Free Letter - District Court of Delaware - Delaware

Case 1:04-cv-00876-GMS

Document 222-2

Filed 08/25/2006

Page 1 of 12

EXHIBIT A

Case 1:04-cv-00876-GMS

Document 222-2

Filed 08/25/2006

Page 2 of 12

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT DISTRICT OF DELAWARE TELCORDIA TECHNOLOGIES, INC., PIaintifflCounterclaimDefendant,
V.

)

1 1
) )

Civil Action No. 04-876-GMS

CISCO SYSTEMS, INC., DefendanKounterclaim Plaintiff.

1 1

STIPULATION CONCERNING ACCUSED PRODUCTS

Plaintiff Telcordia Technologies, Inc. ("Telcordia") and Defendant Cisco Systems, Inc. ("Cisco"), by and through their respective counsel of record, hereby stipulate as follows: WHEREAS, on January 5, 2006, the Court ordered the parties to meet and confer about a compromise schedule pursuant to which Telcordia could add newly accused claims (i.e., the means-plus-function claims it asserted for the first time in November 2005) if it substantially reduced its list of newly accused products (i.e., products accused for the first time in December
2005);

WHEREAS, on February 27, 2006, the Court held a hearing concerning the accused products in this case; IT IS HEREBY STIPULATED:

1.

Pursuant to the Court's order, Telcordia has dropped its infingement

allegations as to the following Cisco products: United States Patent No. 4.893.306: Catalyst 8540 Catalyst 5000 series Catalyst 5500 series

S V I :\239579\01\54%201!.DOCUSE26.0048

Case No.04-876-GMS

C:\DOCUMMTS AND SFITINGS\MEHTA\MY DOCUMENTSU-20 ACCUSED PRODUCTS STlPULATION-#243392.DOC

Case 1:04-cv-00876-GMS

Document 222-2

Filed 08/25/2006

Page 3 of 12

Catalyst 6000 series Lightstream 1010 Lightstream 2020 MGX 8200 MGX 8830 MGX 8850 MGX 8880

IGX 8400

BPX 8600
269 1 3800 series

6000 series
7000 series 7100 series
7400 series

ONS 1 530 1/ISR330 1

ONS 15303ASR3303
ONS 15304

ONS 15190 ONS 15194
6400 Broadband Concentrator

8 110 Broadband Termination Unit United States Patent No. RE 36,633: Catalyst 5500 series MGX 8880 8 1 10 Broadband Termination Unit United States Patent No. 4,835,763:
SV I :\239579\01\54%201!.D0(=\35826.0048

2

Case No. 04-876-GMS

C:\DOCUMENTS AND SETTMGS\MEHTAWY DOCUMENTSU-20 ACCUSED PRODUCTS STIPULATION-iY243392.DOC

2

Case 1:04-cv-00876-GMS

Document 222-2

Filed 08/25/2006

Page 4 of 12

ONS 15301/ISR3301 ONS 15303/ISR3303
ONS 15304

ONS 15350
ONS 15530
ONS 15540 ESP ONS 15540 ESPx

2. products in this case:

Telcordia and Cisco agree that the following is the list of accused Cisco

United States Patent No. 4,893,306: 6509-NEB-A, 65 13 Catalyst 6500 series: 6503,6509, 6509-NEBY Catalyst 8500 series: 8510 MSR, 8510 CSR MGX 8900 series: 3600 series: 3700 series: 7200 series: 8900 and 8950 3620,3631,3640,3660,3661,3662 3725,3745 7202,7204,7204 VXR, 7206,7206 VXR, uBR 7223, uBR 7246,

uBR 7246 VXR
7300 series: 7500 series: 7600 series: 10000 series: 12000 series: 7301,7304 7505,7507,7513,7576 7603,7604,7606,7609,7613 10005, 10008,10720, uBR 10012 12004, 12006, 12008, 12010, 12012, 12016, 12404, X R 12404, 12406, X R 12406, 12410, XR 12410, 12416, XR 12416, 12810, 12816 CRS- 1 ONS 15310 series:
SV I :\239579\0 1\54%201!.DOCU5826.0048
v

15310-CL, 1531O-MA 3
CaseNo. 04-876-GMS

C\DOCUMENTS AND SFTTINGSWEHTAWY DOCUMENTSU-20 ACCUSED PRODUCTS STIPULATION-#243392,DOC

3

Case 1:04-cv-00876-GMS

Document 222-2

Filed 08/25/2006

Page 5 of 12

ONS 15454 MSPP

ONS 15454 MSTP ONS 15600 MSPP
ONS 15327

United States Patent No. RE 36.633: Catalyst 8500: 8510 MSR, 85 10 CSR, 8540 MSR 8220,8230,8240,8250,8260 8830,883O/By8850,8850W 8410,8420,8430,8450

MGX 8200:
MGX 8800 series:

IGX 8400 series:
Lightstream 1010 3600 series: 7200 series:

3620,3631,3640,3660,3661,3662 7202, 7204, 7204 VXR, 7206, 7206 VXR, uBR 7223, uBR 7246,

uBR 7246 VXR
7500 series: IP Transfer Point ATM Port Adapter and Interface Modules United States Patent No. 4,835,763: 7505,7507,7513,7576

ONS 15454 MSPP ONS 15454 MSTP ONS 15455
ONS 15600 MSPP
ONS 15327 ONS 15310 series:

15310-CLY 15310-MA

ONS 15305
6732 Access Device 6705 Access Device
3.

Telcordia believes that its interrogatory answers made it clear that where it 4
Case No.

SV 1:L?39579\01Ci4%ZOl !.DOCU5826.0048

04-876-GMS

C:\WCUMMTS AND SETTMGSWEHTAWY WCUMENTSU-20 ACCUSED PRODUCTS STIPULATION-#243392.DOC

4

Case 1:04-cv-00876-GMS

Document 222-2

Filed 08/25/2006

Page 6 of 12

identilied pmduds

the series Ievel, it intended to encompass all products withiin each
3-4

identified series. -4ccoi-dingly-Telcordia believes that it adequately identified
pmdduccs at lhc sclies kvcl

cisco
he

and tlw where it identified specific prducrs wiUin

a sen=,

identified products must be coilsidered examples of the accused products withill the scn-cs a11d
noi cxliausLivc of them. Similarly. Telcordia believes her

i idmtifving prnducls by product n

number: it inlended to enconips d products that have the same nurnbcr, whether or not tiiwe 1

]my an additional idontifier. Cisco believes that the products identitied by TeIcordia arc the bc
products accitsed of infiingcnitxt and rhac additic?rril pruducrs may not be 3ccused simply

because they fall v h h i n the same series. Notwithstanding Telwrdia's beliefs. the Court hss held: [,a) the addition of iiircher products-whethcr
or nnt thcy fall within a series

for wtlich

other products have pretioudy bcm accused--io the list in p a n p p h 2 above is subject to a good cause showing by Telcordia, Feb. 27.1005. Hearing Tr.at 7 12-13; and @) Telcordia inay ,

ask qucstioils in hrthm Jiscuvwy about other Cisco products that are not on the list in paro-mph
2 above consistent with die Court's ruling at the F&tuuary 27. XI56 Hearing Fcb. 27. 2006

Ilearing Tr. at 12-1 3, 16.
3.

Ttlardia FunIra believes that it has dropped ils inkingmat alleg~tions

as to the products noted i paragraph 1 without prejudice ta (a) is challenging on appeal the n t

Court's order tirat it reduce its list of newly accused products, or (b) iis bringing a separate action directed 10 those products 3t B later timc. Cisu, disagees with Telcanlia's description of thc

Cours's Odcr 3nd Telcordirc's position.

Case 1:04-cv-00876-GMS

Document 222-2

Filed 08/25/2006

Page 7 of 12

Defendant Telcordia Technologies, Inc.

Of Counsel:

Matthew D. Powers Of Counsel: Edward R. Reines Donald R. Dunner Jessica L. Davis Don 0. Burley Sonal N. Mehta Richard H. Smith WEIL, GOTSHAL & MANGES LLP Houtan K. Esfahani 201 Redwood Shores Parkway John M. Williamson FINNEGAN, HENDERSON, FARABOW, GARRETT Redwood Shores, CA 94065 (650) 802-3000 & DUNNER, L.L.P. 901 New York Ave., N.W. Ryan Owens Washington, D.C. 20001 WEIL, GOTSHAL & MANGES LLP Tel. (202) 408-4000 767 Fifth Avenue New York, NY 10153 York M. Faulkner FINNEGAN, HENDERSON, FARABOW, GARRETT (2 12) 3 10-8000 & DUNNER, L.L.P. Two Freedom Square 1 1955 Freedom Drive Reston, VA 20190 Tel. (571) 203-2700

SVI :\239579\0 1'54%201 !.DOCU5826.0048

6

Case No. 04-876CMS

C:\DOCUMENTS AND SFITMGSMEHTAWYDOCUMENTSU-20 ACCUSED PRODUCTS STlPULATION-b'243392.DOC

6

Case 1:04-cv-00876-GMS

Document 222-2

Filed 08/25/2006

Page 8 of 12

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I, Jack B. Blumenfeld, hereby certify that copies of the foregoing were caused to be served this day, June 6,2006 upon the following in the manner indicated: BY HAND Steven J. Balick, Ashby & Geddes 222 Delaware Avenue P.O. Box 1150 Wilmington, DE 19899 BY FEDERAL EXPRESS AND E-MAIL

Don 0. Burley Finnegan, Henderson, Farabow, Garrett & Dunner 901 New York Avenue, N.W Washington, DC 20005-3315
Jack B. Blumenfeld

SV 1:U39579\01\54%201 !.DOCU5826.0048

7

Case No. 04-876GMS

C:\DOCUMENTS AND SEITMGSWEHTA\MY DOCUMENTSU-20 ACCUSED PRODUCTS STPULATION-#243392,DOC

7

Case 1:04-cv-00876-GMS

Document 222-2

Filed 08/25/2006

Page 9 of 12

EXHIBIT B

Case 1:04-cv-00876-GMS

Document 222-2

Filed 08/25/2006

Page 10 of 12

CONFIDENTIAL EXHIBIT

Case 1:04-cv-00876-GMS

Document 222-2

Filed 08/25/2006

Page 11 of 12

EXHIBIT C

Case 1:04-cv-00876-GMS

Document 222-2

Filed 08/25/2006

Page 12 of 12

CONFIDENTIAL EXHIBIT