Free Motion for Leave to File - District Court of Federal Claims - federal

Case 1:01-cv-00201-VJW

Document 167

Filed 05/10/2006

Page 1 of 10

IN THE UNITED STATES COURT OF FEDERAL CLAIMS CAROLE AND ROBERT TESTWUIDE, et. al., Plaintiffs, No. 01-201 L Honorable Victor J. Wolski THE UNITED STATES, Defendant.

UNOPPOSED MOTION FOR LEAVE TO SUPPLEMENT EXHIBIT B Defendant, United States of America, hereby files this Motion for Leave to Supplement Exhibit B, "Declaration of Commander Stephen G. Riley, III," filed electronically on April 28, 2006, as an attachment to Defendant's Motion to Dismiss or, Alternatively, for Summary Judgment and Memorandum in Support Thereof. In his declaration, Commander Riley discusses Air Traffic Activity Reports ("ATARs") and how aircraft operations at Naval Air Station ("NAS") Oceana were reported before 1996 and beginning with 1996. See Declaration of Commander Stephen G. Riley, III, ("Riley Decl."), ¶¶ 7, 15-22. Copies of the 1981, 1992, 1999, and 2000 ATARs for NAS Oceana were inadvertently excluded from Exhibit B. Accordingly, Defendant respectfully requests the Court grant Defendant leave to file the 1981, 1992, 1999, and 2000 ATARs as a supplement to Exhibit B. Counsel for Plaintiffs has authorized Defendant to represent that counsel for Plaintiffs has no opposition to this motion for leave to supplement Exhibit B. Dated: May 10, 2006 /s/Steven D. Bryant Steven D. Bryant Kelle S. Acock Environmental & Natural Resources Division

Case 1:01-cv-00201-VJW

Document 167

Filed 05/10/2006

Page 2 of 10

United States Department of Justice 601 D Street, NW, Rm. 3205 Washington, D.C. 20004 Counsel for Defendants Of Counsel: Robert J. Smith Mary Raivel Navy Litigation Office 720 Kennon Street Washington Navy Yard, D.C. 20374 CDR Dominick Yacono JAGC, USN Commander Navy region Mid-Atlanic, Code (00LE) 1510 Gilbert Street Norfolk, VA 23511-2737

Case 1:01-cv-00201-VJW

Document 167

Filed 05/10/2006

Page 3 of 10

1981, 1992, 1999, and 2000 ATARs to Supplement Exhibit B, Declaration of Commander Stephen G. Riley, III

Case 1:01-cv-00201-VJW
RAFF~C ACTIVITY REPORT (REV,~8-73) SIN 0107,72e. ZgB1 EF OF NAVAL OPERATIONS (0P-513GI) DEPARTMENT
WASHINGTON, D.C. 20350 2. NAME OF ACI'IVITY SUB~IITTING REPORT

Document 167

Filed 05/10/2006

Page 4 of 10

REPORT ~YH80L OPNAV 3721-13
(See Reverse Side For Instructions) |. REPORT PERIOD

1 JAN - 30 JUNE 1981
3. LOCATION IDENTIFIER

Naval Air Station Oceana Virginia Beach, VA 23460
4. NAME OF AIRFIELD THIS REPORT

KNTU

APOLLO SOUCEK FIELD
5.

MILITARY AIRCRAFT OPERATIONS NAVY/ MARINE CORPS O~HER MILITARY AIR CARRIER

CIVIL
GEKERAL AVIATION I TOTAL

IFR (RADAR) VFR(TOWER)

30256 70280 100536 4928

1842 999 2841
---7.'

8

2244 1064
e

34350 72378

36
43 2
NODE II

TOTAL
6.

3308 ,~ , ,,,,,, 52
NOOE I II

RADAR APPROACHES

279
MOOE IA

5261
TOTAL

?.

NODE I ACLS APPROACHES

180/73
8- REMARKS

57/41

l 122/998

1021349

1461

FENTRESS

49928

APPROVED BY (Na~e, title and =i.gnature)

J.W. WAGNER, CDR, USN
COPY TO:

FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION rEFORMATION AND STATISTICS DIVISIOII OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS
WASHINOTON, D.C. 20591

v; c;

OCE238993

Case 1:01-cv-00201-VJW

Document 167

Filed 05/10/2006

Page 5 of 10

SEMI -ANNUAL
AIR TRAFFIC ACTIVITY REPORT 0PNAV 3721/12 (REV, 8-73) S/N O107-728-298I TO: CHIEF OF NAVAL OPERATIONS NAVY DEPARTMENT WASHINGTON, D.C. 20350 REPORT SYMBOL OPNAV 3721-!: (.See Reverse S~.de For Instructions) I3. REPORT PERIOD (OP-513GI)

Z. NAME OF ACTIVITY SUBMITTING REPORT

NAVAL AIR STATION OCEANA VIRGINIA BEACH VA 23460
4. NAME OF AIRFIELD THIS REPORT

I
I ....

1 JUL 81 - 31 DEC81

LOCATION IDENTIFIER

KNTU

APOLLO SOUCEK FIELD
5. AIRCRAFT OPERATIONS MILITARY NAVY/' MARINE CORPS OTHER Mi L, ITARY ] i I AIR CARRIER CIVIL GENERAL AVIATION TOTAL

IFR VFR TOTAL
... ,/

28,110 88,073 ~16,183 6202

1247 1103
'-..

30 166 -,.
/ /

2763 3533

32,150 92,875

2350

196 19
MODE II
i

.6296 t 025,025
11
/ MODE III

6. RADAR APPROACHES k '

/ 1 6441
TOTAL

2o9,//
WODE IA

7.

~DE I ACLS APPROACHES

103/59
8. REMARKS

27114

651 / 558

I

90/240

871

FENTRESS

41,000

I"

APPROVED BY (N==e, title =rid sii~'~e)

/

., -

AC2 SALLY C. D/~~[~<~~/
COPY TO:

FEDERAL AVIATION ADHINISTRATION INFONMATION ANDSTATISTICS DIVISION OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS
WASBINBTN~ D.C, 2~9l

OCE238994

Case 1:01-cv-00201-VJW

Document 167

Filed 05/10/2006

Page 6 of 10

Air Traffic Activity Report
AIR TRAFFIC ACTIVITY REPORT CH IEF OF NAVAL OI~RATION$ ~lql~t" N t~ t~" f NAVY DEPARTMENT WAIHINGTON, D.C. 20360.3000

23462
5. AIRCRAFT OPERATIONS NAVY/
M~INE CORPB

MILn'ARY OTHER MILITAI~Y
AIR CAFIRfER

CIVIL GENERAL AVIATOFI l TOTAL

107,360 VFR TOTAL 99,991 207,351
MODE I 7. ACLI~ACNa

5,956 3,016
,n, ,,

0 0 0 0
MOOE U

7,810 5,251 13,061

121,12 108,25 229,38z
TOTAL

8,972
MODE 1A

8,708 I 356

118 I
MODE III

245
1 ~17 _

4

5,387

1,513

7r149

(1! Nu~lwm~mml

(2l Nunduw of rocW m~ aNompiodmcl 1.002 (31 bhmbf~lml~lW~l~am.m~.mmo.Uvlntfr~d~ew. 36 ¯ 0

14) ~Mmm~-~ i~ m~ o.me *INCLUDES 49,264 VISUAL APPROACHES NFE-93,030 15G20 OTS- 9-27 JAN, 8-27 FEB, 1-4 SEP, 2-7 AND 11-14 DEC.

N/A

1-31 MAR, 1-7 APR, 20-31 AUG,

~.A.,LCDR,AIR TRAFFIC CONTROL FACILTY OFFICER,
OPYTO¢ "PfpeGomNtmdlf (COMNAVAIRLANT) ATC R~nmor~e ~VREP

,1

ctlc (Avlmtlon) (for ucuc oagy)

Nd/IM

ORIGINAL

0CE087548

Case 1:01-cv-00201-VJW

Document 167

Filed 05/10/2006

Page 7 of 10

AIR TRAFFIC ACTIVITY REPORT TO. CHIEF OF NAVAL' OPERATION (N885F) NAVY DEPARTMENT WASHINGTON, D,C. 20350-2000 I. REPORT PERIOD t ~ 19~J9 - 3 t Dc¢~;mbvr 1999

2 NAME OF ACTIVITY ~'BMITITNG REPORT NAS OCEANA, VmGnCINA BEACH, VA 234~0 4 NAMEOF Ammm,D~S~_YORT
APOI5.,O $OUCEK 5 CONTROL TOWER OPERATIONS AIRPORT 126164 TRANSIT 32O TOTAL 126484 6. RADAR APPROACHES ..... MODE I 7. PALS APPROACHES MODE IA 4O23 163 3860 MILITARY NAVY/ MARINE CORPS

3 ~ATION IDENTIFIER

CIVIL AIR CARRIER 0 0
. Lu,| J,

OTHER MILITARY

GENERAL AVIATION 94 2291 2385

TOTAL'
........ 130118 2274 132892

0

MODE II
,,,

MOD]~ m
,,,

TOTAL

8. Training D~wic~ Us=d - Type Devic~ (I) Numbex of hours used (2) Number of radar approaches accxcmplished (3) Number of hou~ of pattc~m control, vc~'tor to outlying fields, ~. (4) Number of hours not usedbocaus¢ ofmamtenanc~ outage 9 Remarks (ur~ additional pages ffdc~e,d)

APPROVED ~ ~ ]" D~:'I~EBERT, CDR, USN OIC) AIR OPS DET) NAS,QCEANA ..... .... COPY TO. CX)IvINAVAIRLANT (N37) NAVREP FAA ATREP SPAWARSYSCEN (313)

0CE087532

Case 1:01-cv-00201-VJW

Document 167

Filed 05/10/2006

Page 8 of 10

AIR TRAFFIC ACTIVITY REPORT TO. CHIEF OF NAVAL OPERATION (NSgSF) NAVY DEPARXaMENT WASHINGTON. D.C 20350-2000 2 NAME oFACTIV1TY SUBMITTING REPORT NAS OCEANA, VIRGININA BEACH, VA 23460 I. REPORT PERIOD

3. LOCATION IDENTIFIER

4. NAME OF AIRFIELD THIS REPORT APOLLO SOUCEK 5. APPROACH CONTROL OPERATIONS MILITARY NAVY/ MARINE CORPS 41262 VFR 2421 TOTAL 43683 6. RADAR APPROACHES 2035 MODE I 7. PALS APPROACHES 39 MODE iA 10 102 "MODE II 2489 0 42 MODE III 709 2179 TOTAL' 3247 2390 0 7640 53531 1522 0 7435 11378 OTHER MILITARY 868 CIVIL AIR CARRIER 0

GENERAL
AVIATION 205

TOTAL 42153

8 Training Device Used -Typc Dew¢~ 15Q33 0 (I) Number of hours used (2) Number of radar approaches accomphshed 0 (3) Number of hours of pattern control, vector to outlying fields, etc _0 (4) Number of hours not used because of maintenance outage 8442 9. Remarks (use mtdmor, al pages ff des~ed) 15G33 CASREP 23 NOV 98

APPROVED~L,,.F-' ~'/"-" D~. P. HEBERT, CDR, USN OIC, AIR OPS DET, NAS OCEANA ,,,,, ,,,, COPY TO. COMNAVAIRLANT (N37) NAVREP FAA ATREP SPAWARSYS CEN (313)

0CE087533

Case 1:01-cv-00201-VJW

Document 167

Filed 05/10/2006

Page 9 of 10

AIR TRAFFIC ACTIVITY REPORT TO CHIEF OFNAVAL OPERATION (N885F) NAVY DEPARTMENT WASHINGTON, D C 20350.2000 2. NAME OF ACTIVITY SUBMITTING REPORT NAS OCEANA, VIRGININA BEACH, VA 23460 4. NAME OF AIRFIELD THIS REPORT APOLLO SOUCEK MILITARY CONTROL TOWER OPERATIONS AIRPORT 154623 TRANSIT 361 TOTAL 154984 6. RADAR APPROACHES MOE)E I 7. PALS APPROACHES 8 Trammg Devlce Used - Type Device (I) Number of hours used (2) Number of radar approaches accomplished (3) Number of hours of pattern control, vector to outlying fields, etc (4) Number of hours not used because of maintenance outage 9. Remarks (use additional pages if desu, e.d) MODE IA ' MODE rr M'ODE m TOTAL 2731 0 1932 159647 245 0 1602 2208 2486 0 330 157439 CIVIL. AIR CARRIER GENERAL AVIATION TOTAL 1. REPORT PERIOD 1 January - 31December 2000

3. LOCATION IDENTIFIER NTU

MARINE CORPS

NAVY/

OTHER MILITARY

APPROVED~-.~. ~ ~ "-~ ~\ D. P.~B'BBE1~, CDK, USN AIR OPERATIONS OFFICER, N AS OCEANA COPY TO- COMNAVAIRLANT (N37) NAVREP FAA ATREP SPAWARSYSCEN (313)

0CE087529

Case 1:01-cv-00201-VJW

Document 167

Filed 05/10/2006

Page 10 of 10

AIR TRAFFIC ACTIVITY REPORT TO: CHIEF OFNAVALOPERATION 0N885F) NAVY DF_,PARTMENT WASHINGTON, D.C. 20350-2000 I 2. NAME OF ACTIVITY SUB~0 REPORT NAS OCEANA, VIRGININA BEACH, VA 23460 4. NAME OF AIRFIF_X,D THIS REPORT APOLLO SOUCEK
........ ~H

'i'["" REPOI~T' PERIOD 1 January - 31 December 2000

! 3. LOCATI6~i'ID~R
NTU

5 APPROACH CONTROL OPERATIONS IFR 65318 VFR 2882 TOTAL 68200 & RADAR APPROACHES 6448 .I.L I MODE I '7. PALS APPROACHES i I

MILrrARY
NAVY/ MAR-~.,,., ~.C_~_~RPS OTHER MR,IrARY 1339 1909 3248 291 MODE IA 2 MODE II 3043

crv~
AIR CARRIER 0 0 0 0 GENERAL AVIATION 336 5832 .... 6168 69 MODE llI 593--" TOTAL

66993 1O623 77616 6808 TOTAL 3649

15G33 8. Training Device Used- Type. Device' (1) Number of hours used,,, 0 0 (2) Number of radar approaches accomplished (3) Number of hours of pattern control, vector to outlying fields, etc._._.._ 0. (4) Number of hours not used because of maintenance outage moving to new localion 9. Remarks (use additional pages if desired)

AIR OPERATIONS OFFICER, NAS OCEANA =., COPY TO:. COMNAVAIRLANT (N37) NAVR.EP FAA ATREP SPAWARSYSCEN (313)

0CE087530