Free Response to Motion - District Court of Colorado - Colorado

Case 1:01-cv-02199-MSK-MEH

Document 492-22

Filed 06/01/2007

Page 1 of 34

Case 1:01-cv-02199-MSK-MEH

Document 492-22

Filed 06/01/2007

Page 2 of 34

Clawson v. Mountain Coal
Plaintiff's Time Entries -- Motion for Attorneys' Fees (By Attorney)

2180.01

5/1/2006 JKK

1

250

0.1

25.00

7564 Instructions to staff regarding billings on costs Staff directions to DDavis concerning motions for back pay, front pay and punitive damages; staff directions to CHRichter regarding billing 7699 time Conference w/CHRichter regarding reduction 7761 in billing

2180.01

5/10/2006 JKK

1

250

0.4

100.00

2180.01

5/18/2006 JKK

1

250

0.16

40.00

2180.01

5/18/2006 JKK

1

250

0.26

65.00

7762 Review billing issues Review entry of time for trial - certain trial 7763 dates on issue of attorney fees Reduce billing in certain categories; 7823 conference x 2 w/CHRichter Instructions to CHRichter regarding procedures for reducing attorney fees billed in 7825 case Conference w/CHRichter about billing rate for 7894 JPGuthro, Beecher Threatt & paralegal Revise Motion for Attorney Fees, Costs and 7978 Interest

2180.01

5/18/2006 JKK

1

250

0.26

65.00

2180.01

5/19/2006 JKK

1

250

0.76

190.00

2180.01

5/22/2006 JKK

1

250

0.26

65.00

2180.01

5/25/2006 JKK

1

250

0.16

40.00

2180.01

6/5/2006 JKK

1

250

0.5

125.00

2180.01

6/5/2006 JKK

1

250

1

250.00

7979 Revise Motion for Attorney Fees

2180.01

6/28/2006 JKK

1

250

0.5

125.00

8132 Revise Request for Attorney Fees

2180.01

8/17/2006 JKK

1

250

0.76

190.00

8161 Review request for attorney fees

3709245_1.XLS

Page 1 of 33

Case 1:01-cv-02199-MSK-MEH

Document 492-22

Filed 06/01/2007

Page 3 of 34

Clawson v. Mountain Coal
Plaintiff's Time Entries -- Motion for Attorneys' Fees (By Attorney)

2180.01

10/4/2006 JKK

1

250

0.9

225.00

8182 Attorney fee and cost issues

6.02

1,505.00

Subtotal - JKK Office conference w/DDavis regarding 7578 Attorneys fees, costs, M/Clarification

2180.01

5/3/2006 JCJ

3

200

0.36

72.00

0.36

72.00

Subtotal - JCJ

2180.01

5/2/2006 DJD

5

150

0.12

18.00

7607 looking for information on costs on computer

2180.01

5/2/2006 DJD

5

150

0.5

75.00

7608 research on allowable costs under the ADA

2180.01

5/2/2006 DJD

5

150

0.5

75.00

7610 research on awardable costs under the ADA

2180.01

5/3/2006 DJD

5

150

0.26

39.00

7613 research on awardable costs research procedure on obtaining an award of 7614 costs call district court clerk regarding use of bill of 7615 cost form in an ADA case discuss with CRichter attorney fees and costs 7616 and plan for proceeding speaking to JJensen and CRichter about 7617 costs and cost procedure and attorney fees research on costs, timing for bill of costs, and 7618 other costs procedures

2180.01

5/3/2006 DJD

5

150

0.5

75.00

2180.01

5/3/2006 DJD

5

150

0.26

39.00

2180.01

5/3/2006 DJD

5

150

0.5

75.00

2180.01

5/3/2006 DJD

5

150

0.76

114.00

2180.01

5/3/2006 DJD

5

150

1

150.00

3709245_1.XLS

Page 2 of 33

Case 1:01-cv-02199-MSK-MEH

Document 492-22

Filed 06/01/2007

Page 4 of 34

Clawson v. Mountain Coal
Plaintiff's Time Entries -- Motion for Attorneys' Fees (By Attorney)

2180.01

5/5/2006 DJD

5

150

1.5

225.00

research on award of permissible costs and 7627 procedure for collecting costs

2180.01

5/8/2006 DJD

5

150

1

150.00

7765 research allowable costs under ADA

2180.01

5/8/2006 DJD

5

150

1

150.00

7766 research allowable costs under the ADA

2180.01

5/8/2006 DJD

5

150

0.76

114.00

7767 research on allowable costs under the ADA

2180.01

5/8/2006 DJD

5

150

2.5

375.00

7768 research allowable costs under the ADA

2180.01

5/11/2006 DJD

5

150

0.26

39.00

7785 review time sheets for duplicate time entries speaking to CRichter about attorney fees 7903 motion work on bill of costs and costs as part of 8011 attorney fees

2180.01

5/22/2006 DJD

5

150

0.5

75.00

2180.01

6/1/2006 DJD

5

150

1.76

264.00

2180.01

6/1/2006 DJD

5

150

0.26

39.00

8013 work on bill of costs

2180.01

6/1/2006 DJD

5

150

0.26

39.00

8015 work on bill of costs

2180.01

6/2/2006 DJD

5

150

0.26

39.00

8016 work on bill of costs

2180.01

6/2/2006 DJD

5

150

0.38

57.00

8017 work on bill of costs

2180.01

6/2/2006 DJD

5

150

0.1

15.00

8018 work on bill of costs

3709245_1.XLS

Page 3 of 33

Case 1:01-cv-02199-MSK-MEH

Document 492-22

Filed 06/01/2007

Page 5 of 34

Clawson v. Mountain Coal
Plaintiff's Time Entries -- Motion for Attorneys' Fees (By Attorney)

2180.01

6/2/2006 DJD

5

150

0.26

39.00

8020 work on bill of costs

2180.01

6/2/2006 DJD

5

150

0.5

75.00

8021 work on bill of costs

2180.01

6/2/2006 DJD

5

150

0.38

57.00

8023 work on bill of costs working on bill of costs and motion for 8033 expenses

2180.01

6/5/2006 DJD

5

150

0.76

114.00

2180.01

6/13/2006 DJD

5

150

0.26

39.00

8092 discuss cost issue with CRichter

2180.01

6/28/2006 DJD

5

150

0.5

75.00

8149 reading motion for attorney fees and costs

2180.01

8/15/2006 DJD

5

150

0.26

39.00

8172 reading motion for attorney fees

2180.01

8/15/2006 DJD

5

150

0.5

75.00

8173 reading motion for attorney fees reviewing research for use in motion for 8174 attorney fees and expenses

2180.01

8/15/2006 DJD

5

150

0.26

39.00

2180.01

8/17/2006 DJD

5

150

0.5

75.00

8175 meeting on attorney fees and costs

2180.01

10/3/2006 DJD

5

150

0.26

39.00

8185 discussing attorney fees motion with CRichter meet with KKillian and CRichter regarding 8186 attorney fees and costs meet with CRichter regarding costs and 8187 expenses

2180.01

10/4/2006 DJD

5

150

0.76

114.00

2180.01

10/4/2006 DJD

5

150

1.5

225.00

3709245_1.XLS

Page 4 of 33

Case 1:01-cv-02199-MSK-MEH

Document 492-22

Filed 06/01/2007

Page 6 of 34

Clawson v. Mountain Coal
Plaintiff's Time Entries -- Motion for Attorneys' Fees (By Attorney)

21.64

3,246.00

Subtotal - DJD

2180.01

4/28/2006 CHR

6

90

0.66

59.40

7533 Research Attorney's Fees

2180.01

4/28/2006 CHR

6

90

0.34

30.60

7534 Research ADA cases and Attorney fees Research Attorney's Fees cases Emp. 7535 Practice Series Research Attorney Fees cases Emp. Practice 7536 Series

2180.01

4/28/2006 CHR

6

90

0.26

23.40

2180.01

4/28/2006 CHR

6

90

0.5

45.00

2180.01

4/28/2006 CHR

6

90

0.2

18.00

7537 Research Block Billing

2180.01

5/1/2006 CHR

6

90

1

90.00

7539 Reviewing Billing Records for April/Trial Research Grounkauf v. Stauffer 7540 congressional intent of Attorney's Fees Discuss with D.D. back pay/costs/attorneys' 7541 fees issues Research Johnson v. Georgia Highway Express - 12 factors for reasonable attorney's 7542 fees

2180.01

5/1/2006 CHR

6

90

0.5

45.00

2180.01

5/1/2006 CHR

6

90

0.18

16.20

2180.01

5/1/2006 CHR

6

90

0.18

16.20

2180.01

5/1/2006 CHR

6

90

0.18

16.20

7543 Research Hensley v. Eckert Hensley v. Eckert - reasonable 7544 fees/successful claim

2180.01

5/1/2006 CHR

6

90

0.5

45.00

3709245_1.XLS

Page 5 of 33

Case 1:01-cv-02199-MSK-MEH

Document 492-22

Filed 06/01/2007

Page 7 of 34

Clawson v. Mountain Coal
Plaintiff's Time Entries -- Motion for Attorneys' Fees (By Attorney)

2180.01

5/1/2006 CHR

6

90

0.1

9.00

Spensieri v. Farmers Alliance Mutual Ins. Co. 7545 - presumption of reasonableness/Expert fees

2180.01

5/1/2006 CHR

6

90

0.18

16.20

Research Powell v. COBE labs, inc. - need 7546 for detailed billing records Review Order of Fees and Costs in Buniger case for applicable case law and what court 7557 most concerned with Getting cases cited in order by Buniger Court 7558 Awarding Fees and Costs - 7 cases from lexis

2180.01

5/2/2006 CHR

6

90

0.76

68.40

2180.01

5/2/2006 CHR

6

90

0.26

23.40

2180.01

5/2/2006 CHR

6

90

0.34

30.60

7559 Research Jane L. Bangerter 61 F.3d 1505 Meeting with JKK, DD, KRS, MR about fees, 7560 costs and interest on judgment Ramos v. Lamm 713 F.2d 546 - reasonable 7561 fees (criteria) Godinet v. mgmt & training corp. 182 f.supp 2d 1108 - westlaw is part of costs/duplicative 7562 attorneys NM Cit. for Clean air and water 72 f.3d 830 7563 non-professional v. secretarial work Cf. Brown v. Unified School Dist. No. 51 878 7567 F. Supp 1430 Carr v. Ft. Morgan Sch. Dist. 4 F. supp 2d 7568 1198

2180.01

5/2/2006 CHR

6

90

0.5

45.00

2180.01

5/2/2006 CHR

6

90

0.4

36.00

2180.01

5/2/2006 CHR

6

90

0.26

23.40

2180.01

5/2/2006 CHR

6

90

0.18

16.20

2180.01

5/3/2006 CHR

6

90

0.4

36.00

2180.01

5/3/2006 CHR

6

90

0.34

30.60

2180.01

5/3/2006 CHR

6

90

0.1

9.00

7569 Fees on Excel sheet

3709245_1.XLS

Page 6 of 33

Case 1:01-cv-02199-MSK-MEH

Document 492-22

Filed 06/01/2007

Page 8 of 34

Clawson v. Mountain Coal
Plaintiff's Time Entries -- Motion for Attorneys' Fees (By Attorney)

2180.01

5/3/2006 CHR

6

90

0.1

9.00

Transpower constr. v. grand river dam authority - 905 f.2d 1413 - Post judgment 7570 interest on Attorney Fees Clawson Excelsheet of Fees - managing 7571 sheet into specific time makers Clawson Fees Sheet - breaking out fees by 7572 timekeeper Discuss costs and back pay and fees and 7573 interest with D.D. Clawson Fees Sheet breaking out by 7574 timekeeper Clawson Fees Sheet - outline of how to attack and organize this information for the 7575 motion Clawson Fees by TMK, each timekeeper on a 7588 separate Excel Sheet

2180.01

5/3/2006 CHR

6

90

0.26

23.40

2180.01

5/3/2006 CHR

6

90

0.26

23.40

2180.01

5/3/2006 CHR

6

90

0.5

45.00

2180.01

5/3/2006 CHR

6

90

0.18

16.20

2180.01

5/3/2006 CHR

6

90

0.18

16.20

2180.01

5/4/2006 CHR

6

90

1.18

106.20

2180.01

5/5/2006 CHR

6

90

0.18

16.20

Discussed with D.D. plan for fees (how to 7589 address review of fees for reasonableness)

2180.01

5/5/2006 CHR

6

90

0.5

45.00

Organizing Cases and past research for 7590 memo to JKK about fees Memo to JKK about case law, attorney fees intro to memo - presumption of prevailing 7591 party attorney fees Memo to JKK on fees - Reasonable hours 7592 case law Outlining of cases for reasonable fees, 7593 substantial success, factors for adjustment.

2180.01

5/5/2006 CHR

6

90

1.26

113.40

2180.01

5/5/2006 CHR

6

90

0.5

45.00

2180.01

5/5/2006 CHR

6

90

0.26

23.40

3709245_1.XLS

Page 7 of 33

Case 1:01-cv-02199-MSK-MEH

Document 492-22

Filed 06/01/2007

Page 9 of 34

Clawson v. Mountain Coal
Plaintiff's Time Entries -- Motion for Attorneys' Fees (By Attorney)

2180.01

5/5/2006 CHR

6

90

0.5

45.00

7594 Memo to JKK case law on reasonable rates

2180.01

5/5/2006 CHR

6

90

0.6

54.00

Memo to JKK 12 factors of johnson v. ga 7595 highway express Memo to JKK about costs/expert 7596 fees/electronic research

2180.01

5/5/2006 CHR

6

90

0.5

45.00

2180.01

5/5/2006 CHR

6

90

0.26

23.40

Figuring out how to actually address review 7597 of fees in the case the most efficient way. Revisions to memo about attorney fees to 7598 JKK

2180.01

5/5/2006 CHR

6

90

0.34

30.60

2180.01

5/5/2006 CHR

6

90

0.1

9.00

7599 Discuss with JKK attorney fees issues

2180.01

5/8/2006 CHR

6

90

0.34

30.60

Gathering and Sorting Billing Records Spread sheet per timemaker by Attorneys and 7628 paralegals Discuss with JKK Review of Fees - deletions, 7629 revisions of comments Reviewing JKK Billing Records 10/11/00 7630 8/10/05 Reviewing JKK Billing Records 8/17/057631 4/27/06

2180.01

5/8/2006 CHR

6

90

0.1

9.00

2180.01

5/8/2006 CHR

6

90

1.66

149.40

2180.01

5/8/2006 CHR

6

90

0.6

54.00

3709245_1.XLS

Page 8 of 33

Case 1:01-cv-02199-MSK-MEH

Document 492-22

Filed 06/01/2007

Page 10 of 34

Clawson v. Mountain Coal
Plaintiff's Time Entries -- Motion for Attorneys' Fees (By Attorney)

2180.01

5/8/2006 CHR

6

90

1.3

117.00

Reviewing JCJ Billing Records 2/14/01 7632 2/19/03 Reviewing JCJ Billing Records 2/19/037633 4/13/06 Reviewing D.D. billing records 10/01/02 7634 3/25/05 Reviewing D.D. billing records 3/25/05 7635 7/21/05 Reviewing D.D. billing records 7/21/05 7636 4/19/05 Reviewing KS billing records 3/20/02 7637 1/20/06 Meeting with JKK, D.D. , KS on post trial 7638 motions/updates on Billing review

2180.01

5/8/2006 CHR

6

90

0.34

30.60

2180.01

5/8/2006 CHR

6

90

0.76

68.40

2180.01

5/8/2006 CHR

6

90

0.26

23.40

2180.01

5/8/2006 CHR

6

90

0.26

23.40

2180.01

5/9/2006 CHR

6

90

1.26

113.40

2180.01

5/9/2006 CHR

6

90

0.4

36.00

2180.01

5/9/2006 CHR

6

90

0.9

81.00

7639 Review KS Billing Records 1/20/06 - 4/25/06

2180.01

5/9/2006 CHR

6

90

0.6

54.00

Review Prior Paralegal Billing Records 7640 11/25/99 - 3/27/02 Review Prior Paralegal Billing Records 7641 3/27/02 - 4/2/02 Discuss with D.D. Depos of Bartlett and Richards (witnesses at trial) - attorneys' fees 7642 and cost motion

2180.01

5/9/2006 CHR

6

90

0.18

16.20

2180.01

5/9/2006 CHR

6

90

0.2

18.00

2180.01

5/9/2006 CHR

6

90

1

90.00

7643 Review Prior Billing records 4/2/02 - 10/1/02

3709245_1.XLS

Page 9 of 33

Case 1:01-cv-02199-MSK-MEH

Document 492-22

Filed 06/01/2007

Page 11 of 34

Clawson v. Mountain Coal
Plaintiff's Time Entries -- Motion for Attorneys' Fees (By Attorney)

2180.01

5/9/2006 CHR

6

90

0.1

9.00

Discussed with D.D. Deletion of fees related 7644 to wives Depo (only called b/c of H's case)

2180.01

5/9/2006 CHR

6

90

0.4

36.00

7645 Review Prior Paralegal 10/1/02 - 10/31/02 Review Prior Paralegal Billing Records 7646 10/31/02 - 4/10/03

2180.01

5/9/2006 CHR

6

90

1

90.00

2180.01

5/9/2006 CHR

6

90

0.8

72.00

7647 Review Prior Paralegal 4/10/03 - 3/28/05 Updated JKK Billing Excel sheet w/ information from MR (Actual time spent was divided between the clients - meaning 1 hour 7649 was divided to .25 per client for all tasks)

2180.01

5/10/2006 CHR

6

90

0.18

16.20

2180.01

5/10/2006 CHR

6

90

0.76

68.40

Review CHR Billing Records 2/2/06 - 3/21/06 7650 (Syncing up meetings with others on the case) Meeting with JKK, DJD, KS on post trial 7651 motions - fees/costs/pay Review CHR Billing Records 3/21/06 4/27/06 (Syncing up meetings with others on 7652 the case) Getting order of Trial day - witness testimony times for billing. Syncing up times and days where attorneys were present. Deleting 3rd attorney time where not necessary for the 7653 trial.

2180.01

5/10/2006 CHR

6

90

0.26

23.40

2180.01

5/10/2006 CHR

6

90

0.7

63.00

2180.01

5/10/2006 CHR

6

90

0.6

54.00

2180.01

5/10/2006 CHR

6

90

0.9

81.00

Trial date billing - making sure all attorneys accurately reflect time by witness testimony. 7654 Deletion of additional attorney time.

3709245_1.XLS

Page 10 of 33

Case 1:01-cv-02199-MSK-MEH

Document 492-22

Filed 06/01/2007

Page 12 of 34

Clawson v. Mountain Coal
Plaintiff's Time Entries -- Motion for Attorneys' Fees (By Attorney)

2180.01

5/10/2006 CHR

6

90

0.5

45.00

Excel Billing Sheets (Correcting division of 7655 time to accurately reflect hours on the task)

2180.01

5/10/2006 CHR

6

90

1

90.00

Prior Paralegal - Excel billing sheet, marking deletions and reductions in time for due to not 7656 part of the prevailing clients' case.

2180.01

5/10/2006 CHR

6

90

0.26

23.40

Meeting with JKK about Block Billing by TS. 7657 Need to have her sort through her time. Excel Sheet for TS to review all the times that could be Block billing, for her to accurately 7658 reflect the time on each task

2180.01

5/10/2006 CHR

6

90

0.5

45.00

2180.01

5/10/2006 CHR

6

90

0.6

54.00

Email to TS - attached spread sheet of time that could be block billed. Directions on what to do and when to get back to us with her 7659 detailed time on each task KS excel billing sheet. Total fees subtracting 7660 deletions and deductions. JKK Excel Billing Sheet - marking deletions 7661 and reductions for court JKK Excel Billing sheet - marking deletions 7662 and reductions for presentation to the court JKK Excel Billing Sheet - marking deletions 7663 and reductions for presentation to the court. JKK Excel Billing Spread sheet - subtracting 7664 deletions and reductions from total time JCJ Excel Billing sheet - marking deletions 7665 and reductions for presentation to court

2180.01

5/11/2006 CHR

6

90

1.5

135.00

2180.01

5/11/2006 CHR

6

90

0.18

16.20

2180.01

5/11/2006 CHR

6

90

0.5

45.00

2180.01

5/11/2006 CHR

6

90

0.66

59.40

2180.01

5/11/2006 CHR

6

90

0.18

16.20

2180.01

5/11/2006 CHR

6

90

0.84

75.60

3709245_1.XLS

Page 11 of 33

Case 1:01-cv-02199-MSK-MEH

Document 492-22

Filed 06/01/2007

Page 13 of 34

Clawson v. Mountain Coal
Plaintiff's Time Entries -- Motion for Attorneys' Fees (By Attorney)

2180.01

5/11/2006 CHR

6

90

0.5

45.00

JCJ Excel Spread Sheet - marking deletion and reductions, subtracting deletions and 7666 reductions from total time. Discuss with DJD possible duplication of entries, give copy of his billing record for 7667 review Prior Attorney Excel Sheet deletions and 7668 reductions

2180.01

5/11/2006 CHR

6

90

0.18

16.20

2180.01

5/11/2006 CHR

6

90

0.26

23.40

2180.01

5/11/2006 CHR

6

90

0.34

30.60

7669 Discuss Billing/costs/interest with DJD Prior Attorney Billing Excel Sheet - deletions 7671 and reductions.

2180.01

5/11/2006 CHR

6

90

0.5

45.00

2180.01

5/12/2006 CHR

6

90

0.5

45.00

7687 KS deletions (Reasons for Reductions)

2180.01

5/12/2006 CHR

6

90

0.2

18.00

Prior Attorney Fees Deleted and Reduced 7688 (Total: Reduced and deleted)

2180.01

5/12/2006 CHR

6

90

0.18

16.20

Formatting Presentation of Fees Former 7689 Attorney KS Formatting Excel Sheet for all data to fit 7690 on page Times for 2nd day of Trial (minutes not 7691 specific) Checklist for what needs to be completed on 7692 the Billing Record

2180.01

5/12/2006 CHR

6

90

0.18

16.20

2180.01

5/12/2006 CHR

6

90

0.18

16.20

2180.01

5/12/2006 CHR

6

90

0.1

9.00

3709245_1.XLS

Page 12 of 33

Case 1:01-cv-02199-MSK-MEH

Document 492-22

Filed 06/01/2007

Page 14 of 34

Clawson v. Mountain Coal
Plaintiff's Time Entries -- Motion for Attorneys' Fees (By Attorney)

2180.01

5/12/2006 CHR

6

90

0.76

68.40

Docket deadlines Billing Records - deleted 7693 and reductions

2180.01

5/12/2006 CHR

6

90

0.9

81.00

7694 CHR Billing - Deletions and Reductions Discuss with JKK Entries for JKK that are 7695 missing from Billing record.

2180.01

5/12/2006 CHR

6

90

0.18

16.20

2180.01

5/15/2006 CHR

6

90

0.18

16.20

7708 DD corrections to billing records Billing spread sheet - totals for all time 7710 makers JPG Billing Records Reviewed for deletions 7711 and reductions, revised AKEF Billing Records, reviewed for deletions 7712 and reductions, revised Question Medical records from about student 7713 clerk working on Clawson case Separating student clerk billing from HVR 7714 billing records Former Law clerk Billing records - reviewed 7715 and revised

2180.01

5/15/2006 CHR

6

90

0.18

16.20

2180.01

5/15/2006 CHR

6

90

0.26

23.40

2180.01

5/15/2006 CHR

6

90

0.26

23.40

2180.01

5/15/2006 CHR

6

90

0.1

9.00

2180.01

5/15/2006 CHR

6

90

0.1

9.00

2180.01

5/15/2006 CHR

6

90

0.26

23.40

2180.01

5/15/2006 CHR

6

90

0.26

23.40

7716 HVR billing records reviewed and revised APearson billing records -reviewed and 7717 revised

2180.01

5/15/2006 CHR

6

90

0.18

16.20

3709245_1.XLS

Page 13 of 33

Case 1:01-cv-02199-MSK-MEH

Document 492-22

Filed 06/01/2007

Page 15 of 34

Clawson v. Mountain Coal
Plaintiff's Time Entries -- Motion for Attorneys' Fees (By Attorney)

2180.01

5/15/2006 CHR

6

90

0.34

30.60

JM and JD Billing records - reviewed and 7718 revised

2180.01

5/15/2006 CHR

6

90

0.5

45.00

7719 CHR billing records reviewed and revised

2180.01

5/15/2006 CHR

6

90

0.1

9.00

7720 Tracking down JKK time sheets

2180.01

5/15/2006 CHR

6

90

0.18

16.20

7721 Synching up second day of trial 4/11.

2180.01

5/15/2006 CHR

6

90

0.9

81.00

7722 KRS billing records - reviewed and revised

2180.01

5/15/2006 CHR

6

90

0.34

30.60

7723 DD billing records - reviewed and revised

2180.01

5/16/2006 CHR

6

90

0.34

30.60

memo to JKK about missing days in Billing 7724 record Attorneys' Fees M - reviewed memo on research; read Black case M/ Attorney Fees 7725 and Cost Read Buniger Case M/Attorney Fees and 7726 Cost

2180.01

5/16/2006 CHR

6

90

1

90.00

2180.01

5/16/2006 CHR

6

90

0.34

30.60

2180.01

5/16/2006 CHR

6

90

0.76

68.40

7727 Draft of M/ Attorney Fees and Costs

2180.01

5/16/2006 CHR

6

90

0.4

36.00

Outlining Argument for M/ Attorney Fees and 7728 Costs

3709245_1.XLS

Page 14 of 33

Case 1:01-cv-02199-MSK-MEH

Document 492-22

Filed 06/01/2007

Page 16 of 34

Clawson v. Mountain Coal
Plaintiff's Time Entries -- Motion for Attorneys' Fees (By Attorney)

2180.01

5/17/2006 CHR

6

90

1

90.00

Reveiw Former Paralegal billing records Reductions for possible Bartlett and Richards 7739 work done and looking for block billing Reviewing Former Paralegals billing records deleting records involving Bartlett/Richards and reducing billing for instances of block billing where task time cannot be 7741 differentiated Past Paralegals billing totals 7745 (Deletions/Reductions/Total billing) Past Paralegal Billing Totals (Formatting the 7746 report) Review JKK billing records for deletions of Bartlett and Richards claims, along with 7747 reductions for parts of case spent on them. Discuss time missing w/JKK and 7748 transportation time. JKK Billing Records Totals (Deleted and 7749 Reduced) CHR Billing Corrections to reductions; new 7750 total for billing Prepare transportation totals and JKK billing 7751 total for his review.

2180.01

5/17/2006 CHR

6

90

1.76

158.40

2180.01

5/18/2006 CHR

6

90

0.5

45.00

2180.01

5/18/2006 CHR

6

90

0.26

23.40

2180.01

5/18/2006 CHR

6

90

0.76

68.40

2180.01

5/18/2006 CHR

6

90

0.18

16.20

2180.01

5/18/2006 CHR

6

90

0.34

30.60

2180.01

5/18/2006 CHR

6

90

0.2

18.00

2180.01

5/18/2006 CHR

6

90

0.34

30.60

2180.01

5/18/2006 CHR

6

90

0.5

45.00

7752 Billing Totals for firm spreadsheet

2180.01

5/18/2006 CHR

6

90

0.34

30.60

Review Billing Records with JKK, get billing 7753 record for 4/8/06 day missing in the report.

3709245_1.XLS

Page 15 of 33

Case 1:01-cv-02199-MSK-MEH

Document 492-22

Filed 06/01/2007

Page 17 of 34

Clawson v. Mountain Coal
Plaintiff's Time Entries -- Motion for Attorneys' Fees (By Attorney)

2180.01

5/18/2006 CHR

6

90

0.34

30.60

Separate out JRA billing from BRB billing for 7754 totals for JRA out of past attorney records Discuss with MR possibility of getting separation for former Paralegals billing time, 7755 not possible through the system Trying to track down the name of former law 7756 clerk Separating out BRB from former attorney 7757 records for BRB totals Meet with JKK to get billing for missing day 7758 4/11/06; name of law clerk Review finished billing records reports for uniformity (JPG, BRB, JRA, AKEF, AP, JD, 7759 JM, CHR, KS, HVR) Review and Revise JCJ Billing Records for deletions and reductions due to unsuccessful 7760 claims Looking for way to differentiate past paralegal 7800 time (no way from current form) Discuss with Linda past reports on case and billing reports to get timekeeper for past 7801 paralegals. Has some reports I can look over. Looking through past billing reports from linda. Has information we can use to 7802 differentiate past paras Separating out past paralegal by hard copies 7803 of past billing monthly statements Discuss with JKK billing what should be 7804 adjusted

2180.01

5/18/2006 CHR

6

90

0.1

9.00

2180.01

5/18/2006 CHR

6

90

0.1

9.00

2180.01

5/18/2006 CHR

6

90

0.34

30.60

2180.01

5/18/2006 CHR

6

90

0.34

30.60

2180.01

5/18/2006 CHR

6

90

0.5

45.00

2180.01

5/18/2006 CHR

6

90

1

90.00

2180.01

5/19/2006 CHR

6

90

0.18

16.20

2180.01

5/19/2006 CHR

6

90

0.18

16.20

2180.01

5/19/2006 CHR

6

90

0.26

23.40

2180.01

5/19/2006 CHR

6

90

0.76

68.40

2180.01

5/19/2006 CHR

6

90

0.26

23.40

3709245_1.XLS

Page 16 of 33

Case 1:01-cv-02199-MSK-MEH

Document 492-22

Filed 06/01/2007

Page 18 of 34

Clawson v. Mountain Coal
Plaintiff's Time Entries -- Motion for Attorneys' Fees (By Attorney)

2180.01

5/19/2006 CHR

6

90

0.26

23.40

Meet with MR to figure out how to get full info on to excel sheet cell for TS report, issue 7805 resolved to fit info in cells and display info. TS Billing: brainstorming ideas on how to efficiently attack the problem. Best to sort out each para's time and then address copying in 7806 TS full reports

2180.01

5/19/2006 CHR

6

90

0.26

23.40

2180.01

5/19/2006 CHR

6

90

0.26

23.40

7807 Sorting out past para's time from hard copy

2180.01

5/19/2006 CHR

6

90

0.26

23.40

7808 Discussion with JKK about billing record

2180.01

5/22/2006 CHR

6

90

0.76

68.40

Sorting past paralegal time by hardcopy 7810 statements from past billing Discussed with Linda about updated reports 7811 on billing BRB billing Records; separating entries 7812 based on information from hard copy reports BT Billing Records, separating from past 7813 attorneys

2180.01

5/22/2006 CHR

6

90

0.18

16.20

2180.01

5/22/2006 CHR

6

90

0.18

16.20

2180.01

5/22/2006 CHR

6

90

0.5

45.00

2180.01

5/22/2006 CHR

6

90

0.26

23.40

LMN billing records separating from past 7814 attorneys JRA billing Records, separating from past 7815 attorneys DJ billing records separating from other past 7816 paralegals

2180.01

5/22/2006 CHR

6

90

0.26

23.40

2180.01

5/22/2006 CHR

6

90

0.66

59.40

3709245_1.XLS

Page 17 of 33

Case 1:01-cv-02199-MSK-MEH

Document 492-22

Filed 06/01/2007

Page 19 of 34

Clawson v. Mountain Coal
Plaintiff's Time Entries -- Motion for Attorneys' Fees (By Attorney)

2180.01

5/22/2006 CHR

6

90

0.34

30.60

MM billing records separating from other past 7817 paralegals

2180.01

5/22/2006 CHR

6

90

2

180.00

TS billing records, separating from other past 7818 paralegals. correcting rounding on hours. TS - full descriptions of task performed that were cut of when entered into excel 7819 spreadsheet TS - full descriptions of task performed, 7821 copied into excel sheet. TS Billing Record - full descriptions copied to 7849 excel sheet.

2180.01

5/22/2006 CHR

6

90

1.76

158.40

2180.01

5/22/2006 CHR

6

90

0.76

68.40

2180.01

5/23/2006 CHR

6

90

2

180.00

2180.01

5/23/2006 CHR

6

90

1.34

120.60

TS billing record - full descriptions copied to 7850 excel sheet

2180.01

5/23/2006 CHR

6

90

0.1

9.00

7851 TS & DJ totals to Billing Total Spread sheet JKK Billing Record - rounding corrections, 7852 current rates

2180.01

5/23/2006 CHR

6

90

0.66

59.40

2180.01

5/23/2006 CHR

6

90

0.34

30.60

JCJ billing record - rounding corrections, 7853 current rates JPG Billing records - reviewing times, crossed with other attorneys on the case, 7854 current rates

2180.01

5/23/2006 CHR

6

90

0.26

23.40

3709245_1.XLS

Page 18 of 33

Case 1:01-cv-02199-MSK-MEH

Document 492-22

Filed 06/01/2007

Page 20 of 34

Clawson v. Mountain Coal
Plaintiff's Time Entries -- Motion for Attorneys' Fees (By Attorney)

2180.01

5/23/2006 CHR

6

90

0.26

23.40

DD Billing Record - rounding corrections, 7855 current rates

2180.01

5/23/2006 CHR

6

90

0.18

16.20

7856 CHR Billing Records Rounding corrections AKEF, JRA Rounding corrections, current 7857 rates BRB Billing record rounding corrections and 7858 current rates LMN Billing records - rounding corrections, 7859 current rate BT Billing Records - current billing adjustment, reduction corrections per JKK 7861 instructions

2180.01

5/23/2006 CHR

6

90

0.1

9.00

2180.01

5/23/2006 CHR

6

90

0.1

9.00

2180.01

5/23/2006 CHR

6

90

0.34

30.60

2180.01

5/23/2006 CHR

6

90

0.26

23.40

2180.01

5/23/2006 CHR

6

90

0.34

30.60

7862 KS Billing Records corrections for rounding. HVR, AP, JM, JD, MM, DJ reviewing for 7863 rounding errors, corrections to any errors TS Billing record - reviewing for reductions per instructions from JKK and checking the 7864 totals Reviewing Billing totals for case; assessing 7865 them for jkk to review Discuss with Medical records from new updated billing time for after trial, report only 7867 takes a few minutes to gather. M/Attorney Fees - gathering cases and materials for review; reviewing past work 7868 completed on motion

2180.01

5/23/2006 CHR

6

90

0.1

9.00

2180.01

5/23/2006 CHR

6

90

0.34

30.60

2180.01

5/23/2006 CHR

6

90

0.26

23.40

2180.01

5/24/2006 CHR

6

90

0.1

9.00

2180.01

5/24/2006 CHR

6

90

0.34

30.60

3709245_1.XLS

Page 19 of 33

Case 1:01-cv-02199-MSK-MEH

Document 492-22

Filed 06/01/2007

Page 21 of 34

Clawson v. Mountain Coal
Plaintiff's Time Entries -- Motion for Attorneys' Fees (By Attorney)

2180.01

5/24/2006 CHR

6

90

0.5

45.00

M/attorney fees - reading Buniger order awarding attorney fees and costs. Notes for 7869 Clawson Motion Searching Black File (past discrimination case w/ m/ for attorney fees) for M/ Attorney Fees and Costs, Response, Reply and Order to be used as reference for Clawson M. No 7870 order in file. Reading M/Attorney Fees and costs in Black 7871 case; notes for Clawson Motion Reading Black Defense Response to M for case law and actual argument; prep for the 7872 Clawson Motion Reading Reply to Defense Response in Black 7873 case; notes for Clawson Motion

2180.01

5/24/2006 CHR

6

90

0.34

30.60

2180.01

5/24/2006 CHR

6

90

0.2

18.00

2180.01

5/24/2006 CHR

6

90

0.34

30.60

2180.01

5/24/2006 CHR

6

90

0.4

36.00

2180.01

5/24/2006 CHR

6

90

0.1

9.00

Discussed Black case with DJD, JPG - if there was an order given by the court. JPG 7874 believes there was, need to get from storage

2180.01

5/24/2006 CHR

6

90

0.26

23.40

Reading notes from previous cases asking for Attorney fees; notes of cases that need to 7875 be retrieved from lexis for Clawson Motion

2180.01

5/24/2006 CHR

6

90

0.26

23.40

2180.01

5/24/2006 CHR

6

90

1

90.00

7876 Pulling cases for Fees Motion from Lexis Reading cases for fees motion pulled from lexis, secretarial work, non-legal work, discretion to award fees, and paralegal time 7877 billed Research case law on dismissed claims 7878 common core of facts/legal theories.

2180.01

5/24/2006 CHR

6

90

0.4

36.00

2180.01

5/24/2006 CHR

6

90

0.5

45.00

7879 Reading case law on 'billing judgment'

3709245_1.XLS

Page 20 of 33

Case 1:01-cv-02199-MSK-MEH

Document 492-22

Filed 06/01/2007

Page 22 of 34

Clawson v. Mountain Coal
Plaintiff's Time Entries -- Motion for Attorneys' Fees (By Attorney)

2180.01

5/24/2006 CHR

6

90

0.18

16.20

Case law on ability to get fees for researching 7880 and drafting M/ Attorney fees Research on conference time for recovery, 7881 also secretarial tasks and costs. Billing Total Spread Sheet - total hours billed 7882 by the firm. Discuss with JKK latest on Billing and 7883 progress with with Motion for Fees and costs BT Billing records - adjustments per JKK: rate and 15% reductions to general description 7884 time Research - Purpose of Attorney fees to make victim whole, incentive to try discrimination 7885 based cases Research - Compensation for travel time and 7886 expert expenses Reviewing JPG Billing records per JKK 7887 instructions Research for M/Attorney Fees - Billing 7888 judgment/15% reduction on non-descript time Research - Reasonable Rates/hours how 7889 courts determine/criteria Reading Hensley v. Eckert; notes for M/ 7890 Attorney Fees Reading and taking notes for attorney fees 7891 motion Jane L. v. Bangerter Reading case law for motion on non7892 professional v. legal work

2180.01

5/24/2006 CHR

6

90

0.34

30.60

2180.01

5/24/2006 CHR

6

90

0.4

36.00

2180.01

5/25/2006 CHR

6

90

0.18

16.20

2180.01

5/25/2006 CHR

6

90

0.18

16.20

2180.01

5/25/2006 CHR

6

90

1

90.00

2180.01

5/25/2006 CHR

6

90

1

90.00

2180.01

5/25/2006 CHR

6

90

0.1

9.00

2180.01

5/25/2006 CHR

6

90

0.4

36.00

2180.01

5/25/2006 CHR

6

90

0.5

45.00

2180.01

5/25/2006 CHR

6

90

1

90.00

2180.01

5/25/2006 CHR

6

90

0.18

16.20

2180.01

5/25/2006 CHR

6

90

0.18

16.20

3709245_1.XLS

Page 21 of 33

Case 1:01-cv-02199-MSK-MEH

Document 492-22

Filed 06/01/2007

Page 23 of 34

Clawson v. Mountain Coal
Plaintiff's Time Entries -- Motion for Attorneys' Fees (By Attorney)

2180.01

5/25/2006 CHR

6

90

0.18

16.20

Reading and notes on Johnson v. GA Expressway; 12 factors which ones apply to 7893 case

2180.01

5/26/2006 CHR

6

90

0.84

75.60

7900 Drafting M/ Attorney Fees Draft M/ Attorney fees - demand by plaintiffs, 7952 supported by case law Corrections to Billing totals regarding transportation time in accordance with case 7953 law Drafting M/ Attorney fees - rates of attorneys 7954 and paralegals with case law.

2180.01

5/30/2006 CHR

6

90

2

180.00

2180.01

5/30/2006 CHR

6

90

0.1

9.00

2180.01

5/30/2006 CHR

6

90

1.1

99.00

2180.01

5/30/2006 CHR

6

90

0.2

18.00

7955 Draft M/ Attorney fees - rates (cont) Draft M/ Attorney Fees - Reasonable Hours 7956 with case law Draft M/ Attorney fees - reasonable hours 7957 with legal support (cont) Draft M/ Attorney Fees - post judgment 7958 interest on award for attorney fees Copy of Draft of M/ Attorney Fees to JKK for 7971 review Reviewing draft of motion for attorney fees 7972 with JKK Amount of Motions by Defendants in case, 7983 for M/ attorney fees Amount of Motions by Defendant in case, M 7984 for Attorney fees

2180.01

5/30/2006 CHR

6

90

0.5

45.00

2180.01

5/30/2006 CHR

6

90

1.34

120.60

2180.01

5/30/2006 CHR

6

90

0.3

27.00

2180.01

6/5/2006 CHR

6

90

0.1

9.00

2180.01

6/5/2006 CHR

6

90

0.66

59.40

2180.01

6/8/2006 CHR

6

90

0.18

16.20

2180.01

6/8/2006 CHR

6

90

0.5

45.00

3709245_1.XLS

Page 22 of 33

Case 1:01-cv-02199-MSK-MEH

Document 492-22

Filed 06/01/2007

Page 24 of 34

Clawson v. Mountain Coal
Plaintiff's Time Entries -- Motion for Attorneys' Fees (By Attorney)

2180.01

6/8/2006 CHR

6

90

0.4

36.00

7985 revisions to m for attorney fees Reviewing Summ Judgment order by Court, 7986 for M for attorney fees Revision to M for attorney fees - clarifying dismissed claims addition of the nature of the 7987 case

2180.01

6/8/2006 CHR

6

90

0.5

45.00

2180.01

6/8/2006 CHR

6

90

1

90.00

2180.01

6/8/2006 CHR

6

90

0.26

23.40

7988 Review M for attorney fees

2180.01

6/9/2006 CHR

6

90

0.84

75.60

7996 Revisions to M/ Attorney fees Reviewing Law Clerk Billing - reductions to 7997 paralegal rate for interviews of witnesses Reviewing KS billing - delete secretarial tasks 7998 per case law Review TS billing - reduce secretarial tasks 7999 per case law TS billing reduce secretarial tasks per 8000 caselaw Discuss with D.D. M/ for costs: his progress 8009 and taking over costs

2180.01

6/9/2006 CHR

6

90

0.4

36.00

2180.01

6/9/2006 CHR

6

90

1.4

126.00

2180.01

6/9/2006 CHR

6

90

0.5

45.00

2180.01

6/9/2006 CHR

6

90

1.34

120.60

2180.01

6/13/2006 CHR

6

90

0.26

23.40

2180.01

6/13/2006 CHR

6

90

0.4

36.00

8010 Research on costs Research on Motion for Costs (reading 8045 cases)

2180.01

6/14/2006 CHR

6

90

2.5

225.00

2180.01

6/14/2006 CHR

6

90

0.4

36.00

8046 Statutory research on fees/costs

3709245_1.XLS

Page 23 of 33

Case 1:01-cv-02199-MSK-MEH

Document 492-22

Filed 06/01/2007

Page 25 of 34

Clawson v. Mountain Coal
Plaintiff's Time Entries -- Motion for Attorneys' Fees (By Attorney)

2180.01

6/14/2006 CHR

6

90

1.84

165.60

Additional research for case law on specific 8047 costs from the annotations of 28 USC 1920

2180.01

6/14/2006 CHR

6

90

0.5

45.00

8048 Colo digest for case law in 10th cir.

2180.01

6/14/2006 CHR

6

90

0.26

23.40

8049 Reviewing receipts for costs motion Reading cases and notes on cases for M/ for 8051 costs Reviewing Receipts for taxation costs 8052 categories Reviewing Receipts taxation of costs 8053 categories (cont)

2180.01

6/15/2006 CHR

6

90

1.4

126.00

2180.01

6/15/2006 CHR

6

90

0.6

54.00

2180.01

6/15/2006 CHR

6

90

0.3

27.00

2180.01

6/15/2006 CHR

6

90

0.26

23.40

8054 Meeting with D.D. costs motion Meeting with M.R. and LM about cost 8055 receipts and excel sheets for exhibits to court

2180.01

6/15/2006 CHR

6

90

0.2

18.00

2180.01

6/15/2006 CHR

6

90

0.34

30.60

8056 Research Costs for Mediation

2180.01

6/15/2006 CHR

6

90

0.5

45.00

8057 Research Costs for Mediation (cont) Excel Sheet breaking costs down by bill of 8060 costs categories Reviewing Depo Receipts (which pertain to 8061 Richards and Bartlett) Reviewing Depo Receipts (which pertain to 8062 Richards and Bartlett) (cont)

2180.01

6/16/2006 CHR

6

90

1.5

135.00

2180.01

6/16/2006 CHR

6

90

0.26

23.40

2180.01

6/16/2006 CHR

6

90

0.2

18.00

3709245_1.XLS

Page 24 of 33

Case 1:01-cv-02199-MSK-MEH

Document 492-22

Filed 06/01/2007

Page 26 of 34

Clawson v. Mountain Coal
Plaintiff's Time Entries -- Motion for Attorneys' Fees (By Attorney)

2180.01

6/16/2006 CHR

6

90

0.18

16.20

Witness receipts (not called at trial). Medical Records Receipts (which pertain to Richards 8063 and Bartlett)

2180.01

6/16/2006 CHR

6

90

0.1

9.00

8064 Reviewing Travel expense receipts

2180.01

6/16/2006 CHR

6

90

0.2

18.00

8065 I/O with LM about expense receipts Vocational Assessment Receipts and expert witness fees (which pertain to Richards and 8066 Bartlett) Consultant Fees/Expert on Brennan 8067 Categorizing these costs

2180.01

6/16/2006 CHR

6

90

0.26

23.40

2180.01

6/16/2006 CHR

6

90

0.2

18.00

2180.01

6/16/2006 CHR

6

90

0.18

16.20

8068 Excel Sheet of the total costs LM Meeting on receipts/documentation for in8069 house copy charges Discuss with D.D. costs, procedures and 8070 research. Travel Reports - matching up date to task 8079 which made the travel necessary Draft M/ Attorney Fees - 1988 expenses 8080 necessary to litigation Draft M/ Attorney Fees - Expenses under 8081 1988

2180.01

6/16/2006 CHR

6

90

0.4

36.00

2180.01

6/16/2006 CHR

6

90

0.4

36.00

2180.01

6/20/2006 CHR

6

90

1.5

135.00

2180.01

6/20/2006 CHR

6

90

0.7

63.00

2180.01

6/20/2006 CHR

6

90

1.5

135.00

2180.01

6/21/2006 CHR

6

90

0.7

63.00

8083 Review M/ Attorney Fees/expenses

2180.01

6/21/2006 CHR

6

90

0.26

23.40

8084 Revisions to M/Attorney Fees/expenses

3709245_1.XLS

Page 25 of 33

Case 1:01-cv-02199-MSK-MEH

Document 492-22

Filed 06/01/2007

Page 27 of 34

Clawson v. Mountain Coal
Plaintiff's Time Entries -- Motion for Attorneys' Fees (By Attorney)

2180.01

6/21/2006 CHR

6

90

0.18

16.20

Fees that need to be addressed still in Motion. Research that need to be done to 8085 warrant fees Research Awards for Litigation Consultant 8086 Fees - case law

2180.01

6/21/2006 CHR

6

90

1

90.00

2180.01

6/21/2006 CHR

6

90

0.34

30.60

8087 Reading case law found on consultant fee Reading Caselaw on expenses and costs for 8088 photocopies, postage, phone calls, etc. Reading case law on expenses and costs for 8089 photocopies, postage, phone calls, etc. (cont) Research for cases involving award of 8090 investigation costs to find witness Sorting Costs/ Expenses into categories, 8102 separating 1920 costs from 1988 expenses

2180.01

6/21/2006 CHR

6

90

0.26

23.40

2180.01

6/21/2006 CHR

6

90

0.6

54.00

2180.01

6/21/2006 CHR

6

90

0.34

30.60

2180.01

6/22/2006 CHR

6

90

0.66

59.40

2180.01

6/22/2006 CHR

6

90

0.1

9.00

8103 Litigation Consultant Fees 10th Cir Research Draft M/ Attorney fees - expert fees and 8104 consultant fees Draft M/ Attorney fees litigation consultant 8105 fees Reviewing in-house photocopies for m/ 8106 attorney fees Case law on photocopies standard for 8107 awarding as cost or expense Research postage expense for 10th circuit 8108 authority

2180.01

6/22/2006 CHR

6

90

1

90.00

2180.01

6/22/2006 CHR

6

90

0.4

36.00

2180.01

6/22/2006 CHR

6

90

0.26

23.40

2180.01

6/22/2006 CHR

6

90

0.26

23.40

2180.01

6/22/2006 CHR

6

90

0.5

45.00

3709245_1.XLS

Page 26 of 33

Case 1:01-cv-02199-MSK-MEH

Document 492-22

Filed 06/01/2007

Page 28 of 34

Clawson v. Mountain Coal
Plaintiff's Time Entries -- Motion for Attorneys' Fees (By Attorney)

2180.01

6/22/2006 CHR

6

90

0.2

18.00

8109 Further research postage expenses

2180.01

6/22/2006 CHR

6

90

0.2

18.00

8110 Research attorney rates Discuss with LM billing and costs for Lexis 8111 Research

2180.01

6/22/2006 CHR

6

90

0.26

23.40

2180.01

6/23/2006 CHR

6

90

1

90.00

8116 Draft M/ Attorney fees other expenses

2180.01

6/23/2006 CHR

6

90

0.34

30.60

8117 Research interest on litigation expenses Draft M/ Attorney fees - citation for rate being 8118 reasonable and interest award

2180.01

6/23/2006 CHR

6

90

0.4

36.00

2180.01

6/23/2006 CHR

6

90

0.76

68.40

8119 Reviewing Editing M/ Attorney Fees

2180.01

6/23/2006 CHR

6

90

0.34

30.60

8120 Revisions to M/ Attorney fees Reading D.D. case law research on costs for 8121 add'l cases to use in cost motion

2180.01

6/23/2006 CHR

6

90

0.1

9.00

2180.01

6/28/2006 CHR

6

90

0.2

18.00

8131 Discuss with D.D. M/ Attorney Fees

2180.01

7/5/2006 CHR

6

90

0.26

23.40

8155 Post Judgment Interest M/ attorney fees Tasks for M/ Attorney Fees and Costs; 8157 timekeeper information Email to MRoussin regarding attorney fees 8158 spread sheet from April to present

2180.01

8/9/2006 CHR

6

90

0.1

9.00

2180.01

8/10/2006 CHR

6

90

0.1

9.00

3709245_1.XLS

Page 27 of 33

Case 1:01-cv-02199-MSK-MEH

Document 492-22

Filed 06/01/2007

Page 29 of 34

Clawson v. Mountain Coal
Plaintiff's Time Entries -- Motion for Attorneys' Fees (By Attorney)

2180.01

8/15/2006 CHR

6

90

0.1

9.00

8159 Tasks for Fees Memo I/O with JKK and DDavis regarding attorneys 8162 fees and costs motions, tasks

2180.01

8/17/2006 CHR

6

90

0.5

45.00

2180.01

8/23/2006 CHR

6

90

0.5

45.00

Sorting time keeper information by individual 8163 time keeper for April-Aug for fees exhibits

2180.01

8/23/2006 CHR

6

90

0.76

68.40

Add recent fees to JKK fees exhibit. review for 8164 delete/reduce fees

2180.01

8/23/2006 CHR

6

90

0.2

18.00

8165 Add recent fees to JCJ fees exhibit Add recent fees to DDavis Fees Exhibits. 8166 Review for delete/reduce fees Add recent fees to CHR fees Exhibits. 8167 Review for delete/reduce fees Add KRS recent fees to Fees Exhibit; print out 8168 other paralegal fees exhibits Add Recent fees to APearson fees exhibits, 8169 putting all paralegal exhibits in folder

2180.01

8/23/2006 CHR

6

90

0.5

45.00

2180.01

8/23/2006 CHR

6

90

0.5

45.00

2180.01

8/23/2006 CHR

6

90

0.5

45.00

2180.01

8/23/2006 CHR

6

90

0.2

18.00

2180.01

8/24/2006 CHR

6

90

0.5

45.00

8170 Fees for PM/CD exhibits

2180.01

8/24/2006 CHR

6

90

0.76

68.40

8171 Checking Billing totals after add'l fees

3709245_1.XLS

Page 28 of 33

Case 1:01-cv-02199-MSK-MEH

Document 492-22

Filed 06/01/2007

Page 30 of 34

Clawson v. Mountain Coal
Plaintiff's Time Entries -- Motion for Attorneys' Fees (By Attorney)

2180.01

10/3/2006 CHR

6

90

0.5

45.00

8179 I/O with DDavis regarding attorney fees I/O with JKK and DDavis regarding attny 8180 fees/costs

2180.01

10/4/2006 CHR

6

90

0.8

72.00

2180.01

10/4/2006 CHR

6

90

1.26

113.40

8181 I/O with DDavis regarding costs Costs: Reviewing Excel Records; notes on 8184 what needs to be done; status Review Clawson & Dillon attorney fees 8188 research, exhibits, motion

2180.01

10/12/2006 CHR

6

90

1

90.00

2180.01

10/17/2006 CHR

6

90

1.26

113.40

2180.01

10/17/2006 CHR

6

90

0.6

54.00

8189 Review Clawson & Dillon Costs Research

2180.01

10/18/2006 CHR

6

90

1.8

162.00

Documentation of costs; spreadsheet and 8190 support for 1920 costs/1988 expenses In house Expenses; documentation and 8191 Exhibits I/O with LMeyers regarding how certain costs/expenses are billed to clients and firm 8192 procedures I/O with JRyman regarding costs and 8193 expenses

2180.01

10/18/2006 CHR

6

90

1.5

135.00

2180.01

10/18/2006 CHR

6

90

0.76

68.40

2180.01

10/18/2006 CHR

6

90

0.76

68.40

2180.01

3/15/2007 CHR

6

90

1

90.00

8305 Review M/ Attorney Fees for Clawson

2180.01

3/15/2007 CHR

6

90

0.9

81.00

8306 Revision to Clawson M/ for Attorney Fees

3709245_1.XLS

Page 29 of 33

Case 1:01-cv-02199-MSK-MEH

Document 492-22

Filed 06/01/2007

Page 31 of 34

Clawson v. Mountain Coal
Plaintiff's Time Entries -- Motion for Attorneys' Fees (By Attorney)

2180.01

3/15/2007 CHR

6

90

0.3

27.00

M/Attorney Fees adding judgment on 8307 economic damages

2180.01

3/15/2007 CHR

6

90

0.6

54.00

8308 Review Billing JKK for Clawson

2180.01

3/16/2007 CHR

6

90

0.2

18.00

8309 Review JKK Billing of Clawson Fees

2180.01

3/16/2007 CHR

6

90

0.5

45.00

8310 Discuss attorney Fees w/ DDavis for Clawson

2180.01

3/16/2007 CHR

6

90

0.7

63.00

8311 Review JCJ billing for Clawson

2180.01

3/16/2007 CHR

6

90

1.6

144.00

8312 Revision to JKK billing Exhibit for Clawson

2180.01

3/16/2007 CHR

6

90

1

90.00

8313 Revision to JCJ billing Exhibit for Clawson Revision to BT (Of Counsel) Billing Exhibit for 8314 Clawson Reviewing DDavis Billing; discuss with D. 8315 Davis

2180.01

3/16/2007 CHR

6

90

0.3

27.00

2180.01

3/16/2007 CHR

6

90

0.8

72.00

2180.01

3/19/2007 CHR

6

90

0.3

27.00

8316 Review Damon Davis Billing for Clawson

2180.01

3/19/2007 CHR

6

90

1.3

117.00

8317 Review Damon Davis Billing for Clawson

2180.01

3/20/2007 CHR

6

90

1.4

126.00

8324 Revise DDavis Billing Ex. for Clawson

2180.01

3/20/2007 CHR

6

90

0.76

68.40

8325 Revise JKK Billing Exhibit for Clawson

3709245_1.XLS

Page 30 of 33

Case 1:01-cv-02199-MSK-MEH

Document 492-22

Filed 06/01/2007

Page 32 of 34

Clawson v. Mountain Coal
Plaintiff's Time Entries -- Motion for Attorneys' Fees (By Attorney)

2180.01

3/20/2007 CHR

6

90

0.5

45.00

8326 Review CHR billing for Clawson

2180.01

3/20/2007 CHR

6

90

0.1

9.00

8327 Revise CHR Billing Ex. for Clawson

2180.01

3/20/2007 CHR

6

90

0.6

54.00

8328 Revise CHR billing Ex. for Clawson Judgment, Attorney Fees, Costs, Deadlines 8338 with DDavis

2180.01

3/28/2007 CHR

6

90

1

90.00

2180.01

3/30/2007 CHR

6

90

0.4

36.00

8339 Reviewing Billing for Clawson (Past Attorneys)

2180.01

3/30/2007 CHR

6

90

0.7

63.00

8340 Reviewing Billing for Clawson (Past Attorneys)

2180.01

3/30/2007 CHR

6

90

0.5

45.00

8341 Reviewing Billing for Clawson TS Reviewing and Revising Billing Exhibit for 8342 Clawson TS Revise Billing Exhibit TS for Clawson (prior 8343 paralegal) Subjects of Linda Meyer Cost Affidavit for 8344 Clawson I/O with JKK, DDavis regarding clawson cost 8345 procedures I/O with JRyman regarding cost procedures 8346 affidavit for Clawson

2180.01

3/30/2007 CHR

6

90

2

180.00

2180.01

4/2/2007 CHR

6

90

0.4

36.00

2180.01

4/2/2007 CHR

6

90

0.2

18.00

2180.01

4/2/2007 CHR

6

90

0.2

18.00

2180.01

4/2/2007 CHR

6

90

0.2

18.00

2180.01

4/2/2007 CHR

6

90

1.4

126.00

8347 Revisions to TS Billing Exhibit for Clawson

3709245_1.XLS

Page 31 of 33

Case 1:01-cv-02199-MSK-MEH

Document 492-22

Filed 06/01/2007

Page 33 of 34

Clawson v. Mountain Coal
Plaintiff's Time Entries -- Motion for Attorneys' Fees (By Attorney)

2180.01

4/2/2007 CHR

6

90

1.2

108.00

Review Billing of KS for Clawson (prior 8348 paralegal) Revise KS Billing Exhibit for Clawson Attorney 8349 Fees Instructions to Louis (IT) regarding fees from August to March into an excel format for 8350 Clawson attorney fees

2180.01

4/2/2007 CHR

6

90

1.3

117.00

2180.01

4/2/2007 CHR

6

90

0.1

9.00

2180.01

4/2/2007 CHR

6

90

0.3

27.00

8351 Revise Clawson M/ attorney fees Review M/Attorney ; Linda Affidavit; LMN 8352 Billing Review/Revise ALL past paralegal and CDC, 8353 PM Billing for Clawson Discussing Clawson Attorney Fees with 8354 DDavis Revise Billing LMN for Clawson Attorney Fees 8355 Exhibit; update Billing totals

2180.01

4/2/2007 CHR

6

90

0.5

45.00

2180.01

4/2/2007 CHR

6

90

0.5

45.00

2180.01

4/3/2007 CHR

6

90

0.3

27.00

2180.01

4/3/2007 CHR

6

90

0.8

72.00

2180.01

4/3/2007 CHR

6

90

0.2

18.00

8356 Discuss time entries for Clawson with DDavis

2180.01

4/3/2007 CHR

6

90

2

180.00

8357 Costs Exhibit for Clawson 1920 costs to court Cost and Expense Issues for Clawson; scheduling time to meet with Keith and 8358 Damon

2180.01

4/3/2007 CHR

6

90

0.3

27.00

172.82

15,553.80

Subtotal - CHR

200.84

20,376.80

Total - All Attorneys

3709245_1.XLS

Page 32 of 33

Case 1:01-cv-02199-MSK-MEH

Document 492-22

Filed 06/01/2007

Page 34 of 34

Clawson v. Mountain Coal
Plaintiff's Time Entries -- Motion for Attorneys' Fees (By Attorney)

Name JKKillian DJDavis JCJensen CHRichter Total

Prop. Rate Fees at Prop. Rate Adj. Rate Fees at Adj. Rate (per Plaintiff) (per Plaintiff) (per Defendants) (per Defendants) Hours 6.020 250 1,505.00 250 1,505.00 21.640 150 3,246.00 115 2,488.60 0.360 200 72.00 180 64.80 172.820 90 15,553.80 90 15,553.80 200.840 20,376.80 19,612.20

3709245_1.XLS

Page 33 of 33