Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM
Document 420
Filed 11/05/2007
Page 1 of 38
IN THE UNITED STATES COURT OF FEDERAL CLAIMS ____________________________________ HOMER J. HOLLAND, ) STEVEN BANGERT, Co-Executor of ) the Estate of HOWARD R. ROSS, and ) FIRST BANK, ) ) Case No. 95-524C Plaintiffs, ) ) (Judge George W. Miller) v. ) ) (Winstar-Related Case) THE UNITED STATES, ) ) Defendant. ) ____________________________________)
DEFENDANT'S OBJECTIONS TO THE EXHIBITS IDENTIFIED BY PLAINTIFFS Defendant, the United States, respectfully identifies its objections to the trial exhibits identified by plaintiffs, Homer J. Holland, Steven Bangert, Co-Executor of the Estate of Howard R. Ross, and First Bank, in their exhibit list, filed September 26, 2007, and their supplemental exhibit list, filed October 12, 2007. We reserve our right to object to any exhibit upon grounds of relevance, Federal Rules of Evidence ("FRE") 401 and 402; hearsay, FRE 802; and foundation, FRE 901, to the extent these issues are raised by the manner in which the exhibit is used at trial. We also reserve all our rights under the Master Stipulation that governs this case, including our right to object upon authenticity grounds to exhibits that include handwritten notes. In addition to these general objections, we have identified upon the attached list our objections to specific exhibits according to the following general categories: authenticity, FRE 901 and 902; composite, FRE 403; hearsay, FRE 802; incompleteness, FRE 403; and relevance, FRE 401 and 402.
Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM
Document 420
Filed 11/05/2007
Page 2 of 38
Respectfully submitted, MICHAEL F. HERTZ Deputy Assistant Attorney General
JEANNE E. DAVIDSON Director /s/ Kenneth M. Dintzer KENNETH M. DINTZER Assistant Director
Of Counsel: SCOTT D. AUSTIN KENNETH M. DINTZER ELIZABETH A. HOLT WILLIAM G. KANELLIS BRIAN A. MIZOGUCHI AMANDA L. TANTUM JOHN J. TODOR November 5, 2007
/s/ John H. Roberson by /s/ Elizabeth A. Holt JOHN H. ROBERSON Trial Attorney Commercial Litigation Branch Civil Division Department of Justice Attn: Classification Unit 8th Floor, 1100 L Street Washington, D.C. 20530 Tele: (202) 353-7972 Fax: (202) 514-8640 Attorneys for Defendant
Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM
Document 420
Filed 11/05/2007
Page 3 of 38
Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 3
Objections Composite (contains excerpts from larger document); Incomplete (contains excerpts from larger document)
4
Hearsay; Incomplete (contains excerpts from larger document)
6
Hearsay; Incomplete (contains excerpts from larger document)
8
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
9
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
12
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
13
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
15
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia; exhibit not identifiable upon its face)
17
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
18
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
Page 1 of 35
Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM
Document 420
Filed 11/05/2007
Page 4 of 38
Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 20 Objections Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face)
22
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face) Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face)
24
27
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
31
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
34
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
42
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
46
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
48A
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia); Inaccurate (contains blank and extraneous pages not part of the exhibit); Incomplete (missing pages)
50
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
Page 2 of 35
Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM
Document 420
Filed 11/05/2007
Page 5 of 38
Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 51 Objections
Composite (contains excerpts from larger document); Hearsay; Incomplete (contains excerpts from larger document)
54
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
56
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
59
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
61
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
64
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
65
Incomplete (contains excerpts from larger document)
71
Authenticity (unidentified handwriting); Composite (appears to be combination of two or more documents)
72
Composite (appears to be combination of two or more documents)
80
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
Page 3 of 35
Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM
Document 420
Filed 11/05/2007
Page 6 of 38
Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 83 Objections Composite (bates ending H&R-B4300680-81 appears to be PX 85)
84
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
86
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia; exhibit not identifiable upon its face)
92
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
99
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
101
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face)
104
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face)
111
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
113
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
116
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
121
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
124
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
129
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia) Page 4 of 35
Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM
Document 420
Filed 11/05/2007
Page 7 of 38
Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 132 Objections Authenticity (unidentified marginalia; exhibit not identifiable upon its face)
136
Incomplete (missing pages)
138
Composite (contains excerpts from larger document); Incomplete (contains excerpts from larger document)
147
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
150
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
155
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
160
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
163
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
164
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia); Incomplete (contains excerpts from larger document)
165
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia; changes made to document)
166
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
178
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
Page 5 of 35
Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM
Document 420
Filed 11/05/2007
Page 8 of 38
Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 181 Objections
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
193
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
202
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia); Composite (bates ending 206-208 appears to be a different document)
203
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
217
Hearsay
218
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
219
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
230
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
238
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
241
Incomplete (poor copy quality)
244
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
247
Authenticity (unidentified handwriting)
Page 6 of 35
Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM
Document 420
Filed 11/05/2007
Page 9 of 38
Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 250 Objections Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
251
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
256
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
261
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
265
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
280
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia); Composite
284
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia); Inaccurate (contains duplicate pages); Incomplete (missing pages)
288
Authenticity (unidentified handwriting; exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Composite
289
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia; exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Composite
290
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia; exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Composite (contains excerpts from larger document); Incomplete (contains excerpts from larger document)
Page 7 of 35
Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM
Document 420
Filed 11/05/2007
Page 10 of 38
Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 295 Objections Authenticity (unidentified marginalia); Composite (appears to be two copies of the same exhibit)
296
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
299
Incomplete
303A
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face)
316
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
317
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
319
Incomplete (contains excerpts from larger document)
324
Incomplete (poor copy quality)
326
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
327
Incomplete
328
Incomplete
Page 8 of 35
Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM
Document 420
Filed 11/05/2007
Page 11 of 38
Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 331 Objections Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
332
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
336
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
339
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
345
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
356
Composite
359
Incomplete (missing pages)
361
Incomplete (missing internal page 6)
363
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
370
Hearsay
375
Authenticity (changes made to document)
378
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia); Composite (appears to be combination of two or more documents)
380
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
Page 9 of 35
Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM
Document 420
Filed 11/05/2007
Page 12 of 38
Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 385 Objections
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
393
Incomplete (missing page)
394
Incomplete (missing page)
395
Incomplete (poor copy quality on page bates ending 01155)
399
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
405
Incomplete (poor copy quality)
407
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
408
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
413
Incomplete
436
Inaccurate (contains blank page not part of the exhibit
438
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
Page 10 of 35
Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM
Document 420
Filed 11/05/2007
Page 13 of 38
Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 441 Objections Inaccurate and Incomplete (bates numbers on exhibit received do not match bates numbers on plaintiffs' exhibit list)
442
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
443
Incomplete (contains excerpts from larger document)
448
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
449
Incomplete (missing pages)
450
Incomplete (missing pages)
451
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia); Hearsay
455
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
486A
Incomplete (missing pages)
499
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
Page 11 of 35
Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM
Document 420
Filed 11/05/2007
Page 14 of 38
Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 499B Objections Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
500
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia); Hearsay
500B
Incomplete (document appears to be correct document, but does not match the bates number description on plaintiffs' exhibit list)
502
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
504
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
505
Incomplete (poor copy quality)
508
Incomplete (contains excerpts from larger document)
512
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
517
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
521
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
529
Incomplete (contains excerpts from larger document)
543
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
Page 12 of 35
Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM
Document 420
Filed 11/05/2007
Page 15 of 38
Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 546 Objections Incomplete (missing pages)
577
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
578
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
581
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
582
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
584
Composite (bates ending 552-561 appears to be a different document)
586
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
589
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
591
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
592
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face)
594
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
Page 13 of 35
Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM
Document 420
Filed 11/05/2007
Page 16 of 38
Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 595 Objections Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face)
597
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face)
599A
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face)
599B
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face)
599C
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face)
600
Hearsay
600A
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay
600B
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay
600C
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay
600D
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay; Relevance (exhibit relates to abandoned lost profits claim)
Page 14 of 35
Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM
Document 420
Filed 11/05/2007
Page 17 of 38
Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 600E Objections Hearsay; Relevance (exhibit relates to abandoned lost profits claim)
601
Hearsay; Incomplete (exhibit ends at p. 57, but should contain 73 pages)
601A
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay
601B
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay
601C
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay
601D
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay; Relevance (exhibit relates to abandoned lost profits claim)
601E
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay; Relevance (exhibit relates to abandoned lost profits claim)
602
Hearsay
602A
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay; Relevance (exhibit relates to abandoned lost profits claim)
Page 15 of 35
Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM
Document 420
Filed 11/05/2007
Page 18 of 38
Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 602B Objections Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay; Relevance (exhibit relates to abandoned lost profits claim)
602C
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay; Relevance (exhibit relates to abandoned lost profits claim)
603
Hearsay; Relevance (exhibit relates to abandoned lost profits claim)
603A
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay; Relevance (exhibit relates to abandoned lost profits claim)
604
Hearsay; Relevance (exhibit relates to abandoned lost profits claim)
604A
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay; Relevance (exhibit relates to abandoned lost profits claim)
605
Hearsay
605A
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay
605B
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay
Page 16 of 35
Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM
Document 420
Filed 11/05/2007
Page 19 of 38
Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 605C Objections Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay
605D
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay
605E
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay
605F
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay
605G
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay
605H
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay
605I
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay
605J
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay
Page 17 of 35
Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM
Document 420
Filed 11/05/2007
Page 20 of 38
Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 605K Objections Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay
605L
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay
605M
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay
605N
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay
605O
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Composite (third and subsequent pages appear to be PX 606); Hearsay
606
Hearsay
606A
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay
606B
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay
606C
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay
606D
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay
Page 18 of 35
Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM
Document 420
Filed 11/05/2007
Page 21 of 38
Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 606E Objections Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay
606F
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay
606G
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay
606H
Hearsay
606I
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay
607
Hearsay
607A
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay
607B
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay
608
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
611
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
612
Hearsay
612A
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay Page 19 of 35
Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM
Document 420
Filed 11/05/2007
Page 22 of 38
Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 612B Objections Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay
612C
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay
612D
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay
612E
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay
612F
Authenticity (unidentified handwriting; unidentified marginalia; exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay
612G
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay
612H
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay
612I
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay
612J
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay
Page 20 of 35
Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM
Document 420
Filed 11/05/2007
Page 23 of 38
Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 612K Objections Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay
612L
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay
612M
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay
615
Inaccurate and Incomplete (extraneous pages without bates numbers; missing bates ending 1101)
618
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia); Composite; Incomplete (missing internal pages 13-14)
619
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
622
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
625
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
628
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
630
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
Page 21 of 35
Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM
Document 420
Filed 11/05/2007
Page 24 of 38
Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 633 Objections Authenticity (unidentified marginalia); Incomplete (poor copy quality)
640
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
642
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
646
Incomplete
647
Hearsay; Incomplete (contains excerpts from larger document)
649
Incomplete (poor copy quality)
650
Composite
651
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
655
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
662
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia); Incomplete (partially missing bates numbers)
665
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
Page 22 of 35
Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM
Document 420
Filed 11/05/2007
Page 25 of 38
Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 669 Objections Authenticity ( unidentified marginalia)
680
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
685
Incomplete (contains excerpts from larger document)
686
Authenticity ( unidentified marginalia)
703
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
717
Composite
730
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
731
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
736
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
739
Incomplete
744
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia); Incomplete (contains excerpts from larger document)
771
Incomplete (contains excerpts from larger document; bates range of document produced does not match bates range on plaintiffs' exhibit list)
Page 23 of 35
Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM
Document 420
Filed 11/05/2007
Page 26 of 38
Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 784 Objections Incomplete (exhibit not produced)
788
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
793
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
801
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
804
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia); Inaccurate (page included without bates stamp)
821
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
826
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
840
Incomplete
851
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
853
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
862
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Composite or Incomplete
872
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
Page 24 of 35
Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM
Document 420
Filed 11/05/2007
Page 27 of 38
Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 885 Objections Incomplete (missing page)
888
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
893
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
899
Hearsay; Relevance
904
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Composite or Incomplete
907
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
914
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable); Composite or Incomplete
919
Incomplete (contains excerpts from larger document)
920
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
926
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
927
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia); Incomplete (missing bates ending 00935)
Page 25 of 35
Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM
Document 420
Filed 11/05/2007
Page 28 of 38
Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 928 Objections Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
938
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
940
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
941
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia); Composite
948
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
958
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
960
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
965
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Composite or Incomplete
974
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Composite or Incomplete
975
Incomplete (missing pages)
980
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
982
Composite
Page 26 of 35
Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM
Document 420
Filed 11/05/2007
Page 29 of 38
Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 987 Objections Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
989
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
990
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
993
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
994
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
995
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia; exhibit not identifiable upon its face)
1001
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
1009
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
1016
Composite (pages subsequent to WCHB80-0431 appear to be different documents)
1020
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
1025
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
1043
Hearsay; Incomplete (contains excerpts from larger document)
Page 27 of 35
Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM
Document 420
Filed 11/05/2007
Page 30 of 38
Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 1044A Objections Hearsay; Incomplete (contains excerpts from larger document)
1047
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
1052
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Incomplete (contains excerpts from larger document)
1057
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
1058
Authenticity (changes made to document)
1060
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
1061
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia); Composite; Incomplete (missing bates ending 2588-2591)
1070
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
1071
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
1072
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
1075
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
Page 28 of 35
Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM
Document 420
Filed 11/05/2007
Page 31 of 38
Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 1076 Objections Incomplete (contains excerpts from larger document); Relevance
1077
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
1085
Incomplete (contains excerpts from larger document)
1089
Incomplete (contains excerpts from larger document)
1091
Incomplete (contains excerpts from larger document)
1093
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
1096
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face)
1097
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face)
1099
Incomplete (contains excerpts from larger document)
1100
Hearsay; Relevance
1101
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay
Page 29 of 35
Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM
Document 420
Filed 11/05/2007
Page 32 of 38
Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 1102 Objections Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay
1128
Hearsay; Relevance (letter from counsel)
1129
Hearsay; Relevance (letter from counsel)
1130
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay
1131
Hearsay; Relevance (letter from counsel; relates to abandoned lost profits claim)
1132
Hearsay
1133
Hearsay
1134
Hearsay; Relevance (letter from counsel)
1135
Hearsay; Relevance (letter from counsel)
1136
Incomplete (contains excerpts from larger document)
Page 30 of 35
Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM
Document 420
Filed 11/05/2007
Page 33 of 38
Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 1141 Objections
Incomplete (contains excerpts from larger document)
1143
Hearsay; Relevance (letter from counsel)
1145
Incomplete (contains excerpts from larger document)
1146
Hearsay; Relevance (letter from counsel; relates to abandoned lost profits claim)
1147
Hearsay
1149
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face)
1149A
Incomplete (contains excerpts from larger document)
1151
Composite; Relevance (exhibit relates to abandoned lost profits claim)
1153
Hearsay
1154
Hearsay
Page 31 of 35
Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM
Document 420
Filed 11/05/2007
Page 34 of 38
Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 1155 Objections
Authenticity (web address of document not visible)
1156
Hearsay; Incomplete (poor copy quality; missing pages)
1157
Hearsay
1158
Hearsay; Incomplete (missing pages)
1159
Hearsay
1160
Hearsay
1161
Hearsay
1162
Hearsay
1163
Incomplete (copy quality)
1165
Composite
1166
Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face)
Page 32 of 35
Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM
Document 420
Filed 11/05/2007
Page 35 of 38
Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 1167 Objections
Hearsay
1168
Authenticity (unidentifiable marginalia)
1170
Incomplete (contains excerpts from larger document)
1171
In addition to any other objections we reserve in this filing, we also reserve our right to object to PX 1171 pursuant to Fed. R. Evid. 1006.
1172
In addition to any other objections we reserve in this filing, we also reserve our right to object to PX 1172 pursuant to Fed. R. Evid. 1006.
1175
Authenticity (unidentifiable marginalia; changes made to document)
1177
Authenticity (unidentifiable marginalia)
1178
Authenticity (unidentifiable marginalia)
1181
Authenticity (unidentifiable marginalia)
Page 33 of 35
Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM
Document 420
Filed 11/05/2007
Page 36 of 38
Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 1183 Objections
Authenticity (unidentifiable marginalia)
1184
Authenticity (unidentifiable marginalia)
1186
Authenticity (unidentifiable marginalia)
1190
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
1193
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
1196
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia); Hearsay
1197
Hearsay
1198
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
1202
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia); Hearsay; Inaccurate (missing bates label between H&R-B-41-1650 and 1651)
1206
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia); Hearsay
Page 34 of 35
Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM
Document 420
Filed 11/05/2007
Page 37 of 38
Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 1209 Objections
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)
1213
Incomplete (poor copy quality)
1214
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia); Composite; Hearsay
1216
Authenticity (unidentified marginalia); Hearsay; Incomplete (missing pages)
Page 35 of 35
Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM
Document 420
Filed 11/05/2007
Page 38 of 38
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I hereby certify that on this 5th day of November 2007, a copy of the foregoing "DEFENDANT'S OBJECTIONS TO THE EXHIBITS IDENTIFIED BY PLAINTIFF" was filed electronically. I understand that notice of this filing will be sent to all parties by operation of the Court's electronic filing system. Parties may access this filing through the Court's system.
/s/ John H. Roberson by /s/ Elizabeth A. Holt John H. Roberson