Document 5
Filed 07/10/2008
Page 1 of 3
1 2 3
4
STAGEY E. JAMES, Bar No. 185651 JUSTIN A. MORELLO, Bar No. 239250 LITTLER MENDELSON A Professional Corporation 501 W. Broadway, Suite 900 San Diego, CA 92101.3577 Telephone: 619.232.0441 Attorneys for Defendant SERVICE SOLUTIONS GROUP LLC
5 6 7 8 9
10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA CINDY KING FEINSTEIN, Plaintiff, Case No. 08CV1174 W(WMc) DEFENDANT SERVICE SOLUTIONS GROUP LLC'S NOTICE OF MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF'S COMPLAINT [F.R.C.P 8(A), 12(B)(6); 12(E)] Hearing Date: Time: Judge: August 11,2008 (No Oral Argument Required under Local Rule 7.1(d)(l)) Hon. Thomas J. Whelan
v.
SERVICE SOLUTIONS GROUP LLC; BARKERS FOOD MACHINERY SERVICE; FRANK HOLDING AG; and DOES 1-25, Defendants.
18
19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27
Complaint Filed: November 20,2007
28
LITTLER MENDELSON
A PHOFf IIIDHM COMOtl 501 W Bte»d**y
Su.it 900 Sin Diijc CA 92101 3577 619 232 0441
DEFENDANT'S NOTICE OF MOTION TO DISMISS
CASE NO. 08CV1174 W (WMc)
Case 3:08-cv-01174-W-WMC
1
Document 5
Filed 07/10/2008
Page 2 of 3
TO PLAINTIFF AND HER ATTORNEYS OF RECORD: PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that on August 11, 2008, or as soon thereafter as this matter may be heard in the courtroom of the Honorable Judge Thomas J. Whelan, United States District Court for the Southern District of California, located at 880 Front Street, San Diego, CA, 92101, Defendant will, and hereby respectfully moves the Court for an order dismissing this case under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 8(a), 12(b)(6), and 12(e). This Motion is based upon this Notice and Motion, the accompanying Memorandum of Points and Authorities, the attached copy of Plaintiff s Complaint (marked as Exhibit 1), and the declaration of Justin A. Morello. WHEREFORE, it is respectfully requested that the Court grant Defendant's Motion to Dismiss Plaintiffs Complaint, and any other relief the Court should deem appropriate. Dated: July 10,2008 Respectfully submitted,
2 3 4 5 6 7
8 9
10 11
12 13 14 15 16 17 18
s/Justin A. Morello STAGEY E. JAMES JUSTIN A. MORELLO Attorneys for Defendant Email: [email protected]: [email protected]
Firmwide:85768347.1 046687.1149
19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28
LITTLER MENDELSON A P»OFflH01»l CotKHtMlON SOI W Bfoidwn Suila 100 Sin On jo CA 93101 3577 6)9 2 3 2 0 4 4 1
DEFENDANT'S NOTICE OF MOTION TO DISMISS
1.
CASE NO. 08CV1174 W (WMc)
Case 3:08-cv-01174-W-WMC
Document 5
Filed 07/10/2008
Page 3 of 3
1
2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
PROOF OF SERVICE BY MAIL I am employed in San Diego County, California. I am over the age of eighteen years and not a party to the within-entitled action. My business address is 501 W. Broadway, Suite 900, San Diego, California 92101.3577. I am readily familiar with this firm's practice for collection and processing of correspondence for mailing with the United States Postal Service. On July 10, 2008,1 placed with this firm at the above address for deposit with the United States Postal Service a true and correct copy of the within document(s): DEFENDANT SERVICE SOLUTIONS GROUP LLC'S NOTICE OF MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF'S COMPLAINT [F.R.C.P 8(A), 12(B)(6); 12(E)J DEFENDANT SERVICE SOLUTIONS GROUP LLC'S MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND AUTHORITIES IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF'S COMPLAINT [F.R.C.P 8(A), 12(B)(6); 12(E)] DECLARATION OF JUSTIN A. MORELLO IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT'S MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF'S COMPLAINT [F.R.C.P 8(A), 12(B)(6); 12(E)] in a sealed envelope, postage fully paid, addressed as follows:
10 11
12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28
LITTLER MENDELSON
501 H Brosdwiy Suilt 900 S*r> Diego. CA S Z t O t 3577 619 232 0441
Mary Elizabeth Bullock 3955 Faircross Place, #73 San Diego, CA 92115 619.677.4066 phone 619.727.4907 fax
Attorney for Plaintiff
Following ordinary business practices, the envelope was sealed and placed for collection and mailing on this date, and would, in the ordinary course of business, be deposited with the United States Postal Service on this date. I declare that I am employed in the office of a member of the bar of this court at whose direction the service was made. Executed on July 10, 2008, at San Diego, California.
KILSHA A. CASTRO
PROOF OF SERVICE
Firmwide:85841158.1 046687.1149
CASE NO. 08CV1174 W (WMc)
Case 3:08-cv-01174-W-WMC
Document 5-2
Filed 07/10/2008
Page 1 of 4
1
2 3 4 5 6 7
STAGEY E. JAMES, Bar No. 185651 JUSTIN A. MORELLO, Bar No. 239250 LITTLER MENDELSON A Professional Corporation 501 W. Broadway, Suite 900 San Diego, CA 92101.3577 Telephone: 619.232.0441 Attorneys for Defendant SERVICE SOLUTIONS GROUP LLC
8
9
10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27
v.
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA CINDY KING FEINSTEIN, Plaintiff, Case No. 08CV1174 W(WMc) DEFENDANT SERVICE SOLUTIONS GROUP LLC'S MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND AUTHORITIES IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF'S COMPLAINT [F.R.C.P 8(A), 12(B)(6); 12(E)] Hearing Date: Time: Judge: August 11,2008 (No Oral Argument Required under Local Rule 7.1(d)(l)) Hon. Thomas J. Whelan
SERVICE SOLUTIONS GROUP LLC; BARKERS FOOD MACHINERY SERVICE; FRANK HOLDING AG; and DOES 1-25, Defendants.
Complaint Filed: November 20,2007
28
LITTLER MENDELSON
A PROFESSIONAL CORPORATIOI
501 W Broidwiy
DEFENDANT'S NOTICE OF MOTION TO DISMISS
CASE NO. 08CV1174 W (WMc)
Case 3:08-cv-01174-W-WMC
Document 5-2
Filed 07/10/2008
Page 2 of 4
1
2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21
22
I.
INTRODUCTION Plaintiffs complaint must contain a short and plain statement of her claim showing
that she is entitled to relief.
At the bare minimum, the complaint must'contain some factual
allegations that put a Defendant on notice as to what it is being accused of and why it is being accused. The Complaint must contain sufficient specificity so that Defendant can frame a
responsive pleading. Through a form complaint used to allege a claim for breach of contract, Plaintiff checked a box in the form titled "other," and listed the title to seven or eight possible claims. She did not attach a statement of facts to support these listed titles and does not make any factual allegations in her complaint. Because Plaintiffs complaint contains no factual allegations, Plaintiff has not alleged sufficient facts to state a cognizable legal theory and her complaint should be dismissed under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12(b)(6). In the alternative, this Court should order Plaintiff to provide a more definite statement under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12(e). II. FACTS Through her complaint, Plaintiff has made no factual allegations. Declaration of Justin A. Morello ("Morello Decl."), f 2, Exhibit 1. Because no facts are alleged, it is impossible to determine what acts are at issue, who the actors are, and when the alleged acts occurred. On November 20, 2007 in the San Diego Superior Court, Plaintiff filed her form complaint. Morello Decl. If 3. The form complaint she filed is used in state court to allege a breach of contract. Morello Decl. If 4. Plaintiff does not allege a breach of contract. Morello Decl. TJ 5, Exh. 1. In the section of the form complaint that should be used to state causes of action, Plaintiff checked the box labeled "Other" and listed the following cause of action titles: "employment law, discrimination based on gender, wrongful termination, discriminatory discipline, sexual harassment hostile work environment violation of public policy." Morello Decl. ]f 6, Exh. 1. Through her complaint, Plaintiff does not allege any dates, times, people, places, or actions. Morello Decl. Tf 7, Exh. 1. She only lists cause of action titles. Under the section requesting a prayer for judgment, Plaintiff also checked boxes for undisclosed damages, interest on those damages at a rate of 10%
///
DEFENDANT'S NOTICE OF MOTION TO DISMISS
1.
23
24
25 26 27 28
LITTLER MENDELSON
501 W Broidwiy Sun. 900 SanDn.o CA 92101 3S77 619 132 0441
CASE NO. 08CV1174 W (WMc)
Case 3:08-cv-01174-W-WMC
1
Document 5-2
Filed 07/10/2008
Page 3 of 4
(but she did not state what period of time that interest should be applied), and attorneys fees at $630 per hour according to proof. Morello Decl. f 8, Exh. 1. On June 2, 2008, over six months after she filed her complaint, Defendant's counsel, Littler Mendelson, received Plaintiffs Summons and Complaint. Morello Decl. If 9, Exh. 1. HI. ARGUMENT A. The Complaint Should Be Dismissed for Failure to Comply with Rules 8(a) and 12(b)(6) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure
2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28
LITTLER MENDELSON SOI W 8(o*d»iy Sun* 900 SanDuga CA 92)01 3577
619 232 0 4 4 1
Rule 8(a), FRCP, requires pleadings to contain (1) a short and plain statement of the grounds upon which the court's jurisdiction demands... (2) a short and plain statement of the claim showing that the pleader is entitled to relief, and (3) a demand for judgment for the relief the pleader seeks. A motion to dismiss is proper where there is either a "lack of a cognizable legal theory" or "the absence of sufficient facts alleged under a cognizable legal theory." Balistreri v. Pacifica Police Dept. 901 F.2d 696, 699 (9th Cir. 1988). Plaintiffs complaint contains no factual allegations. She does not allege what happened, when anything happened, who was involved, or where anything happened. Without these minimal allegations, Plaintiffs complaint does not meet the requirement of Rule 8(a) and does not state sufficient facts to allege a cognizable legal theory. B. Alternatively, Plaintiff Should Be Ordered to Make a More Definite Statement Under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12(e) A motion for a more definite statement should be granted where a complaint is so vague or ambiguous that a party cannot reasonable be required to frame a responsive pleading. F.R.C.P. 12(e); McHenrv v. Renne. 84 F.3d 1172, 1177 (9th Cir. 1996). As noted, Plaintiffs complaint does not contain any factual allegations. Thus, there are no factual allegations for
Defendant to admit or deny. Without such allegations, Defendant cannot frame its responsive pleading. Further, comparing Plaintiffs complaint to the example complaints contained in the official Appendix of Forms shows that Plaintiffs complaint lacks necessary factual allegations. The examples in the official Appendix of Forms, while short and concise, state dates, locations, actions,
///
DEFENDANT'S NOTICE OF MOTION TO DISMISS
2.
CASE NO. 08CV1174 W (WMc)
Case 3:08-cv-01174-W-WMC
Document 5-2
Filed 07/10/2008
Page 4 of 4
1 2 3 4
5
actors, and a theory of liability. Plaintiffs complaint contains none of these elements. Therefore, if the complaint is not dismissed, Plaintiff should be ordered to provide a more definite statement. IV. CONCLUSION For the foregoing reasons, Defendant Service Solutions Group, LLC, respectfully requests that the Court dismiss Plaintiffs action under Federal Rules of Civil Procedure 8(a), and 12(b)(6), or, in the alternative, order Plaintiff to make a more definite statement under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12(e). Dated: July 10,2008 Respectfully submitted,
6 7 8
9
10 11 12 13 14
s/Justin A. Morello STAGEY E. JAMES JUSTIN A. MORELLO Attorneys for Defendant E-mail: [email protected]: j [email protected]
Firmwide:85826660.1 046687.1149
15 16 17
18
19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27
28
LITTLER MENDELSON SOI W Broadway Suitt 900 Sin Dugo. CA 92101 3S7T 619 2320441
DEFENDANT'S NOTICE OF MOTION TO DISMISS
3.
CASE NO. 08CV1174 W (WMc)
Case 3:08-cv-01174-W-WMC
Document 5-3
Filed 07/10/2008
Page 1 of 8
1 2 3
4
STAGEY E. JAMES, Bar No. 185651 JUSTIN A. MORELLO, Bar No. 239250 LITTLER MENDELSON A Professional Corporation 501 W. Broadway, Suite 900 San Diego, CA 92101.3577 Telephone: 619.232.0441 Attorneys for Defendant SERVICE SOLUTIONS GROUP LLC
5 6 7
8 9
10 11
12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28
LITTLER MENDELSON
A PROFf I1IOIM COMOMTI
501 W Bio»
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA CINDY KING FEINSTEIN, Plaintiff,
v.
Case No. 08CV1174 W(WMc) DECLARATION OF JUSTIN A. MORELLO IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT'S MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF'S COMPLAINT [F.R.C.P 8(A), 12(B)(6); 12(E)] Hearing Date: August 11,2008 (No Oral Argument Required pursuant to Local Rule 7.1(d)(l)) Judge: Hon. Thomas J. Whelan Complaint Filed: November 20, 2007
SERVICE SOLUTIONS GROUP LLC; BARKERS FOOD MACHINERY SERVICE; FRANK HOLDING AG; and DOES 1-25, Defendants.
Suitt 900
S*n Di«(o. CA 91101 35 619 232 0441
DECLARATION OF JUSTIN A. MORELLO IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO DISMISS
CASE NO. 08CV1174 W (WMc)
Case 3:08-cv-01174-W-WMC
1
Document 5-3
Filed 07/10/2008
Page 2 of 8
I, Justin A. Morello, hereby declare and state as follows: 1. I am an attorney at law licensed to practice before all courts of the State of
2
3 4 5 6 7
California and this Court. I am an associate in the law firm of Littler Mendelson, P.C. and have been one of the attorneys representing Defendant Service Solutions Group LLC ("Defendant") in the above-captioned matter. As such, I have personal knowledge of the facts set forth in this declaration and, if called upon to do so, I could and would testify competently thereto. 2. Through her complaint, Plaintiff has made no factual allegations. Attached as
8
9
10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26
27
Exhibit "1" is a true and correct copy of Plaintiff s complaint, summons and civil case cover sheet. 3. form complaint.
4.
On November 20, 2007 in the San Diego Superior Court, Plaintiff filed her
The form complaint she filed is used in state court to allege a breach of
contract.
5. 6.
Plaintiff does not allege a breach of contract. In the section of the form complaint that should be used to state causes of
action, Plaintiff checked the box labeled "Other" and listed the following cause of action titles: "employment law, discrimination based on gender, wrongful termination, discriminatory discipline, sexual harassment hostile work environment violation of public policy. 7. places, or actions. 8. Under the section requesting a prayer for judgment, Plaintiff also checked Through her complaint, Plaintiff does not allege any dates, times, people,
boxes for undisclosed damages, interest on those damages at a rate of 10% (but she did not state what period of time that interest should be applied), and attorneys fees at $630 per hour according to proof. 9. On June 2, 2008, over six months after she filed her complaint, Defendant's
counsel, Littler Mendelson, received Plaintiffs Summons and Complaint.
/// /// ///
DECLARATION OF JUSTIN A. MORELLO IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO DISMISS
28
LITTLER MENDELSON
A PROFESSIONS CORPORATION 501 IN Broidway SUM* 900 S»n Diego. CA 92101 3577
1.
CASE NO. 08CV1174 W (WMc)
619 232 0441
Case 3:08-cv-01174-W-WMC
Document 5-3
Filed 07/10/2008
Page 3 of 8
1
2 3 4 5
California.
I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the United States that the foregoing is true and correct. Executed within the United States on July 10, 2008 at San Diego,
6
7 8 9
10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26
Firmwide:85768723.1 046687.1149
s/Justin A. Morello JUSTIN A. MORELLO Attorney for Defendant E-mail: [email protected]
27
28
LITTLER MENDELSON A pRofiiuoNM COMOHMIOK 501 W B'OPdwiy SUIK 900 Sin Oi«go, CA 91101 3677 619 233 04'1
DECLARATION OF JUSTIN A. MORELLO IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO DISMISS
2.
CASE NO. 08CV1174 W (WMc)
Case 3:08-cv-01174-W-WMC
Document 5-3
Filed 07/10/2008
Page 4 of 8
EXHIBIT 1
Case 3:08-cv-01174-W-WMC
Document 5-3
Filed 07/10/2008
Page 5 of 8
SUM-100
SUMMONS
(CITACION JUDICIAL)
NOTICE TO DEFENDANT: (AVISO AL DEMANDADO):
FOR COURT USE ONLY (SOLO PARA USODELA CORTE)
SERVICE SOLUTIONS GROUP LLC; BARKERS FOOD MACHINERY SERVICE; FRANK HOLDING AG; and DOES 1-25
YOU ARE BEING SUED BY PLAINTIFF: (LO ESTA DEMANDANDO EL DEM ANDANTE):
CINDY KING FEINSTEIN
You have 30 CALENDAR DAYS after this summons and legal papers are served on you to file a written response at this court and have a copy served on the plaintiff. A letter or phone call will not protect you. Your written response must be in proper legal form if you want the court to hear your case. There may be a court form that you can use for your response. You can find these court forms and more information at the California Courts Online Self-Help Center (www.courtinfo.ca.gov/selfhelp), your county law library, or the courthouse nearest you. If you cannot pay the filing fee, ask the court clerk for a fee waiver form. If you do not file your response on time, you may lose the case by default, and your wages, money, and property may be taken without further warning from the court. There are other legal requirements. You may want to call an attorney right away. If you do not know an attorney, you may want to call an attorney referral service. If you cannot afford an attorney, you may be eligible for free legal services from a nonprofit legal services program. You can locate these nonprofit groups at the California Legal Services Web site (www.lawhelpcalifornia.org), the California Courts Online Self-Help Center (www.courtinfo.ca.gov/selfhelp), or by contacting your local court or county bar association. Tiene 30 DIAS DE CALENDARIO despues de que le entreguen esta citacion y pape/es legates para presenter una respuesta por escrito en esta corte y hacer que se entregue una cop/a al demandants. Una carte o una llamada telefonica no lo protegen. Su respuesta por escrito tiene que estar en formato legal correcto s! desea que procesen su caso en la corte. Es poslble que haya un formulario que usted pueda usar para su respuesta. Puede encontrar estos formularies de la corte y mas Informacidn en el Centre de Ayuda de las Cortes de California (www.courtinfo.ca.gov/selfhelp/espanol/), en la blblioteca de /eyes de su condado o an la corte quele quede mas cerca. Si no puede pagar la cuota de presentacidn, plda al secretario de la corte que le de un formulario de exencidn de pago de cuotas. $1 no presents su respuesta a tlempo, puede perder el caso por Incumplimiento y la corte le podra guitar su sue/do, cffnero y bienes sin mis advertencia. Hay otros requisites legates. Es recomendable que llame a 'un abogado inmedlatamente. SI no conoce a un abogado, puede llamar a un serviclo de remlslon a abogados. SI no puede pagar a un abogado, es posible que cumpla con los requisites para obtener servlclos legates gratultos de un programs de servlclos legates sin fines de lucro. Puede encontrar estos grupos sin fines de lucro en el sltio web de California Legal Services, (www.lawhelpcalifomla.org), en el Centro de Ayuda de las Cortes de California, (www.courtinfo.ca.gov/selfhelp/espanol/) o ponlendose en contacto con la corte o el colegio de »bogados locales. The name and address of the court is: (El nombre y direcd6n de la corte es):
ESSSS* 37-2007-00082141-CUOR-PTL
SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA, COUNTY OF SAN DIEGO 330 WEST BROADWAY SAN DIEGO, CA 92101
The name, address, and telephone number of plaintiffs attorney, or plaintiff without an attorney, is: (El nombre, la direction y el numero de telefono del abogado del demandante, o del demandante que no tiene abogado, es): MARY ELIZABETH BULLOCK, SBN 153212 3955 FAIRCROSS PLACE, #73, SAN DIEGO, CA 92115 TEL:619-677-4066 FAX:619-727-4907 DATE:
(Fecha) (Secretario) (For proof of service of this summons, use Proof of Service of Summons (form POS-010).) (Para prueba de entrega de esta citation use el formulario Proof of Service of Summons, (POS-010)). NOTICE TO THE PERSON SERVED: You are served [SEAL) 1. I I as an individual defendant. ir ine ncimous name or (specify): 2. [~ | as the person sued under the fictitious name of (speciryj;
MflY Q MAY 3 H 2008 0
rio* by Clerk, h«
C. BOYLE
Deputy (Adjunto)
^w^ ^&*^jt^^
en
.,
,/)
3. I X-1 on behalf of (specify): under: I I CCP 416.10 (corporation) | CCP 416.20 (defunct corporation) | CCP 416.40 (association or partnership) | CCP 416.60 (minor) CCP 416.70 (conservatee) | CCP 416.90 (authorized person)
I | other (specify): 4. I VT by personal delivery on (date):
Form Adopted for Mandatory Use Judicial Council ol California SUM-100 [Rev. January 1, 2004]
Q&-- £\Q~-ff&
Page 1 of 1 Code ol Civil Procedure §§ 412.20.465
SUMMONS
I Annrion LegalN«l. Ine. IIwww.USCo.rfo/tm.coml
riovTao^JJuiD? i o » 3 i | 000-000-00000 Case 3:08-cv-01174-W-WMC '(-RSERJET FRX Document 5-3 Filed 07/10/2008 CIVIL E^-H'
- 7T* °" "**? y*TM°^ ATTORNEY (MM* a** t>numi». . Itt, Ji" * ,[yW^^V'^b'-'4v> 'tf-,, )]0/JL ^y_-K) lO^ 12. *^' ·! : ^ *L.,_^ . ..- ~ . _ -?f>·'?t T '^^^* .f,''ro-~!,-> i ^Ihr.z, &75 5
Y
Page 6 of 8
page 2 p. 3
CH10M
Z r ^ j
·
p'.i
.,
( f£ncGuft7(/MQ«Lr
?\
... I "
^A^^,?4kfii.r].s-4 .uuHbtt *^7op i,1-?:) [$
& / ,, . . » O'Ars EI)«£ETAIX)«B8
^ "*·
V*
PAf ^ ,
N
ATTOENgyfOHfrW
' ^ . , , X , XT , "" ^'"'Ap
' " . J ' " 4 fCX^-V-nr Til COU;
IBWEHION COURT OF CJUJFOHNIA, touwrvtef %
Vjr. iV
--~~
"'· ·'
N.umMo.en cnr^TPCoot
CASE.MAME:
VVJ W
"h ^^^V^. 4 f> ft n 1> ^ O /"'^ 1 «A > ^
ny-
BHAHOHWMt J^U.rpr.^
'
.
_C/VIL CASE GO>VER SHEET t*.-/, ^ - tf" S Cgmplex C*M DealBnaflw» X UnHmMDd D Llmtod (Amount CI3 CounimO Jp|n
^4-J ^Jfii^lll^'.-fb/i v/ ^^
-*--- · - - - -- « fc» '. ^ T w" >f^ 'VVrTf ^,>,y^V^ 1 , ^ ^ it^,,.//Y^.. K, Jd.^£_ r"?' A b-\ u xi^-..^ s. \ i "JT.._ i i , . (*^.. f \ _ _ . . , > · i i /i '-^ t
^*«t MUT»DE»~
37-2007-00082141-CU-OE-CTL
JUOQe;
demanded
-----»>v -- v*r
demanded te
wuii mi r^«akj tq
oxceedg 825,000)
$25,000 or lesa)
Fted with fii^t appaewice by dofendant (Cal, RUJ>« of Caurl_nito a.402)
MPT:
ffg/Tj? 1~4 belgw must bocornptetoa (aeflnstrucliont on paga a,
I (M Qlll Wx ^'Wto»»MB9 ^ ^^to"a*""1*8 Blto ·«·:
^j^,,.^ C2 !t«liotaiTrtfBcWMinBrty(Ofl)
Ru» 3.74D caDoBOgnn (<">) I J Unms'urml moiorw (^) Oonvtructtan d*tact <10) Oitwr ooHodtaM (Oft) OttitrPUPWWD (ParicmBl lnjuryn»rtip«rty MM* ion (40) DgMBtAWrenefel D«th) Ton Irauraiuw cov«ra9« (19) B«curlUeftlttt0«tian(2*) Pj AsttMtoifOi) Oth«r eentrad (37) EnvlrBnm«ntal/T«aila ted (SO) Product nabOhy (24) R«it Pr(*Prty Mtdlcal milpncllc* (43) ( ~ I Enrnnanldwnsln/irTvafR ln»ur»na» wXwtOO* elahni irhlng (mm (he candimnation
PnnMoflMjr Complff* CMH LuJgrton (Ctl. RU)M Of Court, rute 3^00-M03) Cj AntAruM/Tradira0uladon(03)
3. 4. 5. 6.
Rwnetlis* sought ^D/K>C/( eltthutapply): a.l^"] tnonotory b,!Z3 nonmonetay; rtectaratwy gr Injunolve reflef Number of cauaat of action \speclty): ^_ Thiiww I I ii E3k«nrt H dtws Bdion suit, If Ihora are any known related cases, Hie and aerve a noiln erf reJaied caae, f Vow rruy us* fomi CM-013.) M/XIM ±.\\
c.[3punh)ve
Data:
(TrPEOIIPmMTNAME)
d-H Bk-AL,!-..^
« PlaJnHff must filo this cover Btwot wnh ttw flral paper filed in Ihe acton or prqx^ediirc (axc«pi smaH daimi casai or 00004 fliad under the Piobate Code, Family Code, or WeXare and Inaatirtltxit Code). (C«l. Rule* of Coun, ruta 3 JZ2D.) Failure to file may nj&ult in sanctions. · File this cover »hea» in MdHion to any cover dheet required by toca) court role. · rf ini6 case is complex under rute 3,41X3 et »oq, trf the Cuiifomla Rule* of Court, you mum servo a copy of this cover ehael on ill altar pertiet 10 (he adk>n or proc«o4lng. · Untofls this Is a collections cat* under rule 3,740 or B ccmpfcx case, We oovw ETMB) will be, used forHtatlaticaJ porpoaee on^, ^ ^
Tort. A4MU9 It. UBMMKHV l»-- ju4«u
Nsn>5r"
(SK AnWnSfPARTY W ATTDWCf F0« PAKTTI
^-/a^ffA
CIVIL CASE COVER SHEET
Ctf. R"»«CT Cevrt. nj«i 2.W, 1.220.3.«»-J.eW, J.?4a C* nnnn» a AJOC>> AnnHnjHto\ 113 3. ID imrJafAAM^v
NOV 2 0 , 2 0 0 7 1 1 : 2 3
page 3
80V 20,2007 12:04 k 000-000-00000 «nv*80'B007 lO:31flM c JLRSERJET FRK Case 3:08-cv-01174-W-WMC Document 5-3 Filed 07/10/2008
C'~"
ATTotueT o» p
< *lL|DnrF1GE8 C1V1LRI!;-".'.. ·- - , · ·
Page 7 of 8
page 3 i*.l
,.,.. r,. oc. PLD.M01 7KU 5 J £U«*ttiafruBia«r
A >
MWys, ^.?
3W? FA\W'J^ "V'Wc, en?.
«**.,-> mt'wMf ·**/,(>V.^'...-,ryi i
CV ;iirD!ZGa"COU':';;v-C,^-
^1°-L1Hit)fl
^.KGMQIMt. ^ ft< .( ^^
.», ,.,0|
errvAM>»C09b
MUMCMMAMI .!> ·t.o.f ^)
Jf r.
<*'*CXA ^ ·
PLWNTIPP: CJI^A^
<\sw-)'~?rr!,ir,.«i,^)vs
DEPENDANT: .'3i?. ^ V.c(/.^"'^ ori.'. C-^V->L«?, i-l ··& 'Pbcvf Vf4ix \ .^.V (WirUnr^ 3
3*37-2007-00082141-CU-OE-CTL
JuriMtletlon /efMC* ·//
1. Plalntfr (n*M wntmt*); ^, ,,j^ \Li rv;, T6) n ',V.M o
BBeQMcauMSofactloflaga^aW^tf.^rt^ft^iWM;.-'' . A .·Sa
t
;. ^U;^^^/':-
:
r
b. gPlalndff (namBj; 0^>ncU^ IClr^ ^ . ^.u-', ^.^ t n£\ v,Jw\ } ·. C_jr»« compiled with th» fldrtious OOalrMM namv law* and to doing bustnws under ttn fitffliou* nomo (sptclty): b. C--I haa compiled with all (tensing mqulromenli a» a liovruad (specify): c. I -I Infonmatlon about addlOonoi ptabnltfa who ere not competent odullt it atwwn In Anachnwm ic. a. Each dwflendunt named above te a naturalpajtton,, . -'v^,,, A . CZIowapidatenaan. fww;:$^1W^^W^ ^?A«k >J&)J,^ *£>-> · · ·^'·'TV (1) I W-Ta buvinom organization torm urtthowrt I V'ta bu«Jnp«» omancatton, r (1) ^^ a builnou eroanlaatlon, form unknown v (3) I "I an unincorporated «ntlty (deKrUnt): W P (B) | I a pviWic anWy (describe): lothcffwMeW:
<2) (3)
a eerporaUen
an unincorporaiaxl antity (describe):
W C~l a puWie enBty (c*Mcr«»).(3)IH]ottwCap»of/W.COMPLAJNT--Con«r»ct
CM! «l DXPro«««W*. | «S U
· KJHHomB ui*iMtiTc»« .
|Am«lB»r. vittMM. tne. lAmwk MHV rtyTudHjiMew.cwi |w»f
NOV 20,2007 11:22
paqe 1
Case 3:08-cv-01174-W-WMC Document 5-3 Filed 07/10/2008 """. ««,'&8V ,0,3,J ·LBSERJET FBX°°°~000 ' . f
Page 8 of 8
'pjg. 4
PLD-C-001
SHOHTTTTLE: CASl MJkBIft
T~ /· f\
\~/. . ,,vVi... « »···
4.
' (Continued) b. The true names of defendants iuad aa Doea are unknown lo plaintiff, (1) EETbo* d«tendaitta («pec*y Doe numoe/sj; J - »?_.·< ,_ v»r» th« ogante or Brrptoyeaa of the namefl defending «n
\/ OeyVi , ,» ..
'X'Wijj^CV. N (rr-iV.
1 i
/ /,r.. cf» \
plaint Iff,
c. Q Information about additional defendant* wtio af ft not ntrturel ponont I* contained In AtUchrrwnt Ac. d O Defandanta who ar» Joined under Coda of Civil Proc*dur« aaxalon 382 are {namaa): 5. [~1 piBinUfl li raqulred to comply with a daima ktolul*, and a. Q^1w» compllad with applicable claim* Btatutea, o/ b. CD la «cu8*d (mm complying bacauM (specify):
6. CZ3 Thl» action ia «ub)ect to CD civil Coda aectbn 1B12.10 CD Civil Coda section 2884.4. 7. TW« court I* ihe proper court became a. I | atetondtmentered into Ihe contract hem. b. O · detondart Hved here when fce contact WM entered Wo. c. Q e defsniianilivei here now. d. LJ nie contract w»* to be performed hofe. e. p~| a defendanl is a earponaUon or unincorpontad aaaociBfioA and Its principal place of busfrieis to tore. f. l~l real properly that to the aubjed of thla action to located here. B. me following causes of action an afUchad afld tha alaieltMiifiFaoSMreppiy'B) «BO^I feseft oompfa/nf nmcf nave onv or mew couM* of action attached): CD Breach of Contract CD Common Count* C^Other (apectty): £ <·»·}«I<*}Wrr}B. I
. c? ^'^^;?^r,i^^^^^^^^^^^i
Wl ^ J f Wr I other alleaatlonr k ' ^-X^^r* ^ HN n °"4t'\ 1 «.>v;-^:^^r.^^ ·i'-f '~,^^k*i W^^.j.. ^^ "TM^S°;:? - ^^;-?rr^^ v,^: "VK- '-n^i^. v,:;,;;;;'^
w
10. PlalnrtHT pray* for judament for ro»ts of wit tar Mich relief u l» lair, just, and equitable; end for demagei ot: $ interest on the damages (1)IZ3 aooordlng to proof (2) d^fd Ihe rate of (afx>tty): p«rcont per year from (daty: a. I I aUorne/i teea (1)Elof: IfoSojl,-/' (2) EJ accordinfl to proof.
;:i
d. | 1 olrw (specify):
f,
11. CD The pfiregiophe of lhr» ptefKfcr^ ««eo^d on Informafen and b»l»f arBaateHowa^^pecfly^amcrap/jnumis^:
Dote: N'Ov-^v^./'.^D-. ?-<5"O~7 f-;U y\-i f\-|.,-^l/ fju "^... ^r^.(/.
i rrfre 6« PH»rr NAME)
>
'^h-'h.-^
'
?. i^/^
Q
(iiai(*TWHS of w^JMTtf-Vcn AnaRwivi
PUX-OOM**. -- nri.son
(tfyvu ntati lo V9rify Ws pbatllng, Bfffa g ygrtiteaffon,; I ~" " COMPLAINT--ConUnCt
'
^
'
'
js^i^i
NOV 20,2007 11:22
paqe 2
United States Free Forms
Canada Free Forms
United Kingdom Free Forms
Australia Free Forms