Free Motion to Supplement the Administrative Record - District Court of Federal Claims - federal

Case 1:07-cv-00210-EGB

Document 44

Filed 05/31/2007

Page 1 of 17

In the United States Court of Federal Claims
) SOUTHERN FOODS, ) INCORPORATED, ) ) Plaintiff, ) ) BID PROTEST v. ) No. 07-210C ) Judge Bruggink THE UNITED STATES, ) ) Defendant, ) ) and ) ) U.S. FOODSERVICE, INCORPORATED, ) ) Intervenor. ) ) PLAINTIFF'S MOTION TO SUPPLEMENT THE ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD AND MEMORANDUM IN SUPPORT OF THE MOTION TO SUPPLEMENT Pursuant to RCFC 7(b)(1) Plaintiff Southern Foods, Incorporated (Southern Foods) herewith Moves to Supplement the Administrative Record.

Case 1:07-cv-00210-EGB

Document 44

Filed 05/31/2007

Page 2 of 17

Southern Foods asks that the Administrative Record be supplemented with the "Competitive Pricing Guide" attached to this Motion. This Competitive Pricing Guide is a comparison of the pricing under Southern Foods predecessor Contract for United States Service Area 10 with the pricing of three Orders placed by Fort Campbell under U.S. Foodservice's successor Contract for United States Service Area 10. This Competitive Pricing Guide uses Southern Foods prices in effect through March 31st, 2007. In fact, the prices proposed by Southern Foods for the successor Contract, the successor Contract now awarded to U.S. Foodservice, are approximately one percent lower. What this Competitive Pricing Guide shows is that Southern Foods' pricing, as compared U.S. Foodservice's pricing, is in fact lower for two of the three Orders placed by Fort Campbell under U.S. Foodservice's successor Contract for United States Service Area 10. Nowhere is there the difference in the pricing between Southern Foods and U.S. Foodservice that is predicted by the Market Basket used for price evaluation purposes. Administrative Record, at 1910 through 1911. How can this be?

-2-

Case 1:07-cv-00210-EGB

Document 44

Filed 05/31/2007

Page 3 of 17

The answer, quite simply, is that the Contract proposed by Solicitation Number NAFBA1-06-R-0016 requires that the Contractor provide each ordering activity (here, Fort Campbell and Fort Knox) a price book or individual price sheets which "must be a true reflection of the items normally or regularly ordered by the activity." Administrative Record, at 50. This price book has, and these price sheets have, no relation to the Market Basket used for price evaluation purposes. Yet it is from this price book and these price sheets that ordering activities place Orders. It now turns out that the successor Contracting Officer's re-determination is a trade-off between Southern Foods' "impressive" (her words) technical and management proposal and her perception (under the Market Basket price analysis) that U.S. Foodservice is offering better prices. Administrative Record, at 1912. The problem is that her perception does not match reality, reality which is demonstrated by the Competitive Pricing Guide. And without consideration of the Competitive Pricing Guide, this Administrative Record is impermissibly skewed by perception, not reality. There are only a few, limited instances in which an Administrative Record may be supplemented prior to ruling on the merits. These follow: -3-

Case 1:07-cv-00210-EGB

Document 44

Filed 05/31/2007

Page 4 of 17

(1) when agency action is not adequately explained in the record before the court; (2) when the agency failed to consider factors which are relevant to its final decision; (3) when an agency considered evidence which it failed to include in the record; (4) when a case is so complex that a court needs more evidence to enable it to understand the issues clearly; (5) in cases where evidence arising after the agency action shows whether the decision was correct or not; (6) in cases where agencies are sued for failure to take action . . . and (8) in cases where relief is at issue, especially at the preliminary injunction stage. Cubic Applications, Inc. v. United States, 37 Fed. Cl. 339, 342 (1997) quoting Esch v. Yuetter, 876 F.2d 976, 991 (D.C. Cir. 1989). Esch recognizes that supplementation of an existing Administrative Record is often appropriate where the issue is whether all relevant factors were considered, whether there was "at least an effort to get both sides of the story," whether a party got its "procedural just due." Esch, 876 F.2d at 993. A trade-off made only on a Market Basket price analysis which has no relation to the price book/price sheets actually used for Contract performance is a trade-off made on an impermissibly skewed Administrative Record: The agency may not skew the record in its favor by excluding pertinent but unfavorable information. Envtl. Def. Fund v. Blum, 458 F. Supp. 650, 661 (D.D.C. 1978). Nor may the agency exclude information on the grounds that it did not "rely" on the excluded information in its final deci-

-4-

Case 1:07-cv-00210-EGB

Document 44

Filed 05/31/2007

Page 5 of 17

sion. Ad Hoc Metals Coalition v. Whitman, 227 F. Supp. 2d 134, 139 (D.D.C. 2002); Amfac Resorts, 143 F. Supp. 2d at 12. . . . The Fund for Animals v. Williams, 391 F. Supp. 2d 191, 199 (D.D.C. 2005), citing Environmental Defense Fund v. Blum, 458 F. Supp. 650, 661 (D.D.C. 1978). Who can say that consideration of the lack of any relation between the price book/price sheets used for Contract performance and the Market Basket price analysis was not "an important aspect of the problem"? Motor Vehicle Manufacturers Asso. of the United States, Inc. v. State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Co., 436 U.S. 29, 43 (1983). This Administrative Record should now be supplemented in order to ensure proper Administrative Procedure Act, 5 U.S.C. § 706(2)(A), review. Ad Hoc Metals Coalition v. Whitman, 227 F. Supp. 2d. 134, 138-39 (D.D.C. 2002) (extra-record materials which reflected adverse information, were directly related to the issue decided, and were known to the Agency are properly admitted for Administrative Procedure Act judicial review, 5 U.S.C. §§ 702, 706(2)(A)); Public Citizen v. Heckler, 653 F. Supp. 1229, 1237 (D. D.C. 1986) (documents known to the Agency at the time of the decisionmaking, documents directly related to the decision made,

-5-

Case 1:07-cv-00210-EGB

Document 44

Filed 05/31/2007

Page 6 of 17

and documents adverse to the Agency's position properly admitted for judicial review). Respectfully submitted, /s/ Cyrus E. Phillips, IV Cyrus E. Phillips, IV District of Columbia Bar Number 456500, Virginia State Bar Number 03135 May 31st, 2007 1828 L Street, N.W., Suite 660 Washington, D.C. 20036-5112 Telephone: Facsimile: Electronic Mail: (202) 466-7008 (202) 466-7009 [email protected]

Attorney of record for Plaintiff, Southern Foods, Incorporated.

-6-

Case 1:07-cv-00210-EGB

Document 44

Filed 05/31/2007

Page 7 of 17

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify, under penalty of perjury, that on Thursday, May 31st, 2007 a true and complete copy of this Plaintiff's Motion to Supplement the Administrative Record and Memorandum in Support was filed electronically via the Court's Electronic Case Filing System, through which notice of this filing will be sent to: Joan Margaret Stentiford-Ulmer, Esq. Electronic Mail: [email protected]

Attorney of record for Defendant, U.S. Army Family and Morale, Welfare, and Recreation Command. I also certify, under penalty of perjury, that on Thursday, May 31st, 2007 a true and complete copy of this Plaintiff's Motion to Supplement the Administrative Record and Memorandum in Support was filed electronically via the Court's Electronic Case Filing System, through which notice of this filing will be sent to: John J. Pavlick, Jr., Esq. Electronic Mail: [email protected]

Attorney of record for Intervenor, U.S. Foodservice, Incorporated. /s/ Cyrus E. Phillips, IV Cyrus E. Phillips, IV

-7-

Case 1:07-cv-00210-EGB

Document 44

Filed 05/31/2007

Page 8 of 17

ATTACHMENT

Case 1:07-cv-00210-EGB

Document 44

Filed 05/31/2007

Page 9 of 17

COMPETITIVE PRICING GUIDE
Southern Foods Inc.
117 Mitch McConnell Bowling Green, KY 42101 270-843-1121 www.southernfoodsinc.com

Foods

Southern

Southern Foods Inc.
Uem#
1231300

usn Order # 3
Qty
4
3

Pack Size
4 .5 LB LB
3 'f
LB

Brand
TAfYlPA BAY LAMB WESTO NUGGET NUGGET ARDfl.IORE LENDERS

Description
SHRIMP, POPS BREADED 60-80CT FRENCH FRY, OVEN QUlK CANOLA 23L .CORN, ON COB FANCY FRZ
-

Qty E
N

Price
$
26~

----$ 107.92
$ 59,.70

Total

Price
$ 27.66

Total
$ 110.64
$ 52.59 $ 51.39

Savings
$ $ -7.11

6

3 N

$ 19.90 $ 16.

$ 17.53
$ 17.13 $ 18.64 $ 11.36

1723400
1739900 11350

96

3 N
1 N

$ 48.60 $ 19.42 $ 22.44

3
1 2 1
1

VEGETABLE BLEND, ITALIAN FRZ JUICE. APPLE INDV CUP FRZ 41381 BAGEL, CINNAMON RAISIN SLD 2.30 PASTA SHEETS. LASAGNA PRECOOKED WAFFLE STIX, BELGIAN BULK 200/210 COTTAGE CHEESE, SMALL CURD REG MILK, I % CHOCOLATE 03105 MILK, 1% REDUCED FAT 00490 MILK. 1% STRAWBERRY 3308 *S/O CUCUMBERS. FRESH BEANS. MIXED/SHORT CUT GREEN CHIPS, TORTILLA TOSTITOS BULK PAK CHIPS, LAY'S REGULAR VEND PAK 11045 CRACKERS. CLUB 0 I032 SNACK BAR. RICE KRISPIE TREATS MAYONNAfSE.. POUCH 4410560516 Page I

19.42

$

.64

$ -.

96

4 02

2 N

2141400
4 02

1 N
1 N

$ 15.12
$ 14.59

$ 15.12
$ 14.59

$ 14.43
$ 16.04

$ 14.43
$ 16.04

$ $

-~

ROTANELLI CHEF AMERI PRAIRIE FA SOUTHERNB SOUTHERN B SOUTHERN B FLORIDA NUGGET RED LAY'S

l~

2168000 3

144

1 OZ

1

$ 19.93

$ 19.93 $ 15.06

1

$ 19.06
$ 6.21

$ 19.06

$ -.87

LB
50 HF

z
10

y
N

$ 7.53
$ 8.15
$ 8.00

$ 12.42
$ 81.50
$ 65.
$ 32.60

$ -2.

3178600

$ 81.50
$ 64.00
$ 32.60 $ 5.

10 8

$ 8.15
$ 8 ..15

50

HF

8 N
N

$ 1.-20

3178800

50
1

HF
5 LB

$

8~15

$ 8.15

3231200

1 N
1 N
N

$ 5.72
$ 15.

1 1
4

$ 7.28
$ 14.63
$

$ 7,
$ 14.63
S . 5

3614600
4731700

tHO
5 16 OZ

$ 15.48

$ 5.96

5.54
$

.16
~75

$-1.

4733700 4827000

104
300
80

1 OZ
2eT
1. 3 02

LAY'S
KEEBLER KELLOGG'S UNIPRO

3 N

$ 22.55

$ 67.65, $ 8.06

3
1

$ 21.25

$-3.

1 N
1 N
1

$ 8.06
$ 28.94
$ 16.94

$ 12.98
$ 30.61

$ 12.

$ 28.94
1

920700

500

12

$ 18.91

$ 18.91

S 1.97

Case 1:07-cv-00210-EGB

Document 44

Filed 05/31/2007

Page 10 of 17
USB Order # 3

Southern Foods Inc.
Item #
4

Pack Size
.5GR

Brand
UNrPRO PORTION PA
LAWRY'S

Description
t\1USTARD. YELLOW POUCH 44105605 ! 0 00-13-970

Qty E
1 N 1 N 1 N

Price
$ 5.28

Total
$ 5.28

Qty
1 1 1

Price
$ 2.98

Total

Savings

4952000 5096000

100 6

L 5 OZ 9 OZ

SYRUP. PANCAKE POUCH SEASONING. TACO
110

$ 6.25 $ 17.55
$ 17.55

$ 4.44

$ 4.

s

-1~

1

$ 9.63 ($11.99)

Your Total Savings

($11.99)

Page 2

Case 1:07-cv-00210-EGB
u"\ve""

SUMl'MRY

Document 44
Reserved

Filed 05/31/2007
Estimated Price:
Total une Items:

Page 11 of 17
$684.60

Ordered

Total Cases: Total Eaches

53
2

:53

22

ORDER DETAILS

"',-

::1;_

LINE

DESCRIPTION
CHEESE, COTT S~l CURD 4% BTRFT(5340864 ) CHIP, PTATO REG PLN SS

BRAND
GLNVW
FRMS

Pfne:::
4/.5 LB 104/10Z
5/1602

ORDERED
FULL/PART

RESERVED
PART

104 140
146

$24.83 CS $21.25 CS
$554 CS

0/2 3/0
4/0

0/2
3/0
4/0

28)
CHIP, TORTLA RND CR5PY BULK

LA'tS
TOSTITOS

(5098397)
COHN ON COB, 3" PTlTE DMSK

164
186
267

(4328118)
CRACKER, SALAD ClUB(3015054) JUICE, APPl 100% FZN PLST CUP (1117647) MAYONNAISE, POUCH 5S

HONARCH KEEBLER
ARDMORE

96 EA
300/2 EA
96/402 500/12
GR

$17.13 C5
$12.98 CS
$11.36

3/0
I/O 2/0 1/0 I/O

3/0
I/O
2/0

FM
US BLUE

es

298
341

$18.91 CS

I/O
I/O

PASTA, SHEET 40 CT CKD PLN FZN (8329211)
POTATO, FF CC CNTNA OVBL THIN

ROSEll
CAN0 LA.

10 LB

$16.04 $1

cs
CS

(3014594)
45.5
SEASONING, TACO NIX FOIL PKT

6/4
6/90Z

3/0

SPC ClSIC
BELGN

$9.63 CS

I/O
I/O

I/O
1/0

WAFFLE, STICK FZN BELGfiJI'l (2041414)

CHEF PI.';CKER
PACKER PACKER

144 EA
PT .5 Pi

558
559

t'lILK, CHOC 1% PROCD (6726)

NINI

$8,15 CS $8.15 CS

10/0
4/0

10/0

NILK, STWBY LOW FAT (375766 )
1'1llK, LOW FAT 1'10 REF( BEAN, GRN CUT MIX

REF

4/0

EA
10
eN

15 es
$14.63

8/0 1/0
I/O

8/0
I/O

SHORT

HARVEST
VL t'10NARCH BLUEWATER

(4328647)
VEGETABLE BLEND, ITLN FZN (8328296)

es

20 lB
4/3 LB

$18 . 64 CS $27.66 CS

1/0
4/0

SHRIl>1P, BRDD RAW 60-100 Il'ilT
( 139<5639)
SYRUP, TABLE

4/0

POUCH 5S

4/1

Order Confirmation

2

')

(5333919) BAGEL, elN RAT 2.3 Z SLeD T&5 (395293)
SNACK BAR, RICE KRSPS CHOC

AMERICANA 100/1 02 HILLTOP HR KELLOGG'S
US BLUE PACKER

$4.44 es $14.43 cs $30.61 es

I/O I/O I/O I/O I/O

I/O I/O
1/0

12/6 PK

(1279439) MUSTARD, YLW SS(432931'~) CUCUMBER, FRESH(9013566)

80/1.3

02 200/55 GR
24 EA

$2,98 CS
$7.28 CS

1/0
1/0

<-"/p... J<~

Prices shown above are estimates only. Actual pnces will lie reflected on your invoice. Thank you for your order!

Case 1:07-cv-00210-EGB

Document 44

Filed 05/31/2007

Page 12 of 17

COMPETITIVE PRICING GUIDE
Southern Foods Inc.
I 17 Mitch McConnell Bowling Green, KY 42101 270-843-1121 www.southemfoodsmc.com

Foods

Southern

Southern Foods Inc. Item #
1000

USFI Order # 2
Qty
4

Pack Size
136 2.4 OZ
150 CT
48 4 02

Brand
CiRCLE.Z HlLLSHIRE STATE FAIR STATE FAiR

Description
BEEF PATTY. CHARBROILED 80 I24CN

E
4 N
N

Price
$ 40.
$ 33.57

Total
$ 162.80

Price

Total

Savings

0736500
0832600

BACON. SUCED CENTER PIECE FIC FRZ CORN DOGS. TURKEY CN LABEL 09488 BREAKFAST STIX. ORIGINAL 70481

$

.57

1
3

$ 29.82
$ 16.40

$ 29.

3 N
1 N 10 N
$ 15.79

0834000 0977000
0979500 1373000 1637000 1723400 2115200 2141100 250 60
96

$ 15.79 $ 193.

1 10
1

$ 18.34

$ 18.

.68 OZ 3.53
4. 5 OZ

TYSON TYSON TONY'S LAMB WESTO NUGGET

CHICKEN NUGGETS. CHUNKS BRD CHICKEN BREAST. PATTY BRD F/CKD PIZZA, PEPPERONI 4X6 78455

$ 19.39

$ 21.31

$ 213.10 $ 23.07

s

1 N
4 N
$ 41.72 $ 166.88

4

$ 40.00
$ 17.53

$ 160.00
$ 52.59

s

-6.88

6

.J LB

FRENCH FRY. OVEN QUIK CANOLA 23L CORN. ON COB PA.NCY

3 N
4 N

$ 59.70 $ 64.80 $ 29.95

3
4

$ -7.

96
216 2.2 OZ 2.3 OZ 72
5

s

17.13

$ 68.52 $ 26.

$

PILLSBURY LENDERS RICH'S NUGGET BLA ROTANELLI CHEF AMERI PACKER PRAIRIE FA SOUTHERN B

BISCUIT DOUGH. SOUTHERN STYLE 6252 BAGEL. PLAIN SLICED 00027 CINNAMON BUN. JUMBO 14123 FRZ FRENCH TOAST, STICKS 0268 PASTA SHEETS. LASAGNA PRECOOKED WAFFLE ST!X. BELGIAN BULK 2001210 SOUR CREAM. PORTION PAK COTTAGE CHEESE. SMALL CURD REG MILK, I '% CHOCOLATE 03 105 MILK. 1% REDUCED FAT 00490 ..

1 N

1
$ 13.10
$ 19.16

$ 26. $ 13.07
$ 18.99

$ -3.
$ -.

1 N

13.10
$ 19.16

1
1 1

$ 13.07

2155200

3 OZ
2 LB

s

1:3.99

1 N
N

$ 11.32

s

11. 32

$ 12.24 $ 16.04 $ 19.06
$ 10.48

$ 12.24

2162500 2168000 3170500 3172500

40
144

4 OZ
1 OZ

$ 14.59
$ 19.93

$ 29.18 $ 19.93

2

$ 32.08
$ 19.06 $ 20.96 $ 12.42
$ 97.80
$ 40.75

$

1 N
::: t!

1
2

s -

100
4

1 OZ
5 LB

s

-,~,

" 12

y
N

$ 7.53

$ 15.06

2

$ 6.21

$ -2.£4

3178600
31

50 50
HF

$ 97.80
$ 8.00

12
5

$ 8.15
$ 8.15

SOUTHERN B

s

40.00

$

.75

Page I

Case 1:07-cv-00210-EGB

Document 44

Filed 05/31/2007

Page 13 of 17
USFI Order # 2
Qty
$

.·... -~'-"~'-"'-'---

Southern Foods Inc,
~--~

Item #

Pack Size
50 HF

Brand
SOUTHERN B FLORIDA NUGGET RED NUGGETBLA
LB

~--'----~ ·.

_._._._---.

Qty E

Price
$ 8.1 $

Total
$ 57.05 $ 17 .16

Price
8,.1~

Total
$ 57.

Savings
.~--

STRAWBERRY 3308 *S/O

3231200 3614600

1

5 LB

CUCUMBERS. FRESH
BEANS. 1\1IXED/SHORT CUT GREEN
I N

3 1

$

7~28

s

.84

6

#10

$ 15.48

$ 15.48
$ 14.44

$ 14.63
;; 14.90

$ 14. 14. $ 39.39
$ 15.

$ -.8

3618700
3633000

6
6
6

#10
5.

BEANS. PORK & IN TOi\IATO SAUCE
POTATOES. GRANULES COi\IPLETE

1 N 1 N
1 N 1 N
$ 44.01

UNIPRO NUGGETBLA WORLD HORI T MARLETTI
NUGGET RED

$ 44.01
$ 14.26
$ 21.85 $ 23~22 $ 14.94

1
1
1

$ 39.39
$ 15.57

s

-4.62
$ 1.31

#10 #10
1 GAL

KETCHUP. FANCY 33'% CANNED PINEAPPLE. CHUNKS JUICE PAK
DRESSING. [TAtTAN GOLDEN 80032

$ 14.26

6 4125000 16000
4

s

21. 35 23.22

22.47
$ 27.18

s
1 N
3 N

1 1

$ 27. $ 14.62 $ 16.

$
$

3~

1
5
6

5 GAL
16 02
9 OZ

PICKLE. DILL SLICES KK 3il6" 1024

$ 14.
$ 5.96

s

14.62
;; 5.54

47::1700

LAY'S LAWRY'S
PACKER

CHIPS. TORTILLA TOSTIT05 BULK PAK
SEA.SONING. TACO 80110
DRESSING. R,\NCH BUTTERMILK REF

;; 17.88 $ 17.55

3
1 1

;;

1 1l 1 N

17.55

4 17500

4

1 GAL

$ 28.47

$ 30.44

$ 30.44

S 1.

$35.62

$1.341.85

$1.377.47

$35.62

Page 2

ORDER 5Ul'ir-1,'I,RY

Case 1:07-cv-00210-EGB
Ordered

Document 44

Filed 05/31/2007
Estirnat!?d

Page 14 of 17

Total Cases: Total Eaches

79
2

$1358.'18

2

Total Line Hems:

31

OROEi, DETAILS

sc

UNE

DESCRIPTION

BRAND
PATUXENT 2/150 fA GLNVW FRMS TOSTITOS

PRTCr:

ORDERED

RESERVeD

16

BACON, PORK CKD REF 3Nl (13302:;;n CHEESE, COTT SM CURD 4% BTRFT

$7982 CS
$24.83 CS

I/O

1/0

104 (5340864)
146

4/5 LB
5/160Z

0/2
3/0

0/2 3/0
0/0

CHIP, TORTLA RND CRSPY BULK

(5098397)
CINNA!'10N BUN, Jf'lB FZN (3358868) CORN DOG, TRKY eN FZN W/ STICK

$5.54 CS
$18.99 CS $16.40 CS

147
163 164

RICH'S
STATE

72/3 OZ
,48/402
9f, fA

I/O
3/0 4/0

(9039843)
CORN ON COB, 3" PTlTE DfvlSTC (4328118) DOUGH, BSCT STHRN STYl FZN (7521065) DRESSING, ITLN GLDN( DRESSING, RANCH BTRI·IU< REAL FRENCH TOAST, STICK FZN (7331200)
KETCHUP, H1TO

FAIR
!'10NARCH HILLTOP HR

3/0
4/0
1/0

$17.13 CS
$26.20 CS
$27.18C5 $30.14 CS

207
216

220/2.20

02
4/1 GA.

I/O
I/O

us BLUE
us BLUE 1-l!LlTOP

1/0
I/O

4/1
S/2lB

1/0

236
279

HR
I-I0NARCH
ROSEll

$12.24 CS
~;15S7

I/O
I/O
2/0

FRESH

10
CN

PK(43299:?5)
PASTA, SHEET 40 (8329211)

CS

I/O

341 358
363

':T CKf)

PLN FZN

10
5

CS
$14.52 CS

PICKLE, DILL Ht-1BGR CC 3/16"( 4328993) PINEAPPLE, CHNK IN JeE HlP

US RED
INTL GREEN TONY'S US BLUE CANOLA QIK STATE

1/0 I/O
'I/O

1/0

6/# 10

( 1333517)
PIZZA, SMART eHS PPRNI 8< nozz

eN

r.s _c::>
$40_00 CS

369
381 388

96/4.65
OZ
6/5.31 LB

(9316209) POTATO, fllSHD GRNIJL DHY O,lPlT
(8552663) POTATO, FF CC CNTNA OVBL THIN

'I/O

$39.39 CS
$1753 CS

I/O
3/0

I/O
3/0

(3014594)
SAUSAGE, PORK BKFST STICK

6/4 lB

48/2.85

4/1612007

Case 1:07-cv-00210-EGB Con ti rrn-u io»

Document 44

Filed 05/31/2007

Page 15 of 17

') ,--,,-r'l

448
455 474 547

CRND(3076635) SEASONING, TACO !·lIX FOIL PKT

FAIR SPC CLSIC GlNVW FR!'lS BELGN CHEF PACKER PACKER PACl
OZ 6/90Z 100/1 02 144 EA 50/,5 PT 50/.5 PT 50 EA

$18.34 CS

1/0
I/O

1/0

(5223789)
SOUR CREAM, REF ClTD GRO A SS (707109) WAFFLE, STICK FZN BELGIUM

$9,63 CS
:j,lOA8 CS

1/0

2/0
110

2/0
I/O
12/0 7/0

(2042414)
MILK, CHOC 1% PROCD REF MINi (6726) MILK, STWBY LOW FAT (375766) MILK, LOW FAT
1°/.~

:j,19.06 CS $8,15 CS

558

12/0
7/0

559

FYt,

REF

$8.15 CS
$iU5 CS
~,21.31

560

REF(1497338)

5/0
10/0
I/O 1/0
I/O

5/0
10/0

CHICKEN, NUGT BRDD BPST eN BEAN, GRN CUT MIX s SHORT

250/.66
OZ

CS

6/# 10
CN 72/2.3

(4328647)
BAGEL, PlN 2.3 Z SlCD(2033025) CHICKEN, PTY BRDD RND HEAT &

Vl
SARA LEE

$14.63 CS
$13.07 CS

I/O 1/0
I/O

OZ
60/3.3
02

(8350613)

PIERCE
CIRCLE Z SHOW BOAT PACKER

$23.07 CS $4623 CS

BEEF, PTY CN FLAfvlE !3RLD 2.4 2
(2163
BEAN, PORK fi XFCY(40909Bl CUCUI18ER, FRESH(901.J566)

136/2.4 07 10
L.

4/0

4/0

eN

24 EA

$728 CS

3/0

310

Prices

Will

Thank

for

I'"

Confirmation

4/16/2007

Case 1:07-cv-00210-EGB

Document 44

Filed 05/31/2007

Page 16 of 17

COMPETITIVE PRICING GUIDE
Southern Foods Inc.
117 Mitch McConnell Way Bowling Green, KY 42101 www.southernfoodsinc.com 270-843- 1121 Ship to:

Foods

Southern

Southern Foods Inc,
Hem #
2011350 2012150 96

USFI Order # 1
Qty

Pack Size
4 OZ 4 OZ

Brand
ARD1'vIORE ARDMORE SHEDDS SOUTHERNB SOUTHERN B SOUTHERN B SUNNY DELI KELLOGG'S PORTION PA Z-BIRD

Description
JUICE. APPLE INDV CUP FRZ 4 381 JUICE, GRAPE INDV CUP FRZ 41382 MARGARINE. SOLIDS MILK,I%CHOCOLATE03105 IVI!LK. 1% REDUCED FAT 00490 MILK. 1% STRAWBERRY 3308 *S/O BEVERAGE. SUNNY DELIGHT ORIG *S/O SNACK BAR. RICE KRISPIE TREATS DRESSlNG. RANCH POUCH 00-22-951 CHICKEN FRYZ BREAST STIX 66992CN

Qty E
4 N
4 N

Price
::;; 11.

Total
$ 44.88
$ 52.00

Price
s
11.36

Total
$ 45.44
$ 54.

s

.56

$ 13.00

4
1

s

13.74

30
31 600
50

1 LB
HF

1 N 6 N
N

s 13.63
$ 8.15

$ 12.02 $ 8.15

$ 12.02
$ 48.90

$ 48.90

6
4

31
3178800 4019500
300

50

HF
HF

$ 8.00

$ 32.00 $ 32.60
$ 29.24

$ 8.15 $ 8.15
$ 14.15

$ 32.

$

·

50 48

4 N

$ 8.15
$ 14.62

6.75
1.3

1 N

$ 28.94

1

$ 30.61

4921500 0977400

100
3

OZ

3 N
1 N

$

12~70

$ 38.10

3
1

$ 12.63
$ 36.36

$ 37.89 $ 36.36

LB

$ 36.05

Your Total Savings

$3.34

$356.34

$359.68

$3.34

Page I

Case 1:07-cv-00210-EGB
Ordered Total Cases: Total Eacnes

StJ~111l,RY

Document 44
29

Filed 05/31/2007
E:;t1mal:ed Pnce .

Page 17 of 17

31

$32332
10

o

o

Total Line Items:

ORDER DETAILS

SC

LINE
224

DESCRIPTION

13Rl"ND

PAC\(

ORDERED $14.15 CS ;$11.36 CS
$13.74 CS

nESERVE~)

SIZE

FULL/PART FULL/PART

DRINK, TANGY OPJG FL (45237)

srvu;

SUNNY DEL
I\RD~10RE

43/6.75
OZ
96/402 96/402

2/0 4/0 4/0
6jO

'2/0 '1/0
4jO

26l
273

JUICE, APPL WOo;, FZN PL5T CUP

(1117647)
JUICE, GRAPE 100% FlN PLST CUP

Ff' ARDI10RE

(4165452)
MILK, CHOC 1% PROCD REF l'lINI

Ff'l
PACKER PACKER

558 (6726)

50/.5 PT
50j.5 PT

$8.15 CS

6/0

559 (375766)
560
S~IACK

1'1ILK, STWBY LOW FAT l'~!c REF
!'llLK, LOW FAT 1'10
REF(ld~l?338)

$8.15 CS
$8.15 CS
$30.61 CS $1202 CS $12.63 CS

4/0
4/0
1/0
1/0

4/0
4/0
1/0
1/0

PACKER

50 EA

BAR, RICE l
(1279439)
MARGARINE, SOllD(70J496)
DRESSING, RANCH POUCH S5 REF (·19684)

80/1.3 KELLOGG'S 02
GlNVW

FRMS

30/1 LB 100/1 OZ

KRAFf
Z. BIRD

3/0

3/0
0/0

CHICKEN, STRIP BRDD (4166153)

35Z

3/5 LB

shown above
TI1ilnk

Actual pnces INIII

refleckd on your invoice.

Confirmation

4/16/2007