Free Memorandum - District Court of California - California

Case 3:07-cr-00602-VRW

Document 43

Filed 08/20/2008

Page 1 of 26

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14

ANDREW G. OOSTERBAAN Chief, Child Exploitation and Obscenity Section Criminal Division - Department of Justice STEVE GROCKI (VABN 41502) Trial Attorney Child Exploitation and Obscenity Section Criminal Division - Department of Justice MICHAEL I. YOON (ILBN 6244165) Trial Attorney Child Exploitation and Obscenity Section Criminal Division - Department of Justice 1400 New York Ave. NW Ste. 600 Washington, DC 20005 p (202) 514-5780 f(202) 514-1793 email Steve. Grocki(usdoj.gov MichaeL Yoon@usdoi .gov Attorneys for the United States of America UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA

15

SAN FRANCISCO DIVISION
16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, ) No. CR 07-0602 VRW ) Plaintiff, ) Sentencing Memorandum of the United
) States v. BERNARD V. WARD, Defendant. DATE: TIME: COURT: JUDGE: August 28, 2008 10:30am 6, 17th Floor Honorable Vaughn R. Walker

SENTENCING MEMORANDUM OF THE UNITED STATES I. INTRODUCTION On May 8, 2008, pursuant to an Agreement between the parties, the Defendant, BERNARD WARD, entered a plea of guilty to count 1 (Distribution of Child Pornography) of the above

Case 3:07-cr-00602-VRW

Document 43

Filed 08/20/2008

Page 2 of 26

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

captioned Indictment charging him with the felony offenses of Distributing and Receiving Child Pornography, in violation of 18 U.S.C. §S 2252A(a)(2). The United States submits this Memorandum in anticipation of sentencing, which is scheduled for August 28, at 10:30 a.m. Because defendant knowingly distributed images of child pornography; because many of these images depict very young children (3-year-olds) being subjected to abuse of the most serious kind (sadistic and masochistic abuse); because defendant, by his own admission, engaged in this conduct for approximately one year; and because no evidence supports defendant's contention that he engaged in his behavior to further a journalistic investigation, the government respectfully requests that this Court sentence defendant to a term of 108 months of imprisonment, the low-end of the applicable guidelines. II. OUTSTANDING OBJECTIONS The United States notes the outstanding objections of the defense and denials of certain

13 I factual statements on three general issues. See PSR Addendum ¶J 1-5. Although the United 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 As this court is aware, hearsay testimony is permissible at sentencing hearing. United States v. Littlesun, 444 F.3d 1196, 1200 (9th Cir. 2006).

States is prepared to prove the first of these contested issues, it does not believe that the Court needs an evidentiary hearing to resolve these objections. With respect to the first issue, the defendant contests the inclusion of the content of PSR paragraph 7. While the events recounted therein may not have actually taken place, they do, at a minimum, represent the context in which defendant distributed child pornography. It is undisputed that the statements were in fact made by defendant. Because defendant now claims that he engaged in his unlawful activities to conduct journalistic research, it is highly relevant and proper that the Court consider these Instant Messages. As such, they are attached to this memorandum in Attachment 1.1 With respect to the second issue, the United States did not participate in the investigation that yielded the information regarding defendant's purported sexual misconduct 20 years ago and therefore is not in a position to offer evidence to support the PSR findings. However, the United

Case 3:07-cr-00602-VRW

Document 43

Filed 08/20/2008

Page 3 of 26

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28

States echoes the PSR in stating that the Court can give the facts whatever weight and relevance it deems appropriate under 18 U.S.C. §3553(a). Finally, regarding the third defense objection, the 2 level enhancement for use of a computer found in U.S.S.G. §2G2.2(b)(6) is appropriate in this case as uncontested facts demonstrate defendant distributed and received child pornography via a computer. Defendant can cite to no case law or sentencing commission language that supports his position that because his offense intrinsically involved a computer, an enhancement is inappropriate. There are many other circumstances in which an individual can distribute and receive child pornography other than by computer. II. STATEMENT OF FACTS The facts of this case are simple, yet disturbing. Defendant is a 57-year-old man who is married and has four children (approximate ages 15 to 23). Ward lives in San Francisco, California and formerly worked as a radio "shock" talk show host for a local radio station, KGOAM 810, in San Francisco. Defendant also worked as a radio journalist for the same station. (PSR ¶5 7). In late December 2004, defendant, using the AOL Instant Messenger screen name Vincentlio, chatted with a woman via AOL in Oakdale, California who used the screen name SexFairy200S. During one of these chat sessions, defendant sent a photo to Sexfairy2005 containing a depiction of two minors and an adult woman sitting on a couch engaged in sexually explicit conduct. The adult female is seen guiding the minor female's hand onto the minor male's erect penis as the three sit on the couch nude. Defendant described the photo as containing a boy age 14, a girl age 12, and a mom age late 30s. Prior to sending the photo, defendant stated that "he loved trading pictures." This photo has been identified as part of the "Sabaan" series of photos that were taken in Brazil in the mid-1990s. The female in the image is known as "Sabaan" who was approximately 12-14 when the photos were taken. (PSR ¶6) During these chats, defendant also discussed various sexual scenarios involving his children where he was sexually aroused either by his daughter and her friend walking in on him in the bathroom while he was in the shower, or where he was watching Japanese Hentai cartoons

Case 3:07-cr-00602-VRW

Document 43

Filed 08/20/2008

Page 4 of 26

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28

(sexual cartoons) with his son and one of his friends. (PSR ¶7, Attachment 1). Following these chat sessions, Sexfairy2005 reported defendant's activities to the police and identified herself. She allowed Oakdale police to obtain copies of her chat sessions with Vincentlio and provided a statement. In her reporting, she told police that Vincentlio was introduced to her as an ex-priest. (PSR ¶8) Relying on the chat sessions provided by Sexfairy2005 and the image of child pornography she printed that Vincentlio had sent to her, Oakdale police obtained a search warrant for the AOL account with screen name Vincentlio. AOL responded to this warrant by providing Oakdale police the subscriber information for the Vincentlio account, the connection log information, and the emails for the account from approximately December 3 0th, 2004 through January 13th, 2005. All of the information AOL provided to Oakdale police was located on its company servers located in Virginia. AOL was only able to provide the window of time between those dates because it does not retain data for individual email accounts for very long, unless an individual saves emails to their personal filing cabinet. (PSR ¶9) In the stored email account information during this time were approximately 100 imbedded images within the body of the email (not attachments that needed to be opened) of minors under the age of 18 engaged in sexually explicit conduct. These images were located in both the "read" and "sent" folders (approximately 50 in each). Most of the images depicted prepubescent females engaged in sexual acts with adult males. None of the sexually explicit images were in the "unread" folder of Vincentlio's stored emails. Thus, defendant actually accessed the email account and actually opened the emails in the "read" folder. (PSR ¶10). Defendant belonged to a list group of individuals who would trade images of child pornography with one another. (PSR ¶10) These emails typically would have no accompanying text and would just contain an image. A member would send an image to the group, who would then pair off and begin exchanging images individually. Occasionally, defendant would make specific requests for types of images, (e.g. "Young or Family") when prompted by another list member to "send what you like." Defendant distribUted at least one image of child pornography to approximately 10 different members of these list groups. (PSR ¶10).

Case 3:07-cr-00602-VRW

Document 43

Filed 08/20/2008

Page 5 of 26

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28

The images defendant received and sent included numerous images depicting very young prepubescent minors (3-9 years old), typically females, engaged in sexual acts, graphically depicted, with adult males. The sexual acts included vaginal and anal intercourse, as well as oral sex. In some images, the minors are depicted bound by rope or handcuffs and are either being forced to perform fellatio on an adult male or are being digitally penetrated. In one image, a minor approximately 9 years old is being whipped. (PSR ¶10). These images were sent to the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children (NCMEC), which identified approximately 12 known victims, with some appearing in the "read" I folder and some in the "sent" folder. (PSR ¶11). The FBI obtained a federal search warrant for defendant's residence. They also spoke with defendant, his wife, and two of his children. Forensic analysis of the computers revealed no matches to the images that AOL supplied through its warrant. Further, no evidence of chats were retrieved from the computer evidence. One of the drives did contain a few erotic stories that discussed incest and child sex, as well as some indication that "lolita" sites had been visited by a user of the computer. (PSR ¶13) On April 7, 2005, defendant made a statement to an old friend regarding his involvement with child pornography. This individual contacted the FBI and stated he had information that was relevant to its investigation. He indicated he had known defendant for approximately 20 years. On April 3, 2005, he relayed that when he saw defendant, he gave him a hug and when he did, defendant burst into tears. After asking defendant what was wrong, defendant stated to him, "I've been looking at things I'm not supposed to on the Internet." He then clarified that he had been looking at pictures of children. Upon hearing this, the friend asked how long defendant had been involved in child pornography to which defendant responded that he had been looking for pornographic images of children for one year. Defendant further told the friend that the FBI had searched his home and he believed he had been "caught" because he was role playing with someone. (PSR ¶14). The probation officer reviewed 17 of the images defendant either sent or received via his AOL email account. According to her, the photos involved primarily female minors including:

Case 3:07-cr-00602-VRW

Document 43

Filed 08/20/2008

Page 6 of 26

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 2]. 22 23 24 25 26 27 28

1) a female toddler posing next to a penis, 2) an image of a penis penetrating a young female's vagina, 3) a series of six images showing a girl copulating an adult male, 4) a young girl tied up with her mouth taped and her legs spread apart displaying her vagina, and 5) a young girl tied up with rope. (PSR ¶15). 100 photos were involved in the instant offense. (PSR ¶16). IV. GUIDELINES CALCULATION The United States adopts the offense level computations, the criminal history score, and the resulting Sentencing Guidelines range set forth in the Presentence Investigation Report in all respects. V. CONTEXT FOR SENTENCING As the Court is well aware, the Sentencing Guidelines are no longer binding in the wake of the Supreme Court's decision in United States v. Booker, 543 U.S. 220 (2005). As set forth in United States v. Mix, 457 F.3d 906, 911 (9th Cir. 2006), the district court must correctly analyze the Guidelines and then take into account the factors set forth in section 3553. Although the Guidelines are not binding, "it is fair to assume that the Guidelines, insofar as practicable, reflect a rough approximation of sentences that might achieve section 3553(a)'s objectives." United States v. Rita, 127 5. Ct. 2456, 2464-65 (2007). Those factors include: (1) The nature and circumstances of the offense and the history and characteristics of the defendant; (2) The need for the sentence imposed (A) To reflect the seriousness of the offense, to promote respect for the law, and to provide just punishment for the offense, (B) To afford adequate deterrence to criminal conduct, (C) To protect the public from further crimes of the defendant, and (D) to provide the defendant with needed educational or vocational training, medical care, or other correctional treatment in the most effective manner;
-

(3) The kinds of sentences available; (4) The kinds of sentence and the sentencing range established for (A) The applicable category of offense committed by the applicable category of defendant as set forth in the Guidelines issued by the Sentencing Commission.. (5) Any pertinent policy statement (A) Issued by the Sentencing Commission;
-

(6) The need to avoid unwarranted sentence disparities among defendants with similar records who have been found guilty of similar conduct; and (7) The need to provide restitution to any victims of the offense.

Case 3:07-cr-00602-VRW

Document 43

Filed 08/20/2008

Page 7 of 26

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14

18 U.S.C. 3553(a). The statutory minimum term of imprisonment that the defendant faces is five years imprisonment, and the maximum term of imprisonment is twenty years. The maximum term of supervised release is "life," the maximum fine that can be imposed is $250,000. There is a mandatory special assessment of $100 for each count. The United States agrees with the Probation Office assessment that the applicable Guideline range is Adjusted Offense Level 31. The United States also agrees that the defendant's Criminal History Category of I and the applicable Guideline range is 108-135 months. Defendant agrees with this calculation but for the inclusion of the 2 level enhancement for use of computer. Defendant's contention lacks grounding in law or fact. Section 3553(c) requires the district court "at the time of sentencing" to "state in open court the reasons for its imposition of the particular sentence." Greater specificity is required for: (1) sentences within a Guidelines range that exceeds 24 months - for which the court must state "the reason for imposing a sentence at a particular point within the range" (18 U.S.C. § 3553(c)(1)); and (2) sentences outside the Guidelines range - for which the court must state orally and in the written judgment "the specific reason" for the imposition of the sentence (18 U. S.C. § 3553(c)(2)). VI. GOVERNMENT'S RECOMMENDATION FOR LOW-END OF THE GUIDELINES RANGE The Court should sentence the defendant to a term of imprisonment of 108 months followed by a term of supervised release often years with the conditions recommended by the Probation Officer. The United States believes that this sentence would represent the seriousness of the defendant's conduct. Sentencing the defendant to the low-end of the Guidelines recognizes the victimization of the many children depicted in these images, defendant's culpability in distributing these images to approximately ten other individuals, and defendant's current efforts to minimize the criminality of his conduct. A. Defendant's

15 16
17 18 19 20

21
22 23 24 25 26 27

28 II Defendant continues to assert he only engaged in his criminal conduct to research people on

Case 3:07-cr-00602-VRW

Document 43

Filed 08/20/2008

Page 8 of 26

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28

the Internet who trafficked in child pornography. (PSR ¶20). He adds that he did not think his activities were illegal. Id. Interestingly, he comments that he was drinking heavily at the time when he came up with the idea to conduct this research, and that he did have a book title in mind. He did not provide the title but assured probation that he was eager to earn a book deal with his idea and was blinded by greed. (PSR ¶2 1). Defendant's position, in minimizing his culpability, is precariously close to failing to accept responsibility, which in the Plea Agreement, entitled him to a 3 point adjustment. Although standing by the Plea Agreement, the United States suggests that this Court should consider the defendant's failure to (1) fully accept responsibility for his actions and (2) acknowledge the impact and seriousness of his conduct. This man sent and received horrific images of small children being bound, gagged, and brutally sexually abused. He engaged in this conduct with at least 10 other individuals. The method in which he traded these images does not reveal any indication that he was engaging in a journalistic enterprise. The images were sent and received without discussion. Defendant willingly traded in this currency of suffering children, contributed to each child's cycle of abuse, and facilitated the dissemination of their horrific record of sexual abuse. Once these images were sent by defendant, he had no control over them any longer and could not undo the harm. Moreover, in the context of his trading with Sexfairy2005, he discusses his sexual attraction to his own children's friends in his home. While this maybe fantasy, it is certainly inconsistent with a journalistic enterprise. Finally, in his statement to his longtime friend, he says he engaged in this behavior for approximately one year, knew it was wrong, but mentions nothing about doing it for journalism. To all of this, defendant states he feels "chagrined about the instant offense and wishes he had known more before getting involved in his research efforts." (PSR ¶2 1). The defendant's argument should be regarded for what it is - a baseless, last-ditch effort to minimize his culpability and salvage something of his reputation in the community. Even if the defendant did not know that trading these images was illegal, at a minimum, the defendant's conduct was amoral, universally unacceptable, and aberrant. It is preposterous to believe that the defendant thought it was appropriate or acceptable to trade in images of

Case 3:07-cr-00602-VRW

Document 43

Filed 08/20/2008

Page 9 of 26

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

prepubescent children being molested by anal, vaginal, and oral penetration. Defendant acquired images of children being molested for his own prurient and selfish interests, without regard to the victimization of the children depicted. In sentencing this defendant, the Court should consider, in accordance with the Section 3553 factors, the defendant's failure to acknowledge the seriousness of the offense, impact on the victims, and respect for the law. The government's recommended sentence is a reasonable and appropriate disposition of the matter; falls with the applicable Guidelines range; and properly accounts for the defendant's criminal conduct and the section 3553 factors. B. Congress Has Repeatedly Stated That Penalties for the Offenses Committed by the Defendant Should Be Harsh. The defendant is in the general population of sexual offenders that have been deemed

11

worthy of significant federal punishments. The Court is aware of the relatively recent statutory
12

and sentencing guideline amendments that have strengthened the federal penalties for offenses
13

related to the sexual exploitation of minors. Approximately five years ago Congress enacted the
14

Prosecutorial Remedies and Other Tools to End the Exploitation of Children Today Act of 2003
15

(the PROTECT Act, Public Law 108-21) in large part to enhance the penalties for crimes
16

involving the sexual exploitation of children. As justification for higher sentences in child
17

exploitation offenses, Congress stated:
18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27

The Government has a compelling state interest in protecting children from those who sexually exploit them, including both child molesters and child pornographers. "The prevention of sexual exploitation and abuse of children constitutes a government objective of surpassing importance," New York v. Ferber 458 U.S. 747 (1982), and this interest extends to stamping out the vice of child pornography at all levels in the distribution chain. Osborne v. Ohio, 495 U.S. 103, 110 (1990). PROTECT Act, Pub. L. No. 108-066, 117 Stat. 650, Sec. 501, Findings (2003). In the case of child exploitation prosecutions, the government has a compelling interest to protect children from those who would exploit them. The defendant is the very type of offender that Congress contemplated when it drafted and enacted the PROTECT Act. The federal child sexual exploitation statutes and penalty provisions are designed to provide just punishment for the offenses that the defendant has committed. More recently, on July 27, 2006, Congress enacted the Adam Walsh Child Protection and

28

Case 3:07-cr-00602-VRW

Document 43

Filed 08/20/2008

Page 10 of 26

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

Safety Act of 2006, H.R. 4472. This new legislation created new offenses related to the sexual exploitation of minors and increased punishments for some existing offenses. It is worth noting the continued Congressional focus on enacting additional legislation to enhance the protection of children from those who would use the Internet to exploit them.2 The government provides this context to suggest that the trend has been to do everything possible to increase punishment for crimes like the offense for which the defendant now faces at sentencing. This reflects the societal concern that crimes connected to the sexual exploitation of children are some of the most heinous that can be committed. In passing the PROTECT Act and the Adam Walsh Act, Congress undertook its duty to protect the psychological, emotional, and physical development of the nation's children. As the Supreme Court has stated, "A democratic society rests, for its continuance, upon the healthy, well-rounded growth of young people into full maturity as citizens." Ferber, 458 U.S. at 757. The Sixth Circuit has likewise held that using children to produce graphic sexual images is a form of sexual abuse which can cause mental andlor physical harm to a child. United States v. Champion, 248 F.2d 502, 506 (6th Cir. 2001). Further, the viewers of the images contribute to the cycle of abuse and are in part responsible for the psychological and physical harm of the children used to produce the images. United States v. Yeaple, 605 F. Supp. 85, 86 (Pa. D. 1985), see also, Ferber, 458 U.S. at 759. VII. GOVERNMENT'S POSITION REGARDING REMAND Pursuant to the provisions of 18 U.S.C. § 3143(b), the United States respectfully moves the Court for an order directing remand of the Defendant immediately after sentence.

13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26

27 28
2 The Court can also take notice that California's Proposition 83, which provides for lifetime global positioning system monitoring and restrictions on where registered sex offenders can reside, was approved by an overwhelming 70-30% majority of voters on November 7, 2006.

Case 3:07-cr-00602-VRW

Document 43

Filed 08/20/2008

Page 11 of 26

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28

VIII. CONCLUSION

The United States respectfully contends that a sentence at the low-end of the advisory Guidelines range of 108-135 months is appropriate to achieve the goals of sentencing. Respectfully submitted, Dated: August 20, 2008 ANDREW G. OOSTERBAAN Chief, Child Exploitation and Obscenity Section Criminal Division - Department of Justice By: /5/ Steven J. Grocki STEVE GROCKI Trial Attorney Is! Michael I. Yoon MICHAEL I. YOON Trial Attorney

Case 3:07-cr-00602-VRW

Document 43

Filed 08/20/2008

Page 12 of 26

Attachment 1

Case 3:07-cr-00602-VRW

Document 43

Filed 08/20/2008

Page 13 of 26

Page 1 of2

Ben Savage
From: Sexfairy2005@aoi corn Thursday, December 23, 2004 8:10 PM Sent: Sexfairy2005aoLcom To: Subject: (no subject)
Vincenttio [4:49 PM]: Vincentlio [4:50 PM]:

good afternoon mistress

Sexfairy2005 [4:49 PM]:

good afternoon
..

I didnt mean to interupt .just wanted to say hi

Sexfairy2005 [4:51 PM]:

how was your .day slave and why didnt you stop at the video store
.

Vincentllo [4:52 PM]: mostly running errands.. was tempted to stop at this video store with booths in the back but didnt,. .my oldest is having friends over later
Sexfairy2005 [4:53 PM]:

Vincent!io [4:54 PM]: didnt see anyone milling around.. have you ever heard of the palm therater. .no you probably havnt since you live far from the city
Vncentlio [5:03 PM]: Vincentho [5:04 PM]:

its a theater in san mateo. .old style. .one screen. .shows porn. .and lots of guys go there

Soxfairy2005 [5:04 PM]: Sexfafry200s [5:05 PM]: Sexfairy200s [5:05 PM]:

do they ever suck each other off have you ever stood in the back and how was it

yes all the time and if you stand in the back they get very agressive with you

Vincentlio [5:05 PM]: yes once

Vincentijo [5:07 PM]: there were about fifteen or twenty guys back there... nothing happened for a few minutes then a couple of ahnds touched me and when i didnt object they started to grab me and then more did.. .they pulled my pants down and all of a suddenlifted up a leg and took them off and then my shirt and i was almost naked except for my shoes.. .1 tried to get up but they kept pushing me over.., they grabbed my cock nd rubbed theirs up against me. .1 ended up sucking some and they took my clothes to the front of the theater
VmncentHo [5:07 PM]: Vincentllo [5:09 PM]: Vincentiio [5:09 PM]: Vincentllo [5:09 PM]: Vincentiio [5:10 PM]: vincentllo [5:10 PM]:

and i had to walk up naked ot get them

Sexfafry200s [5:09 Prvi:

did you like it did you leave feeling dirty you like that feeling dont you im going to make you get fucked in the ass do u want me to fuck your ass with a strap on then with that package you are sending you will send a nice strap on

yes very much and hated it yes yes way too much want it all the time yes maam yes maam i want to be sisified

Sexfafry2005 [5:09 PM]: Sexfairy200S [5:10 PM]:

Sextairy2005 [5:11 PM]: Vincentllo [5:11 PM]: VincentRo [5:11 PM]: Vincent!io [5:12 PM]:

Sexfary2005 [5:11 PM]:

Sexfairy200S [5:12 PM]:

Vincentllo [5:13 PM]: yes maam
Vincentllo [5:16 PMI:

my daughter wants to know if i will be embarssed in front of her friends tonight

Sexfairy200s [5:16 PM]:

no there are things that children should not see if that ever happens again you will be punished understood?

VincentRo [5:18 PM]: they saw me jacking off this morning by accident
Sexfairy200S [5:18 PM]: Vncenttio [5:19 PM]:

they walked in on me in the shower

1/5/2005

000073

Case 3:07-cr-00602-VRW

Document 43

Filed 08/20/2008

Page 14 of 26

Page 2 of 2

Sexfairy2005 [5:20 PM): Vincentho (5:23 PM]:

from now on you will locI the door get them and why not? thats a good excuse yes
i

I dont hay locks on any doors for safety dont want them to be able to lock doors on me

Sexfairy2005 [5:23 PM]: Vincentlio [5:24 PM]: Sextairy2005 [5:24 PM]:

Vincentlio [5:24 PM]: in case something were to happen i coudint get to them in time
Sexfairy2005 [5:24 PM]: Vincentllo (5:25 PM]: Vincentllo [5:26 PM]:

thank you maam are you going to mke me feel dirty mistress?

Sexfairy200s [5:27 PM]: Vincentllo [5:29 PM]:

am

my i say hi to stacy maam

Sexfairy2005 [5:30 PM]: flO

VncentIio [5:30 PM]: yes maam
Vincentho [5:37 PM]:

have you ever made someone ride sybian

Sexfairy2005 [5:38 PM]: Vincentho [5:38 PM]:

dont know what it is i might have to do that and why havnt i gotten any pics slave send me some more how old are those in the last photos

you should go to sybian.com sometime. its the ultimate vibrator I love trading pictures

Sexfairy200S [5:38 PM]: Vincentlio (5:39 PM]:

Sexfairy200S [5:49 PM]: Sexfairy2005 [5:49 PM]: Vincentho [5:50 PM]:

Vincentljo [5:49 PM]: yes maam

you have maail mistress mail mistress the boy is fourteen the girl is twelve i believe mistress the mom is late thirties

Sexfairy200s [5:51 PM]: Vincentho [5:52 PM]:

Sexfairy2005 [5:54 PM]: Vincentlio [5:54 PM]: Vincentlio [5:55 PM]:

Vrncentlio [5:56 PM]: but you never know the ages could be way different Vuicentlio [5:58 PM]: can i jack off before my daughter comes back with her friend mistress
Sexfairy200S [5:58 PM]: Vincentllo [6:00 PM]:

no you will wait? for me understood
SO

I have to get dinner going mistress wait for what mistress yes of course mistress

Sexfatry2005 [6:00 PM]: Vincentljo [6:01 PM]:

Sexfairy2005 [6:01 PM]: Vincentljo [6:01 PM]:

Sexfafry2005 [6:04 PM]:

i have a question

Vincentljo [6:04 PM]: yes maam
Sexfairy200S [6:04 PM]: Vincentlio [6:05 PM]:

have you ever played with children before

no maam

Vincentho [6:06 PM]: however every so often an opportunity presents itself Vincentljo [6:07 PM]: but if it does i will ask you of course
Vincentho (6:07 PM]: is that ok
SexIairy2005 [6:07 PM):

brb

1/5/2005

000074

Case 3:07-cr-00602-VRW

Document 43

Filed 08/20/2008

Page 15 of 26
Page 1 of I

Ben Savage
From: Sent: [email protected] Sunday, December 26, 2004 1:20 PM To: Sexfairy2005©aoLcom Subject: (no subject)
Vincentko [10:07 AM]:

good morning mistress

Sexfairy2005 [10:09 AM]: Vncentho (10:09 AM]:

good morning yes i did

i hope yo uslept well good thats great flO yes mistress but im horny mistress. .my son had a friend over and i saw his cock and it was hot

Sexfairy260s [10:09 AM]: Vincentllo (10:10 AM]:

Vincentlio [10:23 AM]: mistress is it ok if i go to thta theater today in san mateo?
SexFairy2005 [10:23 AMJ: Vrncentlio [10:24 AM]: Vincentlio [10:25 AM]:

Sexfairy2005 [10:26 AM]: Vincentlio [10:33 AM]: Vincentho [10:47 AM]:

ohhhh really

Vncentlio (10:26 AM]: yes maam

his cock was bigger than mine mistress my daughters and one son say hi mistress

Sexfauy2005 [10:47 AM]: Vincentlio [10:48 AM]:

tell them hello hello ohhh really

Vncentlio [10:48 AM]: yes maam

his friend ross says hi too hes the one with the nice cock

SexfairyZOOS [10:48 AM]: Vinceatho [10:48 AM]:

Sexfary2005 [10:49 AM]:

Vincentho [10:49 AM]: yes mistress..hes walking around in boxers like my son. ..you can see it pretty easily Vincentljo [10:57 AM]: oh i like looking at it mistress
Vincentlio (10:59 AM]:

he is hard looking at my daughters

Sexfary2005 [10:59 AM]: Vincentlia [10:59 AM]: Vincentlio [10:59 AM]: Vrncentlio [11:00 AM]:

ohhh really

yes totally eileen is teasing him mercilessly hes not even trying to hide it now

Sexfairy200s(11:OOAM]: Vincentlio [11:01 AM]: Vincentlio [11:01 AM]: Vincentllo [11:02 AM]: Vincentlio [11:03 AM]:

well tell me about it

its about five inches long...cut...rock hard...lamost no hair around it... eileen is flashing him its not thick but its cute

Sexfairy2005 [11:03 AM]:

how old is he
son is hard too

Vincentljo [11:04 AM]: 13 Vrncentlio [11:04 AM]: my Sexfairy200s [11:05 AM]: Vincentlio [11:05 AM]: Vincentlio (11:07 AM]: Vincentllo [11:09 AM]: Vinceatlio [11:17 AM]:

ohhh really

yes she just told them she would get naked if they both jack off she is doniming them lol they are doing it mistress really doing it

Sexfairy200S [11:17 AM]: Vincentlio [11:17 AM]: Vincentljo [11:19 AM]:

doing what does this happen alot

she got naked and they are jacking off this is so cool to watch

Sexfairy200S [11:19 AM]:

1/5/2005

000075

Case 3:07-cr-00602-VRW

Document 43

Filed 08/20/2008

Page 16 of 26
Page 1 of2

Ben Savage
From: Sexfairy2005©aol.com Sent: Sunday, December 26, 2004 2:05 PM To: [email protected] Subject: (no subject)
Vincentllo [10:07 AM]:
Vincentlio [10:09 AM]: 5exfairy2005 (10:09 AM]: Vincentilo (10:10 AM]:

good morning mistress

Sexfairy200S [10:09 AM]:

good morning
yCS

hope yo uslept well

I did

good thats great

Vincentllo [10:23 AM]: mistress is it ok if i go to thta theater today in san mateo?
5exfairy2005 (10:23 AM]: flO Vincontllo (10:24 AM]: yes mistress VincentHo [10:25 AM]: but im horny mistress. Sexfairy2005 (10:26 AM]: Vincentlio (10:33 AM]: Vincenttio [10:47 AM]:

.my son had a friend over and i saw his cock and it was hot

ohhhh really

Vincentho [10:26 AM]: yes maam

his cock was bigger than mine mistress my daughters and one son say hi mistress

Sexfairy2005 [10:47 AM]: Vincontllo (10:48 AM]:

tell them hello hello ohhh really

Vincentljo [10:48 AM]: yes maam

his friend ross says hi too hes the one with the nice cock

Sexfalry200S [10:48 AM]: Vincentflo (10:48 AM]:

Sexfairy2005 [10:49 AM]:

Vincent!io [10:49 AM]: yes mistress..hes walking around in boxers like my son...you can see it pretty easily Vincentlio [10:57 AM]: oh i like looking at it mistress
Vincentilo [10:59AM]:

he is hard looking at my daughters

Sexfafry2005 [10:59 AM]: Vincentllo [10:59 AM]: Vincentllo [10:59 AM]: Vincentlio (11:00 AM]:

ohhh really

yes totally eileen is teasing him mercilessly hes not even trying to hide it now

Sexfairy200S [11:00 AM]: VrncentHo (11:01 AM]: Vincentlio (11:01 AM]:

well tell me about it

its about five inches long...cut...rock hard...lamost no hair around it... eileen is flashing him

Vincentllo [11:02 AM]: its not thick Vincenttjo [11:03 AM]: but its cute
Sexfairy2005 (11:03 AM]: Vincentjjo [11:04 AM]: Vincentllo [11:04 AM]:

how old is he ohhh really

13 my son is hard too yes she just told them she would get naked if they both jack off she is domming them lol they are doing it mistress really doing it

sexfairy2005 (11:05 AM]: Vincentlio (11:05 AM]: VincentIo [11:07 AM]: Vincentlio [11:09 AM]:

Vincentllo [11:17 AM]: Vincentlio [11:17 AM]:
Vincentllo [11:19 AM]:

Sexfairy2005 [11:17 AM]:

doing what does this happen alot

she got naked and they are jacking off this is so cool to watch

Sexfairy2005 (11:19 AM]:

1/5/2005

OOOOO

Case 3:07-cr-00602-VRW

Document 43

Filed 08/20/2008

Page 17 of 26
Page 2 of 2

Vincentho (11:20 AM]: flO this is the first time ive seen them do this...she is totaHydomming them Vincentilo (11:33 AM]: they both came.. .alot
SexIafry2005 [11:34 AM]: VIncent!o (12:00 PM]: wish you were here Vincentflo signed off at 12:02 PM

ok

1/5/2005

ooow.

Case 3:07-cr-00602-VRW

Document 43

Filed 08/20/2008

Page 18 of 26
Page 1 of 1

Ben Savage
From: Sent: To: Sexfairy2005©aol.com Monday, December 27, 2004 2:46 AM Sexfawy2005©aoLcom

Subject: (no subject)
VrncentUo (12:15 AM]:

you are up late mistress
)fS I flO

Sexfairy2005 (12:15 AM]: Vincentllo (12:15 AM]:

am

are you playing

Sexfairy2005 (12:16 AM]: Vncentilo [12:18 AM]:

Vincentho [12:16 AM]: oh ok

we are watching hentai dvds

Sexfairy2005 [12:19 AM]: Vincentllo [12:19 AM]:

whats that ohhh ok where are the kids where they watching ohhhh realty

Japanese sex cartoons is the best way to describe them

Sexfairy2005 [12:19 AM]: Sexfary2005 [12:19 AM]: Vincentllo [12:20 AM]:

two are here two are asleep

SexIairy2005 [12:20 AM]:

Vincentllo [12:21 AM]: yes they thought the japanese voice track was quite funny. ..my son and his friend are here they are both hard
Sexfairy2005 (12:21 AM]: Vincentlio [12:22 AM]:

yes both hay skinny cocks but definately hard

Vincentllo [12:23 AM]: they are looking at other pictures i have along with my daughter who tinks they are both interesting to watch
Sexfairy200S [12:23 AM]: Vincentllo [12:23 AM]: Vincentiio [12:23 AM]:

phhh realty

yes can i please cum mistress Sexfairy2005 [12:23 AM]: flO Vincentiio [12:24 AM]: lye been good all day Vincentlio [12:28 AM]: they are going to cum can i please?
Sexfairy200s [12:29 AM]: Vincentho [12:29 AM]:

can you what? who is going to cum and you want to cum with them
care mistress

cum please mistress the boys

Sexfairy2005 [12:29 AM]: Vincentho [12:29 AM]:

Sexfairy2005 [12:30 AM]:

Vincentlio [12:30 AM]: or after them i dont Vincentlio (12:34 AM]: IS it ok mistress? Sexfa&y2005(12:34AMJ:

what excatly are you thinking about doing brb

Vincentllo [12:35 AM]: Jacking off while watching them or letting them finish and then Jacking off after or i could go first i really dont care i just want to cum
Sexfairy200S [12:35 AM]: SexfaLry200S[12:44AM]: VncentUo [12:44 AM]:

well im going to bed

can I cum mistress?

1/5/2005

fl U

Case 3:07-cr-00602-VRW

Document 43

Filed 08/20/2008

Page 19 of of4 Page 1 26

Ben Savage
From: Sexfairy2005aol.com
Sent: Thursday, December 30, 2004 5:17 PM To: Sexfairy2005aol.com Subject: (no subject)
Vincentho [1:11 PM]:

happy almost new years mistress

Sexfairy2005 [1:11 PM]: VncentIio [1:11 PM]: Vincentllo [1:11 PM]:

hello slave very unhappy you have been warned not to speak to my slut and you have no she did not and you all will be punished accoridinly why havnt you been on lately ok you are forgiven for that one up to latley

how are you what are you doing for new years eve? whats the matter she lMed me mistress i assumed she had permission i didnt know that i resonded to her responded yes mistress

Sexfairy200S [1:11 PM]: Vincentho [1:11 PM]:

Sexfairy2005 [1:12 PM]: Vincentllo [1:12 PM]:

Sexfary2005[1:12PM]: Vrncentlio [1:12 PM]: Vincentjjo [1:12 PM]:

Sextafry200s [1:12 PM]: Viricentllo [1:12 PM]: Vincentlio [1:13 PM]:

Sexfairy2005 [1:13 PM]:

Vrncentho [1:13 PM]: ive been working mistress.. had to cover the bay area relief efforts for all the people hit by the tsunamis
Sexfairy2005[1:14PM]: Vincentljo [1:15 PM]:

thank you mistress Sextairy200S [1:15 PM]: SO tell me what bad things you have bben Vincentljo [1:16 PM]: well i talked to s tacey and now realize that was bad
Sexfairy2005 [1:17 PM]: Vincentlio [1:18 PM]: Sexfairy2005 [1:18 PM]: Vincentlio [1:19 PM]:

are there others
let my daughter and her friend watch me jack off

and how old where these two slave you are a bad boy do you know what wouldmake mistress happy

they are both fourteen mistress yes i know was in the shower and she walked in with her and they saw me

Sexfairy2005 [1:19 PM]: Vincentho [1:19 PM]: Vincentho [1:20 PM]:

Sexfairy200s [1:20 PM]: Vincentjjo [1:20 PM]:

what mistress Sexfairy2005 [1:20 PM]: more piCS Vincentljo [1:20 PM]: what kind would yo ulike mistress
Sexfairy200S [1:20 PM]: Vincentllo [1:21 PM]:

naughtier the better hold on i need to get off my line right now what makes you think that you have earned speaking to me what are you doing for new years slave

could i talk to you on the phone mistress? ok

Sexfairy2005 [1:21 PM]: Vincentllo [1:21 PM]:

Sexfairy2005(1:24PM]: Vincentlio [1:24 PM]:

I havnt mistress i thought it might be a little present and reward for sending you more pictures... i could send them as we talk if you liked
Sexfary2005 [1:26 PM]: V'ncentlio [1:26 PM]:

nothing as of now mistress

1/5/2005

OOOO2i

Case 3:07-cr-00602-VRW

Document 43

Filed 08/20/2008

Page 20 of 26
Page 2 of 4

Soxfairy2005 [1:27 PM]: Vincentlio [1:28 PM]:

you have no plans at all ohhhh really how old are there friends are they beautiful do you have naughty thoughts about her slave are you worthy of hearing my voice

well for new years i will watchsome football and my kids are having some friends sleep over

Sexfairy2005 [1:28 PM]:

Vincentlio [1:28 PM]: yes Sexfairy200S [1:29 PM]: Vrncentho [1:29 PM]:

they will range from twelve to fifteen mistress

Sexfairy2005 [1:30 PM]:

Vincentiio [1:30 PM]: they are cute... one girl is chubby and i love that
Sexfafry2005 [1:30 PM]: Vincentllo [1:30 PM]: Vincentllo [1:31 PM]:

yes mistress my daughter and her friend laughed at my cock mistress

5extairy2005 [1:31 PM]:

Vincentllo [1:31 PM]: oh yes mistress Vincentlio [1:31 PM]: im yours.. .id do anything Vincentllo [1:31 PM]: OU own me Sexfauy2005 [1:31 PM]: Vincentlio [1:32 PM]:

I WANT PICS NOW let me check dont know how that happened SEND NOW ive seen that one... .do you think that i am stupid....... send more very good MORE GOOD very good am on a phone call slave you will wait

it says i cant send email to you mistress Sexfary20Q5 [1:32 PM]: it does
Sexfairy200S [1:32 PM]: 5exfairy2005 [1:34 PM]: Vincentho [1:34 PM]:

you have mail mistress

Sexfairy2005 [1:35 PM]:

now
Vincentllo (1:36 PM]:

mail mistress

Sexfau-y2005 [1:37 PMI: Sexfairy2005 [1:37 PM]:

Vincentho (1:37 PM]: Sexfary2O05 [1:37 PM):

only have one more new one mistress im trying to get more but ill send itto you

Vincentlio [1:39 PM]:

mail mistress its my favorite one may i please call you mistress? yes maam

Sexfairy2005 [1:39 PM]: Vincentlio [1:39 PM]:

Sexfa*ry2005 [1:40 PM]: Vincentllo [1:40 PM]:

Sexfairy2005 [1:44 PM]: Vincentlio (1:44 PM]: Vincentllo [1:45 PM]:

those pics are very nice nothing as of right now is that what you think you are very right i am still on the phone slave you will wait

thank you mistress what are you doing for new years eve mistrss? you should be entertained by your subs yes but rn a slave so what i think doesnt matter yes mistress would you let this slave call yo umistress? do you like chubby girls mistress yes mistress

Sexfairy2005 [1:45 PM]: Vincentlio [1:45 PM]:

Sexfairy2005 [1:46 PM]: Vincentlio [1:46 PM]:

Soxfairy2005 [1:46 PM]: Vincentlio [1:46 PM]: Vincentho [1:47 PM]:

Sexfairy2005 [1:48 PM]: vincentho (1:49 PM]:

1/5/2005

OOOO?7

Case 3:07-cr-00602-VRW

Document 43

Filed 08/20/2008

PagePageof of4 21 3 26

Sexfairy200S (1:50 PM]: Vincentho (1:51 PM]:

tell me something slave

yes mistress Sexfairy2005 (1:51 PML what naughty things have you done with your childrens friends Vjncentljo [1:51 PM]: Eve seen them naked mistress
Sexfairy2005 (1:51 PM]: Vincentlio (1:52 PM]:

is that all slave you are dissapoinfing because you just are i just want to hear your true confessions areyou dressed put pants on now then stay seated they wernt suppose to be there you must have misuderstood me give me your number slave... i am almost done with my converstaion am almost done bO NOT LOG OFF LJNbERSTOOD?????

yes mistress and ive jacked off watching them

Sexfairy2005 [1:52 PM]: Vincentio (1:52 PM]:

why mistress would you like me to do more
id do anything you suggested mistress...or anyideas you might have my daughter says hello mistress she just walked in the room boxers and t shirt mistress if i get up she will see me a little hard mistress yes mistress she says to tell you i did a good job cleaning their room

SexIairy2005 (1:53 PM]: Vjncentlio (1:53 PM]:

sexfauy200s (1:53 PM]: Vincentlio (1:53 PM]: Vincentllo [1:54 PM]:

Sextairy2005 [1:54 PM]: Vincentho (1:54 PM]:

Sexfairy200S [1:54 PM]: Vincentlio [1:55 PM]:

Sexfairy200S [1:55 PM]: Vincentlio (1:55 PM]: Vincentl*o (1:55 PM]:

Sexfairy2005 [1:56 PM]:

Vincentlio (1:57 PM]: you said to do it with them there mistress..i assumed to embarass me which by the way worked very well
Sexfaix-y2005 (1:57 PM]: Vincontllo (1:57 PM]:

she said to tell you it was really funny 415-218-0392 yes maam

Sexfairy200S (2:03 PM]: Vincentlio [2:03 PM]:

Sexfairy200s [2:08 PM]: i Vincentlio (2:08 PM]:

Sexfairy2005 (2:24 PM]: Vincentlio (2:24 PM]: Vincentho (2:25 PM]:

its a shame i dont live in your area isnt it slave that might be soon would that make you happy they are very intriguing no they are for my eyes and no one elses thats much better you still havent proved yourself worthy what do you propose that you do to prove yourself worthy

yes mistress i hate it but i can come to you when you wish yes mistress very happy mistress do the pictures excite you mistress? im glad you like them do you let your husband see them yes maam my daughter left mistress Em here by myself will you call me mistress? yes mistress have more confessions for you next time mistress

Sexfary2005 [2:25 PM]: Vincentlio (2:25 PM]:

sexfairy2005 [2:26 PM]: Vincentllo (2:26 PM]: Vincentlio (2:27 PM]:

5exfairy2005 (2:34 PM]: Vincentho (2:34 PM]: Vincentlio (2:34 PM]:

Sexfatry2005 [2:34 PM]: Vincentlio (2:35 PM]: Vincentljo (2:35 PM]:

Sexfairy2005 (2:35 PM]: Vincentlio (2:36 PM]:

Sexfairy2005 (2:36 PM]: Vincentllo [2:36 PM]:

Sexfairy2005 [2:39 PM]: VincentUo (2:39 PM]:

1/5/2005

000078

Case 3:07-cr-00602-VRW

Document 43

Filed 08/20/2008

Page 22 of 26
Page 4 of 4

Soxfairy200S [2:39 PM]:

tell me

what you are planning, slave?

Vinceritho [2:40 PM]: im going to play cards with them .strip poker and ill cheat and they will all lose and be naked mistress
Sexfairy2005 [2:40 PM]:

and then?????

Vuicentlio [2:41 PM]: ill figure out how to get truth or dare game going and ill dare them to finger themselves or one of the others mistress and then tell you all about it

i know how perverted you are and i know that you are thinking about more... .liars are always punished I dont tolerate it Vincentllo [2:42 PM]: id like to jack off in front of them mistress or make one of them jack me off Sexfairy2005 (2:47 PM]: very good Sexfairy200S [2:47 PM]: I like when you are honest
Sextairy2005 [2:42 PM]:
.

Vincent!io [2:47 PM]:

thank you mistress

Sexfairy2005 (2:47 PM]: Vincentjjo [2:48 PM]:

is there more .of course id like to be embarassed in front of them by you you still have not proven yourself worthy for that now have you?
i

that would be wonderful mistress.. oh no mistress that was a dream are you still there mistress?

Sexfajry2005 [2:50 PM]: VincentUo [2:50 PM]: Vincentljo (3:01 PM]:

Sexfairy200S [3:01 PM]:

yes
i

am
else you would like me to do?

Vincentho [3:02 PM]: IS there anything Vincentjio [3:09 PM]: mistress? Sextairy2005 (3:10 PM]: Sexfairy2005 [3:14 PM]: Vincentlio (3:14 PM]:

am having trouble with AOL I will be back i need to go to the store i will be back you need to get back online a precisly 6 pm is that understood ok will be punished understood
. .

yes mistress yes mistress they will all be here by then

Sexfairy2005 [3:14 PM]: Vnicentlio [3:15 PM]:

Sexfairy2005 (3:15 PM]: Vincentllo [3:15 PM]:

ill be here Sexfairy200S (3:15 PM]: if not you Vincentlio [3:15 PM]: yes mistress
Sexfairy200S [3:16 PM]:

get off line until there

there is no need to respond just log off

NOW
Vincentijo signed off at 3:16 PM

1/5/2005

0 000

Case 3:07-cr-00602-VRW

Document 43

Filed 08/20/2008

Page 23 of 26
Page 1 of2

Ben Savage
From: [email protected]
Sent: Monday, January 03, 2005 4:56 PM To: Sexfairy2005©aol.com Subject: (no subject)
Vincentljo [12:54 PM]:

good afternoon mistress

Sexfary2005 [12:55 PM]: Vincentlio [12:55 PM]:

good afternoon great and you good to hear
i ask you a question?

how are you im good too

Sexfairy200s [12:55 PM]: Vincentho [12:55 PM]:

Sexfairy200S [12:56 PM]:

Vincentlio [12:56 PM]: thank you Vincentlio [1:17 PM]: mistress can Sexfairy2005 [1:17 PM]:

yes go ahead no

Vincentho [1:17 PM]: ihave a friend who i wrote some ad copy for for her business but now she is short of cash so she has offered to watch me jack off in lieu of paying me may i do that please?
SexfaIry200S [1:18 PM]: Vtncentlio [1:18 PM]: Vincentifo [1:27 PM]: Vincentlio [2:21 PM]:

thank you mistress I told her no mistress mistress i was bad last night

sexfairy200S [2:21 PM]: Vincentho [2:22 PM]:

what did you do ohhh really how old is he really does he? does he really

jacked off so my kids could watch and then sucked my oldest son

Sexfairy2005 [2:23 PM]: Vincentho [2:23 PM]:

Vncentho (2:23 PM]: fourteen

he is bigger than me yes and he knows it yes he enjoys the advantage yes he is always asking to compare

Sexfairy200s [2:25 PM]: Vincentho [2:25 PM]:

Sexfairy200S [2:26 PM]: Vincentlio [2:26 PM]: Vrncentho [2:27 PM]:

Sexfairy2005 [2:27 PM]: Vincentlio (2:27 PM]:

SexfaIry200S [2:28 PM]:

ohhli really
and there isnt any pics
mistess nt from last night but they think its so funny

Vincontlio (2:28 PM]: yes Sexfairy200S [2:28 PM]: Vincentllo [2:28 PM]: flO Sexfau-y2005 [2:29 PM]: Vincentho [2:30 PM]:

what other pics do oyu have no fun how young
send away

some model pics mistress young models young teen

sexfairy200S [2:30 PM]: Vincentlio [2:31 PM]:

Sexfairy200S [2:31 PM]: Vincentho 2:31 PM]:

Sexfairy2005 [2:31 PM]: Vhicentlio [2:34 PM]:

mail mistress Sexfairy2005 [2:36 PM]: iS that all Vincentilo [2:37 PM]: have annother mistress

1/5/2005

0000

Case 3:07-cr-00602-VRW

Document 43

Filed 08/20/2008

Page 24 of 26
Page 2 of2

Sexfairy200S (2:37 PM]: Vincentho [2:37 PM]:

ohhh do u and who is she there isnt anymore who is this other mistress of yours ohhh ok thots good irii glad yes i do yes

yes maam the one i sent you is one of my daughters friends just that one of her so far im hoping for more she isnt a mistress i owe her money and this was how she wanted to collect she is an accountant... she likes to embarass but she doesnt have any hold on me and certainly not one as strong as yours yes it is i love having you as my mistress me too...you have power even over this medium that i can feel mistress did you punish stacey?

Sexfairy2005 (2:39 PM]: Vincentho [2:39 PM]:

Sexfairy2005 [2:40 PM]: VncentIio [2:40 PM]:

Sexfairy2005 (2:43 PM]: Vincentllo [2:43 PM]:

Sexfairy2005 (2:44 PM]: Vincentllo (2:44 PM]: VincentUo [2:45 PM]:

Sexfairy2005 [2:47 PM]: Vincentllo [2:47 PM]:

Sexfairy2005 [2:47 PM]: \flncentho [2:48 PM]:

Sexfairy2005 (2:48 PM]: Vincentlio [2:48 PM]:

Sexfairy2005 [2:48 PM]: Vincentho [2:49 PM]: VincentUo [2:50 PM]:

ok did you enjoy it mistress?

Sexfairy200s [2:50 PM]: Vincentlio [2:51 PM]:

intruges me are you allowed to ask questions?

why is that mistress no sorry mistress

5exfaffy200s (2:51 PM]: Vincentlio (2:51 PM]:

1/5/2005

00 0 0

Case 3:07-cr-00602-VRW

Document 43

Filed 08/20/2008

Page 25 of 26
Page 1 of2

Ben Savage
From: Sent: To: Sexfairy2005aol.com Wednesday, January 05, 2005 11:46AM Sexfairy2005aol.com

Subject: (no subject) good morning mistess Sexfairy200s [8:07 AM]: gOOd morning Vincentilo [8:07 AM]: how are you?
VincentUo (8:05 AM]: Sexfairy2005 (8:07 AM]: Sexfairy2005 [8:07 AM]: Vincentlio [8:07 AM]:

im good u?

Sexfairy200S [8:08 AM]:

im good too. .i love it when you are online and why is that

Vincentho [8:10 AM]: i can feel your strength and i can be free with you in way i cant with many other people and you know im pathetic
Sexfairy2005 (8:10 AM]: Vincentllo [8:10 AM]: Vincentlio [8:12 AM]:

yes you are have a question

yes mistress i know its why i hate to be naked for example because i know ill et laughed at

Sexfairy2005 [8:12 AM]: I Vincentijo [8:12 AM]: ok Sexfairy200s (8:13 AM]: Vincentlio [8:13 AM]:

how far would go to please your mistress could i ever watch you suck off your son are you there good that would please mistress I need a good laugh I want the plc of your cock and the face pic so i can laugh yes send me the face plc then and take another of your cock

pretty far mistress i think

sexfairy2005 (8:15 AMI: Sexfairy200s [8:16 AM]: Vincentlio [8:17 AM]: Vincentlio [8:17 AM]:

yes mistress think that would be Ok but ill ask him too thank you mistress

Sexfairy2005 [8:18 AM]:

VincentHo [8:19 AM]:

5exfairy200S [8:22 AM]:

Vincentho [8:22 AM]: what can i do for you mistress.. .i can be entertaining if you wish
Sexfairy200s [8:23 AM]:

Vincentho [8:24 AM]: I didnt save that mistress ill have to take it again...i have to find the digital camera.. .mistress will you embarass me in front of stacey?
Sexfairy2005 [8:25 AM]: Vincentlio [8:25 AM]:

yes mistress

Sexfairy2005 [8:32 AM]: Vincentlio [8:38 AM]:

Your mistress doesnt like to be kept waiting is that a excuse then send the plc NOW thats not the one that you sent my previously now im pissed

im sorry mistress boss called no mistress mail mistress...sorry its small

Sexfairy200S [8:39 AM]: Vincentlio [8:41 AM]:

Sexfairy2005 [8:41 AM]: Vincentljo [8:44 AM]:

Sexfary2005 [8:46 AM]:

Vincentlio [8:47 AM]: l know...i didnt know you at the time and that wasnt me. ..i apologize but everyone wants a picture and so i send that and then it I get to know them i send the real one...
Sexfairy200S [8:47 AM]:

Vincentlio [8:48 AM]: i knew you would be but didnt know it you were real and so on so i sent that, ..im so sorry mistress but you understand you have to be careful at first

1/5/2005

000 U

Case 3:07-cr-00602-VRW

Document 43

Filed 08/20/2008

Page 26 of 26
Page 2 of 2

Sexfairy2005 [8:49 AM]:

send me the other so i can compare NOW

VincentHo [8:49 AM]: yes mistress Vincentljo [8:50 AM]: mail mistress
Sexfairy200S [8:52 AM]:

ok as punishment you need to get off line NOW well then i guess iwill have to make a visit to you
that would be something...

VncentHo [8:53 AM]: i cant mistress can i do something else..i just got something i have to write from the call from my editor. the governor is giving the state of the state address tonight
Sexfairy2005 [8:53 AM]: Vincentllo (8:54 AM]: wow

Vincentljo [9:28 AM]: can i come and see you? i think you would enjoy it
Sexfairy200S [9:28 AM]: i Vjncentljo [9:29 AM]: i could

will see
bring a housewarming gift your house needs.. .of course

sexfairy200S [9:29 AM]: Vincent!io [9:29 AM]: whatever

and what would you bring

1/5/2005

000086