Free Deposition Designations - District Court of Delaware - Delaware

Case 1:04-cv-01282-JJF

Document 188-2

Filed 10/13/2006

Page 1 of 40

Designations and objections to AES-PR Witness Deposition Testimony

Deponent's Name: Gary Bates

ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Objections to ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Counter-Designations

ALSTOM's Objection to AESPR's Counter-Designations

16:18-22 16: 23-25 17: 1-2 17:3-5 19: 6-14 19:15-25 20:1-6 35: 8-12, 14-17, 24-25 35:18-23 36: 1, 5, 22-25 36:6-13, 16-21 37:1-4 37: 38: 5-6, 8-13, 15-17, 20-21 20-22 38:7-10 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 48: 20-25 49: 1-4 49:11-23 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 50: 10-13 50:24-25 51:1-13 51: 14-19, 21-22, 25 52: 1-6, 9-16, 19-25 As to 52:13, FRE 401 & FRE 402 As to 37:12-13, 15-17, 20, FRE 403

Case 1:04-cv-01282-JJF

Document 188-2

Filed 10/13/2006

Page 2 of 40

ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Objections to ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Counter-Designations

ALSTOM's Objection to AESPR's Counter-Designations

53: 1-3, 5-6

65: 2-4, 6-11, 13-14 65:19-25 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 66:1-10 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 80: 22-24 80:25 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 1-4 13-19 17-23 4-14 6-7, 9-16, 18-21, 86: 24-25 87: 1-4 87:5-9 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 95: 23-25 96: 1-16, 23-25 96:17-19, 22 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 97: 1-7, 9-13 97:14-25 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 98:1, 4-7, 10-23 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 99: 7-25 100: 1-2, 5-9 81: 82: 84: 85:

Case 1:04-cv-01282-JJF

Document 188-2

Filed 10/13/2006

Page 3 of 40

ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Objections to ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Counter-Designations

ALSTOM's Objection to AESPR's Counter-Designations

100:10-15, 17-25 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 101:1, 3-6, 9-11 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 101: 12-17 102:5-8, 12-17, 24-25 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 103:1-3 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 105: 9-10, 13-21 116:23-25 117:1-10 123:25 124:1, 3-6 126:18-25 127:1-21 133: 134: 136: 137: 23-25 1-3, 5-8, 11-12 13-25 1-24 140:3-7, 9 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 142: 11-13, 16-19, 22 142:23-25 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 143:2-3 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 143: 4-25 144: 1-25 145: 1-2, 5-9, 13 145:11 146: 2-3, 5-8 151: 1-5, 7-10, 12-17

Case 1:04-cv-01282-JJF

Document 188-2

Filed 10/13/2006

Page 4 of 40

ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Objections to ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Counter-Designations

ALSTOM's Objection to AESPR's Counter-Designations

151:18, 20-22 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 158: 159: 160: 162: 163: 2-8, 10-13, 16-22, 24-25 1-12, 14-17, 19-25 1-24 19-25 1-2, 4-5 163:13-16, 19-25 164:1 164: 165: 166: 167: 169: 174: 175: 176: 177: 178: 184: 185: 200: 201: 12-14 7-8, 10-25 1-5, 16-25 1-5, 9-19, 21-25 168:1-14, 16-18 20-22, 24-25 25 1-4 17-22, 24-25 1-7, 9-13, 19-21, 24-25 1-2, 5-7 15-25 1-2, 4-6 23-24 1-3, 5, 11-14 203:5-8

Case 1:04-cv-01282-JJF

Document 188-2

Filed 10/13/2006

Page 5 of 40

Deponent's Name: Alan Dyer

ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Objections to ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Counter-Designations

ALSTOM's Objection to AESPR's CounterDesignations

6:5-10 7: 19-21, 24-25 8: 1-4, 7-9 8:11, 15-19, 21-25 9:1-3 13:3-6 15: 21-23 16: 1-2 20: 5-16, 19-22 21:7-11, 18-24 26:24-25 27:1-4 27: 5-11 39: 5-8, 11-16, 19-21 As to 39:6-8, 11-13, FRE 401, FRE 402, & FRE 602 (no personal knowledge) 39:23-25 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 40:1-2 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 44: 6-10, 13-17, 20-22 45:6-25 46:1-9, 20-23 47:2-9 49:2-4, 8-11 49: 17-24 50: 3-11, 14-16 51: 10-11, 14-25 52: 1-3, 6-8 As to 49:17-19, FRE 401, FRE 402, & FRE 403 Objection to 21:7-11 Move to Strike as NonResponsive FRE 403 and 611(a)

Case 1:04-cv-01282-JJF

Document 188-2

Filed 10/13/2006

Page 6 of 40

ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Objections to ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Counter-Designations

ALSTOM's Objection to AESPR's CounterDesignations

54: 55: 56: 57: 58: 73: 74:

21-25 1-4, 13-17, 21-23 1-24, 25 1, 4-14, 17-24 1-13 23-25 1-2 75:21-22 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 76:2-6 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 79:18-21, 25 80:1-3, 17-19, 23-24 Objection, Move to Strike 80:17-19 and 2324 as Non-Responsive FRE 403 and 611(a) Objection, Move to Strike as NonResponsive FRE 403 and 611(a) Objection, Move to Strike as NonResponsive FRE 403 and 611(a)

86: 103: 104: 105: 109: 110: 111: 112:

2-8 19-22 1-8 12-15 12-25 1-21, 24-25 3-8, 11-19, 22-25 1-10 6-9, 12-15, 22, 23118: 25 118:17-21 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 119: 1, 4-6 119:8-22 120: 5-6, 9-18, 23-25 121: 3-6, 9-25 123: 9-12, 15-19

Case 1:04-cv-01282-JJF

Document 188-2

Filed 10/13/2006

Page 7 of 40

ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Objections to ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Counter-Designations

ALSTOM's Objection to AESPR's CounterDesignations

123:20-21 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 124:2-11 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 125: 126: 128: 129: 130: 131: 132: 133: 16-20, 24-25 1-2 19-25 1, 5-25 1-6, 9-22 1-4, 16-20, 24-25 1-3, 6-15, 18-25 1-4, 8-10 134:2-3, 7-8, 23-25 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 135:1-7 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 135: 138: 141: 142: 8-10, 13-16 8-19, 22-24 25 1-3, 6-8 172:22-24 173:4, 6, 10-11, 13-15 188: 5-9, 13-14 189: 23-25 189:12-14, 19-22 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4))

190: 1-2 239: 11-15, 18-20 242: 243: 249: 250: 22-25 1-7 14-18, 22-25 1-8, 14-25 FRE 602 (no personal knowledge), FRE 801, & FRE 802

Case 1:04-cv-01282-JJF

Document 188-2

Filed 10/13/2006

Page 8 of 40

ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Objections to ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Counter-Designations

ALSTOM's Objection to AESPR's CounterDesignations

251: 1-12, 15-22 252: 1-5, 20-21 252:7-12 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 253: 1-2 266:9-14 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 267:14-16, 20-24 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 268: 1-4, 8-18 268:19-25 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 269: 1-25 270: 1-9 270:16-21 270:22-23 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 271:4-5 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 271:7-8, 12-14 293:19-25 294:5-6, 8-12, 23-25 295:1-3, 7, 12-19 Lack of Personal Knowledge FRE 602 Opinion by Lay Witness FRE 701

Case 1:04-cv-01282-JJF

Document 188-2

Filed 10/13/2006

Page 9 of 40

Deponent's Name: Alan Dyer 30(b)(6) 1-18-06

ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Objections to ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Counter-Designations

ALSTOM's Objection to AESPR's Counter-Designations

65:16-18 73:17-20, 24-25 Objection, Move to Strike as NonResponse FRE 403, 611(a) Objection, Move to Strike as NonResponse FRE 403, 611(a) Objection, Move to Strike as NonResponse FRE 403, 611(a) Objection, Move to Strike as NonResponse FRE 403, 611(a) Objection, Move to Strike as NonResponse FRE 403, 611(a)

74:1-3, 13-16, 24-25

75:2, 7-14

79:9-25

80:1-3 81:3-4, 9-12 82:3-9 85:15-25 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 86: 20-21, 24-25 87: 1-2 87:4-5, 9-15, 17-25 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 88: 8-11, 14-18 88: 24-25 88:20-23 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 89:24-25 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4))

Objection, Move to Strike as NonResponse FRE 403, 611(a)

89: 1-7, 19-22

Case 1:04-cv-01282-JJF

Document 188-2

Filed 10/13/2006

Page 10 of 40

ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Objections to ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Counter-Designations

ALSTOM's Objection to AESPR's Counter-Designations

90:4-5, 14-15, 19-21 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 91:13-15, 19-24 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 92:2-4, 11-14 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 92: 15-20, 24-25 93: 1 93:25 Objection, Move to Strike as NonResponse FRE 403, 611(a) Objection, Move to Strike as NonResponse FRE 403, 611(a) Objection, Move to Strike as NonResponse FRE 403, 611(a) Objection, Move to Strike as NonResponse FRE 403, 611(a) Objection, Move to Strike as NonResponse FRE 403, 611(a)

94:1-13

99:11-13, 17-23 7-10, 14-15, 16, 2225 102: 1-4 103: 22-24 101: 103:25 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 104:1-8, 16-18 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 104: 19-25 105: 1-8, 11-12 106:16-25 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) As to 104:19-23, FRE 401 & FRE 402

Best Evidence and Cumulative FRE 403 and 611(a)

Case 1:04-cv-01282-JJF

Document 188-2

Filed 10/13/2006

Page 11 of 40

ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Objections to ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Counter-Designations

ALSTOM's Objection to AESPR's Counter-Designations

107:1-2, 6-8 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 108: 7-12, 15-21 109: 11-14, 20-21 109:23-25 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 110:1-8 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 124: 16-19 125: 16-18, 21-24 126: 1-21 127: 1-10, 15-18 128: 129: 130: 131: 132: 133: 138: 139: 10-16, 19-25 1-4, 7-15, 21-24 1-4, 7-11 13-25 1-5, 8-16, 23-25 1, 4-7 19-25 1-4, 7-10 139:11-13, 15-17 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 144: 21-25 151:15-23 152: 23-24 153: 3-8 154: 1-6, 25 155: 1 162: 25 163: 1-4 154:7-9, 13-14, 18-21 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) As to 126:14-21, FRE 401 & FRE 402 As to 127:1-2, FRE 401 & FRE 402

Best Evidence and Cumulative FRE 403 and 611(a)

Case 1:04-cv-01282-JJF

Document 188-2

Filed 10/13/2006

Page 12 of 40

ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Objections to ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Counter-Designations

ALSTOM's Objection to AESPR's Counter-Designations

163:5-23 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) Objection to 167:15-18 Form of the Question 167:15-18, 23-25 Objection and move to Strike 167:23-25 as Non-Responsive FRE 403 and 611(a) Objection and move to Strike as NonResponsive FRE 403 and 611(a)

168:1-11 169: 16-25 170: 1-5, 8-9, 14

170:6-7, 16-25 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4))

171:1 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4))

Objection, Move to Strike as NonResponsive; Hearsay; Lack of Personal Knowledge FRE 403, 602, 611(a), 802 Objection, Move to Strike as NonResponsive; Hearsay; Lack of Personal Knowledge FRE 403, 602, 611(a), 802

171: 9-14 174: 23-25 175: 1-4, 8-12, 15-16 175:18-24 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 176: 18-25 177: 1-23 178: 1-6, 14-16 178:8-11 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 183: 10-15, 24-25 Lack of Personal Knowledge FRE 602 Lack of Personal Knowledge FRE 602

Case 1:04-cv-01282-JJF

Document 188-2

Filed 10/13/2006

Page 13 of 40

ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Objections to ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Counter-Designations

ALSTOM's Objection to AESPR's Counter-Designations

184: 185: 186: 187: 188:

1-2, 6-12, 24-25 1-6, 10-11 21-25 1-7, 22-24 4-5, 17-19, 23-25 As to 189:16, 24-25, FRE 401, FRE 402, & FRE 403 As to 190:1-6, FRE 401, FRE 402, & FRE 403 As to 192:15-16 FRE 401, FRE 402, & FRE 403

189: 1-16, 24-25

190: 1-6, 16-23 191: 2-19, 24-25 192: 1-8, 11-25 193: 1-9 194: 17-25 195: 1-23

223:22-25 224: 1-3, 7-25 224:5-6 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 225:1-10 230: 231: 232: 235: 236: 241: 24-25 1-3, 8-11 8-11, 14-18 16-25 1-2, 16-22 240:11-25 12-22 241:1-11 Move to Strike Testimony by Counsel; Lack of Foundation FRE 603, 611(a)

242: 10-25 243: 1-4, 8-13 246: 21-23

Case 1:04-cv-01282-JJF

Document 188-2

Filed 10/13/2006

Page 14 of 40

ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Objections to ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Counter-Designations

ALSTOM's Objection to AESPR's Counter-Designations

247: 7-22

As to 247:15-16, FRE 401 & FRE 402. As to 247:21-22, FRE 401, FRE 402, FRE 403, & FRE 501 As to 248:8-10, 15-17, 22-24, FRE 401, FRE 402, FRE 403, & FRE 501

248: 8-10, 14-17, 22-24 249: 1-5, 9-13, 17-25 250: 1-10, 13-17, 21-25 251: 1-8, 24-25 252: 1-3, 15-25

As to 252:23-25, FRE 401, FRE 402, & FRE 403 252:4-5, 9-14 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4))

253: 11-15, 18-21

As to 253:11-12, FRE 401, FRE 402, & FRE 403

Case 1:04-cv-01282-JJF

Document 188-2

Filed 10/13/2006

Page 15 of 40

Deponent's Name: Alan Dyer 30(b)(6) 3-9-06
ALSTOM's Designations AES-PR's Objections to ALSTOM's Designations AES-PR's Counter-Designations ALSTOM's Objection to AESPR's Counter-Designations

11: 1-4 12:3-11 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 13: 14: 17: 18: 19: 20: 21: 18-25 1-4 16-19, 22-25 1-3 6-11, 19-22 1-16, 19-25 3-16 22:21-25 23:1-3 25: 5-12, 19-25 26: 1-16 27:1-11 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 27: 12-23 28: 14-24 29: 3-14 30:11-19 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 31: 32: 33: 34: 10-22 1-18 22-24 3-9 36:23-25 37:1-13, 17, 19-25 38:1-3, 11-13, 17-18 43: 4-11 43: 16-25 44:1-4 Irrelevant FRE 402 Irrelevant FRE 402 Objection to 38:11-13 and 38:17-18 ­ Form of the question: Leading FRE 611(c)

Case 1:04-cv-01282-JJF

Document 188-2

Filed 10/13/2006

Page 16 of 40

Deponent's Name: Tracy Jarvis

ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Objections to ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Counter-Designations

ALSTOM's Objection to AESPR's Counter-Designations

7:10-11 8:17-25 9:1-3 11:4-19 13:12-25 14:1-25 15:1-9 17: 64: 65: 68: 19-24 14-25 1-4, 5-8 8-22 68:23-25 69:1-3, 19-21 70:5-6 70: 71: 83: 84: 87: 88: 89: 90: 91: 97: 98: 99: 101: 111: 116: 7-16 1-14, 15-18 12-21, 22-25 1-6 12-14, 17-25 1-4, 7-12, 15-18, 21-25 1-4 15-25 1-11 15-25 1-8, 18-25 1-2, 4 2-13, 14-18 7-18, 19-23 2-17

98:9-17

119:22-25 120:7-13, 20-25 121:1-6 121: 19-22, 24-25 122: 1-3, 6-8, 19-25

Case 1:04-cv-01282-JJF

Document 188-2

Filed 10/13/2006

Page 17 of 40

ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Objections to ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Counter-Designations

ALSTOM's Objection to AESPR's Counter-Designations

123: 130: 139: 140: 141: 142: 148: 149: 150: 158: 159: 161: 162: 163: 164: 165: 166: 174: 175: 176: 177: 178: 180:

1-4, 5-10, 18-21 5-22 17-21 4-10, 13-14 21-25 1-6 5-11, 14-17 25 1-4, 7-10, 13-16, 19 25 1, 5-6 18-25 1-10 25 1-2, 6-25 1-13, 18-25 1-4, 9-12 166:5-8 14-25 1-7 7-9, 13-14 12-25 1-4 12-20 180:21-23, 25 181:1-12

181: 182: 183: 184:

13-17, 20-24 4-10 15-17, 23-25 1-5

Case 1:04-cv-01282-JJF

Document 188-2

Filed 10/13/2006

Page 18 of 40

Deponent's Name: Ron McParland

ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Objections to ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Counter-Designations

ALSTOM's Objection to AESPR's Counter-Designations

12: 10-11, 14-17 12:19-22 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 13:1, 5-8 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 18:9-12, 14-15 19:5-9 19:18-19, 22 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 20:1, 3, 6-7 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 27:13-18 28:18-22 29:2-3, 5-7 30:11-14 34:2-12, 17-22 35:1-2 37:3-10, 21-22 38:1-8 45:13-15, 18-20, 22 46:1-7 48:19-22 57:16-18, 20-22 58:1 61: 16-21 63:17-21 64:8-21 65:1-5 81: 82: 83: 84: 85: 12-22 1-6 16-22 1-2, 5-17 5-6, 9-13, 16-22

Case 1:04-cv-01282-JJF

Document 188-2

Filed 10/13/2006

Page 19 of 40

ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Objections to ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Counter-Designations

ALSTOM's Objection to AESPR's Counter-Designations

86: 1-3, 6-10, 13-21 3-4, 6-8, 11-15, 1887: 22 88: 1-5, 7-9

As to 87:8, 11, FRE 401, FRE 402 93:17-19, 21-22 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 96:13-19, 21-22 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 97:1, 3-4, 6, 10, 12-14, 18, 21-22 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4))

98: 1-3, 5-7, 9-22

99: 1-10, 12-22

100: 1-8 103:4-5, 8-10, 12-19 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 106: 17-20 107: 1-13 144:17-18, 22 145:1, 3-4 145: 146: 147: 148: 149: 150: 6-7, 9-22 1-3, 5-11, 14-22 1-6, 9-17, 19-22 1-3, 6-22 1-18, 20-22 1-18, 21-22

Case 1:04-cv-01282-JJF

Document 188-2

Filed 10/13/2006

Page 20 of 40

ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Objections to ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Counter-Designations

ALSTOM's Objection to AESPR's Counter-Designations

151:

1-2, 4-12, 15-18, 21-22

152: 1-9, 12-22 153: 154: 155: 156: 157: 158: 159: 160: 161: 162: 163: 164: 1-18, 21-22 1-4, 7-12, 15-22 1-22 3-4 4-7 18-22 1-22 1-11, 14-22 1-7, 9-16, 18-22 1-22 1-16, 18-22 3-14, 17-20, 22

As to 151:10-12, 15-18, 21-22, FRE 602 (no personal knowledge, see 151:10 - 152:13) As to 152:1, 6-9, 12-13, FRE 602 (no personal knowledge, see 151:10 - 152:13)

165: 1-22

As to 165:17-22, FRE 401, FRE 402, FRE 602 (no personal knowledge, see 165:20 - 166:5, 167:16-17) FRE 602 (no personal knowledge, see 165:20 - 166:5, 167:16-17) As to 167:1-6, 7-14, 16-19, 22, FRE 602 (no personal knowledge, see 165:20 - 166:5, 167:16-17)

166: 1-22

167: 1-9, 12-19, 22

168:

1-3, 6-11, 14-17, 20-22 As to 169:11-22, FRE 602 (no personal knowledge, see 165:20 - 166:5, 167:16-17)

169: 1-22

Case 1:04-cv-01282-JJF

Document 188-2

Filed 10/13/2006

Page 21 of 40

ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Objections to ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Counter-Designations

ALSTOM's Objection to AESPR's Counter-Designations

170: 1-6, 8-22 171: 172: 183: 184: 185: 199: 200: 201: 202: 209: 210: 211: 212: 213: 214: 1-22 1-6, 8-10, 13 3-22 1-10, 13-22 1, 9-11 20-22 1-14, 17 (Ending with the phrase "I believe it is.") 1-3, 6-12, 15-22 1-2, 5-6 18-22 1-7, 10-22 1-8, 10-21 1-22 1-22 1-5, 8-10

As to 170:1-9, FRE 602 (no personal knowledge, see 169:1619)

200:17-22 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4))

217:8-22 218:1-2 218: 237 : 3, 5-6 236:3-14, 17-20, 22 8-9, 11-14 237:1-2, 4-6

Case 1:04-cv-01282-JJF

Document 188-2

Filed 10/13/2006

Page 22 of 40

Deponent's Name: Elias Sostre

ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Objections to ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Counter-Designations

ALSTOM's Objection to AESPR's Counter-Designations

13:22-25 14:1-20 17:2-24 18:2-13 18: 15-23 19: 2-6, 10-25 20: 1-18 22:23-24 23:5-10, 12-13, 20-23 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 37: 38: 43: 44: 47: 6-25 1-8, 12-18 18-25 1 3-4, 7-9, 20-21 47:11-12 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 48: 12-13 72:18-19, 23, 25 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 73:1-25 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 74:1-5, 22-23 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 74: 6-13, 17 75:2-3 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 80:4-14, 17-20 82: 4-5, 8-15, 18-25 83: 1, 11-16, 17-25 1-5, 8-13, 16-20, 84: 23-25

Case 1:04-cv-01282-JJF

Document 188-2

Filed 10/13/2006

Page 23 of 40

ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Objections to ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Counter-Designations

ALSTOM's Objection to AESPR's Counter-Designations

85: 1-6, 15-25 86: 1-8 89:20-25 90:1-7 91: 16-18, 22-25 92: 1 FRE 403 (confusion as to temporal scope of question) FRE 403 92:9-10, 15-17 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 94: 7-9, 12-19 95: 1-7 102: 18-20, 23-24 103: 1-6, 10-12 103:14-16, 21-25 104:2-3, 7-9, 11-15 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 106: 18-21, 24-25 107: 1-2, 10-13 109: 16-20 FRE 602 (no personal knowledge see 109:2124) 109:21-24 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 120: 1-9, 20-25 121: 1-2 133:7-8, 21-23 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 133: 24-25 134: 1-25 135: 1-7 137:15-16, 20-22, 2425 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) As to 120:7-9, FRE 401 Hearsay FRE 802 Hearsay FRE 802

Case 1:04-cv-01282-JJF

Document 188-2

Filed 10/13/2006

Page 24 of 40

ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Objections to ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Counter-Designations

ALSTOM's Objection to AESPR's Counter-Designations

138:1-4 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 140:8-20 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 157: 6-16, 19-22 158: 1-6, 23-24 As to 158:23-24 FRE 403 158:7-8, 13-16 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 159:9-10, 16-18 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 159: 19-25 160: 1-3, 6-14, 17-24 161: 3-5 As to 160:21-24, FRE 403 FRE 403 165:2-3, 7-11, 20-25 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 165: 12-19 166: 7-23 167: 2-3, 17-19, 22-23 167:6-11 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 168: 2-5, 9-10 174: 175: 176: 177: 12-13, 18-24 3-6, 23-25 1-4, 7-10, 22-25 1-18, 21-24 177:25 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) Objection, Move to Strike as NonResponsive FRE 403, 611(a) FRE 403 172:1-2, 7-9

Case 1:04-cv-01282-JJF

Document 188-2

Filed 10/13/2006

Page 25 of 40

ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Objections to ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Counter-Designations

ALSTOM's Objection to AESPR's Counter-Designations

178:1-5 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 178: 11-15, 21-25 179: 1-8 179:15-25 180:10-12, 16-19, 2123 181:17-25 182:1 193:19-23 218:4-9 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 218: 20-23 219: 1-7, 11-17, 20-25 220: 3-5 248:13-20, 25

Objection, Move to Strike as NonResponsive FRE 403, 611(a)

182: 2-6, 9-10 183: 3-13

249:2-10

Objection to Form: Leading FRE 611(c) Objection because of Previous Improper Question FRE 611(c)

Case 1:04-cv-01282-JJF

Document 188-2

Filed 10/13/2006

Page 26 of 40

Deponent's Name: Paul Stinson

ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Objections to ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Counter-Designations

ALSTOM's Objection to AESPR's Counter-Designations

40: 21-24 41: 1-23 3-8, 11-17, 19-21, 42: 24 As to 45: 1-2, 5-11, FRE 401, FRE 403, & FRE 602 (no personal knowledge see 43:23 44:24) 47: 18-24 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 48: 1-7, 9-11 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 49: 7-9, 11, 13-15 77: 14-24 78: 1-3 79:21-24 80:1-12 81: 82: 83: 85: 86: 87: 90: 2-18, 19-24 2, 24 1-18, 19-23 9-24 1-4 5-15 23-24 92:2-14 Opinion Testimony by Lay Witness ­ refer to 105:23 ­ 106:7 FRE 701 Opinion Testimony by Lay Witness ­ refer to 105:23 ­ 106:7 FRE 701

45: 1-2, 5-13, 15-23

46: 1-2

93:17-24

Case 1:04-cv-01282-JJF

Document 188-2

Filed 10/13/2006

Page 27 of 40

ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Objections to ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Counter-Designations

ALSTOM's Objection to AESPR's Counter-Designations

94:1, 4-9, 12-18

Opinion Testimony by Lay Witness ­ refer to 105:23 ­ 106:7 FRE 701

104: 8-10, 13-21, 24 105: 1-3, 23-24 106: 4-7 110:14-20 121:10-24 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 122:3-8 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 122: 9-22 138:19-24 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 139:1 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 139: 140: 141: 142: 2-24 1-18, 22-24 1-11, 15-24 1-16, 145:11-13, 17-24 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 146:1-3 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 146: 19-24 147: 1-3 As to 148:14-16, 1920, FRE 602 (no personal knowledge see 13:6-8, 148:19-20) 149:5-9 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 157: 20-22 Lack of Personal Knowledge FRE 602

148: 4-9, 12-16, 19-20

Case 1:04-cv-01282-JJF

Document 188-2

Filed 10/13/2006

Page 28 of 40

ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Objections to ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Counter-Designations

ALSTOM's Objection to AESPR's Counter-Designations

158: 2-9 162: 12-24 1-2, 5-8, 15-17, 19163: 21, 24 164: 1-10, 13-14 165:1-13 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 166: 167: 168: 169: 170: 171: 172: 173: 174: 3-24 1-3, 5-24 1-22 1-11, 14-18, 20-24 1-8, 11-17, 19-24 1-5, 14-24 1-6, 8-24 1-4, 7-24 1, 4-16, 19-21 174:22-24 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 175:2-24 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 176:1-5, 9-17, 20-24 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 177:1-4 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 177: 178: 179: 180: 5-24 1-9, 14-24 1-24 1-10, 12-24 1, 13 (starting with 181: "The plant . . .")-17, 19-24 182: 1-2 184: 5-8, 12-24 As to 184:12-15, 1923, FRE 401 Lack of Personal Knowledge FRE 602 and 802 Lack of Personal Knowledge FRE 602 and 802

181:13 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4))

Case 1:04-cv-01282-JJF

Document 188-2

Filed 10/13/2006

Page 29 of 40

ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Objections to ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Counter-Designations

ALSTOM's Objection to AESPR's Counter-Designations

185: 1-3 185:4-5, 10-17, 23-24 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 186:1-9 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 188:4-7, 11-17 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 193: 24 194: 1-2, 5-12, 14-24 195: 1-11, 14-23 As to 195:10-11, FRE 401 195:24 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 196:1-3, 7-14, 22-24 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 197:1-7 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 200:20-23 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 201:1-8, 10-18 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 203: 206: 207: 208: 209: 210: 215: 216: 217 218: 15-17, 20-23 11-24 1-12 10-24 1-24 1-6, 10-19, 22-23 15-21, 23 2-13, 16-24 1-24 1-5, 15-24 Objection, Move to Strike as NonResponsive FRE 403 and 611(a) Objection, Move to Strike as NonResponsive FRE 403 and 611(a)

Case 1:04-cv-01282-JJF

Document 188-2

Filed 10/13/2006

Page 30 of 40

ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Objections to ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Counter-Designations

ALSTOM's Objection to AESPR's Counter-Designations

219: 1-3, 5-24 220: 1-3 221: 15-18, 20-21 222:4-7 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 223: 224: 225: 226: 20-24 1-11, 13-24 1-24 1-11, 15-23

227: 6-9 As to 230:17-24, FRE 801 & FRE 802 As to 230: 22-24, FRE 602 (no personal knowledge see 230:22 231:11) FRE 602 (no personal knowledge see 230:22 231:11), FRE 801, & FRE 802 233:13-21 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 234: 235: 238: 239: 240: 241: 242: 243: 245: 246: 9-12, 15-24 1-2, 4-7 15-19 9-11, 14-21, 23-24 1-3 9-24 1-24 1-4, 7-16 3-6, 8-24 2-9 259:16-24 260:1-3, 5-7

230: 1-24

231: 3-5

Case 1:04-cv-01282-JJF

Document 188-2

Filed 10/13/2006

Page 31 of 40

ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Objections to ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Counter-Designations

ALSTOM's Objection to AESPR's Counter-Designations

264:10-13, 17-24

265:1-14

Opinion Testimony by Lay Witness ­ refer to 105:23 ­ 106:7 FRE 701 Opinion Testimony by Lay Witness ­ refer to 105:23 ­ 106:7 FRE 701

Case 1:04-cv-01282-JJF

Document 188-2

Filed 10/13/2006

Page 32 of 40

Deponent's Name: David Stone 30(b)(6)

ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Objections to ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Counter-Designations

ALSTOM's Objection to AESPR's Counter-Designations

22:18-21 23:1-25 24:1-8 29: 5-8, 12-17, 21-24 30: 1-4, 7-10, 13-22 31: 1-7, 12-20 32: 1-6 As to 30:2-22, FRE 403 FRE 403 FRE 403 FRE 403 33:11-15, 19-21, 23-25 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 34:1-3, 18-25 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 35: 17-25 36: 1-2, 13-23 37: 1-6, 9-22 38: 1-25 39: 1-2, 3-6, 15-21 40: 11-13, 16-25 41: 1-15, 18-21 50: 14-24 51: 3-5, 6-23 52:5-7, 12-15 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 53: 1-5, 8-14 As to 50:22-24, FRE 401, FRE 402, & FRE 403

Case 1:04-cv-01282-JJF

Document 188-2

Filed 10/13/2006

Page 33 of 40

ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Objections to ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Counter-Designations

ALSTOM's Objection to AESPR's Counter-Designations

54: 55: 56: 57: 58: 59: 60:

7-13, 16-25 1-2, 5-23 5-7 18-20, 23-25 1-7, 11-13 7-22 1-3 FRE 602 (no personal knowledge see 59:1316; 62:8-21) 66:20-24 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4))

62: 8-11, 15-21 66: 1-5, 9-11

67: 68: 69: 70: 71:

15-25 4-7, 10-22 1-8, 12-22 1-8, 11-19, 20-23 2-6 As to 72:23-25, FRE 602 (no personal knowledge see 72:23 73:2) FRE 602 (no personal knowledge see 72:23 73:2) FRE 602 (no personal knowledge see 72:23 73:2) As to 75:1-4, FRE 602 (no personal knowledge see 72:23 73:2)

72: 2-4, 8-13, 17-25

73: 1-18, 21-25

74: 1-21

75: 1-8, 17-20 76: 77: 78: 79: 18-22 1-13, 16-25 1-6 9-11, 15-19

90: 21-24

FRE 602 (outside scope of Rule 30(b)(6) notice)

Case 1:04-cv-01282-JJF

Document 188-2

Filed 10/13/2006

Page 34 of 40

ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Objections to ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Counter-Designations

ALSTOM's Objection to AESPR's Counter-Designations

91: 4-8, 11-17, 22-25 92: 1-2, 5-7 110: 21-24 111: 3-10

As to 91:11-17, FRE 602 (outside scope of Rule 30(b)(6) notice)

134:21-22 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 135:2-4 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 136: 145: 146: 147: 5-9 7-17, 18-25 1-2, 5-7, 19-25 1-2, 5-7 FRE 602 (no personal knowledge see 4:7-8; calls for legal conclusion) FRE 602 (no personal knowledge see 4:7-8; calls for legal conclusion) FRE 602 (no personal knowledge see 4:7-8; calls for legal conclusion) 153:1-3 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 153: 154: 163: 164: 169: 16-20, 24-25 1-2 4-9, 12-25 1-16 6-7, 10-13 169:15-25 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) Objection, Move to Strike as NonResponsive FRE 403, 611(a)

149: 21-24

150: 3-11, 14-24

151: 3-5 152: 18-19, 23-25

Case 1:04-cv-01282-JJF

Document 188-2

Filed 10/13/2006

Page 35 of 40

ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Objections to ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Counter-Designations

ALSTOM's Objection to AESPR's Counter-Designations

170:1-3 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 190: 19-21, 24-25 191: 1-8, 14-17 191:9-13 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 207: 208: 209: 212: 218: 18-21, 24-25 1-3 9-16 14-25 6-9, 12-13 218:15, 19, 23 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 220: 1-25 221: 1-6, 9-16, 19-25 222: 1-6 227: 228: 232: 233: 12-15, 18-25 1-4 6-21, 24-25 1-12 257:4-12 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 269: 270: 272: 309: 325: 326: 20-23 1-17 5-9, 13-20 10-15, 20-25 2-11, 14-23 9-11, 14-18 327:9-20 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4))

Objection, Move to Strike as NonResponsive FRE 403, 611(a)

Objection, Move to Strike as NonResponsive FRE 403, 611(a)

Case 1:04-cv-01282-JJF

Document 188-2

Filed 10/13/2006

Page 36 of 40

ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Objections to ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Counter-Designations

ALSTOM's Objection to AESPR's Counter-Designations

332: 333: 334: 336:

22-25 4-8 12-15, 18-20 10-20, 24-25

337: 1 343: 1-2, 5-8, 24-25 344: 1-4, 13-15, 18-22 350:16-18, 22-24 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) Objection to Form: Leading FRE 611(c) Hearsay FRE 802 In addition, Objection as to Form (Leading) to 351:18-20, 24-25 FRE 611(c) Hearsay, Objection as to Form (Leading) FRE 611(c) and 802 Hearsay FRE 802

351:2-20, 24-25

352:1-3 355:8-10, 14-16 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 366: 1-11, 16-21 368: 20-25 FRE 401, FRE 402, FRE 403 FRE 401, FRE 402, FRE 403 As to 369:1-14, FRE 401, FRE 402, FRE 403 As to 369:15-16, FRE 401, FRE 402, FRE 403, FRE 601, FRE 602As to 370:14-24, FRE 401, FRE 402, FRE 403

369:

1-6, 9-14, 15-16, 17-25

370: 1-19, 22-24

Case 1:04-cv-01282-JJF

Document 188-2

Filed 10/13/2006

Page 37 of 40

Deponent Name: Doug Tomlin
ALSTOM's Designations AES-PR's Objections to ALSTOM's Designations AES-PR's Counter-Designations ALSTOM's Objection to AESPR's Counter-Designations

5:15-18 7:3-4 8:3-5 12:2-7 23: 17-24 1-3, 6, 13-15, 17-20, 24: 23 29: 10-12, 15-24 30:11-19

Irrelevant FRE 402 Irrelevant FRE 402 Irrelevant FRE 402

31:3-7 36:11-14, 16-25 37:1-25 38:1-8 43:24-25 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 44:1-8 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 46:2-5, 11-13, 16-18 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 47: 24-25 48: 3-4, 8-9, 12-25 50:3-11 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 50: 12-19, 22-25 51: 3-6, 15-17, 20-23 52: 1-5, 24-25 53: 1 As to 50:18-10, 22, FRE 403

Lack of personal knowledge ­ refer to 28:21 ­ 24, 29:10 ­ 24 FRE 602 Lack of personal knowledge ­ refer to 28:21 ­ 24, 29:10 ­ 24 FRE 602 Irrelevant FRE 402 Irrelevant FRE 402 Irrelevant FRE 402

Case 1:04-cv-01282-JJF

Document 188-2

Filed 10/13/2006

Page 38 of 40

ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Objections to ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Counter-Designations

ALSTOM's Objection to AESPR's Counter-Designations

73: 4-6, 8-13, 17-20

FRE 602 (no personal knowledge, see 63:21 64:2) 80:25 81:1-24

83: 12-17, 20-22, 24 91: 16-18, 21-25 92: 1 102: 24-25 103: 1, 4-7, 10-13, 16-23 104: 1

As to 83: 16-17, 21-24, FRE 401, FRE 402, & FRE 403

As to 103: 11-16, FRE 403

113:21-25 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 114:1-2 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 114: 3-4, 7-8, 10-20 115: 13-23 121:9-10, 25 122:1-11 125: 14-16, 18-22 126:4-5, 8-11 (Included per FRCP 32(a)(4)) 126: 19-20, 23-25 127: 1-2 129: 15-24 137:17-19, 22-25 138:1-25 Lack of personal knowledge; Opinion by lay witness FRE 602 701

139: 1-4, 7-9, 12-19

163: 7-13 164: 19-21, 24

Case 1:04-cv-01282-JJF

Document 188-2

Filed 10/13/2006

Page 39 of 40

ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Objections to ALSTOM's Designations

AES-PR's Counter-Designations

ALSTOM's Objection to AESPR's Counter-Designations

165: 5-10 176: 18-25 177: 1-5, 7-9, 12-14, 17

Case 1:04-cv-01282-JJF

Document 188-2

Filed 10/13/2006

Page 40 of 40