120:8-121:4 121:7-:14 121:16-124:9 124:11-:15 124:17 125:6-129:7 129:9-:11 129:14-130:11 130:13-:22 131:4-133:18 133:22-136:8 136:10 136:16-139:4 139:6-:8 139:13-140:16 140:22-142:19 143:1-:5 143:7-:13 143:16-:21 144:1 144:6-:12 4

Lack of foundation; legal conclusion; relevance Lack of foundation; legal conclusion; relevance Lack of foundation; relevance Lack of foundation; legal conclusion; improper hypothetical Lack of foundation; legal conclusion; improper hypothetical Lack of foundation; improper hypothetical Duplicative; improper hypothetical Duplicative; improper hypothetical Improper hypothetical; lack of foundation Improper hypothetical; lack of foundation Improper hypothetical; lack of foundation Improper hypothetical; lack of foundation; legal conclusion Lack of foundation Lack of foundation; speculation Relevance; lack of foundation Relevance; lack of foundation; improper hypothetical Relevance; lack of foundation; improper hypothetical Relevance; lack of foundation; improper hypothetical; incomplete designation Relevance; lack of foundation; improper hypothetical Relevance; lack of foundation; improper hypothetical Relevance; lack of foundation; improper hypothetical Relevance; lack of foundation; improper hypothetical Relevance; lack of foundation Relevance; lack of foundation; incomplete designation Relevance; lack of foundation; improper hypothetical Relevance; lack of foundation; improper hypothetical Relevance; lack of foundation; improper hypothetical Relevance; lack of foundation; improper hypothetical

Case 1:04-cv-00360-JJF

Document 234-2

Filed 09/12/2006

Page 6 of 37

144:17-146:22 147:4-148:4 148:13-149:2 149:6-151:16 151:18-154:12 154:17-156:19 164:21-165:14 169:7-170:6 175:19-177:12 179:5-181:2 181:11-182:3 Bell, Gregory K, Ph.D. (6/12/06) 7:5-:6 7:18-8:13 8:20-12:7 17:22-21:10 28:6-:10 32:18-33:4 33:23-34:10 35:25-36:25 48:15-50:14 53:20-54:17 55:25-56:4 56:8-:25 57:4-:9 59:1-60:9 60:18-61:12 62:23-63:9 64:4-:10 64:11-:15 65:24-66:7 66:19-67:2 67:8-67:14 67:18-68:23 69:6-73:5 74:3-75:9 78:2-81:16 82:24-83:11 83:17-:21 86:6-:17 93:20-94:5 94:14-95:8 96:9-97:9 98:2-99:25 5

Relevance; lack of foundation; improper hypothetical Relevance Relevance

Lack of foundation; improper hypothetical

Case 1:04-cv-00360-JJF

Document 234-2

Filed 09/12/2006

Page 7 of 37

102:14-103:5 121:22-123:23 124:17-127:23 Beller, Marti (12/15/05) 8:12-9:17 11:9-:18 12:20-13:21 14:5-:13 15:12-17:5 17:12-18:15 18:21-20:13 20:21-22:9 23:9-:13 23:17-26:12 26:18-28:13 28:18-31:2 31:7-32:17 32:22-33:5 33:22-36:5 36:11-38:18 39:19-42:12 43:22-44:8 44:20-45:12 45:18-46:11 47:2-49:3 49:8-51:20 52:8-55:1 56:4-57:20 58:13-60:5 60:15-62:11 63:17-64:9 64:13-64:15 64:21-72:10 73:2-:16 75:12-76:2 76:8-77:9 79:14-86:2 86:14-87:1 87:4-90:1 90:13-92:3 92:9-95:10 96:1-:18 97:10-102:7 103:2-:11 103:16-105:1 6

Relevance

Relevance; lack of foundation Lack of foundation; speculation Relevance

Lack of foundation

Lack of foundation; relevance Lack of foundation; relevance Assertion of privilege; relevance Incomplete designation; relevance Relevance

Lack of foundation; speculation Lack of foundation; relevance

Assertion of privilege; relevance Assertion of privilege; relevance Assertion of privilege; relevance

Case 1:04-cv-00360-JJF

Document 234-2

Filed 09/12/2006

Page 8 of 37

107:11-109:6 110:16-113:9 113:15-114:20 115:3-121:1 121:7-122:22 123:6-124:17 125:2-:7 125:19-126:8 126:14-:22 127:21-129:1 129:11-:15 129:19-131:12 132:9-133:17 134:2-:7 134:11-135:6 140:2-:11 140:15-144:7 144:13-:15 144:18-:19 147:2-:19 148:11-152:6 152:15-154:15 154:20-157:9 157:14-158:14 158:20-160:3 162:9-166:17 169:12-:20 170:4-:22 171:6-172:15 172:20-174:7 174:12-175:17 197:12-199:9 199:15-200:4 201:8-:11 201:18-:22 202:5-:10 202:13-203:8 205:21-206:2 206:4-208:15 209:6-211:4 213:6-217:2 217:7-:18 218:7-219:5 219:17-222:16 223:3-:17 7

Lack of foundation; relevance Lack of foundation; relevance

Lack of foundation; speculation

Lack of foundation

Assertion of privilege

Lack of foundation; relevance

Relevance; lack of foundation; speculation

Assertion of privilege

Speculation; lack of foundation Assertion of privilege; attorney discussion

Case 1:04-cv-00360-JJF

Document 234-2

Filed 09/12/2006

Page 9 of 37

224:5-226:2 226:12-227:5 227:7-230:21 231:15-:19 231:22-232:8 232:13-234:3 234:7-:9 234:21-238:15 239:7-243:6 243:20-246:2 247:13-248:20 250:5-254:11 255:1-259:4 259:9-266:22 Beller, Marti (12/16/05) 286:16-288:21 297:9-298:4 319:13-:20 329:4-330:15 332:4-333:4 333:18-:21 334:9-:11 334:17-336:8 336:11-338:1 338:6-:14 339:6-:13 340:5-:15 340:22-341:19 342:7-:16 342:21-343:5 344:1-:17 345:4-:11 346:3-:12 346:18-348:1 352:17-353:11 353:18-356:19 357:11-358:11 358:13-359:2 359:20-360:8 366:10-:18 367:18-368:14 371:18-372:5 8

Assertion of privilege

Incomplete designation

Relevance; lack of foundation; assertion of privilege Relevance Relevance Relevance Assertion of privilege; relevance Relevance Relevance Relevance Relevance; assertion of privilege Relevance Relevance Relevance; assertion of privilege Relevance Relevance; assertion of privilege Relevance Incomplete designation; relevance; assertion of privilege Relevance Relevance; assertion of privilege Relevance; assertion of privilege; incomplete designation Relevance Incomplete designation

Relevance Relevance Lack of foundation

Case 1:04-cv-00360-JJF

Document 234-2

Filed 09/12/2006

Page 10 of 37

372:12-373:7 374:18-375:2 375:20-377:1 380:13-381:22 383:12-385:5 385:19-386:6 388:20-389:14 390:13-:20 392:5-:1 Beller, Marti (5/19/06) 407:5-:8 408:14-:21 409:5-:21 411:21-412:21 413:3-414:21 419:9-420:5 422:6-422:17 426:4-427:20 429:7-430:9 433:1-433:8 435:5-:15 435:16-436:9 439:6 439:11-:20 441:3-:4 441:7-:20 441:22-442:10 445:13-448:2 448:6-:7 448:12 448:14-:19 452:8-454:13 462:11-:15 463:15-466:5 469:11-:21 470:4-:11 473:1-:6 474:12-:16 475:3-:4 475:7 475:18-476:4 476:15 477:11-478:10 482:10-:18 483:11-:17 9

Incomplete designation; lack of foundation

Relevance Incomplete designation

Incomplete designation Incomplete designation Relevance Incomplete designation Relevance

Incomplete designation

Relevance Relevance Relevance Relevance Relevance Relevance Relevance Relevance Relevance Relevance Relevance Lack of foundation; attorney argument Lack of foundation; attorney argument Lack of foundation; attorney argument Relevance; lack of foundation Relevance; lack of foundation Lack of foundation; relevance Relevance

Case 1:04-cv-00360-JJF

Document 234-2

Filed 09/12/2006

Page 11 of 37

483:21-484:9 484:21-485:17 485:9-:13 488:1-:8 488:15-:17 498:5-:18 499:11-500:13 504:6-:9 504:16-:17 505:17-506:12 506:15-:19 516:16-517:13 518:1-:11 519:10-:21 522:13-523:15 525:12-:16 530:5-:6 530:10 531:13-:17 532:7-:10 532:21-533:2 537:8-:15 537:20 542:8-:10 542:19-543:6 544:3-:5 544:12-:14 547:3-:4 547:10-:15 548:10-:12 548:14-:16 549:4-:20 550:3-:13 550:18-:19 551:2-:15 551:20-552:1 Bushold, Thomas (3/2/06) 5:9-6:16 6:25-12:2 12:5-10 13:23-16:12 17:2-20:20 21:3-24 22:2-23:22 23:25-24:15 10

Incomplete designation

Lack of foundation

Lack of foundation

Lack of foundation; relevance Lack of foundation; relevance Lack of foundation; relevance Lack of foundation; relevance Lack of foundation; relevance Lack of foundation; relevance Lack of foundation; relevance Lack of foundation; relevance Lack of foundation; relevance Lack of foundation; relevance Lack of foundation; relevance Lack of foundation; relevance Lack of foundation; relevance Lack of foundation; relevance Lack of foundation; relevance Relevance Relevance Relevance Relevance; form Relevance; form Relevance

Incomplete designation

Case 1:04-cv-00360-JJF

Document 234-2

Filed 09/12/2006

Page 12 of 37

24:18-25:8 73:1-76:14 116:24-117:2 117:5-7 117:15-23 120:7-121:5 121:8-20 144:15-145:19 159:18-20 160:1-8 172:17-173:24 174:5-8 174:10-18 Chaney, Colleen (3/22/06) 9:11-10:4 10:8-:14 11:4-12:6 12:12-:21 14:1-:6 126:2-:3 126:15-127:22 147:19-150:11 150:18-151:13 152:10-:15 152:22-153:13 153:16 153:18-155:6 155:7-156:19 157:22-159:3 Fliesler, Martin (6/15/01) 6:25-7:10 13:1-14:8 Gandrud, David (5/24/01) 4:9-5:3 5:11-12 10:3-13 10:24-11:13 11:23-12:24 16:20-18:25 24:20-25:14 25:16-26:19 26:25-27:4 32:7-34:13 35:1-36:9 36:13-24 11

Incomplete designation

Incomplete designation

Relevance; foundation Relevance; foundation Relevance; legal conclusion Relevance; legal conclusion

Incomplete designation Incomplete designation Incomplete designation

Relevance; incomplete designation

Relevance Incomplete designation

Case 1:04-cv-00360-JJF

Document 234-2

Filed 09/12/2006

Page 13 of 37

37:2-38:7 45:25-46:13 67:21-70:25 Gang, Sherri A. (7/21/06) 6:12-:14 8:09-9:23 12:01-14:12 14:18-15:10 16:3-:21 17:13-:24 18:2-:12 20:23-21:5 22:8-22:21 22:22-24:2 25:7-:22 26:6-27:2 28:1-29:14 29:15-32:23 33:4-34:7 34:15-35:8 35:13-36:9 37:10-:18 41:15-43:8 58:1-:6 Gray, Gerald T. (6/14/01) 7:1-15 9:21-10:11 14:18-16:20 17:5-:8 18:16-:23 30(b)(6) and Heintzeman, Scott (5/23/01) 4:9-5:10 5:16-19 7:1-8:25 10:10-23 11:14-12:14 12:20-16:15 17:3-18:2 19:12-20:3 20:5-7 20:24-21:12 22:7-16 22:19-23 22:25-24:24 25:2-27:9 12

Relevance Relevance Incomplete designation

Relevance; lack of foundation; speculation

Relevance; legal conclusion; foundation

Relevance

Case 1:04-cv-00360-JJF

Document 234-2

Filed 09/12/2006

Page 14 of 37

28:25-35:5 38:25-40:20 49:8-14 49:25-50:21 51:1-16 53:20-57:7 57:23-61:18 62:20-63:10 66:2-15 73:22-24 74:2-8 74:11-75:8 75:21-76:18 83:16-18 84:9-17 85:6 85:10-17 Hodges, Andrew (1/19/06) 9:10-17:2 17:12-22:22 24:22-25:5 27:1-28:22 31:9-32:4 32:22-33:21 50:7-22 54:3-56:8 56:17-57:6 61:7-18 62:1-20 64:22-66:2 66:11-21 68:12-69:1 69:15-71:20 72:17-73:18 74:1-18 75:1-17 76:4-9 79:11-13 80:14-81:21 82:4-18 83:1-14 84:10-85:5 87:13-88:9 92:9-18 93:1-10 13

Relevance Relevance

Relevance Relevance

Relevance Relevance

Relevance Relevance; incomplete designation

Relevance; lack of foundation

Relevance

Lack of foundation; relevance Lack of foundation; relevance Relevance Relevance; lack of foundation Relevance; lack of foundation Relevance; lack of foundation Relevance; lack of foundation

Case 1:04-cv-00360-JJF

Document 234-2

Filed 09/12/2006

Page 15 of 37

97:6-9 97:14-98:1 98:5-8 98:13-99:9 105:20-106:10 109:13-20 110:1-13 110:22-111:5 112:13-20 113:2-9 113:15-21 114:5-14 116:2-117:6 118:2-119:22 120:17-122:16 123:22-125:16 127:4-8 130:10-15 131:3-10 132:8-12 132:18-133:4 137:10-21 141:7-19 142:9-20 142:22-143:2 143:22-144:5 145:20-146:1 169:16-173:8 173:10-16 174:3-198:2 Hsu, Chih-Cheng (5/12/06) 6:14-:20 8:8-13:6 13:15-14:1 14:19-15:15 17:6-19:18 19:20-20:16 20:18-21:6 21:8-22:11 22:13-22:20 23:1-:3 23:8-24:9 24:11-26:1 26:12-27:9 14

Lack of foundation Lack of foundation; speculative Lack of foundation; speculative Lack of foundation Lack of foundation Lack of foundation Lack of foundation

Relevance Object to form; Relevance Relevance Speculative Relevance

Speculative; lack of foundation Relevance Incomplete designation Relevance; improper citation of assertion of privilege; lack of foundation

Lack of foundation Lack of foundation

Case 1:04-cv-00360-JJF

Document 234-2

Filed 09/12/2006

Page 16 of 37

27:11-28:11 28:13-29:8 30:9-31:2 31:4-35:18 36:6-37:2 37:4-:14 37:16-37:21 38:1-38:15 38:17-39:8 39:10 39:12-40:9 40:11-41:4 41:6-:11 41:14-42:12 41:15-:17 42:19-43:17 43:19-44:4 45:11-45:20 45:22-46:1 46:3-46:12 46:14-47:2 47:4-48:12 48:14-:18 48:21-49:2 50:5-:7 50:9-:22 51:3-52:5 52:7-:11 52:13-:15 55:11-56:13 56:15-:21 57:2-59:2 59:4-62:14 62:16-63:12 63:14-64:3 64:5-66:7 66:9-:19 66:20-67:10 67:12-:15 67:17-68:10 68:12-68:21 69:1-:8 69:10-:13 69:15-:17 69:19-70:1 15

Case 1:04-cv-00360-JJF

Document 234-2

Filed 09/12/2006

Page 17 of 37

70:3-72:16 72:18-73:18 73:20-74:5 74:7-:18 74:20-75:5 75:7-:13 75:16-:17 75:19-78:10 78:18-79:18 79:20-81:3 81:5-:10 81:13-83:10 83:12-:17 83:19-84:4 84:6-:12 86:1-86:13 86:15-87:5 87:7-88:15 88:17-89:11 89:13-:16 89:18 95:1-96:16 96:18-97:2 97:4 98:16-99:10 99:14-100:10 101:4-:7 104:4-105:20 105:22-106:6 106:8-:18 110:10-:12 110:14-:20 112:2-:7 112:9 114:11-117:1 117:3-118:22 119:2-:3 119:5-121:5 121:12-:13 121:15 121:17-122:11 122:13 127:10-:21 162:6-:21 168:21-169:6 16

Lack of foundation Lack of foundation Lack of foundation Lack of foundation Lack of foundation

Lack of foundation Lack of foundation

Case 1:04-cv-00360-JJF

Document 234-2

Filed 09/12/2006

Page 18 of 37

Johnson, Christopher S. (12/14/05) 6:8-:10 6:15-7:11 8:1-10:18 12:1-14:17 15:16-:19 16:2-22:5 23:12-24:14 25:10-:14 26:1-:10 34:7-36:11 37:8-39:22 40:5-43:14 46:9-53:8 54:3-55:7 55:16-56:22 58:6-59:6 59:17-60:3 61:11-:15 61:20-62:19 64:1-:19 66:19-67:7 71:4-72:1 72:10-:22 73:8-:9 73:12-79:15 84:17-93:10 94:21-112:17 114:1-122:4 125:10-130:10 131:8-132:10 135:10-:15 136:7-138:22 139:5-:22 142:5-143:2 143:7-155:12 156:3-161:22 Johnson, Robert (7/26/06) 20:22-25:9 28:8-29:6 43:3-:25 53:20-54:8 55:16-56:6 93:20-95:15 98:22-99:3 17

Incomplete designation; attorney argument Lack of foundation Incomplete designation

Incomplete designation Incomplete designation Lack of foundation Lack of foundation

Relevance; lack of foundation

Relevance

Lack of foundation; relevance Relevance; lack of foundation Lack of foundation; relevance Incomplete designation; lack of foundation

Relevance Lack of foundation Lack of foundation Relevance

Speculation Relevance; lack of foundation

Relevance; lack of foundation

Case 1:04-cv-00360-JJF

Document 234-2

Filed 09/12/2006

Page 19 of 37

129:9-131:12 Lazear, Scott Alan (1/18/06) 7:11-:22 8:9-9:15 10:2-:13 11:19-12:11 12:18-:22 13:1-:2 13:16-14:21 13:22-14:14 16:11-17:1 21:3-23:14 23:15-24:22 26:1-26:11 26:21-27:17 27:22-28:6 28:7-:12 28:17-29:2 29:7-:22 31:7-:10 31:15-:22 32:8-:17 34:7-36:7 42:9-43:9 46:20-47:4 48:7-:15 48:18-49:1 49:19-50:2 53:1-:19 76:6-77:15 80:21-81:5 91:10-92:7 93:9-:17 93:20-94:9 94:20-95:8 96:14-:19 96:22-97:19 98:12-99:8 99:22-101:7 102:15-:18 109:18-110:14 110:14-111:11 112:6-113:8 113:14-:22 121:17-122:7 18

Relevance; legal conclusion

Incomplete designation

Lack of foundation

Incomplete designation

Lack of foundation; relevance Lack of foundation

Lack of foundation

Incomplete designation

Case 1:04-cv-00360-JJF

Document 234-2

Filed 09/12/2006

Page 20 of 37

122:16-123:1 123:18-124:8 125:7-:14 127:3-128:11 129:18-130:3 133:1-:17 134:5-135:1 135:20-136:12 140:16-:22 141:3-:12 143:17-:19 144:10-:13 146:5-:3 172:12-:18 173:6-:8 173:11-174:8 176:18-177:18 178:6-:9 178:18-179:4 180:18-181:10 181:19-:22 182:1-:12 183:13-:21 184:3-:12 186:12-187:1 189:4-190:12 197:8-:9 200:15-:19 201:10-:14 203:7-:17 206:8-208:12 212:1-218:12 218:20-219:7 219:14-222:2 240:8-:13 269:18-270:6 273:8-:16 276:13-278:1 286:10-:22 287:4-:13 287:20-288:3 Malark, Gregory Alan (6/12/01) 7:6-:7 8:13-9:1 13:6-:7 19

Relevance

Relevance; assertion of privilege Incomplete designation Lack of foundation

Relevance Unclear designation Incomplete designation Attorney discussion Incomplete designation

Incomplete designation

Incomplete designation Incomplete designation Lack of foundation Incomplete designation Assertion of privilege

Incomplete designation

Case 1:04-cv-00360-JJF

Document 234-2

Filed 09/12/2006

Page 21 of 37

14:11-:19 15:17-:19 16:22-:24 18:1-:6 18:22-19:9 19:18-20:2 23:8-24:7 25:23-26:21 27:18-28:9 31:14-:20 32:20-33:1 34:9-35:19 37:5-38:1 39:3-43:16 44:6-45:2 45:24-49:6 49:17-51:2 52:3-54:10 56:7-57:14 57:18-59:5 61:1-63:8 64:10-:19 65:8-66:8 66:23-68:2 68:16-:20 70:6-71:24 74:4-:23 75:22-76:16 76:20-77:13 77:17-78:8 81:20-82:6 82:14-:23 83:10-85:11 86:21-88:6 89:12-:15 Mann, Darlene (5/12/06) 4:3-6:2 6:21-7:20 8:4-:12 8:20-9:13 9:19-11:19 12:1-12:10 12:18-:19 12:21-13:16 13:19-17:3 20

Relevance; attorney argument

Relevance

Speculative; lack of foundation

Relevance Relevance; lack of foundation

Case 1:04-cv-00360-JJF

Document 234-2

Filed 09/12/2006

Page 22 of 37

17:14-19:17 19:19-20:3 20:6-21:7 21:9-22:12 22:14-23:14 23:16-:19 23:21-24:8 24:10-:19 25:6-30:7 30:9-:13 30:15 31:7-:13 31:15-33:1 33:3-:11 33:14-:21 34:1-:11 34:13-:17 34:19-36:22 37:2-:10 37:12-38:18 38:20-39:8 39:10-:19 39:21-40:10 40:12-42:13 44:7-:9 44:11 44:13-:15 44:17-:19 45:7-10 45:12-46:5 46:8-:11 46:13 48:12-49:22 50:1-:10 50:13-:18 50:19-51:10 52:18-53:14 53:17-:18 53:20 53:22-54:1 54:2-55:15 55:18-:19 55:21-56:3 56:5-:9 56:11 21

Incomplete designation Incomplete designation

Case 1:04-cv-00360-JJF

Document 234-2

Filed 09/12/2006

Page 23 of 37

57:8-:14 57:16 58:3-:17 58:20-59:22 60:3-63:5 63:9-64:21 65:6-68:12 68:14-70:3 70:7-:8 70:10-:21 71:1-:8 71:11-:13 71:15-72:3 72:6-:11 72:13-73:6 73:10-:22 74:2-:13 74:15-:20 74:22-76:16 76:18-77:13 77:15-79:15 79:17-80:14 80:18-81:20 81:22-82:3 82:5-:9 82:14-83:8 83:10-84:16 84:18-85:8 Miller, Jacqueline (5/15/01) 5:22-23 10:20-11:12 15:1-18 16:4-5 17:19-18:8 18:25-20:10 20:21-21:22 22:1-23:23 24:13-25:13 26:10-:14 27:2-29:5 30:5-:21 31:6-32:24 36:8-37:12 38:22-39:8 40:21-:25 22

Incomplete designation

Speculation

Relevance; speculation; lack of foundation Relevance; speculation; lack of foundation Relevance; speculation; lack of foundation Relevance; speculation; lack of foundation

Relevance

Case 1:04-cv-00360-JJF

Document 234-2

Filed 09/12/2006

Page 24 of 37

45:1-46:4 49:10-51:7 56:7-:9 56:22-:24 58:1-59:4 59:19-65:7 69:6-71:7 71:14-73:4 74:3-:8 74:19-76:2 78:2-:24 79:13-80:16 80:21-89:25 90:8-:11 92:3-:6 97:2-:12 98:6-:11 99:1-:23 Miller, Laura (3/15/06) 7:8-10 9:8-12:3 12:8-13:4 13:15-14:6 14:9-18 14:22-17:13 19:2-7 22:3-13 22:23-23:8 23:14-24:4 24:8-10 24:12-14 24:17-25:21 27:5-18 28:11-13 28:15-20 28:23-25 31:20-32:9 33:6-34:7 34:11-15 36:9-38:7 40:8-22 40:25-41:14 41:19-42:4 42:10-12 42:16-20 23

Relevance

Case 1:04-cv-00360-JJF

Document 234-2

Filed 09/12/2006

Page 25 of 37

42:23-43:4 46:14-47:6 49:14-16 49:19-50:9 50:11-52:8 52:12-22 53:1-54:2 54:5-24 55:3-57:20 57:23-59:23 60:1-13 60:16-18 61:1-14 82:3-84:9 84:11 84:14-85:10 87:12-15 87:17-89:8 90:3-20 105:22-107:21 115:6-116:7 116:10-16 116:22-23 117:2-18 118:12-119:17 119:21-123:11 124:11-125:15 125:23-127:2 131:18-19 131:21-25 133:14-25 135:7-23 142:2-15 143:1-14 143:17-144:10 163:1-166:9 166:17-167:20 168:1-12 174:11-175:1 175:15-177:6 177:9-25 179:11-180:5 180:8-11 182:10-14 182:16-23 24

Relevance

Case 1:04-cv-00360-JJF

Document 234-2

Filed 09/12/2006

Page 26 of 37

186:5-24 187:13-189:2 189:5-10 189:17-190:4 Pike, Debra (11/23/05) 8:24-9:22 7:13-8:23 12:11-:22 13:13-14:17 16:11-:18 12:7-20:2 21:3-:18 22:22-24:5 24:13-25:18 27:16-28:16 28:21-34:6 34:11-35:5 36:5-:9 37:1-:25 38:8-:17 39:8-43:2 45:3-:16 45:24-46:1 47:15-:20 48:15-49:9 50:8-:10 50:15-51:21 51:24-52:5 52:24-53:19 54:21-55:4 55:5-56:3 56:22-60:6 60:12-61:10 64:19-65:1 65:15-65:25 66:11-68:20 92:8-93:23 Shipley, Mark (12/19/05) 6:9-7:18 10:23-14:4 14:18-16:24 17:8-18:2 18:9-:14 18:21-:24 20:10-21:23 25

Case 1:04-cv-00360-JJF

Document 234-2

Filed 09/12/2006

Page 27 of 37

22:19-23:1 37:7-38:9 50:6-52:12 52:21-57:17 57:20-61:5 61:10-62:14 64:4-65:8 65:14-:21 67:18-:24 68:1-:12 70:20-72:22 74:16-80:18 80:22-81:24 83:9-:18 87:3-89:3 89:9-:11 89:14-91:16 92:16-93:11 97:2-98:15 98:20-101:6 101:11-102:19 103:6-:16 104:2-105:14 105:21-107:21 108:1-111:13 113:8-:18 113:23-115:17 117:10-118:9 122:7-125:4 126:1-127:4 136:8-139:2 139:8-141:14 163:5-164:2 183:25-186:9 186:25-187:21 194:1-195:7 204:2-206:22 221:11-222:12 223:2-:22 228:12-229:7 229:17-232:4 232:8-234:5 Stattler, John (6/15/01) 6:23-9:15 10:4-:24 26

Relevance Lack of foundation; relevance

Relevance; lack of foundation

Relevance

Hearsay

Hearsay; foundation;

Case 1:04-cv-00360-JJF

Document 234-2

Filed 09/12/2006

Page 28 of 37

11:11-:16 11:25-12:18 13:6-14:25 15:17-17:3 18:1-21:25 22:7-26:25 34:25-43:18 55:11-:16 56:21-57:10 57:19-59:7 62:18-63:6 70:10-72:3 76:5-78:7 79:15-84:25 95:20-:24 96:21-97:12 Stattler, John (4/7/06) 6:9-13:16 15:1-19:22 20:11-25:16 29:9-50:10 50:13-56:15 56:20-57:9 57:13-66:16 70:14-77:22 78:3-90:22 91:4-93:17 93:21-106:1 107:16-109:10 109:14-114:19 115:10-122:21 123:9-130:6 130:19-134:10 137:20-142:8 142:18-143:21 144:1-161:17 162:7-172:15 172:20-180:16 180:19-181:5 181:7-:9 181:11-183:1 183:7-184:20 195:4-226:15 27

Relevance; attorney argument; assertion of privilege Relevance; attorney argument; assertion of privilege Relevance; assertion of privilege Legal conclusion; relevance Relevance; legal conclusion Relevance; legal conclusion Relevance; legal conclusion Relevance; legal conclusion Relevance; legal conclusion; lack of foundation Relevance; legal conclusion; lack of foundation Relevance; legal conclusion; lack of foundation

Relevance; legal conclusion Duplicative of 2001 testimony

Case 1:04-cv-00360-JJF

Document 234-2

Filed 09/12/2006

Page 29 of 37

227:4-236:2 250:21-255:9 Storey, Thomas W. (4/2/01) 7:4-:6 8:8-9:7 20:18-21:23 22:4-23:23 24:1-:25:23 26:4-27:21 28:16-:23 29:1-:5 29:8-:13 32:5-34:8 37:20-39:14 40:1-42:11 42:18-43:5 43:14-44:3 44:6-:9 48:4-:17 53:6-59:11 60:6-:21 60:24-61:2 61:4-:9 61:13-65:7 67:2-:9 68:19-73:21 74:14-75:3 76:7-:15 81:24-83:19 84:4-:11 88:8-89:20 103:4-:18 103:20-:21 104:15-:18 104:21-112:18 113:20-117:9 118:21-121:5 121:24-122:4 123:5-124:15 125:22-127:11 131:1-:9 135:13-136:6 140:14-141:12 141:15-:19 141:25-142:1 28

Incomplete designation

Relevance Incomplete designation

Incomplete designation

Lack of foundation

Relevance

Improper attorney comment

Case 1:04-cv-00360-JJF

Document 234-2

Filed 09/12/2006

Page 30 of 37

142:18-144:13 150:20-:25 151:14-154:8 Storey, Thomas W. (4/3/01) 164:4-166:23 168:7-:17 170:2-:21 174:9-176:6 176:22-177:19 178:18-180:11 184:5-185:19 186:17-:20 189:12-190:1 193:8-194:7 196:13-197:3 197:9-199:8 201:24-204:15 204:21-205:7 206:22-211:22 212:24-214:7 222:14-:15 223:12-224:23 225:8-226:16 227:14-231:6 237:1-238:23 241:10-242:2 242:24-243:24 244:3-248:8 249:2-:6 249:10-:19 250:1-:22 252:18-258:9 259:16-:18 260:5-263:22 283:19-284:6 285:11-286:1 287:2-289:21 291:12-292:2 Storey, Thomas W. (4/11/06) 7:7-:12 15:3-:18 16:10-:16 18:3-21:19 21:21-24:6 24:9-25:9 29

Incomplete designation Legal conclusion Legal conclusion; relevance Legal conclusion; relevance Legal conclusion; relevance

Relevance; legal conclusion Relevance; legal conclusion

Relevance Relevance Lack of foundation Lack of foundation; speculation

Case 1:04-cv-00360-JJF

Document 234-2

Filed 09/12/2006

Page 31 of 37

26:22-27:4 30:22-31:19 33:1-34:10 36:17-38:3 41:7-:18 44:11-45:5 45:11-:17 45:19-46:9 46:11-48:2 48:22-49:6 49:8-50:16 50:22 51:7-:19 51:22-52:18 52:20-:22 53:7-55:3 56:7-:16 56:18-58:5 58:8-:10 58:15-:17 60:22-61:6 61:8-:12 61:19-62:3 62:7-63:5 63:8-69:16 70:12-71:1 71:5-:13 72:15-80:12 80:15-81:5 81:7-:13 81:15-83:12 85:8-87:1 87:3-:9 87:11-:17 87:19-88:10 88:12-:17 90:1-91:19 91:21-92:16 92:18-95:15 95:17-:18 95:22-96:2 96:4-104:8 105:1-:18 106:14-:19 107:2-110:3 30

Duplicative; relevance Duplicative Duplicative Incomplete designation

Foundation; relevance; incomplete designation Relevance

Attorney statement Incomplete designation Lack of foundation; unclear questions Duplicative

Relevance

Case 1:04-cv-00360-JJF

Document 234-2

Filed 09/12/2006

Page 32 of 37

110:9-111:19 112:1-114:15 115:6-:9 115:11-:14 115:21-117:18 119:7-122:12 123:2-:22 124:4-125:1 125:5-127:14 127:22-129:16 130:10-:21 131:15-135:5 136:20-137:10 140:21-141:22 142:6-143:8 144:14-146:2 146:19-147:18 147:22-149:8 150:2-:14 152:4-153:2 154:10-156:1 156:10-:14 156:18-157:6 158:15-:19 159:20-160:20 161:5-163:4 163:6-:14 164:2-165:19 166:2-:16 167:1-:4 169:11-170:5 170:7-:11 170:13-171:3 171:5-:15 171:18-172:2 172:12-174:1 175:10-176:16 177:12-178:2 178:22-179:7 179:22-181:12 181:15-188:16 188:18-189:11 189:21-190:6 190:8-:21 191:1-:22 31

Lack of foundation

Lack of foundation

Lack of foundation Lack of foundation; relevance Lack of foundation; relevance Lack of foundation

Incomplete designation; lack of foundation

Lack of foundation; hearsay

Relevance Relevance

Assertion of privilege

Case 1:04-cv-00360-JJF

Document 234-2

Filed 09/12/2006

Page 33 of 37

193:5-200:19 200:21-203:1 203:22-204:14 204:16-206:17 206:19-207:14 207:16-209:2 209:12-212:21 213:1-214:15 214:17-226:21 227:15-232:6 233:3-240:7 241:10-242:15 242:17-244:17 244:19-246:22 248:1-:8 248:13-252:22 253:8-255:2 255:4-:18 255:22-261:22 262:8-263:13 264:2-269:22 270:17-:22 271:2-276:9 276:12-277:16 278:3-:9 279:4-281:8 281:13-284:8 285:6-:12 286:8-289:12 289:18-294:12 294:21-295:22 297:3-301:16 302:13-305:13 Wofsey, Carol (3/21/06) 6:4-6 11:1-12:19 12:24-13:3 12:2-13:3 19:2-20:3 26:5-22 27:12-28:22 28:25-29:5 29:11-19 30:1-5 30:8-15 32

Attorney discussion Attorney argument

Attorney argument Assertion of privilege; relevance

Incomplete designation

Relevance Incomplete designation

Relevance; attorney discussion

Assertion of privilege Relevance; attorney discussion

Case 1:04-cv-00360-JJF

Document 234-2

Filed 09/12/2006

Page 34 of 37

31:2-34:17 37:17-22 37:25 38:7-11 39:2-40:4 40:15--42:13 42:16-25 43:3-25 51:1-2 51:5-52:21 52:24-53:3 55:4-56:14 56:25-57:18 58:2-20 58:23-59:8 59:10-61:11 61:14-24 62:2-65:21 66:5-16 66:25-68:17 69:3-70:17 70:20-71:7 71:25-74:10 74:13-75:15 76:3-6 76:11-14 76:16-77:4 79:20-80:15 85:1-9 89:7-22 93:15-17 96:3-20 96:24-25 98:16-25 99:5-13 102:2-104:1 105:9-22 106:5-108:9 109:23-110:4 115:17-116:13 119:9-120:15 128:10-22 129:2-5

Lack of foundation; hearsay

33

Case 1:04-cv-00360-JJF

Document 234-2

Filed 09/12/2006

Page 35 of 37

EXHIBIT 16

Case 1:04-cv-00360-JJF

Document 234-2

Filed 09/12/2006

Page 36 of 37

EXHIBIT 16 TO JOINT PRETRIAL ORDER AFFINION'S MISCELLANEOUS ISSUES 1. Maritz's refusal to identify which of the 26 witnesses (23 fact witnesses, three

expert) it has identified in the Pretrial Order it intends to call live at trial. (Affinion has identified ten witnesses; seven fact, three expert.) Maritz's position is that it cannot provide this information until after Affinion concludes its case-in-chief. Affinion has offered to exchange lists of witnesses who will be called live (and their order) on October 18, 2006. 2. Maritz's refusal to provide a definitive (or near definitive) exhibit list prior to trial

or to narrow its deposition designations. Maritz has provided an exhibit list with 1,432 exhibits and has designated testimony from over 2,500 pages of deposition testimony, many of which involved designating all or substantially all of the page. Maritz objected to the provisions Affinion proposed to require the parties to disclose specific exhibits or deposition testimony to be used in trial. 3. 4. The time allocated to each party for trial. Any court preferences regarding the order and/or presentation of issues, including

whether equitable issues will be tried to the jury. 5. Affinion's August 24, 2006 letter to the Court about Maritz's characterization of

this Court's order regarding documents regarding invalidity and unenforceability as "dictum" and its consequent refusal to produce such documents. 6. Maritz's designation of deposition testimony from one of its own experts while

also identifying him as a live witness.

Case 1:04-cv-00360-JJF

Document 234-2

Filed 09/12/2006

Page 37 of 37

7.

Maritz's refusal to stipulate to Affinion's ownership of the `412 patent even

though it listed that as an "uncontested fact" in its summary judgment motion regarding lost profits.