Free Objection to Exhibit List - District Court of Federal Claims - federal

Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM

Document 420

Filed 11/05/2007

Page 1 of 38

IN THE UNITED STATES COURT OF FEDERAL CLAIMS ____________________________________ HOMER J. HOLLAND, ) STEVEN BANGERT, Co-Executor of ) the Estate of HOWARD R. ROSS, and ) FIRST BANK, ) ) Case No. 95-524C Plaintiffs, ) ) (Judge George W. Miller) v. ) ) (Winstar-Related Case) THE UNITED STATES, ) ) Defendant. ) ____________________________________)

DEFENDANT'S OBJECTIONS TO THE EXHIBITS IDENTIFIED BY PLAINTIFFS Defendant, the United States, respectfully identifies its objections to the trial exhibits identified by plaintiffs, Homer J. Holland, Steven Bangert, Co-Executor of the Estate of Howard R. Ross, and First Bank, in their exhibit list, filed September 26, 2007, and their supplemental exhibit list, filed October 12, 2007. We reserve our right to object to any exhibit upon grounds of relevance, Federal Rules of Evidence ("FRE") 401 and 402; hearsay, FRE 802; and foundation, FRE 901, to the extent these issues are raised by the manner in which the exhibit is used at trial. We also reserve all our rights under the Master Stipulation that governs this case, including our right to object upon authenticity grounds to exhibits that include handwritten notes. In addition to these general objections, we have identified upon the attached list our objections to specific exhibits according to the following general categories: authenticity, FRE 901 and 902; composite, FRE 403; hearsay, FRE 802; incompleteness, FRE 403; and relevance, FRE 401 and 402.

Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM

Document 420

Filed 11/05/2007

Page 2 of 38

Respectfully submitted, MICHAEL F. HERTZ Deputy Assistant Attorney General

JEANNE E. DAVIDSON Director /s/ Kenneth M. Dintzer KENNETH M. DINTZER Assistant Director

Of Counsel: SCOTT D. AUSTIN KENNETH M. DINTZER ELIZABETH A. HOLT WILLIAM G. KANELLIS BRIAN A. MIZOGUCHI AMANDA L. TANTUM JOHN J. TODOR November 5, 2007

/s/ John H. Roberson by /s/ Elizabeth A. Holt JOHN H. ROBERSON Trial Attorney Commercial Litigation Branch Civil Division Department of Justice Attn: Classification Unit 8th Floor, 1100 L Street Washington, D.C. 20530 Tele: (202) 353-7972 Fax: (202) 514-8640 Attorneys for Defendant

Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM

Document 420

Filed 11/05/2007

Page 3 of 38

Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits

PX Exhibit # 3

Objections Composite (contains excerpts from larger document); Incomplete (contains excerpts from larger document)

4

Hearsay; Incomplete (contains excerpts from larger document)

6

Hearsay; Incomplete (contains excerpts from larger document)

8

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

9

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

12

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

13

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

15

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia; exhibit not identifiable upon its face)

17

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

18

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

Page 1 of 35

Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM

Document 420

Filed 11/05/2007

Page 4 of 38

Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 20 Objections Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face)

22

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face) Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face)

24

27

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

31

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

34

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

42

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

46

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

48A

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia); Inaccurate (contains blank and extraneous pages not part of the exhibit); Incomplete (missing pages)

50

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

Page 2 of 35

Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM

Document 420

Filed 11/05/2007

Page 5 of 38

Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 51 Objections

Composite (contains excerpts from larger document); Hearsay; Incomplete (contains excerpts from larger document)

54

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

56

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

59

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

61

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

64

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

65

Incomplete (contains excerpts from larger document)

71

Authenticity (unidentified handwriting); Composite (appears to be combination of two or more documents)

72

Composite (appears to be combination of two or more documents)

80

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

Page 3 of 35

Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM

Document 420

Filed 11/05/2007

Page 6 of 38

Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 83 Objections Composite (bates ending H&R-B4300680-81 appears to be PX 85)

84

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

86

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia; exhibit not identifiable upon its face)

92

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

99

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

101

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face)

104

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face)

111

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

113

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

116

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

121

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

124

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

129

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia) Page 4 of 35

Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM

Document 420

Filed 11/05/2007

Page 7 of 38

Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 132 Objections Authenticity (unidentified marginalia; exhibit not identifiable upon its face)

136

Incomplete (missing pages)

138

Composite (contains excerpts from larger document); Incomplete (contains excerpts from larger document)

147

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

150

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

155

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

160

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

163

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

164

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia); Incomplete (contains excerpts from larger document)

165

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia; changes made to document)

166

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

178

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

Page 5 of 35

Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM

Document 420

Filed 11/05/2007

Page 8 of 38

Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 181 Objections

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

193

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

202

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia); Composite (bates ending 206-208 appears to be a different document)

203

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

217

Hearsay

218

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

219

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

230

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

238

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

241

Incomplete (poor copy quality)

244

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

247

Authenticity (unidentified handwriting)

Page 6 of 35

Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM

Document 420

Filed 11/05/2007

Page 9 of 38

Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 250 Objections Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

251

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

256

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

261

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

265

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

280

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia); Composite

284

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia); Inaccurate (contains duplicate pages); Incomplete (missing pages)

288

Authenticity (unidentified handwriting; exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Composite

289

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia; exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Composite

290

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia; exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Composite (contains excerpts from larger document); Incomplete (contains excerpts from larger document)

Page 7 of 35

Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM

Document 420

Filed 11/05/2007

Page 10 of 38

Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 295 Objections Authenticity (unidentified marginalia); Composite (appears to be two copies of the same exhibit)

296

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

299

Incomplete

303A

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face)

316

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

317

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

319

Incomplete (contains excerpts from larger document)

324

Incomplete (poor copy quality)

326

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

327

Incomplete

328

Incomplete

Page 8 of 35

Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM

Document 420

Filed 11/05/2007

Page 11 of 38

Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 331 Objections Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

332

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

336

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

339

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

345

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

356

Composite

359

Incomplete (missing pages)

361

Incomplete (missing internal page 6)

363

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

370

Hearsay

375

Authenticity (changes made to document)

378

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia); Composite (appears to be combination of two or more documents)

380

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

Page 9 of 35

Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM

Document 420

Filed 11/05/2007

Page 12 of 38

Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 385 Objections

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

393

Incomplete (missing page)

394

Incomplete (missing page)

395

Incomplete (poor copy quality on page bates ending 01155)

399

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

405

Incomplete (poor copy quality)

407

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

408

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

413

Incomplete

436

Inaccurate (contains blank page not part of the exhibit

438

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

Page 10 of 35

Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM

Document 420

Filed 11/05/2007

Page 13 of 38

Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 441 Objections Inaccurate and Incomplete (bates numbers on exhibit received do not match bates numbers on plaintiffs' exhibit list)

442

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

443

Incomplete (contains excerpts from larger document)

448

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

449

Incomplete (missing pages)

450

Incomplete (missing pages)

451

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia); Hearsay

455

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

486A

Incomplete (missing pages)

499

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

Page 11 of 35

Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM

Document 420

Filed 11/05/2007

Page 14 of 38

Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 499B Objections Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

500

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia); Hearsay

500B

Incomplete (document appears to be correct document, but does not match the bates number description on plaintiffs' exhibit list)

502

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

504

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

505

Incomplete (poor copy quality)

508

Incomplete (contains excerpts from larger document)

512

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

517

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

521

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

529

Incomplete (contains excerpts from larger document)

543

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

Page 12 of 35

Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM

Document 420

Filed 11/05/2007

Page 15 of 38

Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 546 Objections Incomplete (missing pages)

577

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

578

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

581

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

582

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

584

Composite (bates ending 552-561 appears to be a different document)

586

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

589

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

591

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

592

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face)

594

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

Page 13 of 35

Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM

Document 420

Filed 11/05/2007

Page 16 of 38

Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 595 Objections Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face)

597

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face)

599A

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face)

599B

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face)

599C

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face)

600

Hearsay

600A

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay

600B

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay

600C

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay

600D

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay; Relevance (exhibit relates to abandoned lost profits claim)

Page 14 of 35

Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM

Document 420

Filed 11/05/2007

Page 17 of 38

Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 600E Objections Hearsay; Relevance (exhibit relates to abandoned lost profits claim)

601

Hearsay; Incomplete (exhibit ends at p. 57, but should contain 73 pages)

601A

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay

601B

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay

601C

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay

601D

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay; Relevance (exhibit relates to abandoned lost profits claim)

601E

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay; Relevance (exhibit relates to abandoned lost profits claim)

602

Hearsay

602A

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay; Relevance (exhibit relates to abandoned lost profits claim)

Page 15 of 35

Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM

Document 420

Filed 11/05/2007

Page 18 of 38

Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 602B Objections Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay; Relevance (exhibit relates to abandoned lost profits claim)

602C

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay; Relevance (exhibit relates to abandoned lost profits claim)

603

Hearsay; Relevance (exhibit relates to abandoned lost profits claim)

603A

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay; Relevance (exhibit relates to abandoned lost profits claim)

604

Hearsay; Relevance (exhibit relates to abandoned lost profits claim)

604A

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay; Relevance (exhibit relates to abandoned lost profits claim)

605

Hearsay

605A

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay

605B

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay

Page 16 of 35

Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM

Document 420

Filed 11/05/2007

Page 19 of 38

Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 605C Objections Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay

605D

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay

605E

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay

605F

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay

605G

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay

605H

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay

605I

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay

605J

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay

Page 17 of 35

Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM

Document 420

Filed 11/05/2007

Page 20 of 38

Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 605K Objections Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay

605L

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay

605M

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay

605N

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay

605O

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Composite (third and subsequent pages appear to be PX 606); Hearsay

606

Hearsay

606A

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay

606B

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay

606C

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay

606D

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay

Page 18 of 35

Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM

Document 420

Filed 11/05/2007

Page 21 of 38

Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 606E Objections Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay

606F

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay

606G

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay

606H

Hearsay

606I

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay

607

Hearsay

607A

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay

607B

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay

608

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

611

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

612

Hearsay

612A

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay Page 19 of 35

Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM

Document 420

Filed 11/05/2007

Page 22 of 38

Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 612B Objections Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay

612C

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay

612D

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay

612E

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay

612F

Authenticity (unidentified handwriting; unidentified marginalia; exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay

612G

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay

612H

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay

612I

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay

612J

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay

Page 20 of 35

Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM

Document 420

Filed 11/05/2007

Page 23 of 38

Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 612K Objections Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay

612L

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay

612M

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay

615

Inaccurate and Incomplete (extraneous pages without bates numbers; missing bates ending 1101)

618

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia); Composite; Incomplete (missing internal pages 13-14)

619

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

622

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

625

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

628

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

630

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

Page 21 of 35

Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM

Document 420

Filed 11/05/2007

Page 24 of 38

Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 633 Objections Authenticity (unidentified marginalia); Incomplete (poor copy quality)

640

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

642

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

646

Incomplete

647

Hearsay; Incomplete (contains excerpts from larger document)

649

Incomplete (poor copy quality)

650

Composite

651

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

655

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

662

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia); Incomplete (partially missing bates numbers)

665

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

Page 22 of 35

Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM

Document 420

Filed 11/05/2007

Page 25 of 38

Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 669 Objections Authenticity ( unidentified marginalia)

680

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

685

Incomplete (contains excerpts from larger document)

686

Authenticity ( unidentified marginalia)

703

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

717

Composite

730

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

731

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

736

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

739

Incomplete

744

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia); Incomplete (contains excerpts from larger document)

771

Incomplete (contains excerpts from larger document; bates range of document produced does not match bates range on plaintiffs' exhibit list)

Page 23 of 35

Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM

Document 420

Filed 11/05/2007

Page 26 of 38

Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 784 Objections Incomplete (exhibit not produced)

788

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

793

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

801

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

804

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia); Inaccurate (page included without bates stamp)

821

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

826

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

840

Incomplete

851

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

853

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

862

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Composite or Incomplete

872

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

Page 24 of 35

Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM

Document 420

Filed 11/05/2007

Page 27 of 38

Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 885 Objections Incomplete (missing page)

888

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

893

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

899

Hearsay; Relevance

904

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Composite or Incomplete

907

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

914

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable); Composite or Incomplete

919

Incomplete (contains excerpts from larger document)

920

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

926

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

927

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia); Incomplete (missing bates ending 00935)

Page 25 of 35

Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM

Document 420

Filed 11/05/2007

Page 28 of 38

Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 928 Objections Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

938

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

940

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

941

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia); Composite

948

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

958

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

960

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

965

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Composite or Incomplete

974

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Composite or Incomplete

975

Incomplete (missing pages)

980

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

982

Composite

Page 26 of 35

Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM

Document 420

Filed 11/05/2007

Page 29 of 38

Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 987 Objections Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

989

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

990

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

993

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

994

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

995

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia; exhibit not identifiable upon its face)

1001

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

1009

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

1016

Composite (pages subsequent to WCHB80-0431 appear to be different documents)

1020

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

1025

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

1043

Hearsay; Incomplete (contains excerpts from larger document)

Page 27 of 35

Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM

Document 420

Filed 11/05/2007

Page 30 of 38

Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 1044A Objections Hearsay; Incomplete (contains excerpts from larger document)

1047

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

1052

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Incomplete (contains excerpts from larger document)

1057

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

1058

Authenticity (changes made to document)

1060

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

1061

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia); Composite; Incomplete (missing bates ending 2588-2591)

1070

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

1071

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

1072

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

1075

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

Page 28 of 35

Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM

Document 420

Filed 11/05/2007

Page 31 of 38

Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 1076 Objections Incomplete (contains excerpts from larger document); Relevance

1077

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

1085

Incomplete (contains excerpts from larger document)

1089

Incomplete (contains excerpts from larger document)

1091

Incomplete (contains excerpts from larger document)

1093

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

1096

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face)

1097

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face)

1099

Incomplete (contains excerpts from larger document)

1100

Hearsay; Relevance

1101

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay

Page 29 of 35

Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM

Document 420

Filed 11/05/2007

Page 32 of 38

Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 1102 Objections Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay

1128

Hearsay; Relevance (letter from counsel)

1129

Hearsay; Relevance (letter from counsel)

1130

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face); Hearsay

1131

Hearsay; Relevance (letter from counsel; relates to abandoned lost profits claim)

1132

Hearsay

1133

Hearsay

1134

Hearsay; Relevance (letter from counsel)

1135

Hearsay; Relevance (letter from counsel)

1136

Incomplete (contains excerpts from larger document)

Page 30 of 35

Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM

Document 420

Filed 11/05/2007

Page 33 of 38

Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 1141 Objections

Incomplete (contains excerpts from larger document)

1143

Hearsay; Relevance (letter from counsel)

1145

Incomplete (contains excerpts from larger document)

1146

Hearsay; Relevance (letter from counsel; relates to abandoned lost profits claim)

1147

Hearsay

1149

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face)

1149A

Incomplete (contains excerpts from larger document)

1151

Composite; Relevance (exhibit relates to abandoned lost profits claim)

1153

Hearsay

1154

Hearsay

Page 31 of 35

Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM

Document 420

Filed 11/05/2007

Page 34 of 38

Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 1155 Objections

Authenticity (web address of document not visible)

1156

Hearsay; Incomplete (poor copy quality; missing pages)

1157

Hearsay

1158

Hearsay; Incomplete (missing pages)

1159

Hearsay

1160

Hearsay

1161

Hearsay

1162

Hearsay

1163

Incomplete (copy quality)

1165

Composite

1166

Authenticity (exhibit not identifiable upon its face)

Page 32 of 35

Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM

Document 420

Filed 11/05/2007

Page 35 of 38

Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 1167 Objections

Hearsay

1168

Authenticity (unidentifiable marginalia)

1170

Incomplete (contains excerpts from larger document)

1171

In addition to any other objections we reserve in this filing, we also reserve our right to object to PX 1171 pursuant to Fed. R. Evid. 1006.

1172

In addition to any other objections we reserve in this filing, we also reserve our right to object to PX 1172 pursuant to Fed. R. Evid. 1006.

1175

Authenticity (unidentifiable marginalia; changes made to document)

1177

Authenticity (unidentifiable marginalia)

1178

Authenticity (unidentifiable marginalia)

1181

Authenticity (unidentifiable marginalia)

Page 33 of 35

Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM

Document 420

Filed 11/05/2007

Page 36 of 38

Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 1183 Objections

Authenticity (unidentifiable marginalia)

1184

Authenticity (unidentifiable marginalia)

1186

Authenticity (unidentifiable marginalia)

1190

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

1193

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

1196

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia); Hearsay

1197

Hearsay

1198

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

1202

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia); Hearsay; Inaccurate (missing bates label between H&R-B-41-1650 and 1651)

1206

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia); Hearsay

Page 34 of 35

Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM

Document 420

Filed 11/05/2007

Page 37 of 38

Defendant's List Of Objections To Plaintiffs' Exhibits
PX Exhibit # 1209 Objections

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia)

1213

Incomplete (poor copy quality)

1214

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia); Composite; Hearsay

1216

Authenticity (unidentified marginalia); Hearsay; Incomplete (missing pages)

Page 35 of 35

Case 1:95-cv-00524-GWM

Document 420

Filed 11/05/2007

Page 38 of 38

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

I hereby certify that on this 5th day of November 2007, a copy of the foregoing "DEFENDANT'S OBJECTIONS TO THE EXHIBITS IDENTIFIED BY PLAINTIFF" was filed electronically. I understand that notice of this filing will be sent to all parties by operation of the Court's electronic filing system. Parties may access this filing through the Court's system.

/s/ John H. Roberson by /s/ Elizabeth A. Holt John H. Roberson