Case 1:98-cv-00484-JPW
Document 269
Filed 10/06/2006
Page 1 of 37
IN THE UNITED STATES COURT OF FEDERAL CLAIMS NORTHERN STATES POWER COMPANY, Plaintiffs, v. THE UNITED STATES, Defendant. ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) )
No. 98-484C (Senior Judge Wiese)
DEFENDANT'S EXHIBIT LIST Pursuant to the Court's order entered September 14, 2005, defendant provides the following list of trial exhibits. This list does not contain exhibits that the defendant may choose to use for impeachment or to refresh the recollection of a witness. Defendant reserves the right to amend this list as described in the Court's orders and rules, and further reserves the right to amend the list based upon the Court's determination of the various pending motions in limine. Finally, defendant reserves the right to use any exhibit listed on the exhibit list provided by plaintiff, Northern States Power Company ("NSP"). Respectfully submitted, PETER D. KEISLER Assistant Attorney General DAVID M. COHEN Director
s/Harold D. Lester, Jr. HAROLD D. LESTER, JR. Assistant Director
Case 1:98-cv-00484-JPW
Document 269
Filed 10/06/2006
Page 2 of 37
OF COUNSEL: JANE K. TAYLOR Office of General Counsel U.S. Department of Energy 1000 Independence Avenue, S.W. Washington, D.C. 20585 ALAN J. LO RE ANDREW P. AVERBACH STEPHEN P. FINN Civil Division Department of Justice 1100 L Street, N.W. Washington, D.C. 20530 October 6, 2006 s/Heide L. Herrmann HEIDE L. HERRMANN Trial Attorney Commercial Litigation Branch Civil Division Department of Justice 1100 L Street, N.W. Attn: Classification Unit 8th Floor Washington, D.C. 20530 Tele: (202) 305-3315 Fax: (202) 307-2503
Attorneys for Defendant
-2-
Case 1:98-cv-00484-JPW
Document 269
Filed 10/06/2006
Page 3 of 37
CERTIFICATE OF FILING AND SERVICE I hereby certify that on this 6th day of October, 2006, a copy of foregoing "DEFENDANT'S EXHIBIT LIST" was filed electronically. I understand that notice of this filing will be sent to all parties by operation of the Court's electronic filing system. Parties may access this filing through the Court's system.
s/Heide L. Herrmann
Case 1:98-cv-00484-JPW
Document 269
Filed 10/06/2006
Page 4 of 37
10/6/2006 2:30 PM
Northern States Power Company v. United States, No. 98-484C
Defendant's Exhibit List Gov. Exh # 0001A Bates - Begin KRGNSP07972 Bates - End KRGNSP08033
Full Name Doc Date Contract for Disposal of Spent Nuclear Fuel and/or High-Level 06/20/1983 Radioactive Waste, US DOE Contract No. DE-CR01-83-NE44400.000, between DOE and Northern States Power, Re: Prairie Island Nuclear Generating Plant 1 and 2 Contract for Disposal of Spent Nuclear Fuel and/or High-Level Radioactive Waste, U.S. Department of Energy Contract No. DE-CR01-83-NE44473.000, Monticello Nuclear Generating Plant Contract for Disposal of Spent Nuclear Fuel and/or High-Level Radioactive Waste, U.S. Department of Energy Contract No. DE-CR01-83-NE44474.000, Monticello Nuclear Generating Plant 06/20/1983
0001B
KRGNSP08100
KRGNSP08161
0001C
KRGNSP08036
KRGNSP08097
06/20/1983
0002
ARC0010001
ARC0010055
Administrative Record-Standard Contract: Public Hearing on the 03/03/1983 Standard Contact for Disposal of Spent Nuclear Fuel and/or High Level Radioactive Waste Federal Register Notice Part IV, re: Standard Contract for Disposal of Spent Nuclear Fuel and/or High Level Radioactive Waste Federal Register Notice Part II, re: Standard Contract for Disposal of Spent Nuclear Fuel and/or High Level Radioactive Waste Response to request for comments on Standard Contract for Disposal of SNF and/or HLW Letter from Hunton & Williams to NWPA-Project Office, DOE Letter from Southern California Edison Company to NWPA-Project Office, re: Contract for Disposal of SNF and/or High-Level Radioactive Waste Letter from H.B. Tucker, Duke Power Company, to NWPA-Project Office, re: Contract for Disposal of SNF and/or High-Level Radioactive Waste - Preliminary Comments Letter from the Virginia State Corporation Commission Division of Energy Regulation to NWPA - Project Office, re: Standard Contract: Proposed Rulemaking Letter from San Diego Gas & Electric to NWPA-Project Office, re: Request for Comments on Standard Contract - Federal Register 02/04/1983 04/18/1983 02/04/1983 02/08/1983 02/07/1983
0002.01 0002.02 0002.03 0002.04 0002.05
ARC0010056 ARC0010071 ARC0010091 ARC0010102 ARC0010121
ARC0010070 ARC0010090 ARC0010101 ARC0010120 ARC0010125
0002.06
ARC0010126
ARC0010136
02/08/1983
0002.07
ARC0010137
ARC0010137
02/17/1983
0002.08
ARC0010138
ARC0010140
02/24/1983
Page 1 of 34
Case 1:98-cv-00484-JPW
Document 269
Filed 10/06/2006
Page 5 of 37
10/6/2006 2:30 PM
Northern States Power Company v. United States, No. 98-484C
Defendant's Exhibit List Gov. Exh # ** 0002.09 0002.10 Bates - Begin ** ARC0010141 ARC0010149 Bates - End ** ARC0010148 ARC0010156 Full Name Notice Statement before the Public Hearing on DOE's Draft Statement of E. Linn Draper, Jr., Senior Vice President- External Affairs Gulf States Utilities Company on behalf of the Edison Electric Institute, The Utility Nuclear Waste Management Group Public Hearing Comments from Dr. William M. Jacobi, General Manager, Nuclear Fuel Division, Westinghouse Electric Corporation Letter from D. H. Peterson, Northern States Power Company, to NWPA-Project Office, re: Comments on the Draft Waste Disposal Contract Omaha Public Power District's Comments concerning draft standard contract for the disposal of SNF Letter from the Cincinnati Gas & Electric Company, re: Notice of Proposed Rulemaking on standard contract for disposal of SNF to NWPA-Project Office
Doc Date ** 03/03/1983 No Date
0002.11 0002.12
ARC0010157 ARC0010164
ARC0010163 ARC0010168
03/03/1983 03/03/1983
0002.13 0002.14
ARC0010169 ARC0010176
ARC0010175 ARC0010187
No Date 03/04/1983
0002.15 0002.16
ARC0010188 ARC0010207
ARC0010206 ARC0010211
Comments by Consumers Power Company on Contract for disposal of No Date SNF Letter from H.L. Brey, Public Service Company of Colorado to NWPA-Project Office, re: Proposed standard contract for disposal of SNF Comments from the Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, re: Contract for disposal of SNF and/or High-Level Radioactive Waste Comments from the Gulf States Utility, re: Standard Contract for disposal of SNF and/or High-Level Radioactive Waste Comments by Wisconsin Public Service Corporation; Contract for the disposal of SNF and/or High Level Radioactive Waste Letter from the Iowa Department of Transportation to NWPA-Project Office, re: Proposed DOE Standard Contract for disposal of SNF and/or High-Level Radioactive Waste 03/03/1983
0002.17 0002.18 0002.19 0002.20
ARC0010212 ARC0010225 ARC0010236 ARC0010240
ARC0010224 ARC0010235 ARC0010239 ARC0010241
03/04/1983 No Date 03/03/1983 03/04/1983
Page 2 of 34
Case 1:98-cv-00484-JPW
Document 269
Filed 10/06/2006
Page 6 of 37
10/6/2006 2:30 PM
Northern States Power Company v. United States, No. 98-484C
Defendant's Exhibit List Gov. Exh # 0002.21 Bates - Begin ARC0010242 Bates - End ARC0010245 Full Name Letter from the Public Service of New Hampshire to NWPA-Project Office, re: Standard Contract for disposal of SNF and/or High-Level Radioactive Waste Letter from GPU Services to NWPA-Project Office, re: Contract for disposal of SNF and/or High-Level Radioactive Waste
Doc Date 03/04/1983
0002.22 0002.23
ARC0010246 ARC0010250
ARC0010249 ARC0010254
03/04/1983
Letter from Yankee Atomic Electric Company, A.R. Soucy to 03/04/1983 NWPA-Project Office, re: Standard Contract for disposal of SNF and/or High-Level Radioactive Waste Letter from Public Service Electric & Gas Co, Fryling, to NWPA-Project 03/03/1983 Office, re: Nuclear Waste Policy Act of 1982 Standard Contract for disposal of SNF and/or High-Level Radioactive Waste Notice of Proposed Rulemaking 10 CFR Part 961 48 F.R. No. 25 Letter from the Long Island Lighting Company, W.J. Tunney, to NWPA-Project Office, re: Contract for disposal of SNF and/or High-Level Radioactive Waste Letter from Northeast Utilities, B.W. Erk, to NWPA-Project Office, re: Contract for disposal of SNF and/or High-Level Radioactive Waste 03/03/1983
0002.24
ARC0010255
ARC0010259
0002.25
ARC0010260
ARC0010262
0002.26 0002.27
ARC0010263 ARC0010269
ARC0010268 ARC0010273
03/03/1983
Letter from Southern Company Services, Inc., Ruble A. Thomas, to 03/04/1983 Robert Morgan, NWPA-Project Office, re: Contract for Disposal of SNF and/or High-Level Radioactive Waste Letter from Alabama Power, F.L. Clayton, to Robert Morgan, NWPA-Project Office, re: Contract for Disposal of SNF and/or High-Level Radioactive Waste Standard Contract Administrative Record Final Comments from Duke Power Company; Standard Contract for disposal of SNF and/or High-Level Radioactive Waste Letter from Kansas Gas and Electric Company to NWPA-Project Office, re: Contract for disposal of SNF and/or High-Level Radioactive Waste Letter from Iowa Electric Light and Power Company to NWPA-Project Office, re: Comments on the proposed DOE Waste Disposal Services 03/04/1983
0002.28
ARC0010274
ARC0010282
0002.29
ARC0010283
ARC0010290
03/03/1983
0002.30
ARC0010291
ARC0010298
03/01/1983
0002.31
ARC0010299
ARC0010301
03/03/1983
Page 3 of 34
Case 1:98-cv-00484-JPW
Document 269
Filed 10/06/2006
Page 7 of 37
10/6/2006 2:30 PM
Northern States Power Company v. United States, No. 98-484C
Defendant's Exhibit List Gov. Exh # ** 0002.32 Bates - Begin ** ARC0010302 Bates - End ** ARC0010315 Full Name Contract J-70 Letter from the Mississippi Power and Light Company to NWPA-Project, re: Grand Gulf Nuclear Station Units 1 & 2 file: 0321/15162/N155.0/L860.0 Comments, re: Standard Contract for disposal of SNF and/or High-Level Radioactive Waste; Notice of Proposed Rule
Doc Date ** 03/04/1983
0002.33
ARC0010316
ARC0010324
Letter from Portland General Electric Company, J.T. Owens to NWPA- 03/04/1983 Project Office, re: Comments and Recommendation concerning DOE's Draft Contract for disposal of SNF and/or High-Level Radioactive Waste vb (per HDL 05/05/06) Letter to Edison Electric Institute to Robert Morgan, NWPA-Project Office, re: Standard Contract for Disposal of SNF and/or High-Level Radioactive Waste 03/07/1983
0002.34
ARC0010325
ARC0010412
0002.35
ARC0010413
ARC0010413
Letter from Atlantic Electric to NWPA-Project Office, re: Nuclear Waste 03/02/1983 Policy Act of 1982 Standard Contract for disposal of SNF and/or High-Level Radioactive Waste Notice of Proposed Rulemaking Letter from Detroit Edison to NWPA-Project Office, re: comments on Standard Contract for disposal of SNF and/or High-Level Radioactive Waste 03/03/1983
0002.36
ARC0010414
ARC0010415
0002.37
ARC0010416
ARC0010416
Letter from the State of Iowa, Dept. of Public Defense-Disaster 03/02/1983 Services to NWPA-Project Office, re: Standard Contract for disposal of SNF and/or High-Level Radioactive Waste Letter from Robert Alexander to the NWPA-Project Office, re: Standard 03/02/1983 Contract for disposal of SNF and/or High-Level Radioactive Waste Letter from American Electric Power to NWPA Project Office, re: 10 C.F.R. PART 961, Standard Contract for disposal of SNF and/or High-Level Radioactive Waste Letter from Nuclear Energy Information Service, Energy Analyst, to NWPA Project Office, re: Corrections to testimony given concerning recommended sites for High-Level nuclear waste repositories Letter from Penberthy, Electomelt International, Inc., L. Penberthy to 03/07/1983
0002.38 0002.39
ARC0010417 ARC0010418
ARC0010417 ARC0010420
0002.40
ARC0010421
ARC0010422
03/05/1983
0002.41
ARC0010423
ARC0010435
03/04/1983
Page 4 of 34
Case 1:98-cv-00484-JPW
Document 269
Filed 10/06/2006
Page 8 of 37
10/6/2006 2:30 PM
Northern States Power Company v. United States, No. 98-484C
Defendant's Exhibit List Gov. Exh # ** 0002.42 Bates - Begin ** ARC0010436 Bates - End ** ARC0010437 Full Name NWPA-Project Office, re: Hearing for Public Comment on Utility Contracts, March 3, 1983 Letter from Larry Caldwell to NWPA Project Office, re: Comments on Standard Contract for Disposal of Spent Nuclear Fuel and/or High Level Radioactive Waste -Federal Register, vol. 48, Proposed rule Letter from Florida Power and Light Company, re: Standard Contract for disposal of SNF and/or High Level Radioactive Waste Letter from Arkansas Power & Light Company, re: Comments on Contract for disposal of SNF and/or High Level Radioactive Waste
Doc Date ** 03/05/1983
0002.43 0002.44 0002.45
ARC0010438 ARC0010442 ARC0010444
ARC0010441 ARC0010443 ARC0010445
03/07/1983 03/04/1983
Letter from Nebraska Public Power District to NWPA-Project Office, re: 03/04/1983 Comments on Contract for disposal of SNF and/or High Level Radioactive Waste Letter from Department of Justice to NWPA-Project Office, re: Contract for disposal of SNF and/or High Level Radioactive Waste 03/07/1983
0002.46 0002.47
ARC0010446 ARC0010447
ARC0010446 ARC0010448
Letter from Nebraska Public Power District to NWPA-Project Office, re: 03/04/1983 Comments on Contract for disposal of SNF and/or High Level Radioactive Waste Letter from Pennsylvania Power & Light Company to NWPA-Project Office, re: Comments on Contract for disposal of SNF and/or High Level Radioactive Waste 03/04/1983
0002.48
ARC0010449
ARC0010451
0002.49
ARC0010452
ARC0010455
Letter from Duquesne Light to NWPA-Project Office, re: Letter from 03/04/1983 Nebraska Public Power District to NWPA-Project Office, re: Comments on Contract for disposal of SNF and/or High Level Radioactive Waste Letter from Toledo Edison to NWPA-Project Office, re: Comments on Contract for disposal of SNF and/or High Level Radioactive Waste Letter from Commonwealth Edison to NWPA-Project Office, re: Comments on Contract for disposal of SNF and/or High Level Radioactive Waste Letter from the Environmental Policy Institute, re: Comments on Contract for disposal of SNF and/or High Level Radioactive Waste 03/04/1983 03/04/1983
0002.50 0002.51
ARC0010456 ARC0010458
ARC0010457 ARC0010464
0002.52
ARC0010465
ARC0010467
03/07/1983
Page 5 of 34
Case 1:98-cv-00484-JPW
Document 269
Filed 10/06/2006
Page 9 of 37
10/6/2006 2:30 PM
Northern States Power Company v. United States, No. 98-484C
Defendant's Exhibit List Gov. Exh # 0002.53 Bates - Begin ARC0010468 Bates - End ARC0010472 Full Name Letter from Westinghouse Electric Corporation to NWPA-Project Office, re: Comments on Contract for disposal of SNF and/or High Level Radioactive Waste Letter from Atlantic Electric to NWPA-Project Office, re: Comments on Contract for disposal of SNF and/or High Level Radioactive Waste
Doc Date 03/07/1983
0002.54 0002.55
ARC0010473 ARC0010474
ARC0010473 ARC0010476
03/02/1983
Responsive Comments from the AIF Committee on the Nuclear Waste No Date Fund, re: Comments on Contract for disposal of SNF and/or High Level Radioactive Waste Letter from the American Electric Power Service Corporation, to NWPA-Project Office, re: Comments on Contract for disposal of SNF and/or High Level Radioactive Waste 03/04/1983
0002.56
ARC0010477
ARC0010483
0002.57
ARC0010484
ARC0010487
Letter from the Philadelphia Electric Company to NWPA-Project Office, 03/03/1983 re: Comments on Contract for disposal of SNF and/or High Level Radioactive Waste Letter from Carolina Power and Light Company to NWPA-Project Office, re: Contract for disposal of SNF and/or High Level Radioactive Waste Letter from Friends of the Earth to NWPA-Project Office, re: Comments on Contract for disposal of SNF and/or High Level Radioactive Waste Comments by Pacific Gas and Electric Company; Contract for the disposal of SNF and/or High Level Radioactive Waste Letter from Mary Metcalf to NWPA-Project Office, re: Comments on Contract for disposal of SNF and/or High Level Radioactive Waste Letter from LeBoeuf, Lamb, Leiby and MacRae to NWPA-Project Office, re: Contract for disposal of SNF and/or High Level Radioactive Waste 03/03/1983
0002.58
ARC0010488
ARC0010490
0002.59
ARC0010491
ARC0010492
03/07/1983
0002.60 0002.61 0002.62
ARC0010493 ARC0010525 ARC0010527
ARC0010524 ARC0010526 ARC0010532
03/04/1983 03/02/1983 03/07/1983
0002.63 0002.64
ARC0010533 ARC0010560
ARC0010559 ARC0010561
Comments by TVA; Contract for the disposal of SNF and/or High Level No Date Radioactive Waste Letter from the Nuclear Fuel Service, Inc. to NWPA-Project Office, re: Comments on Contract for disposal of SNF and/or High Level 03/07/1983
Page 6 of 34
Case 1:98-cv-00484-JPW
Document 269
Filed 10/06/2006
Page 10 of 37
10/6/2006 2:30 PM
Northern States Power Company v. United States, No. 98-484C
Defendant's Exhibit List Gov. Exh # ** 0002.65 Bates - Begin ** ARC0010562 Bates - End ** ARC0010564 Full Name Radioactive Waste Letter from Maine Yankee Atomic Power Company to NWPA-Project Office, re: Comments on Contract for disposal of SNF and/or High Level Radioactive Waste Letter from The Houston Lighting and Power Company to Office of Procurement Operations, re: Comments on Contract for disposal of SNF and/or High Level Radioactive Waste Letter from Virginia Electric and Power Company to NWPA-Project Office, re: Comments on Contract for disposal of SNF and/or High Level Radioactive Waste Letter from General Electric to NWPA, re: Comments on Contract for disposal of SNF and/or High Level Radioactive Waste Letter from Middle South Services, Inc., to NWPA-Project Office, re: Comments on Contract for disposal of SNF and/or High Level Radioactive Waste Letter from Vermont Yankee Nuclear Power Corporation, to NWPA-Project Office, re: Comments on Contract for disposal of SNF and/or High Level Radioactive Waste Letter from Baltimore Gas and Electric to NWPA-Project Office re: Draft DOE Utility Standard Waste Disposal Contract Letter from Consolidated Edison Company to NWPA, re: Draft Contract for disposal of SNF and/or High Level Radioactive Waste Letter from C-E Power Systems to NWPA-Project Office, re: Comments on Contract for disposal of SNF and/or High Level Radioactive Waste Letter from Southern California Edison Company to NWPA-Project Office, re: Comments on Contract for disposal of SNF and/or High Level Radioactive Waste
Doc Date ** 03/07/1984
0002.66
ARC0010565
ARC0010570
03/04/1983
0002.67
ARC0010571
ARC0010573
03/07/1983
0002.68 0002.69
ARC0010574 ARC0010624
ARC0010623 ARC0010631
03/08/1983 03/07/1983
0002.70
ARC0010632
ARC0010638
03/07/1983
0002.71 0002.72 0002.73
ARC0010639 ARC0010642 ARC0010648
ARC0010641 ARC0010647 ARC0010648
03/07/1983 03/07/1983 03/07/1983
0002.74
ARC0010649
ARC0010649
03/04/1983
0002.75
ARC0010650
ARC0010652
Letter from Virginia Electric and Power Company to NWPA-Project, re: 03/07/1983 Comments on Contract for disposal of SNF and/or High Level Radioactive Waste
Page 7 of 34
Case 1:98-cv-00484-JPW
Document 269
Filed 10/06/2006
Page 11 of 37
10/6/2006 2:30 PM
Northern States Power Company v. United States, No. 98-484C
Defendant's Exhibit List Gov. Exh # 0002.76 Bates - Begin ARC0010653 Bates - End ARC0010656 Full Name Letter from Louisiana Power and Light to NWPA-Project Office, re: Comments on Contract for disposal of SNF and/or High Level Radioactive Waste Letter from Rochester Gas and Electric Corp. to NWPA-Project Office, re: Comments on Contract for disposal of SNF and/or High Level Radioactive Waste Letter from South Carolina Electric and Gas Company, to NWPA-Project Office, re: Comments on Contract for disposal of SNF and/or High Level Radioactive Waste
Doc Date 03/07/1983
0002.77
ARC0010657
ARC0010659
03/07/1983
0002.78
ARC0010660
ARC0010662
03/07/1983
0002.79
ARC0010663
ARC0010663
Letter from Arizona Nuclear Power Project to NWPA-Project Office, re: 03/07/1983 Comments on Contract for disposal of SNF and/or High Level Radioactive Waste Letter from Dairyland Power Corporation, to NWPA-Project Office, re: Comments on Contract for disposal of SNF and/or High Level Radioactive Waste Letter from J.T. Beckham, Jr, Georgia Power to NWPA-Project Office, re: Comments on Contract for Disposal of SNF and/or High Level Radioactive Waste Letter from Delmarva Power to NWPA-Project Office, re: Contract for disposal of SNF and/or High Level Radioactive Waste Letter from Niagara Mohawk Power Corporation, to NWPA-Project Office, re: Contract for disposal of SNF and/or High Level Radioactive Waste Letter from Florida Power to NWPA-Project Office, re: Standard Contract for disposal of SNF and/or High Level Radioactive Waste Comments by Boston Edison: Contract for the disposal of SNF and/or High Level Radioactive Waste Excerpts from Federal Register, re: Standard Contract for Disposal of Spent Nuclear Fuel and/or High Level Radioactive Waste - Final Rule Correction Certificate of Need Application to Increase Storage Capability of the 03/07/1983
0002.80
ARC0010664
ARC0010672
0002.81
ARC0010673
ARC0010680
03/04/1983
0002.82 0002.83
ARC0010681 ARC0010682
ARC0010681 ARC0010690
03/08/1983 03/07/1983
0002.84 0002.85 0002.86
ARC0010691 ARC0010693 ARC0010695
ARC0010692 ARC0010694 ARC0010696
03/04/1983 No Date 05/24/1983
0003
NSP0030492
NSP0030593
09/1979
Page 8 of 34
Case 1:98-cv-00484-JPW
Document 269
Filed 10/06/2006
Page 12 of 37
10/6/2006 2:30 PM
Northern States Power Company v. United States, No. 98-484C
Defendant's Exhibit List Gov. Exh # ** 0004 Bates - Begin ** NXS0010001 Bates - End ** NXS0010057 Full Name Spent Fuel Pool at the Prairie Island Generating Plant Submitted by Northern States Power Amendments Nos. 48 and 42 to Facility Operating Licenses Nos. DPR-42 and DPR-60 for the Prairie Island Nuclear Generating Plant, Unit Nos. 1 and 2, May 13, 1981 June 1982 - Spent Fuel Storage Requirements - An Update of DOE/SR0007
Doc Date ** 05/13/1981
0005 0006 0007 0008 0009 0010
PA100903 TV 1378 SN011616 SN145831 SN048515 SN145731
PA100986 TV 1426 SN011620 SN145837 SN048568 SN145766
06/1982
Letter from James J. Fiore, DOE, to Ray Hoskins, TVA, enclosing draft 06/03/1982 version of contract for disposal of spent nuclear fuel Memo from D. C. Hagan to B. E. Hunt, re: Utility Nuclear Fuel Economic Group Meeting November 4-5, 1982 Memo from R. E. L. Stanford, UNWMG, to Members, Steering Committee, re: High-Level Waste Policy Act of 1982 Comments of the EEI/UNWMG Added, Draft Contract for Disposal of Spent Nuclear Fuel and/or High-Level Radioactive Waste Memo from Loring Mills to Members, Nuclear Power Executive Advisory Committee, re: Nuclear Waste Policy Act of 1982 and Safety Goal Policy Statement Letter from Larry Hobart, American Public Power Association, to Charles Dean, TVA, enclosing parts of a working draft of contract Letter from S.P. Kraft, Edison Electric Institute, to Robert Mullin, TVA, enclosing EEI mark-up of draft contract Letter to T. Dillon, re: Specific Language Changes to 1/19/83 DOE Draft Contract Letter from the American Public Power Association, L. Hobart to DOE, Dr. Thomas Dillon, re: APPA's comments on DOE's January 19, 1983 draft Standard Contract Agenda Re: Northern States Power Meeting on NWPA with Attached House Bill Overview, US HLW Waste Management Policy Time Line, and November 22,1982 Northern States Power Internal Memo Re: 11/15/1982 12/23/1982 01/1983 01/11/1983
0011 0012 0013 0014
TV 1365 TV 1317 SMUD0011715 TVP0041022
TV 1376 TV 1359 SMUD0011729 TVP0041036
01/12/1983 01/14/1983 01/21/1983 01/21/1983
0015
NSP0043681
NSP0043687
01/21/1983
Page 9 of 34
Case 1:98-cv-00484-JPW
Document 269
Filed 10/06/2006
Page 13 of 37
10/6/2006 2:30 PM
Northern States Power Company v. United States, No. 98-484C
Defendant's Exhibit List Gov. Exh # ** 0016 Bates - Begin ** TVP0041012 Bates - End ** TVP0041021 Full Name Influence of Waste Legislation on Northern States Power's Spent Fuel Memorandum from Eileen Peerless to APPA Members with Interest in Nuclear Power, re: Results of DOE Briefing on Nuclear Waste Bill and Disposal Contracts Letter from Edison Electronic Institute S. Kraft to Tennessee Valley Authority, R. Mullin containing attachment EEI's marked-up version of DOE's January 19, 1983 draft Standard Contract Letter from Larry Hobart, American Public Power Association, to Charles Dean, TVA, enclosing APPA correspondence with DOE Letter from the Atomic Industrial Forum, Inc., Emanuel Gordon to Working Group on Nuclear Waste Fund Draft Contract, re: EEI's and Shaw Pittman's comments upon DOE's January 19, 1983 Standard Contract EEI's Draft Unsolicited Comments on Contract for Disposal of Spent Nuclear Fuel and/or High-Level Radioactive Waste DOE Spent Fuel Disposal Contract
Doc Date ** 01/24/1983
0017
TVP0041103
TVP0041145
01/24/1983
0018 0019
TV 1251 TVP0041148
TV 1261 TVP0041148
01/24/1983 01/24/1983
0020 0021 0022 0023
SN048683 SMUDPRIV0050 SN010659, SN011066 GPE0010322
SN048724 SMUDPRIV0054 SN010682, SN011067 GPE0010392
01/25/1983 02/04/1983
Memo from J. R. Tomonto from M. C. Cook, re: EEI Meeting to 02/11/1983 Prepare Comments on the DOE Disposal Contract - February 10, 1983 Letter from Edison Electric Institute, S.P. Kraft, to Members of the Nuclear Fuel Committee, re: Comments on Draft DOE/Utility Standard Waste Disposal Contract Memo from H.G. Parris to W.F. Willis, re: Nuclear Waste Policy Act of 1982 (Act) - Comments on Draft Contract Between the Department of Energy (DOE) and Utilities for Disposal of Spent Nuclear Fuel (SNF) and High-level Radioactive Waste (HLW) Letter from Kearney, John J. (Senior Vice President, Northern States Power) to Morgan, Robert (NWPA Project Director, DOE) Re: Comments to Standard Contract for Disposal of SNF and/or HLRW with Attachments A and B Letter from Kearney, John J. (Senior Vice President, Northern States Power) to Morgan, Robert (NWPA Project Director, DOE) Re; 02/18/1983
0024
TVA000079
TVA000127
03/02/1983
0025
HQR0520323
HQR0520400
03/07/1983
0026
GPE0010407
GPE0010414
03/07/1983
Page 10 of 34
Case 1:98-cv-00484-JPW
Document 269
Filed 10/06/2006
Page 14 of 37
10/6/2006 2:30 PM
Northern States Power Company v. United States, No. 98-484C
Defendant's Exhibit List Gov. Exh # ** 0027 0028 Bates - Begin ** SMUDPRIV0102 YDK024125 Bates - End ** SMUDPRIV0108 YDK024129 Full Name Comments to Standard Contract for Disposal of SNF and/or HLRW with portion of Attachment A (No Bates Range on Attachment) Shaw Pittman Memorandum from Jay Silberg, re: DOE Final Disposal Contract Presentation to The Institute of Nuclear Materials: Management Presentation by Mr. Loring Mills, Edison Electric Company, re: Importance of Various Provisions of the Nuclear Waste Policy Act of 1982 to Electric Utility Companies Meeting Notes from Edison Electric Institute, Task Group on Waste Contract Letter from Edison Electric Institute, J. J. Kearney, to NWPA Project Office, Robert Morgan, re: 10 CFR Part 961 - Standard Contract for Disposal of Spent Nuclear Fuel and/or High Level Radioactive Waste Memo From Wegener, D.G. to Hill, W.J., Re: Various Letters and Memos Concerning Disposal of Nuclear Fuel Memorandum from Allan T. Mullins to Erik Kvaven, re: Requisition for Contract with DOE Required by the Nuclear Waste Policy Act of 1982 (ACT) Memo from S. P. Kraft, EEI, to Members, Task Group on the Waste Contract, re: Results of May 12, 1983 Meeting Letter from Kraft, Edison, to Members Task Force, w/05/20/83 Kearney, Edison, to Morgan, DOE, with Net v. Gross Generation Attachment, 06/17/83 Morgan, to Kearney, with Draft Complaint, 06/03/83 Burstein, WE, to Keefe, DOE, 6/15/83, Britt, WE, to Keefe Potential Issues to Be Addressed in a Rulemaking Proceeding on the DOE DisposaI Contract Potential Issues to Be Addressed in a Rulemaking Proceeding on the DOE DisposaI Contract
Doc Date ** 04/14/1983 05/04/1983
0029 0030
GPE0010496 YDK023709
GPE0010501 YDK023716
05/12/1983 05/20/1983
0031 0032
NSP0001645 TV 1467
NSP0001646 TV 1475
05/23/1983 05/24/1983
0033 0034
SN010996 SN011047
SN011011 SN011067
05/24/1983 07/15/1983
0035 0036 0037
SN011286 SMUDPRIV0130 YDK045589
SN011302 SMUDPRIV0146 YDK045591
08/29/1983 08/29/1983
Memorandum from Yankee Atomic - Bolton, J. Buchheit and E. Pilat to 10/19/1983 R. Grube and R. Rich re: Sept. 27, 1983 UNWMG DOE Contract Task Force Meeting
Page 11 of 34
Case 1:98-cv-00484-JPW
Document 269
Filed 10/06/2006
Page 15 of 37
10/6/2006 2:30 PM
Northern States Power Company v. United States, No. 98-484C
Defendant's Exhibit List Gov. Exh # 0038 Bates - Begin SNP0118459 Bates - End SNP0118885 Full Name DOE Office of Civilian Radioactive Waste Management: Proceedings of the 1983 Civilian Radioactive Waste Management Information Meeting Memorandum from Yankee Atomic, J.M. Buchheit to R.M. Grube, re: Petition for Rulemaking to Amend the Nuclear Waste Contract Contract between Northern States Power and General Electric Morris Letter from James Hall to Members, Steering and HLW/SF Storage Working Group, re: Comments on DOE Draft Mission Plan for the Cilivan Radioactive Waste Management Program Licensing Report for Prairie Island Nuclear Generating Plant, Units 1 and 2, Spent Fuel Cask Drop Evaluation prepared by A.J. Elliott and M.E. Pearson of Quadex Corporation Letter from Donald Paul Hodel, Secretary, Dept. of Energy to the Honorable J. Bennett Johnston, Committee on Energy and Natural Resources, U.S. Senate responding to his letter of June 21, 1984, concerning the disposal of spent nuclear fuel Memorandum in Support of Petition for Rulemaking DOE, Office of Civilian Radioactive Waste: 1985 Mission Plan for the Civilian Radioactive Waste Management Program - Volumes I, II, & III Utility Nuclear Waste Management Group High-level Waste / Spent Fuel Storage Working Group December 17, 1986 Meeting Notes Northern States Power News, In-House Periodical dated February 1987 Recommendations for Management of Greater-Than-Class-C Low-Level Radioactive Waste: Report to Congress in Response to Public Law 99-240 (DOE/NE-0077) Monitored Retrievable Storage Submission to Congress--Volume I: The Proposal Letter from John J. Kearney, Senior Vice President, Edison Electric Institute, to Ben, C. Rusche, Director, OCRWM
Doc Date 12/12/1983
0039 0040 0041
YDK023771 KRGNSP09249 SN046231
YDK023772 KRGNSP09299 SN046272
01/20/1984 05/11/1084 07/13/1984
0042
NSP0024373
NSP0024494
09/05/1984
0043
YDK013940
YDK013941
09/07/1984
0044 0045 0046 0047 0048
SMUD0014889 HQR0031088, YMP0011045 SN007280 NSP0073083 NRC0040012
SMUD0014914 HQR0031620, YMP0012123 SN007284 NSP0073104 NRC0040074
03/18/1985 06/1985 12/17/1986 02/1987 02/1987
0049 0050
PNL0370307 PA142473
PNL0370349 PA142480
03/1987 04/03/1987
Page 12 of 34
Case 1:98-cv-00484-JPW
Document 269
Filed 10/06/2006
Page 16 of 37
10/6/2006 2:30 PM
Northern States Power Company v. United States, No. 98-484C
Defendant's Exhibit List Gov. Exh # 0051 Bates - Begin CTR0060247 Bates - End CTR0060260 Full Name Letter from Steven P. Kraft, Director, Utility Nuclear Waste Management Group, to Christopher T. Jedrey, Contracting Office, Department of Energy DOE Office of Civilian Radioactive Waste Management Publication: 1987 Annual Capacity Report
Doc Date 04/28/1987
0052 0053
HQR0012705 HQR0031621
HQR0012792 HQR0032143
06/??/1987
DOE Office of Civilian Radioactive Waste: 1987 OCRWM Mission Plan 06/01/1987 Amendment w/ comments on the Draft Amendment and Responses to the Comments Letter from Utility Nuclear Waste Management Group, Nancy Montgomery to Members, High-Level Waste/Spent Fuel Storage Working Group, re: Changes to the Standard Contract Formation of the Annual Capacity Report (ACR) team Memo from Schaefer, Steve (Northern States Power) to Lindsey, Dick (Northern States Power), Re: Spent Fuel Pool Bridge Crane Upgrade with attached undated Memo, Re: Justification for New Spent Fuel Pool Bridge Crane Due to the Fuel Consolidation Project Spent Fuel Strategic Plan, August 1987 Letter from Christopher T. Jedrey, Contracting Officer, Department of Energy, to S.P. Kraft, Director, Utility Nuclear Waste Management Group Letter from Utility Nuclear Waste Management Group, Nancy Montgomery to DOE, Office of Civilian Radioactive Waste Management, Alan Brownstein, re: Annual Capacity Report Modification Process Letter to Barrie McLeod (E.R. Johnson) from C. Villard (Yankee Atomic), re: Comments on Standard Contract Issues 06/24/1987
0054
YDK038291
YDK038416
0055
NSP0072310
NSP0072312
06/25/1987
0056 0057
NSP0001632 PNL0281142
NSP0001642 PNL0281146
08/1987 10/02/1987
0058
CTR0031055
CTR0031056
11/10/1987
0059 0060 0061
YDK015462 PNL0460173 NSP0072951
YDK015463 PNL0460173 NSP0072974
12/01/1987
Edison Electric Institute Listing of Members of the Utility Nuclear Waste 12/09/1987 Management Group; Annual Capacity Report Response Team Memo from McCarten, Laura (Special Nuclear Programs, Northern States Power), Re: Attached Prairie Island Spent Fuel Storage Increase Public Information Strategy Draft Report Authored by 04/12/1988
Page 13 of 34
Case 1:98-cv-00484-JPW
Document 269
Filed 10/06/2006
Page 17 of 37
10/6/2006 2:30 PM
Northern States Power Company v. United States, No. 98-484C
Defendant's Exhibit List Gov. Exh # ** 0062 0063 0064 0065 HQR0012610 HQR0255201 NSP0001617 HQR0012704 HQR0255309 NSP0001630 Bates - Begin ** Bates - End ** Full Name McCarten, Laura Dated April 11, 1988 Removed DOE Office of Civilian Radioactive Waste Publication: 1988 Annual Capacity Report DOE Report, Office of Civilian Radioactive Waste Management: Draft 1988 Mission Plan Amendment Memo from McCarten, Laura (Special Nuclear Programs, Northern States Power) Re: Northern States Power's Spent Nuclear Fuel Strategic Plan, June 1988 Update
Doc Date **
06/1988 06/1988 07/01/1988
0066
NSP0036987
NSP0037089
Prairie Island Spent Fuel Storage Technology Evaluation Report 09/06/1988 Prepared by McCarten, Laura (Northern States Power) and Kapitz, Jon (Northern States Power) Removed
0067 0068 0069 0070 CTR0060075 NSP0024566 NSP0033671 CTR0060085 NSP0024567 NSP0033672
Minutes of Meeting between ACR Response Team, UNWMG, and DOE Letter from, Jon Kapitz, NSP to Charles Agen, Fluor re: Prairie Island using a Dry Storage System Letter from Patrick D. Charais (Power Supply Procurement, Northern States Power), Re: Request for Proposal "PDC DSFSS" PI Dry Spent Fuel Storage Letter from Edison Electric Institute Brian Farrell to ACR Committee, re: DOE White Papers Prairie Island Dry Spent Fuel Storage System Evaluation and Recommendation prepared by Laura McCarten, Jon Kapitz and Mark Stoering
10/13/1988 01/04/1989 02/20/1989
0071 0072
CDB006316 NSP0003035
CDB006336 NSP0003067
07/17/1989 07/17/1989
0073
NSP0034813
NSP0034813
Memo From Stoering, Mark E. (Economic Analyst, Northern States 08/07/1989 Power) to McCarten, Laura (Northern States Power) and Kaptiz, Jon (Northern States Power), Re: Evaluation Team for Dry Storage Options for Spent Fuel at Prairie Island
Page 14 of 34
Case 1:98-cv-00484-JPW
Document 269
Filed 10/06/2006
Page 18 of 37
10/6/2006 2:30 PM
Northern States Power Company v. United States, No. 98-484C
Defendant's Exhibit List Gov. Exh # 0074 0075 Bates - Begin NSP0001838 NSP0024298 Bates - End NSP0001838 NSP0024396 Full Name Memo from McMarten, Laura (Northern States Power) to Perkett, Lisa (Northern States Power), Re: Decommissioning Studies Cover Letter from Charais, Patrick D. (Power Supply Procurement, Northern States Power) to McDonald, Robert (Stone & Webster) and Bisesti, Angelo (Bechtel), cc: McCarten, Laura, Inviting Proposal to Design ISFSI with Attached Excerpt of RFP Report to Congress on Reassessment of the Civilian Radioactive Waste Management Program 1990 Handwritten Notes Authored by McCarten, Laura, Re: Cost Estimates for Rerack with Marginalia Authored by PBC Northern States Power News, In-House Periodical dated February 1990 titled "Economic Development of NSP" Meeting Minutes of the High-level Waste/spent Fuel Storage Working Group Meeting of March 29, 1990, in Washington, D.C.
Doc Date 08/25/1989 10/05/1989
0076 0077 0078 0079 0080
DB0001441 KRGNSP11052 NSP0027292 SN168529 NSP0042605
DB0001474 KRGNSP11054 NSP0027315 SN168532 NSP0042610
11/1989 1990 02/1990 03/29/1990
Letter from Anderson, C. Gary (Northern States Power) to Cupit, 04/26/1990 Robert (Envionmental Quality Board), Re: Attached Northern States Power Comments filed in response to Environmental Impact Statement Scoping Decision Document Memo from McCarten, Laura (Northern States Power), Re: Prairie 06/21/1990 Island Nuclear Projects Department, PI Dry Spent Fuel Storage Project Status, Minutes of June 6, 1990, Management Oversight Committee Meeting Letter from McCarten, Laura (Project Manager, Northern States Power) to Sable, Gretchen (State Planning Agency, Environmental Division), Re: Cost Figures for EIS Alternatives for Prairie Island Dry Cask Storage Facility Letter from Parker, Thomas M. (Nuclear Support Services Manager, Northern States Power) to Cunningham, R.E. (NRC), Re: Application for a License to Construct and Operate a Dry Cask ISFSI at Prairie Island with Attached Portion of Application Appendix D Form Request for Authorization to Engage Transnuclear 07/20/1990
0081
NSP0070062
NSP0070096
0082
NSP0002674
NSP0002675
0083
NSP0036413
NSP0036424
08/31/1990
0084
NSP0035145
NSP0035148
09/07/1990
Page 15 of 34
Case 1:98-cv-00484-JPW
Document 269
Filed 10/06/2006
Page 19 of 37
10/6/2006 2:30 PM
Northern States Power Company v. United States, No. 98-484C
Defendant's Exhibit List Gov. Exh # ** Bates - Begin ** Bates - End ** Full Name Inc. to perform spent fuel storage cask design, with attached January 17, 1989 Memo from Schaefer, S.C. (Northern States Power) to Mataczynski, C.A. (Northern States Power), Re: Benefit/Cost Letter from E.R. Johnson Assoc. to Pat McDuffie, re: 1990 ACR Review Letter from Energy Resources International, M. Schwartz to Brian Farrell, Edison Electric Institute DOE 1990 Annual Capacity Report, Office of Civilian Radioactive Waste Management, Appendices Attached
Doc Date **
0085 0086 0087 0088
HQR0020235 NET0010692 HQR0012487
HQR0020236 NET0010714 HQR0012609
10/29/1990 11/15/1990 12/1990
Preliminary Estimates of the Total System Cost for the Restructured 12/1990 Program: An Addendum to the May 1989 Analysis of the Total System Life Cycle Cost for the Civilian Radioactive Waste Management Program EDB0011518 EDB0011519 DOE Memorandum from Ron Milner to the Director, Office of Civilian Radioactive Waste Management, Approval for the publication of the 1990 Annual Capacity Report Letter from DOE, Office of Civilian Radioactive Waste Management, Ron Milner to D. Zabransky, Re: Modification Process Northern States Power Appplication for Certificate-of-Need for Prairie Island Spent Fuel Storage Volume 2 of 2 Environmental Impact Statement Standard Contract Issue Resolution Process (An Overview and Status), re: Standard Contract for disposal of SNF and/or High-Level Waste PI ISFSI ALTERNATIVES: LLW Considerations (entirely handwritten) with protective order stamp Memo from Milner to Director, OCRWM, RW-1, re: Approval for Issuance of a Comment Draft of the Annual Acceptance Priority Application for Certificate of Need for Temporary Spent Fuel Storage for Prairie Island with protective order stamp 12/21/1990
0089
0090 0091
HQR0080332 NSP0000455
HQR0080333 NSP0000943
03/01/1991 04/1991
0092
CTR0030916
CTR0030922
04/1991
0093 0094 0095
NSP0039979 HQR0011256 NSP0000100
NSP0039985 HQR0011257 NSP0000349
4/24/1991 04/25/1991 4/29/1991
Page 16 of 34
Case 1:98-cv-00484-JPW
Document 269
Filed 10/06/2006
Page 20 of 37
10/6/2006 2:30 PM
Northern States Power Company v. United States, No. 98-484C
Defendant's Exhibit List Gov. Exh # 0096 0097 0098 Bates - Begin NSP0000986 NSP0058563 NSP0032523 Bates - End NSP0001154 NSP0058566 NSP0032548 Full Name Prairie Island Certificate of Need June 1991 Supplemental Filing Northern States Power Community Information Request No. 3
Doc Date 06/1991 08/09/1991
Northern States Power Initial Correspondence from Eckholt to Parker, 08/14/1991 cc: Goering, McCarten, Kapitz & McKeown, Subject: Summary of July 17, 1991 Meeting With NRC on ISFSI, w/Northern States Power Prairie Island Dry Cask Spent Fuel Storage Project Update Standard Contract Task Force Meeting Summary 8/29/91 with marginalia UWASTE Report Utility Nuclear Waste and Transportation Program Number 91-4 Cover Letter from Bradley, Michael J. (Moss & Barnett) to Klein, Allan W. (ALJ, Office of Administrative Hearings), Re: Prairie Island ISFSI Certificate of Need Proceeding, with attached Certificate of Service, Errata Sheet, and Excerpts from Application 1991 DOE Draft Mission Plan Amendment, Office of Civilian Radioactive Waste Management 08/29/1991 08/30/1991 08/30/1991
0099 0100 0101
SN169450 SN169935 NSP0240038
SN169451 SN169937 NSP0240670
0102 0103
HQR0030798 NSP0003110
HQR0031012 NSP003130
09/1991
Rebuttal Testimony of Schwartz, Michael H. Before the Minnesota 10/1991 Public Utilities Commission in re: Application of Northern States Power for a Certificate of Need for a Temporary SNF Storage Facility for the Prairie Island Nuclear Generating Plant Rebuttal Testimony of McCarten, Laura, Before the Public Utilities Commission of the State of Minnesota In Re: Application for a Certificate of Need for a Temporary SNF Storage Facility for Prairie Island Nuclear Generating Plant Letter from Erickson, Kimberly J (Northern States Power) to Klein, Allan W. (ALJ, Office of Administrative Hearings) enclosing Northern States Power's Errata notices including April 29, 1991 Application by Northern States Power for a Certificate of Need UWASTE Report Utility Nuclear Waste and Transportation Program Number 91-8 Transcript of Hearing Before the Office of Administrative Hearings of 10/30/1991
0104
NSP0250375
NSP0250406
0105
NSP0003274
NSP0003338
11/11/1991
0106 0107
SN169918
SN169922
11/15/1991 11/18/1991
Page 17 of 34
Case 1:98-cv-00484-JPW
Document 269
Filed 10/06/2006
Page 21 of 37
10/6/2006 2:30 PM
Northern States Power Company v. United States, No. 98-484C
Defendant's Exhibit List Gov. Exh # ** 0108 0109 0110 0111 0112 Bates - Begin ** HQR0020797 PNL1042511 HQ0006854 EDB0011662 EDB0011764 Bates - End ** HQR0020859 PNL1042705 HQ0006889 EDB0011663 EDB0011765 Full Name the State of Minnesota In Re: Application for a Certificate of Need for Construction of an ISFSI, Volume 1 DOE Office of Civilian Radioactive Waste Publication: DOE 1991 Annual Capacity Report Spent Fuel Storage Requirements 1991-2040, DOE-RL 91-54 1991 Acceptance Priority Ranking Memo from Milner to, Director, OCRWM, RW-1, re: Approval for Publication of the 1991 Acceptance Priority Ranking DOE Memorandum to the Director, Office of Civilian Radioactive Waste Management, J.W. Bartlett, re: Approval for the publication of the 1991 Annual Capacity Report UWASTE Report Utility Nuclear Waste and Transportation Program Number 91-10 UWASTE Report Utility Nuclear Waste and Transportation Program Number 92-02
Doc Date ** 12/1991 12/1991 12/1991 12/04/1991 12/20/1991
0113 0114 0115
SN169909 SN170372 NSP0260544
SN169913 SN170376 NSP0260630
12/23/1991 02/01/1992
Initial Brief of the Minnesota Department of Public Services, Re: 02/03/1992 Application of Northern States Power for Authority to Increase Its Rates for Electric Services in the State of Minnesota, with cover letter Letter from M. Detmer, DOE Contracting Officer, to David P. Austin, Superintendent Nuclear Fuel Procument, RE: Standard Contract for Disposl of Spent Nuclear Fuel and/or High Level Radioactive Waste provisions Memo from Michael Alissi, EEI, to High-Level Waste Working Group, re: Delivery Commitment Schedule Meeting Memo from Lothan, Shri (Nuclear Fuel Specialist, Fuel Resources Department, Northern States Power) to McCarten, Laura (Northern States Power), Re: Delivery Commitment Schedule, Spent Nuclear Fuel Letter from Energy Resource International to Edison Electric Institute 03/04/1992
0116
NSP0043935
NSP0043936
0117 0118
SN172067 NSP0001722
SN172077 NSP0001723
03/06/1992 03/16/1992
0119
NET0010333
NET0010337
05/13/1992
Page 18 of 34
Case 1:98-cv-00484-JPW
Document 269
Filed 10/06/2006
Page 22 of 37
10/6/2006 2:30 PM
Northern States Power Company v. United States, No. 98-484C
Defendant's Exhibit List Gov. Exh # 0120 Bates - Begin NSP0001721, NSP0001727 Bates - End NSP0001721, NSP0001734 Full Name Letter from M. Detmer, Contracting Officer, to David P. Austin, Superintendent, RE: Standard Contract provision that purchaser submits delivery committment schedules (DCS) to the DOE (with marginlia) with attached DCS
Doc Date 06/26/1992
0121
Letter from Masciantonio, NRC, to Parker, NSP, cc: Charnoff, Watzl, 07/09/1992 Tiegel, Miller, Sanda & Kvalseth, Subject: Prairie Island Nuclear Generating Plant, Unit Nos 1 & 2 - Amendment Nos 99 & 92 to Facility Operating License Nos., DRP-42 & DPR-60 ... SN170236 NSP0001470 SN170240 NSP0001504 UWASTE Report Utility Nuclear Waste and Transportation Program Number 92-13 08/01/1992
0122 0123
Order Issued by Minnesota Public Utilities Commission Granting 08/10/1992 Limited Certificate of Need In Re: Application for Certificate of Need for Construction of ISFSI Northern States Power Internal Correspondence from D.G. Wegener, 08/24/1992 Superintendant, Nuclear Engineering, to B.D. Day, GSE, Subject: Fuel Storage Data Letter from Supko, Energy Resources to Alissi, Edison Electric Insititute, re: Issue Papers for Standard Contract Rulemaking Memo from John Closs to Distribution including D. Wegener, T. Breene, and L. McCarten et. al RE: Spent Fuel Delivery Committment Schedule 10/13/1992 10/26/1992
0124
NSP0001659
NSP0001660
0125 0126
ERINSP02787 NSP0001724
ERINSP02798 NSP0001724
0127
CTR0030001
CTR0030030
DOE Standard Contract Issue Resolution Process - An Overview and 04/29/1993 Status; 1993 International High-Level Radioactive Waste Management Conference DOE Office of Civilian Radioactive Waste Publication: 1992 Annual Capacity Report, Rev. 1 Memo, T. Breene to E. Watzl, June 6, 1993 Lettter from Beth Tomasoni, Contracting Officer, to David P. Austin, Superintendent, RE: Standard Contract for Disposal of Spent Nuclear Fuel Excerpts from Application for Resource Plan Approval, 1994-2008, 05/1993 06/06/1993 06/15/1993
0128 0129 0130
HQR0012315 NSP0038389 NSP0001882
HQR0012353 NSP0038390 NSP0001883
0131
NSP0004236
NSP0004282
07/1993
Page 19 of 34
Case 1:98-cv-00484-JPW
Document 269
Filed 10/06/2006
Page 23 of 37
10/6/2006 2:30 PM
Northern States Power Company v. United States, No. 98-484C
Defendant's Exhibit List Gov. Exh # ** 0132 Bates - Begin ** NSP0040914 Bates - End ** NSP0040930 Full Name Northern States Power Before the Minnesota Public Utilities Commission, Volume 2, Application Appendices Letter from McCarten, NSP, to Lancaster, MPUC, RE: Information ... Order ... Certificate of Need for Nuclear Waste Storage Facility at the Prairie Island MPUC Docket No. E002/CN-91-19 w/attached Northern States Power Annual Nuclear Waste Management Report
Doc Date ** 08/10/1993
0133
NSP0040872
NSP0040874
Draft Memo from Kapitz, Jon (Northern States Power) to McCarten, 08/20/1993 Laura (Northern States Power), re: Potential to Regain Spent Fuel Pool Space to Support 5/95 Outage Memo from Closs, John to Antony, Doug, Re: 1993 Delivery Commitment Schedule 08/27/1993
0134 0135
NSP0001868 GPE0010596
NSP0001868 GPE0010597
Letter from DOE, Office of Civilian Radioactive Waste Management, L. 09/02/1993 Barrett to Sacramento Municipal Utility District, J. R. Shetler, re: Northern States Power transportation of SNF DOE Appendix C Delivery Commitment Schedule for Prairie Island Nuclear Plant, Certified by D.D. Antony (Vice President, Nuclear Generation, Northern States Power) on September 21, 1997 Approved Appendix C Delivery Committment Schedule for Prairie Island Nuclear Plant 09/21/1993
0136
NSP0025715
NSP0025715
0137 0138
NSP0001877
NSP0001877
10/20/1993
DOE Appendix C, Delivery Commitment Schedule Re: Prairie Island 12/03/1993 Nuclear Plant Certified by Antony, D. D. (Vice President, Nuclear Generation) on Sept. 21, 1993, Approved by DOE Technical Officer on Oct. 20, 1993, and DOE Contracting Officer on Dec. 3,1993 NSP0001795, NSP0001797 NSP0001880 NSP0001795, NSP0001797 NSP0001880 Letter from Beth Tomsoni to David P. Austin RE: DOE review and 12/06/1993 approval of Northern State's September 21, 1993 Delivery Committment Schedule with attached Delivery Committment Schedule Correspondence from John Closs to various RE: Spent Nuclear Fuel 12/16/1993 Delivery Committment Schedule and Northern State's submission of its first DCS on September 21, 1993 Removed NSP0001872 NSP0001873 Table entitled: 1994 Acceptanace Priority Ranking: Listing of Spent 1994
Page 20 of 34
0139
0140
0141 0142
Case 1:98-cv-00484-JPW
Document 269
Filed 10/06/2006
Page 24 of 37
10/6/2006 2:30 PM
Northern States Power Company v. United States, No. 98-484C
Defendant's Exhibit List Gov. Exh # ** 0143 0144 Bates - Begin ** SN179002 NSP0057456 Bates - End ** SN179017 NSP0057458 Full Name Nuclear Fuel by Date of Permanent Discharge Private Fuel Storage Facility Financial Analysis, Mescalero, MN, Presentation For Mescalero Apache Tribe and Northern States Power
Doc Date ** 03/1994
Letter from Auld, Richard L. (Assistant Commissioner, MN Department 03/01/1994 of Public Service) to Novak, Steven G. (MN State Senate) providing Letter dated Febrary 22, 1994, Re: Reracking Prairie Island's Storage Pool Memo, J. Jensen to E. Watzl, September 19, 1994 Letter from McCarten, Laura (Manager Regulatory Projects, Northern States Power) to Novak, Steven G. (Minnesota State Senate) Re: reracking option for Prairie Island 03/02/1994 03/02/1994
0145 0146
NSP0100712 NSP0001431
NSP0100715 NSP0001433
0147
NSP0056839
NSP0056841
Signed Original of Contractual Agreement between the State of 05/19/1994 Minnesota and Northern States May 19, 1994, for Authorization for the use of Dry Casks by Prairie Island Northern States Power News, In House Periodical, June 1994 Letter from DOE, R. A. Milner, Response to Andrew Kadak's letter of April 20, 1994, to the Secretary of Energy Private Fuel Storage Facility, Financial Analysis Letter from David Sparby, Northern States, to Burl Haar, MN Public Utilities Commission, re: Information Submittal in Connection With Order Granting Limited Certificate of Need for Nuclear Waste Storage Facility at the Prairie Island Nuclear Power MPUC 06/1994 06/16/1994 07/20/1994 08/10/1994
0148 0149 0150 0151
NSP0027978 YDK007568 SN179033 NSP0300304
NSP0028005 YDK007572 SN179046 NSP0300316
0152
KRGNSP13757
KRGNSP13904
Report entitled Multi-Purpose Canister System: A Systems Engineering 09/1994 Approach, by the U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Civilian Radioactive Waste Management NSP's Annual Capacity Report NSP's Delivery Committment Schedule Summary 09/01/1994 09/01/1994
0153 0154 0155
NSP0001801 NSP0001862 EDB0021127
NSP0001805 NSP0001867 EDB0021127
Letter from DOE, Office of Civilian Radioactive Waste Management, D. 09/06/1994 Dreyfus to Commissioner Striebel, re: The statutory limit on
Page 21 of 34
Case 1:98-cv-00484-JPW
Document 269
Filed 10/06/2006
Page 25 of 37
10/6/2006 2:30 PM
Northern States Power Company v. United States, No. 98-484C
Defendant's Exhibit List Gov. Exh # ** 0156 0157 0158 0159 0160 0161 0162 0163 0164 Bates - Begin ** NSP0001790 NSP0001786 NSP0001792 KRGNSP00591 NSP0001789 SN014270 NSP0001787 HQR0290676 YDK012462 Bates - End ** NSP0001791 NSP0001786 NSP0001792 KRGNSP00594 NSP0001789 SN014347 NSP0001788 HQR0290745 YDK012463 Full Name acceptance capacity NSP Spreadsheet Showing Assemblies and Discharge Dates Appendix C Delivery Committment Schedule for Prairie Island Nuclear Plant Working draft of letter from Beth Tomasoni to David P. Austin RE: Standard Contract and DCS allocation provision Minnesota Environmental Quality Board Request for Check from Northern States Power for $35,000 Appendix C Delivery Committment Schedule for Prairie Island Nuclear Plant Private Fuel Storage, Facility Business Plan Letter from Beth Tomasoni, to David Austin RE: DOE review and approval of September 12, 1994 Delivery Committment Schedule 1994 Acceptance Priority Ranking and Annual Capacity Report
Doc Date ** 09/06/1994 09/12/1994 10/12/1994 11/04/1994 12/02/1994 12/20/1994 01/18/1995 03/1995
Informal Memorandum from Mike B. to Andy, re: summary of the 03/03/1995 discussions Mike B. had on the status of SMUD's attempts to get DOE to accept canistered Rancho Seco fuel Letter from Jay K. Thayer, Yankee Atomic, to Thomas Grumbly, DOE, re: GTCC waste Regular Meeting of Board of Directors Northern States Power Company (Minnesota) March 24, 1995 House Executive Message from Johnson, Gary E. (Governor, New Mexico), re: veto of House Energy and Natural Resources Committee Substitute for House Bill 1122 with attached letter from Mescalero Apache Tribe to Northern States Power, re: MRS Project Internal Correspondence from Kapitz to Wadley, re: Fuel Retrievability with protective order stamp Presentation entitled: Utility At-Reactor Spent Fuel Storage Requirements and Cost 03/07/1995 03/24/1995 04/05/1995
0165 0166 0167
HQR0051281 NSP0085902 NSP0011732
HQR0051282 NSP0085909 NSP0011733
0168 0169
NSP0030671 NSP0001850
NSP0030675 NSP0001856
5/02/1995 05/25/1995
Page 22 of 34
Case 1:98-cv-00484-JPW
Document 269
Filed 10/06/2006
Page 26 of 37
10/6/2006 2:30 PM
Northern States Power Company v. United States, No. 98-484C
Defendant's Exhibit List Gov. Exh # 0170 Bates - Begin NSP0300429 Bates - End NSP0300446 Full Name Information Submittal in Connection with Order Granting Limited Certificate of Need for Nuclear Waste Storage Facility at the Prairie Island Nuclear Power MPUC Letter from O'Neill Sr, Paul X. (PX Engineering Co., Inc.) to Charais, Pat (Northern States Power), Bystrzycki, John (Northern States Power), and Watzl, Ed (Northern States Power) Re: Confirmation of settlement of delay of charges submitted by PX Engineer Northern States Power Company Response to DPS Information Request No. 50 with cover page Spent Nuclear Fuel Management Meeting NSP Spreadsheet Showing Assemblies and Discharge Dates Letter from Edward Watzl to DOE RE: 1994 Minnesota legislation impact on Northern States delivery plans and typographical errors in 1994 submiittal with attached 1993 and 1994 DCSs
Doc Date 08/10/1995
0171
NSP0034517
NSP0034518
09/07/1995
0172 0173 0174 0175
NSP78811 NSP0001871 NSP0001766 NSP0001775
NSP78838 NSP0001871 NSP0001768 NSP0001779
09/11/1995 09/13/1995 09/26/1995 09/29/1995
0176
NSP0030676
NSP0030677
Letter from Dawson, David (Vice President, Transnuclear, Inc.) to 10/05/1995 Closs, John (Northern States Power), Re: Availability of Transportation Casks Memo From Watzl, E.L. (Northern States Power) to McIntyre, E.J. (Northern States Power) and Antony, D.D. (Northern States Power), Re: IR Increase, PI Spent Fuel Cask Procurement Mescalero Fuel Storage LLC Organization Chart Northern States Power Dry Cask Alternatives Study Northern States Power Dry Cask Alternatives Study DOE Appendix C Delivery Commitment Schedule, Re: Prairie Island Nuclear Plant, Certified by Watzl, E.L. (Vice President, Nuclear Generation) on Sept. 29, 1995, Approved by DOE Technical Representative on Dec. 15, 1995 10/10/1995
0177
NSP0026951
NSP0026952
0178 0179 0180 0181
NSP0010079 NSP0001400 NSP0001309
NSP0010080 NSP0001430 NSP0001367
10/18/1995 11/1995 11/1995 12/15/1995
0182
NSP0001772
NSP0001774
Letter from Beth Tomasoni to John Closs RE: DOE review and approval of Delivery Commitment Schedule with attached DCS
02/23/1996
Page 23 of 34
Case 1:98-cv-00484-JPW
Document 269
Filed 10/06/2006
Page 27 of 37
10/6/2006 2:30 PM
Northern States Power Company v. United States, No. 98-484C
Defendant's Exhibit List Gov. Exh # 0183 Bates - Begin NSP0001770 Bates - End NSP0001771 Full Name Letter from Beth Tomasoni to John Closs RE: DOE review and approval of September 29, 1995 delivery commitment schedule with attached DCS
Doc Date 02/23/1996
0184
NSP0001769 NSP0001793, NSP0001763 NSP0071523
NSP0001769 NSP0001793, NSP0001763 NSP0071529
Northern States Power Internal Correspondence from John Closs to 03/21/1996 Dan Wegener & Tom Breene, cc: Bonneau, Jensen & Kapitz, Subject: Delivery Commitment Schedules, with attached schedules signed by E. L. Watzl on 9/29/95 Letter from Alders, NSP to Carlson, MDPS re: Northern States Power Company's response to DPS Information Requests Numbers 12 and 13 Northern States Initial Correspondence from Closs to Distribution (Breene, Wegener, Ziemba, Kapitz, Fey, Beard, Jensen, Schuelke, Schnoebelen, O'Brian, Agen, Leighton, Eckholt & Alders), Subject: Annual Spent Fuel Report to MN PUC Letter from James Alders , Northern States Power, to Burl W. Haar, Executive Secretary of Minnesota Public Utilities Commission, RE: Information Submittal in Connection with Order Granting Limited Certificate of Need for Waste Storage Facility at PI DOE Appendix C Delivery Commitment Schedule, Re: Prairie Island Nuclear Plant, Certified by Watzl, E.L. (Vice President, Nuclear Generation, Northern States Power) on September 27, 1996 Draft DOE Appendix C Delivery Commitment Schedule, Re: Prairie Island Nuclear Plant, Certified by Watzl, E.L. (Vice President, Nuclear Generation) Setember 27, 1996 06/05/1996
0185
0186
NSP0040775
NSP0040790
06/27/1996
0187
NSP0300449
NSP0300462
08/09/1996
0188
NSP0001760
NSP0001760
09/27/1996
0189
NSP0001761
NSP0001761
09/27/1996
0190
NSP0037121
NSP0037127
Letter from Henkel, Christopher J. (Nuclear Energy Institute) to 10/18/1996 Northard, Scott (Northern States Power), et al., Re: Standard Contract Task Force and Attached Issue Description and Draft Meeting Agenda for October 20, 1996 Meeting Business Plan Prepared by Parkyn, John D. (Skull Valley Band of Goshutes), Re: Private Fuel Storage LLC Spent Fuel Storage Project Confidential outline entitled Nuclear Generation's Avoided Costs Due to Lack of DOE Fuel Acceptance Beginning January 31, 1998 02/19/1997 03/1997
0191 0192
NSP0003166 NSP0001612
NSP0003273 NSP0001613
Page 24 of 34
Case 1:98-cv-00484-JPW
Document 269
Filed 10/06/2006
Page 28 of 37
10/6/2006 2:30 PM
Northern States Power Company v. United States, No. 98-484C
Defendant's Exhibit List Gov. Exh # 0193 0194 Bates - Begin NSP0001505 NSP0001759 Bates - End NSP0001505 NSP0001760 Full Name Table entitled Projected Spent Nuclear Fuel Generation & Casks Needed at the Prairie Island Plant Letter from Tomasoni, Beth (CO, DOE) to Watzl, E.L. (Vice President, Nuclear Generation, Northern States Power) not approving submitted Delivery Commitment Schedule and inviting comments of contract holders on anticipated delay Quarterly Update on Status of Lawsuit Related to Siting of Goodhue County Independent Spent Fuel Storage Installation Removed NSP0300463 NSP0300479
Doc Date 03/11/1997 03/13/1997
0195 0196 0197
NSP0042786
NSP0042802
05/15/1997
Letter from James Alders to Burl W. Haar, RE: Information Submittal in 08/11/1997 Connection with Order Granting Certificate of Need for Nuclear Waste Facility at Prairie Island Nuclear Power Plant DOE Appendix C Delivery Commitment Schedule, Re: Prairie Island Nuclear Plant, Certified by Watzl, E.L. (Vice President, Nuclear Generation, Northern States Power) on Sept. 30, 1997 09/30/1997
0198
NSP0001762
NSP0001762
0199 0200
MOV.20000714.00 MOV.20000714.00 EIA 2000, Final 1998 RW-859 Database, Rev. 1. Washington, D.C.: 15 15 U.S. Department of Energy, Energy Information Administration NSP0038374 NSP0038374 Northern States Response to DPS Information Request No. 30: Why the Establishment of 195 Spaces on a Temporary Basis would not be Considered "Reracking" Letter from Beth Tomasoni to John Closs RE DOE reciept of Prairie Island DCS and departments rejection of submittal
1998 01/12/1998
0201 0202
NSP0001869 NSP0300480
NSP0001869 NSP0300494
02/11/1998
Letter from James Alders to Burl W. Haar, RE: Information Submittal in 08/10/1998 Connection with Order Granting Limited Certificate of Need for Nuclear Waste Storage Facility Letter from Jon Kapitz to Beth Tomasoni RE: enclosed Northern States 09/1998 Delivery Committment Schedule and Final Delivery Schedule for submittal and approval with attached schedules Removed
0203
NSP0001751
NSP0001754
0204 0205 NSP0001655 NSP0001658
Northern States Power Internal Correspondence from Daniel Wegener 10/13/1998
Page 25 of 34
Case 1:98-cv-00484-JPW
Document 269
Filed 10/06/2006
Page 29 of 37
10/6/2006 2:30 PM
Northern States Power Company v. United States, No. 98-484C
Defendant's Exhibit List Gov. Exh # ** Bates - Begin ** Bates - End **
Full Name Doc Date to Mike Hammer, Plant Manager, & Craig Schibonski, GSE, cc: Harold ** Paustian, Scott Vanevenhoven & Steve Hammer, Subject: Spent Fuel Pool Capacity Letter from Beth Tomasoni to Ed Watzl RE: DOE reciept and rejection of Final Delivery Schedule for Prairie Island Letter from Supko, Eileen M. (Energy Resources International, Inc.) to Kapitz, Jon (Northern States Power), Re: Proposal to Northern States Power to Supply Estimate of SNF Acceptance Rates by DOE for Prairie Island and Monticello Nuclear Power Plants Letter from Jon Kapitz to Eileen Supko RE: attatched NSP data fuel discharges from Prairie Island and Monticello Memo from Supko, Eileen (Energy Resources International, Inc.) to Kapitz, Jon (Northern States Power), Re: Historical Discharges NSP Documents Received from Kapitz, Cover Letter from Supko (Energy Resources International, Inc.) to Kapitz (Northern States Power) With Attached Requested ERI Report Entitled Projection of SNF Acceptance Rates for Northern States Power Company Northern States Power Initial Correspondence from Kapitz to McKeown, Breene, Wegener, Northard & Alders, Subject: Revised DOE Fuel Acceptance Rates,with attached 2/3/99 letter from Supko, ERI, to Kapitz, NSP, &, 2/99 Projection of Spent Nuclear Fuel Letter from Alders, Northern States, to Haar, MPUC, RE: Infomation Submittal in Connection With Order Granting Limited Certificate of Need for Nuclear Waste Storage Facility at the Prairie Island Nuclear Power Plant MPUC Docket No. E002/CN-91-19 Letter from Michael Wadley to Beth Tomasoni RE: Enclosed Northern States Delivery Commitment Schedule and Final Commitment Schedule for review and approval Manitoba Hydro's Proposal to Supply 500 MW of System Participation Power in Response to Resource RFP-9908 Northern States Power August 2, 1999, RFP For Supply Resources 11/06/1998 11/11/1998
0206 0207
NSP0001755 NSP0001836
NSP0001755 NSP0001837
0208 0209 0210
NSP0001846 NSP0001835 NSP0001661
NSP0001849 NSP0001835 NSP0001685
11/13/1998 11/30/1998 12/01/1998
0211
NSP0001556
NSP0001590
02/06/1999
0212
NSP0040669
NSP0040684
08/11/1999
0213
NSP0001747
NSP0001750
09/08/1999
0214
NSP0069204
NSP0069354
09/23/1999
Page 26 of 34
Case 1:98-cv-00484-JPW
Document 269
Filed 10/06/2006
Page 30 of 37
10/6/2006 2:30 PM
Northern States Power Company v. United States, No. 98-484C
Defendant's Exhibit List Gov. Exh # 0215 0216 Bates - Begin NSP0001647 NSP0036638 Bates - End NSP0001650 NSP0036639
Full Name Doc Date Northern States Power Internal Correspondence from Daniel Wegener 10/26/1999 to John Grubb, GSE, Subject: Final Fuel Disposal Draft Northern States Power Spent Nuclear Fuel Project Meeting Minutes of November 4, 1999, Meeting, Re: Northern States Power Work Scope in SNF Proposal Utility At-Reactor Spent Fuel Storage Costs for the Private Fuel Storage Facility Cost Benefit Analysis Revision 2 Letter form Arnold Gjerstad to Michael Wadley RE: DOE reciept and rejection of Delivery Committment Schedule for Prairie Island Plant Unit 1 for 2005 11/09/1999
0217 0218
IMP0200001 NSP0001845
IMP0200034 NSP0001845
04/2000 04/03/2000
0219
NSP0044270
NSP0044273
Faxed email Hammer to Blegen & Zercher, Subject: FW: Reactor 05/22/2000 Building Crane IPC item & original email from Wegener to Hammer, cc: Grubb Subject: Reactor Building Crane IPC item & Monticello Plant NGS Project Request Form signed 5/26/00 & 5/24/00 Letter from Alders, Northern States, to Haar, MPUC, RE: Information Submittal in Connection with Order Granting Limited Certificate of Need for Nuclear Waste Storage Facility at the Prairie Island Nuclear Power Plan (sic) MPUC Docket No. E002/CN-91-19 Letter from David Wilks to Herbert Watkins RE: enclosed Northern States Delivery Committment Schedule submission for review and approval with attached DCS Letter from Kadak Associates, Andrew Kadak, to Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Richard Meserve, re: Greater Than Class C Waste (GTCC) NRC Certificate of Compliance for Radioactive Material Packages, Certificate Number 9010, Revision Number 40, Docket Number 71-9010, Package Identification Number USA/9010/B()F, issued to NAC International, Inc. 08/11/2000
0220
NSP0040645
NSP0040668
0221
NSP0001740
NSP0001743
09/27/2000
0222
GPE0010123
GPE0010123
10/24/2000
0223
03/29/2001
0224
Letter from Brach, E. William (NRC) to Thompson, Thomas C. (NAC 03/29/2001 International) with Enclosed NRC Certificate of Compliance for Radioactive Material Packages, Number 9010, Revision 40, and Safety Evaluation Report, User List Not Included
Page 27 of 34
Case 1:98-cv-00484-JPW
Document 269
Filed 10/06/2006
Page 31 of 37
10/6/2006 2:30 PM
Northern States Power Company v. United States, No. 98-484