Case 3:07-cv-04755-JSW
Document 87-3
Filed 06/02/2008
Page 1 of 1
TRANSLATION of A: Figaro article November 21, 1998 The Marriage of Bordeaux and Champagne .............................. The American at Chateau d'Ay Today, the firm of Ayala, whose chateaux had received the visits of the poet Andre Chenier and Tsar Nicolas II, is still out in front; with an objective of 50% of their sales at export and 50% in France. Alain Ducellier, the actual owner (his father, a collaborator of Rene Chayoux, inherited the business), is one of the rare Champagne businessmen to work with an American, John Gidding charged with sales at export. ..................................
EXHIBIT A-1