Free Objections - District Court of Colorado - Colorado

Case 1:01-cv-00413-JLK-BNB

Document 232

Filed 09/10/2007

Page 1 of 17

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLORADO Civil Action No. 01-K-0413 M.D. MARK, INC., Plaintiff, vs. KERR-McGEE CORPORATION and ORYX ENERGY COMPANY, Defendants. DEFENDANT'S RULE 26(a)(3) OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFF'S TRIAL EXHIBITS Defendant Kerr-McGee Corp., 1 pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 26(a)(3), submits its objections to Plaintiff's trial exhibits. Defendant stipulates to each Plaintiff exhibit not identified in the table below. OBJECTIONS

No. 24

Description PGI Continuation of Original Participation Agreement to Sun Exploration and Production Company. MD01-0186 8/2/82 Davies Depo Ex. 7

Objection Relevance (FRE 402).

1

Oryx Energy Co. ceased to exist on February 26, 1999, at which time it became KerrMcGee as a result of a statutory corporate merger.

Case 1:01-cv-00413-JLK-BNB

Document 232

Filed 09/10/2007

Page 2 of 17

No. 54

Description PGI Letter of Agreement to Sun Exploration and Production Company MD01-0231 - MD01-0233 10/10/83 Davies Depo Ex. 12 MD Mark Inc Non Exclusive License Agreement to Use Data to Kerr-McGee Corporation NO BATES 5/13/94 Helm Depo Ex. 5

Objection Incomplete document; Authenticity (FRE 901) and Hearsay (FRE 802) as to handwritten notes on MD01-0232. Relevance (FRE 402), not related to any data as issue; as a matter of law, this license agreement cannot modify or supersede premerger agreements between PGI and Oryx. Relevance (FRE 402), not related to any data at issue; Defendant will stipulate upon a showing that this license corresponds to data that Plaintiff alleges to be missing or unaccounted for. Relevance (FRE 402), not related to any data at issue; Defendant will stipulate upon a showing that this license corresponds to data that Plaintiff alleges to be missing or unaccounted for. Relevance (FRE 402), not related to any data at issue; Defendant will stipulate upon a showing that this license corresponds to data that Plaintiff alleges to be missing or unaccounted for.

60

61

PGI Non-Exclusive License Agreement to Use Data to KerrMcGee MD05-00557 - MD05-00558 5/13/94 Davies Depo Ex: 119 PGI Non-Exclusive License Agreement to Use Data to KerrMcGee MD05-00560 - MD05-00561 9/22/87 Davies Depo Ex. 119 PGI Non-Exclusive License Agreement to Use Data to KerrMcGee MD05-00562 - MD05-00563 9/18/87 Davies Depo Ex. 119

62

63

-2-

Case 1:01-cv-00413-JLK-BNB

Document 232

Filed 09/10/2007

Page 3 of 17

No. 64

Description PGI Data Purchase Agreement to Kerr McGee MD05-00564 4/23/84 Davies Depo Ex. 119

Objection Relevance (FRE 402), not related to any data at issue; Defendant will stipulate upon a showing that this license corresponds to data that Plaintiff alleges to be missing or unaccounted for. Relevance (FRE 402), not related to any data at issue; Defendant will stipulate upon a showing that this license corresponds to data that Plaintiff alleges to be missing or unaccounted for. Relevance (FRE 402), not related to any data at issue; Defendant will stipulate upon a showing that this license corresponds to data that Plaintiff alleges to be missing or unaccounted for. Relevance (FRE 402), not related to any data at issue; Defendant will stipulate upon a showing that this license corresponds to data that Plaintiff alleges to be missing or unaccounted for. Relevance (FRE 402), not related to any data at issue; Defendant will stipulate upon a showing that this license corresponds to data that Plaintiff alleges to be missing or unaccounted for. Relevance (FRE 402, 403), not related to any data at issue.

65

PGI Data Purchase Agreement to Kerr McGee MD05-00565 5/18/84 Davies Depo Ex. 119

66

PGI Data Purchase Agreement to Kerr McGee MD05-00566 12/20/84 Davies Depo Ex. 119

67

PGI Data Purchase Agreement to Kerr McGee MD05-00567 1/15/85 Davies Depo Ex. 119

68

PGI Data Purchase Agreement to Kerr McGee MD05-00568 4/25/85 Davies Depo Ex. 119

69

Bailey Banks Seismic L.P. NonExclusive License Agreement to Use Data to Kerr-McGee MD05-00581 - MD05-00582 1/11/02 Davies Depo Ex. 120

-3-

Case 1:01-cv-00413-JLK-BNB

Document 232

Filed 09/10/2007

Page 4 of 17

No. 71

Description PG1 Non-Exclusive License Agreement to Use Data to KerrMcGee MD09-005 - MD09-006 12/18/89

Objection Relevance (FRE 402), not related to any data at issue; Defendant will stipulate upon a showing that this license corresponds to data that Plaintiff alleges to be missing or unaccounted for. Stipulate to KM0005500056; KM00054 not part of the same license agreement.

77

82

PGI Non. Exclusive License Agreement to Use Data to un Exploration and Production Company KM00054 ­ KM-00056 12/21/87 PGI Eastern Arkoma Basin Purchase Agreement 2/15/85 KM00022-00023 and additional page with no dates

84

85

Letter of Agreement from Frontier Petroleum Services and Kerr McGee Oil & Gas Corporation Encl: Exhibit A - Description of Data NO BATES 2/5/01 Southern Frontier Petroleum Services, Inc. Letter to Kerr McGee Corporation (Tricia Dark to Dan Hahn) Attached: Email Transmissions from Dan Hahn, Subsequent Corres., License Agreement (3/3/94) Between Frontier and HS Resources, License Agreement (4/17/90) Between Frontier and Oryx Energy Company

Stipulate to KM0002200023; Non-Bates labeled page was not previously disclosed (FRCP 37(c)(1)) and does not appear to be associated with this license agreement. Not previously disclosed (FRCP 37(c)(1); Relevance (FRE 402, 403), not related to any data at issue; Hearsay (FRE 802).

Relevance (FRE 402, 403), not related to any data at issue; Hearsay (FRE 802); portions of this composite exhibit not previously disclosed (FRCP 37(c)(1).

-4-

Case 1:01-cv-00413-JLK-BNB

Document 232

Filed 09/10/2007

Page 5 of 17

No. 87

Description Diamond Geophysical Service Corporation Letter to Oryx Energy Corporation (Horsfall) Re: Transfer Fees KM00458 - KM00459 2/18/98 Geotrak Letter to Kerr McGee Oil and Gas Corporation (Christian) Re: Non-transferable data KM-008391 4/7/98 Peter Siviglia Letter to KerrMcGee (Carlos Salazar) Re: Return of Data KM-002225 4/1/99

Objection Relevance (FRE 402, 403), not related to any data at issue; Hearsay (FRE 802).

88

Relevance (FRE 402, 403), not related to any data at issue; Hearsay (FRE 802).

89

90

92

97

TGS NOPEC Geophysical Company Letter to Kerr-McGee Oil & Gas Corporation Re: Transfer Fee KM-002339 4/8/99 Seismic Exchange Inc Letter to Kerr-McGee Oil and Gas Corporation (Christian) Re: Financial Offer/Transfer Data KM-002300 5/18/99 Diamond Geophysical Service Corporation Letter to Kerr-McGee Oil and Gas Corporation (to Christian) Re: Extension of Grace Period KM-002286 ­ KM-002287 3/1/99

Relevance (FRE 402, 403), not related to any data at issue; Hearsay (FRE 802). If Plaintiff is permitted to admit Exhibit 89, Defendant may offer the documents attached hereto as Defendant's Exhibit D20, and D21. Relevance (FRE 402, 403), not related to any data at issue; Hearsay (FRE 802).

Relevance (FRE 402, 403), not related to any data at issue; Hearsay (FRE 802); Incomplete document.

Relevance (FRE 402, 403), not related to any data at issue; Hearsay (FRE 802).

-5-

Case 1:01-cv-00413-JLK-BNB

Document 232

Filed 09/10/2007

Page 6 of 17

No. 98

Description TGS Nopec Letter to Kerr-McGee Oil & Gas (to Christian) Re: Transfer/Temporary Storage KM-002349 2/24/99 Seitel Data Letter to Oryx Energy Company (Horsfall) Re: Refusal of Request of Transfer KM-008503 2/15/99 Seismic Exchange, Inc Letter to Oryx Energy Company (Horsfall) Re: Data Non-Transferable KM-002314 2/19/99 TGS Nopec Letter to Oryx Energy (Horsfall) Re: Non-Transferable Data/ Transfer Fees KM-00476 2/2/99 Western Geophysical Letter to Oryx Energy Company (Horsfall) Re: Refusal of Transfer KM-008539 1/29/99 Kerr-McGee Letter to Thistle, Inc (to Robert Gray) Re: Return/Destruction of Data KM01704 - KM01705 8/25/99 TGS Nopec Letter to Kerr-McGee Oil & Gas Corporation (Christian) Re: Transfer Fees KM-002339 4/8/99

Objection Relevance (FRE 402,403), not related to any data at issue; Hearsay (FRE 802).

99

Relevance (FRE 402, 403), not related to any data at issue; Hearsay (FRE 802).

100

Relevance (FRE 402, 403), not related to any data at issue; Hearsay (FRE 802).

101

Relevance (FRE 402, 403), not related to any data at issue; Hearsay (FRE 802).

102

Relevance (FRE 402, 403), not related to any data at issue; Hearsay (FRE 802).

103

Relevance (FRE 402, 403), not related to any data at issue.

104

Relevance (FRE 402, 403), not related to any data at issue; Hearsay (FRE 802).

-6-

Case 1:01-cv-00413-JLK-BNB

Document 232

Filed 09/10/2007

Page 7 of 17

No. 105

Description Kerr McGee Letter to Geotrak Corporation Re: Geotrak Seismic Data (previously listed as "blank") 4/20/99 KM02229 Kerr-McGee Oil & Gas Corporation Letter to TGS Nopec (Christian) Re: Transfer Fees KM-002340 4/6/99 Geotrak Letter to Kerr-McGee Oil & Gas Corporation (Christian) Re: Data Non-Transferable KM00365 4/5/99 Fairfield Industries Letter to KerrMcGee Corporation (Morton). Re: Overriding Royalty Interests KM-002191 3/26/99

Objection Relevance (FRE 402, 403), not related to any data at issue.

106

Relevance (FRE 402, 403), not related to any data at issue.

107

Relevance (FRE 402, 403), not related to any data at issue; Hearsay (FRE 802).

108

109

110

111

Kerr-McGee Oil & Gas Letter to Western Geophysical KM-004945 3/22/99 Schlumberger Geco-Prakla Letter to Kerr-McGee (Horsfall) Re: Transfer Fee KM-004945 3/22/99 Kerr-McGee Corporation Letter to Fairfield Industries (from Salazar) Re: Termination of Licenses KM00461 3/15/99

Relevance (FRE 402, 403), not related to any data at issue; Hearsay (FRE 802). If Plaintiff is permitted to admit Exhibit 89, Defendant may offer the document attached hereto as Defendant's Exhibit D20 and D21. Relevance (FRE 402, 403), not related to any data at issue. Relevance (FRE 402, 403), not related to any data at issue; Hearsay (FRE 802).

Relevance (FRE 402, 403), not related to any data at issue.

-7-

Case 1:01-cv-00413-JLK-BNB

Document 232

Filed 09/10/2007

Page 8 of 17

No. 112

Description Western Geophysical Letter to Oryx Energy Company (Horsfall) Re: Data Non-Transferable KM00478 1/29/99 TGS Nopec Letter to Oryx Energy (Horsfall) Re: Non-Transferable Data/ Transfer Fees KM-008570 2/2/99 Geotrak Letter to Oryx Energy Company ((Horsfall) Re: Non-Transferable Data KM-002233 2/9/99 Jebco Letter to Oryx Energy Company (Horsfall) Re: Transfer Fee KM-002144 2/15/99 Seital Data Letter Oryx Energy Company (Horsfall) Re: Data Non Transferable KM-008503 2/15/99 Seismic Exchange Inc Letter to Oryx Energy Company (Horsfall) Re: Transfer Fee KM-00470 2/19/99 TGA Topec Letter to Kerr-McGee Oil & Gas Corporation (Christian) Re: Transfer Fee/Summary KM-008563 - KM-008564 3/1/99

Objection Relevance (FRE 402, 403), not related to any data at issue; Hearsay (FRE 802).

113

Relevance (FRE 402, 403), not related to any data at issue; Hearsay (FRE 802).

114

Relevance (FRE 402, 403), not related to any data at issue; Hearsay (FRE 802).

115

Relevance (FRE 402, 403), not related to any data at issue; Hearsay (FRE 802).

116

Relevance (FRE 402, 403), not related to any data at issue; Hearsay (FRE 802).

118

Relevance (FRE 402, 403), not related to any data at issue; Hearsay (FRE 802).

119

Relevance (FRE 402, 403), not related to any data at issue; Hearsay (FRE 802).

-8-

Case 1:01-cv-00413-JLK-BNB

Document 232

Filed 09/10/2007

Page 9 of 17

No. 120

Description Kerr-McGee Oil & Gas Corporation Letter to Geotrak Corporation (from Christian) Re: Refusal of Transfer Fee KM-02230 4/14/99 Glen Morton Letter to Jeff Roberts Subject: The Handling of Seismic Data in the Merger KM-002399 ­ KM-002410 12/9/98 Seitel Data Letter to Oryx Energy (Pat Horsfall) Re: Request for Transfer of Data From Oryx to Kerr McGee KM 008503 7/16/P SEI Letter to Oryx (Pat Horsfall) Re: Request for Transfer of Data from Oryx to Kerr McGee KM 002314 1/25/99 Western Geophysical Letter to Oryx (Pat Horsfall) Re: Request for Transfer of Data from Oryx to Kerr McGee KM 008539 1/29/99 Kerr McGee Letter to Seital (From Schlirf) Re: Request of Grace Period on Transfer Fees KM 002320 2/22/99 PGl Letter to Sun Exploration and Production Company (Amonett to Fleming) Re: Contracts KM 00008 2/14/85

Objection Relevance (FRE 402, 403), not related to any data at issue.

121

Relevance (FRE 402, 403), not related to any data at issue.

133

Relevance (FRE 402, 403), not related to any data at issue; Hearsay (FRE 802).

134

Relevance (FRE 402, 403), not related to any data at issue; Hearsay (FRE 802).

135

Relevance (FRE 402, 403), not related to any data at issue; Hearsay (FRE 802).

136

Relevance (FRE 402, 403), not related to any data at issue.

141

Relevance (FRE 402, 403); incomplete document, referenced license agreements not attached.

-9-

Case 1:01-cv-00413-JLK-BNB

Document 232

Filed 09/10/2007

Page 10 of 17

No. 142

Description Pelz Letter to Kerr-McGee Corporation (Tom Schultz) Re: Termination of 1994 License Agreement Encl: MD09-06 - MD09-07 5/13/94 4/28/04 (Date of Letter) Holland & Hart Letter to Harlan Pelz Re: Response to Correspondence to Kerr McGee/ Tom Schultz 5/12/04 Davis Graham and Stubbs Letter to Pelz, Encl: KM001891-KM001897 (PGI Lines and Purchase Agreements)

Objection Letter from Harlan P. Pelz: Hearsay (FRE 402) M00906-07: see also Exhibit 60.

143

Hearsay (FRE 802); Relevance (FRE 402, 403); see also objections to Exhibit 60. Hearsay (FRE 802); Relevance (FRE 402) as to letter; Defendant will stipulate as to enclosures upon showing that documents correspond to data that Plaintiff alleges to be missing or unaccounted for. Hearsay (FRE 802) and Relevance (FRE 402) as to letter by counsel; stipulate as to enclosures. Relevance (FRE 402, 403), not related to any data at issue. Relevance (FRE 402, 403), not related to any data at issue.

144

148

149

150

Holland & Hart Letter to Pelz Re: Additional Disclosures Encl: KM5 00623 - KM5 00630, KM5 00636 - KM5 00656 4/5/04 Brian Lindsey Overview Letter Re: SEI Negotiations KM 002315 6/3/99 Glenn Morton Email Correspondence to Schlirf, Christian, Horsfall, Patterson Re: Cheaper to Get Seismic Now 2/17/99 & Dave Christian Email Correspondence to Horsfall, Morton, Schlirf Re: Seismic Transfer (Payouts) 4/14/99 KM 008346 - KM 008347, KM 008336

-10-

Case 1:01-cv-00413-JLK-BNB

Document 232

Filed 09/10/2007

Page 11 of 17

No. 157

Description MD Mark Inc vs. Kerr-McGee Corporation and Oryx Energy Company: Affidavit of Marilyn Young 2 Pages 12/8/03 MD Mark Inc vs. Kerr-McGee Corporation and Oryx Energy Company: Response to Plaintiff MD Mark Inc.'s Third Request for Production of Documents and Interrogatories to Defendants KerrMcGee Corporation and Oryx Energy Company 14 Pages 6/X/02 MD Mark Inc vs. Kerr-McGee Corporation and Oryx Energy Company: Response to Plaintiff MD Mark Inc.'s Fourth Request for Production of Documents and Interrogatories to Defendants KerrMcGee Corporation and Oryx Energy Company 8 Pages I/29/03 MD Mark Inc vs. Kerr-McGee Corporation and Oryx Energy Company: Response to Plaintiff MD Mark Inc.'s Fifth Request for Production of Documents and Interrogatories to Defendants KerrMcGee Corporation and Oryx Energy Company 28 Pages 10/31/03

Objection Hearsay (FRE 802).

158

Hearsay (FRE 802); written discovery prepared for litigation.

159

Hearsay (FRE 802); written discovery prepared for litigation.

160

Hearsay (FRE 802); written discovery prepared for litigation.

-11-

Case 1:01-cv-00413-JLK-BNB

Document 232

Filed 09/10/2007

Page 12 of 17

No. 161

Description MD Mark Inc vs. Kerr-McGee Corporation and Oryx Energy Company: KMG Objections to Plaintiff's Fifth Set Of Interrogatories And Requests For Production of Documents Propounded to Defendants 16 Pages 9/22/03 MD Mark Inc vs. Kerr-McGee Corporation and Oryx Energy Company: Response to Plaintiff MD Mark Inc.'s Fifth Set of Interrogatories and Requests for Production of Documents Propounded to Defendants 28 Pages 10/31/03 MD Mark Inc vs. Kerr-McGee Corporation and Oryx Energy Company: Supplemental Response to Plaintiff MD Mark, Inc.'s Fourth Request for Production of Documents and Interrogatories to Defendants Kerr-McGee Corporation and Oryx Energy Group 3 Pages 4/18/03 MD Mark Inc vs. Kerr-McGee Corporation and Oryx Energy Company: Supplemental Response to Plaintiff MD Mark, Inc.'s Third Request for Production of Documents and Interrogatories to Defendants Kerr-McGee Corporation and Oryx Energy Group NO BATES 5 Pages 1/14/03

Objection Hearsay (FRE 802); written discovery prepared for litigation.

162

Hearsay (FRE 802); written discovery prepared for litigation.

163

Hearsay (FRE 802); written discovery prepared for litigation.

164

Hearsay (FRE 802); written discovery prepared for litigation.

-12-

Case 1:01-cv-00413-JLK-BNB

Document 232

Filed 09/10/2007

Page 13 of 17

No. 165

Description Kerr-McGee Corporation's Certifications Pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P. 26 (g) 3 Pages 6/1/04 MD Mark Inc vs. Kerr-McGee Corporation and Oryx Energy Company: Plaintiffs Amended Notice of F.R.C.P. 30(b)(6) Video Deposition to Kerr-McGee Corporation 15 Pages 5/21/04 MD Mark Inc vs. Kerr-McGee Corporation and Oryx Energy Company: Plaintiff's Response to Defendants' Fourth set of Discovery Requests 13 Pages (No Bates) 11 /13/03 Davies Depo Ex. 125 Results From Carlos Salazar Re: Transfers KM00672 Sun/Oryx Seismic Licenses Revised Mile MD03-01 - MD03-20 4/16/02 Kerr McGee Seismic Data Licenses MD2-00013 - MD2-00015 11/27/01 Davies Depo Ex. 25 Kerr McGee Seismic Data Licenses MD05-00578 - MD05-00580 11/15/03 Davies Depo Ex. 118

Objection Hearsay (FRE 802); written discovery prepared for litigation.

166

Hearsay (FRE 802); written discovery prepared for litigation.

167

Hearsay (FRE 802); written discovery prepared for litigation.

168

169

Relevance (FRE 402, 403), not related to any data at issue. Hearsay (FRE 802), prepared by Plaintiff for this litigation. Hearsay (FRE 802), prepared by Plaintiff for this litigation.

170

172

Hearsay (FRE 802), prepared by Plaintiff for this litigation.

-13-

Case 1:01-cv-00413-JLK-BNB

Document 232

Filed 09/10/2007

Page 14 of 17

No. 173

Description Marietta Basin Resolution Group Survey data Sales 1983 MD05-00575 - MD05-0577 DATE UNKNOWN Davies Depo Ex. 119 Original Participants Marietta Basin Resolution Group Survey Phase I MD05-00573 - MD05-00574 DATE UNKNOWN Davies Depo Ex. 119 Kerr McGee Seismic Data Licenses MD2 00013 - MD2 00015 11/27/01 Davies Depo Ex. 130 Mid-Con Inventory Listing of Kerr McGee Data Data in Kerr McGee Possession NO BATES 5/21/04 MDM Seis Lines - Check Out History Hahn Depo. Ex. I KM002629 Sun/Oryx Tapes Not Returned 2 pages Sun/Oryx Seismic Films Not Returned 6 pages Oryx Contract/Kerr McGee Contract KM 008647 - KM 008648 Pelz Letter to Holland & Hart Encl: PGI Synopsis MD11-0003 - MD11-0037 and MD11-0054 ­ MD11-0083 3/23/04 Davies Depo Ex. 135

Objection Hearsay (FRE 802); Relevance (FRE 402).

174

Hearsay (FRE 802); Relevance (FRE 402).

175

Hearsay (FRE 802), prepared by Plaintiff for this litigation.

177

Hearsay (FRE 802), prepared by Plaintiff for this litigation.

178

Hearsay (FRE 802).

179

180

182

183

Hearsay (FRE 802), prepared by Plaintiff for this litigation. Hearsay (FRE 802), prepared by Plaintiff for this litigation. Relevance (FRE 402, 403), not related to any data at issue. Hearsay (FRE 802) as to Harlan P. Pelz letter, Relevance (FRE 402, 403) as to MD11-0003-0037, MD110054-0083).

-14-

Case 1:01-cv-00413-JLK-BNB

Document 232

Filed 09/10/2007

Page 15 of 17

No. 187

Description Kerr McGee Corporation Data Transmittal Ref: 4037 NO BATES 1/9/97 Helm Depo. Ex. 1 Houtex Seismic Inc Letter of Transmittal to Kerr McGee Corporation MD05-00570 9/22/87 Davies Depo Ex. 119 Houtex Seismic Inc Letter of Transmittal to Kerr McGee Corporation MD05-00572 9/18/87 Davies Depo Ex. 119. PGI Invoice to Kerr McGee Corporation Invoice No. 300897 MD05-00571 10/12/87 Davies Depo Ex. 119 PGI South AK/North LA Seismic Data Index Map Seismic Data Map Mike Elliott Deposition Exhibit 6 KM00083

Objection Hearsay (FRE 802).

189

Relevance (FRE 402, 403); Hearsay (FRE 802).

190

Relevance (FRE 402); Hearsay (FRE 802).

196

Relevance (FRE 402).

200 201

Hearsay (FRE 802). Hearsay (FRE 802); Plaintiff's version is incomplete. If ruled admissible, Defendant will provide complete document from original deposition transcript of Mike Elliott. Hearsay (FRE 802); not previously disclosed (FRCP 37(c)(1). Hearsay (FRE 802); not previously disclosed (FRCP 37(c)(1).

203

204

Marathon Oil Company Letter to POI 1/16/91 NO BATES POI Letter to Marathon Oil Company 2/21/91 NO BATES

-15-

Case 1:01-cv-00413-JLK-BNB

Document 232

Filed 09/10/2007

Page 16 of 17

Dated: September 10, 2007 Respectfully submitted,

s/ M. Antonio Gallegos Scott S. Barker Gregory E. Goldberg M. Antonio Gallegos H OLLAND & H ART LLP 555 Seventeenth Street, Suite 3200 Post Office Box 8749 Denver, Colorado 80201-8749 (303) 295-8000 A TTORNEYS F OR D EFENDANTS

-16-

Case 1:01-cv-00413-JLK-BNB

Document 232

Filed 09/10/2007

Page 17 of 17

C ERTIFICATE O F S ERVICE
I hereby certify that on September 10, 2007, I electronically filed Defendant's Rule 26(a)(3) Objections to Plaintiff's Trial Exhibits with the Clerk of Court using CM/ECF system, which will serve, via electronic mail, the following: P ELZ , B ONIFAZI & I NDERWISCH , P.C. Harlan P. Pelz Daniele W. Bonifazi [email protected] [email protected]

s/ Sally A. Walter

3759463_1.DOC

-17-