Free Motion in Limine - District Court of Federal Claims - federal

Case 1:01-cv-00201-VJW

Document 217-3

Filed 10/02/2006

Page 1 of 6

Exhibits from Plaintiffs' Exhibit List subject to Defendant's Motion in Limine to Exclude Certain Witnesses and Exhibits

Trialx# Begdoc#

Enddoc#

Exh#

Docdate

PT524 AR-035758-035759

PX051

Trdesc Email exchange between Alan Zusman and Jeffrey Borowy regarding sound attenuation of homes surrounding NAS 7/11/1997 Oceana Memo from LCDR Matt Cartier to Daniel Cecchini regarding history of Class A mishaps in 8/5/1997 and around NAS Oceana Email from Alan Zusman to Joseph Czech regarding sound attenuation of homes 1/29/1998 surrounding NAS Oceana Email exchanges between Alan Zusman, Jeffrey Borowy and Duncan Holaday, et al. 1/29/1998 regarding sound attenuation Point Paper by Borowy regarding aircraft noise policy and sound attenuation costs Memo from Jeffery Borrowy to Admiral Lou Smith regarding sound attenuation costs in areas surrounding NAS Oceana All Units - All Inclusive All Units - Increase Due to Relocation of F/A-18s Handwritten formula by Jon Nelson used to calculate estimated NDI Expert Report of Alexander Salzberg and Dennis Gruelle

Objection

Relevance

PT536 AR-042018-042019 AR-042018-042020

Relevance

PT538 AR-042530-042531

Relevance

PT540 AR-043806-043806

PX130

Relevance

PT543 AR-050501-050501

1/28/1998

Relevance

PT544 AR-050507-050507 PT545 AR-050508-050508 PT546 AR-050509-050509

PX052A PX052B PX052C

2/13/1998 2/3/1998 2/3/1998

Relevance Relevance Relevance

PT551 DX119 PT552 DX132

DX119 DX132

DX119 DX132

12/21/2005 00/00/2005

Subject to Stipulation (Daubert Challenge) Subject to Stipulation

Case 1:01-cv-00201-VJW

Document 217-3

Filed 10/02/2006

Page 2 of 6

Exhibits from Plaintiffs' Exhibit List subject to Defendant's Motion in Limine to Exclude Certain Witnesses and Exhibits

PT553 DX134

DX134

DX134

PT555 DX149

DX149

DX149

PT556 DX150

DX150

DX150

The Repeat Sales 00/00/0000 Spreadsheet Rebuttal - DRAFT Report by Dr. Noral Stewart entitled, "A Review of Report of Sanford Fidell in Testwuide et al. v. United States of America in the United States Federal 1/5/2005 Court of Claims" Rebuttal - A Review of Report of Sanford Fidell by Noral D. 12/00/2005 Stewart Memo from Tom Horsch to Monica Shephard regarding noise mitigation and attached Spreadsheet showing 12/4/1994 operations from 1980 to 1993 Letter from Alan Zusman to Virginia Beach City Public Schools Representative regarding sound level reduction and attached Wyle 11/25/1997 memo Statement of Admiral William Fallon before the House Committee on Government Reform on Constraints on 5/9/2001 Military Training Rebuttal - Wyle Guidelines for Sound Insulation of Residences Exposed to 11/15/1989 Aircraft Operations

Subject to Stipulation

Subject to Stipulation

Subject to Stipulation

PT575 HEBERT024

PX036

Relevance

PT579 NEP000703

NEP000706

Relevance

PT580 NEP000957

NEP000968

Relevance

PT610 OCE009383

OCE009609

Relevance

Case 1:01-cv-00201-VJW

Document 217-3

Filed 10/02/2006

Page 3 of 6

Exhibits from Plaintiffs' Exhibit List subject to Defendant's Motion in Limine to Exclude Certain Witnesses and Exhibits

PT635 OCE019446

OCE019447

Correspondence exchange between Capt. Zobel and Virginia Beach resident Laureen Docteur regarding noise complaint following move into condominium near 11/30/1999 Lynnhaven Mall Letters from various Virginia Beach and Chesapeake 12/13/1999 residents complaining of noise Wyle Report 04-03 - Pre-Final Guidelines for Sound Insulation of Residences 02/00/2005 Exposed to Aircraft Operations Memo from Jeffery Borowy to N44 regarding Oceana Sound Attenuation and Memo on Aircraft Noise Policy for the 02/00/1998 FAA and the Navy. Rebuttal - Various Newspaper 00/00/0000 Articles Expert Report by Jon P. Nelson - Effects of Aircraft Noise on Residential Property Values: NAS Oceana and 9/26/2005 NALF Fentress Report by Jon P. Nelson Plaintiffs' Rebuttal to the Expert Report of Dr. David Dale-Johnson (Analysis of the Impact of the Realignment on 12/12/2005 House Values)

Hearsay & Relevance

PT636 OCE019478

OCE019485

Hearsay & Relevance

PT735 OCE224799

OCE224935

Relevance

PT803 PClassX002 PT804 PClassX013

PClassX002 PClassX013

Relevance Hearsay

PT805 PL-EXPT000001

PL-EXPT000044

DX116

Subject to Stipulation (Daubert Challenge)

PT806 PL-EXPT000045

PL-EXPT000072

DX120

Subject to Stipulation (Daubert Challenge)

Case 1:01-cv-00201-VJW

Document 217-3

Filed 10/02/2006

Page 4 of 6

Exhibits from Plaintiffs' Exhibit List subject to Defendant's Motion in Limine to Exclude Certain Witnesses and Exhibits

PT818 PL-EXPT000249

PL-EXPT000266

DX151

PT820 PL-EXPT000284

PL-EXPT000287

PT829 PL-INV000447

PL-INV000474

Rebuttal - Report by Noral D. Stewart - A Review of Report of Sanford Fidell in Testwuide et al. v. United States of 2/21/2006 America Rebuttal - Dr. Noral Stewart letter to Jack Ferrebee regarding improvement of 7/22/2005 sound insulation in homes META-ANALYSIS OF AIRPORT NOISE AND HEDONIC PROPERTY VALUES: PROBLEMS AND PROSPECTS BY JON P. 07/00/2003 NELSON Graphic and Map by the Virginian Pilot entitled, "Train the Way You Fight," regarding problems with training at 08/00/2005 Oceana and Fentress Newspaper Article by Jon W. Glass entitled, "Jet-noise zone 10/13/2005 restrictions develop." Rebuttal - Opinion Editorial by Anthony J. Principi, "Cecil's Accident Zones have Fewer 10/21/2005 Homes than Oceana's." Opinion Editorial by Admiral Stephen Turcotte entitled "Navy Has a Right and Responsibility to Weigh in on 12/4/2003 Development Near Oceana."

Subject to Stipulation

Hearsay & Relevance

Subject to Stipulation

PT833 PL-INV001651

PL-INV001651

Hearsay

PT835 PL-INV003077

PL-INV003079

Hearsay & Relevance

PT836 PL-INV003148

PL-INV003148

Hearsay & Relevance

PT839 PL-INV005701

PL-INV005702

Hearsay

Case 1:01-cv-00201-VJW

Document 217-3

Filed 10/02/2006

Page 5 of 6

Exhibits from Plaintiffs' Exhibit List subject to Defendant's Motion in Limine to Exclude Certain Witnesses and Exhibits

PT842 PL-INV007661

PL-INV007661

9/30/2005

PT843 PL-INV010352

PL-INV010353

12/26/2005

PT844 PL-INV010355 PT847 PL-INV011688 PT848 PL-INV011689 PT849 PL-INV011694 PT850 PL-INV011695 PT851 PL-INV011706

PL-INV010500 PL-INV011688 PL-INV011693 PL-INV011694 PL-INV011695 PL-INV011706

04/00/2005 05/00/2004 00/00/2004 3/10/2005 11/27/2000 00/00/2001

Affidavit signed by David Dubbink regarding the Interactive Sound Information System Virginian Pilot Article "The jet engine's roar? Get used to it from Super Hornet." Rebuttal - Guidelines for Sound Insulation of Residences Exposed to Aircraft Operations prepared by Wyle Research and Consulting for the Navy. Overflight video taken by Janet Holloway Photos of overflights by Janet Holloway Overflight video taken by Herk Stokely Overflight video taken by Thomas Askins Overflight video taken by Herk Stokely

Hearsay & Relevance

Hearsay & Relevance

Relevance Relevance & Document not in Def. Posession Relevance & Document not in Def. Posession Relevance & Document not in Def. Posession Relevance & Document not in Def. Posession Relevance & Document not in Def. Posession

PT853 PL100492 PT854 PL100558

PL100538 PL100564

PT856 PL102662

PL102761

Rebuttal - Expert Report of Dr. Jon Nelson entitled, "Naval Air Station (NAS) Oceana and Naval Auxiliary Landing Field 3/7/2001 (NALF) Fentress." Curriculum Vitae of Dr. Jon 09/00/2001 Nelson. Rebuttal - Report by United States FAA entitled, "Aviation 03/00/1985 Noise Effects"

Subject to Stipulation Subject to Stipulation (Daubert Challenge)

Relevance

Case 1:01-cv-00201-VJW

Document 217-3

Filed 10/02/2006

Page 6 of 6

Exhibits from Plaintiffs' Exhibit List subject to Defendant's Motion in Limine to Exclude Certain Witnesses and Exhibits

PT863 PSJX049

PSJX049

Declaration of Dr. Noral Stewart in Testwuide et al. v. the United States, Case No. 5/23/2006 01-201L. Rebuttal - Rebuttal Declaration 4/22/2002 by Dr. Jon P. Nelson

Hearsay

PT870 PX152

PX152

PX152

Subject to Stipulation