Free Redacted Document - District Court of Delaware - Delaware

Case 1:04-cv-01258-SLR

Document 457-8

Filed 07/07/2006

Page 1 of 37

EXHIBIT 11

Case 1:04-cv-01258-SLR

Document 457-8

Filed 07/07/2006

Page 2 of 37

Redacted

Case 1:04-cv-01258-SLR

Document 457-8

Filed 07/07/2006

Page 3 of 37

EXHIBIT 12

Case 1:04-cv-01258-SLR

Document 457-8

Filed 07/07/2006

Page 4 of 37

Case 1:04-cv-01258-SLR

Document 457-8

Filed 07/07/2006

Page 5 of 37

Case 1:04-cv-01258-SLR

Document 457-8

Filed 07/07/2006

Page 6 of 37

Case 1:04-cv-01258-SLR

Document 457-8

Filed 07/07/2006

Page 7 of 37

Case 1:04-cv-01258-SLR

Document 457-8

Filed 07/07/2006

Page 8 of 37

Case 1:04-cv-01258-SLR

Document 457-8

Filed 07/07/2006

Page 9 of 37

EXHIBIT 13

Case 1:04-cv-01258-SLR

Document 457-8

Filed 07/07/2006

)

Page 10 of 37

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF DELAWARE
MCKESSON INFORMATION SOLUTIONS

LLC,
Plaintift
v.

)

THE TRIZEUO GROUP, INC.,
Defendant.

) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) )

C.A. No. 04-1258 (SLR)

DEFENDANT THE TRIZETTO GROUP, INC.'S

FIRST SET OF INTERROGATORIES (l-2O

Pursuant to Fed. It Civ. P. 33, TriZetto Group, Inc., ("l'RIZEUO") hereby requests that

plaintiff McKesson Information Solutions, LLC ("McKESSON") respond in writing to the
following interrogatories within thirty (30) days of their service.

INSTRUCTIONS
1.

These Interrogatories are continuing in character, so as to require that

supplemental answers be filed seasonably if further or different information is obtained with
respect to any interrogatory.

2.

The terms "and" and "or" shall be construed either conjunctively or disjunctively,

as necessary, to bring within the scope of a discovery request any information which might
otherwise be construed to be outside of its scope.

3.

No part of an interrogatory should be left unanswered merely because an

objection is interposed to another part of the interrogatory. If a partial or incomplete answer is
provided, the responding party shall state that the answer is partial or incomplete.

1

S

Case 1:04-cv-01258-SLR

Document 457-8

Filed 07/07/2006

Page 11 of 37

4.

In accordance with Fed. R. Civ. P. 26(b)(5), where a claim of privilege is asserted

in objecting to any. interrogatory or part thereof, and information is not provided on the basis of
such assertion:
A.

In asserting the privilege, the responding party shall, in the objection to the

interrogatory, or part thereof, identify with specificity the nature of the privilege (including work
product) that is being claimed;
B.

The following information should be provided in the objection, if known

or reasonably available, unless divulging such information would cause disclosure of the
allegedly privileged information,

(I)

For oral communications:

a.

the name of the PERSON making the communication and

the names of the PERSONS present while the communication was made, and, where not
apparent, the relationship of the PERSONS present to the PERSON making the communication;

b.
c:

the date and place of the communication; and the general subject matter of the communication.

(2)

For documents:
a.

the type of document, the general subject matter of the document,

b.

c.

the date of the document, and

d.

such other information as is sufficient to identify the

document, including, where appropriate, the author, addressee, custodian, and any other recipient

of the document, and where not apparent, the relationship of the author, addressee, custodian,
and any other recipient to each other.

2

Case 1:04-cv-01258-SLR

Document 457-8

Filed 07/07/2006

Page 12 of 37

5.

If the responding party elects to specify and produce business recOrds in answer to

any interrogatory, the sjieciflcation shall be in sufficient detail to permit the interrogating party to

locate and identify, as readily as the responding party can, the business records from which the
answer may be ascertained.

6.

If, in answering these interrogatories, the responding party encounters any

ambiguities when construing a question, instruction, or definition, the responding party's answer
shall set forth the matter deemed ambiguous and the construction used in answering.

7.

All terms capitalized in these Interrogatories are defined in the definition section.

DEFINITIONS
1.

"YOU" or "YOUR" means McKesson Information Solutions, LLC., and any

subsidiaries, divisions, branches, predecessors or successors in business, and any entities acting

or purporting to act for or on behalf of the foregoing or who are subject to the direction or
control of the foregoing, including any present or former agents, employees, officers, directors,
insurance companies, attorneys, accountants, investigators, and consultants of the foregoing.

2.
3..

"The '164 PATENT" means U.S. Patent No. 5,253,164.

The term "DOCUMENTS" includes the plural as well as the singular, and is

synonymous with the terms "writing" and "recording" as defined in Rule 1001 of the Federal
Rules of Evidence, and is intended to include without limitation any handwritings, typewritings,
printings, photostats, photocopies, drawings, drafts, charts, photographs, e-mail, tape recordings,

filming and every other form of recording upon any tangible thing, any form of communication or representation including letters, words, numbers, symbols, pictures, sounds, or combinations

thereof, any stored information or databases, whether maintained S paper, magnetic or
electronic media, floppy disks, CD-ROMs, hard drives, zip drives, tapes or on other computer

3

Case 1:04-cv-01258-SLR

Document 457-8

Filed 07/07/2006

Page 13 of 37

storage, or any other maimer including the originals, or if the originals are unavailable, the
duplicates of said DOCUMENTS, from which information can be obtained or translated.
4.

The term "PERSON" shall include both natural PERSONS and corporate or other

business entities, whether or not in the employ of.a party, and the acts and knowledge of a
PERSON are defined to include the acts and knowledge of that PERSONS directors, officers,
members, employees, representatives, agents, and attorneys.

5.

The term "IDENTIFY" means, with regards to documents, to:

(a)
(b)

describe the nature of the document (e.g., letter or memorandum); state the date of the document and its bates or control numbers, if any;

(c)

identify the PERSON who sent and received the original and any copy of
the document;

(d)

state in as much detail as possible the contents of the document; and
state the manner and date of the disposition of the document.

(e)
6.

The term "IDENTIFY," with respect to PERSONS, shall men to state the

PERSONS: (a)
Individual, company, or corporate name;
last known address; and

(b)

(c)

last known phone number.

INTERROGATORIES

INTERROGATORY NO.1:

State in detail YOUR construction of each term of each asserted claim of the '164
PATENT, by means of a claim chart (including whether YOUR construction is based on the

ordinary meaning, any intrinsic and extrinsic support for YOUR definition, whether YOU

4

Case 1:04-cv-01258-SLR

Document 457-8

Filed 07/07/2006

Page 14 of 37

contend 'that any claim term has any meaning other than its ordinary meaning, and any evidence
YOU contend supports a construction other than the ordinary meaning).

INTERROGATORY NO.2:
Describe in detail how each asserted claim of the '164 PATENT has been infringed by
TRIZEUO (including, for each system or product accused of being infringed, stating in detail,
by means of a claim chart, YOUR contention as to where each limitation of the asserted claim is

found in the accused infringing TRIZETTO system or product and whether YOU are asserting
literal infringement or infringement under the doctrine of equivalents).

INTERROGATORY NO.3
For each asserted claim of the '164 PATENT, describe in detail the alleged conception of each. claimed invention (including, but not limited to, the date each claimed invention was first

conceived, the names of all PERSONS who participated in the, conception of the claimed

invention, 'the contribution made by each PERSON, and any documents related to that
conception).

INTERROGATORY NO.4:
For each asserted claim of the '164 PATENT, describe in detail the first reduction to
practice (either actual or constructive) of each claimed invention (including but not limited to the

circumstances of the reduction to practice, the date(s) of the reduction to practice, identification

of all PERSONS who participated in the reduction to practice, the contribution made by each
PERSON, and any documents that relate to that reduction to practice).

INTERROGATORY NO.5:
For each TRIZETTO system or product that YOU contend infringes the "164 PATENT,

describe the circumstances under which YOU or YOUR predecessor-in-interest first became

5

Case 1:04-cv-01258-SLR

Document 457-8

Filed 07/07/2006

Page 15 of 37

aware of that system or product and its alleged infringement (including, but not limited to, the
date(s) upon which YOU or YOUR predecessor-in-interest first became aware of such product,
the date upon which YOU or YOUR predecessor-in-interest first became aware that such product

allegedly infringed the '164 patent, and identification of all PERSONS involved and all
documents relating thereto).

INTERROGATORY NO.6:
For each asserted claim of the '164 PATENT, describe any disclosures of the subject

matter thereof prior to the date on which the application for the '164 PATENT was filed
(including but not limited to, all prior written publications, all sales, all offers to sell, and/or
public uses of any product or system embodying or practicing any claimed invention of the '164

PATENT, the dates ?

any such disclosures, sales, offers for sale and/or public uses, an

identification of the products or systems sold, offered for sale and/or publicly used, and an
identification of the PERSONS involved in the disclosure, sale, offer, and/or public use and all
documents relating thereto).
·

INTERROGATORY NO.7:
IDENTIFY each product or system ever made, sold, or licensed by YOU, by YOUR
predecessor-in-interest, by the named inventors of the '164 PATENT, or by any owner, assignee,
·

or licensee of the '164 PATENT that embodies, practices, or uses any of the alleged inventions

claimed in the '164 PATENT including the specific claim(s) of the '164 !ATEIST'l' that are
embodied, practiced, âr used in or by each such product or system and the product name, model number, trade name, trademark or other indicia and the dates each product or system was made,
sold; or licensed.

6

Case 1:04-cv-01258-SLR

Document 457-8

Filed 07/07/2006

Page 16 of 37

INTERROGATORY NO.8:

For each produôt or system, the identification of which is sought by, Interrpgatory
Number 7, IDENTIFY the PERSONS most knowledgeable about that product àr system and
state when it was' first described in a printed publication, publicly disclosed,, or offered for sale
and sold anywhere, in the world.

INTERROGATORY NO.9:
IDENTIFY all prior art to the '164 PATENT (including publications, patents, patent
applications, inventions by others, uses, sales or offers for sale, and disclosures) which YOU, the

named inventors of the '164 PATENT, any owner, assignee or licensee of the '164 PATENT, or
any patent agent or attorney acting on behalf of the named inventors of the '164 PATENT, were
aware prior to filing the '164 PATENT;

INTERROGATORY NO. 10:
For every item of prior art the identification of which is sought by Interrogatory No. 9,
describe how the prior art was located and the PERSON most knowledgeable about the location
of that prior art, and identify all documents relating thereto.

INTERROGATORY NO. 11:
Describe in detail any investigation, analysis, testing, studying, or reverse engineering of

every TRIZETTO product that YOU have ever considered to infringe or possibly infringe any
claim(s) of the '164 PATENT (including, but not limited to, the identification of all PERSONS

involved, the nature of each such PERSON'S involvement, the time period of the PERSON'S
involvement, any conclusions reached, and any documents relating thereto).

7

Case 1:04-cv-01258-SLR

Document 457-8

Filed 07/07/2006

Page 17 of 37

INTERROGATORY NO. 12:

IDENTIFY and describe any secondary considerations or objective evidence of
nonobviousness (e.g. commercial success, long-felt need, expressions of skepticism or disbelief

copying, etc.) that YOU contend support or evidence the purported nonobviousness of the

subject matter claimed in the '164 PATENT, and identify all documents supporting such
contention.

INTERROGATORY NO. 13:
State the amount of damages to which YOU claim to be entitled from TRIZETTO in this

action, and the method used to calculate those damages, and identify all documents relating
thereto.

INTERROGATORY NO. 14:
State the royalty rate or rates YOU contend are a "reasonable royalty" under 35 U.S.C. §
284

for the alleged iifringement of the '164 PATENT, and how that royalty rate(s) was

determined (including all facts and contentions that support the use of the royalty rate, and all
DOCUMENTS that YOU contend support YOUR asserted royalty rate).

INTERROGATORY NO. 15:
iDENTIFY allreference materials, including without limitation books, publications, and

computer software, that were used or relied upon by any of the inventors of the '164 patent
during its conception, development or reduction to practice.

INTERROGATORY NO. 16:
iDENTIFY all PERSONS, in addition to the inventors, who may have contributed to the
conception, development or reduction to practice of the invention claimed in the '164 PATENT.

S

Case 1:04-cv-01258-SLR

Document 457-8

Filed 07/07/2006

Page 18 of 37

INTERROGATORY NO. 17:

IDENTIFY all PERSONS involved with the conception, development or
commercialization of Health Payment Review, Inc.'s CodeReview product.

INTERROGATORY NO. 18:
Identify all materials used which were the basis of the CodeReview product, including all
prior software, medical device codes and sets of relationships among the medical device codes.

INTERROGATORY NO. 19:
IDENTIFY the programming language or languages used, and any commercial software

products used to define the programming environment and/or to assist in the coding of the

knowledge base and knowledge base interpreter portions of the system discussed in '164
PATENT as included in the patent's specification and appendices.

INTERROGATORY NO. 20:
Describe in detail the basis for YOUR allegation that TRIZET1O's alleged infringement
of the '164 Patent has been willful and wanton. MORRLS,NICHOLS, ARSHT & TUNNELL

B. Bluinenfeld (#1014) Rodger D. Smith, 11 (#3778) 1201 N.. Market Street P.O. Box 1347 · Wilmington, DE 19899 (302) 658-9200 Attorneys for Defendant The TriZetto Group, Inc. -

9

Case 1:04-cv-01258-SLR

Document 457-8

Filed 07/07/2006

Page 19 of 37

OF COUNSEL: John M. Benassi

JessicaR. Wolff
Matthew C. Lapple Paul, Hastings, Janofsky & Walker LLP 3579 Valley Centre Drive San Diego, CA 92130 (858) 720-2500

December 14, 2004

10

Case 1:04-cv-01258-SLR

Document 457-8

Filed 07/07/2006

Page 20 of 37

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

I, Jack B. Blumenfeld, hereby certi& that copies of the foregoing were caused to
be served on December 14, 2004 upon the following in the manner indicated:

BY HAND

Thomas J. Allingham, II Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom LLP One Rodney Square P.O. Box 636 Wilmington, DE 19899
BY FEDERAL EXPRESS

Jeffrey 0. Randall Skadden, Alps, Slate, Meagher & Flom LLP 525 University Avenue Suite 1100 Palo Alto, CA 94301]

.TJackB.eld

Case 1:04-cv-01258-SLR

Document 457-8

Filed 07/07/2006

Page 21 of 37

EXHIBIT 14

Case 1:04-cv-01258-SLR
03--18--05

Document 457-8

Filed 07/07/2006
T118

Page 22 of 37
P.02/10

O3:22pm

From--

F--279

N TEE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR. THE DISTRICT OF DELAWARE

MCKESSON INFORMATION SOLUTIONS ) ) LLC, ) Plaintift ) v. )
THE TRIZETTO GROUP, NC.,
Defendant.

CIVIL ACTION NO. 04-1258--SLIt

) ) ) )

__________________________________________________________________)

PLAINTIFF MCKESSON'S SECOND SUPPLEMENTAL RESPONSE TO DEFENDANT TRIZETT(fl FIRST SET OF INTERROGATORJES (1-20)
Plaintiff, McKesson Information Solutions LLC ('McKesson"), hereby
supplements its responses as follows to Interrogatory Nos. 6-8, 15-18, and 20 of the First Set of Interrogatories by defendant, The TriZetto Group, Inc. ("TriZetto").

GENERAL OBJECTiONS
McKesson incorporates by reference as if fully set forth herein the General

Objections set forth in its January 13, 2005 Responses to TriZeno's First Set of
Interrogatories (1-20) and irs February 18, 2005 Supplemental Responses to Defendant

TriZetto's First Set of Interrogatories (1-20)

Case 1:04-cv-01258-SLR
03--18--05

Document 457-8

Filed 07/07/2006
T--118

Page 23 of 37
P.03/lU
F--2T9

03:22pm

From--

RESPONSES

INTERROGATORY NU
For each asserted claim of the '164 PATENT, describe arty disclosures of the subject matter thereof prior to the date on which the application for the '164 PATENT was filed (including but not limited to, all prior written publications, all sales, all offers to sell, and/or public uses of any product or system embodying or practicing any claimed invention of the '164 PATENT, the dates of any such disclosures, sales, offers for sale and/or public uses, an identification of the products or systems sold, offered for sale andlor publicly used, and an identification of the PERSONS involved in the disclosure, sale, offer, and/or public use and all documents relating thereto).

RESPONSE TO INTERROGATORY NO.6;
McKesson incorporates by reference as if fblly set forth herein its original

response to this interrogatory, including objections. Subject to and without waivingthe
foregoing objections7 McKesson supplements its response to this interrogatory as follows: On February 18, 1988, at least Dr. Robert Hertensrein7 Dr. Don Holloway, and

Kelli Dugan demonstrated a computer system, an early version of what later became known as CodeReview, embodying subject matter of the '164 Patent to Caterpillar. Inc. Non-privileged documents within McKesson's possession, custody, or control relating to this demonstration have been or will be produced.
On March 22, 1988, at least Dr. Robert Irlertenstein, Dr. Don Holloway, and Dr.

George Goldberg demonstrated a computer system, an early version of what later became

known as CodeReview, embodying subject matter of the '164 Patent to Aetna Life Insurance Company. Non-privileged documents within McKesson's possession, custody,
or control relating to this demonstration have been or will be produced.

2

Case 1:04-cv-01258-SLR
03--18--05

Document 457-8

Filed 07/07/2006
1--118

Page 24 of 37
P.04/iD
F--279

03:22pm

From--

On April 26, 1988, at least Dr. Robert Hertenstein, Dr. Don Holloway. and Kelli
Dugan demonstrated a computer system, an early version of what later became known as
CodeReview, embodying subject matter of the b164 Patent to Blue Cross Blue Shield of

Michigan. Non-privileged documents within McKesson's possession, custody, or control
relating to this demonstration have been or will be produced. On June 8, 1988, a computer system, an early version of what later became

known as CodeReview, embodying subject matter of the '164 Patent was installed at Caterpillar, Iztc. in Peoria, illinois. Non-privileged documents within McKesson's
possession, custody, or control relating to this system have been or will be produced. On June 16, 1988, Dr. Don Holloway offered to implement a computer system, an early version of what later became known as CodeReview, embodying subject matter of

the '164 Patent for ARMCO, Inc. Non-privileged documents within McKesson's
possession, custody, or control relating to this offer have been or will be produced.
McKesson's mv est g4tlon into information responsive to this ufletrogatory is

ongoing and McKesson reserves the right to supplement this response as discovery continues or as circumstances otherwise warrant.

INTERR OGATORY NO.7:
UDENTWY each product or system ever made, sold, or licensed by YOU, by YOUR predecessor-in-interest, by the named inventors of the 164 PATENT, or by any owner, assignee, or licensee of the '164 PATENT that embpdies, practices, or uses any of the alleged inventions claimed in the '164 PATENT including the specific claim(s) of the '164 PATENT that are embodied, practiced, or used in or by each such product or system and the product name, model number, trade name, trademark or other indicia and the dates each product or system was made, sold, or licensed.

3

Case 1:04-cv-01258-SLR
03--18--05 03:ZSpm From--

Document 457-8

Filed 07/07/2006
T--118

Page 25 of 37
P.05/lu F--279

RESPONSE TO INTERROGATORY NO.7:
McKesson incorporates by reference as if fully set forth herein its original

response to this interrogatory, including objections. Subject to and without waiving the
foregoing objections, McKesson supplements its response to this interrogatory as
follows:

McKesson has made and licensed CodeReview and ClaimCheck. Value Health Sciences, Inc. has developed and marketed Medical Review System. Solucient, LLC has
developed and licensed Auto-Audit and Auto-Query.

McKesson's investigation into information responsive to this interrogatory is
ongoing and McKesson reserves the right to supplement this response as discovery continues or as circumstances otherwise warrant.

INTERROGATORY NO..8:
For each product or system, the identification of which is sought by Interrogatory No. 7, IDENTIFY the PERSONS most knowledgeable about that product or system and state when it was first described in a printed publication, publicly disclosed, or offered for sale and sold anywhere in the world:

RESPONSE TO INTERROGATORY NO.8:
McKesson incorporates by reference as if fully set forth herein its original response to this interrogatory1 including objections. Subject to and without waiving the foregoing objections, McKesson supplements its response to this interrogatory as
follows:

Codekeview was first installed at Caterpillar, Inc. in Peoria, Illinois on June 8, 1988. ClaimCheck was first shipped on a pilot basis in June 1989. Value Health
Sciences, Inc. developed and marketed Medical Review System on or before October 21,

4

Case 1:04-cv-01258-SLR
03--18--05
03:23prn

Document 457-8

Filed 07/07/2006
T--118

Page 26 of 37
P.06/10 F--279

From--

1994.

Solucient, LLC first marketed Auto-Audit and Aiuo-Query on or before July 1,

2002.

McKesson's investigation into information responsive to this interrogatory is ongoing and McKesson reserves the right to supplement this response as discovery continues or as circumstances otherwise warrant.

INTERROGATORY NO- 15;
IDENTIFY all reference materials, including without limitation books, publications, and computer software, that were. used or relied upon by any of the inventors of the 164 patent during its conception, development or reduction to practice.

RESPONSE TO INTERROGATORY NO. 15:
McKesson incorporates by reference as if fully set forth herein its original

response to this interrogatory, including objections. Subject to and without waiving the
foregoing objections, McKesson supplements its response to this interrogatory as
follows:

The American Medical Association's Current Procedural Terminology, Fourth Edition (CPT-4) manual, software entitled "Clipper" and "dBASE III," and expert shell software marketed by Texas Instruments were used in the development and reduction to

practice of the subject matter of the '164 Patent. McKesson's investigation into information responsive to this interrogatory is
ongoing and McKesson reserves the right to supplement this response as discovery continues or as circumstances otherwise warrant.

INTERR OGATORY NO. 16:
IDENTIFY all PERSONS. in addition to the inventors, who may have contributed to the conception, development or reduction to practice of the invention claimed in the '164 PATENT.

5

Case 1:04-cv-01258-SLR
03--18--05

Document 457-8

Filed 07/07/2006
T--118

Page 27 of 37
P.07/iD

03:23pm

From--

F--279

RESPONSE TO INTERROGATORY NO. 16;
McKesson incorporates by reference as if fUlly set forth herein its original

response to this interrogatory, including objections. Subject to and without waiving the
foregoing objections. McKesson supplements its response to this interrogatory as

follows:
McKesson is unaware of any persons who contributed to the conception of the claims of the '164 Patent other than the named inventors who, as a matter of law, are presumed to have conceived the inventions claimed in the '164 Patent. 1-n addition to the
named inventors, Peggy Saal, Clifford Alper, Denise Konicelc, R.icbarcl AUler, and Lenore

Tracey may have contributed to the development and reduction to practice of the subject

matter of the 164 Patent.
McKesson's investigation into infonnation responsive to this interrogatory is
ongoing and McKesson reserves the right to supplement this response as discovery
continues or as circumstances otherwise warranr

iNTERROGATORY NO.11;
IDENTIFY all PERSONS involved with the conception, development or commercialization of Health Payment Review, Inc's CodeReview product.

IWSPONSE TO INTERROGATORY NO. 17;
McKesson incorporates by reference as if fUlly set forth herein its original

response to this interrogatory, including objections. Subject to and without waiving the
foregoing objections, McKesson supplements its response to this interrogatory as

follows;
Dr. Robert Hertenstein, Dr. George Goldberg, Dr. Don Holloway, Kelli Dugan, Dr. Richard Egdahl, Clifford Alper, Richard Adler, Lenore Tracey, Denise Konicek,

6

Case 1:04-cv-01258-SLR
03--18--05
03:24prn

Document 457-8

Filed 07/07/2006
T--118

Page 28 of 37
P.08/10
F--219

From--

Marcia Radosevich,

and Peggy Saal were involved with the development and

commercialization of Health Payment Review, Tue.' s CodeReview product.

McKesson's investigation into information responsive to this interrogatory is
ongoing and McKesson reserves the right to supplement this response as discovery continues or as circumstances otherwise warrant.

INTERROGATORY NO. 18:
Identify all materials used which were the basis of the CodeReview product, including all prior software, medical device codes and sets of relationships among the medical device codes.

RESPONSE TO INTERROGATO RY NO. 18;
McKesson incorporates by reference as if fully set forth herein its original

response to this interrogatory, including objections. Subject to and without waiving the
foregoing objections, McKesson supplements its response to this interrogatory as

follows:
The American Medical Association's Current Procedural Terminology, Fourth Edition (CPT-4) manual, software entitled "Clipper" and "dBASE UI," and expert shell software marketed by Texas Instruments were used in Health Payment Review, Inc.'s development of the CodeReview product. McKesson's investigation into information responsive to this interrogatory is ongoing and McKesson reserves the right to supplement this response as discovery continues or as circumstances otherwise warrant.

INTERROGATORY NO. 20;
Describe in detail the basis for YOUR allegation that TriZetto's alleged infringement of the '164 patent has been willful and wanton.

7

Case 1:04-cv-01258-SLR
03--18--05

Document 457-8

Filed 07/07/2006

Page 29 of 37
F279

03:24pm

From--

T118 P.09/10

RESPONSE TO INTERROGATORY NO. 20:
McKesson incorporates by reference as if fully set fbrth herein its original

response to this interrogatory, including objections. Subject to and without waiving the
foregoing objections; McKesson supplements its response to this interrogatory as

follows:
In its January 20, 2005 responses to McKesson's First Set of Interrogatories,

TriZetto admits that it knew ofthe '164 patent at least as early as 1995." See, e.g.,
TriZeno Responses at 26. TriZetto also previously marketed and distributed ClaimCheck

software that TriZetto knew was covered by claims of the 164 Patent. TriZetto then
acquired Erisco and began marketing the FACETS product, knowing it infringed claims

of the '164 Patent, without obtaining a license from McKesson.
McKesson's investigation into information responsive to this interrogatory is ongoing and McKesson reserves the right to supplement this response as discovery continues or as circumstances otherwise warrant.

DATED: March 18, 2005
By:

Jg

QüizS.
G. Randall

S DEN, ABPS, SLATE MEAGUER & FLOM LISP

525 University Avenue, Suite 1100 Palo Alto, CA 94301
Attorneys for Plaintiff, McKesson Information Solutions LLC

S

Case 1:04-cv-01258-SLR
03--18--05
03:24prii

Document 457-8

Filed 07/07/2006

Page 30 of 37

From--

TH18 P.10/10 F279

PRQOF OF SERVLç
(FRCP 5)
1 am a citizen of the United States and a resident of the State of Califontia. I,
employed in Santa Clara County, State of California, in the office, of a member of the bar of this

Court, at whose direction the service was made. I am over the age of eighteen years, and not a party to the within action. My business address is 525 University Avenue, Suite 1100, Palo Alto,

CA 94301.
On March 18. 2005,1 served PLAINTIFF MCKESSON'S SECOND

SUPPLEMENTAL RESPONSE TO DEFENDANT TRIZETTO'S FIRST SET OF
INTERROGATORTES(1-20) in the manner described below;

(BY FACSIMILE) I am personally and readily familiar with the business practice of Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meafler & Elom LLP for collection and processing of document(s) to be transmitted by facsimile, and I caused such document(s) on this date to be transmitted by facsimile to the offices of'
addressee(s) at the numbers listed below.

(BY U.S. MAIL) I am personally and readily familiar with the business practice of Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom LLP for collection and
processing of correspondence for mailing with the United States Postal Service, and I caused such envelope(s) with postage thereon fblly prepaid to be placed in the United States Postal Service at Palo Alto, California. on the following party in this action; Matthew C. Lapple, Esq. Paul, Hastings, Janofslcy, Walker LU' 695 Town Center Drive ' Costa Mesa, CA 92626 Facsimile: 714.979.1921
Executed on March 18, 2005 in Palo Alto, California.

Jack B. Blumenfeld, Esq. Moths, Nichols, Arsht & TunneU 1201 N. Market Street P0. Box 1347 Wilmington, DE 19899 Facsimile: 302.425.3012

CLJAJ

Pamela Carrier

Case 1:04-cv-01258-SLR

Document 457-8

Filed 07/07/2006

Page 31 of 37

EXHIBIT 15

Case 1:04-cv-01258-SLR
anne an._ UIJUUI UIni UFFI
an ii,

Document 457-8
rLU
nAl

Filed 07/07/2006
TOIU4IU4OIU

Page 32 of 37
i4 n anainna ,.i I4f r.UUlUUI rI1 I

r.__ aI,Ann..I Anna

rFUFFIwL)rI )rr

----

!iLIU

II

T.Tur]iTh T kTT1Th C m A m i1 rvrc rr Tr'T' r'r.T TI P uiN TTT LNuIJThLJ uJ-.u1 LJ]ur.11 JLJrLL
mT3r? L.'I I i'.JL I rL' T1T 1 T I .JXS. J. £J TT mU Tr'm 'JI .'LL.21AVY A U 1

1.1

II II I

v.a

iv' I-II1flT1TT

tIV II ( I loiN INtl
nfl CT r A nrnTCVK T W.

fl A I fl C C) Cit ri

V
I I1I' 1K 1fF'

I

Iii (TK( H JI

tTh Th T1'l

II"J(

I JI11flIflI

1 _pIL'LL'l%11 A T%J'I' IIJ I'ff L'I'II '.7 k .1' L .L L 1. l'4. Li Ll.'1' .L"I' IlL'LL' IL .L 1L %'JJA 'ItlIJI If 11_1l11 .1. .JL. L I r%Y'Ik'IJIJ1%1 L '.LL.I2 . 4

II .II'rrrn'tnrIVI( I M.%( s%'aYIII IM I I1 Y%trn'nV 'C, s 'c '.Ytt, S V flr, C, ..t'%VC, 'i C, I I liii 1t JI% 41'l C,'t't!ttlS'V C, V II'II I1I'IIlI I I I(IM.%It II%I1.

I-I I Q.r.tl Ft ft/in IC noor,n I ntnrvn otinn CTTnT,i,rrirl T TTT1TTT11T TTflECWTTAT flflTlflITTTflTTfl .n Ii Iti nfl o

Ir.rTrr I't/I n IC aoenn" I T.TT rn--1 o,imm I n,n,ntc '1T I I 1" \ TTflCDlXT'flST horcil"n r OITflTTTTfl,InOIto

lIt.r .'It Ir ,CriDrr', F'..Id I I Yf1 1 vv I.',.' .·-i-'.'.
tP1Ylt I I1LA'.? A. ,PTtF ._JSSf'.+I.# aSS.'. A. I Ti S Ai'fl%# I vVC',i1T 1T14'
I" I·5 A..r.,'.fr% J. Ti ,.pTTc

'D 1

t...I1.'% UtI(I I

JI.I Iii : I

II JI

[VICI'..II I!1CUFflOraLcS [iv ririic as ii ILL!IV StL IL)rLIi IItrIT1 LFl itritrai t)fl14CLIt}[1S L
TOTIT]
TTT

4Ii

1I f TPI1TTR A I c Cflfl TT0fl\T T
-n

01 T flh1I7Tt

'7

3 1TT C' Tfl TTflflTTflT1 1C'

'

(I fl' I T "It\

1

!1T

W11T(1J A 1 0 C('.R7 OT 'I1\1

TP1TTTTTT11(1T1' TTC'U1DS.J

#- 11iP11TTT(T (1I7TTT 1TTT C ,--T Cfl 1t' -4
m.. L'. .-.t L 1LUU&L iiLLI LLLI.V IJL

(1 11V ..i-, VLlJI,11 1 V )IV V 1O. 4.%JJJ I 1ThUh iI. 1.
I. --

1J UUi LLIJU1LUL1 L'U UJ

ItArrn1tvri 1 1 _)1il ,1 vriI 111 /111} I hirñ ---------'..-.rn11s Tn I 1it(-.yfIriT I i1 ,1-rn Iit1I W -- '---,--, '--
--

rirr

(T Inleirl TFFIt9 I I--'.III ann JT .III11 I
r' IISL c,_.

, cst

/111!) lflhITEfl

iinnierneiirat

ntmes Tfl

IJtItLIUIIL I [ILLLU

/1 'f\ UI I[ILCI1ULLU1!C I 1U I

Case 1:04-cv-01258-SLR
anne an._ UIJUUI UIni UFFI
an ii,

Document 457-8
rLU
nAl

Filed 07/07/2006
TOIU4IU4OIU

Page 33 of 37
i4 n anninna ,.i I4f r.UUlUUI rI1 I

r.__ aI,Ann..I Anna

rFUFFIwL)rI )rr

----

!iLIU

II

I I.PI'I II/I II' IIJ I

I - II1%II JIlI1'l

tItIIJ'I rJI I --, J-"-... J

mmr'rf ti1;-. h if
4I.S '.S'.dI,'ASS .LS'..#
1

- J (Il1TT1 flT ruie - I fl+ Ii A I -"I'..ir i-... L?CCLI U1llhiiU IJV _ 1 1iI' in (1,T1 I PrrI tT1i.11 _-l rI-t ---- --11db LN I .'bW4,4, -iiYn rrin* in n,ri I MI I T U T1TflT1TMTT TflT TTV TTT1A Tr. I,T11 I · I.. I iivi T --- -----.-.L TTflT1VITTTTTT Tfl TT1 ,,.e,a.4a,l TTTTT'IC !LI LULI JU A I II ri-s t1U1IULUUJ (H JIIflA-. - -1 Z N TT1P #J ·L%JSLSLI %JJ. 'IIf If I-. r1 1 1 ,ct1YI v 1fI1/'T T1(1 WflP.TI1PT Y I ii J lT VLI1I! .r,,, flTnim ITT TT1 "V'IV flu TTTTTTTTTTT I
1

IiT,rI lnrrn

.

.fr

I

(TneT1J flT 1BTflT1

Tll!fl

I1[ILLLL

LLlL UUt.LIILLC UI UL41ViUUDli

'

----

ti .

r

.1

-,.4-' +1..

1V
--

m.rn Il.IVI Il.I I IYIF ttffiI%t' Is'tLi 1L II1JLJL72i.I.J.I, J-Li. .. YI -.1-c'r' I TTmT?I)U IThI A ms U 1%J Il I U11 ,
it i_Yx_.__._ 1VTflflTflTtT Afl TTflS\II1Ai
1L1LLLU1LU1 V_ 11iL.1UUJ.U tJL) I ..'ILtJIJ2.

.

. +.ATTIIT ic +-.-fITT f-II ttitrn
tl LLLL1 .J14.W1J T.ztrr, J tIw mt
-

II r,.rrI 9(W

T1. TI1

1A.-

+-, ,Il 3U4J I u7lthr.llt ur31tyrICr th t P(wirlc ('lr1P('T,rr1' l rr.,l cU..'.- VV . . VV
+'-'..'-'
- - _1 -- 1_ Iflf1 -- -- rII flITTfl -- -- I flI
--

IY1-fli 1LLJIJLLJ1LL.L1IZ j A R,1-It fli SYtVS'Vk??',,FLA .LACLQ 1I.''44 ¼4L3
i'.&S'4, SSt. S'.hIA',' VT 4-1-at

}i.' itrI 'cr rr lWiI itt1aa.L 'cxrrili'nu 11rII flVI- IiIV ++4+L4I.%.t.* 1r
-,

--,-,- rn 1_ ___I_1._ th tIltfi71( li1 T1-r' rrrW111tT Ir nni _L' iir lflP.I11(le :1 C 11flfI1l (;111flI

- __. (iT Tf1e.(11c1I 1iI\f1IitI1L 1IlTEl& r1:.-E ".-. rrrirmiY cIinir.I Pflh11fl7 nr II1(1IT1T1J____1 LdL1L11Ik,L.

I IJL4

. )IUI

L[LUILfIA

L1 t iirr.L1usgJI LUUI

l]1M(1IU)I TTflt1TflT1rfl) Tfl

I-----.9., 1.. ..,1 1
------ 4

---.r

aiiu

1MTt

YI17TTT

TTrClUll]CTIIIT1 (11 uncrJnIr - -. -L. IIF1)ULL1L

r'r-. dilU 1C1tLCU U1L1tJac. L4IL iii 1.---1

I -I P1JLIAL I1'.A L'JI
LI11L

1-,-

-l ..1L11 1 IaIL[If'acLs fL1,C1 1UU JILdIiK IJIA...$.

r'

+h -.-'JUI a 1uc1%A IJY I,LL.i'.-v.,,-l- I44 !4'- t,iIPV X

Cflfl? 'TT TA A FPTT TT 1 .....A . TT(C!%.T'TAT flhiD
TTTTPT1

t

OTT

l/ 11i1-T t A ,-

c,1rl v l.JI' K .oc!r.YI Will !n(1ft
1 1 gl %ITrITI1I fI11r1 e'I1rr TCr Tflt

T Ttfl i -T(VV

tI I.TTTT' rT1ti ,r,rr/',(%cii1('tc QYII1 Cli .Idn,,+, n,-.-l I 1I rr.IP ,,1 TT1 ..,.,

L _.. FJi'J.I.t4.'.
TNt TT/'TTt'.fl15

Iii I1,1itirni Ii ...*tttti.,. I c _-c__ .. ri ti-i ?Ilirh I £L &-

-

141

II

.

I I/J I , I £,.
1

- - ] I ILL z' A --- -1T1(1 A - UIT Ir1I 1 ('p4 T1{LI1L I F11EUJ S --
--

, ( I1itYI-q('T I'fTI 1rnC1 I l1(I .111I( rrrlniIFTc 1T11flfllf ann navt 1TI1T1U(1CIaHII-- 0 IC .-.1lU LII J Q i L1U 1..V -,-------------A 1I1t $1 (+-11ittflI. /45 I l-r..:--- I CA -- FIL.CLLU: IS cIWU 'T'...-. IIJL -- r -

_C---T

c_ Pfl'7a_I

LIJ IIUV
ktc rr,tI I hfI T *tft

nnrI ni,c'tnrnn,c W1LLLi, Q.L1 JLW4.?
c'(7Q1rI1c! iYrr1TcYP

APIT

TTV TTflT A YTTT1 111

11 4,11

,I-..+ 1tT?

t T 1Y7T r,, I I ,I-tc. rrrTTT

,,.

,'..

'If1Tfl

1 .J 4.SSM. I .v-l I_I A

#. .JS SVa..SnJhJ%JSS .JIStL 1It11t .. t FS,1t'I '.r
'1

Case 1:04-cv-01258-SLR
11 UIUUUU UI .FJFII

Document 457-8

Filed 07/07/2006
TUUU'fILi'+UIU

Page 34 of 37
I'ff'f

ArFC rAI ñ Al 'rrl rFUIIIIvwI'II trr ---- rtu.IJ iii.IU

fl flA inrm r.UU'WUUU M?1 rf I

IvlrK P'.SCT1 S I11V.SLWdLIL)II IIILU ii1iJ1i1LQ.U'JIL L
, T1fl IVIClLSflh1

,

-i' IJJ.LLLV'.' s-'-'

TflIQ i,1rrriQIrcrv is flT1k'iJiIi

resrvc

[L1C

rirrJ]fl1sLa11(;i ULILCLW1

-I·

11LIL I.'J 'I

i1L1IL' I-l44

(1twerv [flTlI.1T1Ii'4

UI

ILIr

A 'PITh1J '7 l.JyJ.Jix1 1%1 1.

ii Ni'i L L I_LJLiN .11 I.V
--

- - 1 -] . JLJ. 1' I TUT fI h ,rc%.111r? mv TP1fl 1JiV rniiie -'()ILLi -ur IIIIsu uv 1 T('iTU Vl- %JL)J.. 4'--' I-' '-'- ' '-'b

nr11rsnr--1B-1nIrrI. DV LILt &11A uYcIJ UJ.
,JJ_

tI iLJ ''4W--%J iJi 1W-fly- aur Stlt11 131UUUL UI VLJI1 U1U L11' - -i-1. iI.rd1i.rI r?T1((I 1W 11.Ffl 1TI
.
rnimei
_____1.
1./4. 1"--'-'--'--
J-----------.,---.--.-,---

-- L' I I- RI I .1 .1 - --- _ I1 I tI1 - I t'.LL -- ,·.,-,·..,,-r TF1T 1TIflfl11 T)i1{CL1CS UI ..---. ijlIV UI.- LU aI1u II1V1l.PIJLL -- ''4 ---·-- A fl A 9flfl T!TI -- 1 A m1KT'T1US.44U441 I,iL (t C. I C 1#'hL I-h I 1 I'J 1 rnr--re TFLP I I1I i.[l iUP I
-

---------.,

1(

I

I V JF '.+*J
1

·,iL'

[!UE11UC1 L1dU UU11.
11 eiI(I rr I1PIflPfl

LLWLi.. JJ. ,-thA, -."-'. -.'-+ 'JI.LL 1Th11('1 I1I1 trip 1TP SWfl irnniicr nr sVI[I1 wa !IIdA1t.

1LL wi-i-l.1

j-.'. I'v....F. WI II, I I / I it ii , i!. r,. II 1 I

. ..'

r rFi iL I. I LI
Afl

T1%.T'I'I? 11 £Thr' A Tb I'I 'fl tJ
TT ATT!,T

1J .1 % 7.

' '-'- '*

II(,'d:)IA :.-.-.... 1PTflflTfl1r1I
P.

t1TTT
ti-. rv1

1- t-,-fh Ir'A,r, II rv1nr vTflTIP T Tfl1 i.c, TtiTfT

,,

-.. A11P()ll3IL[[

TTTflflTTTI

·TTfIT1Iflfl InTlf a

A.T7 Ia.! IvJ_I_J_cu11 IAJIJII1i 1! I IPJLI l--

+h, tA-,r?ttW7 Q tIII'f
1VT(I (c--Il I1TI1Z .r 1' C, Ifl1T VT1TL
--.

.LLL LZ
hy4aaaJsL a isa, S?h?

I h?

-''-'J

rTT xrhft.t \1T1,1VIc VttirAA

,.,Th trarni rl1fvT1nn

Ir,1
1'

·"11T('I 1Y1TñrYflT1frn T T)()T1!.1Vt Ill tF1 UILLFLJtRJ1V 1 U11Ufl1.
a

_·_
--

C?

SW

nfI l11(K eE-t rrv Tfl V1YI1F iU 'iJnnIrTir1t [US rsuuiisc S U1SLUVt V-UU1ii1U UI --., --

rr

1r(1Tq11(tc nTnrwi'.l warrartl
.--

--S

PIlflfl% P l'(I I: 11% I IICItII(v1 ILJlYt% C. -

i w-iii-iht I'tf Ir,'rrrtcfqtri/rT 1\1r / TTrI,' h. .-.A 1*.¼.., it WU1L £L II I-r'.iIII-v ,L4...S.JS S S.L .1. VSS' S S1.# II'i' rI1cT mnwieieinie SIflflh]I. IFUhI. flIIJUIIU4 tr SViLIIH t11U .1 .4?. d 1 ·1 ,C. flT1fl ITT P W1TTTTfl 1-.A +,-l rr 1't1P.1 trr QqI T1l1 Clfl T!A VZTIT £TTT(11qI1 YCT1
TflJ

TIT 1WlflflTfl 1(1 TTT1QA TT1I %TTT1TTflT ---I I- _ 1 1_

th -'hI(

-

-

_1____ a. sl_ ._. _.___.. .L._

t1rT Tt

TTVTTTAA CT

4I.%? 4flAJ Vtihv 1T

$1 TF W(Wt(1

4

Case 1:04-cv-01258-SLR
anne a,._ UIJUUI UIni UFFI
an ii,

Document 457-8
rLU
nAl

Filed 07/07/2006
TOIU4IU4OIU

Page 35 of 37
i4 n aneinna ,.i I4f r.UUIlUUI rI1 I

r.__ aI,Ann..I Anna

rFUFFIwL)rI )rr

----

!iLIU

II

C'TTT)U1 L'T'1I.AT 1PL7 Wl I-· S%I4 It I I 1 I 11 IJI II _ II II V II I P I-J__., IYI.Ii-.L' LA
.,-,' .. ---j-'.- --,-,Fr -- ---- LV.LL1 ii(4I' ',-/y vtlfl('P --, it TliIIV T TflrIfl nriri XII flflflU T 1U11. LII IFII,

,'tf17 iwi.Iiirl'iyi( j'-'.-' iTlrr L1I.4I.,I,LLtJL , ILLIl.4%ILLiff,
rtI1i-.I c#ri £vsb.'s'kIl.".Ia
1T V ·S¼.'SSSSSI.JSbLIS
JLLI .-)LJUJLL?I/%I

%iir1irT T( T1fl WlTflflhlI WH1V11J TI1 J..'.."

IflT(JII1 Ut)I1LiULI.
-.

1 UUUIJ%U I)W TJilJIfl cI1irPi. 1TflTT TTTYI1A 11(1 Tfl

ii

n(11cA I(' Tfl1 1nTerr1w11nrv 1S 1t)IIt)W .1 ---- -- -

IVIfl1I'.Oh1 4 irivciiaiiuii 11110 Uh1UIU11.1UI1 IU04IIY 10 LLJ.I -. c7

.',----

TTfl TTTI1

I rT ltiU1

, t-

04.10L Y ,,

aiiu IvIeJ,.ssu11

ieivci u1c i1iLL +. UJ
ë.J
VV aL.L Q.LII..

, c4 Z,'T.7 11L1.AiL .t.U £'A1' .1, JV'- y

11' 1vr Q

tJLUL

1ATIF. ¶1ci

1

J1III

1

--3.

-----_:..-------j__ ,,:--
A

KAIJhN P.IIN I A I- I- IVII-AtI-IIK 0 riIMV1 LL : . .. T 'f TI
'i I I-ni,mrc',ty .,JL..J ,JS±1 V L OSI.y .L 1. V '.LSI.&', kJ L&SI'.9 I I III! k 4.'.",'

I.+,ifU-?l.II 1' I

7 L'V1 1 ii ' b 1 ,YI f. I17/f17Ff J 7 ._IuIJ I I11 .AJF f L. If I
,·_

1__..,--,

A1. k/-t 3UI 1IU i-tiLt) f'IA (A%1

xr.nn.n '.,1t

4-'.-.... Th1;..-;4itLUi11V IUI rlfliLI1l

V I. ...'. - n_I. PnTI IflhIThTfl1lT1fT1 flI11T1CW1S I .1 .1

Case 1:04-cv-01258-SLR
11 UIUUUU UI .FJFII

Document 457-8

Filed 07/07/2006
TUUU'fILi'+UIU

Page 36 of 37
I'ff'f

ArFC rAI ñ Al 'rrl rFUIIIIvwI'II trr ---- rtu.IJ iii.IU

n lrn,inn M?1I r.UUU(UUU rf

rrn g'I.T' (t1 lU PUll' flI
%,LLLL'.'IL -.+ '_'.-

lI1I'(U I' 2' !.I

U) %I I I I.e V L%I.I

T

II1

tI

..-, I Yl1?ft(1 TTf A11(t (--flSILJ1IL UI. L1i ,---- -- -----,-------

1i1I_fl_p V

,,-. k?c4u. I'-..,-- CI11flTV 1V ( ii.

- ,--

i- -l-..
-

-+1&LLWL4 Iti-rii'
IJJ,

I

+_ ,UiI OL 1LI1U11I1d LU L1J
-- -

ti 1-nic.v 1miTTPfl. nm inir '.JL LL."
7

r7r +- +I- E- f%t thJ.L. %SLt·W - ''' - U1rtCL1UI1 L11 Si V1''. V 11IW.AI . $- '-' 1rP I,') Ut'... LJCLJ. I i\llrr cir -"-'.
y %.a.La, 444'.!-

flT ewflI.[I

.rt1 T1fIT--. riqilV -- Tfl WilFilil 1CL1ULL EYIV 1 r- '-J TC -

--------

ic

I I111vFr1TvAP.VtTIIJ4 U1L

·-- '---------

111111 I-'IC

A 'i'.1!II &IIT ( .P (A,f\1

I JT1

)(1FI eflhL-1TI1)i I Z.U1JJ. I
- - - -- -- -- ---- -.- .--.

Ull

T.Ir'Y1T tIrJII I4I I'-"-... IVII i I1kI Ji iii r I LI
- F'% I I I( I

r, . 'r.YT ILLYI 1l.T'I' A IJtI III T1% if 1' 1LL I ri

Ut £1IY.LJkJ I II L1 1T] I. L' I 1 L I''I-'.- I - I I I

r"1'rt, C' 1'TTb C"T' I1 m '.JII I J - 1' 11W 1 ('' L
----
--

tti'

L I I I1IJX'.J'J,
I U V I..

5 Ui_Phi ui trip 11111T Elf C'flflt(l D1UW. .4

I ' I 11 II I-I. 1

--

A...nranit t)L I'dUUJi. CLIJ

I 1Y1 T'ItTSflTI ii ai Ill i(LU11V IcULULLaL VY ALLI 'J(IV --------- -------,--r...;l;-... ,+I-. tIa '-

(? fll11fl1TliI
'--...

I',J ." ,' ----'-- 1 L7c1uw, 1rPI W-"-''-'J r rn niirrinrs IlSLcl.L.,._.:1 Mh.4
tli1111[IICIILI J Uli 1..LU
.-1-...
- ---- "----- -- -- -- -- -- -- -

I f,. 1-A TrriiTT(1

RCIV r hIL!TI I ,. .,-. r _11 TflT (flIICLI(J11 tIIU l__L1t[1ilh1ILLCU IJV iitUI. ,i,1 I ,11rtI Q1(fl _i--,4 l-... -..1 L( FJ
I

.I-

.L

fly TICS1Tfl1 tC It) LII U1Ifl. LPL

4--

qrin

1II

,r,rtm AT I 1D\ I £LLLi1d1 VP.IflhIV T1TT11I11T--- - LI1C i-II'c/ i-J W1LFI .L-. ThtfijThIJ1t., LLI'I LIJJ) r,I I I I I t) ."rI Irtiu1
_,,
_.1.______

P

1,

HIU uiuecsii

£- L1 iri'ttri rr kflflen. Mrr) A .r' ±V11Ii O4 I'LLP.ILL IaLe,.
·

..4-1-. liii Y1Ti1(I TCI 411(1 I f'fllZffl I]tFI -eiivtiuucti WILIi UULa U.WJ-I,£ALJ -''- F'iP. ,J.L V r I fl A irn al i itiriiit 1._ I-.-& IJ1dU 111 U1 I 1-,i ¼tt.c lJtcI I 11I( T l-'l
----

UI

D.---1 3iL%.LW'.. 1r mIiria )JiTn Tflf I iniieii iai IU51U
-- --
F

i

4'-'

--

'JIL +i-.

$i.IIriri vv

i·1lP in Trlic 1r.i1nn

IeTlTt9v I F1IT1t LU I I Li Til__ riU1L LJLLIUI i ULLi1'i i1_4
A '4 I'iTK r UiL1. 3U1L 1 ,1( 1r'JV

1.TTI 1)1) It Z1ILc1

-t-.'i 1 ,17 .I1tl _r' .e11uJ.i. u(i,1(V%.- r%J,
--

f A (V1 A Q7 ITV1TiC $/t LU19OJJf

-, , a V. IJTIIIIi rt/IriIrIQ F'ir'II(Ig ,.rsni -- - I-___ -.11 I Itt I J IVIIVkPI L'i:rL nflI I-WY I S/ I' I

''

I' I 1 T - -- I-( I-I1Wr1TITIfl FL] '

--r11TI1Ie---

Wi ITflhilQTflfl

A EI I M7Z.}- (.IDU1Z. -- -- --' -- - - -

'.T' II ror I J.

:,-. A ii-i-wi ,P'fl1'fmner i--_, /tflL) III LIU .1LU. I.jjWLLiiO.. ----

-,;:-

Ifii I4.-\ /7 II
1

I

V

III A! ;j L47I..

I
A._...'
S

--

I . 7 - 1%I I ''
'_,

_( £I, 1, i-

)'i

I11flF rSfII1T

Case 1:04-cv-01258-SLR
FlU--iW WWW I I--7Flfl

Document 457-8

Filed 07/07/2006
..RIFlA1flAR1Fl

Page 37 of 37
T--IIJA

lii 7)nm W1fl P'lII

rnm--l(AFifll'JI1IU W IWIII WII lb'W II AP ---- PAl fl Al Tfl III II I

P FIfli Iflfl

--7Ji

A

kA.k..ii - --. IVI &L ri II J £&'. I-- --IL I-- I.-I I Y VNIJ JI. IIU kA I IFJIVIA

-

I

C I TCI fAI 1I-(]INIM. LJ I
"I..,

TLPHON NO

'7tI--47Q

'i

D1EcT FAsIMtL N01 -i- 1

J4MlI; LIycJ4'""
--

II -- t-- _.t a.. -- I IIlIV1 11 I --.",-- ri -- -- ·r L. -- E...I I I II · '--I IVI II I··' . II
--

r-I Ir II
II II II
-----II

--.--.--------------,--.----.F1 IlRI TH FDLLcWINc

.PtIIFCV 1
,-- ·1 -- -- --

11JUl11

0.. iTh L Ti fl)T1 LUi ILL L( LI UL.eIIcPT T fl I_I_r

...-.IIJ 1.
lW'.
--

IFV111 ( Mi

LATE?

JLL1LLL 1 c iiiii iJ.

I _hL Ill
U,l(j

AC5IMtL NO,

/i1 /IItl
______________________

rILtI11- LL4YII LJ
NC

i'
_r ______ ______ /f L L. 77

LL.+U+U

I fFAI. NUME I I--AIr INL.L.UIJIN
I
1

I 1,

_ --. I INtOI1NAIILPN. It TLflJ #tNr_ N%,I nP. lIMIP.flL,P.L# rP. .IrjLd,I
1

I fl! r'..aI,II.,p,

--- -- --. I COPYING--CI' hI- tt,bIMlLt lb blKlll! rN'.rll'l.I-'. 'r I¾I! nIVnüV4S'
---- -- --- -- ---- I ILEPHONE ArID RETURN TP1 RINAI.--AIMILE T U AT Trr I YCII IWLI IN N9IN LIE AND RETURNING TH AOIMIL. TO U.
-

'ILlI
-

A MAY 41WT.IW LALI.Y IVIL APcIOR ONFIDENTAL __· _ C vrl I ·_%·%·_ ,.--.'--.--. ,a,WIRIP. 'Fl-la Ally rHSSFMINATIOW nl,vflrlreU'rIOpi I.arct,v ____ --1L?I %.j --!.--.

--

I_%·.

OR

IMñAI V JtYVIWV IIS SY ---- --. flW

I I I I

I_

-I- S%dLtIJ'.# .J tA1fr''SS'."..,

IJIA

IttthI1