Free Deposition Counter-Designations - District Court of Delaware - Delaware

Case 1:04-cv-00833-KAJ

Document 307

Filed 10/24/2006

Page 1 of 25

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF DELAWARE PHARMACIA & UPJOHN COMPANY, LLC, ) ) ) Plaintiff, ) ) v. ) ) SICOR INC. and SICOR ) PHARMACEUTICALS, INC., ) Defendants. )

C.A. No. 04-833-KAJ

PHARMACIA'S AMENDED DEPOSITION COUNTER-DESIGNATIONS & OBJECTIONS

Plaintiff Pharmacia & Upjohn LLC ("Pharmacia") designates the following portions of deposition transcripts, and provides the following objections, in response to the designations of portions of deposition testimony designated by Defendants Sicor Inc. and Sicor Pharmaceuticals, Inc. (collectively, "Sicor") as testimony to be presented at trial. Pharmacia also reserves the right to make additional counter-designations to Defendants' deposition designations, as well as to amend these designations by adding, removing, or otherwise changing designations. 1. Defendants' Revised Designation, Beginning Page, Line Nos. 7:2 7:22 10:7 11:9 12:7 Diego Oldani (June 6, 2006 - Pharmacia & Upjohn v. Sicor, Inc., et al.) Defendants' Revised Designation, Ending Page, Line Nos. 7:5 9:12 10:13 11:24 13:1 Plaintiffs' Amended CounterDesignation Beginning Page, Line Nos. Plaintiffs' Amended CounterDesignation End Page, Line Nos. Plaintiffs' Objections

Case 1:04-cv-00833-KAJ

Document 307

Filed 10/24/2006

Page 2 of 25

Defendants' Revised Designation, Beginning Page, Line Nos. 21:7 26:10

Defendants' Revised Designation, Ending Page, Line Nos. 22:5 28:7

Plaintiffs' Amended CounterDesignation Beginning Page, Line Nos. 28:13 29:22 33:3

Plaintiffs' Amended CounterDesignation End Page, Line Nos. 29:9 30:6 34:15

Plaintiffs' Objections

401; foundation; stand by objection. made at 27:21-22 401; 403 401; 403; stand by objection made at 32:2-4

30:14 35:11

32:10 35:19

36:16

38:5

38:6

39:8

401; 403; stand by objection made at 36:12-22 401; 403; stand by objection made at 39:13-14

39:9

40:7

41:13

41:22

41:23

42:6

401; 403; incomplete hypothetical 401; 403; incomplete hypothetical; stand by objection made at 42:11-13 401; 403; stand by objection made at 45:13-16 401, 403; stand by objections made at 47:13-14, 48:18-20, and 49:15-16 401; 403; stand by objection made at 51:22-23

42:7

42:16

43:14

44:11

44:12

46:6

46:12

47:5

47:9

49:19

51:17

52:5

2

Case 1:04-cv-00833-KAJ

Document 307

Filed 10/24/2006

Page 3 of 25

Defendants' Revised Designation, Beginning Page, Line Nos. 53:9

Defendants' Revised Designation, Ending Page, Line Nos. 54:11

Plaintiffs' Amended CounterDesignation Beginning Page, Line Nos.

Plaintiffs' Amended CounterDesignation End Page, Line Nos.

Plaintiffs' Objections

401; 403; incomplete hypothetical; stand by objection made at 53:15-18 106 401; 403; lacks foundation; incomplete hypothetical 91:21 92:15 401; 403; 602; stand by objection made at 90:23-25

73:10 85:21

74:4 86:7

90:9

91:11

2.

Gaetano Gatti (June 8, 2006 - Pharmacia & Upjohn v. Sicor, Inc., et al.) Defendants' Revised Designation, Ending Page, Line Nos. 7:9 8:7 15:7 17:20 30:3 31:4 35:14 401; 403; lacks foundation 401; 403 401; 403; stand by objection made at 35:12-13 Plaintiffs' Amended CounterDesignation Beginning Page, Line Nos. Plaintiffs' Amended CounterDesignation End Page, Line Nos. Plaintiffs' Objections

Defendants' Revised Designation, Beginning Page, Line Nos. 7:5 8:2 13:8 17:2 29:13 30:20 35:6

3

Case 1:04-cv-00833-KAJ

Document 307

Filed 10/24/2006

Page 4 of 25

Defendants' Revised Designation, Beginning Page, Line Nos. 35:15

Defendants' Revised Designation, Ending Page, Line Nos. 41:11

Plaintiffs' Amended CounterDesignation Beginning Page, Line Nos.

Plaintiffs' Amended CounterDesignation End Page, Line Nos.

Plaintiffs' Objections

401; 403; stand by objections made at 40:3-4, 40:17-18, and 41:7-8 401; 403; stand by objections made at 44:5-6; 44:23-25 401; 403; incomplete hypothetical 401; 403; 602; 106; stand by objections made at 54:20-21, 56:1-2, 57:15-16, and 60:13-17 401, 403; 602; 802; stand by objection made at 68:23 ­ 69:4, 70:1-2, and 71:12-14 71:15 76:5 72:5 76:10 602

43:22

45:20

46:21

47:24

54:16

63:20

67:16

71:14

74:20 76:15 82:3 95:2 96:9

76:4 79:16 82:13 96:1 97:24

401; 403 401; 403; lacks foundation; incomplete hypothetical; stand by objections made at 96:11-12 and 97:12-13

4

Case 1:04-cv-00833-KAJ

Document 307

Filed 10/24/2006

Page 5 of 25

Defendants' Revised Designation, Beginning Page, Line Nos. 103:4

Defendants' Revised Designation, Ending Page, Line Nos. 103:19

Plaintiffs' Amended CounterDesignation Beginning Page, Line Nos. 97:25 99:19

Plaintiffs' Amended CounterDesignation End Page, Line Nos. 99:9 100:1

Plaintiffs' Objections

401; 403; 602; stand by objections made at 100:25101:1, 102:25103:2 and 103:1617 401; 403; 106; lacks foundation

106:2 115:20

106:15 117:24 115:14 115:19

401; 403; 602; stand by objections made at 116:11-12, 116:22-23 and 117:20-21 401; 403; 106; stand by objections made at 122:1-3 and 122:12-13

121:16

122:17

124:10 127:7 147:4

125:25 129:2 148:1 132:22 134:16 401; 403; stand by objection made at 147:24-25

3.

Carlo Confalonieri (February 17, 1999 ­ Faulding (CANADA) Inc. v. Pharmacia S.p.A) Defendants' Revised Designation, Ending Page, Line Nos. 1:19 2:15 401, 403 Plaintiffs' Amended CounterDesignation Beginning Page, Line Nos. Plaintiffs' Amended CounterDesignation End Page, Line Nos. Plaintiffs' Objections

Defendants' Revised Designation, Beginning Page, Line Nos. 1:12 2:7

5

Case 1:04-cv-00833-KAJ

Document 307

Filed 10/24/2006

Page 6 of 25

Defendants' Revised Designation, Beginning Page, Line Nos. 4:5 16:9 19:4 23:3 24:8 27:16

Defendants' Revised Designation, Ending Page, Line Nos. 4:25 18:4 19:19 23:16 24:18 28:13

Plaintiffs' Amended CounterDesignation Beginning Page, Line Nos. 11:18 12:24 19:22 22:12 23:17 24:19 25:16 27:05 28:14 29:06 32:06 34:24 35:25 37:18 39:20 41:04 42:20 42:20 44:12 46:16

Plaintiffs' Amended CounterDesignation End Page, Line Nos. 12:02 13:06 20:11 23:02 24:02 25:16 26:14 27:15 28:22 30:24 33:10 35:01 36:05 39:05 40:18 41:08 44:04 42:23 45:11 46:25

Plaintiffs' Objections

401, 403 401, 403 401, 403 401, 403 incomplete 401, 403 incomplete 401, 403

28:23 30:25 33:14 35:2 36:10 39:6 40:19 42:8 44:5

29:5 32:5 34:23 35:6 37:17 39:19 41:3 42:19 44:11

401, 403 incomplete 401, 403 401, 403 incomplete 401, 403 401, 403 401, 403 401, 403 401, 403 401, 403

6

Case 1:04-cv-00833-KAJ

Document 307

Filed 10/24/2006

Page 7 of 25

Defendants' Revised Designation, Beginning Page, Line Nos. 49:5 60:20

Defendants' Revised Designation, Ending Page, Line Nos. 49:22 64:13

Plaintiffs' Amended CounterDesignation Beginning Page, Line Nos. 49:04 51:16 68:08 70:11

Plaintiffs' Amended CounterDesignation End Page, Line Nos. 52:17 68:25 70:18

Plaintiffs' Objections

401, 403 incomplete 401, 403

4.

Lawrence Welch (February 9, 2006 - Pharmacia & Upjohn v. Sicor, Inc., et al.) Defendants' Revised Designation, Ending Page, Line Nos. 7:11 21:16 23:16 27:2 Plaintiffs' Amended CounterDesignation Beginning Page, Line Nos. Plaintiffs' Amended CounterDesignation End Page, Line Nos. Plaintiffs' Objections

Defendants' Revised Designation, Beginning Page, Line Nos. 5:9 18:2 22:6 25:21

402, 403P 402 402 402, 403P, 602; 25:25-26:2, 26:1426:15 402, 403P, 602 802, 37:3 78:20 79:20 402, 403P, 602

28:19 36:25 61:23

29:10 37:6 62:21

7

Case 1:04-cv-00833-KAJ

Document 307

Filed 10/24/2006

Page 8 of 25

5.

Martin Williamson (February 21, 2006 - Pharmacia & Upjohn v. Sicor, Inc., et al.) Defendants' Revised Designation, Ending Page, Line Nos. 6:12 8:11 9:7 35:18 38:17 40:13 43:20 44:21 49:14 51:1 53:14 57:10 58:7 44:8 45:2 49:22 51:9 53:19 57:17 58:14 402, 602, 802 402, 602 402, 602 Plaintiffs' Amended CounterDesignation Beginning Page, Line Nos. Plaintiffs' Amended CounterDesignation End Page, Line Nos. Plaintiffs' Objections

Defendants' Revised Designation, Beginning Page, Line Nos. 5:14 7:1 9:2 31:3 38:11 39:4

50:14 54:13 58:15 62:21 64:7 71:6 73:23 80:10 82:7 83:9 89:20

50:24 56:6 62:12 63:22 64:16 72:19 79:21 81:16 83:4 89:16 90:23

402, 602, 802 402, 602, 802; 55:13, 56:4 402, 602, 802

402 402 402; 79:6 74:5, 78:9,

602, 802 91:15 91:23 91:19 92:9

8

Case 1:04-cv-00833-KAJ

Document 307

Filed 10/24/2006

Page 9 of 25

Defendants' Revised Designation, Beginning Page, Line Nos. 92:19 100:24 115:23 121:12 125:2 6.

Defendants' Revised Designation, Ending Page, Line Nos. 94:18 102:15 116:15 121:24 129:10

Plaintiffs' Amended CounterDesignation Beginning Page, Line Nos.

Plaintiffs' Amended CounterDesignation End Page, Line Nos.

Plaintiffs' Objections

602 602 402 129:18 130:4 602

Wesley Fach (May 3, 2006 - Pharmacia & Upjohn v. Sicor, Inc., et al.) Defendants' Revised Designation, Ending Page, Line Nos. 7:20 13:14 17:3 18:5 18:24 20:8 24:24 32:13 34:15 Incomplete Response (32:11 ­ 33:5) 20:10 24:25 20:13 25:9 Plaintiffs' Amended CounterDesignation Beginning Page, Line Nos. Plaintiffs' Amended CounterDesignation End Page, Line Nos. Plaintiffs' Objections

Defendants' Revised Designation, Beginning Page, Line Nos. 7:9 11:16 15:6 17:9 18:15 19:7 24:2 31:6 33:7

35:23 38:16

37:7 39:19

9

Case 1:04-cv-00833-KAJ

Document 307

Filed 10/24/2006

Page 10 of 25

Defendants' Revised Designation, Beginning Page, Line Nos. 40:3 40:8 43:12 44:19 46:4 50:8 51:15 54:5

Defendants' Revised Designation, Ending Page, Line Nos. 40:5 43:7 44:4 44:1 46:20 51:8 51:17 55:25

Plaintiffs' Amended CounterDesignation Beginning Page, Line Nos.

Plaintiffs' Amended CounterDesignation End Page, Line Nos.

Plaintiffs' Objections

Hearsay

44:5 49:16 53:18 53:23 56:4 61:3 61:21 64:3 64:24 65:4 68:9

44:18 49:20 53:20 54:3 56:11 61:14 61:24 64:9 65:1 65:8 68:25

62:24 64:12 65:17 69:9 69:18 71:3 72:9 73:21 77:3 77:15 77:25 78:19

63:17 64:23 66:2 69:11 69:24 71:18 73:14 75:2 77:11 77:22 78:4 78:21

71:19

72:3

Relevance Relevance

75:3

75:6

78:6

78:18

10

Case 1:04-cv-00833-KAJ

Document 307

Filed 10/24/2006

Page 11 of 25

Defendants' Revised Designation, Beginning Page, Line Nos. 79:2 80:11 80:23 86:13 91:10

Defendants' Revised Designation, Ending Page, Line Nos. 79:22 80:17 81:5 87:16 92:24

Plaintiffs' Amended CounterDesignation Beginning Page, Line Nos.

Plaintiffs' Amended CounterDesignation End Page, Line Nos.

Plaintiffs' Objections

90:13 93:15 95:6 96:5 96:22 97:3 98:6 98:12

90:18 95:2 95:22 96:6 96:24 97:11 98:10 99:5

Contains objections of counsel

96:8 97:12 99:6 101:7 104:4 106:13

96:21 98:5 99:22 101:24 104:21 107:7

101:25 102:7 104:22 104:25 110:16 110:24 111:10 111:21

102:2 102:18 104:23 105:4 110:19 111:6 111:17 111:23

Contain Objections of Counsel

113:12 114:16 115:6 115:24 117:11

114:9 114:24 115:18 116:8 119:2 116:10 116:14 116:12 116:15

11

Case 1:04-cv-00833-KAJ

Document 307

Filed 10/24/2006

Page 12 of 25

Defendants' Revised Designation, Beginning Page, Line Nos. 119:8 120:25 123:21 127:2 127:9 130:20 131:2

Defendants' Revised Designation, Ending Page, Line Nos. 120:20 121:11 125:25 127:5 128:8 130:24 131:23

Plaintiffs' Amended CounterDesignation Beginning Page, Line Nos.

Plaintiffs' Amended CounterDesignation End Page, Line Nos.

Plaintiffs' Objections

Relevance (119:19 ­ 120:20) 121:12 121:15 121:16

135:13 136:22 137:3 138:24 140:2 143:17

135:21 136:24 137:5 139:1 140:22 143:24

133:10 133:17 135:2 135:22 136:9 138:13 138:20

133:12 134:1 135:8 135:23 136:13 138:16 138:22

145:21 149:25 150:5

146:3 150:2 150:12

150:14 153:1 154:2 155:4 155:20

151:8 153:22 154:25 155:16 156:1 156:12 156:21

12

Case 1:04-cv-00833-KAJ

Document 307

Filed 10/24/2006

Page 13 of 25

Defendants' Revised Designation, Beginning Page, Line Nos. 156:22 158:24 159:6 160:9 161:9 163:6 164:3 165:1 165:19 171:8 173:1 180:20 181:5 191:17 195:10 197:19 198:25 199:23 201:1 202:8

Defendants' Revised Designation, Ending Page, Line Nos. 157:21 159:2 159:14 160:22 161:16 163:18 164:25 165:2 166:14 172:25

Plaintiffs' Amended CounterDesignation Beginning Page, Line Nos.

Plaintiffs' Amended CounterDesignation End Page, Line Nos.

Plaintiffs' Objections

161:17 163:19

162:9 164:2

173:2 179:11 180:22 181:18 192:20 196:13 198:14 199:18 200:25 201:4 202:16 201:5 201:24 189:23 191:8 192:24 194:4 196:14 196:18

173:16 179:23

190:13 191:16 193:8 195:9 196:15 196:19

301:18 202:7

13

Case 1:04-cv-00833-KAJ

Document 307

Filed 10/24/2006

Page 14 of 25

Defendants' Revised Designation, Beginning Page, Line Nos. 202:20 203:8 206:15 207:23 209:18 212:22 217:20 221:8 223:14 224:1 224:12 224:15

Defendants' Revised Designation, Ending Page, Line Nos. 202:21 205:7 206:25 209:8 210:10 213:23 218:18 222:3 223:17 224:10

Plaintiffs' Amended CounterDesignation Beginning Page, Line Nos. 202:22 205:8

Plaintiffs' Amended CounterDesignation End Page, Line Nos. 203:7 206:2

Plaintiffs' Objections

209:9 211:24 215:9 220:6

209:17 212:15 217:19 221:7

224:17 226:21 229:23 230:25 235:11 238:19 245:1 266:21 268:21 271:18 272:19 272:24 267:3 231:1 232:2 235:12 235:19

225:25 228:8 230:2 231:13 232:8 235:16 236:7

230:3 233:24 238:5 243:19 265:25 267:22 269:1

267:9

272:21 272:25

14

Case 1:04-cv-00833-KAJ

Document 307

Filed 10/24/2006

Page 15 of 25

7.

Peter Laivins (November 2, 2005 - Pharmacia & Upjohn v. Sicor, Inc., et al.) Defendants' Revised Designation, Ending Page, Line Nos. 6:10 7:2 8:13 9:4 11:23 14:23 45:14 53:24 53:25 56:2 56:14 54:18 56:7 56:21 802 402 8:14 9:16 8:19 9:19 Plaintiffs' Amended CounterDesignation Beginning Page, Line Nos. Plaintiffs' Amended CounterDesignation End Page, Line Nos. Plaintiffs' Objections

Defendants' Revised Designation, Beginning Page, Line Nos. 6:5 6:13 7:25 8:20 10:17 12:25 45:6 53:13

61:3 62:16 63:20 65:20 74:2 75:5 78:18 79:3

61:23 63:14 64:10 66:18 75:4 75:21 78:24 80:4 77:3 80:5 81:6 90:6 91:11 113:17 78:17 80:13 81:16 90:19 91:18 114:4 73:12 73:25 63:15 63:19

402 402 402 402, Attorney Argument 402

91:19 114:5

92:2 114:14

106

15

Case 1:04-cv-00833-KAJ

Document 307

Filed 10/24/2006

Page 16 of 25

Defendants' Revised Designation, Beginning Page, Line Nos. 114:19 117:8 119:19 120:9 132:20 133:10 133:19 136:14 138:25 139:17 140:23 141:12 142:15 144:10 146:8 148:17 150:19 152:10 154:18 157:21 160:17

Defendants' Revised Designation, Ending Page, Line Nos. 116:9 118:12 119:22 120:17 133:7 133:13 136:5 136:22 139:12 140:5 141:16 141:21 143:20 144:16 147:20 149:9 151:13 152:18 155:24 160:13 161:2

Plaintiffs' Amended CounterDesignation Beginning Page, Line Nos. 116:10 118:13 119:23 120:2 120:8

Plaintiffs' Amended CounterDesignation End Page, Line Nos. 116:14 119:18 119:24 120:4 120:8

Plaintiffs' Objections

106

402 402 402

106 141:22 143:21 144:17 145:2 145:15 149:10 151:14 142:14 144:6 144:19 145:14 146:7 149:19 152:9 106 402

402; Argumentative 402; Argumentative

115:18

116:14

16

Case 1:04-cv-00833-KAJ

Document 307

Filed 10/24/2006

Page 17 of 25

Defendants' Revised Designation, Beginning Page, Line Nos. 161:8 162:10 162:24 168:22 174:5 175:6 176:2 181:11 183:17 184:4 185:12 185:22

Defendants' Revised Designation, Ending Page, Line Nos. 162:4 162:19 165:2 169:5 174:14 175:25 177:18 181:25 183:25 185:8 185:14 186:21

Plaintiffs' Amended CounterDesignation Beginning Page, Line Nos. 162:5

Plaintiffs' Amended CounterDesignation End Page, Line Nos. 162:9

Plaintiffs' Objections

165:3

166:14

402

174:15

174:23

402

182:2 184:2

182:21 184:3

106 106

185:15 186:22 188:16 189:11

185:21 187:11 189:7 189:12

402

189:13 194:5 195:10 197:2 199:5 200:15 203:17

190:12 194:10 196:25 197:13 199:25 202:25 204:4 204:5 204:11 204:15 204:8 204:13 204:16 402, 602 106, 402, Argumentative 194:11 194:15

17

Case 1:04-cv-00833-KAJ

Document 307

Filed 10/24/2006

Page 18 of 25

Defendants' Revised Designation, Beginning Page, Line Nos. 205:2 207:3 209:10 221:13 224:6 225:2 229:17 229:20 230:8 231:5 237:8 239:24 240:2 244:7 244:12 252:6 8.

Defendants' Revised Designation, Ending Page, Line Nos. 205:12 207:16 210:11 221:25 224:24 228:24 229:19 230:2 230:14 233:9 238:9 239:25 240:24 244:9 244:18 252:18

Plaintiffs' Amended CounterDesignation Beginning Page, Line Nos. 205:13 207:17 210:12

Plaintiffs' Amended CounterDesignation End Page, Line Nos. 207:2 208:3 210:22

Plaintiffs' Objections

602

402 402

402, Attorney Argument 106

402 402 402 251:9 252:5

Howard Meyer (September 29, 2005 - Pharmacia & Upjohn v. Sicor, Inc., et al.) Defendants' Revised Designation, Ending Page, Line Nos. 6:5 Plaintiffs' Amended CounterDesignation Beginning Page, Line Nos. Plaintiffs' Amended CounterDesignation End Page, Line Nos. Plaintiffs' Objections

Defendants' Revised Designation, Beginning Page, Line Nos. 6:3

402

18

Case 1:04-cv-00833-KAJ

Document 307

Filed 10/24/2006

Page 19 of 25

Defendants' Revised Designation, Beginning Page, Line Nos. 6:8 7:25 8:23 10:23 11:11 13:3 14:7 15:5 38:15

Defendants' Revised Designation, Ending Page, Line Nos. 6:14 8:7 9:2 10:25 11:17 13:24 14:15 15:8 39:20

Plaintiffs' Amended CounterDesignation Beginning Page, Line Nos.

Plaintiffs' Amended CounterDesignation End Page, Line Nos.

Plaintiffs' Objections

402

11:18 12:22 14:5

12:5 13:2 14:6

402 402

18:22 35:23 63:22

19:4 36:25 64:5

402, 403C 402, 403C

47:17 48:2 49:19 53:11 53:25 56:14 61:13 61:19 62:7 63:13 68:12

47:23 49:6 50:14 53:21 55:16 60:12 61:15 61:24 63:7 64:5 69:7 61:25 63:8 65:14 69:8 71:16 62:6 63:12 65:20 71:2 71:20 49:7 50:15 53:22 55:17 49:18 53:10 53:24 56:13

402 106 106, 402 106, 402 106, 402 402, 403C, W 106, 402 106, 402 402

602

19

Case 1:04-cv-00833-KAJ

Document 307

Filed 10/24/2006

Page 20 of 25

Defendants' Revised Designation, Beginning Page, Line Nos. 72:11 73:4 77:18 91:6 113:9 115:20 117:10 121:13 122:21 125:15

Defendants' Revised Designation, Ending Page, Line Nos. 72:16 73:15 80:25 92:3 114:22 116:8 117:17 122:3 124:20 126:4

Plaintiffs' Amended CounterDesignation Beginning Page, Line Nos.

Plaintiffs' Amended CounterDesignation End Page, Line Nos.

Plaintiffs' Objections

402 81:5 92:7 114:23 116:9 81:15 92:16 115:19 116:21 602, 403W 402 402 106, 402 402 122:4 124:21 126:5 122:20 125:4 127:3 106 Question mischaracterizes the evidence, 106 602

127:4 128:13 129:18 131:15 132:23 134:8 134:22 135:21 137:5 143:11

127:13 128:23 129:23 131:25 133:4 134:12 135:12 136:15 137:11 144:3 137:2 137:4 135:13 135:20 129:10 129:24 132:2 129:17 130:11 132:7

402

402

20

Case 1:04-cv-00833-KAJ

Document 307

Filed 10/24/2006

Page 21 of 25

Defendants' Revised Designation, Beginning Page, Line Nos. 144:10 145:18 154:11 154:25 157:2 158:4 158:22 159:14 160:19 163:17 167:2 168:10 169:20 170:19 171:4 176:6 178:5 178:17 179:3 182:7

Defendants' Revised Designation, Ending Page, Line Nos. 145:14 145:20 154:16 155:4 157:9 158:16 159:4 159:22 160:22 163:22 168:5 169:15 169:25 170:20 171:10 176:15 178:13 178:22 179:16 182:21

Plaintiffs' Amended CounterDesignation Beginning Page, Line Nos. 145:15

Plaintiffs' Amended CounterDesignation End Page, Line Nos. 145:17

Plaintiffs' Objections

402

154:17 155:5 157:10

154:24 155:8 157:13

402, 602 402 402, 602 402, 602 602

159:9

159:13

602 602

163:23 168:6

164:4 168:9

602 106 106

170:2 170:21

170:13 171:3

106

175:19 176:16

176:5 177:2 Question calls for speculation, 602 Question calls for speculation, 602 Question calls for speculation, 602 402

21

Case 1:04-cv-00833-KAJ

Document 307

Filed 10/24/2006

Page 22 of 25

9.

Bradley Winter (November 17, 2005 - Pharmacia & Upjohn v. Sicor, Inc., et al.) Defendants' Revised Designation, Ending Page, Line Nos. 9:17 15:7 16:8 20:23 21:8 23:5 24:10 26:16 27:25 37:6 38:24 46:18 48:17 50:3 44:12 47:8 48:18 50:4 44:18 47:21 49:5 50:4 Incomplete hypothetical, 701, 402, foundation Incomplete hypothetical, 701, 402, foundation Incomplete hypothetical, 701, 402, foundation 21:9 23:10 24:14 26:17 21:14 23:12 24:24 27:4 602 15:17 16:9 15:20 16:18 402 Plaintiffs' Amended CounterDesignation Beginning Page, Line Nos. Plaintiffs' Amended CounterDesignation End Page, Line Nos. Plaintiffs' Objections

Defendants' Revised Designation, Beginning Page, Line Nos. 9:6 13:24 15:21 20:10 21:5 21:15 23:24 26:6 27:5 36:25 37:25 46:4 47:22 49:15

402

50:5

50:8

51:11

51:12

51:13

51:17 60:13

52:16 60:21

52:17

53:5

22

Case 1:04-cv-00833-KAJ

Document 307

Filed 10/24/2006

Page 23 of 25

Defendants' Revised Designation, Beginning Page, Line Nos. 62:22 63:20

Defendants' Revised Designation, Ending Page, Line Nos. 63:10 64:22

Plaintiffs' Amended CounterDesignation Beginning Page, Line Nos. 63:11 64:23

Plaintiffs' Amended CounterDesignation End Page, Line Nos. 63:19 64:24 65:16 68:2 72:3 72:16 77:13 78:19 79:20 82:16 85:6 86:2 89:15 93:6 95:11 100:9 101:14 103:13

Plaintiffs' Objections

64:25 66:20 70:14

65:6 67:14 71:2

65:7 67:15 71:3 72:8 73:18

106

78:2

78:8

78:9 79:18 80:24

84:9 85:13 86:3 91:18 93:7 98:5

84:24 85:15 86:12 92:16 93:14 99:11

84:25 85:16 86:13 92:17 93:15 99:16 100:24 102:23

106 106

23

Case 1:04-cv-00833-KAJ

Document 307

Filed 10/24/2006

Page 24 of 25

MORRIS, NICHOLS, ARSHT & TUNNELL LLP /s/ James W. Parrett Jack B. Blumenfeld (#1014) Maryellen Noreika (#3208) James W. Parrett (#4292) 1201 N. Market Street P.O. Box 1347 Wilmington, Delaware 19899-1347 (302) 658-9200 Attorneys for Plaintiff Pharmacia & Upjohn Company LLC OF COUNSEL: Daniel A. Boehnen Joshua R. Rich McDONNELL BOEHNEN HULBERT & BERGHOFF LLP 300 S. Wacker Drive Chicago, Illinois 60606 (312) 913-0001 October 24, 2006
542944

24

Case 1:04-cv-00833-KAJ

Document 307

Filed 10/24/2006

Page 25 of 25

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I, James W. Parrett, hereby certify that on October 24th, 2006 I electronically filed Pharmacia's Amended Deposition Counter-Designations & Objections with the Clerk of the Court using CM/ECF, which will send notification of such filing(s) to the following: Steven J. Balick, Esquire John G. Day, Esquire ASHBY & GEDDES I also certify that copies were caused to be served on October 24th, 2006 upon the following in the manner indicated:

BY HAND Steven J. Balick, Esquire John G. Day, Esquire ASHBY & GEDDES 222 Delaware Avenue Wilmington, DE 19801

BY FEDERAL EXPRESS Reid L. Ashinoff, Esquire David R. Baum, Esquire SONNENSCHEIN NATH & ROSENTHAL LLP 1221 Avenue of the Americas New York, NY 10020 Jordan Sigale, Esquire SONNENSCHEIN NATH & ROSENTHAL LLP 8000 Sears Tower Chicago, IL 60606

/s/ James W. Parrett James W. Parrett (#4292) MORRIS, NICHOLS, ARSHT & TUNNELL LLP (302) 658-9200 [email protected]