Free Reply to Response to Motion - District Court of Federal Claims - federal

Case 1:02-cv-00466-LB

Document 82-2

Filed 03/10/2006

Page 1 of 21

SECOND SUPPLEMENTAL APPENDIX

Case 1:02-cv-00466-LB

Document 82-2

Filed 03/10/2006

Page 2 of 21

Relining

Corp. v. U. S. CONTENTS p) VOIR WITNESSES: DIRECTCROSS REDIR~F-CTRECROSS DIRE

o!

r Robc~ Myrb~n 514 524 531 532 Hcn~Stcvcn Prime 533 556564 - ~ohn Harold Ay=r~ 36B~B~ - -~ith Puhainc 614 - - 58~ John S. Cooka 18 632 - - L~wrcnc¢Caly}n Ervin 634 656 668 670 Gen~c Rgland Sch;nk 671 II II

(Ill

P~g~507 APPeARANCe: (c~ntinucdJ F~r [he Dcf~nflam; ~RRY L. FLOYd, ESQ. U.S.Dcpanm~n~ 110OL S~r, W~sh~n~ton,D.C. Z0530 (302)616-8278 D~fens= Fu~I Supply Comer (DFSC-G) 8725 JohnA ~iogm~nRoad, $ui[¢ 4~50 Fort gelvoir, Virginia 220fi0-6222 (703) 7~-5010 I/

EXHID1TS

Pag," 509

PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBITS: IDENTIFIED RECEIVED D~SCRIPTION 226 56I -Bid ~val~afion mod~l II 11 // II H

II If

//

II 11 I1

HerRnge ~eporting

Page 506 co Page 509

/

Case 1:02-cv-00466-LB

Document 82-2

Filed 03/10/2006

Page 3 of 21

Herituge

Reporting

(202) 628-488B

l~ge 6/7 to Pnge 620

Case 1:02-cv-00466-LB

Document 82-2

Filed 03/10/2006

Page 4 of 21

Page 6;~1 to Page 624

(2o2) 628-d88E

Heritage Reporting

Case 1:02-cv-00466-LB

Document 82-2

Filed 03/10/2006

Page 5 of 21

Pasc628 TH~ f~ ~blicaaon ~em. ~~ p~l~ dam forla~u~ wo~ ~, wo~ ~ut~ for ~n ~nd~l of~jci fucl r~, but ~on by f0 we'd for ~ ~ ~mc out ~ Ap~ or May, Q 0~. till r~lr fom be~ ~fl~d ov~ d, e yea~?

fill the Fr~iou~ page. th~ f~ re~ned pr~ ~ the zame zince the period, z~, 19917 Q N~, When theEne~ Infor~ffon Admlnl~tian group

~po~ th~ i~a~n th~ you ~e obmlned~am this of peopte,

Heritage

Reporting

(202)

:Page 62~ to Page

Case 1:02-cv-00466-LB

Document 82-2

Filed 03/10/2006

Page 6 of 21

It's, ~ ~ m~ Some ~ ~ ~cu~ for p~ r~ aw~,

tt'~,

R ~pp~ to ba ~of~,a~r~ to

~rit~ge

Reporting

Case 1:02-cv-00466-LB

Document 82-2

Filed 03/10/2006

Page 7 of 21

T~TAL P, 05

Case 1:02-cv-00466-LB

Document 82-2

Filed 03/10/2006

Page 8 of 21

La61oria Transcript

Bournazian 120303MF.txt 1

1 2 3 4

IN THE UNITED STATES COURT OF FEDERAL CLAINS

LA GLORIA OIL AND GAS COMPANY,

: :

6 vS. 8 9 I0 II 12 13 14 15 16

Plaintiff, : : No. 02-465C : (3udge Hewitt)

THE UNITED STATES,

Defendant. : .............. X Pages 1-50

Depositionof JACOB BOURNAZIAN Districtof columbia wednesday,December3, 2003

~8 19 2O 21 Reported by: Marilyn Feldman, RPR Job No. 156784

December3, 2003 10:00a.m. Page i

Case 1:02-cv-00466-LB

Document 82-2

Filed 03/10/2006

Page 9 of 21

LaGlorim Transcrip~ BournazianL20~O~F.txt 16 I7 18 t9 20 2I 22 the PNMback to the 1980s? A. q. A. q. Yes. Are they all Yes. To your knowledge, none of the project Z980s to now currently employed by EZA?

managers from the P~M from the early have left the agency; is that correct?

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 !I 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21

A. Yes. Q. Let's turn to the first request,

requestno. 17, which is on page 6 of Plaintiff's Exhibit 2. Reques~ 17 reads: "All documents relating to communications between DESC and concerninguse of the PMM index to adjus~ prices in DESC's price adjustmentclauses." What efforts did you undertake to collectdocuments in response to that and what did you find? A, First, in response to that request there was confusion in our organizationon the use of the term "i.ndices" becausethat's not a term we use and we don't -- an index is a ratio of two

numbers with a baseline but we only publish

being in the denominator, prices, so my

statistics

assumptionis you meant just price data when you used the word index. Is ~hat correct? q. Z think that's a fair assumption.

A. Okay. So the efforts in responding to 17, everyone was asked to check if Page 8 zhey have any

Case 1:02-cv-00466-LB

Document 82-2

Filed 03/10/2006

Page 10 of 21

DESC-G COUNSEL En~r~, In~'rr~n

703 767 5822 P.02/13 Form E:~Ir~:l~l~s

PAErI, IDEHTIFICA'[ION ~TA

For a,.~i~ta.nce In c~mpledng [on'n, c~JI (800.) 63~-~81Z th~

Ym~ A;e Ropm~g

I
PART CERTIFICATION II,

-{

Case 1:02-cv-00466-LB

Document 82-2

Filed 03/10/2006

Page 11 of 21

!_PART IlK MONTHLY STATE.,~ALES FIIWISHI~I)MOTOIi G~LI_NE (R~ ~lu~ ~...a~nd~/,,'-p:,~ OF SA I.E~ THROUGH
]No,

ir

$O.OO~Re~.~./ WHI:iLF-SALE

t~i~fu=f fS~/m" IrWin-x] m~#Tn Fi~ir>h~d ~o~r G~Ii~

, ~

RET.i~ OU'TLE"T~ 1L , VOluri~ Un Prl=a {¢

OTHER END.LI,~EBS
Vo |l.llllti

r~k I~[,~

VolUr~z

h7

7

Lead~lR~31ilar
., _,

Unled~ Regular B.~ g Pr~m{~m
..

Case 1:02-cv-00466-LB

Document 82-2

Filed 03/10/2006

Page 12 of 21

GENERALINFORMATION

Purpose The EIA-782A designedto provide data on the sales of selected petroleumproduc~(volumesand is prices] to V~fioLrscategories end-users o~ ~m-=d reselIe~by type of seller at the Stablevel "Thesedata are coliecled pursuant(o ~heprovisions of ReFederalEnergyAdministtal~on (FEA) of 1974, P.L. 93-275, ThBdata are used by the Department Energy(DOE)in revlewfng petroleum of product supply, demand p~ice changes. and

Any~rrn that directly or ind~re~y controls a refinery or gas ptant mustprepareandfile bheE]A-TB2A e~ch manta. IIL Wha[and Whereto Su~mit Submitn sfngle Schediule[ as a cover sheet, anda separaleS¢hedule for eachState in wh;ch 11 the respondenKsells or moreof the t~ed products, Sendthe completedEIA-TB2A one to: U,S, Department Energy of EnergyInform~l~on Administration Mail Station: BG-09¢ Forres~ Wash~nglon,D.C. 20585 Carried computer printouts ~bat are generaJlyin the format of the EIA-782A will be accepted, RequestDOE approval ~n advance c~[n~l the number by below if you plan to submit computer printout. If you haveany questionsconc~minarty of ~a EIA-78?.A instructJon~, ca~t~ll free (800) 638.8812. 9 i~rrrm locatedin Maryland should call (301) 495-8440. iV. When Submit to The E~A-782~ be submittedto DOE iate~ than ,30 caJendar must no daysaider the close of each reference month.For example~ the reference month June1990, the repor~ mustbe submitted ~f is to DOE July 30, 1990. by

This report iS mandatory under Pubic L~w93-27~. Failure to comFly'M~ teportfng requfrements may result in cr~m[naJ fines, ¢[w3penalties, andabhor s~.ncffonsas providedby

//

Case 1:02-cv-00466-LB

Document 82-2

Filed 03/10/2006

Page 13 of 21

FEB-~I-~OOG14:~IG

DESC-G COUNSEL GENERAL |NFORM/~TION (Continued)

T03 ~GT 502~ P.05/!3

Provisions Regarding Con~dentiati~of Informa~on The information containedon thb form will be kept confidential andnot d~clos~l to the public to the extent that KsatJsiies the criteria for exemption underthe Freedom InformaSon of §552, the DOE regulaSons,10 C.F.R. §1004.11,imp~ement/ng FOIA, and the T~deSecrets Act, 18 lhe U.S.C. Uponreceipt of a request for this information under the FOIA, ~he DOE shall makea final determination whether the informatbn is ~empt from d~sclosure ]n ac~=e with ~e procedures and criteria provided in the regula~ons. To ~s[st us in th~s ~e~naSon, r~ponden~ should demonstra~ to ~e DOEtha~, for ex~p¢¢. ~e~r ~nfo~a~on cantons ~ad~ s~e~ or commer~alor financial information wh~erelease would be likely to cause ~u~anS~ ha~ to theircompany's competitive p~on. A le~er sc~mpanying ~e subm~sion ~at ~plai~ (on ~ elemenbby-e[em~t basis) ~h¢ reasons why the information would be tikely to ~us¢ the respondent sub~nt~a[ compe~veh~ if re[e~ed to ~e public would ~d in ~Ts dete~[nafon. A n~ ]u~t[on do~ not need ~o be provided each t~me ~nformatbnls submi~ed the fo~, if ~e company previously on ~s s~mi~ed a ju~Efi~on 1or ~ ~rmatbn an~ the j~catbn h~ not changed. Exceptas o]:herv~se pro~idedby law, the hfformat~onmay made be. avaiiable in response an order to of a Court of competentjurisdiction, or, uponrequest, to other components the DOE,to any of Committee Congress,the GeneralAccountingOff~ce, or other Congressionalagenciesauthorized of by law to receive suchinformation. D~taile~l provisions o1' the res~¢tbnson the disclosure of'this informalJencam found in the Policy on the Disclosureof lndMdually be ldenth'[a~le Energy Information in the Pc~esskm the EIA ot'

T~ avoid double coundnq,respondenb to exclude sales to other companies are (and their subsidiaries) whoalso report on ~e EIA-TB2A, lis~ of these companies provided periodicaI{~ to all respondents. A is Addili~naJ¢~pie~are available uponrequest. Reportall voium~s thousands gallons;, e.g., repor~ 6,500 gallons as 7, and6,400 9aJlonsas 6, Leave in ~[ both volumeand price blank ~f no volumeswere sold. Ent~ 1 forvolumesbetween and 1,499. Note: One 0 barrel is equalto 4~gallons, during the reference monthonly. Exclude from all calculations any Ill. Enter data ~eflec'Jng sales made mstedalprior per~,d adjustments~or volumesan~/or prices, and revise the report(s) ~or the appropriate prior per~od(s]o Revisionsto prior m~nth'sreports are required if previously reported prices or volume data are in error 5y m~rethan plus or m~nus ~ve Fercen~(5~), AtI revb~onsmust ~e submi~~i~in 120 d~ after the end the reference month. However,E~ must be no,Sad of si~ifi~nt ~angesd[s~vered a~er ~is date ~d will dete~ine~f a late resubm~sion r~U[~d. [s [30 not report negative volumes prices;, resubmit or eal'l~er repor~instead. Reportunit prices in decimalsof U.S. do[Iars, ~xpressed the nearestbnth of a cent: (e,g,, $1.065). Unit to prices are to be determined dMding total r~venu~s by the derived from the sales of the product during the reference monthby the total numberof galbn$ sold. ~e unit price [s th~ same~ ~e w~ghtedaverage price for afI sal~$ of ~hat pa~cul~ product to a particular group of customersor cl~s-of-~ad¢. The ~pa~ed un[~ pHc~ should exclude all ~ on ~e sale o~e pe~oleum pmdu~sU~ as Fede~, S~te, ~d local ~cise or ~es ~es. T~es in chaining, ~mpoding,or producing petroleum pr~u~ ('such a~ crude oil or p~du~impo~5onmr~s, demotic ¢~d~ o]1 l~es, ~ciliSes t~, etc.] should not ~e e~luded from

Case 1:02-cv-00466-LB

Document 82-2

Filed 03/10/2006

Page 14 of 21

FEB-21-28~6 14:49

DESC-6 COUNSEL GENERAL II~b-'TRU~--'TiONS(Continued)

993 969 5022 P, 06/i~

sales prices for EIA reporting purposes. For example, even though upstream e;~penses'suchas the Supsrfundtax maybe shown=¢ a separate lfne item on invoices of product sales, they should not be excluded from the reported sales price. TransportationcosL~ that are paid as part of the s~esprice at the point of sale should be ir~clUded in the reported unit price, Donot calculate unit price~ using rounded
vo[ume~.

Reportonly the data for the productsl~sted: DOE; not seekingi'ull Is sold,

coverage all peIroleum of products

Excludeamoun~ supplied to exchange partners e.~cept wl~ere the amount: given up exceedsthe amounl receivedandthe imbalance invoiced as a sa~aduring the referencemen,h, is ~1. If firms do not: maintain information sufficient to provide actua[ sales volumesandunit prices by the customer categories specified on ~e forms, estimates of saJ¢~volume.~andunit prices maybe provided. The basis for the eslimates must be consistentwith the standard accounEng records maintained by the firm. The estimating procedureand data supporting ~e estimates should r~sult In a reasonablyaccurate estimatewhichwill be subject to review, Report sales in the State wher~ trans-/er of title occurred.For FOB the sales at a relineryAermfnaJ, Sta~ the Is lhe onein whichthe refinery/terminal is located. For del'r~ered sales (by any mode conveyance), of the Stateis the onein which buyerreceivedthe product(see Appendix "~or a F~t: of Sta~abb~'eviations).Itthe A transfer of title occursin 1heUnitedStates, volumes sold far export shou{db~ included under=Whole-sale = Sales. Residualfuel oil sa/e~ for vessel bunkering shouIdbe reported under"Re~'l Sales.* No. Z distillate sal~s for vessel bunkeringshould be reported under*¢ommerc~al/lnstit~liona] Sales.* Reportthe entire firm's sates of the sele~ecl produ~ls. This includes sales, made d~rectly by ~e parent. affiliates, subsidiaries; or through commissioned agenls. Exclude sales m~de among parent ~irm, the subsidiar/es,anda~ffates; Le., ~ntraSrm transfers/sa|es. SPECIFIC INSTRUCTIONS ScheduleI Partl Iden~cation Dam item I thru 7 Ins_buclk~n_ ¢omplete items 1 thru 7 if you are a newrespondent~ if information shown the label is or on incomplete or incor:ect. If changes needto be mad=,cross outthe inappmpdat~ information on the label andenter the cermet informationin the s~ace(s)to the right at'the label. Enter the monf~ and year of the reference month. Oheck type of report that is beingsubmitted, Lhe 10 Enter the number Schedule pagessubmittedwith Schedule This will rellect the total of II I. number States for vchich reports are b~ingsubmitted. of En~rthe date this r~porl is being~led, Markthe appropriatetype of entity according the definitions provided.Refiners ope~tingin to mare than one capacity should made"Refiner/Gas Plant Operator." Firms engagingin both

Viii.

Case 1:02-cv-00466-LB

Document 82-2

Filed 03/10/2006

Page 15 of 21

FEB-21-2BB6 14:47

DESC-C, COUNSEl_ SPECIFICINSTRUC'~IONS (Continued)

703 76? 58?.2 P.07/13

reselling and reta~lin 9 shauld mark"Fi~sellerJRetaJler.= Firms which~E~or {ndire~y conEol a re,nat shoul~ m~ ~Refiner/G~ PI~I Operator.' ~s which d~y or ~n~ly ten.el gas plan~ operator should mark "RRflner/e~ Plant Operator.= The ~pe of en~ should change ~m mon~ to mon~5ut should re~ ~e ac5~ o~ lh~ 5rm througho~ ~a y~. Enf~rthe stak.ts n/: the firm at the end of the reference month..it me firm has been sold, leased, or perrnanentJy" ceased operat]on, auSm[.ta I~tter to DOE stat;ng the .¢eason the change for In status. If the firm has been sold or leased, proVide the nameand address of the new company, the date of the transfer. If the firm has parmanent[y and ceased operatfon, provide ~he date the ~rmcea~u=d operation. Youmayinclude the |ether with your mon~lyreport or sendit separately to the addressshown Page on 1. Schedule I Pa~ II Cer'dfication

l~,thru 17

Enter the name title of the indMdualdesignatedby lhecompany ~figa the ce~EcaLion. and to Theindividual mustsign in the space providedon the form andenter Ihe dale of the signinp. Schedule II Identificat~onData

Item

Instr~on Enter the name the reporting finn. of Emar 1g-digit |dentificalion number the assipned 1hereporting firm for ihLs survey. This Is to the number printed in the upper left comer the company of identification labels ~vhich have beenprovided to you. SequenLP~]Iy assign a page number each Schedule11 page. Enter ~le to~ number pa~es to of being submittedhn item 10 on Schedule I. Enter the mon~ year of the reference month and for wh/chthis schedule"m being submitted. CheckwheLher is aa or~g~n=lor revised rspod. this Enter the abbraviaEon ~a State. SeeAppend~ for a ]]st of Stat~ aI:~reviations, for A Schedule 11 P~ II1 Mon~h|y Sta~aSales of Finished Motor Gasoline

Item 7thru 9

Instruction =alI direct sales to end.users lhat Include ~n the columnheaded =Salesto Other End-Users were not made~rough company-operated retail outlets. Sales madeto retag outlets other tha~th~se~perated directly, by th~ tape.rig company, affiliates, or subsidiaries, shoul~l be its ~ncluded the who|esaJe in sates category"(~;atas for Resare). / H i'zge 4

Case 1:02-cv-00466-LB

Document 82-2

Filed 03/10/2006

Page 16 of 21

14: 47

DESC-GCOUNSEL

7B3 967 51322 P. 138/13

Repo~gasoline s~les volumesand prices by grade in accordancewith their ~sifica~on at Ihe time of sale, Tnefn~nt of this formis to capturesales volumes prices for gasolinesold and as leadedregular, unleaded regular, premium (both leadedand unleaded), anda "mldgrade" unleadedgasoline that lies betWeen unleadedregular andpremium both octaneand price. in For the majority of the United ~tales, the octane ranges(R+M/2)below are appropriate for dls~nguishingamong tour classes of gasoline Io be repo~ted: the Leaded Regular-Greaterthan or equal to 87, andless than or equal, to ~0 ~ct~ne. Unleaded Regular- Gre~ter than or equal to 85, buHess 86 octane. ~,n Unleaded lVtldSradeo Equalto, or grealer than BS,but less l~an, or equalt~ 90 octane. Premium Greater than 90 omane, leaded or unleaded. In general, aut~motiveoctane requirementsare lower at high altitudes. Therefore, {n some areas of the United States, such as the RockyMountain~tates, the octane ranges for the gasolir~e grades abovemaybe 2 or moreoctane poin~ lower. For other aspects ot gasoline sped~fications, pleasesee the Def~nltions s~ct~on. Blends of gasotine containing ethanol or other oxygenates should be reported accordingto ~e abovecriteri~. Donot ~eportethanol (~¢ohol) soId separatelyfor blendingpurposes. Schedule II Parity Monthly Sta~ Sales No.2 Distil[ales lnst~on 10and11 Report volumea~d price data in accordancew~hwhat the pr~lu¢~ wassold as, regardless of ~e a~ual speclfl~tIon~ of ~nt p~du~If a No. 2 disSllate w~ sold as a repo~ ~at~lume Rrlce ~a calego~ ~d JR "No.2 Di~el F~el;" a No,2 d~llate sold if ~s a headng fuel oil, repo~ ~at volume~d pric~in ~e catego~=N~. 2 Fuer Oit = even if or product ~n~o~ed ~e higher spe~ca~o~ a diesel fuel. I~ s~ of a No. 2 dis~llate were to of made for whlch no d~ermina~on ~ be made ~ b whe~er ~e produ~ ~s speci~Ily sold as ei~er a fuel oil or di~eI Iuel, sal~ volum~ and pric~ shouId be cl~ed in ~ord~nca with your beet estimate of th~ intended u~ or the product regard/ess of the product specifica~on; i.e,, ~[~ of No, 2 ~sS~ate~tyou bdieve ~11 be ~ed for headn pu~osesor 9 as a boiler fuel should be reposedunder "No. 2 Fuel Oil," s~as of No. 2 distillate ~at you bdieve will be used ~ ~po~on ~els shouI~ be reposed ~ "No, 2 DI~ Fuel," Include under category =Residential Sales" those sales of No. ~- fuel oilto individual the customers or households opposedlo businesses or institutions). (as Sal~ Io ap~men~ buildings/cgmplexes or o~er mulE.f~ily dwelling? should 5e exoluded ~am~e =Res~denS~ S~es" catego~ but include~ in ~e "~mmerciai~onal S~" ¢atego~. For ~ese to residential facil[~ for which the respondentis u~sur~as ~ where~esesales ar~ to be reported, responden~are ~ked ~ repo~ those sales in the category that, in their judgment, ~ more Include underthe c~tegory"Commercial,qnstilutlonal S~les"thosesales of either No. 2 fuel oil or No. 2 diesel fuel I;~ firms engaged transportation, wholesale ret~il ~rade, finance, in or insuranceand real estate. Also include sales to apar{mentbuildirtgsJccmplexes, and other multi-family dwellings,hotels arid office buildings or comple.~es, s~lesto local, Stateor Federal

Case 1:02-cv-00466-LB

Document 82-2

Filed 03/10/2006

Page 17 of 21

Govemmenlal "facilities or erganiza~ons, along wffh military sales inelUd~ng thosedirected to post exchanges, Sales ta schools, hospitals, religious |nstltutlan~, universities or other gevernment-supporled organizationsare al~o ta be included in this category. Includeunder~e category=Industrial Sales" those8ales of eilher No, ~ fuel oil or No. ~ diesel fuel to pub~= private firms engaged mining, construction, or manufacturing, or in = Include under the category" "Sales Through Company-Operated Ret~u] Ougets those ~ales of ¯ No, ~ diesel fuel made through company-operated retell outlets which are subject to motor fuel gaJlonage ta~es. Refer t~ the deBnidon company-operated out~fts. of reta~ Include underthe category"Sales to OtherEnd-Users" (e.g., sales to agricultural customers or to ub3ities) sales of either Nu,2 luel o~ or No, 2 diesel fuel to end.use customers included not in anyof th~ above four categories, Schedule I1 F'arIM MonthlyState SaJes of Other PetroleumProducts l~Ir~clion 12 thru 19 Includeunder category the ~Retall Sales"all direct satesto eald.users. Include underthe category%VholesaJe Sa~es" s=les to resollem, all

DEFINITIONS AfiilialelSubsidia:)r- Entities directJyor indirectly controlledby a parent, A..__~__~ Theacronym the Amori~Surety for Testing andMat~dal~, far Aviafion GasoEne (Finished) - All special gradesof gasoline for use in aviation reciprocating engines, as given in ASTM Specification D 910 and Military Specification MIL-C--S572, Excludesblending components which will be used in blending or compounding into finished aviation gasoline. Commefciaf//nstituEonalFirms engaged transportation, ~holesaleor retail trade, finance, in insurance, and real estate, Also included ~re apartment buildings/complexes and other multi-family dwellings, holels, and office buildings or ~omplexes, local, Stale or Federal faciii#es or organizatiarzs including ~e military, schools, hespi~Is, religious institutions, universities andall other g~vemment-supported organizations. ~o__mpa_nlr_-O~erated Outlet - Anyretail outlet {e.g., ~ervicestation) solllng gasolineor Retail diesel fuel w~ich under direct ¢ontJ'elc/the tfrm filing this report by virtue ofthe abaft'y" ~o is the set the retail productprice anddirectly collect oJl er part of t~ retail margin."This category includes retail outlets: (1) being operatedby salaried employee9 the company of and/or its subsidlaries andaffiliates, and/or (2) invoMng personnelservicescontractedby 1he~rm. Di~tillafe Fuel Oil- A general classification for one~f the petroleum fractions produced in conventionaldistillation operations, it is usedprimarily for spaceheating, ow ~d off.h~ghway ~ diesel engine fuel (includin~railroad engine ~el ~d fuel for agricultur~ machine~),and

/o"

Case 1:02-cv-00466-LB

Document 82-2

Filed 03/10/2006

Page 18 of 21

14:48

DQSC-6 COUNSEL

703 767 5022 R, 10/i3

power genemS~n. Included product~ are known No. 1, No,2, andNo. ~s No.I,No.2, andN~.4 di~fuels. which nle~s b~e speoifi~o~ iar No. 1 Heating or ~or ~e ~p~ff~n~ far No. ~ Oi~el Fuel ~ ~ef[ned

N (i}o. T Diasel Fuel -

A volaLffe d[stWatefuel oil with a boiling rangebetween 3O0-S75"F and used in h[flh-speed diesel engines generally operated under wide variations in speed and toad, Includes type C~-EI diesel f~e! used for ~fb] buses and similar opera~ons. Properties ~re defined in ASTM Spec~ec~:~/ion E) 97~. Fuel Oi!. A ~ghtdistillate fuel o1[ ~ntended use in v~oor~n9 for pot-type burne~. ASTM Spe~5~on D 39~ spec~ for ~is grade m~um K~II~ temporaries of 400=Fat the 10-percent point and S50=Fat the 9O-percant point, and k[nema~c ~s~oS~ baleen 1.4 ~d ~2 ~okaa at I~'F,

N~. 2 OisEllate - A petroleum d~t/lla(e which mee~~e spac~onsfor No, fi Heating o~ Fuel Oil ~ defined ~ AfiTM D ~6 ~d/or ~a sp~5~Uans for No. ~ D~el Fuel ~ dashed in ASTMS~ca~on D 975.

O) N_o. 2 Diesel Fuel -

A gas oil type distillate o! lower volatility with distillation temperaturesat ~e 90-percent point between .~O.$dO'Ffor ~e ~n h~gb-spead diesel e~gines gener~ly ope~t~ under un~o~ speed and load ~ndl~ons. In~udes Type R-R d~el ~el ~sed for tailr~d lo¢=mo~ve engines, ~d Type T-T for di~e[-eng~ne ~cks. Prope~ ~e defined ~n AS~ Spe~on D 976. |Uel off for use in atomizingtype burners for heating or for moderate cape=fly ~ommerc~al-~ndustrial b:;rner units. ASTM SpaciScaSon ~6 species for ~s grade di~la~a~ lempara[ures at ~e ~0.parcant D point baleen 540"F and 64D'F, and kinematic v~cositias baleen 2.0 and 3.6 ~n~ok~ at

(2) No. 2 Fuel 0I~ o A distillate

No, 4 Fuel - A fuel oil [or commercial burner installations not equipped with preheating facilities. It ~sused@xtansively indust~al in plants. gradeis a blendd~st/llat~ fuel o~ Th~s of and res[dua~ fuel o~l stoc~s that conforms to ASTM @pecifica¢~onD 396 or FederaJ SpecificaEon W-F-81~C; its kinematic v;scosity is be~een5.8 and 26.4 cenSstokesat 100"F. Also included is No. 4-D, a fuel oli for low- andmedium.pearl d~ese(enginesthat conforms to ASTM Spec~cationD ~75. Fin~shedMotorGasaline.A complex mixture of relat~ve|y volatile hydrocarbons, wffh or without small quantRies additives, blendedta form a fuel suRable use in spark-ignition of for engines.Specification ?or motor9asoI~ne as 9k~enin ASTM Specification 13 439-BB Federal or , ~pech~catJan W-G-1690B, include a buffing rangeof 17.?.° to 158°Fat the 10-percentpoint to ° 365 tc 374°Fat the 9a-percentpoint anda Rddvapor pressurer~ngef~om9 to 15 psi. "Motor gasoffne° ~ncludes finTshed leaded ~asol~ne, finished unleadedgasoSne,and gasohol, 8lendstockis e~cludeduntil blending has beencompleted. (Alcohol lhet is to be usedin the b[encling of gesohol aIso excluded,) L~ Leadedf~egufarGasolfne - Gas01in~having an ant~nockindex (R+M/2)greater than equal to 87 and less than or equa! to 90, and containing morethan 0.05 gram~ lead or of 0.00S gramsof phosphanJ~ gallon. per

Case 1:02-cv-00466-LB

Document 82-2

Filed 03/10/2006

Page 19 of 21

FEB-21-2B06 14:49

DESC-GCOUNSEL DERN|TIONS (Con~nued}

7@3 767 5@22 P. 11/13

U~_n/eadedRequ]ar GasoEne.G~ol[ne h~ng ~ ~o~ inde~ ~) greater Ihan or equ~to 85 ~d I~s ~an 88, and ~n~[ning not mor~th~ 0.05 g~ of le~ or 0.005 g~s of phospho~ per g~bn. Unleaded M[dqrade GasoF~neGasoline o havingan antiknockindex(R+MJL0 greater or equalt~ eel and|Essthanor equa~ 90, andcontaining more to not tllan 0.o5 9rams lead or 0.005gram~ phosphorus g~lon. of per Premium Gasoline-Gasoline having an antiknock index (R+M/2)greater than 90. lneludes bo~LEADED premTurn g~so]ineas well a~ UNLEADED premium gasoline. Leaded Premium G~oEneGasoline havingan antiknockindex {R÷M./2) grea[er than 90. and con~a[nlng moret~an 0.05 grams lead or 0.005grams phosphorus of of per ga.q~n. Premium Gaso/ine-Gasolinehavln9 an an~knocR index (R+M]~)greater (~) Un/eaded than 90, and ¢~h~ining ~ot moreth~n o.o5 gramsot lead or 0,005 gramsof ph~p~ ~r gallon.

Note;For ~is survey,gasolinesales shouldbe reportedby gradein accordance their with class~catbrt the timeof sob.In general, at automol~ve octan~ requirements lowera~high are aJfitudes.Therefore, some [r~ areasof~eUnitedS[stes, suchas 1,he Rocky Mount~n States, ~eoctane ranges t~e gasoline for grade~ above be ~- or mere may octane po~n~s lower.

~ - Any' a~ciation, company, corporatbn,estate, ~ndMdua6 joint-venture, partnership, or sole proprietorship or any other entity, however organized, including charitable. educat~onal, ot~ercharitableinsStuSons, the Federal or ~nd government includTng operations, depm~-nents, Federal agenc[~, o~hertnstrumental~-es, State andlocal governments. and end Gas P/antQ.peratar Any firm, includinga gaspla.n~owner, which operates gasplant and a ~;e~ps gasplantrecords. g~splant Is~ fac='li~ in which th~ A naturalgasF~tu~ds separated are fromnatural gas,or in whbh naturalgasl~quldsare fract~onate~ othe~,Sse or separated ~nto natural g~liquid products both. or 10. Gasoho.l A blend of~inishedmotorgasoline~eaded unleaded) alcohol (generally or and etha~no! sometimes bu~ methanol)., I~m~d 10 percentby volume ~c~hoL the purpose to of For ofthis survey report gasoholthe grade gasol~ne in of inwhich sold. [tw~ /ndu~tr[~- ~rms engaged mining,construction,or m~mufacturing. in Kero.~ene A petroleum d~Jllat~ that h~s a maximum ~st~ll~t~ontemperate ~1 degrees of F ~t ~e lmper~ntracove~ point, a ~nal boiling point of 57~~ag~ anda minimum P, point of ~00 degm~ InclUded ~e ~e ~o cl~s~ca~o~~eco~edby AS~~pec~ca~on F. D 3~9: No. 1-K ~d No. 2-~ ~d a~ gmd~ kerosene ~ c~lled ~geor s~oveell which have ptope~ s~mi[m ~ No. 1 fu~ o~ but w~ ~ gm~of ~o~ ~" API ~d a m~imum o~ 625"F. ~rosene used [n spacehea~ers,cook stov~, ~d w~t~ h~ers ~d b suit~le is for use ~ ~ i~[um~n~t~enbum~in ~ck l~ps,

11.

Case 1:02-cv-00466-LB

Document 82-2

Filed 03/10/2006

Page 20 of 21

14=49

DESC-GCOUNSEL DEFINITIONS (Continued}

?E~3?67 5E}2_2 P, 12//-3

KeJc~sene.type Fuel - A qu~ity kerosenepmductwith~ maximum Jet d~sb-Ilat~on temperature of 400 degreesF ~t the 10-percentrecovery point anda final rnaxJmum boiling point of 572 degreesF. The fuel ~s des[gnatecl in ASTM Specification 01655and Military Spec~ficatlon MIL-T-5624L (Grades JP-5 andJP-8), A relatively low-freezJng point cffstilTaie ol: the kerosene type usedprirna]i|y for ¢ornmerc'~] turbo]el andturbopropa~rcraft engines. 14. 15. Pamn__~t "firm that direddyor indirectly conkols - A a.nather enSb]. P.rapane, Consumer Grade- A normally gaseous paraJ13niccompound (C.~Ho}, whleh includes .all products covered by Natural Gas Policy Act Specifications for commereia~ HD-5 and propane and ASTM Specification D proT=anes class~fiec[ ssc~nsurnergrade propanes,includin91he propaneporlion of any not natu~ gas I~quid mixes, Reference Month - The calendar month and year t~ which the reported cost, price, end volume L~Tormat/on reTat~s. R~Fzner. f~rm or the part. ol'a f~rm that refines productsor blends ~'~d subst~[ally changes A ~ts. or m~nes~iqu~ hydrocarbons "from o~l ~nd gas fieldgases, Or recovers liqum3~d peb'oTeum gases incident to petro|eum reEningandsells 1hose productsto resellers, ret~u'lers, reseller/ret.~ilers or ulLirnate consumers. "Refiner" incTudesany ownerof products which contracts to havethose products relined and then sells the ret~nec~products to resellers, re~[ers, or ui~rnate consumers. Rese/[er- A lirm (other than a refiner) that carries on the trade or businessof purchasing refine~] p~t[o~eum produc(~ reselling} ~o l~urc:[".ssers o~erthan uff]rn~t~ consurne~. ~md them Resel[erAReJailerA lirm (other than a refiner) that carries on the ~-ade business or activities both a reseller anda retailer;, i.e., purchasing refined petroleum productsandreseliing them to purchaserswhomay either ultimate or ether than ul6rnate consumers. be :20. Res[dentlal. In cases~f sales of No. 2 Fuel Oil, includes ind~v/~fual customers households or (~ opp~s~ ~ h~~n~ or (n~ons) ~ho o~Ty use ~e ~el ~n ~ r~idenc~ ~s apa~ment build~ngslcomplexeaor to other multi.f~mJly dwellings are exclude~ from the "R~den~al Sales" eatego~ and ~e ~ncluded ~n ~e "Commer~~on~ S~ ~t~a~_ ,Re~,idualFUe~ O~i[s - Thetoppedcrudeof rel]ner] operations, whichincludes No. 5 andNo. 6 fuel oils as del]ned ~n A~TM Speciffr_.~on D 396 and Federal ~pecff~c~l~onW-Fo815G, Navy Spec~aJ fuel o~I as de,ned in Mil|tmy Specilicalion MIL-F-859E including Amendrnent (NATO Z ~ymbolF-77), ~nc[ BunkerG fuel ~l. R~duaT tuei o~! is u~edTot ~heproduction of electdc power,spaceheating, vessel bunkefin~, andvar[ou~ in~ust~a~purp~ses. FCet~Te.......~r Afirm (otherthana refiner, reseller, or reseller/m~'ter) carriesonthe tcacle that businessof p~rch~sing rel~nedpetroleum producL~ reselling thorn (o ulllrnate cormurners. and Sa/e- Thetransfer of ~{t~e from the s~ler to a buyerfor a price. EXCLUDE: tnt~J~rm transfers, product consumed ¢[ire~Jy by the reporting ~rrn, or sales of hot(tied fuel. Also exclude product~ del[vered/lo~ted to eXc/~ange paltners excepl:whereffze amount ~g~cen exceeds up the amount receivedandthe diffet'ant~ ;s invo;ced ~s a sale during ths referencemonth,

16.

17.

21.

/7

Case 1:02-cv-00466-LB

Document 82-2

Filed 03/10/2006

Page 21 of 21

14:49

DESC-G COUNSEL

7~3 767 5E~22 P.IZ/IZ

UnFed Slat(is-"The 50 States andthe District of Columbia.

APPENDIX A

LIST OF STANDARD STATEABBREVIATIONS

AL ... AI<..., AZ... AR ... CA, .., CO,.. CT .., DE ,.. E~G...

Alabama ~daska Ar~zorm Arkar~as OaI~fomia Colorado Connect/cut DeI~a~e DL~I/~ o{ Oolumhia

NO ,., North OH,.. Ohio OK ,,. OF; ... RI ... Rhodebland ~C ... Sou~ C~ot~a SD ... So~ D~o~ TN ,.. Te~S~ ~,.. T~ ~.., U~

H1 ,,. (O ... IL... IN ... IA ... KS ...

H~wa~ Idaho [IIino~s indiana Iowa Kar~a~

~ ...

Wyombg

TOTAL P,13