Free Exhibit List - District Court of Federal Claims - federal

Case 1:01-cv-00201-VJW

Document 207-2

Filed 09/28/2006

Page 1 of 37
09/28/06

PLAINTIFFS' TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST
Plaintiff Exhibit No.
1 PT500

Expect to or May Offer
Plaintiffs May Offer

Date

Description

Defendant Objection
Relevance

Plaintiff Objection

Graph entitled, "Affects of Noise Level 00/00/2000 Changes."

2 PT501

Plaintiffs May Offer

CATALOG OF NOISE LEVELS FROM NAVY None 09/00/1984 AIRCRAFT - AESO Report No. 313-01-84 Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections

3 PT502 4 PT503 5 PT504

Plaintiffs May Offer Plaintiffs May Offer Plaintiffs May Offer

6 PT505

Plaintiffs May Offer

00/00/1994 Rebuttal - "FCLP ... Where and how much?" Email from Dan Cecchini to Pamela Anderson 1/9/1996 regarding EIS issues Email from John Reuther to N8 regarding 2/9/1996 noise and air quality impact of F/A-18 C/D Memo from Mr. Lyn Coffer (AESO) to Daniel Cecchini regarding Ecology and Environment, Inc. Draft Report on Conformity for NAS 2/6/1996 Oceana

None Relevance Relevance

Relevance

7 PT506

Plaintiffs May Offer

8 PT507

Plaintiffs May Offer

9 PT508

Plaintiffs May Offer

Point paper by Daniel Cecchini regarding NAS None 4/18/1996 Oceana Operations data and Noise Issues Rebuttal - Memo from E. L. Miller to CDR Pabst regarding Wyle Laboratories BRAC Relevance 5/2/1996 1995 Noise Study and EIS Rebuttal - Memo from Cdr. Miller to Daniel Cecchini regarding review of Wyle Relevance 5/10/1996 Laboratories Draft Noise Study WR 96Rebuttal - Email from Eric Boyajian to John 5/9/1996 Reuther re NASMOD data

10 PT509

Plaintiffs May Offer

None

11 PT510

Plaintiffs May Offer

12 PT511

Plaintiffs May Offer

Rebuttal - Email from Daniel Cecchini to None 6/19/1996 Pamela Anderson regarding NASMOD ATAC Corp document entitled, "Operational Assumptions and Scenario Descriptions for the Airfield and Airspace Operational Study of None 9/3/1996 the BRAC 95 Navy F/A-18 Relocation"

Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections

None

Testwuide v. United States

Page 1 of 37

Case 1:01-cv-00201-VJW

Document 207-2

Filed 09/28/2006

Page 2 of 37
09/28/06

PLAINTIFFS' TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST
Plaintiff Exhibit No.
13 PT512 14 PT513 15 PT514 16 PT515

Expect to or May Offer
Plaintiffs May Offer Plaintiffs May Offer Plaintiffs May Offer Plaintiffs May Offer

Date
11/6/1996 12/00/1996 12/30/1996 1/21/1997

Description
Email from Daniel Cecchini to Alan Zusman regarding possible changes to Draft EIS WYLE RESEARCH REPORT WR 96-3 Letter from Joseph Czech to Alan Zusman enclosing Wyle Research Report WR 96-3 Letter from Czech to Zusman regarding contours, with enclosures listed Email from Daniel Cecchini to Pamela Anderson regarding continued work on the Draft EIS Email from Alan Zusman to Daniel Cecchini regarding the 1979 AICUZ Noise Contours and Accident Potential Zones Memo from Daniel Cecchini to Jim Nordberg regarding noise, AICUZ and sensitive receptors Email from John Reuther to Glen McDowell, etc.

Defendant Objection
Relevance None None None

Plaintiff Objection

None None

17 PT516

Plaintiffs May Offer

2/13/1997

Relevance

18 PT517

Plaintiffs May Offer

2/17/1997

Relevance

19 PT518 20 PT519

Plaintiffs May Offer Plaintiffs May Offer

2/26/1997 3/4/1997

Relevance Relevance

21 PT520

Plaintiffs Expect to Offer

Memo from Director, Facilities & Engineering Division to N4, VCNO and CNO regarding 3/28/2000 Assessment of NAS Oceana EIS with notes

None

22 PT521

Plaintiffs Expect to Offer

23 PT522

Plaintiffs May Offer

Graph prepared by ATAC Corporation entitled, "Percent Increase of Airfield Operations from Baseline," regarding projected operations increases for the various realignment and closure scenarios considered in the EIS for None 00/00/2000 the Realignment of the F/A-18 C/D Memo from M. Shephard to Commander, Naval Base, Norfolk regarding Cecil Field Relevance 06/00/1997 Closure / AICUZ

Testwuide v. United States

Page 2 of 37

Case 1:01-cv-00201-VJW

Document 207-2

Filed 09/28/2006

Page 3 of 37
09/28/06

PLAINTIFFS' TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST
Plaintiff Exhibit No. Defendant Objection

Expect to or May Offer

Date

Description

Plaintiff Objection

24 PT523

Plaintiffs May Offer

25 PT524

Plaintiffs May Offer

Email from Alan Zusman to Jeffrey Borrowy regarding newly impacted residents in the 6575 dB and greater than 75 dB DNL noise zones surrounding NAS Oceana based on the Relevance 7/2/1997 Draft EIS Email exchange between Alan Zusman and Jeffrey Borowy regarding sound attenuation of Relevance 7/11/1997 homes surrounding NAS Oceana Rebuttal - Projected day/night operations 7/29/1997 Oceana for alternative realignment scenarios Informational Paper by LCDR Matt Cartier 8/11/1997 regarding continued work on the Draft EIS Email exchange between Alan Zusman, Jeffrey Borowy and Joseph Czech, et al. re 8/13/1997 Oceana DNL and Leqs Email exchange between Alan Zusman, Jeffrey Borowy, and Tom Peeling, et al. re F18 E/F and F-18 C/D versus F-14 noise levels WYLE RESEARCH REPORT WR 97-10 Memo from LCDR Matt Cartier to Captain Hoppock regarding responses to Draft EIS questions Memo from Duncan Holaday to Deputy Chief of Naval Operations regarding flight tracks stated in the Draft EIS Rebuttal - Memorandum for Deputy Chief of Naval Operations from Duncan Holiday regarding flight paths Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections

26 PT525 27 PT526

Plaintiffs May Offer Plaintiffs May Offer

Relevance Relevance

28 PT527

Plaintiffs May Offer

Relevance

29 PT528 30 PT529

Plaintiffs Expect to Offer Plaintiffs May Offer

8/13/1997 09/00/1997

None None

None

31 PT530

Plaintiffs May Offer

11/24/1997

Relevance

32 PT531

Plaintiffs May Offer

12/3/1997

None Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections

33 PT532

Plaintiffs May Offer

12/3/1997

None

34 PT533

Plaintiffs May Offer

Rebuttal - Memo from M.R. Johnson to Chief 12/9/1997 of Naval Operations re Draft EIS / flight tracks None

Testwuide v. United States

Page 3 of 37

Case 1:01-cv-00201-VJW

Document 207-2

Filed 09/28/2006

Page 4 of 37
09/28/06

PLAINTIFFS' TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST
Plaintiff Exhibit No. Defendant Objection

Expect to or May Offer

Date

Description

Plaintiff Objection
Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections None Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections

35 PT534

Plaintiffs May Offer

Rebuttal - Email from Cecchini to Vice 12/12/1997 Commander et al regarding flight tracks / EIS None Rebuttal - Memo from Joseph Czech to Alan None 12/12/1997 Zusman regarding flight tracks Memo from LCDR Matt Cartier to Daniel Cecchini regarding history of Class A mishaps Relevance 8/5/1997 in and around NAS Oceana Rebuttal - Fax from Cecchini to Zusman et al re EIS and Wyle tables / noise contours Relevance Email from Alan Zusman to Joseph Czech regarding sound attenuation of homes surrounding NAS Oceana Relevance Excerpts from WYLE RESEARCH REPORT WR 97-10 AIRCRAFT NOISE STUDY FOR THE BRAC REALIGNMENT OF NAVY F/A-18 AIRCRAFT None Email exchanges between Alan Zusman, Jeffrey Borowy and Duncan Holaday, et al. regarding sound attenuation Relevance Email exchange between Richard Anderson, Alan Zusman, Jeffrey Borowy and Duncan Holiday, et al. re real estate values surrounding Oceana Relevance RECORD OF DECISION FOR REALIGNMENT OF F/A-18s Relevance Point Paper by Borowy regarding aircraft noise policy and sound attenuation costs Relevance Memo from Jeffery Borrowy to Admiral Lou Smith regarding sound attenuation costs in areas surrounding NAS Oceana Relevance All Units - All Inclusive Relevance

36 PT535

Plaintiffs May Offer

37 PT536

Plaintiffs May Offer

38 PT537

Plaintiffs May Offer

1/27/1998

Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections

39 PT538

Plaintiffs May Offer

1/29/1998

40 PT539

Plaintiffs May Offer

02/00/1998

41 PT540

Plaintiffs May Offer

1/29/1998

42 PT541 43 PT542 44 PT543

Plaintiffs May Offer Plaintiffs May Offer Plaintiffs May Offer

11/24/1997 5/18/1998 1/28/1998

45 PT544 46 PT545

Plaintiffs Expect to Offer Plaintiffs Expect to Offer

2/13/1998 2/3/1998

Testwuide v. United States

Page 4 of 37

Case 1:01-cv-00201-VJW

Document 207-2

Filed 09/28/2006

Page 5 of 37
09/28/06

PLAINTIFFS' TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST
Plaintiff Exhibit No.
47 PT546

Expect to or May Offer
Plaintiffs Expect to Offer

Date
2/3/1998

Description
All Units - Increase Due to Relocation of F/A18s Rebuttal - Annual Flight Operations 1990, 1997, 1999; Historic and Projected Aircraft Loadings; Single Event Noise Levels for Various Aircraft Excerpts from the FEIS for the Realignment of F-18 C/D Aircraft Map of Test Plaintiff Properties, Virginia Beach, Virginia Appraisal Report of Test Case Plaintiffs by Alexander Salzberg and Dennis Gruelle

Defendant Objection
Relevance

Plaintiff Objection

48 PT547 49 PT548 50 PT549 51 PT550

Plaintiffs May Offer Plaintiffs May Offer Plaintiffs Expect to Offer Plaintiffs Expect to Offer

00/00/1997 3/4/1998 4/28/2006 9/29/2005

None None None None Subject to Stipulation Daubert Challenge Subject to stipulation Subject to Stipulation

Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections None None

52 PT551 53 PT552 54 PT553

Plaintiffs May Offer Plaintiffs May Offer Plaintiffs May Offer

Handwritten formula by Jon Nelson used to 12/21/2005 calculate estimated NDI Expert Report of Alexander Salzberg and 9/29/2005 Dennis Gruelle 00/00/0000 The Repeat Sales Spreadsheet Rebuttal - Lou Figari letter to Daniel Cecchini regarding relocation of F/A 18s to Oceana Naval Air Station - Comment from EIS 10/31/1997 Scoping Process

None Bates Nos

55 PT554

Plaintiffs May Offer

None

Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections

56 PT555

Plaintiffs May Offer

Rebuttal - DRAFT Report by Dr. Noral Stewart entitled, "A Review of Report of Sanford Fidell in Testwuide et al. v. United States of America Subject to 1/5/2005 in the United States Federal Court of Claims" Stipulation Rebuttal - A Review of Report of Sanford Subject to Stipulation 12/00/2005 Fidell by Noral D. Stewart Official Map of AICUZ for NAS Oceana, NALF None 00/00/1999 Fentress and NAS Chambers Field

57 PT556 58 PT557

Plaintiffs May Offer Plaintiffs Expect to Offer

Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections

Testwuide v. United States

Page 5 of 37

Case 1:01-cv-00201-VJW

Document 207-2

Filed 09/28/2006

Page 6 of 37
09/28/06

PLAINTIFFS' TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST
Plaintiff Exhibit No. Defendant Objection

Expect to or May Offer

Date

Description

Plaintiff Objection

59 PT558 PT559 60 Withdrawn

Plaintiffs May Offer

Withdrawn (Duplicate)

Excerpts from Wyle Report WR 97-10 regarding impact of F/A-18 C/D aircraft 2/1/1998 realignment Graphs excerpted from various documents regarding numbers of flight operations and 2/1/1998 noise complaints at NAS Oceana Graph of air operations at NAS Oceana and 00/00/0000 NALF Fentress for years 1998 through 2000 Rebuttal - ATAR for January through 00/00/1990 December 1990 Rebuttal - ATAR for period January through 00/00/1991 December 1991 Rebuttal - ATAR for period January through 00/00/1993 December 1993 Rebuttal - ATAR for period January through 00/00/1994 December 1994 Rebuttal - ATAR for period January through 00/00/1995 December 1995 Rebuttal - ATAR for period January through 00/00/1996 December 1996 Rebuttal - ATAR for period January through 00/00/1997 December 1997 Rebuttal - ATAR for period January through 00/00/1998 December 1998

None

Duplicate

None

61 PT560 PT561 62 Withdrawn PT562 63 Withdrawn PT563 64 Withdrawn PT564 65 Withdrawn PT565 66 Withdrawn

Plaintiffs May Offer

None Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections

Withdrawn (Duplicate)

Duplicate

Withdrawn (Duplicate)

Duplicate

Withdrawn (Duplicate)

Duplicate

Withdrawn (Duplicate)

Duplicate

Withdrawn (Duplicate)

Duplicate

67 PT566 PT567 68 Withdrawn PT568 69 Withdrawn

Plaintiffs May Offer

None

Withdrawn (Duplicate)

Duplicate

Withdrawn (Duplicate)

Duplicate

Testwuide v. United States

Page 6 of 37

Case 1:01-cv-00201-VJW

Document 207-2

Filed 09/28/2006

Page 7 of 37
09/28/06

PLAINTIFFS' TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST
Plaintiff Exhibit No.
PT569 70 Withdrawn PT570 71 Withdrawn PT571 72 Withdrawn PT572 73 Withdrawn PT573 74 Withdrawn PT574 75 Withdrawn

Expect to or May Offer

Date

Description

Defendant Objection

Plaintiff Objection
Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections

Withdrawn (Duplicate)

Rebuttal - ATAR for period January through 00/00/1999 December 1999

Duplicate

Withdrawn (Duplicate)

Rebuttal - Monthly ATARs for January through Duplicate 00/00/2000 September 2000

Withdrawn (Duplicate)

10/00/2000 Rebuttal - Monthly ATARs for October 2000

Duplicate

Withdrawn (Duplicate)

11/00/2000 Rebuttal - Monthly ATARs for November 2000 Duplicate

Withdrawn (Duplicate) Withdrawn (Duplicate)

76 PT575

Plaintiffs May Offer

12/00/2000 Rebuttal - Monthly ATARs for December 2000 Duplicate Official Map of AICUZ for NAS Oceana, NALF None 00/00/1999 Fentress and NAS Chambers Field Memo from Tom Horsch to Monica Shephard regarding noise mitigation and attached Spreadsheet showing operations from 1980 to Relevance 12/4/1994 1993

77 PT576

Plaintiffs May Offer

Rebuttal - ATAR for period January through 00/00/1999 December 1999

None

78 PT577 79 PT578

Plaintiffs May Offer Plaintiffs May Offer

80 PT579

Plaintiffs May Offer

Rebuttal - ATAR for period January through None 00/00/2000 December 2000 None 10/1/1997 CV NATOPS Manual Letter from Alan Zusman to Virginia Beach City Public Schools Representative regarding sound level reduction and attached Wyle Relevance 11/25/1997 memo

Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Authenticity Hearsay Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Hearsay Aut henticity

Testwuide v. United States

Page 7 of 37

Case 1:01-cv-00201-VJW

Document 207-2

Filed 09/28/2006

Page 8 of 37
09/28/06

PLAINTIFFS' TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST
Plaintiff Exhibit No. Defendant Objection

Expect to or May Offer

Date

Description

Plaintiff Objection

81 PT580 82 PT581 83 PT582

Plaintiffs Expect to Offer Plaintiffs May Offer Plaintiffs May Offer

Statement of Admiral William Fallon before the House Committee on Government Reform Relevance 5/9/2001 on Constraints on Military Training Volume II of Final EIS (FEIS) of West Coast None 5/15/1998 siting of F/A-18 E/F NAS Lemoore (Draft) 1999 AICUZ Report for Hampton None 2/21/2000 Roads Naval Ait Installations Rebuttal - Agency Review of Selected Airport None 08/00/1992 Noise Analysis Issues (FICON) Letter from Captain S. E. Benson to The Honorable Charles S. Robb, US Senate None 10/23/1997 regarding affect of aircraft operations Rebuttal - ATAR for period January through 01/00/2000 December for years 1999 and 2000 2/15/1998 Wyle Research Technical Note TN 97-3 Graph Containing Air Traffic Activity Totals 00/00/0000 1999-2000

84 PT583

Plaintiffs May Offer

None Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections

85 PT584

Plaintiffs May Offer

86 PT585 87 PT586 88 PT587

Plaintiffs May Offer Plaintiffs May Offer Plaintiffs May Offer

None None None

Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections None None Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Authenticity Hearsay None Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Authenticity Hearsay Relevance Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Authenticity Hearsay Relevance

89 PT588 90 PT589

Plaintiffs May Offer Plaintiffs May Offer

Rebuttal - Airfield and Airspace Study for the Introduction of F/A-18 E/Fs to the East Coast None 12/6/2002 Revision A None 5/25/1979 OPNAV INST 11010.36

91 PT590

Plaintiffs May Offer

Rebuttal - OPNAV Notice C3110 Allowances 3/31/1978 and Location of Navy Aircraft

None

92 PT591

Plaintiffs May Offer

Rebuttal - OPNAV Notice C3110 Allowances 9/30/1978 and Location of Navy Aircraft

None

Testwuide v. United States

Page 8 of 37

Case 1:01-cv-00201-VJW

Document 207-2

Filed 09/28/2006

Page 9 of 37
09/28/06

PLAINTIFFS' TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST
Plaintiff Exhibit No. Defendant Objection

Expect to or May Offer

Date

Description

Plaintiff Objection
Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Authenticity Hearsay Relevance Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Authenticity Hearsay Relevance Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Authenticity Hearsay Relevance Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Authenticity Hearsay Relevance Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Authenticity Hearsay Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Authenticity Hearsay Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Authenticity Hearsay Relevance Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Authenticity Hearsay Relevance

93 PT592

Plaintiffs May Offer

Rebuttal - OPNAV Notice C3110 Allowances 3/31/1978 and Location of Navy Aircraft

None

94 PT593

Plaintiffs May Offer

Rebuttal - OPNAV Notice C3110 Allowances 9/30/1978 and Location of Navy Aircraft

None

95 PT594

Plaintiffs May Offer

Rebuttal - OPNAV Notice C3110 Allowances 3/31/1979 and Location of Navy Aircraft

None

96 PT595

Plaintiffs May Offer

Rebuttal - OPNAV Notice C3110 Allowances 3/31/1980 and Location of Navy Aircraft

None

97 PT596

Plaintiffs May Offer

Rebuttal - OPNAV Notice C3110 Allowances 9/30/1980 and Location of Navy Aircraft

None

98 PT597

Plaintiffs May Offer

Rebuttal - OPNAV Notice C3110 Allowances 7/2/1981 and Location of Navy Aircraft Rebuttal - OPNAV Notice 05400 Naval Aeronautical Organization Yearly Report on 6/27/1978 Base Loading Rebuttal - OPNAV Notice 05400 Naval Aeronautical Organization Yearly Report on 11/29/1978 Base Loading

None

99 PT598

Plaintiffs May Offer

None

100 PT599

Plaintiffs May Offer

None

Testwuide v. United States

Page 9 of 37

Case 1:01-cv-00201-VJW

Document 207-2

Filed 09/28/2006

Page 10 of 37
09/28/06

PLAINTIFFS' TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST
Plaintiff Exhibit No. Defendant Objection

Expect to or May Offer

Date

Description

Plaintiff Objection
Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Authenticity Hearsay Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Authenticity Hearsay Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Authenticity Hearsay Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Authenticity Hearsay Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections

101 PT600

Plaintiffs May Offer

Rebuttal - OPNAV Notice 05400 Naval Aeronautical Organization Yearly Report on 6/13/1980 Base Loading Rebuttal - OPNAV Notice 05400 Naval Aeronautical Organization Yearly Report on 11/19/1980 Base Loading Rebuttal - OPNAV Notice 05400 Naval Aeronautical Organization Yearly Report on 7/13/1981 Base Loading Rebuttal - OPNAV Notice 05400 Naval Aeronautical Organization Yearly Report on 12/16/1981 Base Loading Rebuttal - Memo regarding Oceana Course 01/00/2000 Rules and Noise Abatement Procedures Rebuttal - Email exchange between Commander Dirk Hebert and Alan Zusman re Noise Mitigation/Abatement Procedures at 3/15/2000 NAS Oceana Memo from NAS Oceana Commanding 00/00/0000 Officer regarding FCLP Note regarding operations at NAS Oceana and NALF Fentress from April 17, 2000 5/26/2000 through May 10, 2000 ANNUAL FLIGHT OPERATIONS AT NAS 2/1/1998 OCEANA FOR UPDATED SCENARIO 2 Draft Aircraft Noise Survey Update (HMMH 11/00/1989 Report No. 280400.11) for NAS Oceana Rebuttal - Wyle Guidelines for Sound Insulation of Residences Exposed to Aircraft 11/15/1989 Operations

None

102 PT601

Plaintiffs May Offer

None

103 PT602

Plaintiffs May Offer

None

104 PT603

Plaintiffs May Offer

None

105 PT604

Plaintiffs May Offer

None

106 PT605 107 PT606

Plaintiffs May Offer Plaintiffs May Offer

None None

108 PT607 109 PT608 110 PT609

Plaintiffs May Offer Plaintiffs Expect to Offer Plaintiffs May Offer

None None None Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections None

111 PT610

Plaintiffs May Offer

Relevance

Testwuide v. United States

Page 10 of 37

Case 1:01-cv-00201-VJW

Document 207-2

Filed 09/28/2006

Page 11 of 37
09/28/06

PLAINTIFFS' TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST
Plaintiff Exhibit No.
112 PT611

Expect to or May Offer
Plaintiffs May Offer

Date

Description

Defendant Objection
None

Plaintiff Objection

113 PT612

Plaintiffs May Offer

114 PT613

Plaintiffs May Offer

115 PT614

Plaintiffs May Offer

116 PT615 117 PT616 118 PT617

Plaintiffs May Offer Plaintiffs May Offer Plaintiffs May Offer

2/1/1998 Wyle Research Technical Note TN 97-3 ATAC Airfield and Airspace Operational Study for the 1995 BRAC Realignment of Navy F-18 2/18/1998 Aircraft. Rebuttal - Fact Sheet from Air Operations Department at NAS Oceana regarding 3/20/1997 operational numbers from 1977 to 1984 Fact Sheet from Air Operations Dept at NAS Oceana re operational numbers from 1985 to 3/31/1997 1996 Rebuttal - Memo from LCDR Rick Bates to Fred Pierson regarding modification to GCA 12/12/1997 flight patterns and instrument approaches Graph of Air Operations Counts at NAS 10/30/1998 Oceana from 1997 to 1998 02/00/1996 Wyle Research Report WR 96-3

None

None

None Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections

None Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections

None None None

None

119 PT618

Plaintiffs May Offer

Memo from Captain S.E. "Sodbuster" Benson to all Commanding Officers regarding NAS None 9/29/1997 Oceana FCLP Course Rules Rebuttal - ATAR for January 1999 through 1/1/1999 December 1999 Rebuttal - ATAR for January 1998 through 01/00/1998 December 1998 Rebuttal - ATAR for January 1997 through 1/1/1997 December 1997 Rebuttal - ATAR for January 1995 through 1/1/1995 December 1995 Rebuttal - ATAR for January 1994 through 1/1/1994 December 1994 Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Relevance Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Relevance

120 PT619

Plaintiffs May Offer

None

121 PT620

Plaintiffs May Offer

None

122 PT621

Plaintiffs May Offer

None

123 PT622

Plaintiffs May Offer

None

124 PT623

Plaintiffs May Offer

None

Testwuide v. United States

Page 11 of 37

Case 1:01-cv-00201-VJW

Document 207-2

Filed 09/28/2006

Page 12 of 37
09/28/06

PLAINTIFFS' TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST
Plaintiff Exhibit No. Defendant Objection

Expect to or May Offer

Date

Description

Plaintiff Objection
Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Relevance Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Relevance Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Authenticity Hearsay Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections None Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections None Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections None Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections None Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections None Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Hearsay Bates Nos Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Authenticity Hearsay

125 PT624

Plaintiffs May Offer

Rebuttal - ATAR for January 1993 through 1/1/1993 December 1993 Rebuttal - ATAR for January 1991 through 1/1/1991 December 1991

None

126 PT625

Plaintiffs May Offer

None

127 PT626

Plaintiffs May Offer

Rebuttal - ATARs for January 1990 through 1/1/1990 December 1990

None

128 PT627

Plaintiffs May Offer

12/1/2000 Rebuttal - ATAR for December 2000

None

129 PT628

Plaintiffs May Offer

11/1/2000 Rebuttal - ATAR for November 2000

None

130 PT629

Plaintiffs May Offer

10/1/2000 Rebuttal - ATAR for October 2000 Rebuttal - Monthly ATARs for January 2000 1/1/2000 through September 2000 Rebuttal - Monthly ATARs for January 1999 1/1/1999 through December 1999 Rebuttal - Monthly ATARs for January 1998 01/00/1998 through December 1998 AICUZ Report for NAS Oceana and NALF 3/3/1999 Fentress

None

131 PT630

Plaintiffs May Offer

None

132 PT631

Plaintiffs May Offer

None

133 PT632 134 PT633

Plaintiffs May Offer Plaintiffs Expect to Offer

None None

135 PT634

Plaintiffs May Offer

Rebuttal - Handwritten Airport Traffic Records for NAS Oceana; Graph of Complaints; 1973None 00/00/0000 1997

Testwuide v. United States

Page 12 of 37

Case 1:01-cv-00201-VJW

Document 207-2

Filed 09/28/2006

Page 13 of 37
09/28/06

PLAINTIFFS' TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST
Plaintiff Exhibit No. Defendant Objection

Expect to or May Offer

Date

Description
Correspondence exchange between Capt. Zobel and Virginia Beach resident Laureen Docteur regarding noise complaint following move into condominium near Lynnhaven Mall Letters from various Virginia Beach and Chesapeake residents complaining of noise Rebuttal - Memo and enclosed study entitled "Noise Control Study Report," regarding NAS Oceana noise ATAC report "Airfield and Airspace Operational Study for the 1995 BRAC Realignment of Navy F/A-18 Aircraft"

Plaintiff Objection

136 PT635 137 PT636

Plaintiffs May Offer Plaintiffs May Offer

11/30/1999 12/13/1999

Hearsay Rele vance Hearsay Rele vance Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections

138 PT637

Plaintiffs May Offer

9/20/1978

None

139 PT638

Plaintiffs May Offer

8/22/1997

None Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Not Provided

140 PT639 PT640 141 Withdrawn

Plaintiffs May Offer Withdrawn (Duplicate)

Rebuttal - Spreadsheets and Graphs regarding operations at NAS Oceana and 4/12/1997 other Naval Air Stations Official Map for AICUZ for NAS Oceana, 1/1/1999 NALF Fentress and NAS Chambers Field

Bates Nos None

142 PT641

Plaintiffs May Offer

Rebuttal - NAS Oceana Operations Manual 6/5/1998 (3710.1Q)

None

143 PT642

Plaintiffs May Offer

7/3/1996 Rebuttal - NAS Oceana Air Operation Manual None

144 PT643 145 PT644 146 PT645 147 PT646

Plaintiffs May Offer Plaintiffs Expect to Offer Plaintiffs May Offer Plaintiffs May Offer

10/1/1985 Rebuttal - Noise Contour Analysis by HMMH 06/00/2000 1999 AICUZ Report AICUZ Land Planning Report (MCON Project 6/15/1979 P-997) AICUZ Land Planning Report (MCON Project 6/15/1979 P-996)

None None Relevance Relevance

Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections None Bates Nos Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Relevance B ates Nos Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Hearsay Bates Nos

Testwuide v. United States

Page 13 of 37

Case 1:01-cv-00201-VJW

Document 207-2

Filed 09/28/2006

Page 14 of 37
09/28/06

PLAINTIFFS' TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST
Plaintiff Exhibit No.
148 PT647 149 PT648 150 PT649

Expect to or May Offer
Plaintiffs May Offer Plaintiffs May Offer Plaintiffs May Offer

Date

Description

Defendant Objection

Plaintiff Objection

6/15/1982 Land Planning Report (MCON Project P-995) Relevance 6/15/1983 Land Planning Report (MCON Project P-993) 11/1/1997 Wyle Research Technical Note TN 97-3 ATAC report "Airfield and Airspace Operational Study for the 1995 BRAC 11/19/1996 Realignment of Navy F/A-18 Aircraft" Handwritten note forwarding attached response from Joe Czech to Alan Zusman regarding NAS Oceana letter regarding 12/12/1997 changes to flight tracks Memo regarding FCLP pattern at NAS 4/24/1989 Oceana Rebuttal - Email exchange between Glen McDowell, RADM Michael Johnson, Duncan Holiday, Daniel Cecchini and Capt. George Dillard, et al. re AICUZ in Virginia Beach Email exchange between Fred Pierson, Joe Ludovici and CDR William Duffy, et al. re land use issues surrounding NAS Oceana Email from Lisa Padgett to Patty Hankins regarding the Steinberg Dog Kennel Emails between Dan Cecchini, Capt Shawn Smith, et al. regarding Oceana operations count Rebuttal - Email exchange between Alan Zusman and Duncan Holiday, et al. regarding Oceana APZ mitigation Relevance None

151 PT650

Plaintiffs May Offer

None

152 PT651 153 PT652

Plaintiffs Expect to Offer Plaintiffs May Offer

None None

None

154 PT653

Plaintiffs May Offer

6/2/1999

None

Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections

155 PT654 156 PT655

Plaintiffs May Offer Plaintiffs May Offer

6/3/1999 7/6/1999

Relevance None

157 PT656

Plaintiffs Expect to Offer

11/27/2000

None

158 PT657

Plaintiffs May Offer

4/10/1998

None

159 PT658

Plaintiffs May Offer

Rebuttal - 1992 Air Traffic Activity Report 00/00/1992 (ATAR) for NAS Oceana and NALF Fentress

None

None Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Relevance

Testwuide v. United States

Page 14 of 37

Case 1:01-cv-00201-VJW

Document 207-2

Filed 09/28/2006

Page 15 of 37
09/28/06

PLAINTIFFS' TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST
Plaintiff Exhibit No. Defendant Objection

Expect to or May Offer

Date

Description

Plaintiff Objection
Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Relevance Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Relevance Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Relevance

160 PT659

Plaintiffs May Offer

00/00/1999 Rebuttal - ATAR and Monthly ATARs for 1999 None

161 PT660

Plaintiffs May Offer

00/00/2000 Rebuttal - ATAR and Monthly ATARs for 2000 None

162 PT661

Plaintiffs May Offer

163 PT662

Plaintiffs Expect to Offer

164 PT663

Plaintiffs May Offer

00/00/1998 Rebuttal - ATAR and Monthly ATARs for 1998 None Spreadsheet showing operations and complaints at Oceana and Fentress from None 4/7/1999 1973 to 1998 Rebuttal - Aircraft Noise Survey NAS Oceana and Auxiliary Landing Field Fentress; HMMH None 11/00/1984 Report No. 230104

165 PT664

Plaintiffs May Offer

166 PT665

Plaintiffs May Offer

167 PT666

Plaintiffs May Offer

10/00/1985 Rebuttal - Noise Contour Analysis by HMMH None Rebuttal - Memo from T.C. Kelley to CO NAS Oceana enclosing correspondence between None 1/19/1984 Alan Zusman and Andrew Harris Draft Report (HMMH Report No. 280400.11) entitled, "Aircraft Noise Survey Update: Naval Air Station Oceana and Auxiliary Landing Field None 11/00/1989 Fentress, Virginia - Draft"

Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Hearsay Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Hearsay Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Hearsay Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Hearsay Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Hearsay None

168 PT667

Plaintiffs May Offer

169 PT668 170 PT669

Plaintiffs May Offer Plaintiffs May Offer

06/00/1986 Rebuttal - Aircraft Noise Survey by HMMH Rebuttal - HMMH Report No. 280400.11, "Aircraft Noise Survey Update: Naval Air Station Oceana and Auxiliary Landing Field 01/00/1991 Fentress, Virginia" 04/00/1995 Wyle Research Report WR 94-18

None

None None

Testwuide v. United States

Page 15 of 37

Case 1:01-cv-00201-VJW

Document 207-2

Filed 09/28/2006

Page 16 of 37
09/28/06

PLAINTIFFS' TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST
Plaintiff Exhibit No. Defendant Objection

Expect to or May Offer

Date

Description

Plaintiff Objection

171 PT670

Plaintiffs Expect to Offer

172 PT671

Plaintiffs May Offer

ATAC Corp Report entitled, "Naval Air Station Oceana Airfield and Airspace Operational None 2/15/1996 Study for BRAC 95." Rebuttal - Letter from Capt. C. A. Silvers to Mayor Meyera Oberndorf regarding overstated None 1/10/2002 F/A-18 C/D noise contours Rebuttal - Memo for the Record by M. N. Clemente regarding F-14 Flight Profiles for 12/7/2001 NAS Oceana/NALF Fentress

173 PT672

Plaintiffs May Offer

None

174 PT673

Plaintiffs May Offer

175 PT674

Plaintiffs May Offer

176 PT675

Plaintiffs May Offer

Rebuttal - Memo from Benson and enclosed None 12/5/2001 Flight Profiles F/A 18 Rebuttal - Letter from Capt S. E. Benson to Mayor of Chesapeake regarding noise None 6/16/1998 contours Rebuttal - Letter from Fred Pierson to Ms. Cheryl Fortin regarding replacement map for use as the official Air Installations Compatible None 6/30/1998 Use Zones (AICUZ) map. Rebuttal - Wyle Appendix B Flight Profiles for None 02/00/1998 F/A 18 Aircraft Rebuttal - WYLE TECHNICAL NOTE TN 03None 08/00/2003 04 Rebuttal - Federal Agency Review of Selected Airport Noise Analysis Issues by Federal Relevance 08/00/1992 Interagency Committee on Noise Report by J. Steven Newman and Kristy R. Beattie entitled, "Aviation Noise Effects," for Relevance 03/00/1985 the FAA

Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Authenticity Hearsay Bates Nos Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Authenticity Hearsay Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections None Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections

177 PT676

Plaintiffs May Offer

178 PT677

Plaintiffs May Offer

179 PT678

Plaintiffs May Offer

180 PT679

Plaintiffs Expect to Offer

Testwuide v. United States

Page 16 of 37

Case 1:01-cv-00201-VJW

Document 207-2

Filed 09/28/2006

Page 17 of 37
09/28/06

PLAINTIFFS' TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST
Plaintiff Exhibit No. Defendant Objection

Expect to or May Offer

Date

Description

Plaintiff Objection
Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections None Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Authenticity Hearsay Original

181 PT680

Plaintiffs May Offer

Rebuttal - Draft Noise Footprints for F-14D operations at NAS Oceana and NALF 00/00/0000 Fentress.

None

182 PT681

Plaintiffs May Offer

183 PT682 184 PT683

Plaintiffs May Offer Plaintiffs May Offer

Rebuttal - Handwritten notes from Wyle None 6/13/2001 Laboratories Report by Federal Interagency Committee on Noise entitled, "Federal Agency Review of Relevance 8/21/1992 Selected Airport Noise Analysis Issues." 11/1/1995 Noise Map Noise Curves regarding F-18A/C None Rebuttal - Emails between Long, Zusman, et 12/00/2001 al re F/A 18 Power Settings

185 PT684

Plaintiffs May Offer

None

186 PT685

Plaintiffs May Offer

187 PT686

Plaintiffs May Offer

188 PT687

Plaintiffs May Offer

Rebuttal - Emails between Downing and 12/00/2001 Zusman et al regarding power setting F/A 18 None Rebuttal - Email (redacted) from Ling to Zusman and Cecchini re F/A 18 Power None 10/22/2001 Settings Noise and Emissions Rebuttal - Email (redacted) between Zusman, Cecchini et al regarding additional data F/A 18 None 10/15/2001 power settings Rebuttal - Email (redacted) exchange between Alan Zusman, Daniel Cecchini and Robert None 10/3/2001 Smith, et al. regarding noise contours Rebuttal - Email (redacted) exchange between Alan Zusman, Daniel Cecchini and Robert None 10/2/2001 Smith, et al. regarding noise contours None 12/19/2002 OPNAV Instruction 11010.36B None 4/11/1988 OPNAV INSTRUCTION 11010.36A

Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections None Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Hearsay Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Hearsay Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections None None

189 PT688

Plaintiffs May Offer

190 PT689 191 PT690 192 PT691

Plaintiffs May Offer Plaintiffs May Offer Plaintiffs May Offer

Testwuide v. United States

Page 17 of 37

Case 1:01-cv-00201-VJW

Document 207-2

Filed 09/28/2006

Page 18 of 37
09/28/06

PLAINTIFFS' TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST
Plaintiff Exhibit No. Defendant Objection

Expect to or May Offer

Date

Description

Plaintiff Objection
Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Authenticity Hearsay Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Authenticity Hearsay Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Hearsay Aut henticity Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Hearsay Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Hearsay Aut henticity Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Hearsay Aut henticity Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Hearsay

193 PT692

Plaintiffs May Offer

Rebuttal - Emails between Cecchini, Zusman None 10/30/2002 et al and report - F14 engine report Rebuttal - Email from Micah Downing to Daniel Cecchini with attached noise contour 12/19/2001 maps regarding revisions to noise contours

194 PT693

Plaintiffs May Offer

None

195 PT694

Plaintiffs May Offer

Rebuttal - Flight Profiles prepared by Wyle 12/19/2001 Laboratories for the F/A-18 C/D

None

196 PT695

Plaintiffs May Offer

Rebuttal - Email from Micah Downing to Todd 12/11/2001 Pollard, et al. with attached F-14 flight profiles None Rebuttal - Email from Micah Downing to Xaviera Jessurun with attached files used for 11/30/2001 revising the 1997 ARS2 Oceana noise contour None Rebuttal - Email exchange between Micah Downing, Alan Zusman and Todd Pollard, et None 11/29/2001 al. re F-14 flight profiles Rebuttal - Email from Micah Downing to Alan Zusman with attached F/A-18 C/D flight 11/21/2001 profiles Rebuttal - Email from Micah Downing to Alan Zusman with attached Memo comparing 11/21/2001 single event noise footprints Rebuttal - Email exchanges between Micah Downing and Alan Zusman regarding F-14B 11/20/2001 flight profiles

197 PT696

Plaintiffs May Offer

198 PT697

Plaintiffs May Offer

199 PT698

Plaintiffs May Offer

None

200 PT699

Plaintiffs May Offer

None

201 PT700

Plaintiffs May Offer

None

Testwuide v. United States

Page 18 of 37

Case 1:01-cv-00201-VJW

Document 207-2

Filed 09/28/2006

Page 19 of 37
09/28/06

PLAINTIFFS' TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST
Plaintiff Exhibit No. Defendant Objection

Expect to or May Offer

Date

Description

Plaintiff Objection
Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Hearsay Aut henticity Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections None Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Hearsay Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections

202 PT701

Plaintiffs May Offer

Rebuttal - Email from Micah Downing to Alan Zusman, et al. with attached F-14 flight 11/19/2001 profiles Rebuttal - Email Ling to Smith re F/A 18 10/24/2001 Power Settings Noise and Emissions Rebuttal - Email exchange between Robert Smith, Alan Zusman and Phillip Logan, et al. 5/29/2001 re interview with F/A-18 C/D pilot interview

None

203 PT702

Plaintiffs May Offer

None

204 PT703

Plaintiffs May Offer

None

205 PT704

Plaintiffs May Offer

206 PT705

Plaintiffs May Offer

207 PT706

Plaintiffs May Offer

Rebuttal - Email (redacted) between Zusman None 10/5/2001 and Cecchini et al regarding draft contours Rebuttal - Email exchange between Alan Zusman, Daniel Cecchini and Micah Downing, None 10/2/2001 et al. re noise contours Rebuttal - Redacted emails between Zusman, Cecchini et al regarding Additional Data re F/A None 10/25/2001 18 Power Settings Rebuttal - Redacted emails between Smith, 10/31/2001 Zusman, et al regarding Work Priority for Wyle None Rebuttal - Email (redacted) exchange between Robert Smith, Allison Ling, Lyn P. Coffer and Everette Douglas, et al. regarding AESO None 11/5/2001 Information on F/A-18 Power Settings Rebuttal - Email (redacted) exchange between Jude L. Klena, Robert J. Smith, and Alan Zusman, et al. regarding F/A-18 C/D Flight None 11/28/2001 Profiles Rebuttal - Redacted Emails between Alan Zusman, Jude Klena and Robert Smith, et al. None 11/29/2001 regarding F/A-18 C/D flight profiles

208 PT707

Plaintiffs May Offer

209 PT708

Plaintiffs May Offer

Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections

210 PT709

Plaintiffs May Offer

211 PT710

Plaintiffs May Offer

Testwuide v. United States

Page 19 of 37

Case 1:01-cv-00201-VJW

Document 207-2

Filed 09/28/2006

Page 20 of 37
09/28/06

PLAINTIFFS' TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST
Plaintiff Exhibit No. Defendant Objection

Expect to or May Offer

Date

Description

Plaintiff Objection
Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections

212 PT711

Plaintiffs May Offer

213 PT712

Plaintiffs May Offer

214 PT713

Plaintiffs May Offer

Rebuttal - Email from Alan Zusman to Daniel Cecchini and Fred Pierson, et al. regarding 11/29/2001 F/A-18 E/F noise contours Rebuttal - Email from Alan Zusman to Dan Cecchini and Fred Pierson, et al. regarding 11/29/2001 F/A-18 E/F noise contours Rebuttal - Email (redacted) from Jude Klena to Duncan Holaday, Robert Smith, James Brookshire and Julia Evans et al. with two redacted attachments regarding noise 12/4/2001 contours

None

None

None

215 PT714

Plaintiffs May Offer

216 PT715

Plaintiffs May Offer

217 PT716

Plaintiffs May Offer

218 PT717

Plaintiffs May Offer

219 PT718

Plaintiffs May Offer

220 PT719

Plaintiffs May Offer

221 PT720

Plaintiffs May Offer

Rebuttal - Redacted report from Jude L. Klena 10/3/2001 to Julia Evans et al regarding noise contours None Rebuttal - Email from Alan Zusman to Geral Long and Micah Downing regarding F/A-18 None 12/6/2001 E/F EIS noise contours Rebuttal - Email from Alan Zusman to Geral Long and Micah Downing regarding F/A-18 None 12/6/2001 E/F EIS noise contours Rebuttal - Email (redacted) from Alan Zusman to Bret Muilenburg, and Ronald Borro et al. None 11/30/2001 regarding F-14B flight profiles Rebuttal - Email from Alan Zusman to Bret Muilenburg, and Ronald Borro et al. regarding None 11/30/2001 F-14B flight profiles Rebuttal - Email (redacted) from Alan Zusman to Phillip Logan, et al. regarding aircraft profile None 12/17/2001 endorsements Rebuttal - Email (redacted) exchanges between Lt. Col. Christopher St. George, Micah Downing, Fred Pierson, Daniel Cecchini and Robert Smith, et al. regarding Beaufort None 12/20/2001 data validation

Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Hearsay Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections

Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections

Testwuide v. United States

Page 20 of 37

Case 1:01-cv-00201-VJW

Document 207-2

Filed 09/28/2006

Page 21 of 37
09/28/06

PLAINTIFFS' TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST
Plaintiff Exhibit No. Defendant Objection

Expect to or May Offer

Date

Description

Plaintiff Objection
Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections None Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Hearsay Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Hearsay Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Hearsay Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Authenticity Hearsay

222 PT721

Plaintiffs May Offer

Rebuttal - Email (redacted) exchange between Kim Depaul, Robert Smith, and Alan Zusman, None 12/20/2001 et al. regarding noise contours Rebuttal - Email (redacted) exchange between Alan Zusman, Kathy Reed, Kim Depaul, 12/21/2001 Robert Smith, et al. regarding noise contours None Rebuttal - Email (redacted) exchange between Robert Smith, Phillip Logan, Daniel Cecchini, 12/21/2001 Alan Zusman, et al. regarding noise contours None Rebuttal - Redacted emails between Smith, Klena and Zusman regarding Description File None 11/26/2001 Flight Profiles Rebuttal - Email exchange between Thomas Alderson, David Dale-Johnson and Paul Relevance 11/15/2001 Wazzan re Wyle Laboratories Rebuttal - Emails between Downing, Zusman None 11/2/2001 et al re Flight Profiles Rebuttal - Emails between Long, Downing and None 12/7/2001 Jessurun re ASR2 revised profiles Rebuttal - Emails between Zusman, Logan, et None 12/17/2001 al regarding aircraft profile endorsements Rebuttal - Email from Zusman to Downing et 12/12/2001 al regarding contours - F14

223 PT722

Plaintiffs May Offer

224 PT723

Plaintiffs May Offer

225 PT724

Plaintiffs May Offer

226 PT725

Plaintiffs May Offer

227 PT726

Plaintiffs May Offer

228 PT727

Plaintiffs May Offer

229 PT728

Plaintiffs May Offer

230 PT729

Plaintiffs May Offer

None

231 PT730

Plaintiffs May Offer

Rebuttal - Email from Polard to Downing with 11/28/2001 attachment re noise data

None

Testwuide v. United States

Page 21 of 37

Case 1:01-cv-00201-VJW

Document 207-2

Filed 09/28/2006

Page 22 of 37
09/28/06

PLAINTIFFS' TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST
Plaintiff Exhibit No. Defendant Objection

Expect to or May Offer

Date

Description
Letter from Captain Thomas Keeley to Virginia Beach Mayor Meyera Oberndorf regarding opposition to "by-right" development. Email (redacted) exchange involving Thomas Keeley, Alan Zusman and Raymond Firenze, et al. AICUZ and density Email from Thomas Keeley to Raymond Firenze regarding the JLUS Rebuttal - Email (redacted) from Alan Zusman to Capt. Thomas Keeley with attached redacted Memo from Alan Zusman entitled, "Virginia Beach JLUS; AICUZ Noise Contour Strategy." Wyle Report 04-03 - Pre-Final Guidelines for Sound Insulation of Residences Exposed to Aircraft Operations

Plaintiff Objection

232 PT731

Plaintiffs Expect to Offer

2/8/2005

None

233 PT732 234 PT733

Plaintiffs May Offer Plaintiffs Expect to Offer

2/16/2005 2/16/2005

None None

235 PT734

Plaintiffs May Offer

8/18/2004

None

Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections

236 PT735

Plaintiffs Expect to Offer

02/00/2005

Relevance Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections

237 PT736

Plaintiffs May Offer

Rebuttal - Handwritten Notes regarding FCLP None 00/00/1996 operations Rebuttal - Handwritten Notes regarding FCLP 00/00/1996 operations Email exchange between Michael Abkin and Alan Zusman, et al. re NAS Oceana and NAS 12/9/1996 Beaufort operations Letter from Abkin to Zusman regarding Oceana/ Cherry Point Scenario Results 1/13/1997 Working Paper (Partial Draft) Graph entitled, "Percent Increase of Airfield Operations from Baseline," prepared by ATAC 00/00/2000 Corporation Email from Derek Huber to Alan Zusman re 4/24/1997 night FCLP

238 PT737

Plaintiffs May Offer

None

239 PT738

Plaintiffs May Offer

None

240 PT739

Plaintiffs Expect to Offer

None

241 PT740 242 PT741

Plaintiffs May Offer Plaintiffs Expect to Offer

None None

Testwuide v. United States

Page 22 of 37

Case 1:01-cv-00201-VJW

Document 207-2

Filed 09/28/2006

Page 23 of 37
09/28/06

PLAINTIFFS' TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST
Plaintiff Exhibit No. Defendant Objection

Expect to or May Offer

Date

Description

Plaintiff Objection

243 PT742

Plaintiffs May Offer

244 PT743

Plaintiffs May Offer

Letter from Mike Abkin at ATAC Corporation to Alan Zusman regarding the Scenario 5/13/1997 Results Working Paper submitted. Report by the ATAC, "NASMOD: Airfield and Airspace Operational Study for the 1995 BRAC Realignment of Navy F/A-18 Aircraft 5/13/1997 Scenario Results Working Paper."

None

None Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections

245 PT744

Plaintiffs May Offer

246 PT745 247 PT746

Plaintiffs May Offer Plaintiffs May Offer

Rebuttal - Email exchange between Alan None 6/13/1997 Zusman and Michael Abkin re the Draft EIS Rebuttal - Email from Alan Zusman to Michael Abkin regarding operations counts at NAS None 12/8/1997 Oceana Email from Derek Huber to Alan Zusman re None 1/15/1998 NAS Oceana aircraft operations. Rebuttal - Noise Complaint Log Records of Complaints from Residents of Virginia Beach 00/00/2005 and Chesapeake from January to May 2005. Rebuttal - Monthly ATARs January through 00/00/2001 December 2001 Rebuttal - Redacted emails between Klena, 12/1/2001 Houck, et al regarding revise noise contours

248 PT747

Plaintiffs May Offer

None

249 PT748

Plaintiffs May Offer

None

250 PT749

Plaintiffs May Offer

None

251 PT750

Plaintiffs May Offer

Rebuttal - Micah Downing's Lemoore Pilot interview notes - 7/12/01 and attachments 12/20/2001 regarding flight profiles

None

252 PT751

Plaintiffs May Offer

Rebuttal - Redacted Summary of Operational Relevance 12/3/2002 Assumptions EIS Review Meeting

Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Bates Nos Authenticity Hearsa y Relevance Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections

Testwuide v. United States

Page 23 of 37

Case 1:01-cv-00201-VJW

Document 207-2

Filed 09/28/2006

Page 24 of 37
09/28/06

PLAINTIFFS' TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST
Plaintiff Exhibit No. Defendant Objection

Expect to or May Offer

Date

Description

Plaintiff Objection
Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Hearsay Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Hearsay Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Hearsay Aut henticity Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections

253 PT752

Plaintiffs May Offer

Rebuttal - Email exchange between CDR Jim Webb and Micah Downing re revisions to F/ANone 6/11/2001 18 C/D flight profiles Rebuttal - Email (redacted) between Cecchini, 10/25/2001 Logan, et al regarding F/A 18 Power Settings None Rebuttal - Email (redacted) exchange between Daniel Cecchini, Alan Zusman and Robert Smith regarding payment of Wyle for DOJ None 10/31/2001 litigation support Rebuttal - Email (redacted) from Klena to Benson et al regarding flight profiles with None 12/3/2001 attachments listed

254 PT753

Plaintiffs May Offer

255 PT754

Plaintiffs May Offer

256 PT755

Plaintiffs May Offer

257 PT756

Plaintiffs May Offer

Rebuttal - Redacted emails between Zusman, None 12/10/2001 Cecchini, et al regarding noise contours Rebuttal - Emails between Logan, Zusman et None 12/18/2001 al re operations / Beaufort data validation Rebuttal - Redacted emails between Logan, 12/21/2001 Zusman, et al regarding noise contours

258 PT757

Plaintiffs May Offer

259 PT758

Plaintiffs May Offer

None

260 PT759

Plaintiffs May Offer

Rebuttal - Email exchange between Daniel Cecchini, Fred Pierson, Geral Long, Alan Zusman, Micah Downing and Bret Muilenburg None 6/11/2001 re noise analysis for the E/F EIS Rebuttal - Draft Comparison of Single Event Noise Footprints for F/18 C/D between flights None 10/00/2001 and new profiles used in F-18 E/F EIS Rebuttal - Redacted Emails between Robert Smith, Dan Cecchini et al regarding legal None 10/5/2001 advice as to contours

261 PT760

Plaintiffs May Offer

262 PT761

Plaintiffs May Offer

Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Authenticity Hearsay Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections

Testwuide v. United States

Page 24 of 37

Case 1:01-cv-00201-VJW

Document 207-2

Filed 09/28/2006

Page 25 of 37
09/28/06

PLAINTIFFS' TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST
Plaintiff Exhibit No. Defendant Objection

Expect to or May Offer

Date

Description

Plaintiff Objection
Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Authenticity Hearsay Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Hearsay Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Hearsay Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections

263 PT762

Plaintiffs May Offer

Rebuttal - Redacted emails between Zusman and Long et al regarding C/D profile None 10/12/2001 documentation Rebuttal - Redacted emails between Logan, 10/30/2001 Borro et al regarding Noise and Emissions Rebuttal - Redacted emails between Reed, Holaday, et al regarding Conference call / 10/30/2001 Comparison Table F/A 18 C/D

264 PT763

Plaintiffs May Offer

None

265 PT764

Plaintiffs May Offer

None

266 PT765

Plaintiffs May Offer

Rebuttal - Email exchange between Cecchini, 11/01/0320 Logan, Zusman, et al., regarding flight profiles None Rebuttal - Memo from Long and Downing to 11/14/2001 Zusman re flight profiles Rebuttal - Email (redacted) from Zusman to 11/28/2001 Long and Downing regarding flight profiles

267 PT766

Plaintiffs May Offer

None

268 PT767

Plaintiffs May Offer

None

269 PT768

Plaintiffs May Offer

Rebuttal - Redacted emails between Bowers, Douglas et al regarding FA18 Followup site 11/00/2001 visits and interviews at Lemoore and Miramar None Rebuttal - Emails between Zusman, Bowers, 11/29/2001 et al regarding power settings Rebuttal - Email from Geral Long to Micah 12/7/2001 Downing re the F14A Rebuttal - Redacted emails between Guerin, 12/12/2001 Downing, et al regarding profiles

270 PT769

Plaintiffs May Offer

None

271 PT770

Plaintiffs May Offer

None

272 PT771

Plaintiffs May Offer

None

273 PT772

Plaintiffs May Offer

Rebuttal - Redacted emails between Cecchini, None 1/7/2002 Klena et al regarding Noise Contours Q&As

Testwuide v. United States

Page 25 of 37

Case 1:01-cv-00201-VJW

Document 207-2

Filed 09/28/2006

Page 26 of 37
09/28/06

PLAINTIFFS' TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST
Plaintiff Exhibit No. Defendant Objection

Expect to or May Offer

Date

Description

Plaintiff Objection
Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Hearsay Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Hearsay Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections

274 PT773

Plaintiffs May Offer

275 PT774

Plaintiffs May Offer

Rebuttal - Email from Alan Zusman to Micah Downing, Geral Long and Dan Cecchini None 9/29/2001 regarding Comparison of Noise Footprints Rebuttal - Email from Alan Zusman to Geral Long and Micah Downing regarding concerns None 10/1/2001 over the accuracy of Wyle's work Rebuttal - Emails between Benson, Klena 12/4/2001 regarding flight profiles with attachments listed None Rebuttal - Redacted emails between Cecchini, None 12/4/2001 Long, et al regarding COS suggestions Rebuttal - Emails between Phil Logan, Fred Pierson, Alan Zusman, William Zobel, Micah Downing and Dan Cecchini et al. regarding abeam distance for FCLP flight tracks at None 7/17/2001 Oceana and Fentress Rebuttal - Email exchange between Phil Logan, Fred Pierson, Alan Zusman, William Zobel, Micah Downing and Dan Cecchini, et al. re abeam distance for FCLP flight tracks at None 7/17/2001 Oceana and Fentress Rebuttal - Email exchange between Fred Pierson, Dan Cecchini, Alan Zusman, Micah Downing, Geral Long, et al. re description of 7/17/2001 FCLP pattern at NAS Oceana Rebuttal - Email exchange between Fred Pierson, Dan Cecchini, Alan Zusman, Micah Downing, Geral Long, et al. re description of 7/17/2001 FCLP pattern at NAS Oceana

276 PT775

Plaintiffs May Offer

277 PT776

Plaintiffs May Offer

278 PT777

Plaintiffs May Offer

Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections

279 PT778

Plaintiffs May Offer

Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections

280 PT779

Plaintiffs May Offer

None

Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections

281 PT780

Plaintiffs May Offer

None

Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections

Testwuide v. United States

Page 26 of 37

Case 1:01-cv-00201-VJW

Document 207-2

Filed 09/28/2006

Page 27 of 37
09/28/06

PLAINTIFFS' TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST
Plaintiff Exhibit No. Defendant Objection

Expect to or May Offer

Date

Description

Plaintiff Objection
Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections

282 PT781

Plaintiffs May Offer

283 PT782

Plaintiffs May Offer

284 PT783

Plaintiffs May Offer

Rebuttal - Email exchange between Micah Downing, James Webb and Geral Long re None 6/20/2001 FCLP and Touch and Go operations Rebuttal - F/A-18 C/D Flight Profiles for NAS Oceana and NALF Fentress for Use in F-18 None 10/25/2001 E/F EIS Rebuttal - Emails and attachments between Zusman, Long, Benson, et al regarding Flight None 11/1/2001 Profiles Rebuttal - Email (redacted) from Zusman to 11/6/2001 Logan, et al regarding noise contours

285 PT784

Plaintiffs May Offer

None

286 PT785

Plaintiffs May Offer

287 PT786

Plaintiffs May Offer

Redacted emails between Cecchini, Logan et 11/00/2001 al regarding E/F EIS progress / Wyle contract None Rebuttal - Email exchange with draft contours attached between Micah Downing, Dan Cecchini, Phil Logan, Alan Zusman and Fred Pierson re DRAFT F-18 C/D noise footprint None 10/00/2001 work Rebuttal - Emails between Zusman, Richman, None 12/00/2001 et al regarding power settings

288 PT787

Plaintiffs May Offer

289 PT788

Plaintiffs May Offer

Rebuttal - Monthly ATARs for January through None 00/00/1981 December 1981.

290 PT789

Plaintiffs May Offer

291 PT790

Plaintiffs Expect to Offer

Rebuttal - Monthly ATARs for January through None 00/00/1982 December 1982. Emails between Micah Downing and Robert Smith et al with attached DNL values for May None 2/2/2006 property

Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Authenticity Hearsay Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Authenticity Hearsay

Testwuide v. United States

Page 27 of 37

Case 1:01-cv-00201-VJW

Document 207-2

Filed 09/28/2006

Page 28 of 37
09/28/06

PLAINTIFFS' TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST
Plaintiff Exhibit No. Defendant Objection

Expect to or May Offer

Date

Description

Plaintiff Objection

292 PT791

Plaintiffs Expect to Offer

Email from Micah Downing attached Test Plaintiffs' Geographical and Noise Level 9/22/2005 Information Rebuttal - OPNAV Notice C3110 regarding 3/31/1978 Allowances and Location of Naval Aircraft Rebuttal - OPNAV Notice C3110 regarding 9/30/1978 Allowances and Location of Naval Aircraft Rebuttal - OPNAV Notice C3110 regarding 3/31/1979 Allowances and Location of Naval Aircraft Rebuttal - OPNAV Notice C3110 regarding 3/31/1980 Allowances and Location of Naval Aircraft Rebuttal - OPNAV Notice C3110 regarding 9/30/1980 Allowances and Location of Naval Aircraft Rebuttal - OPNAV Notice C3110 regarding 3/31/1981 Allowances and Location of Naval Aircraft Rebuttal - OPNAV Notice C3110 regarding 9/30/1981 Allowances and Location of Naval Aircraft Rebuttal - Email (redacted) from Zusman to 11/7/2001 Long regarding profiles

None Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections

293 PT792

Plaintiffs May Offer

None

294 PT793

Plaintiffs May Offer

None

295 PT794

Plaintiffs May Offer

None

296 PT795

Plaintiffs May Offer

None

297 PT796

Plaintiffs May Offer

None

298 PT797

Plaintiffs May Offer

None

299 PT798

Plaintiffs May Offer

None

300 PT799

Plaintiffs May Offer

None

301 PT800

Plaintiffs May Offer

Rebuttal - Emails between Jone Guerin to Dan None 10/5/2001 Cecchini et al re noise contours Rebuttal - Redacted emails between Zusman None 11/7/2001 and Coffer, et al regarding AESO WriteUp

302 PT801

Plaintiffs May Offer

Testwuide v. United States

Page 28 of 37

Case 1:01-cv-00201-VJW

Document 207-2

Filed 09/28/2006

Page 29 of 37
09/28/06

PLAINTIFFS' TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST
Plaintiff Exhibit No. Defendant Objection

Expect to or May Offer

Date

Description

Plaintiff Objection

303 PT802

Plaintiffs May Offer

304 PT803

Plaintiffs Expect to Offer

Excerpts from the FEIS for the Realignment of F-18 C/D Aircraft from Cecil Field to other None 2/28/1998 East Coast Installations Memo from Jeffery Borowy to N44 regarding Oceana Sound Attenuation and Memo on Aircraft Noise Policy for the FAA and the Relevance 02/00/1998 Navy. Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections

305 PT804

Plaintiffs May Offer

00/00/0000 Rebuttal - Various Newspaper Articles

306 PT805

Plaintiffs May Offer

9/26/2005

307 PT806

Plaintiffs May Offer

12/12/2005

308 PT807

Plaintiffs May Offer

8/26/2005

309 PT808

Plaintiffs May Offer

8/26/2005

310 PT809

Plaintiffs May Offer

8/26/2005

311 PT810

Plaintiffs May Offer

8/26/2005

312 PT811

Plaintiffs May Offer

8/26/2005

Hearsay Subject to Expert Report by Jon P. Nelson - Effects of Stipulation Aircraft Noise on Residential Property Values: Daubert NAS Oceana and NALF Fentress Challenge Report by Jon P. Nelson - Plaintiffs' Rebutal to Subject to the Expert Report of Dr. David Dale-Johnson Stipulation (Analysis of the Impact of the Realignment on Daubert House Values) Challenge Final Appraisal of 1805 Loganberry Court (James and Virgie Riddick) as of 1999 by Alexander Salzberg and Dennis Gruelle None Final Appraisal of 2004 Brickell Court (Harold and Elaine Levenson) as of 1999 by Alexander Salzberg and Dennis Gruelle None Final Appraisal of 925 Lamplight Lane (Kenneth and Tammy Hill) as of 1999 by Alexander Salzberg and Dennis Gruelle None Final Appraisal of 1856 Pathfinder Drive (Sean and Graciela Ryan) as of 1999 by Alexander Salzberg and Dennis Gruelle None Final Appraisal of 3209 Chicory Court (Michael and Diane Leary) as of 1999 by Alexander Salzberg and Dennis Gruelle None

Bates Nos

None

Testwuide v. United States

Page 29 of 37

Case 1:01-cv-00201-VJW

Document 207-2

Filed 09/28/2006

Page 30 of 37
09/28/06

PLAINTIFFS' TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST
Plaintiff Exhibit No. Defendant Objection

Expect to or May Offer

Date

Description
Final Appraisal of 305 Corvette Lane (Herbert and Betty Van Nostrand) as of 1999 by Alexander Salzberg and Dennis Gruelle Final Appraisal of 409 Pallets Road (William and Betty Capps) as of 1999 by Alexander Salzberg and Dennis Gruelle Final Appraisal of 1301 Brant Road (Sara Lynch Hoag) as of 1999 by Alexander Salzberg and Dennis Gruelle Final Appraisal of 912 Carolina Avenue (Theodore and Sue Dingle) as of 1999 by Alexander Salzberg and Dennis Gruelle

Plaintiff Objection

313 PT812

Plaintiffs May Offer

8/26/2005

None

314 PT813

Plaintiffs May Offer

8/26/2005

None

315 PT814

Plaintiffs May Offer

8/26/2005

None

316 PT815

Plaintiffs May Offer

8/26/2005

None

317 PT816

Plaintiffs May Offer

318 PT817

Plaintiffs May Offer

Final Appraisal of 2244 Windy Pines Bend (Eddie and Elizabeth Waterman) as of 1999 8/26/2005 by Alexander Salzberg and Dennis Gruelle Final Appraisal of 2709 E Kings Road (Caroll Lindsay) as of 1999 by Alexander Salzberg 8/26/2005 and Dennis Gruelle Rebuttal - Report by Noral D. Stewart - A Review of Report of Sanford Fidell in Testwuide et al. v. United States of America Final Appraisal of 620 Little Neck Road (Eileen May) as of 1999 by Alexander Salzberg and Dennis Gruelle Rebuttal - Dr. Noral Stewart letter to Jack Ferrebee regarding improvement of sound insulation in homes Resume of Alexander Salzberg Defendant's Answers to Interrogatories GIS Maps

None

None Rebuttal document Plaintiffs reserve all objections

319 PT818

Plaintiffs May Offer

2/21/2006

Subject to Stipulation

320 PT819

Plaintiffs May Offer

2/1/2006

None Rebuttal document Hearsay Rele Plaintiffs reserve all vance objections None Not Provided None

321 PT820 322 PT821 PT822 323 Withdrawn 324 PT823

Plaintiffs May Offer Plaintiffs May Offer Withdrawn Plaintiffs May Offer

7/22/2005 9/29/2005

Testwuide v. United States

Page 30 of 37

Case 1:01-cv-00201-VJW

Document 207-2

Filed 09/28/2006

Page 31 of 37
09/28/06

PLAINTIFFS' TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST
Plaintiff Exhibit No. Defendant Objection

Expect to or May Offer

Date

Description

Plaintiff Objection

325 PT824

Plaintiffs May Offer

326 PT825

Plaintiffs May Offer

327 PT826

Plaintiffs Expect to Offer

328 PT827

Plaintiffs May Offer

329 PT828

Plaintiffs May Offer

330 PT829

Plaintiffs Expect