Free Proposed Pretrial Order - District Court of Colorado - Colorado

Case 1:01-cv-02089-MSK-CBS

Document 218-2

Filed 02/28/2006

Page 1 of 13

EXHIBIT LIST of DEAN A. BRAMLET Case No. 01-cv-2089-MSK-CBS Dean A. Bramlet v. Aspen Valley Hospital District
Ex h. # 1 Witness Description Curriculum Vitae of Dean A. Bramlet Stip. Offer Re c'd Refused Ruling Reserved Comm ents/Information

2

Curriculum Vitae of L aw re nc e W . G a u l, M . D . F .A .C .C . R e s u m e of La u ra A . V o ig t, C P C S , CMSC Cu rriculum Vitae of Jeffre y C. B aue r, P h .D . Curriculum Vitae of Gordon Gerson, M.D.; Dep. Ex. 37; BRAMD2005 Curriculum Vitae of S asm ar Kho ury, M.D.; Dep. Ex. 84; BRAMD1956-1960 Curriculum Vitae of Edmund Gaulden, M.D., F.A.C.C.; Dep. Ex. 85; BRAM D1961-1963 Cu rriculum Vitae of Ab hishe k G aur, M.D; Dep. Ex. 86; BRAM D1964-1966 Cu rriculum Vitae of M irhass en F arivar, M.D., F.A.C.C.; Dep. Ex. 87; BRAM D1967-1971 Cu rricu lum Vita e o f Sa sa n G ha ffari, M.D.; Dep. Ex. 88; BRAMD1972-1973 Curriculum Vitae of Christine Villarino, M.D.; Dep. Ex. 89; BRAMD1974

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

Case 1:01-cv-02089-MSK-CBS

Document 218-2

Filed 02/28/2006

Page 2 of 13

12

Cu rricu lum Vita e o f Ha m id T ah eri, M.D.; Dep. Ex. 90; BRAMD1978-1981 Curriculum Vitae of Faisal Wahid, M.D.; Dep. Ex. 91; BRAMD1983-1987 AVH Professional Code of Conduct for Ph ysic ian a nd Allie d H ea lth Professionals of AVH, 2/4/98, BRAM D106 AVH General Medical Staff meeting minutes, 12/15/98; BRAM D138-142 AVH M edical Staff Development Plan, Dep. Ex. 16; AVH/B 0423 Flo ws he et for ph ysic ian/A llied H ea lth Staff Policy regarding disruptive conduct, 2/7/9; Dep. Ex. 98; BRAM D205 M inutes of AV H B oard of Dire ctors meeting (pages 1, 3 & 5), 2/14/00; BRAM D194-196 AVH reappointment application, 4/25/00; BRAMD229 AVH Special procedures privilege checklist, 4/25/00; BRAM D233-236 P r in c ip le s o f A g re e m e n t b e tw e e n A V H & Morris Cohen, M.D., 6/21/00; Dep. Ex. 55 P r in c ip le s o f A g re e m e n t b e tw e e n A V H & Morris Cohen, M.D., 9/10/02; Dep. Ex. 56 P r in c ip le s o f A g re e m e n t b e tw e e n A V H and Dr. Gerson, 8/14/00; Dep. Ex. 40; AVH/B 1368 AVH M edical Staff Development Plan Thres hold C riteria Pe r Spec ialty; BRAM D424-462

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

Case 1:01-cv-02089-MSK-CBS

Document 218-2

Filed 02/28/2006

Page 3 of 13

25

AV H P hys ician /Allie d H ea lth S taff Po licy R eg ard ing D isrup tive C on du ct; Dep. Ex. 97; BRAMD203-204 AVH M edical Staff Development Comm ittee Needs Analysis Per Specialty, 9/01; Dep. Ex. 80 Me dical Staff De velopm ent Po licy; Dep. Ex. 82; BRAMD1935-1947 AVH M EC meeting minutes, 8/5/98; Dep. Ex. 5; AVH/B 0148-0154 AVH M EC meeting minutes 1/6/99; Dep. Ex. 6; AVH/B 0193-0196 AVH M EC meeting minutes, 4/4/00; Dep. Ex. 7; AVH/B 0311-0320 Pages 2 and 3 of MSDC - 9/14/99; Dep. Ex. 17; AVH/B 0470-0471 Page 4 of 8 of MEC - 10/6/99; Dep. Ex. 18; AVH/B 0259 Meeting minutes, 1/4/00; Dep. Ex. 19; AVH/B 1293 Pages 1 and 2 of the Minutes of the AVH BOD mee ting 1/10/00; Dep. Ex. 20; AVH/B 0645-0646 Minutes of the AVH BO D meeting 3/13/00; Dep. Ex. 21; AVH/B 06580662 Minutes of the AVH BO D meeting 5/8/00; Dep. Ex. 22; AVH/B 06710676 Medical Staff Bylaws and various resolutions adopting amendm ents; Dep. Ex. 3; AVH/B0001-0064 Delineation of Clinical Privileges, BRAM D231-232

26

27

28

29

30

31

32

33

34

35

36

37

38

Case 1:01-cv-02089-MSK-CBS

Document 218-2

Filed 02/28/2006

Page 4 of 13

39

Cre den tials Po licy & P roce dure Manual; Dep. Ex. 57; AVH/B 00670094 Article VIII. Review, Revision, Adoption and Amendment of the M e d ic a l S t af f B y la w s F a ir H ea ri ng P la n o f A V H (BRAMD537-554) AVH M edical Staff Development Plan Ne ed s A na lysis Pe r Sp ec ialty; BRAM D463-500 MEC P eer Review Minutes from 11/4/98 (BRAMD693) MEC P eer Review Minutes from 2/9/00 (BRAMD806) MEC P eer Review Minutes from 5/3/00 (BRAMD821) MEC P eer Review Minutes from 6/7/00 (BRAMD835) MEC P eer Review Minutes from 7/5/00 (BRAMD844-BRAM D845) MEC P eer Review Minutes from 8/2/00 (BRAMD852) Minutes (BRAMD924-BRAM D926) Minutes (BRAMD928) Minutes (BRAMD938) Minutes (3/23/00) (BRAMD965BRAM D966) Minutes (4/13/00) (BRAMD968) Minutes (6/22/00) (BRAMD971) Minutes (11/15/00) (BRAMD976)

40

41

42

43

44

45

46

47

48

49 50 51 52

53 54 55

Case 1:01-cv-02089-MSK-CBS

Document 218-2

Filed 02/28/2006

Page 5 of 13

56

Medical Staff Development Policy (Effec tive to M arch 7, 19 99); BRAM D1917-1934 Medical Staff Development Policy (Effe ctive M arc h 8 , 19 99 to 2000);BRAM D1935-1947 AVH letter to Bramlet regarding appointment as Assoc. Staff, 11/4/98; BRAM D109 Memo to AVH doctors regarding internal medicine em. call and coverage, 12/7/98; Dep. Ex. 70 Letter from Bramlet to AVH Chief of M edicin e reg arding allega tions o f Dr. Cohen, 12/14/98; Dep. Ex. 72; BRAM D111 Letter from Bramlet to Middlebrook regarding development loan for new members, 12/15/98; BRAM D113 Memo from Mass to Bramlet regarding c a rd io lo g y c o ve ra g e a t A V H , 12/16/98; Dep. Ex. 73; BRAM D116 Letter from Bramlet to Kremer regarding patient coverage, 5/21/99; BRAM D134 Letter from Ferguson to Bramlet regarding end of provisional period, 8/22/99; BRAMD135 Memo to Bramlet from Libby Barlau regarding medical staff credential file, 8/30/99; BRAMD136 Letter from Middlebrook to Bramlet reg ard ing in tern ist se co nd ary c all coverage, 9/23/99; BRAM D137 Letter from Durham to Bramlet regarding medical directorship of cardiac rehab, 10/14/99; BRAM D151

57

58

59

60

61

62

63

64

65

66

67

Case 1:01-cv-02089-MSK-CBS

Document 218-2

Filed 02/28/2006

Page 6 of 13

68

Letter from Martinez to Bramlet reg ard ing g en era l m ed ical s taff attendance roster, 1/3/00; BRAM D157 Ha nd -writte n lette r from Bra m let to Ma rtinez regarding Asp en reside ncy, 1/4/00; BRAMD158 Letter from Jaffrey, Bramlet and Sc he ue r reg ard ing m ed ical s taff development policy, 1/6/00; BRAM D159 Letter from Bramlet to Middlebrook regarding copies of bylaws, 1/7/00; BRAM D163 Letter from Bramlet to AVH Governing Bo ard reg ard ing p erm an en t staff status, 1/10/00; BRAM D165 Letter from Martinez to Bramlet regarding reappointment and request to change status, 1/13/00; BRAM D167 Letter from Kotz to Bramlet regarding medical development meeting, 1/14/00; Dep. Ex. 83; BRAM D1903 Letter from Martinez to Bramlet regarding reappointment and request to change status, 1/19/00; BRAM D169 Letter from Bramlet to Kremer regarding documen tation of residency requirements, 1-21-00; Dep. Ex. 29 Letter from Bramlet to Middlebrook regarding reappointment process, 2/10/00; Dep. Ex. 30; BRAM D189 Letter from Ayers to Bramlet regarding approval of care plan, 2/16/00; BRAM D198 Letter from Kotz to Bramlet regarding complaints against Bramlet, 2/18/00; Dep. Ex. 99; BRAMD199-202

69

70

71

72

73

74

75

76

77

78

79

Case 1:01-cv-02089-MSK-CBS

Document 218-2

Filed 02/28/2006

Page 7 of 13

80

Letter from Bramlet to Martinez regarding reappointment, 2/24/00; De p. E x. 9 Letter from Middlebrook to Bramlet regarding Bylaws, 3/2/00; Dep. Ex. 33; BRAM D211 Letter from Kotz to Bramlet regarding Disruptive Physician Policy, 3/14/00; BRAM D217 Letter from Bramlet to Kotz regarding leave of absence, 4/5/00; BRAM D219 Letter from Bramlet to Ayers regarding change in category status, 4/11/00; Dep. Ex. 31; BRAMD220 Letter from Kienle to Ayers regarding recommendation for Bramlet, 4/11/00; BRAM D221 M em o fro m Hu nte r to m ed ical s taff regarding survey - residency requirement, 4/21/00; BRAMD223-224 Letter from Middlebrook to Bramlet regarding request for leave, 4/21/00; BRAM D225 Letter from Bramlet to Martinez regarding withdrawal of request for leave, 4/24/00; Dep. Ex. 26 Letter from Mass to Martinez recommending Bramlet, 4/25/00; BRAM D237 Memo from Bramlet to Kremer regarding medical staff application, 5/2/00; Dep. Ex. 27; AVH/B 0098 Letter from Bramlet to Kotz regarding Board vote on credentials, 5/5/00; Dep. Ex. 28; AVH/B 0099

81

82

83

84

85

86

87

88

89

90

91

Case 1:01-cv-02089-MSK-CBS

Document 218-2

Filed 02/28/2006

Page 8 of 13

92

Letter from Martinez to Bramlet rega rding c ons ulting s taff/tem pora ry privileges, 5/5/00; BRAMD240 Letter from Middlebrook to Bramlet regarding leave of absence, 6/19/00; BRAM D337 Letter from Bramlet to Ayers regarding leave from Florida hospital, 6/26/00; BRAM D340 Memo from Middlebrook to Medical Staff regarding Cohen receiving privileges, 6/26/00; Dep. Ex. 65; BRAM D341 Letter from Middlebrook to Bramlet reg ard ing c ard iolog ist rec ruitm en t, 7/10/00; BRAMD342 Letter from Ayers to Bramlet regarding Credentials Comm ittee letter/leave of absence, 7/11/00; BRAMD345 Letter from Bramlet to Ayers regarding conclusion of leave of absence, 7/27/00; Dep. Ex. 114; BRAM D346 Letter from Bramlet to Ayers regarding updating care plan, 7/27/00; BRAM D347 Letter from Bramlet to Kotz regarding disruptive physician policy, 8/1/00; Dep. Ex. 100; BRAMD348 Letter from Kotz to Bramlet regarding disruptive physician policy, 8/14/00; Dep. Ex. 101; BRAMD349 Letter from Ayers to Bramlet regarding Credentials Comm ittee Meeting (term ination of leav e of a bse nce ), 8/15/00; BRAMD358 Letter from Ayers to Bramlet regarding acceptance of request to terminate, 8/30/00; BRAMD363

93

94

95

96

97

98

99

100

101

102

103

Case 1:01-cv-02089-MSK-CBS

Document 218-2

Filed 02/28/2006

Page 9 of 13

104

Letter from Bramlet to Ayers regarding co ns ulting staff p rivileg es refu sa l, 8/30/00; BRAMD364-365 Letter from Middlebrook to Bramlet regarding rejection for contracted position as cardiologist, 9/6/00; Dep. Ex. 32; AVH/B 0113 Letter from Middlebrook to Bramlet reg ard ing r eq ue st for c on su lting s taff membership, 9/18/00; Dep. Ex. 24; AVH/B 0108-0109 Letter from Middlebrook to Bramlet Re jectio n fo r Ap po intm en t to Consulting Staff, 11/20/00; BRAM D379 Letter from Martinez to Haynes, 1-2900; Dep. Ex. 2; AVH/B 0408-0410 M e m o fr om A V H M E C to A V H BO D reg ard ing m ed ical s taff ap po intm en ts for review, 11/2/98; Dep. Ex. 14; AVH/B 0545 Letter from Merritt, Hawkins & Assoc. To Middlebrook, 7/28/00; Dep. Ex. 45; BRAM D2015-2018 Letter from Bramlet to Ayers, 9/1/00; Dep. Ex. 116; AVH/B 2050-2051 Letter from Kotz to Bramlet regarding Disruptive Physician Policy dated 3/14/00; BRAMD217 Letter from Bramlet to Kotz regarding disruptive physician policy dated 8/01/00; BRAMD348 Letter from Kotz to Bramlet regarding disruptive physician policy dated 8/14/00; BRAMD349 Letter to AVH Internists from Middlebrook, 4/20/00; BRAMD1756

105

106

107

108

109

110

111

112

113

114

115

Case 1:01-cv-02089-MSK-CBS

Document 218-2

Filed 02/28/2006

Page 10 of 13

116

Letter to Dr. Bramlet from Dr. Martinez dated 1/13/00 re: staff status; Dep. Ex. 94; BRAMD167 Letter to Dr. B ram let from Dr. A yers da ted 6/0 5/0 0 re : con su lting s taff privileges; BRAMD336 Letter to Dr. B ram let from Dr. A yers dated 7/11/00 re: leave of absence; BRAM D345 Letter to Dr. B ram let from Dr. A yers da ted 8/1 5/0 0 re : Co ns ulting Sta ff Privileges; BRAMD358 Letter to Dr. Bramlet from Dr. Martinez dated 1/03/00 re: attendance of meetings; BRAMD157 Letter to Dr. Bramlet from Dr. Martinez dated 1/13/00 re: staff status; BRAM D167 Letter to Dr. Bramlet from Dr. Martinez dated 1 /31/00 re: reside ncy; BRAM D188 Letter to Dr. Bramlet from Dr. Martinez dated 2/15/00 re: application for reappointment; Dep. Ex. 95; BRAM D197 Copy of Bramlet's driver's license and Voter's Registration Card; BRAM D166 Sn ow m ass Village Su n A rticle "Dr. Co he n P luck ed ou t of R etire m en t, Heads Back to the Table", 8/9/00; Dep. Ex. 61; BRAMD373-374 Em ploy er's P os ition S tate m en t, 8/13/01; BRAMD392-402 Form 1099s for Dr. Gordon Gerson, 1996-2003; BRAMD3340-3359

117

118

119

120

121

122

123

124

125

126

127

Case 1:01-cv-02089-MSK-CBS

Document 218-2

Filed 02/28/2006

Page 11 of 13

128

"Th e C olor ad o S ki Ind us try: H ighlig hts of the 1997-1998 Season", Business Research Division, Graduate School of B us ines s A dm inistra tion, U nive rsity o f C o lo ra d o a t B o uld e r, B o uld e r, C O ; BRAM D3360-3403 Physician Compensation and Production Survey Report, Medical Group Management Association; BRAM D3213 Dean A. Bramlet, M.D., P.A. Balance Sheets, 1997, 1999, 2001, 2003-2004; BRAM D3197-3206 I nc o m e ta x re tu rn s fo r D e a n A . Bramlet, M.D., P.A. 1992-2001; BRAM D3246-3305 Classified advertisement Colorado Medicine, 12/99; Dep. Ex. 60; BRAM D153 Complaint, 10/23/01 Plaintiff's Motion to Supplement Response in Opposition to Defendant M orris C ohe n's M otion fo r Sum m ary Ju dg m en t an d D efe nd an t AV H's Motion for Summ ary Judgment Pursuant to F.R.C.P. 56 (F), 3/15/02 Cohen's Answer to Amended Complaint, 5/1/03 Amended Com plaint, 5/13/03, Dep. Ex. 23 Se con d A ffidavit of A nne tte J. Kre m er, 7/8/03; Dep. Ex. 103; BRAM D635-636 Affidavit of Dean A. Bramlet, 8/27/03; De p. E x. 8

129

130

131

132

133 134

135

136

137

138

Case 1:01-cv-02089-MSK-CBS

Document 218-2

Filed 02/28/2006

Page 12 of 13

139

Plaintiff's Amended Brief in Support of his R es po ns e in O pp os ition to De fen da nt's M otion to D ism iss O r, in the A lternative , Mo tion for S um m ary Judgment RE: §1983 and Breach of Contract, 9/2/03 Affidavit of Teresa Hock, 11/26/03 AVH 's Answers to Plaintiff's Inte rrog ato ries a nd Re sp on se s to Requests for Production of Do cum ents Pe r Ru le 56 (f) Orde r, 2/5/04 Response to Plaintiff's Interrogatories and Requests for Production of Documents to Defendant Cohen Per Rule 56(F) Order, 2/12/04; Dep. Ex. 47 Co nfide ntial R es po ns e to Pla intiff's Discovery Requests to Defendant Cohen Per Rule 56(f) Order, 2/17/04; Dep. Ex. 48 AV H A ns we r to A m en de d C om plain t, 3/12/04 Plaintiff's Second Set of Interrogatories and Requests for Pro du ction of D oc um en ts to Defendant Cohen, 5/17/04 Re sp on se s to P laintiff's Se co nd Se t of Interrogatories and Request for Production of Documents, 6/18/04, Dep. Ex. 49 De fen da nt A VH D's An sw ers to Plaintiff's Second Set of Inte rrog ato ries a nd Re sp on se s to Request for Production of Documents, 7/1/04; Dep. Ex. 92 Response to Plaintiff's Third Set of Interrogatories and Requests for Production of documents, 7/13/04; Dep. Ex. 50

140 141

142

143

144

145

146

147

148

Case 1:01-cv-02089-MSK-CBS

Document 218-2

Filed 02/28/2006

Page 13 of 13

149

Su pp lem en tal R es po ns es to P laintiff's Third Set of Interrogatories and Requests for Production of Documents, 8/13/04; Dep. Ex. 51 Affidavit of Morris Cohen Affidavit of Melinda Sandgren, 5/6/05 D e po sitio n tra ns crip t o f G o rd on M . Gerson, 8/5/04 Deposition transcript of Morris Cohen, 8/9/04 De po sition tran scr ipt of A nn ette Kremer, 12/16/04 Deposition transcript of J. Christopher Martinez, 2/2/05 Deposition transcript of J. Stevens Ayers, 2/3/05 Deposition transcript of Melinda Sandgren, 5/6/05

150 151 152

153

154

155

156

157