Free Motion in Limine - District Court of Delaware - Delaware

Case 1:04-cv-00968-G|\/IS Document 154-2 Filed O1/O9/2006 Page 1 of 2
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
F OR THE DISTRICT OF DELAWARE
ALLERGAN, INC., and ALLERGAN )
SALES, LLC., )
I
Plaintiffs, )
I
v. )
I . ‘
ALCON INC', ALCON ) C.A. No. O-4-968-GMS
LABORATORIES, INC., and ALCON ) .
RESEARCH, LTD., )
I
Defendants. )
I
I
ORDER GRANTING DEFENDANT DEFENDANTS ALCON INC.,
ALCON LABORATORIES, INC., AND ALCON RESEARCH, LTD.’S
MOTIONS IN LIMINE
Having considered the submissions of all parties, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED THAT:
Defendants’ Motion In Limine No. l, To Preclude Plaintiffs From Presenting Evidence
Of Alleged Superiority Or Copying, Neither Of Which Is Relevant To Non-Obviousness
In This Case, IS GRANTED.
Defendants’ Motion In Limine No. 2, To Preclude Dr. Wilson From Offering Opinion
Testimony Regarding The Statistical Analysis Of His Student's Solubility Measurements,
IS GRANTED.
Defendants’ Motion In Limine No. 3, To Exclude Opinions Of Dr. Valentino Stella
Pertaining To The Alleged Infringement Of Claim 6 Of The ’337 Patent, IS GRANTED.
Defendants’ Motion In Limine No. 4, To Exclude Opinions Of Dr. Valentino Stella
Pertaining To Solubility Studies Conducted By Dr. Clive Wilson, IS GRANTED.

Case 1:04-cv-00968-G|\/IS Document 154-2 Filed O1/O9/2006 Page 2 of 2
Defendants’ Motion In Limine No. 5, To Require Allergan To Bring The Inventors On
The Patents—In-Suit To Testify At Trial, IS GRANTED.
IT IS SO ORDERED:
United States District Judge
Dated: , 2006