Free Objections - District Court of Colorado - Colorado

Case 1:04-cv-01070-PSF-PAC

Document 59

Filed 06/20/2005

Page 1 of 5

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLORADO Civil Action No.: 04-F-1070 (DAC) DANNIE W. JOHNSON and MARTHA D. JOHNSON Plaintiffs, v. OVERRIGHT TRUCKING, INC., a New Mexico corporation, and ROSS A. REED, Defendants. ______________________________________________________________________________ STIPULATIONS/OBJECTIONS RE: PLAINTIFFS' PROPOSED EXHIBITS ______________________________________________________________________________ COME NOW, Defendants Overright Trucking, Inc., a New Mexico corporation and Ross A. Reed, by and through their attorneys of record, Wittman & McCord, and submit Stipulations/Objections re: Plaintiffs' Proposed Exhibits, as follows:

DESIGNATED EXHIBIT i. Plaintiffs Travel Trailer ii. State of Colorado Accident Report with Supplement iii. Videotape of inside of Plaintiffs' home shortly after the accident iv. Time spent and out of pocket expenses with list of damaged personal property sent to Larry French v. Grouping of 15 damaged home photos taken 1/1/04 and disclosed 9/30/04. vi. Photo of Northwest corner of home taken 1/1/04. vii. Photo of Southwest corner of home taken 1/1/04. viii. Photo of North side of home taken 1/1/04 ix. Photo of point of impact showing yardstick for reference of movement.

STIPULATED TO

OBJECTIONS F.R.E. 401 (relevance); F.R.E. 403 (prejudice, cumulative) Hearsay; F.R.E. 403 (cumulative); F.R.E. 401 (relevance)

X Hearsay; F.R.E. 403 (cumulative)

X X X X X

Case 1:04-cv-01070-PSF-PAC

Document 59

Filed 06/20/2005

Page 2 of 5

x. Photo of Northwest corner of home, showing yardstick for reference of home movement. xi. Photo of Mr. and Mrs. Johnson near point of impact, showing West side of buckled front porch, point of impact, and leaning front porch supports. xii. Photo showing travel trailer in the winter xiii. Photo showing water truck imbedded into Southwest corner of home xiv. Photo showing Northeast corner of home with exposed gas line and damaged electrical post and hook-up xv. Photo from West, showing Northwest Corner of home and ripped electrical service xvi. Photo from interior of home showing impact site. xvii. Photos of accident scene, truck, skid marks, and damaged gas line as referenced in Michael Overright deposition concluded on 5/18/05. xviii. Mercy Medical Center Lab report dated 1/8/04 containing four (4) pages xix. Photographs taken by digital camera on 1/1/04 by either Defendant Overright or Brad Smith disclosed after Motion for Sanctions. xx. Photographs of tires of truck. xxi. Handwritten diagram sheets of home layout prepared by Larry French xxii. Photos of sub floor structure and attic structure of Johnson home xxiii. Photo from Southwest corner of home showing movement North xxiv. Any document necessary for impeachment or rebuttal purposes xxv. Any document necessary for proving foundation xxvi. Any exhibit necessary for demonstrative purposes at time of trial xxvii. Copy of La Plata County Building

X

X

X F.R.E. 403 (prejudice, cumulative)

X

X

X F.R.E. 401 (relevance); F.R.E. 403 (prejudice, cumulative)

Hearsay, F.R.E. 401 (relevance); F.R.E.403 (prejudice, cumulative) F.R.E. 401 (relevance); F.R.E. 403 (cumulative, prejudice)

F.R.E. 401 (relevance); F.R.E. 403 (cumulative, prejudice) Foundation, F.R.E.403 (cumulative, prejudice) X X Objections reserved pending identification Objections reserved pending identification Objections reserved pending identification Foundation, hearsay, F.R.E. 403

2

Case 1:04-cv-01070-PSF-PAC

Document 59

Filed 06/20/2005

Page 3 of 5

Codes xxviii. Report of Rodney Ems, Engineer, with Curriculum Vitae xxxix. Report of John Dustin, Appraiser, with Curriculum Vitae xxxx. Bids from Brian Glenn, General Contractor for construction of entire home and for framing, 9/7/04 and framing 3/11/04 xli. Plaintiffs' 1040 Income Tax Returns for 201, 2002, and 2003 xlii. Plaintiffs' list of damaged personal property xliii. Jay C. Hecker's drawing, floor plan, of the subject premises xliv. Construction bid from Philpott & Hinds for building of entire home dated 7/26/04 xlv. Landscaping bid from Katherine Aeby, M.A., for Covering Ground Landscape Design totaling $32,324.24 xlvi. Alpine Landscaping Bid dated 9/6/04 xlvii. Bids from Winterhawk Siding & Construction for all phases of the home construction, including entire home and for various interim phases dated 7/6/04 xlviii. Bids from D&S Construction, Inc. dated 1/7/04 and 8/30/04 xlix. Proposal from JD's Plumbing dated 3/9/04 xlx. Proposal from May Insulation, Inc. dated 3/9/04 li. Bid from M. Leeder Construction, inc. dated 2/20/04 lii. Bid from Turtle Lake Construction, Inc. dated 2/2/0/04 liii. Bid from Winterhawk Siding dated 3/9/04 for vinyl siding liv. Bid from Phillips Electric, Inc. dated 3/9/04 lv. Proposal from Garrhs, Inc. dated 3/9/04. lvi. Estimate from Above All Roofing dated March 8, 2004
3

(cumulative, prejudice) Hearsay, F.R.E. 403 (cumulative); Curriculum Vitae not objected to. Hearsay, F.R.E. 403 (cumulative); Curriculum Vitae not objected to. Hearsay, F.R.E. 403 (cumulative)

F.R.E. 401 (relevance); F.R.E. 403 (prejudice, cumulative) X Lack of Foundation; F.R.E. 403 (cumulative, prejudicial) Lack of Foundation; hearsay; F.R.E. 403 (cumulative, prejudicial) Lack of Foundation; hearsay; F.R.E. 403 (cumulative, prejudicial) Lack of Foundation; hearsay; F.R.E. 403 (cumulative, prejudicial) Lack of Foundation; hearsay; F.R.E. 403 (cumulative, prejudicial)

Lack of Foundation; hearsay; F.R.E. 403 (cumulative, prejudicial) Lack of Foundation; hearsay; F.R.E. 403 (cumulative, prejudicial) Lack of Foundation; hearsay; F.R.E. 403 (cumulative, prejudicial) Lack of Foundation; hearsay; F.R.E. 403 (cumulative, prejudicial) Lack of Foundation; hearsay; F.R.E. 403 (cumulative, prejudicial) Lack of Foundation; hearsay; F.R.E. 403 (cumulative, prejudicial) Lack of Foundation; hearsay; F.R.E. 403 (cumulative, prejudicial) Lack of Foundation; hearsay; F.R.E. 403 (cumulative, prejudicial) Lack of Foundation; hearsay; F.R.E. 403 (cumulative, prejudicial)

Case 1:04-cv-01070-PSF-PAC

Document 59

Filed 06/20/2005

Page 4 of 5

lvii. Invoice from La Plata Painting to Glenn Const. For $8,000 lviii. McCormick Tile quote for $4,500 lix. Proposal from Durango Floor Sanding & Finishing Co. dated 3/10/04 lx. Zircon Storage receipts lxi. Original Deposition of Ross Reed lxii. Exhibits to Ross Reed deposition

Lack of Foundation; hearsay; F.R.E. 403 (cumulative, prejudicial) Lack of Foundation; hearsay; F.R.E. 403 (cumulative, prejudicial) Lack of Foundation; hearsay; F.R.E. 403 (cumulative, prejudicial) X Hearsay; F.R.E.403 (cumulative) Lack of foundation, hearsay; F.R.E. 401 (relevance); F.R.E. 403 (cumulative, prejudicial) Hearsay; F.R.E.403 (cumulative) Lack of foundation, hearsay; F.R.E. 401 (relevance); F.R.E. 403 (cumulative, prejudicial) Hearsay; F.R.E.403 (cumulative) Lack of foundation, hearsay; F.R.E. 401 (relevance); F.R.E. 403 (cumulative, prejudicial) Defendants reserve objection pending identification.

lxiii. Original Deposition of Michael Overright lxiv. Deposition Exhibits for Michael Overright lxv. Original Deposition of Charles Minkler lxvi. Deposition Exhibits for Charles Minkler lxvii. Any document confirming substantial modification of a bid before trial Respectfully submitted this 20th day of June 2005.

WITTMAN & McCORD

/s/ J. Bradley Hardman J. Bradley Hardman (#17122)
Pursuant to Rule 121, § 1-26, this document has been electronically filed and a duly signed original is on file at Wittman & McCord.

4

Case 1:04-cv-01070-PSF-PAC

Document 59

Filed 06/20/2005

Page 5 of 5

CERTIFICATE OF MAILING I hereby certify that a true and correct copy of the foregoing was sent via facsimile and mailed this 20th day of June 2005, addressed to the following: Michael W. Baty, Esq. 1040 Main Avenue PO Box 1157 Durango, CO. 81301 Randolph H. Phillips, Esq. 609 Pine Avenue PO Box 2303 Albany, GA. 31702 /s/ Sherri L. Humphrey

5