Free Objections - District Court of Colorado - Colorado

Case 1:00-cv-02098-REB-MJW

Document 267

Filed 09/25/2007

Page 1 of 12

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLORADO

Civil Action No. 00-cv-02098-REB-MJW KELLY FINCHER, by her guardian, JAMES FINCHER, on behalf of herself and all others similarly situated, Plaintiffs, v. PRUDENTIAL PROPERTY AND CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY, a New Jersey Corporation, Defendant.

PLAINTIFFS' OBJECTIONS TO DEFENDANT'S EXHIBITS

Plaintiffs KELLY FINCHER, by her guardian, JAMES FINCHER, by and through their attorneys of record, The Carey Law Firm, submit the following objections to Defendant's Exhibits: Exhibit Ltr. a. b. c. d. e. f. g. Description March 31, 2005 letter from Latiolais to Rector. Liberty Mutual Check No. 60155353, dated March 28, 2005 April 14, 2005 letter from Latiolais to Rector. April 19, 2005 letter from Rector to Latiolais, with attachments. March 14, 2006 letter from Rector to Latiolais. March 16, 2006 letter from Rector to Latiolais. April 12, 2006 letter from Latiolais to
Stipulated Objections

Case 1:00-cv-02098-REB-MJW

Document 267

Filed 09/25/2007

Page 2 of 12

Exhibit Ltr. Rector. h. i. j. k.

Description Liberty Mutual check number 60370327, dated March 23, 2006. May 11, 2006 letter from Latiolais to Rector. May 30, 2006 letter from Latiolais to Rector. Order Concerning Motion For Summary Judgment in this case, dated 6-7-02.

Stipulated

Objections

l.

Copy of the Brennan v. Farmers Alliance case, 961 P.2d 550, (Colo. App. 1998). Copy of the Thompson v. Budget case, 940 P.2d 987 (Colo. App. 1996). Order in Clark v. State Farm, No. 00-B-1841 (D. Colo. June 20, 2001).

m.

n.

o.

Affidavit of Anthony J. Bekeshka, Sr., September 23, 2001.

p.

Affidavit of Mary Henry.

q.

Affidavit of Mary Rowe, September 27, 2001.

r.

Order in Clark v. State Farm, dated December 18, 2003.

OBJ-Foundation, Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403), contrary to the law of this case OBJ--Not evidence, contrary to the law of this case OBJ--Not evidence, contrary to the law of this case OBJ--Not evidence, contrary to the law of this case OBJ-Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403); Hearsay (FRE 801, 802) OBJ-Not provided, disclosed or described, Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403); Hearsay (FRE 801, 802) OBJ-Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403); Hearsay (FRE 801, 802) OBJ--Not evidence, contrary

Case 1:00-cv-02098-REB-MJW

Document 267

Filed 09/25/2007

Page 3 of 12

Exhibit Ltr.

Description

Stipulated

Objections

s.

Summary of interest calculations used by Prupac to pay statutory interest.

t.

Plaintiff's records from Illinois Dept. of Human Services.

u.

Plaintiff's employment records.

v.

w. x.

Application for Prudential automobile insurance, signed by Anthony and Doloris Bekeshka on April 23, 1992. Prudential's policy of insurance issued to the Bekeshkas. Copy of C.R.S. §10-4-706 and 710, as they existed at the time of the Bekeshka application and policy issuance.

to the law of this case OBJ-Not provided, disclosed or described, Relevancy, FRE 401, 402, 403 OBJ-Not provided, disclosed or described; foundation; relevancy OBJ-Not provided, disclosed or described; foundation; relevancy OBJ-Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403), contrary to the law of this case

y.

Chronology Exhibit

OBJ--Not evidence; Foundation; Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403), contrary to the law of this case OBJ--Portions prejudicial; Foundation; Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403); contrary to the law of this case; Incomplete (FRE 106); Improper opinion and speculation (FRE

Case 1:00-cv-02098-REB-MJW

Document 267

Filed 09/25/2007

Page 4 of 12

Exhibit Ltr.

Description

Stipulated

Objections

z. aa.

Curriculum vitae of John Grund Prudential's Bate stamp no. 110

bb.

Prudential's Bate stamp no. 123

cc.

Prudential's Bate stamp no. 125

dd.

Prudential's Bate stamp no. 158

ee.

Prudential's Bate stamp no. 176

ff.

Prudential's Bate stamp no. 180

gg.

Prudential's Bate stamp no. 191

701); Contains comments and legal analyses of counsel; Hearsay, (FRE 801, 802); Authentication, (FRE 901); Improper summary under FRE 1006 OBJ-- Foundation OBJ-- Foundation; Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403); contrary to the law of this case OBJ-- Foundation; Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403); contrary to the law of this case OBJ-- Foundation; Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403); contrary to the law of this case OBJ-- Foundation; Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403); contrary to the law of this case OBJ-- Foundation; Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403); contrary to the law of this case OBJ-- Foundation; Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403); contrary to the law of this case OBJ-- Foundation;

Case 1:00-cv-02098-REB-MJW

Document 267

Filed 09/25/2007

Page 5 of 12

Exhibit Ltr.

Description

Stipulated

Objections

hh.

Prudential's Bate stamp no. 204-205

ii.

Prudential's Bate stamp no. 207-234

jj.

Prudential's Bate stamp no. 238-242

kk.

Prudential's Bate stamp no. 274

ll.

Prudential's Bate stamp no. 284-285

mm.

Prudential's Bate stamp no. 396-399

nn.

Prudential's Bate stamp no. 411-429

oo.

Prudential's Bate stamp no. 461-464

Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403); contrary to the law of this case OBJ-- Foundation; Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403); contrary to the law of this case OBJ-- Foundation; Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403); contrary to the law of this case OBJ-- Foundation; Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403); contrary to the law of this case OBJ-- Foundation; Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403); contrary to the law of this case OBJ-- Foundation; Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403); contrary to the law of this case OBJ-- Foundation; Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403); contrary to the law of this case OBJ-- Foundation; Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403); contrary to the law of this case OBJ-- Foundation; Relevancy, (FRE

Case 1:00-cv-02098-REB-MJW

Document 267

Filed 09/25/2007

Page 6 of 12

Exhibit Ltr.

Description

Stipulated

Objections

pp.

Prudential's Bate stamp no. 444-462

qq.

Prudential's Bate stamp no. 493-497

rr.

Prudential's Bate stamp no. 509-517

ss.

Prudential's Bate stamp no. 556-560

tt.

Prudential's Bate stamp no. 563-566

uu.

Prudential's Bate stamp no. 599

vv.

Prudential's Bate stamp no. 610

ww.

Prudential's Bate stamp no. 613-616

401, 402, 403); Authenticity, (FRE 901); contrary to the law of this case OBJ-- Foundation; Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403); Authenticity, (FRE 901); contrary to the law of this case OBJ-- Foundation; Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403); contrary to the law of this case OBJ-- Foundation; Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403); contrary to the law of this case OBJ-- Foundation; Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403); contrary to the law of this case OBJ-- Foundation; Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403); contrary to the law of this case OBJ-- Foundation; Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403); contrary to the law of this case OBJ-- Foundation; Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403); contrary to the law of this case OBJ-- Foundation;

Case 1:00-cv-02098-REB-MJW

Document 267

Filed 09/25/2007

Page 7 of 12

Exhibit Ltr.

Description

Stipulated

Objections

xx.

Prudential's Bate stamp no. 671-675

yy.

Prudential's Bate stamp no. 778

zz.

Prudential's Bate stamp no. 780-784

aaa.

Prudential's Bate stamp no. 854-855

bbb.

Prudential's Bate stamp no. 857

ccc.

Prudential's Bate stamp no. 878

ddd.

Prudential's Bate stamp no. 883-885

eee.

Prudential's Bate stamp no. 887

Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403); contrary to the law of this case OBJ-- Foundation; Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403); contrary to the law of this case OBJ-- Foundation; Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403); contrary to the law of this case OBJ-- Foundation; Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403); contrary to the law of this case OBJ-- Foundation; Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403); contrary to the law of this case OBJ-- Foundation; Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403); contrary to the law of this case OBJ-- Foundation; Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403); contrary to the law of this case OBJ-- Foundation; Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403); contrary to the law of this case OBJ-- Foundation; Relevancy, (FRE

Case 1:00-cv-02098-REB-MJW

Document 267

Filed 09/25/2007

Page 8 of 12

Exhibit Ltr.

Description

Stipulated

Objections

fff.

Prudential's Bate stamp no. 896-897

ggg.

Prudential's Bate stamp no. 898-903

hhh.

Prudential's Bate stamp no. 910

iii.

Prudential's Bate stamp no. 989

jjj.

Prudential's Bate stamp no. 997

kkk.

Prudential's Bate stamp no. 1001

lll.

Prudential's Bate stamp no. 1004

mmm.

Prudential's Bate stamp no. 10581059

401, 402, 403); contrary to the law of this case OBJ-- Foundation; Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403); contrary to the law of this case OBJ-- Foundation; Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403); contrary to the law of this case OBJ-- Foundation; Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403); contrary to the law of this case OBJ-- Foundation; Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403); contrary to the law of this case OBJ-- Foundation; Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403); contrary to the law of this case OBJ-- Foundation; Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403); contrary to the law of this case OBJ-- Foundation; Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403); contrary to the law of this case OBJ-- Foundation; Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403);

Case 1:00-cv-02098-REB-MJW

Document 267

Filed 09/25/2007

Page 9 of 12

Exhibit Ltr.

Description

Stipulated

Objections

nnn.

Prudential's Bate stamp no. 10651067

ooo.

Prudential's Bate stamp no. 10701075

ppp.

Prudential's bate stamp no. 10891091

qqq.

Prudential's bate stamp no. 1098

rrr.

Prudential's bate stamp no. 1122

contrary to the law of this case OBJ-- Foundation; Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403); contrary to the law of this case OBJ-- Foundation; Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403); contrary to the law of this case OBJ-- Foundation; Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403); contrary to the law of this case OBJ-- Foundation; Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403); contrary to the law of this case OBJ-- Foundation; Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403); contrary to the law of this case OBJ-- Foundation; Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403); contrary to the law of this case OBJ-- Foundation; Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403); contrary to the law of this case OBJ-- Foundation; Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403);

sss. ttt.

Prudential's bate stamp no. 1134 Prudential's bate stamp no. 1146

uuu.

Prudential's bate stamp no. 11571167

vvv.

Prudential's bate stamp no. 11711182

Case 1:00-cv-02098-REB-MJW

Document 267

Filed 09/25/2007

Page 10 of 12

Exhibit Ltr.

Description

Stipulated

Objections

www.

Prudential's bate stamp no. 12041210

xxx.

Prudential's bate stamp no. 13441345

yyy.

Prudential's bate stamp no. 1402

zzz.

Prudential's bate stamp no. 14131414

aaaa.

Prudential's bate stamp no. 1440

bbbb.

Prudential's bate stamp no. 1451

cccc.

PIP claim processing document

dddd.

Bulletin 6-94, Colorado Division of Insurance

contrary to the law of this case OBJ-- Foundation; Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403); contrary to the law of this case OBJ-- Foundation; Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403); contrary to the law of this case OBJ-- Foundation; Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403); contrary to the law of this case OBJ-- Foundation; Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403); contrary to the law of this case OBJ-- Foundation; Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403); contrary to the law of this case OBJ-- Foundation; Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403); contrary to the law of this case OBJ-Not provided, disclosed or described; foundation; relevancy OBJ-- Foundation; Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403); contrary to the law

Case 1:00-cv-02098-REB-MJW

Document 267

Filed 09/25/2007

Page 11 of 12

Exhibit Ltr. eeee.

Description Form PAC 190/CO (Ed. 5/93)

Stipulated

Objections

of this case OBJ-- Foundation; Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403); contrary to the law of this case OBJ-- Foundation; Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403); contrary to the law of this case OBJ-- Foundation; Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403); contrary to the law of this case OBJ-- Foundation; Relevancy, (FRE 401, 402, 403); contrary to the law of this case

ffff.

form PAC 3821 ­ (Ed. 1/98); (Ed 1/99); and (Ed. 4/99)

gggg.

form PAC 226 ­ (Ed. 4/98); (Ed. 8/99); and (Ed. 2/00)

hhhh.

form PCD 3601 (Ed. 10/99); PCD 3492 (Ed. 12/98)

Respectfully submitted this September 25, 2007. s/Leif Garrison Robert B. Carey Leif Garrison The Carey Law Firm 2301 East Pikes Peak Ave. Colorado Springs, Colorado 80909 Phone: (719) 635-0377 Fax: (719) 635-2920 Email: [email protected] Steve W. Berman, WSBA #12536 HAGENS BERMAN, L.L.P. 1301 Fifth Avenue, Suite 2900 Seattle, WA 98101 L. Dan Rector
FRANKLIN D. AZAR & ASSOCIATES, PC

Case 1:00-cv-02098-REB-MJW

Document 267

Filed 09/25/2007

Page 12 of 12

5536 Library Lane Colorado Springs, CO 80918 Attorneys for Plaintiffs

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that on this September 25, 2007, I electronically filed the foregoing with the Clerk of the Court using the CM/ECF System, which will send notification to the following email addresses: [email protected] s/Leif Garrison Robert B. Carey Leif Garrison The Carey Law Firm 2301 East Pikes Peak Ave. Colorado Springs, Colorado 80909 Phone: (719) 635-0377 Fax: (719) 635-2920 Email: [email protected]

12