Free Answering Brief in Opposition - District Court of Delaware - Delaware

Case 1:04-cv-01230—G|\/IS Document 73-9 Filed 12/15/2005 Page 1 of 4
EXHIBIT H

Case 1 :04-cv-01230-GMS Document 73-9 Filed 12/15/2005 Page 2 of 4
E . ~~ .rr¤•‘
E 4
E -. : ‘ UNITED STAT§ES.bEF?A¥£TMENT GF ¤0MMERcE
E 5, 41 Pqtqnt and 'ljrnqnmark Dlflgzu
§ ; ?‘*··»¤¤*fr pu"., c0MmsSE_L}NER ¤F PATENTS ¤H1> Thanwnnxg
{5% _ Wunhlnpturt. 0.0,. 213231 ·
g Z { CQNTRDL N%3HHE.H..¥ EILHQCI DATE ‘ ' PATENT UNDER HEEXAMIIATEON . i ·kT¥¤llNEY BUCKET H5. i l `
E .90/004., 771. _ U?/30/97 49G3'.7é6` ‘ 33179/155596
it . - ’-· ’ ‘
t , . , . .
§ . . ] · _ E¥Al»llhlER ‘ I
i ._.. asmzu 121; ‘
E JOHN S PRATT ~ BERMAN, J
* '“'··‘°"*"*“"“ ‘·“`°“?‘“°“ ~ = - t
i 1 1D0 PEQCHTEEE SUITE? 2.900 { Am mm. PAPER Human
E RTIANTA 303BQ-*4530 . - :2506
I: · _ QATE HAILED: UJEB/97 t IV

I . I ‘ I { H _ • , " J . · .
5 M QHQEB ·GFl.ANTlNQi/DENYtNG FtECtUES”{” FDR ·FtEEXAM¥NATlON
The request tor. reéxamtnatiun hae been considered}. `_Idant§1icat¥¤n bf the elaims. the references
5 wetted on, and the ratlnnala supporting the determination are attachad: ·~
I A{tachrnerst{s): PTO--892, gl PTG4 449, Q Other; . R . ’
· 1.. Q The requst far reexaminatlun Ie GRANTED. `
" `RELSPONSE TIMES IEEE SET TQ’§(PlBE AS FCLLGWS: x __
·- Fur Patent Gturgérp jélaterfténr tpptldnat): TWG MOl’gl`l'l-IS tram the maitingptate hmcft 37 CFR 1.530{b}'. “
EXTENSIDNS OF TIME ARE GOVERNED BY 37 CFFI 1.55l`l(¤)t 4
~ ‘- For Ftqczueatafé reply tépttunallr l\iDN’i`t¤{S train the date dl ggwlda ut any patent owners slalamertlt
3T_GFH 1r&5.. ` NO EX.TENSl0N UF`!“lMElS,`PERMl1TED" tt patent éiéner-dueanut tile attmety .
- statement undera? C`F.Ft. ·t.5:·1¤(b];n¤ reply by requester is perrniited, '
2. [1 Tna request for tjeeatamlnatipn ls DENIED, -—
Thts decision is nut appealabla. _35 U.5.C. SD3{c)t. Requester may geek retqiew by petltlenjo tha — ··
Cumnqsslonarsyhhtn ONE MONTH trumthe mHi|lt1g`dBlB here¤!.. 37 `CJFH 1.5150:7. EKTENSIONS OF
TIME ONLY UNDER 37 QPR 1..183.. l
` tn dur: octptse. areturqg underq?Qt’R 1125(c},w§ll_be mage to regueater {listed below it net patent ¤wn¤r}
Q by treasury grim. l:]=i>y garage pawn A¤¢q¤¤= wb. .,t;i»;;,»,,... ‘ ‘ . · ` - t S ...· *
E l_ Hunless rtetiitectiatttertvise. 35 U.S.Q.3ti3(t:). t ?` ' ’· '; ·
i U`hY.rd party rr?-t;¤¤Zs;¤·'s ¤¢;rr¤;per;.i¤1¤¤ address) · 1,
¤¤··--·»»-»...·......~:..»»»..1..»»»»·.........—»·-»--~`jA 377 1 ¤‘ t 7 "

Case 1 :04-cv-01230-GMS Document 73-9 Filed 12/15/2005 Page 3 of 4
Serial $0/`0D4771° U . ` Page 2.
Anuuamsns _
? `A snbstaptial new question niigetentability cleims 1-*24 dtiilinited Srntes Patent
jp Number 4,963,73[6`is rnisédhy fur reex¤n1ip¤Linn.· l l
3; _ ; Engtehsiens utitime under 37 1,136Qtj net t>e,pegm3néd·`in these pmcieeziiugs
;_ ·hecamse the pre\}i;i5re’cif$‘7 l.13j6Le§gpIy th "lm nppl}@t" and net tu pnrtiesin e I" .
nr0eeE•:;ixpg. 305 reqrgires the:. reexqminetich prceebailipgs
'WH be °¤!¤d¤¤*¢{i §p¢;éi§!—di-epatqlnil-[37.0PIi l.5§0Ee)3j ;E>ére{;.si6n=¤r1j;et€i}1 rwreénlnntten Il E;
l ·pr¤5:eecti.ngs are prevideclrfnriri 3'/Cliti 1.550(e). l : H _ E
1 M French raises a su5sitentia1_ue6b questinn utinriteiitahility ns chzims 1-54 ofthe Dcuglae
ea all petem. At lines 4 thrmtgh II? un page 20, the French njplieelieh teechee iiantjnstend ofthe `
- three quadrupole wszem in the rm ofthe appheatien, it is possible ru arrange only two D i I
nquzgdrupélcls in series. Aceorzling in the applicetinxy the first quetlrupele insuch it qsten: should
have cmly Aflapplied to it sc tinit it acts as an inn-gnide to direbt inns prpduced uuiizide the _ "
~ system td the sealant! qqedrepqle, which has beth AC" and applieri to it eq that it acts us amass r d —
spectrometer. As the requester paints unt,. the French épplication also teeehcs that eueh an AC- I
only quadngpcle sb`¤tQlcl have rolilé which ere}4 inches long ami be npeaatéd at`Fire`§si:res. ef IO'}
: to 101 tm-r for n prcchicr ¤fD.1016 to 10:164: 10* ter: r:mJit°h.etw¤ Fizmigen references teach l
that the cclllsipn energies qfiqne ineluge be I ‘
: varied berween Glauit were netinqesgnt Qfhel preéeenirin genre ‘ li
» nppnmuen when-hmm; iz; ell p¤;e}stQ1?re¢;¤;¢i» sguétaenh :·11;Q1a;h;q¢ ntetg ¤
. reasnnalile emma wnnldi erhenhu- emqgxhe
`
li 1 _ L JA 378 ~ .i:q .ua; ., r r

Case 1:04-cv-01230-GMS Document 73-9 Filed 12/15/2005 Page 4 of 4
t
I .
{ - M
{ 1 4
2 1 1 . 1
; Serial Numbcxt 9E1l004771 _ MM Page 3
t ¢ ‘ 1 M 1 1 T
E Art Ubin 2506 11 1 _
i M 1 ` =—· 1 ‘
g 2 M
. . claims ztrc pa1cntabI¤..M Anscrdzhgly, Fmiiah and the seferemzés mise a substantial nsw
question ufpatcritébitityas giaimé I-24,1whjch quéfciiéjx has not been decided in tx prétricus { 1;
i I M ` . M` · M " _` M, =1" :1.M. 1 M1=M M -...
3 ·¤»¤&¤éii¤¤i¤¤1¤@mé Dquglasiziil. gs£sm3*rt1s£es61e;‘auL5s¤1zga¤.t; ;;rt:.1$.113at¤pgNp.1i1;sss,vs_6 1 1; 1_ 1
s _ be F6MB3€&H`t1IlM_.M “ ad. M M 2 M M M M ` MM M ` ‘
E 1 The patcntfnvéricé E-.; ofthe c¤ntixag11gSg.r2&sfmb¤sg‘biHty under S 1.5655),10 .: ie-1
I " · 1 . ' Z ",__'· 4, ·M’ `. U : In E'.=;1
zpprisc the Dlicc ufttny l;1ti§Esti¤n ntziivicjrg gr ptlhgijiarisir or é;51:¤m·e¤t`pf¤¤aeding; " t _ ` `
{ Pa1cntN¤.1 4,953,736 thxuitgftout tis: course oftlzis récxan1i11ati6n prncbctftipgt Sw MPE? 'M
§§ 22071 2282 and 22861 1 ` -- M M J _ '1*
Any ixsquizy consuming this ¤;gmmt{nit:ati¤n‘0r earticr cimtmpnicatinns fiom the cxatuincr
I - M ._ _ 1
E shcnuld bt: directed {¤i3,xi·Qmi,nc}}acJqBaf·p:¤ai1whbsaiclcphuhe nua‘nbcr_in (763) 5D8·-48491 _.1 1_1;_;·_
t T 1 ` 1 1 ` =¢-tjggtfigeé
t 1 1 1
Q .},1
1 ‘ 1 1 a 1
MM . I I _ I l - ,:2,- UE 1- {J I . 0 2 M, I?
I ‘ M -1 ” . 1 F : M M1 -1* C1" M EM g_:,q‘ jgggg F1 1 1
I ~ . 1 `t M 1. 1 _ 1 *15*%* ;
1 . 1: ’1·: 1 1' 1 1 “ `J 1 Li 1 ->· "“BK0‘i!P¥»`¤*D · 1 ‘·‘ 1 ¤1,t;‘.*`1
§ I- ` .I 1 · 1 I V r-I ' M H ·· :1 h- » . · -.] I- 1 E—,1:_’!:·:r. ··
1 ‘ ,5.,11: 1; ,3 · · 1 II ` :. _ ; _ "
i N¤vcmbcr18, {SEQ 1;- M _ = . . . M
1 1 M ‘ Q 1 1 1, . EM 1 1 `‘`t ‘ 1 Q
t
M = MM M 7 =
E M-M M : M 1 M 11 1 1:.
___1 1 1 1 1/JA 379 ‘ 1 1