Free Motion for Summary Judgment - District Court of Federal Claims - federal

Case 1:07-cv-00271-RHH

Document 56-2

Filed 05/15/2008

Page 1 of 30

IN TH UNITD STATES COURT OF FEDERA CLAS
)

JACK LADD and MAR LADD, et al., )

v. )
)
)

Plaintiffs, ))
)

No. 07-271 L
Honorable Robert H. Hodges, Jr.

THE UND STATES OF AMRICA, )

Defendant. )

)

DECLARA TION OF CINI A. R. STRUP
I, Cindi A. R. Straup, declare under penalty of perjury that:
1. I am the Director of Axion

Administration, LLC. I have been engaged in claims

administration for over ten years. I have been engaged to obtain the relevant landowner
information for over fort lawsuits involving landowners who adjoin active and

abandoned raioad corrdors. These engagements included review of

Valuation maps

and tax maps.

2. Axon Administration, LLC, was retained to conduct title examination work in
Ladd v. United States.

3. We were asked to identify the conveyance documents that record how the railroad

acquired an interest in the corrdor identified in the Surace Transportation Board's
Decision and Notice ofInterim Trail Use or Abandonment dated July 25,2006.
4. We used tax maps and tax cards obtained from Cochise County, Arizona along

with the docuents attached to the Plaintiffs' First Amended Complaint (provided to us)
to locate the named Plaintiffs' properties. Using the known location of

the Plaintiffs'

properies, we correlated each Plaintiffs' propert to the Val maps covering those same

Case 1:07-cv-00271-RHH

Document 56-2

Filed 05/15/2008

Page 2 of 30

locations. Using the Deed Schedules on the Val maps, we obtained the Deed Book and
Page for the relevant private conveyance documents. We then obtained a copy of

the

related source documents from the Cochise County Courhouse.
5. The following char shows which source conveyance documents conveyed the

portions of the corrdor that abut the eight named Plaintiffs' properies as of July 25,
2006.1 The referenced instruments are attached hereto as exhibits.

Plaitiff
Ladd Family

Relevant Conveyance Instruent(s)

Grantor/ Grantee E.M. Fike/ E.P. & S.W.R.R. Co. Lydia L. Fike/ E.P. & S.W.R.R. Co. B.L. Robinson! E.P. & S.W.R.R. Co. P.J. Fikel E.P. & S.W.R.R. Co.
August Bohralk/

Date
July 9, 1903

Record
D.R. 19-498

Exhibit
1

July 31, 1903

July 20, 1903
July 16, 1903

D.R. 19-493

2
3

July 31, 1903
D.R. 19-491

July 31, 1903

July 7, 1903

n.R. 19-488

4
5

July 31, 1903

July 13, 1903
July 7, 1903
Mar. 3,1875
Oct. 30, 1911

n.R. 19-500
July 31, 1903

E.P. & S.W.R.R. Co.

Henr Lee Hadt! E.P. & S.W.R.R. Co. United Statesl
E.P. & S.W.R.R. Co. Lindsey Family C.L. Cummngs! E.P. & S.W.R.R. Co. Castro John E. Logan et ux/ E.P. & S.W.R.R. Co. United States/ E.P. & S.W.R.R. Co. Joseph Lawrence John E. Logan et ux/ Heinzl E.P. & S.W.R.R. Co. United States/ E.P. & S.W.R.R. Co. Miler Family J. V. Vickers et ux.l E.P. & S.W.R.R. Co.

D.R.19-496
July 31, 1903 Act of Congress
D.R. 53-247
Nov. is, 1911

6

7 8

Nov. 6,1911
Mar. 3, 1875

D.R. 53-232
Nov. 9, 1911

Act of Congress
n.R. 53-232

Nov.

6,

1911

8

Nov.9,1911
Mar. 3,1875
Jan. 14, 1910

Act of Congress
n.R. 50-416

9

Feb. 14, 1910

1 Some of

the propert described in the deeds attached to Plaintiffs' First Amended

Complaint, including all of the property described in Quitclaim Deed #000411149, does
not abut the rail

line.

Case 1:07-cv-00271-RHH

Document 56-2

Filed 05/15/2008

Page 3 of 30

Azec Land and

Mar. 20, 1903

Singletree Rach

Cattle Company/ Ariz & Col RR. Co. United States! E.P. & S.W.R.R. Co. United States/ Ariz. & Southeastern

D.R. 27-495 Apr. 5,1905

10

Mar. 3, 1875

Act of Congress Act of Congress

Mar. 3, 1875

RR.Co.
Miller Ranch Trust

United States/ Ariz. & Southeastern

Mar. 3,1875

Act of Congress

RR.Co.

Tamy
Windsor-Brown

United States! E.P. & S.W.R.R. Co.

Mar. 3,1875

Act of Congress
.

6. We determined tht Joseph Lawrence Heinzl sold his propert on June 6,2007.

The relevant deed is attached as Exhbit 11.
7. We reviewed the original conveyance documents identified as Exhibits F, H, I,
and J to Plaintiffs' Proposed Findings of

Uncontroverted Fact (provided to us) and

determned that they relate to portions of the railroad corrdor that do not abut the named
Plaitiffs' properties. In addition, we reviewed Exhibit K to Plaintiffs' Proposed

Findings of

Uncontroverted Fact (provided to us) and determined that it is not an original

conveyance document.

8. We determined that the Lindsey Family, Castro, Heinzl, Singletree Rach, Miller
Ranch Trust, and Windsor-Brown Plaintiffs' properties abut portions of

the railroad

corrdor located beteen milepost 1040.15 near Curtiss and milepost 1074.3 at the

intersection ofthe rail

line with State Highway 92.

9. We determined that the Ladd Family propert and most of

the Miler Family

proper abut portions of

the railroad corrdor located between milepost 1074.3 at the line with State Highway 92 and milepost 1084.0. A small piece of

intersection of

the rail

Case 1:07-cv-00271-RHH

Document 56-2

Filed 05/15/2008

Page 4 of 30

the Miller Famly proper abuts a porion of

the railroad corrdor located beteen

milepost 1084.0 and milepost 1097.3 at Paul Spur.

I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct.
Executed this à day of

May 2008 at Dallas, Texas.

c=

Cindi A. R. Strp

ts

Case 1:07-cv-00271-RHH

Document 56-2

Filed 05/15/2008

Page 5 of 30

1,' ... -'. ~ :.'.~.,. ...;....--~ ~...~'.' 'l..:.'~;':"'? :1"' .

.,' tl.( ''. ,.y...,.. ..'¿,(, iul"1A.1W"~ ~ .fW~-e..~...l.'''-l''''7:¿: "'7'

. ..' icC . ;~,t. H¡/.,i "S;I.,'1, :A.'''1't.''H~,.~.tr//;'l''''-~A~ l..,,~.f 4¿.....
.:.

It. ,("1M i.t" l.' :~ ')/1 ~ ,j' ~ï ..~~~(if.)"'" ,,,.I)1',e,,f, ~::""'l'~" ~ ,.q.,L.

\....r;l~.f ::t ...1)'.; ftt!t'l....',.~I'J..il:l/t\"'lIU.t/ i.'l"lfl~l(k.t,lllll,.~Jt'N..ej .

:. "Jlt~. ldot I 'If~; r.:'(I'I?(("ÆFl ;¿&..1J"..l'.IP..l"'.rtl;t.r..'hL;l~U#.,,,(,;('htt'(l:" /Iii'(.(-l(. l'~(.v~t'f'.

. ,/ .';' "J,*", ./ ¿!.

i) " .'/ 1. .. . f" (7 , i~.

i ..¿' i " .~. . . , I

I i ") # l./t .g t';~ ¿J. L '..1 ..~

. ,. .~ ~

. . t'V' .

J '( i.p ir l l. I II ~ #' '~l; n .. Æ.., ic:l' ... ne* .~l't.i-.l! o/i#('l~. ,1;(",, )' At 1.~Z:.1

:'~:l,~~1 (.""\.1, ';i'..'f .' . i
L /~J4~/,,(. I-,I,....oI'RH ,.~!iA.M..l.lb..r."t) iy'v) ,

(Ii. ,.' '. . rJ_

. ',\ ¡I..,l¿ '..',.' .,., : I' i,..;'

. ~ ;/7-\'..:Lk;' ~~~. ~~.a. 71 .. t.g..l CrAOid /Ut:,.taa+A.~fJl;f.~-e/7..rJ /A:

(&ti¿,J . ,'. .. ,'" ~n~z~~__.

.l.

i: ii.:/-.¿.~ ~"~./'Ý7j/Jkt,;~A"';¿::

, v1tø'1~'l .~~ g"'~ :~~~ CJ ~.a'~¥~jl ~~..
.

¡û..e'!fIJ,' a.-Itl Ph. . c,l"' .. " . ..... ,... 'r;/ .

; .1~~Cl1.-~ ~"r,,,. ~~ ~

~ ~.,J¡¿. "~~:~~l' j~."r~ ~d.'~:¿ZÇ~7,6. t~1-".t/,,? ..u.I,¿a1t.~w.. ~ J-en'... .r/&. ~"'r'h ~~ V!
1..r-~'d7"~ . ~\!~~' ~ ,A.u:"a-.( ~~. ~r. ! . ~

''2'1 _. / V /~ d '. 1/ -/" iT / I

..1.""(' . ~jíjt (ltI-l) ) iÔ,ai~ ,/:L, ~ -: ~ ~ y ;r~i
,l(:.~'4.~?~~ ~ ,(J~lrl. /~ .A~r:,~;/~~.... ~r~.~~ .

, ,~k.~ /""" . m l)~h'".j/¥Ã: ~J/E"AMM4~ 'M/ (/ / , . . g A.. /

i I

!~ L"j liJ'1d~ ~~z~rr.~ ~~ . -~ tJ, :¡,J..'l'(~f),o''t'el ~ ~~ .~~~..
"(N~f''')/'''d,) .?"",Á? )~ot~ ~ 7-~ "~~'
:¿w..I(.~ ,,~.'lu..dí N1' ~4; ~~L.æ¿~~~ ;t~~~

I.
!

I

.v~.~.n,~~ :~l~ -d~£~ ~ ~ ~/~¿Y

,¿t.../. J l.e.I."dl!'~ ~~ei ~ C~~;.ûl., . ~ ~ .r;i;.

~1~"l..;It,./i~" A.~.,~tv/"-e' ""V?,:f~&.QD ,. ~A.e-e:& '--,'\(.(..,n:.~ /IJA,tN.,?'lC "a.c7 Cla'...P74"~::~.¡ ~~

( ,.) ¡l I . rlJ:/ /.;. #_1 . -z_, "

~ :it,¡l'''''~Ut.( '~d"i.d.. ~~?- Q. ~~.r.,L~.', /,....~.~. ~. .¿ ~.~~.. ~

fétA-i..c, ~- )tl.~A:. .. '.'~ ',,,,,:,:,#~:"~:';:.~?"4o. il
¡J'/: '" ',. '.. . .:';::~~~I;~'i~~";~1~::.. .'\é!1:~~ttSJ;~;~ ;;l~~~Dt~/: '.:ijI:J;(f.;'~~:: .,:\ . ~'" j
I ..... '. ...... ....\...,. ~:.:".~._..¡.,.,...\¡,~.liu.,.:.h"\1"¡;"",,,:t;:~~.,....:;(_,,~".",,,,,.,,, ~

DEFENDANT'S EXHIBIT

it

--

-

· a_po

I . '.' ..,;,' . ":;;' .," ':";'4ö1~:
: ll;':~ r- ,,;':/...t 11.' '. ,It ?'~' Ad¥. il£/ ~dt¡ ~/MA .. '. ,,;,~; l,~
:.l/ /f,' L'''~~~ j , . I /J i . ~~~)4 ee?t ~ DV"~'-"-~ ,,' ~ ,-~. . r.-Ý ' g)____.A..~l:~~

:.. . 11,
,~~ if'i/.)'~ l.d~~.. ~.M.~a-

Case 1:07-cv-00271-RHH

Document 56-2

Filed 05/15/2008

Page 6 of 30

:".i"/,,,~~. e7l:/~~/#~'l~'.~AN. 14.zf~~ . 'Al.\

.",''- %,'r ~~7 ~ ~v (/.7l\l; .r~, ~;;.-"/)Æ.~~'~ - ,¡..~i"~.

.31' ~ ~ ~ rt~.r ~.t~,~"4'.i t;~flU4'¿.-'':"I"f: ß.~ ~."t~g,"j -4 ..Ii

1 ~ r~. tf(,'t 4t;/:...~. ¿, ~~. l~ ~~~r: /. ~e:"".",..d"' ,d',4,d- ..',

,~Ú'~.~ ~'Á~'-,Z~~\ ..t,I~~ I... " ri ,,'. 4~ ., ttt.- "~/~"7 "'r-f'~~ . :Hr "'~~a--~~,tý.-~---7)~
1/ &:/9?)~7~""7' ~ -d..:~i
~'ttat,1i-e.u..~ . ..... . .. . .... ,'~"'~'

~~ ~;,_...;...~;.:';,..

. """id ~¿ ,.;t ,~lL .~~"l~e-~ ,~~d ',' ......-:::~l¡.~..

~rt ~~av~- ~J"~"~~~ ~;~. '..~3~.::...

. ~-dj"~~~"" ~~~-- /~~~ . ..'

,;í ~.. ,¿;#'i,d ~ ~- ¡'-t~~~/~ ~~'-r-

.lr:7~.:. ..~,,~'ad.,~-n.Tdø ,.ùu:~ r?'Y

I.. /.~-dr-?y~~L~ \?-2~
i~.v .A!;¡e(tof'7,,4 ~,,/I ~,A ~ a-..~'-~ ~ 7-

(/ ß A_ .:.. ¿) - ,/ ~ . /(9.M.i~~) r:i ~"'k~ ' 1'.; . ~~v~",

i~~"'~r: ~ " t ' . . Or/i/. ~
I ,. -1i?Io',i..:..~' .~ ",tI~"'Æ -

(:'Y~" /¡;,.:~ ,_,t¿iLf.."d 1l~'~l.~f (l,,/!~;.~lL¿ ~ , .4w: ..rl 'r1IZ''' em", ?~?~,..:;~ a ~./bMe~1
lII tp ,,/1, ';7" .-"..e,. ;;n.~lU-~~'CI'? 'Pie. _ ¿; l)f! ,; /¡,t.. /,:'~l~l.1/ . 'J.'

t7.u~~4- tl-;¡, ~,d.A;Y' -/ y -,-~ ,r A, ç: ~f' _.J / ~~ ,..,~~ v-l.-~ e:aA~

1 I a-", aøfJ--&'?J'~ ~ ~~:i-. ..4 '.....-~~ ;r ..~'. .';. ~:;~ .
I. ;. . :. :' .' :._. ~. . . ' '.' '...,,' ,'. .' . ,:.. ''';',' ::. '¡'.'" ,'.¡I~ . :..",.. :,':. ",.;.d:~~;);~; r~;

1P7~ ~vi ,-...h...hd ;S'7i,/'~'(~ "~ . (~ -. A "f~~ ('ll~.Mll.-n /~.. .'- '.:. . ." .,I".dí,& J ~ . J- ~ , ~,, . '. / / / . :"£~". . ~A1~."~f~:~.~ ;';¡l~~

----~-".,

Case 1:07-cv-00271-RHH

Document 56-2

Filed 05/15/2008

Page 7 of 30

:..., ~" u ;".,.~, a. W'~.Ljl~.. MLa:d' a-eú' .' il

~. /. / ~ (./ /7 , /0' ;;-; Øo , ,,'1

.i.~/.... ~V~~.'. ÑYi&';~~~;':7. dz.~l-:r,dj& ':"~'.;;;;~ ~£f/~~-ol ~~: . v ....:,1
. ;t4l~~:/~w,~ T:-v l' 4~;~~~//;t,~c"_d ':: ~~

",:- I 1'.. ~~4N~ 11 ~ f,:i~,,~ ~~e-~7-::S vÇe4.~;2'7 7 ..:~

~d.dt'd~"~_ ('~?/ ~~ 4/' '¿,,~d'~'¿" .. Y ~

'... ~~.. ;,..2... ~'::: ~:-; . .~a-t!~'~7 ,~7, .' :,:...'~,:i
.. arid (/rl./£ M.i~ t'- '/p,,.

'-..' - .æa:u7~¿~~~¿,~I~~A/~~4 . ';:....;~,'
....,....... (I ..~.~~... ~?t. ~ rf~~j~~~rlæ'.,?:t.l.. ,~;4;¿; /~~:~ ¿~? ... ..::::

"~.~ "iY.le~ ~/N¿eu~~~ ." ':::'Õ;'.

.. ~44'~.l ";.ff-t~fI~ r ¿v~~ ~~¿ -1;#.. ~/ú-; - ~r . i

A ~ 6~a,,/ '¿~~ÅA~~~ --~74~7"" .::'

:~I:'7-/"I_-j'P/f. ~~-~ ~
ø_ i?¿j/' ..f!a"¡'dc.w~/-,/Ii,.(',L d'"'~~ .J,,i-1'.. CI''1-2.'I-rtt:",.,cc.t!/

.1, eJ/~r;:e~'i ~ r'~ ..~~~ A~/A

a4~i:r¿"~/"/~ 4"' '1~u'ú~~ l'4t7 ~.

. ~.~i:¡j~~" //.1 . 'I ¿I"/l "/tV'(",.",,.,:./.y..eZ.~ Øl'dZ ~

~::~ (J"'Ut4.'""~ Al J?".,:z ~n:. :,''A~:Yr ~ t:.,t ~~-* ...; ¡ .;.. / C/. ut ) ... Po //)/';,' /i +. . ~~ /:J ~ ~":A'í~ ~.J 6,,Ñ;i~I/(, (,d ~ ;/n, ~iI¿,~nd".~:'\
G L~ ""U'-f..'lL~J-/tÂ'¿4f. .,/.i s, '~/CV,;'~ttJ .:~t~~.l. /;n..~if "~.:';.
..11;, 71t~ ..(ttr,n,~,.YJMtLo~~~",~'dl,~):ci¡1;';" r':.,~,~,. or 'l'U.~d i.y-' i'J"I A .

;e&+~/~/.l.. ~-rd'~" l!lld.';1 \l"l.l~..i;./ (~"l'lä l.t(~~!~~t. . ,-tff:~ei a ' . /f' .~t¡.:¿,.~.. ,I~.4'/ 0"" (.lrttt:..,,,r'¡: '.'~'/t'í"l jul., '...~-f.ltl,c. .N" I'll) ,-(ff.l:' "f.;''l('''fM.~ fH'H4'tÚ(..'" .".l'('~A f'l ~ i ,~,'.cf(lf, r "~('. C"e- ,Lt"('~ ,fj¥l:'~ 'rrn. ...." t"'", ttt c,tt.! ,./-' 1'.,,1, ",~'4f "":.!:~.:~ , '¡~l~ ¡i' ""fl-': ,(!:. ....;1" ..~.,~ ..t. ,,;,,'''f *H~(.'" .~y(."-.iI.,, ,,rt~r..t! ..: ,t)(h:e ,.lt.l.8,.~.. .K.'~~olt:''' ,. ~/",)~..,~~ ..... ~;(-.: ".~...f/¡,- ¿;4- . :'~?

.r. . .... /" l.' g.

1.,, J . ~. I .~. ,." -/ . (/ 4'~ .

'i i ~ t. '" :s'.J \' :'-6-'J 1;)' i '. :.;:.
. . Jl'NJ\.:!:~~::?~' ""'''10;'; t.l' ~.T;.í...... ~~I~.~?¡'tl"/. ~ ~- -'~.r~~~::.: J~:J.
~..:-_.;:,~ ,;.:',. ~¿'L/.:) (l', /~ ....~, ,.~.. ,...:"d e:,~(~:.~~; ...~rFi...,~,' .;,; . f'" .... :... .' , . (i, ~~ ;/f~ ld~. ~~-( ~~(..:.~.~;:,..~t ...;;.~~~

~ DEFENDANT'S
~
u g

EXHIBIT

:2c

I

Case 1:07-cv-00271-RHH

Document 56-2

Filed 05/15/2008

Page 8 of 30

,. , . t~~. ,. ,. ¡x: :;r~C",~~~~ErR.~:;r'~!'~"t';:' "1

.:.. r .w,.Uh çI'-~¿ ,*'-r~t~..e. 6.,,,. l,.'?,,& y.. . i I

::.~ ~.~:. ./I'~ a'~'-M';;-~l¿ /-d'O~/~:'~rl I
. ¿)&.~/ U. dÁ;t' ~d m..vf ~~ (¿(Jo.,/rd ~ ' ~ I
,i-v ::~!.wl."., ft~d¿ ¿,,,'¡;I' é"a~.æAd'¿,o/~. . i (t~ .:-~~ .'. &\

~,,~Af . . g p . ~~ I i .' /J Z...."..._&~..¡t?. . ~1 ~ Q¿'1'Z~ ..viA ¡(~'I"v"n'i."z,~ .~/a... ~ 7./'~.~-U
.! dn-u,i~. r.""e, \~..n~- ~.u (.3J). ~ -& ,r':;la... ~

. n'I"("''' ~~ . n. ,r.~' A..1 ~rUI'.. . ~! _. ~ (JI: ~ .,.. .

. ..J. t ~ ri%f . /I L '1.~...~~,... i

. 7'¿..~ ~_~¿ (81'. :') ~ ~,,-h: ~-I
, 8a4;,IOI',t""'L(A 'Y ~ ¿d Ch~- /¿¿0) ~ t: ~J~ . i
IUM-:7trJ.''ét.6'ë7~(n'!.~ ;/~~ ~~~'-~. ~)(:1"')

; .rd¡(¿,' /" . j),,; ¿7 /,:\. /J:1 /.. .,.tt .. q i'.' " ,. ,J 11' ~ ~ .7
l : ,¡.¡-" ,o~U"'1. ,~__i; ruli7"l ':~/"k'¿ ( .. ~".~? ¡t'Nd '''1~~ ~ r~Á- ;

i ~. -- ",' /,. . .. ...

tdJ')' / d ø #)7 1'1 . :

. ~l) ~,;'.1¡A4C ~ ~ C'ýp . ~ :L ~ A -r,~ "~""v-1 ¡'"~..~ A-UA"'..

~ l~1.~ - .~.~~ (.".J g~(Î; .:d¿ i:-;~;".'~ 1.t.:1ñ:,~H:. .~. 41, l . i A.n'U.i1:6-II..- .ka.//~,' .1& 'Ælß.(./diÆ../4,.i.;"-t~H. ~,."e'(.¿ :

, Q:/, ,/ iJ i \ (/ _-: l :
;(i,. i ?¡l"-¿lfl~ H ~ ~~' JU.l~ot~~..'. -0/1 !lu4 tfl).f ~ ,,d~ l./. / . r:'t . -'. - j . , It..r;U, ,~-t:.AA~.: .J_~ tJ 4 ' ~ L)~f~(J~

,. imrM'YU.J ~~",;, ...~' a/(4..7.qht.L~. 7r~"MJ.-l~"¿ Cl1d'r~I"~.p...,~(A tlAf") ;

¡,ili~ ()~"" ,ILJ ....., ,. ,:.. ., ..' . .,l~ tw aa(2~7~. ~.~A"~ ~¿-*a.-

1Új,~-~ '.t-___ ,..... ~ ~.l..t/)~

: //, -d~.:~.~.~~ -J' l~tr'l¿r=~&4
, . ,"'r:- '_ _ . , . . ()

: 9Yi.i. a. a.~¡.~ ~l,."A~, .. . ~ ... b" ~ I
,;!ff,t4oC(.ln/ it., ..~i,'#wi a""i.,;l -;At..-i-l. i :J ~AV::-;. ./t" Q, ,~jf.L/-¿ ¡

I; #., ,(I(Ucl /t,~~ .~;Wv(.' -'J i / _.//. v . ~'7 d:: : 9'&ra;1 /:~
..4lCi'nd ;i('lA~ .¿k ,(ùe.f/"r'4J,tl~~l-.'''~ .... , I

,!-;/,d.t't k ~.""UVCI.a..:I~a.~. . -. ~ ..,.~

A ~. .. I ,I! . . ". ,
i / lI /-.----,~~--'_. -7 '

; /l.I1;"aA'1(,6A"";fes/V7~ ~ ~.~~~I
.t;'i., vn. 11.. Co,., .,,,a., ",diJrc:l, 7æ, ,~y"ld~. .... '. .1b~L'" .' .~ I

~'1"¡ rl! JI~f. ~)ltI':Il;t.,u.¿ n.- tylJ~ r.A~ ..~~
; Y~~Lo' .C;:r"(A,. 1...~.A4. - -~,.. ...... :.- .. . " .....".... ...: .

i ;1..~a.4 11' '. "/ ...~" J-'." .~t u(. ,,l.i-. .L ~'l. - .;:.:.~;~:: ~.c.:
/' ~r.:'.:' :,:':":'.:~:;::',!;:~~~;;E;i!;:t~.::¡~;:;A;::~~:d::~:/:. )~:~~,..;tr,;.

ll ,'( ( '//~"d/ ..," ,

. ....... .........~1\...,......"... .J.......I....:.I,..i",.I..."~iiI:I.-...~..~....~ ..._""".J"I,,_.:- ;.........ri""..(.i.;,. ,., 0"

_ n ¡.~ I"u~"", ~~+-uuJr"~ 4àd?-'(':~ :04"'.l~ ~~-~7 ¡...':;~: ~r'/ : l't, .g, ,4 ~ '"..~..:"'''''r;¿ ~r'/",
Case 1:07-cv-00271-RHH Document 56-2 Filed 05/15/2008

Page 9 of 30

\ ¡ . ..,t ::~. ~'¡'ir;~ :'''~d''~~, '" '1;.Wrf"":; Y;~'\":-;V :::it:r. ~:, .

.... " ,/,i~..~ /~, ':~:~i~ ,\ / AJVlO.' ,f It .,; ". $~~~~~~/: ~ r~~") ~_ ~/ ~ _? / "/~~r; ".: .':', tk~.~il'~ ZZ. ,~g~7'~ zt~,y. ..t.~.: ., ~ l ..~4"~ ..4ø~..lZ.'1'~'~~" ....._~;: 1.1 _ t?.," :,:,.3~." /
V ~ "u;r/I1Lt(M'6~.I!¿'~ d ~ ~~.' ...... ....~:..

~ /' rr / r' ..:::~: ,~

',' ~Zd~.~~. / rz.. -/dR l'.... ,',!~~, .' R .~ // .... '~4i '~;-~p~'. ;~'

~~~'Æ"/ .t7 .'.-. .... · :;,'i' i fu7.r 4in l
,'ff,' ~r_-t.2: ~ A. d,.' ~~ ?~J- ~ ,..,.:...'~;; ~
If 'I.tMI..4.. wu~Nt?.Jo).~ 'i ('l4''ie6A/..bJ:~; ~'..,..~,n ,

~lÑ;'~':4-A ~ . .,4uv,w; ~~ ~ '7 ~.... '.~.' .~f~ ~'

.. .' . ;r~á'~ ~¿ Z~ C-¿tl/) . ,..;.,.

.I.d~~~;:::'~';::' ø;~) ~'z~; ~ ;:~7~ ,~; ~~':t~

~ ~ . . ~
. Itl,Æ).lli1' tI~ ~,
+i'.

~ tlAA ' /Æ-,~/i. ...,'...,'~..! .~ .1,/, ~ U'. # // , ~~/, /.~ '. :" ?t~,'l
1.~..~ .~ ~. rJlA4 7'd dl~ëd.-4.L ........~;, :,::".:~:~~ f.

.' .-~ z,-'~;¡a. ~./'!Go~.d ;,&, #~. .:..).. ;t¡:. .. _".4 t7 , ./ _. .i' "y~A' ~ ::'d:~.~ ~.~. 6. '. ~~~ ~. /"~~~. '.. ~ynu Pvv,,~... .'lh~~' ".~";.~" .7t' Rl/~o;~ ,~tl~L~.-r¿J or.-'. . ../ .,"~: ~

('./~ ~ ~~r~..?p~) " . ."
¡;.. _ / /J

~.l) l ;l.~lløtØU~~ .../7/.-ß . ,'.,; ¿.. ..A ", .?~~ . 1(2 ",¿I.

, ¿-2..' .. "i~ .....' ,.~.,,.t.Q " .
~l'?'MA"1_ -.~~ "r;i~ ~'... . ';". :.
,. AA..~;A _.tA4-e O,hlA~. ..' ';"~ '..'13
t,i4 ..?if ú(. /...i!.~'!?.i~ ,~-,....~'. ~;. ':.~~.

...~(.-¿d 4i'zd A-(.:f't.r.ú~¿ 4-/7~u:.-~ 'J/ ~:!L ,,A~"~/'/:.I't..- . .,~'.:.

fJ/"1 d..d :/"". .v/rjf~ /~ ø .. ~,-; . ".if;.
~'f.., b~ A ~ . .,/r 0' , _~i';\~

r-.. ".. ",'A,ú~;iil \.,. ' ..

¡¿ :7 /',; .....,

Case 1:07-cv-00271-RHH

Document 56-2

Filed 05/15/2008

Page 10 of 30

-'. '.,

. :.l-...~,:...-

..~ ,7 ~ 1 ¿ _# _/ r'Y. ¿~ / 'c.'."". ..~~ ~~~.' U.r/4-?"a.r~~ ,.
,',cr" ./~l'dv~. .t:R"/4.7-.-erl-i~~¿l4"'d- ? ~"(~ó!.t;;7 ¿-¿~ ~t-~"',.. ....:..;~

, i' /J"0~ . , "t7 r "/l1-l~('"',r /'""..L:~'?~~~r~~ ~./¿

(/~. 'J ~ ~.41.(I; ~;~l. ~a-/&'~~ /¡l/J ~o/~ a,) -?..

f"'c4 5?~~a~ ~~.& ;(Lr..~L 7f-.. i. ....:: .

rQ.,'(Jí7~/ w¿~vr -t.e-tQl"lZ" íPwl a'.(" ,.¡tr".,o .,(ta,.".oIp~" .~oQ .,,'n~ :".&~q.:J p.,s'id g'rltrol 10 (/c,..~/r e..-?t~,,) ."l;...",e ..A~i..~-_v:,_ ~..,"",

iM(;r-"'''''¿ ~.?, ,;1't'4.-/~t'''.ee;¿ tbf¡¡¡;¿ a.,.d ~d .'. &"'n.u~

I .,'-,4 oJ" .~ . . ¡ '/' './ (,

¡ il _,/ . l."/ . /, ;

¡"Ú40-rA. r..i"t -?~"'1(l.~ ..(,J-f''I"e. /7 .tlfv.~ .A.t:~(.o'¿o n....7 ~-r:

I, ~.-:., J_'; / ;' '"//' . _ r ./ . // . ¡f. A ..
~ ..'~ ¿2-~,~y;." flk~id (h.ve /t¿.~d~r6 é,"? r4'", 'I'",~~

Ig, ;''" "".", "~,.:/..~ ¿1 .- L _ 'I''.~ I (/.' _L' ~'~.L' i... ?.-. 1".. / " ..,'l.'.. i .¡ '" Ai, ..., r.' .. _ I ,"~.. ó'.,." -l )':-? d'.,r"',.... i , ...-X-/ y 7 ~ i" C/ I
it~ ':I~/7aa~~~~~¿,"¿~e-~' "t~"':',,~ " ...~ :..ú.~a-dldr-.¿~~7-'~"'~-e,,~ æ-£ ..
'I t:'(,l// 6: C~ r.",~~..~..¡/.,'t~.r!.ø~'''¿-; zL~::¿,o/-4 . . ,.,:d::' .'

I :r ~ (7~ ',,7 e? ,/ I~. /,,, .;/ ~ ":: /~ ./_. . i
¡~. .~1!,~ ?C;!.?_' ;;~I;,.'¿4/~~., d..f,(J .,1f"";~""¡¡ ..~-' ~~_ .... .;.;':' ~

--/. I ' , . C?~ .'. ~ #0 1..-: . ,./ Gi~'1-";~ 8~~r~#-:~:7~
í'~A~ (lw'. 'Vtl4~..,en.,n-ø~r¿,~V. ¿;',u-4ud7.A7-? '

'- .' _ it r/ (.1 C/ '. lf~ /' -..:.;:~' ~~..t!~,..,' ~ ... . . - I '..' ,

1:L¿6. "~";/.~~&ÆZ'U;¿'' "-~;'~.'.~ _*..n¿''f,¿ fi.q.4-1/ud~..__: .

, 'f~~.z, .-.,.¿a.V'~~'¡( a~.. At:(..~.lt1,.~ /t.~~w.t;e 4,.~ r._., ...'.. ,...;

r'U'l.d;'Y~alt )/".~t ,u..id/d--.!.t ..m.;~t:-¿:~ ;"l'£ ~.:~::.ecr"'¿'''.'i "''7:;.~'" IÆ~ /..~U,~ V7 ;I~d'd~kl.~ ,AuZgL¡f .~:'' .¿&e ¿çH-J-~~7'. _ ,!. '¡';,:;' :~'

!'Ú¿.(...¿~ w;~...~¿:7-l, l'~~~.,.,.~ ¿iq,L.....,,:"t" /'Iov, A,~.L';;r- ~ ~i#'. ..L-:.. ~

r~~q, i."n,d Or"./ ..~ ~""~,. ¡; -."~;

¡ :1~l-a4 a-u/, ¡t'(r.~~,? /Yr/~.4~J"V ,....o¿c'r.." 't~.edi!,~ .m,. r'¿r...

- ~. I

! '~..,å~.. I?_ti:...e..... (/'.~ (:~..v...~-"'~ ".I;-(.i-c:1; -.~f,t:,~.(~~.¿,,~ í ;:'."t a..o1'.'t: '/"'"~'Io(1" ~ //;.t.~ V 'l) (f..r..Ol.... G(~~ 1' ... Ý //1 '.. ""~!

: #. .47. ¿' .' G' .~4,l''.'. J 'A/Í 0' " v . z '//:..(i "".-,6' .' ','
, './ / , . '. .., ~ ',:;) I

l(6oM. :.,,/0 ::""..~~~~ -. ~.,~,d~_" ,..-..u..y.. f

i .4~~:eI~ ¥.l.~_f;?¿ ~/ ..t4~ . ~L'I.~~..L9'C(""4'.d;.. ~ ,

r! .it 7,J ""'Y4'l""!l./ ,,~. /"'~"l:: YI..-i.-;¡ ,(t.'"''$~'' .a;, '~""1'''''.:?!~(~.4,K

Jt¡':'_":'~c.l'l,"Z,7 ,(./,,l i':"".. l'~/,d l':'~g.'''~'i;,? .......;d:. r:/o .,.~,,~.,,~ /"!".,......y..., l..._ ':.:: ,r/t-t~¿"'..L ~è-(..l'_,l.I'.... ,('/' -l~"'r.r.....,. ,....., ~i?..: ! .4-eu.;.t _?:i ~.t,.,.",;.Æiý1",

" '- ,..,.,...," I ¿. I ' . ¿'. ./ - /.,. .~ i j ;
i .. . /¡J A ,r... /" ,(.' , .' .
! ,;yf.A'~",.(,¿u-d ,. r-f.~ i "1,$ .' in i .~.. t I"J-" d/.. "."l. -,le;..";/,:;~ ~ ~y/ /. ".. .l

, .. , /. '.' ,/'1 I

I i ;¿ I'I,./ .~i..~ G 1;l'l,-t9!..~..i,c..I-i:..('..c''.''1.'7 'Co..... /of'!.. '''K (..r'/ ""#'I'e'r",.,- I - . ./ .../, ~. /' ¿., - . '.t.,~ -' ' , ~JltA . i '~""bct

.t ",1 (.1 , ;,;, ,. ,.,1,..-/. ,

; .Z4,u'á 1._1, lL- /...1..(: c~:j I'i'/ - ~~.irt~ (l.J '~'l(',L 7'r-r,/ /-u~.~ )j§~'

! .. (/ I :.....~

~ DEFENDANT'S

! . .' . / _ ;.;:.::At~ i;;'

j
I

ir

EXHIBIT

3

Case 1:07-cv-00271-RHH

Document 56-2

Filed 05/15/2008

Page 11 of 30

~/492
//1 f' I'

&

.... · .V¡":?::~\'~~~~ll~~';'l'?F0\r ~W:'J.:.'

/. ¿Ç-- . (;I "" ':'-:.£~,..,..~_.., " ". '.' i '''. '. ¡"" r."d. -\.Ú..n'I i/-fA-i-; (M"'al~:;,wù:;~~_..~
':ltf.""r.tt. /oo'~.'¿/.' ()'/¿t-v.U% /f.((j~~l...~~~.¿,~a,_

1 'I.... .'1 .'f I.,J'UA¡~(/~~~ .Ad,u.zÆa+~~~..~~+.:~~.~:..: ' i

. t. 'I./,..,.¿ ':i-..U''' ..l;'(~~~-/k~t7;-7~'; ;¡,i-IA~'a~:\~,,-V~ '71A. ',. I

...,. : ,:.'.'r..!í:...u.': ..... __.......... ,_ ¡

. ;/ , ' !

I

',,-, l"'fo,.tl! .e.L~id. ',,"70M.-:.;&.~,.~~../, /¿/,,,"".~ . . ~~r- "l!~ '-lJ I

,.; i ,'I:"(.,,.¿ ~''''i,tl,.t'n¿''7', . ....._- -.... ._.., I

. .'G " J~:(.Jt.~ a ,,~ ~ ~XJ't""è~ ii-/,.. ,4-~'¿ '~~'~~"~r""A~J.""¡

..1 ir '/ '. / .. ;, . -.;,. ,/ . " , . ./1

//.~,lt'b..n~tr .¿",l'¿"~", "l',~;;rM.?7-T/~.4.ù~~ "~'~~l l:~....Ie.I'_M'I'l-?~.I-~-ell.~~".!J a~û-"'~_i: ~J'~y 7r-..4

v-I..(! a.'~"'7 'U17 i~/r-_.,.,,'l, .' . ., ,. '- . '.~""" ..:,:.. -- I'

.~" ~. ~ A '~"'~f,~",~lJ7vv~~,. ~;.J' I n, -t~...IV/.'l" _ . ~ .A~ ..~ ~~~.~? i
,r;~.".,-dJ .~:",(~ /;~~.....i.~~;: ~uc.L 7Q.~eZ~v .~~::~Ç-!7- .

, ,:M.e'~L~' :J/~Y~~~"vi.~~~,

.t..l'f~('Vl,e,;lrr q~ ,(Aúi: ¿~Q.~ l) .~~._.~. .-,1 /
~ i I I

¡t1.1~-vA-: ø;¿.Lo ?;~A.:t.d~~.d .~~ ¿. é .(1,/~'.~i( '''~¿:¿llr./~o.¿~

;'~/~4(.(...-r.(J A.(/J ~.. -k;; lJ.'7'~~,a~ ~"'7-'~r""A/
fw.. fk.l.,r¿; .lAtä.7lA.""
.:0'1

(7?~.::""~) ,I i'n Ú /,1'1 _( (.h;:;~AJJ ) ¡:
'lt'(A""7 r "~~,('C;' ) 9! ~ ,A ,...",. ~ I

. J I..,,, / ,! /.¡AAl I i. .) .(
).. . /./1 ~.,¿ -/ - er' ., ,
!:l,.~.. ¿ ...'; ,.,~~. ':,)7' 1f1'1A ¿i.i-'4'¿d&d7~"'¿; ~¿' 771

i

"

f
i

.i

( v " ~/.. ~ ( ;J..~.i'~-~-:fri~;~ .." '.'_.' ~ I

: .t~¿-.....r~ ~ -'~/~ I

I

,
J
,

'a::ø~~tt ~:l~~~~ ø~.." '~~'''~4e'':~-c~ : ~..'t'-VH,"~ ~ ~ Æ. ,~)~uw_,~~,~~~l~¡
. ~ t.ff'f !'(t;Y~"~7' ..e.",t.z'~WûWlb1 a.,ç(~~..z:~ '~~..I .'

i
i
! . 1 i ¡

~w A?-~:f",,4e.,Cl --;r..ç ,(,-r..~ "'-'" :n"'~~~~_.~~a.~b ¡
I~~~ r ( , I 'r1.tA,(æ'o wi v"............ j

,.'e.Iý, a,~), ~".7'..., ~ ~'.... .,........ ...... I ! .. ',.f? . '4 ,I, .',. .:~¿- ""J"',,'''~' '.o!.
(Z:. · · tf (" 01 "/ "-ioe~~ 1(. /....g_~"... .":.:.:._._~_.. . ...'. .. .

. i . .~. ~-I' ... ~'............_..~..~.....'l.~.:""... .."l ~~~ ~ .í.__.._. .-..... .' .~.. L.rbZ~;~~"~"'::::::~~~':"J'~'~~,:':'~i.::,: .~tii . t . ii..__.; ... ..~.:~ .,:~;~;:~~~:~.-

l .. .c.~': .,- . _ . ... .....:
~ ~.¿.t.,;I::~':,: .'

Case 1:07-cv-00271-RHH

~488'

~.=_ vi__.

Document 56-2

Filed 05/15/2008

Page 12 of 30

"""'. :":"'~""~'l."f~:'Vr;r:;~':J.t~t~&'ï;~~:~~': ." :

,;' ,;ii '(4'/.(.&,/i/,//-' i'i, /~. ~"ie'" .. : 7/,l~'1 ,tè.t . t. i' ,,'" ~ ~;'. A¡;~~' .'

,.1 ,~:¡ 'J/,G,~eLl/J¿ ,r/I/);/lerLi ~1'k../ß~¡..:,¡:~/it....:;¡~f~, ¡.

l"P¿"?.4 r,y...til, e:U~H¿;Ø .-;' ~¿( .~.. ..A~: '. . ~~.-,c:

, (Y;/(t1.1.,.~ c-ol-. r;i.l). fI..",.i.i.r.(,¿ A/4 A-Gë:t cú-u ./~.~ ¥/.¿~

1'/ U .£¿ , ¡ . . ~ý.vc:ró.~:.:~~.
i~l-'If""~.. ;,,,' 4of:U.: i4~~? '" ¿ d M.-: -1~.~...., .....

"';-1 /1'let.4/j£"';' ø~ 4/4, ~~",~~~~j,. ~~ .~. i

~ ,.1 - ./ ~ A// r-I '.' /. _. J

" . " ¿I. c~ J d " , I

¡..¿~,4.~~a;,a~''id ,C!t#?"i'¿';. ~;u. .~Hf.~Ó: ~~

¡1;:7: dI~". ~ -J~.. .'. .....:....,....... -.

1" ~~....,da..3_.. ~. I . ~,J, c;:~//..
I . . . '.. .. ...i;a-.,' ~~ .C:~
I c'Je.ø a~wt A.l~d a../ A.f!('U~i d/¿.;Ð, ~/~..7 .I"'"

('Z . (7

: .~-;.d-4/~/ t" ,¿;~;;~ t !&

I(.._4.~~¿.4~ . (Í . ~ .' ~i.y~. Çl~r/ I
ia.~. 1"! ii; /01;;,. Z:' " ',. ' .. -" .

I ,~. ~.¿¿, ~a~~ ~r~.

'ld.rl"..(?¡.7~J:¿'jM~~~. I

.,t"¿i-d~ "..(~:.: C"ry~ l¿ ~,.~b:,_ I
¡.ry,...utl.t!,,¿ (.~~) .6.:~ nM~Id~.. ~ ~~ ~/~ I
¡.tt.fllf ~:~(,l ~(,~/. ~l,- d~ ri~7 ~¿ ;kur ,'U.(!~ ,r¡,,~z ¡
1"1. it?.' 7' ii ('k-I'("#"'¿1!&..0 "\t~"l'c./t;~/)"o/~~.. Zr.-.. f

t¡ ';l¡" ~/ til- ¿l.i~id ,"M. (JlI~..c"('~'.;~.~" 7)'Fi- .A."""" f ~ i

'!o/a,)d'''~ 7k1A.4l .~~~k "J' ..g 'Á~¿ . I :¡ t:h- '¿, tl¡j r).l.~,.~/~ /j "

!a,i~iæ~~:? '~~~~f ~7~"~~ ~~i4

1Y't....",., ~...~ /7çU-;'~.A.u-'' ¿~~~ M....fU~ ,-t~ (.~ ! i d":' ...V'n-u.d" "¿,'ict ~ ;AL(.~'--, ~~Ut~ .' ~ 7 ,~~'
jit .IL'.' I~) A.~.Û~¥U /.Ä,-¡,~.,,~c;6'U¿ ø;~),~-. ~ ~'j

i L i / .LJ JJ ,.g. ..í? . ~ I
! l; ~ (~ ( i ,.' n' c7 ær. _~ ::.' ;~.a,~..c:". &t d.~:.:;~., : d'it ivt; \.~i;. ,c.ll~.t/ ,)~.H~. .:.' I _ .-,.

.tl ~~',. ...(lU,"#-¡t't/(bl~ ~U"'ld~~ ',ø'.u,~'¿:~u; ._y I ~et~iV-,/¿~l"1.t:~:r~~.1.~t/~-:,~.,.;i.4.~¿, ....", ¡.

t1 1/(¿ti"c, __),á-l/_O~~ ;Q"'-r~~: ,~~..7.W'."..', j ¡ ll.l;;(; "i,,,cr. Q?-(-t~.I/l;,~ ~~-:~"... ,: ...:,......,;..; .,.. ~'i ! i ?¿ ~7~~~j:~::~f::~\~~~~:.h~~
~ DEFENDANT'S
~ i ,.... ..,,' .,' :: :.;.,....,.:..; i ~ 'j..: ,.:i:.~~:2:;~::,~:!.,~;.~.~;, :'~~:;.~~¿);:.'~.r.~d:::i;;:;~~i.~..::.;,~ ,:::... :', ::: I,

! E4l1BIT
~

I

7.

Case 1:07-cv-00271-RHH

-

Document 56-2

Filed 05/15/2008

Page 13 of 30

! ,(: ..:;'~¡: ':'()';¿~""':\\~t1;~:t'":'i':"t:!k; ~.,.'.,¡.. ""'\ ..,,: · '(. ~9; l

~'~~~~~..'~~~;;~'¿R ":1
"~~- ..--_2~~J~"¿
reUl (l~/ii kb ~,,,.I-t"I~AZ ~G~¡n.",...,;:I-d:,.&L.,l/

" '~~~.P~F)~~~In~:r,AM4I¡¿

~~~::d~râ~~c~¿

. .~ ...(2 y ~:.~ ~~:v~ ~t.~ ¿;I~", .

,~/~ . d::'-:":-T~:--~-i;r t' ..~~ ,A~ i.--7~ .7~ r/._./TV~J') -') i,.,',c . ~.

. l

",l)~,~~ "'Y~~~r4;y'....,..

.......':~ ~..017n',,, ,~.:~~/;.~".7~./Úr~::"~'" ........ :.....~~,. ..' .o"¿'l~~-'~Æ~Q"yux~';_". ~ct,' ~: .~d~ . r: r;., ~ .L.;/'" ,:

..øu4. ~,.~~~~,~i: ""£:~. /,1~.. . ...., . .... ~ .~.~~~-~lf~. . ..,.;.
~r~ ~~.J/~~-?,~g~(L;~ .~,.,.~:~ ~,.~~~g~ed~Yld,"'k~¿f ..:~;::~.'
l) - ..';(i;~l-;l:e (.1 6J,".) ;¡~¥~~ ""H.,rt/¿n:e/. . ø. ./._~..,¿e /A ~ cr.-4~) ...-.'.' ..,¡. . A:q £o.~~ ~ ~. (Tng' // h æ' ~ ,......;~".f
~.t ~,J '.6/~/dP'~b¿'4ei,c~:T'~'" ." ~- ..~ y4';: ~ ,,/$'äd Y ,. ~.a~'
i u /;¡nr .¿""A¿~¡')J ~"A''/,; /)?'¿,c.,.f!Q,. dl~~ ~l4. ,
e,rY/;l'ñe'J~ a'+L¿/Jp.f";.~ ~;r4 k;~.. '7:P - g-~... .,

~~y~ Æ~~~ a..v/~ ....~-?. .:

~'?~ ~~ (lr"/.tj p~~ ~~~~V /M A4'".¿d:
1,!aU (i'M4M,Z~ ¿~/êu..L'dh~i¿:.~. ~/Æ ~ .._..
,~ereI r;1, ~"" ~ ..~~'t:(;~i-ie.'Z-i(/o"" .' L/¡""'tø~~. ,.,?'';.e."r~ -. ;_

, & ./ -Y._' a /.."1 ..~_ ~//q" -..

~r,'7Ji,)~~d~ ~~~/~..' ~~ ~~~ ~ ~.4..- ~.,~ V7¿.;7 /:~
.. &lr~~ ~ ;/~ ~U"~ d-z./ot, r ...~..... Al~,. 7'¿

U,"',,g";N'¿ ~ (j'?,.., ~~.n'3~ - ~;f'- 6~~ M ,ý/\.~ .. ,

V'~. ."..;-Pu/í. AJ..d ¡?.~i.,. .. a~.r"a.,.__ ~.~, ..~eet .'

cI /l_~./.~ ~. './ i .fi ~ ../ ~ 7,.#

,,),~ ~(;Ll'..;:. t1 p./. l1~ "J.i.,'1.'~~,;,rI~~.~.' u---¿..,'ldZi. po, /~¿R-~l.

t',..~ I"w.ruu:'d ...Il..~(.~ r-e.~~ '7"7c ~~4 .... ;.:::~:~.~
":':'" .. . ... . ~ ;_';'~"" ......... ..., . .. '., ., "".' ......_ .' . ',. ..' ':.',,::' ¡;;. '..;j;..~j:ll;.i¡f:r

~7 -/b.a (~ t1~/,~/c.~t/"lC¡"iz/. Jit' r¿e "J'Z./:~,.:r~.. ,..:;:.,...;:?

Case 1:07-cv-00271-RHH

"'490

, ,'1" '4~;'l-i th-i.',;l(,_",,¿'U/¿(/'/~), t1MA¿Â41;o 1?"H;'-~:f..:,.,:f.If; . I

¡ . 1 r .. " ..., ~
.w

Document 56-2

Filed 05/15/2008

Page 14 of 30

· . "- ,- . (' .- . : '(-~i;"2i;~r;:~"'E~11r~~;''''" "¡ "

".',( '&A'l;t(cJa.l_~ ,,-r~4¡'1'. ~n; l.M~~~~~., ~'.2' :" i 11

-!f.,(lU" , "-1"(.(.1 (l.a,."".,,¿ /rt(7,tk,,~A, ~QH.z~ ..~4. ~Ao'LlA.r./~~l'J'¡'(? ~e.(.~;¿Wi.",,A,//~~bYl- :~7 -- ¿,~ i

r~/,I;;r/~~7.. '.'~ .'.. ~_...~",......~:......~..~b:'.::,. i

¡ Jc. ~a..;-~.."",~..~,w~'11Ç~ ~/~"~:.

"'~~~r.ed .tc¿pU'~l~ ~'.Úi 7~ ~:J~rJ';7 rM ~~~, I i,\

r4~/'ld~~~~~~'~7r. :1
: :¡~,f!4/i~/r..X~,/lA~~./ Û'n-hta~. a~~7t~ I

:_-&4 -'~~Ul'.?-t ~ ~1.-vvr~ .., ., ... .. ...., ,. ... .! 'i'l

~l.., -k ~,.. ~ ~;s- ~ -. /--r~ i ~

(1;;' /a,/'.".v¡: "~4M-~ '7""I'~':'~~YI nii. i -t~1.d,. "oilUh'rY~.u..~r'~ø4 ~ ~~~/t

.t?~~~ß. ~~~~i;¿A~'~' 'I::. :"1/~'N& ,t~1 ¿'r;. /l~,¡,çl,r~ ~'~~~r~~ lal~I1'' Il1U:TbH.. (~ '2 I: I d '., i2'A .?~ .~)

~ t/.t1~~~ ~ - J(tl~~ ~ .. . l: ; r t' f''; ;' ~~" '. ,.y.."'Y 'J I j' ,¿n.Vt~iJ /¿ .. . . .. ' . \ .
1 ih:. 7/!i(l' ~.a~ -/~vvdk ~Nu.oA~,'¿ . ~ tJdL,~~'1; ~, II

L~._dA-¿z:_~1~~a:::' I ~
i 1'/ ç/ ¿'/~. _£.J I' X
· ¡;''f!~''?- ~ ~~.,g. "'';r! i 1'~' rf~ee~,~ ¡I¿~/.r ..~~,~8hAN;;47":~ I : /l,t.;,/",..,. t.-I.u:....,.t.r. .. ...., .... ,. ..
!I~PI;'~ 1;..14 /A'A.."" ~h 0'14,;,U.,e '~~-U "~'~~~ ¡ii

i ,'!/('N"": "IVI"l,tv ~~.~ ~ ~7~,~~jr/¿
1(.~t&~~-~1;.('7' a,~ ,/?,J. . ' . '...,.. ,... ..., _ ..'.' ~. .

: ~ ran~¡;V'~"U.ø-", / ~ ..r~. Z ~ __...... ......,..

'/1. i/. . . '.. ~. A.. J.nLI. I

: (.~i:;l£.) . '.. .... ...Æ.;~d&U"9..., _ ¡

f?'á~~~~~'V~;l)~-"';1

, . " .. ,. .:.. :,... :..:, -, '. a~....uu. i
~

'.. ~~/~.i.1

. . ' .... .1 '.~ ...~..,.._l;.' _.':::' : ,..;'. ,¡,';:M:~~,'¡.(7.:I\::'t:''',,''''~~'' ,,:~;.~;)i?2't,~.~.: .... ~;..~r 'I. /lc.,..'. , .......,. '.."1: '.' . .~..._" ",i .......~;~.,.~~:t~.~~~i-I,.:..I..-. ~~I, .~~.~:. ..., I" ..

.
,(,

Case 1:07-cv-00271-RHH Document 56-2 Filed 05/15/2008 Page 15 of 30 _ . ..' ".,:-,-. i:'t'?:;~~~~;d:'~':~:;~i~~~ê"' ':~I !: I 500

..

.xi'.. nw!t~ 7~~~:r~"~'~~7" ~':, ',.'¡

.r':~",(. li.:-ldAu~u;'¿(la/.A.a~ r I(..Ýjik~~ /jJ,,/.e . ~~Z" ~~~~~fI¿9.b.J-~-Ã"

',~l /l, ' ...8/911 oJ .. i t.n~,.,.~~o/tMr~/f'~) . ," / ,/' . 1"/7 ; ~..æJ 1:p~~~ r~ . r /-~.-~
2 ,., # /'r' ¡r7 If

,,:'" ,t(, /jtlJdt,t/tZ tI~. v d" , . - ........., '.

, ~~tf~~ '. ,'t¿i ~Nr~

.,

. ; ,

: .'J:; jJ~) ~7f""'3¡('7P-,(2'&.1"f'~ l

:t4-,('J~7:tl.r"7 r~~"". 7J ~(2", !.
i r11M'~i,;,. /l,v,,~;i "/~ ~ ~.~.c~~~e,~.~.. J:i-~;.~¡fJ,d t:~, J: ~A' ~ "; ~~-"~~7 ¡

,¡~~~"~~~~' ~Ú1~ ". '''_ .
Ii ) tL.Ij~"-,l--'--+x-Z.c ¿44 / ~.~ ~~;r~ :. . ::"\;l1u-¡ti.- (lrt")a.p~A' 7~~... ~. ~.~-~ j..
~ yv¿dr~-.7- ~ /~~~~ ~¿/: ~r ~~ .'1 :

(:4 ~~~ti~~~~d7:~~ I~ :,9'Uw-¿~ '~#Q.t.r.cr Æ,t~ a¿A~ ~4~~~ 4ûæeJa-na'./
'Y~?I.ßv~.~"fJ,,7~~~~ ~'~.' ,.~ 1¿,,,...:,,,~h~~~'0I7~~"~~Y ...

, b -. /.J . , , ~.... j d:. /. g "~~ I ¡~~.eJY~Cq.I~ ~' /'°tu_ rr"~~"~'
~-..,¿I. "'V'W'1i., ; A:i- .~-. - .~
u - -n .. . _. :'.. .

¡;t .qM,fI'''~ ¡IDav? /A /~~_ ~~ . r~ ¡1.. . .

i;a.rRjM-w-g."'''Z''YMo ~ I.,.'., tt"..jp,....f./,,LVr.O,t.jlr.,, . ,%~p.J~~n7~n-~ :.!

¡ q 4~j(~ mu ~e",n/~~-u~i 1'.1
!"~"I'l (r.(/ ./ .4' /I d 11 ..' ,#, .~ ¿¿ I ':.', ~ &i~~ ,,~ .~e.t7~ ~~A~~ g . Ai:' f" ~y"N~ Qna. Í/~~;fHi.'~r~H2~ ! AI...nn-,d" /"1øi~ ~ U. ~Ao .ñ~~""~..;~ ! :

;.it'..r~;'~l Ð~,',~evrl~.:ed~~:.~,~ 1:'1
!&iA,t:.~ 7'~~'l.:-~':(j"~..e~~~'.'..:~':."",:,,":" .i :-l

'¡1I ..,.tt'.ldAA. ~t?~":,~~:,,, ;:.. . "';. .,i..~ , ' ,'. ~;..1
i' ,ll"_ '~l~f'..'.~'~' .\ .~J~' .: J,)I'Ø.f.'~1:::;¿i_~:~-:~~'il ':.:' .:,ti'f.. ..or.:. ','- .

i ':'.-"1.:' .', ~.~ :~,~... . ". .~~~i;Y ~gJii'ir¡'~~ti~?~~liJ1~.,~§¡~~~~~ì.;:j~~;;¡;¿&~. -,.: DEFENDANT'S

_. ..';', .~.: .:_d).1':':'~'.- -. ow:. ""~~,it~ tl .:!~~~~:;;~~.t.iSJ-~tt~â~...~¿..~v.:~e£,oJ~~

! 6"
I

il EXHIBIT

Case 1:07-cv-00271-RHH

Document 56-2

Filed 05/15/2008

Page 16 of 30

I " ,¡~.~~-; 4drJ~-~..\; '" : . 1-: . ¡"Oil
~ti '.",,y4', di.4'~~j/~~~J~ .. ~~'~." '~~...'~ Ar~~"'4""

! ,:. '3 '::",'~,::'"':~:':~''' ,::;:::,::,,:::,::,,- '::.:'::: ::~(:' ',,'7:~.:':::' , '. , .., :'501~,

~!! ~ /~dCl(7~..~~~~~,~~-zu.;I ,.. "f :~~:~~.~..~~.' ~~¡J'l;~. i ',.,.8,

nv~_~~~?:~~~; .:. " ~~~~~-."$~.(Z.t)~ J' .;:,~:'
. ",~~~~,.::,:';i;~ ,.t::=~;l'~-~.?~u~ ..~. .:':t
:z ,/J~.7:~ ~ '.-M".,,~l'~ A4¿/Æ,.:aet"u-,L ~II;:;;~;.~ ¿ , , -~ . at p. ,,;,~. . L~,¡~, ;t.~t ~~~~.~~~td~"..:.:,~;.,
,/ . /; ., ')".;

,n"-~~ -., . .... ~ . ~~_J .- . .... ..: :,:t .. , .1J~~7:.#~..~ ~ -.-f /~., , ,:~:l~: '-..... LØ"~"~~"~æ-_~'--'tJ,..",.,~;~.

/ " ~ . d7fA" , " ., ~~~::~~;=::::=:;/~' ~tt M~' . ~,~~"..~:::~¡~,\,
/ . a~J'~~ a~~4 ,:;\~~~
,.... ~~?~?n~ ~í9' ~,..~~~ Q.

(Ni44f (?~t~.17 /'¡7"'-UJ.d~~.. . " . i ,4~7 . ¿: ¿: ø ,'\..:A~

~~

¿:¿.. ';/ ~ /' ß~.".,~~ò? " .d' 0,. ~ ~ø /U. iL ~ ~
/2~ ~Z'~ñ&~~~~~~:'::!J.t

I,ka ~~..i4,.~ l't-e ~QA'¿ tJ4-e6 A!ota~~ á?~, " ~,~,~ f

~ '4- /vv ad,.,." ~. .", .,';-~

(~ --~---,.,' ..' c?~ r....4.(/~, J ,..,~ii a~Jl æ4 i?~;r
. '''. ~. ,'. ~. ~ ~..~ Á "'fI._~_. ~ ".I~

~~(7~-t#4A' Q.,a c.. ¿. ':rf,~~~ ~'" y ¿;~lfl&~"9'.1 ./ l'/. -;q _~ ~ . .' r-. (l.d¿'. /.~. -7 ,J ~~ U ~.-' ~ ~~ ,,:,,~,; ,~,~~,ul~~;r~,£.~...., --- ":~ ~¿e ~ ~ ~~~ ~.. J,:.:-:::;, 'z'~~~Y..~:&~~v~'- -7f'A~:~~.. .. ..~ ~.
"', . :,'C' ,.;'., ',1.':, :'¡,' .:. ';/:\" t:. ::..;,_ ':' /: ,'. ,.j. .:,\..~ . ':" :: . ~" ,,,'J~~~:~t:;,.';;,,~; ';;'-',.:;L'~;',:(~ ,:' ,;~~~::;:!~~~:\:!~;i~~;:;;~:~~;;d~; ;,

. ':_~/,'" 7~ ~~~,~~ ~b;-:,~~~ . .,'~"

Case 1:07-cv-00271-RHH
b

Document 56-2

Filed 05/15/2008

Page 17 of 30

. . ~ .... .~. . .~ . ~,!. \ :".::".~:¡~~':_;'~..;~ ~ "'~~:~;"" :.:.:~'ì~~r;i~-':~:( :.S':~"~I.i~:~!;~::.~!,~ :~. "':~~rtõ' .' -,;

f r ñ02

i,)t:~ 9J,p.~.: /) " , .¡k)
~ '"t. .. ,.(-l+id/ (')-7!//(a1-t Q/P/d,.(ee y~v~'. /'!I.d.f, :'17 " I

, ,':" I

'( .~, I),:D If (/ .1 ' . ' ' . .. .:. ..,(..' i

t Yh'p- ,ÜR~/'I'''''IA.W'l':.." f'r.l4U .j4A'i1 /f/n 'I) .' , , ..... 'y,.' - 1

, de-,~ ~~alu;(q/- ~~(! .#.S'/~ I~ 3/

~ ~ ry~~ ~.£~ ~~IU,

.2 ~ ,/¿ ~. // / f" "......', ;,.."t:; /fll.. ev! ..' ?to rz ., ? t?

: ;i~~~,æ-1i.~~

L Cf ~.a ~'ur~ 1: øi SL~"7 ~~ ~1L)/~"~:_~
i~:rtf~ ~.¥~~~(.y'J'¡
! 1r4:":_ .,;~C1.: _f?!'''z'''~x'.. ~~;~ 74"'i~L ¡ 1"((-'£Je..l'/ Hie ..~~~~ r/.M~, M:.)~ 4o~ d.

: 1~,4.~,r "'~~ryr7&~.\'M l" . .. . .,.. . .,.... .."..,..... .

l; Ilt'/w,llr~.t,M'~ ~e1tr'~ I'ei"ut. ~"'Z~ , Ul/".' \l'¿1~/l"'~""''''' (.re' . l,..i-~"PQ~..;~, :;~.~:~.",l'

'i~' .. -- . ,/.L. ~l:t'.- .,~. t/,~7kd d ~ , 9h:ti'f,ftA¿:." Ø~;ck (/ tf.' './ / / i
I .;. ~ t4l. ß~,(,.dLA.aA-.;: l' 4.~? ,.u- .J~~4A''C: J

: ~~~~. (Jt7~~~~ ,.e~~y~£;~,~A~
Wa~..~~ll." á d .4."' ,,£,AA~l'a':~j '1~!:~qCl.c.d/lla.t,??.,~:),
:'-l.r..li.'.l"'... '¡;dr.~d. . i -ta..:'~~~;Wt,".u. .~. ...&o4. ~. .,~n-/e._.et~.u ; I

1'~"l'4"l'",L /c~ 7& /u,a-f¡L /;~".z:r~l ,~?-..t'''7~~(1t'''

f'wdrfL .r(A..,,..~ Ae~ ~"¿i : ~~ ,D I _.. tt 'I,¿l~ f'.g. I
:,'ltA'fJ~ ~-"ie .A"-¿ /a"-~tJ ..1t .AU-.n/ . ,.~~r;-- . , ,

; l,."'~m.,..7';i:......¿~ ~~.M.;~ I
. ,,,,, , .... n .... ,(. d.....a.Hd ~b' 7l ."";4 """"7..;.."£ /.~~/ I

i;4..L",..,:a..J&r ~~-~..~.~ ; tdta:tt aA'4e¿/'re~ ,Æ~~t~. :¡;~~~,f2r
¡~ rtt if1A~~y~YI~~:~~l~7:'~
:t:"I..~,.(l(~ (~l.d,.t'~~4~~~:.~~~-, ~I~
~ tV "'ï!UL ~u-..~j;,.~'~h,:., ,~~~.. ~,./ .'al'â:'_,/ ¡ oc P. Jt .~:- :~,\,-'';:'::'~''/.';''~''.q,~:.,--,~,,~~¥~~. .
V . '., . .... ,.....,~ .r:' .1;,;,4"~:'~'.~'.,( .':~l:"~\:~~'ir.~,.,i~':'~~~;A?~'~~~ ".,', .;~,"..t.7,'i...rl~:.:i:~'j,,~~,: : ~~.::~ .'..- '. i ." . . . i....:,.,:..a :,;,,_,'i~.-t(.'K~\...1oL"i..,.-.~w~~~~..~-i~ .ir~..,~,.~~;.,\",...I""....ri"';"':. ,.,~..,. tI .,

l

Case 1:07-cv-00271-RHH

Document 56-2

Filed 05/15/2008

Page 18 of 30

. " .,,::,~ ~.' ~ . ::...t,.I:.~.:,~: ,í~. :':~'~ '::I:.:"I;:..~?~~\'~! ~,:-.~~'.~':~:'.~:: ~.'~;'''::''~::'~'i~:-'~ .....: :~. . .:-:'. ,.

), . ". '. . . . :.

,;..¿:~.k~" 'k",,,.., ;¡~?~7)f:;;f:~l;'I;;1./ .
.... . ....w . 4.~!lZ~ .~ll"~~'ll.l; ~.l-t~,.y.~, ~uI..~~,~'W~:d. ) I - ...:J Z '7.~,:i ",r.- r.A .
.'t ''I' ,", 'V / tl .lt..,~¿:..; '" (i.f,'\"':¡'lhl f~l ",~t:'y'" if.. ø.r:~,..ll";U ,
,( ~J' .' l,. (, " ~ I f l 1~~U ~ Ii 7- 'l l-,i H~fl ~l.'l',~,(!l ~ íl'(J,l,f-l~r./¡fd :,t:..,;,~l;Jt

. ",'~ l Ù~~". l(, .rt?i'!J p., fa; ß"l-l:ft :Y'I¡¡;' "tCV.,,~jO&~~ 'I.r¡,~",;,l:
. \ I l ( J (9 ", ~1 't' '.~ (1,..'.l) 'l. i'("(.,,,~ .'rlf: 4Ú~,,'l'H'(. ,o¡~r;r.û,( ,.i' .,~ø,;;""~t,~

. ~.¡, l~tu ~/ It: ;i, lt!;4 ..i,l.k..' ...6~~c.t~ "is,.,;"ra.-7' r ;;rtJ"'l-U
, :

., 'l' .. ~~~¿y I'I..A , , l.' ,. . l- /" ,: ,,:.

/ I: :I (/ / ". iI ~g,. ,-,~ ,?.J

I ..., i~t ,~l"";l ~l'lf~(...l.H' ~"~('~("H'l"'f'G"'~'~;" 7"""Clr""l'#'~4~ll~lf",*~ .

.;/hit ..4,.'i.L ~.l.¡,',l 4 tl.û.~!~..t.t.,1;'rhft. l~¡tU#l.,l/¡llt-tl ~~~,,,L

~,('é.~l ;ii'hi.ytc-l'Ji''¿l'~ , ,', ,-/ 1~~?t'I.l"';"~(;l .1Z,-~ Z -. ~~d...., ¿) .u aH,l ,;de-,~I,? Ã.~~~ d - /Jú...6~~.u. ,'Ü.-I,1'1(ù..c£ C¿.I.-I&¡l 1!7-"''-L-;'ut,:

,ft.(.'(,.VK1.-- . f¡¿ ..,........,.. ,.n..M.I p- .'1.A/_ ~-..:.. ,~Lu£6. ',. ,"/' ..~. '/ .,.., ..7.R; ,ddt; ~k....~ ~ ~~ ~,u7~"
¡./..~:... '/':" '/')/ d~ ~-ß~j/,/ ~".-.jI . ...L_~~" i
'rU'M'~J 1'~:tr.. o;jC."UÑ7~ '(Û(.~~' . ';vt .' ~. t7.. I

;-ll)t!...k.de.g.~l'~. 70/. et ,ú4. /~. 4-~.~y a.MlIN.I(Ur~''' ~ !

¡ ,0 .. ,.du(,"I~...~It~~v. (LcA..-4J/ ~""r?# . v ø _// ", /1 i7 ti _ lT ~.~l1'f: 'Ot(,~.. ,. !/t; ~;I tø,.~: . . .... , .. - ... ,.....,', .
I. a..(;kt.,~ ,c: c; ~~ ~ ..:~. '" no) ¡I~~ .~ a,~'

IlUN¡;/t~~~eq,L~,,¿" (l~k~?~ ~~

\ i1~MA.. ':l /& ~.d,.~ &,.( ';A.E ,0: ~,¿~~. ad' ìdt ,.6t"."I/t. "",, "'u vi/~~, a. ""~c.fi ~ ~~ ,.ot/

. ,7 ..¡. / r /,1 " g .

! ~ø,~,,,.~~,,/ Mel r~~ ~~';tl1~~~ ~ ~ 74 i
! .~1;d.e~~.. dM'~. ¥kr~ ~ &), ':~ (?4-ri't. -,Ch'

¡ Ä'ørd ~ ~- ~ ~ 4)440 (ì.)'- ~Jl?, ¡
, .t .l/iL,et /ld'~ ~ 1 ~ ~ A., e4a-. Q?~

:..,¡ ~'~4 _ /.~~, (W.~ ~..i . ~~ ~7~. l'l"I"ç/ AA?-lwI¿'" (f.JJ.tlJfe- -~ . ~n, ¡ '/J J'
f'fi~..~;L¿¿~u-~. 'f,'~.N ~,~tl~..f; ~.. ~~nt.
~f'I'I'M'e.,,~ _ 't.l4; ,;f.f'u, .... "... . ,. "

l")L-,.aA-£M.I (J""ÛI r~' ~ eu.L.~ ~ ~; V~ ¡ ';4t. ,'¡' ,,,,,,it' "~ ".e.t4"'l-v£ - .t~~~ jot).,

. /l"~ J~/.~ ~ ~(l~)/U/~~" t, ¿f ,~ ; Û..
~ "7.Ht.~ ~,tA;rl1f7 /e. (),.;" ~d ~7 ~ ~ ~
l ".. . .....: .~.."I . ::~:..':". ;S~';..'~';-¡¡""'.'~-;;~::i::;.~.~... ..'..... ':';.': '.'

l

!)'''/l;t, ?,u:~i, tt4'4;t;¿"~~r~'~j('~

~ DEFENDANT1S

i
l
~

i

EXHIBIT
CO

Case 1:07-cv-00271-RHH
I .'
i

Document 56-2

Filed 05/15/2008

Page 19 of 30

! i . .,' ~. :" '. .' ' ~;; ", '. ,...::::~:~( 3~ . 'lL~'~"'¿,~~.,~.a.,7 .~..,~, . . .fea. l.~__~ ¿./ , :'. ,',A

i" /.n '.' v,.~ ~~~~ .' _. ,r,

.,'6itet /d", ~èWP¿¿¿ ~'L":~' .~. .'thve" d;l~~~ :~'''.:::r~i~~'

, '¿~'i~kl,t#) .Jht.;7.d~ ,f",,(,;r¿M7.~.~ ~~, .~~:,\;;' '\

..~~.~. .~. ,,"'_ '. ' ,I, .. ,tv - /.-,. .g , ,~~ ..~.~l'"'IJ~~~~~..., .:..,!::Z~"
/) .J . . . tJ /. . l7. ~.r " ;:
(J1$';!~~~. . ... ;;~..- ß' . ....: j;
4d-t.4 .""c.i, _.: -,,'t . ,~AA:/ a,;i,¿ ,tg'~;¡-d ".-~ ~U" t:~.,~. - ",,;,~,W ,

. ~~~ ~. ~.".4+1~.~ ~~~.. '-"~:';,t~,. .~..Ø//...l..A. ..J( rZ' & rl,~. ~ ,.,~\.t,.., ~.~.~,~. :;')4./;~__r T.# 1M I~ ¿J.."';," H.' ~ V... .~. ,~., 7'-'~~' ~h"~ ,;~,.~. .... ".' "S' ~ ,/ ¡;.1., J.~ %J" ,OJ '-:. .'::"~~"~', II -. ;¥~ - ~ L. ~ e~ '.:-"..1:;, ~. ~~' r~ ,~l. ...,~ -. N#J --.. : :s

~; .. - _./ . '#~..,J t~

, .....'.,.. ~ .,', ' ,.,' ,~. '~,;.~ .

~ ..' . ..A: _ _:' \~

'. . ~~.. .~~~_.Ø4.u ~ R~,;-~,. .- .......(.,i,

~~Y~~-=~f~Y ..;; L . . -._ . .i- _....,' :.;. , #. pi... r._.',,..,~...I, ,'.i¡'''~ ~. (.J/) tU~.,..~a; 'i,~~~,d?,r~j .. ""'' .- . d&~.,.-~..~., :.t:;" " ' (A . _ . ~~a~4~7t ~;;" .. ,..", l'; , .... ,/J~~_' l". .. " . " or: fl,~...-. .,:, ':_". ~ I' -..
7./' - , . . c7 r: .' " '. "~r

.tr~~~ '~'~~ hV¿ .~~~~ ¿~':-'\1:,'
~ N~ a." ' ~.) ~- ~ aL'~á %..../~~A¡ Ø?" .' ~:~ ~~.~

.. tV ~.. t: t:d #;¡ ~Z,/ . - '£ tn ør~ P7".".: ," ..:~:

y/~ .u~;?~ ~4~~ ~ ~.~. .":'::11~
A. y~ 4.',~ ,~~"Z ,~ui__i.~,_ A!~d'. ".;:)';

di y~r~/~~~ ¿~~'~¿.~.~fU1!. . .... tki( ,Q~~~'" /'-- h :Y~H ~~~~;:~~~~~.~ 7tA.4- '.

..IÙÜ...~ ,ta~.wa.J ~ ~w~~ 7' .~ ."'.i...,../~ . ~;

/ ,/ /,, A / ~p; ....

.J ¿ P Q.yJ'~~ ". .1£ . ' k.. 7~i4 ,r Ut' ~ r/: ." J2 J' ,. t/ I',/ c/ -i ./ y'/ d, ~.-~. ,:,: .':. c/-a ~ :P~ /~ C.~ J..v - '. :'''l.~
qL~.7""~7: SA! ., .
¿;/AI.7! 0/ ~ d~ ,) . . -; ", ~'~:.~~:.~.' .. C:/.y~.. ?):~,tI,..7/;r ,rb~~~..7/.~.-J-r~ øl';~~:;i:."'~"
..... ,l";'
. .' ';'-.ff~:~.....:." . '(. t.,. . . "',i' ,.~~~ .:.~::i¿l~~"~~ ,

--'~~ç' ," ...,',:,J . ~~ ~ . ~7&l".~.,~,¥/¿.".,~ ...,~.,";~.':
i' ./ r' ) (.~,O p /. ~J.,"~¡".,

. _" .. ÍN7 e... ~¿e~ (~ ..,..:'..,'!':'

Case 1:07-cv-00271-RHH
.:',7".:,-.::
'.'. \' .. ....~f..!.

Document 56-2

.. .t.... .-:,....~.,.. :. ," ....

. .::. .::....,. ", '....~... .".'

Filed 05/15/2008

Page 20 of 30

...-......
i

, .,.. . . ...__..~_-~--_-...._r..

.._...--._.p.......~...;_._--..... ....,po

... ...---"'----_.-_....

dO it,n., ' '. '...' "

. utI an4, COnTl!r~\lllt,D,i t)i'.-',..I,~14 Ani.e. B;anaab 1111 thiit. oortaln "'l'tJhlli

'¡ô~e~lbed..1 tGUOW", ,v"a:' 'i.Oíll'J1U~b~\'''d. light (S) and.Sevln ('I) ,mó thi yut. (1/2)

~~ '. ,'~
cochh't . . ".. ...,

hut Ql J,t'IiWDl' s1i. (il) .iri Dl011l(' n~llroi~ Hun4:~d, Th1i'tY".IJt, (i;,ii) 1i1tuah, In
~t8l. CO~tY Dr. coont,', '~e.rr~ tori or Arizona.. aa ~ounda4 ar~ 4oQcr1~cd upon A ~p
enUUed 'Ilp ot iioIlSia.:,~owi.ltoi lle by'JI.' G. HO'lI, C. ,1", dated .r"o\ll1'y ia" 1;01,

d'd" and r11ed tn:th. 'órfia. 'ot tho County kico:dor. -at tni 1114,Uountu at

, 10 itAVJ AAD,"O llo'L,ah..,;i...o~TI,I1.DClrU¡oi lil"OIløea, taiethii' w1tn &11 and elniiar

. ..... I,. .. ' '

\lt rlølt, ilI appur¡¡.iian.o,..::tb~r:.tO'::1n: anywh. .~.lonsin,'l1nto tll. ,Ha14.Andl'~W Dr.nash
hIe Iiel~,,'~nd a8l'liin,;~'0~,e:i~r :-:; - .,,'
Md.-'';I barob~..,~i~i~ô;hâ~i~~.;. ',o\l1'~.11'." .xaol1t.on anI ai1n1ltl'tol', . to W&riant.

ai toreY'~ ",et~i'4ì ~iili ~i~.i~¡;iiil" 'tb,..prll18I' llao tolll' ..14 .Adrow llrana¡i -h1l

i i
I ¡

hllr' G14' I..S~n..:" .i~i~.~, e'.'it~" ø.~'o~,. WbOIlIUy.r.-, lawt\.ii~, olaiiiing or too 01a11Q 1ol\
pa..or ';iiJi.it.' t1í.~.~t ~'~",: ,... ',... ,-,:., .' .., "t

'fHnl~. ollt,ll~., ~hh :,i!l~, 4a. of JlaYfllbir, A, D. 1911.
:I~~~ ..;~:~:4~:4~D:i~~~~:~t:.~~b:,~r~:n:c~ 0: l

i i

R. L. Ilnllln

(OIAL)

Uinn1eB. Dunaian

(siw)

I i

røtiGl' " ..' llll. ' , . :,", .. or,'ARtZOllA. ~-): .... ' '.. .;, I

OOIUW',ot~Ctahh~' ,:d .... ,:' .,""'. i
¡i.to~..,'ø.'~, ~.,:.~. .D~~~~~ "~,:iot~l'Y 1'IlbUo 1n and t01' the Uount)' ,ot Coohlu, T.rritory l

01 Ari&Dnl;' u. thl'l:d.II.'.p.iionaiiJ app.....cl ,1\0 10. ,ii~an known tG lia to be, tho paroon :

",u.. r";~,:1i~il1~~~i'ili~4;:to :thc:!ore'01l'iS 1n,irumint.l\nd .alelio.lAdlad to mi thit. be i

g.~t..4¡~. .... ,tor~tø.ip~rpvii ,and.: oon,14lratlon ,tbor'inhvxprl..e4. ¡ ,',.., ..' .:'''. '..',' '., . i
OS.¡Ï1 U'nd.r:ii:,ií4~;an4'a.ai ótottlo.¡ tM., 111th dq ot lfoyiibar I.. D. 1911. :

. _. '. " ,. i
w. B. 1l1x.on

lwri.\',.,(:. ,:':...~:::~,.; ".~::.:":.. " ':. i ,', '. Y. 8, Diltoñ. I Ill ~l~~lo:~ :ftliir~."1)~o: I,l.: 1812) Dotai:1 l'u'blio, i
count~::~r: åogi~~:: ..J. ~~.~; ,

tlllfofý: tr.' :.Q. 'lI0Ilil')" '," "..,; :,' I'
'hi~i¡. ~r":";,~;.::Øl~~~~' 'a.iii;t.;u)',PU'bUe ln ~d rc:"t~= c~~nt~ ':1' .Onn11h"i ,'to"..itol')' I
or Ar~~~~~¡/o~ ~~.l~,:~~,::~~~~~n~~~ ':~~P~.~~4 ~~n1t ,B.~~.aanwS,h ~r, .a14 'R. r.,DunlL'~ 1
.tiO'':~~.IIl:to'b. ,t."pt'ion :wiÔIl naie 1. .u1¡.ål'~e4 to the.

'" , ..., '," . I

foregoing inatrwiumh lind ,

..)i.~ì~4' 'i~;'~~~ t~";'~hr~~¡~~t~4" tÏi. lUi, ¡or tJii PUJ'poli~;i' lind. :ien1i1lulItlon ¡

'bl~;i~'~~~.~~4: ",' i.: ;.. ," ' i .~.~:"~.~.: ';. .;... . y . ,,' ..... ..
~1~:e. ii4lr:iq hå4. .n4' ..al or oCtla., tl\1I 13th 4a~ of !:IiY"bl:, A. D. 11111.

~~'\'.;..L, , :', :.,,) ;:~,:'i;~:?':":' ,'," ..
I"" .~~~.~C1n Ixpirèl.:1).o."l~, 1.'12.)

Notary l'uü¡¡...
C. A, Ilc:DonlLld,

.. II. ~;:Hl\hiiioñ;'" :""," ",' ' "I ...,..,.. ...,...... ,", .'

,~~',~1~4 Ì'.~~rÚ~.,~t..,r.lll1.~~ or 9. 8. Dixon, Nov U iøii at 1 1'11.
"'... .'.. .". .,.......; ...:.".. .

........~',.:.i. ,: . " ",~~;":' '. County lI,cordar. ...I~:.ta:"'.,;..i~.~'/:.::,..,;;¡:.;.,;i". :;¿.... I: ~ ..1 .
'hi'.... , " '".-:,\,. "", .. ". , .,:-,;..~~U!\i?~Va.':ihi..,tlllr\loth 4&y of ooto'1er. A. D. 1911, ,betweon O. It.

"'~" ...~~".."......,........;."........_,............_.......................".......~i......

~i~'~:\lri~;,.i.4~:ái~' õt:;'QOObl'~ County. Terr1tory of AlillOn.. ~hi ".rty 0: tiic

t¡U~~~~~;.;.a.Ie:,~~¡~~$ouiíb'1IIN RAILROAD 001AK. Q. aorpora.t1on Di'san1l1tl aM

! Li.' ~.; :i~~.~~::, :~.f:~~;..;,..¡.1.4"P~t1 of t.1\ tl~ot port tor!L. In cionu~eriition or
Leai~~~~!,,~~.~ .~~;jl\~...Q¡.~'b., 't~rr1torJ Dr Aiizonci. tl\o party ot tbo neaoni1 PAI't,

.,' fi ~ ,_~ ...~-:m~v.'..l...~ .... "'i.." . .-... '. . . . ~ ~~~.;1f~:~~:~~~ir.ilOUr8 (.IISO.OO). lii"ful Iin01 of thi Unlt..i atate.
~ DEFENDANT'S
,;

;;:... ,i~~~,~¡'.p..;:~~:,'1.:~: th., par~ 0: the lioon,4 pl\tt, thi riaiipt .lIon.d. II: .:~~ ,.i;~~~~::~~:r:~,,~,~~r ,haG ba.ri:Ained, 1014. Gl'lLntt~. oonvøyci,whil'ol'

..~~';lIii;.Olnfiriie4'.aiia:¿~l tbelo I'roa.n~i .' .. . ".. 0111, arAnt, convey. : 00'. lli-lci1n. 'C1I....~t-U.".'..Ii. .......(.~.

j 9
..
~

EXHIBIT

r

Case 1:07-cv-00271-RHH

Document 56-2

Filed 05/15/2008

Page 21 of 30

248

'" ",~ .;\;:t:,'_\:'~:1~:~:tl~~~~t~t~!i~~;~~~~:~it:.
. t . .... OJ, :'. "!!;...,.~.t\.~,,,,~~,!!1m~"?":-"'~ftA74.11~..t:.~

,--,---,.,------,_. " '. ,:,'.'.:';~. ~,~,.~:~~...::~::::~;~:::~;.;~~~.

aUen, "tihe, I'eleaii Aiid: oollth'ai :utö. ill.Lll'.i't1~~r:~t~.~"Î.ê~~'¡~j~t'~ ~1'~.~.i;.:;,rl~:~.,:. ~

and .1I£,n., 1n -tii i1111., aU tbat Ot1\~~n.l~~,.,~l1I!"!:¡~~5.~!~\';i~~~.iali\.tiiäl+';:..
tile Coiiiit)" of Coohho, T.r1'l tor)': ot, Arl:ion.,.,: .nd~e~ailblia'ra.¡l~ot;'(öWl;\,.li~\¡'*í!~î,:,... :~.

_. ':."' -. ~.;.;.~;.~.\...:....f~.~:~..~1;Ji:~,¡..~;~1a~.~.~:.:~~ù.~:r~,.~~:i

. . ....,..~..r.....,~~., .11t..,.t,.~,1,,,, ,".ti "',.~ . . . ..1, .",..",~.l...;

A l\r1p or land on thi ...t ,.lell ~t ~i' 8~,~~~~~~ri.;~fi~~~~~~~d~t;~~f~~ti:i:i
111 wldth be

In, one bunlSrI" 'fiot til "ldth upon' '.aõ"...i14i~~ò~tlit"¡ö~1ìtO¡.,riri.;.f H\.~ '.1 , . . .......... . "..,...,.:..'.',..."...'..,... ...!"If'if"

nOl .talid alit lIPOIl thi iround ,toJ' .tbi l'.too~t.~~~.:~~~~~.!t~~~t~~~~h!~~\~'i,PiIr.;,
Coiian7 betwOln tll. .kUon.. or Y,."lt '8pi11Ρ1;:.....: .~'.' .....I.."'....¡:...:I,!.:. ..z..! . t." _ _ 01...... . . . ._ ~ and Ja'Ii-1Ïia¡;1cït:l'f'òY'i'::!tll1'o\lili':'~'" :.':

an4 upon the 81 1/4 ot HI 1/4, 8110tton 'fw,i'frt(é);~àiiiitiii':mviif*o~,hì~~\~~.~.:;;~

.... .' ':,~: ..... ':-'~I :;::\&~~!'l.~r.~~::~~~';"~i .: .:._.~....~. ....-,

ot 8I1at.011 1119"11 (11) ln TO'l'hi,''1..iilJO,''l':~i:~,~:,~~li~'!~!í1~Ø,.,tja''~~~G~.l(i:ì;~

"Jo. la14 .td, ot bnd 1I.hl. npro~iíl"'1l:~lh.itbùiii'~~l¡~'8)~:i~~t';:î~~i~i;ij~:,~::

. .' . :'._~'''.'. _ ;i.'~'.. ::,/:'': t,:.~;~:lt\",;(-!'~~:i).f. _,"~""'i'f"'Å::~ :.,

the oiitll lin.. lIbi-aoins' an'll'l..'ot 4.211 ,acir!Î "o,t,,~ii:~i!!!~~~~.~t:~J'~"tll~iì!~(~~(~~ ....;',
traate rilto.,. "4..orll1e4. .. :( " ::.~ ... t: i'... i!'.,.~' :::"1:l~.:rI.;~r~:~~:~f¥~~r~'~~~~iai!- .:..~'.:~r~~~~~:~.:.. '.~

TO HAW "lI TO HOLD ua. &"0". 4.'lIl'L)i4. 'Pr~..j;"ó¡r~iï(¡;~ii'i'~::~ii,:~~Ci,Y~I~~IÌ' ,),
.' . '.'..; ;.... ..... ;'':, ':'''~4.~:,..:'~!.~.';.:'t:!S.1~1~~';~i'' '.-:~-;:;:. _::~:~:. ...:~~~.. t.-:, 'hi .,p\ll"tenanon ai p,idle... tf.riwito '.'ø.ion8i~.~ò~"¡lii~~lÎiraPi.riunSlii¡~'il'. :,
. . I' ì .- .,' J'~ ..... ......'...., :..._....: .,....._A., ",'.,,. ..~'~ 'C

Ui II lULU p.1'\)' ot thi iiooncl'på"t, 'U.'; 'U'liCií.or'li :âiil':¡.~~íi~~~tô¡r.¡-~i~::,~~ '.~','. .. .. -....". . . ... ...1.. ..-.....1 ... ......... !,:,:,,' r; ," ,;:

1M lrTimS WH:ø. .as.ci' pøt~. òr :tl.'; ti¡'~t,~'¡ir~'J~~¡;~¡i'i'~¡;;í\1i~¡~',~~l~¡;\~~~
dil and 1eii1' 111'' allovi wrUt.I'. '.. ~'.' ': :"'¡:~i';.~ :.J' ..~/fi\:.. "1,.... ~:..!!,_~...~: ," ":::\""!!;" ,¡J,r.. ' . :.'. .,o~: '..-:";''f'l;'':'~L.,;u.,,'r.I:'':~¡.t:-.:'';. ~,\, '.: .' ~ .
. ,,'. J ". '- ;~~ . '. .i:~~:,~.' '.'. : :,t :"l"::.i;~'~"-~',:.':~~.~~~.~;~?~..: ':~Ji~:.: ), .~, 't.. ;;:i 'f,:' '!

,. ;~'.':~;:~.~~r(~j;~~~""'.'~:~~'..::i: ,.... :.~.::.~?r;:tt ., ..... ,..: ~.; .~::. ''''''1Y.ct' ,",.;'.::Åil~' .~':',.,f¡.'.J.".... ,'I ...',,'~:I.~'t. .:

TBJ:TOIlY OJ ARIZOifA I ',. .'.~ ~,' '. ':; ::~''',.m.:r..-*,¡:;/~ ':&""";.¡;'1':''; ":~. ..;;,:~;.V- :;.1

Oount~ ,ot Ooohl.... ..", ..~,',"', :",' '~',~ '.',:;; 'c..::1.,..-i.1"-!,;':' .' ~.1\', ~. .'.:;'; :.' :.'::it~r~:',~ ,
SelOi,. ic'. O. 01boon. & H~~' .~\l~1i~'I;,:iii~'~~:':~~fi~~t~~~:#~~~~:~~h~"'I"~~~~~~'I
L fJt Ari~ona. Ol' thi. cla Pl~.on~~~.'.;,~~~~~~',:~;:::.~'~~~~~~:~:~~~~~~~.ii~~!:'o'~," ~~.~Pll"1

88. -.' ~:,~. ..: ~ : .~::.'~.: -~~.;:', i)~';~. ;$.';i!~ "~,(;~~,,.~~~.;.,\'. ..:.:,:..:;~'~';':'.: :~

,W!oee iian. it elbiodb.4' to.,t)."tOI'1f0~1~.1~'~~~,~~¡;;~' ' .i~dlld',~t~',~.~:~~:Il~' .xiolite4 "he .ai. rii~ the p~rl'ÌJ~.¡'¡¡~:¡~~~14~¡¡¡\ì~ìf~ij~ 1ì~~:;::;:;,,;," .':lÍ.tik'"
.. .:....:. _.: .... .-~ ~:-;. ":,:./:. ,~~'.~;l:~..,.'~'~ ;;;~'lJ:FN:; $~,~,?:.' ":.' . .., :': .:.
, OIVJ! Iin4.. II bi" ,,4, ~~ai '.~: .~flit~, ,~.~:§;~~~~~irJ:.!r~:.:t~~~.~.A.- ~., iDi,~i.;.
.1

f, rlh'" and 1'00:1''' at rl'I1.lt Óf :.rÜ'V;::IêÍ4rìli~ifõ:r!'úriit~.lit..:.li~ ,

'"... ., ,,, :"~'"'~''' ~:',Jlt.*,¥._~"h,D. I~~\ .......-..'......_. ........._i ..it~.:,:.:'~lW4tii1l~t~;~ " " ') 1..1 Or ._i..i.. ~.. __......__..~..,~..~..ai&."'...., '

.1

,

¡~ By H. L. Hutohhon, ': ~:i:!.: .. ' '. , c~: ''''!~::' :"~;::d:".??!!:~~~~~~~~~~~,;.' " .

, . .... . ... . ... ''l.'"'.','!'".' ':':'__'" :.:,t. Còlint)' ._.,.. t. .... l PePllt1., ' ,: ' . .', ..... ~.: .. : ...;~....., n.,OO"''' .
t ..... ................ _..-.... e.e ....e.. _ ~...~. .~._..... .~. -.ë ~'..... ."¥~'¡¡.:"'.. ~~ '. ..".,~ ... ........ ......1...
i W::A 'R. R A ,I T'J.. :,~i,~~;;r.J:.:t~f.?~!;~E:::~::;~,...

.

TIITORY or ARIZONA, ) , .. ,:..,;.~':!,;.;:?..." . ,.., .",
"3unt,. ot. Cooh... ..' .~:. .,.::.~ ,,;y.:¡;_t.. ,.;;) .~ ~~.:,;.;; ..!f;r~' 1....-::. r ~8~ .\_.. ,.1.' _.,,__'j...~~~~i~::~;'~;~~Ji¡..~..,.. . .~ '.

JOO" JJy, SI:BY TH l'SI , ,...:..'¡~.". :'~\':';.','I"'''~','''':,'''' .,;,
, ..- . .,' . . . ., .. ._i.i..;..j;l....~t-i ;"'of'f,! ".. .t:...h'.::...:.:."

That We, .raoquet Aidti.on -.itd Miii Är4J:..ol', ~'1Ìi."" .',ii~:ôOr' ot iiU'lIl,

Coiintl' ot ÇOOhh..Tor¡'~to'~, õ~ ~1~ona, ~o~:'.~4"líi ':0-~~'¡¡i~~~¡:tto:n.::6t:t;~n ('10.001'
. . . " . .. ... ,_;, . '. !o'\.. '_.'.'~II'_~_ ..~.~ ....\",... . .~.. i:U.I"., too II' iii hind ,a14 li, "Ux'J)y. .have ailÜtid¡;"'Ílôra=:Ül4"ODIi.;qd; ai4 b1
thOl' PI',lint. do ¡rant.. 0011 ~~ "oon~~'~¡ll"~h~: ~;~:~;'j;tf~~~~~::~¡id CollAt ~lSt.l"

pniih.. deioribod :.. ~oi \l)ÌIJJ..,~!~'i"M iiri4'i~IIl'lId.,oiie~!'ktfit~~~¡t';ÚI',lln4 to LoU .'
nU'bor04 I'Ut..n (10) iull '81xt¡~IFt:rò)d iä;'äibiik:Íi~~:;¡¡~~'t;,ö~~;'('l:) enuatt l~ i.;
Jliill.', c1nintf ot Çoaliill, f.~¡:1tori' ilt~~1~Ón;¡:~¡¡¡:,:b:¡i&t~t¡:4'~~~ï~ll1ed iapon · i, I
ent! tle4 0Sl or 2l\I1al 'roWliÌ:jk.ii_r)i'. :1'.: :,Û¡ :,dii~w~i~õ:~;l~t~å:¡¡¡.~t~~1I1&r1 12, mi. I

'I' Mended,. tUdtllei ln .tho ~rti.;~:ddt'ith~~coÌb~~;~H~i6¡.ij¡i,¡I~;:"~~í4 Count)' ot Ctolll!

: , TO HAVa AlD ':0 iioLD:t.~i:~~¡:~i~~¡¡ilii~~t;¡i:¡¡~~~;ti~g~~i~tâil 'anllinJl.i., i ¡

¡ ,~~ ,~íøh" im4 ..p~~~~iiar"g: tlib'"."_.... =':Rii;tmõ ' ì,iiUll''D',- I

i . 'lP:''',ò'', .... .:.'.... ::::;~I "ò.' v..... "':i:¡~a. "~ .~P':!~\.~~~,.~1.t... ,.:...~- . _.. '.¡: ..~
. -,......~:~:.::'.. ¡:.: l.......:..¡~~~;t:";,',.~~ ..;~.:tl~:~~~..l. ..~~J"~~;.~ . ~J.tr.;~.:'.~..;....:.;=,~-;.~

",Ai,_, h.l~...and:~..~~¡i.:',toity,..:~t':, ,...' . . ,,;~'i.' .. ,~~i~,,,('d;:

.".~_.;:. ..-..... ,.:-,~'!l:õ~¡¡~":.=i.'.J.Y:.~'~ . _'!9~~~.w"" _':Ìr"''''''' L ..... ,. .... .....,.....~,-_._. el "'...-:', I,..., i, '''. .... ,- ,

..--,-~.. ~a2

Case 1:07-cv-00271-RHH

Document 56-2

Filed 05/15/2008

Page 22 of 30

"'. ." - . . ...~:"::.,~ - :

.. 'u_... ~~.:~...: .... . ..~:~_ -~=:-:~:---~~~~.---~_--,_. " . ..'.._~. ~-..~:......... .:~ : .. ...-...:.
tiilrtl'-D!i (sa) t!i1t,rA"ven (3'1) 'iid tlltrt-l"-U¡¡ht (:se) 11\ .'loçk; ~1¡ (6), ";.~~ . .111

, " .",': . ",~':", , ," :,,,:,~, ~:i';' ,,'..

To hllVC t\d to 1101ci the oiie tosothoJ' with all lind 01naulii tlié tiineiicnt ':h , " . Bi; er~Lt.
wi.." L.. ..11(\ Iip!,ul"hI\II1l0"'B thBNlunto b..or.!i~l'¡; iir.to tho', ii:ilc! P:i:-'~1 ot, 'tiu;, DacÌli'l1' ,:. "

lIie eUCOOØOOrl ln 0,':"10'. iiiiether'.. 8upel'ntendent ,'of tho ,1I~~~,lo.n Goiihll'lnoe, o~, Gt" I

;, .". "p'~~. i

ini,ual confãt;rc;i hcrciitter ol's"nized hl'vlni Jurl.a41cUon of 'li~~",:h,rÌ'.i~~r.v 'In,.wIt.oli Illk ¡

lotB are looated. or aee1ine. roraver, ' i
In truGt tOll th, iiae 4ld benetit ot the 1I1nhby an4 Ueibllohtp ,òt, tho U.tlo4hi I
Bphoopal Churoh ln the IJnitK Bt.atn or /d,~iO", B~'bJellt' t~':t.hw:Pfø~ll1l1nel 11.ë¡.,; w ¡
1I1n1e~er1al &ppoiiitnienh of la14 CbliS'ob. 1111 troii Umi tô t-i11 '.uthol'1ild 1I4¡4.0hted. ¡

G,nd 1t øolc, the iiroøoed8' iihaii be dlopOlOd ot and. uGad in a~oordån.io wUIl tllo P~O'lll~¡

of Baid nll0iglino. \
iiild triiet.

ShouU :sald iiart~ at the eecond pan e.,er raU or a iu\l~eltol' In theOf'ftc. .to,...liH
oapable of' exooi.Ull8 thi aondltiøni ot lihi afor'Gliit! tr:i.et.~ ,~~~n_:,~., B~pedOl'l~~e 01 f

CoOhhe cOi.nto)", Arlzon", 1. hll'llil" autliollhid and oiio"ired. to oarr)" oiit tho tonu or ¡
!

In hlUinon)" wblITiot tohi ""14 part)" of thl,t1rit vart ..I' htt,eunto let 1111 han4

the dar and year tir.t abov. ~ittin.
Prank 1'' Ooo4'1od) , , ,

probi.~w ~1i4aI' ~l ,b~:D1iiiil ticiiint)". Mbani, lld

'lfUI't... 'tor ,~h~¡,'..~'e~.i, U~'i '~4 1ienim ot t~,
1RRRJTORY OP ARJ?,OWA

ooaupanti ot tbe Townilti of PODro.,

aB.
Countoy or Coabl..

1I1fol.0 ~i0 O. 01blion. a Dotar)" 1'lib110 in and ;-tOl":tlili :Ciiiint;. ot 'Cochllii. TorrUoa
of' Arlzana. on \hii day Pll'oon~íiy Q~poAr04' frank ~" åD44~~ØY~ knD~ to =e to ~e tho
pereon whoei Ilam_ 1& Bub,ori'ied to the toregOlni 1Jl.t~.nt" Ud 'known to IDe to be the

PlIo,"lite Judee of iaid oountf. and Tel'lIltor:r. and Truo'tØo fos: 'tho:a~~r:: u=~ and be.tll
of tbe oaciianh of Peara. Towneltø. Bald cciunt~i aoao;din/l to tbe1~ 'riipe4thi inhrel
an4 l'olcnowi.4sid to ~i1 that hi, III .uah Tl'Ultlie. exeoute( the eald lnetrwDint tor 'he

purpoiu lind oon11481'.t10n thir.1n exprouood.

Oinn u n40l' "' band .n4 lioc.1 of ottloi thie 6~" 1Iii ot Hoviibir, 1911.

(SEAL) ~ commiselon oxpire. April 4. 191e.
o. 01'olon

1fot_lIY PubUo.

J'Ued anel 1'8001'4.4 at r.quut or 01blOn "'b.traiit 00 110'( 6.llni at Il:OO PII.
B)" H. L. HutBbi ilon.

O. 4. lloDoneid,
,ooiint)" !locoi'd.r.

:Peputy,

... e._ ._.. ._... oi-.. _~.. ... "'........... _.. ..... .... .1.. .._. *.. .*. ....._.. ......1......... '... .-.,,.1"1
'IHtll UlllEHTUJ, Kada tliii abtli 4ay at lloveiiber, A. D.. lVÜ,"bøt"..n JaM 21, toga'

and Boii. D r.ø:iilll hie wire, of Couhlee Clli.nt)", 'IÒl'i'lto'l')" of Ai1ioiiä, parU,ø of lb' tirBt part, end El Puo ol 8outhwntorn Rii1iroR4 co~any, Il ç01'~r~t1on ol'lranlr.sd øn4 lxht.1ns under the laws at the Tir1'tcr)' ~t .\biin.; put¥, ot tl,il aeound'I'ClI't,
'I'!!!l!!!9E'Jl: ThiU. \liii aa14 pcut.ioa lit' i.ti~ nr'ls\ par' toi' iiiid in äoiieiciR...~l~r. ~r

ihe Dum of One Hun4red wnd f1fto)" and 00/100 (11&0;00/100) lawti ~oney or the VPltf4

Stiitøii of' MierJ,DQ. to 'hemin Iinnd rinld. by tlio party of \.1;. Re'H'Ýi.i Plll't, tJ)c rR4111pt

wlilll'cof h herOlli)' oon!oslIlid Dnd lloknowled8d, haii ~arBál""i1. ,old, Iiranhd, oiinvii~cd,
alhn.d, i'...hall. :rhaftfl Md i:o~t1m~4. 'a'~d bf, thc:~~ p.:c;icr.U do biirgall', ~i11. Ci.~r.
aonTOl', "lhn.'reiu.... l'elliuil':aiì4' ¡¡o~¡lio~~rito:'",a'iili""L1:'~t::t;;'~'''~.'¡¿nis 'PPJ't. ItB BYC'

euon anll ..."sne, in tei æ.¡ '~ií:tii~'t' o~~t~l~' io~, '¡¡;~Ù"~~;,'~~èr~1 ot lDlId BU~J
In the uauiity Öf Coùl¡iu.,Tei~ùDi;;':l~i¡~~~~~:::~~;il::àei'oilb~t¡ì':~iö1ï~~..' vi::"
.. ".~. ... ," . ~b. ',I. ::~'.J:i¡:~~~ .:'.. ..\o?t~:'t-~~r;í:~.,:j~::t;~~~~~~!~.:":~t:1!.~.r'~!r1/;i !:~:~~:~:~1:~;t¿~~~£~~¡~:r~.:. ". ~, ..;oJ

~ DEFENDANT'S
il

!
~ '"
I!

EXHIBIT

g

Case 1:07-cv-00271-RHH

Document 56-2

Filed 05/15/2008

Page 23 of 30

':":¥r':Y7:":"~'" '=:...:?~:~p',:~r&:!~r~!~ll;~:;;;!;~;':::~E?'::~~:~~''::~~';::',~ ?~~::",';:' -': "'.. " ~u u

"...----. ", 1. '.' - ._-: .-~.,~:. , -.---..._..._.. ...
A .~iP öl 'i"ii~~:b~~~Ìi~~4~ë.~~:(~d~t~~~~r:~,~,,:1I~4:b~;' ,Veins' I1f+."1 (110), foe~, i'n ,;ld~h

oa II :.. .... ." .. ....1......1.,...... 0,' . ' :
ell' .hlt ot "'i¡"~.~tu:h:.iJÍ~"':Of.'::.tn. '.::ìi:;~äiii i..'Øê\1i....torn i\in~o'ácf J'100at.10n

i''1''O,,,on L"ia"8P;~d,ilë¡, "~~:~~~f.~~.:~ !i~i::i\rTòYÓ4, a~d,:.tòiell1lOn tbo /piiund. ~ uri .' 'aon!'e :Dì,6. ~p'~~~~.~~.:;,~,:~!,:,~~~,.~: i/~:,~"~Uon..i:B. iudtho lI 1/4 '.,.. '" l)o\l,ii 0 ....",' ..'..,..¡ ....' .... ,.... '.. of llW 1/" ; )
llOÍl :i'. ,l l! 0; :Jl' d :ii~::o;'I:S',R::l.&it~,':;'e~I',.ol.na, an .1'0" of' '1:.$'1 aaroii of 1encl. '¡
::1 or 1.... ..., ':. ': L'" '~:: '. ~;~,; ~:;~~;: ::: :'~:,:::',' ,~:,.:: ,; ". . !
oro HAW AIlr,Ò ii~tæ ,'~,~':.~~~~!:::~!~~~~~:"~~~~!,Ol~.øD .toiiitbcr wi'h aU 8nd Illl1guio~ !
lbe GPPlIriinlllCl.i 'ti~ii:'p~,~~~~~~~~:!i~~ê,n,~~:¡~~..~;Í!~l~S"or 1n anyill11 airpertalnlns. un't~ I

tie..l1f P"''J. ~i,.tb', ....~~~'4::!~,~...;:.h~j:.;~?f~:~~~.or~.:~a .".l'PIi tonv.'. !

~irfl.jÏ88 :_loï:qlïì~iW~,l~iï,:ir~'i,ñ'Ì';¡ir~f pøî, MTe 'iixeout.iid th,,,. prøi:enta. !

, , .;)".,..,.,. " . ,

\11. ''''\,;:,' . ,,;1i;:, ::~.A~h:tf.;:':: "; :~',.,.;;,:;..",:"". .iöliii' ï Losåii \
':,.,~:i '0" 'fí"i'i;;ii;..~~,tt(er'¡ \--'~';".':" ''': ",. .' .' ..,. , ' "

, , '.". , .,'. ,,':" ;'" ' '.. . ,lloii. ',ù lioS"1I I
lialfOIlY,OJ.,.uUZO~~;:' ):' ,:', ":"; i,..,'.,: . "." ,;', :"" ',,', .' I

" I

COi :"ot'èoolihe';:' y~B/::i:..'''''''' ..~: ":/7:

L .. . .. ..,..., _.. ........':.,. ....',..' '.. '., ..'

,;~'ó¡.~~ "l,~li)j~i~~\:,~'~iii'~~;,¥\Î~~:t,k.~:.~n: ,,~~" 't~~ ~'II'l;~nt:t of: "oobi... '~',r1 t.or~ 'I'" .',: ;:~~

.t ~l.'i;~¡;.,.ro."~=:;.b.'l'=:':4~.::;'~.'~D.).~'~.i1.'.\0.'; 't.I;.l,D.ii.iiiiìn 'Z."; "~.08ii", knowii ". Ò 1111 'tò ..:; .t.iie'l'er~ol' ~ '..,:' '.t ". .::,'~ ~'::':'" :.::.....;_.~t...~.;:':.;..~~~.'~:"'~'.~R~::;!.::~.......~..':::..; :::..t,.- . '. -.. . De, . .- .: .... '. :.....~

lIallJu"!Ïlçiu".il'l11.4 'tto!;tfi.'t,ot.ïo'1ftB~'ln.irrwllir. In4 '.olinD'l.diici, to ill' tbat)il ,',' ' ':' .'~;; .. ....,. ~..,....~."'~..i~'",~, ,¡ ..* .1'. -". '.." . . \ ,,' . .......
.u.ø~~:?x.;'l~~'f(~lli.:'~:fi~~~~;~it~~."~l1.,:d~ïà":O'~'\ii~,;e1~ '1I~~IOIi.cl" '. " l' ':'/:. )
. :.......\ .. ,.,..l..j~,,,,~,.\~~!.,,,,,,~,.j'~'..~...':..\'.:t-_.t:.... ..'..;'. .:. . . . ~ . , ,.,

',lJi'Í~Wi~~:iihuìi-i~.ñ¡:~iëai::õl:'òttloï .... '...... .. ,. ". ....1\.,. 'I.. . 't.h1i" _libt. "41V of. iiÖ,'fei'oe" '/i¡'f. 1111'. "
. (l~~':~;i;~'~;;l~ihh' '~ìi"ieii;',,'u1;O~ 'litl. ',,, ''';, ;', ' :

: ,,::~~: :,:::-;";:..,",~~:i;:,; ~,: ';'/'~;: !:é:?~~.:::::'" ": .::.: 30hÍ'"1l01.er t \ ...\..;-.~:v.'I.....~:;. ~~~l:.~(:;:) '.:~f.;;i:~::.!-~.; )l '.. ,I~.. -.. i'!.. d , ""1- i

: ',' ," , ',' , , ' .. , . ''', ,'" ',,0t.11'1' \lu ~o, I
' co$itfot UÓÒlll".r'.~ : "'J',.;o',:,~;\:::" ':1,:',"''

~;DifoiV;Ó,. ~tZÓÎfk')l";:~~'~.~~i:,;..::,¿,;. ~ :~,:' ..'

1'.':.=.'. " .,....: .. ~:'" :.'8~:: !,'.. '.. . . I

. ::¡¡iOi'~~IG;,;,'~~~~!oiiW:,:'¡:.'ilg't-~~y' îi~lii'io. :Ln ancl tor \110 Count.)' of Coohlee. 'frrUor)' i
tt ~~~~~\'~~'i:t",1~~;,~.9j~~~~~~~~.',~~,~~~)~ ..iiii 11, Losan. lenown 'to 110 to bo tll11 peron I

.i..,na..,l'i'.~"Ii,"i1id: \1i'itii.'forlsolns"ll1ltI'W1l1nt ai Witii of Jobn :I. Loiinn lI',ntloneO . I . '.~t.:......". .!' _.. ,;:\l..... ....,,~ i::'.-~J....i. '.... . . '. 'blrliki~!ii~::,¡ciìu~wiew¡;~:tbt.Jí..tti\f'!.iiê""ï:iCCiilil1 the Iliie of hei own' free wIll tiM f"" ! :.'):!"í~i...-..."i.... . .."\...l':..C.."¡....~'l..iJ:..;:.,¡,..I.~...., 'l' . :.,)1..,.. :. \Ii .lt(.Ù~,~'Ò1i~r¡_~'d'~itlî1r)lrt '.ji¡¡... .ci~

.
I'

~..,,¡:..:,i ".',',:' ':'(."~""""'i'~,""""';i."","''''''~'' ' , I
;-' ~.:Io ~~. 'I'!.... .....f'.it..f'~-....tii.r-;.i .',.. ". .-. i

. Qa~'un..r,:'$~:bÍil;:¡ìi~~:Ii~.i;:.ot :oft101 tbio e1¡lt I! ot lfoTlllbe' A.P.'. 11111. I

i~,,:,: ;,ÌI,.IOöii":Ll;;;Jir~~lüi'¡ ',;: ':1111.. ;;'.'t;;wv ,.:'" .i.~.::t-:::::'I~.;1l~':3-:~f'~.~(:"-" ...:-,. . I "".:.'1:,;: .. .- " :';,! ,;I"""I,,,'J~I,,.\ tit :,tJ, 30M )a1 ei
, ~\~¡~il':::¡:~;;;~'~:i :G;~~,:"~:~':::.'~;;~:~' ~:" , :, Notar)' PIi'ol1ll. i

:~t~~f~ ~tt#!~~¥~f~~W~~~~~t :ot E. :s. :nUnwooel Nov '-l~ii at 9100 Al. I

"I i1..'~; :Ru\olllon¡ ':,~..' :", .". ,;,: o. A. iiøJ)nalll, i

;jA~;~;',::, '''',:: '::r, ',:~:~:;~~;::;':';::' , Count:. ReCOlter.
..... .~~~!J.::~~;~~,. ::f.~~iji~~ti;~::,~r~~~ ~: ~"'_. .. '.".'.. ." ~'.".O r".... -'.' .. . 0 ~ 0."..."_. .".'. '-' ~.

.'.. .....~_~.... ..:'1...... _.. _ *.~ .i¡~~.. ...~. .

.. ..,:,...;-::. ,.\:: .: -;:;;:':~;;,,, :.:.; DÍ 0'1 IUAllB 0' 'fllUST ii.
Ul'tUAJ llILPXNØ.LOAN AlllOCU'UOit

.:~,~:,~..ii~i(Bl:!ii~_m9;' Tlit rno'mmH'l

ot.~ì.ii~..~r#,rt~~~~:'.l¥~;~';~~l ~ø trust 1n tho Truit Deed hereinafter iinUoned, ~

~~.,::"¡~~:,~lr~~;:iii'll.ïi:~i'~~i4I1r~\.lo,,' ot thii paient. ot Pour )funduel and '14/100 .
1l~1~~~;t.\:~~lt;;".i~1'ii:":t~îl~~~~nt :ot the note Iil1ciireil "o t.h. 'frui, J)lil1cl hereindtll

I ,.~'.y.,l~~;;~~~~li'òìiiiõG.:.íi4"óhiirao. oonneoteci tl'll'lw1\1I 'I)' 'rhoMII L. S101.1 of J)ollslnl.:
. ~~l~~iii:~i :j--;..~~f,T~t~liië'~ft" I.lIe par~)' or tho 1100n4 ~al't. huii roiihel\. '

'~òír:::::~:'¡::'"';;-;. ..;,..... O;¡" . _. .

,. r.i..i . ,;i...t'.. .','

t;:ârut:"bl:',,,..ïop¡'..oiit. di:th rlJDSeo. 2"o18a81 and 'lul~olaim
';~~6.p~~'ni.'b.Srli &"4 ..ilgna aii'Sta r1ght. ilt1e and

....:~._~..;..:II:. ..', .... 9 .-

l:lõ:;iiï¡;:à,¡lci'lied' )lrDpl~t.)'. ,ø1~!l.t~4 iñ tb. Count.)' Df
t~~~:'¡~':";:' ~~ ~.:. ::~;:j'¿~~::.;~~1~~~à~~~::;'. .~~ : .:~.::. I.... ":"f":~':n .;.. . .~. .

Case 1:07-cv-00271-RHH

Document 56-2

Filed 05/15/2008

Page 24 of 30

. ," .. '~'''il~Ç~I..;.''''~i~(:e~~~$t...

f 416
!~, -

, -: ': t:":: ~""::~.l,~'!:~~;~JT:'

I. I,

t harolii uXlil'OA30i1. ': ::, :,:,~, ~,:. ~';~~;:~~h~'~~!i~~:,r~!; ":' ',:',':. ";~¿r':'~'!l""~'~
.. 'vnn llndlll' iiv 110M iil1 SOlll ot ott10G,',.;t1\. :'ílÕ,êì'h-14~~bt,t6i! " .,j;'~;:":l1,tY,l~:I..1

ilot8ii;Püb~sci',iiF'id':ir"t1Ìo Cu ,;'.:...,i-:,.

, "(:,i~or~:~~..8.lle,,.i""':'-~,,~, .,¡"'t.:,,, ' ... '1, -4. .. ...'r., ..-....-.. ' . . . ._,.'~..t.

':', . ...;~ ;¡;.::~.: ;f''::' ~~i~' :;.~;~ . ~, l'V,~~, ~~.i,IO" :

(50111) J~ ~~~~~'~~.'~~~~~:f'.~~~UO~,Joth ¡~~~~..,
FU ael :ira recol'uel1 lit I'oquollt or Albimt H.;' 8~ai~.., ~~u;;i~":.i',lP... at 1 P.ii' : .: ,

~rOti:UQW 0"1 ~1,..onn. ',rCle1o.iu :~.~ii:COOlilli

!:~ Go'). ;', WiileB . ,'.,' , . O,~:"A.':.lliiiiQ " :;" ....
Iloput)' ':.: ,:'::':': ,/~::, .~~~t~: ROOOrclel'. ",
~.::":.o .:.,~,.:'-== ::",.- ,.:'.. ¡,..::.¡:'':."\-:""; :"~,:~.f..t;'''~~f.::;''~i:¿¡';.~.r~~_..-'t . .;~

D g B D r 0 R R % G H ,'1 0)0 ..,A .y,;;'\:~,::;:i..;.,..,~., '.' "
. . . -., ", (. : .:~. ".¡:~".' f': .... . ..... '_

'l18 1m1entiire lIade oM erte1'ol1 1nto tii. ,lI',th dá;ot;:..i~iiu~~,./'Ä ~ .n.. 1910, 6':....,
1t " ...... ..........1,.., . . ". 1;cWQ;;n J. 'I. 1'101:01'9 Dm1 Ar_,::! e. 1/10korli. li1Ì,wltO.,.,o(;il¡ii.Sø,1~¡:J)t.loìi,Aii&Î.~:..,¡~. , " '.,. ..,.... Yt;' ..',",.., ",.,~"". .~. , " ...'".. e or
00 11

t01'1i18. tllo iiiirt101 Qt thO t1rDt Pllt. Gf~:Ei.~~~'6"':~ô,il~liyo~~0i\ãøiir,å4\~aÌ

. . . f. . ,_ '4.\' ..o. .., ..\...ol:. ..'l........ .." ...... l

:i :o:oriiUoll or/l.iI11ieed ftll! ,ixvtin.t llMOl'tr.',; ..lli..ir,~..,~1li¡':;~1.Ili'¡;i~f~;'1;:ll:""-""i.,:". .
ot the iiooiind put. ." " ,:' ",:)~i::'/.\W'f.:~:~~~i~~~~1f(;~.;:;:;L.':,:~~;~.~~:~', Pi.r i
.. I 'I Ii i; a B i T,K: 'Iiit tho 8ii1d,pliiot1o~':,ot,t~~,tij~.~:.:~'~~I;,~~to,t':~rtn 'Ofl¡¡)~.l"l1ai

or thu IIID or one ilUndi'eid Dolllirs ("10~'.o6) -:iii~,tiiJào~¡)iót~.bi;'ù'i""~'tai~.. l't~ :l~ , . -' . "'_~l":V',":" ';,;:~..':.:~.':' '~'. . . . -.' ., .

1n hand iin1 II 1))' tllo Biild partv ot." tM ';S~~~!\';:p~h~~a;:il~#p'~~.:~è~io~Î'llli~Î'~~Ìi"H : Dnd b)' thllBO prllBOIts dO rein1 se I'ttiiia..'llCl,:tIiTlIl' ':cii;;.ìuii '::'.'..;. :.'.. ',,' .', "" .
:inl1 8nK!IOWltt~ired, have J'll18ISd, rsleUOl..anCl-r04'lI'loi:"QlinOllJlIisÆntcirlbè 'BI1I1'putl' Of '

thO Iloiionll piirt, 1ts SuccllR~r8 Mit lij'~iìi~t;';~-;~ii~~I~~itii~::gëî~~: to-.ïè'~,..;::, A str1p ot land two huncÍr04;.to~'~ iii~;ù~ti'¡~:J~iif~~~ii,~;;¡~5ji'lt~jn "I",tb',i~ ll~~
.' .. ",' .~ ~ ... ~i.~. . ..i.~:~~. :t".: '- "~;a:. ~ .'. ~ _ .

ot the Contei' Uno ot tho ii palO &. lJ\lt1i1I8t'iti'la",Riíi1tóilt~;~CJ'1I OPOrstM bY tll6.~ld
. . . , '..' '~~. i .;;''".,J~r:~~: :..;: .:\::if~.. i :~i'.: .~.\... ~ :', ..

piirt) ot tho R80imil PIli,". aR ntw oah.tl'otol..O'ler~l~tn,¡oùJll.',;,.CØ.:ci ,ii_ IIiUon

Ðevontoll (17). jl1tont04 to _aW J~:,v.3tÌ~ke~~i;¡:~~1f~~i'i~~i1.i~~);' u:i'); l~B~,tÔ'lld .....:. :....:. :~:. ~ ~ -.=:r '.~"'"1'' ",,;', II...'¡' .... ," .' . J. v. Vlo~ur/l. botb /lUnated In 'MwnBbtp' Nei~":Iôiù;;,8oÍ1'li.~lliïnie~olib'-t~r laiit, ,DU.
nii'" ROlL 111 Vl B.80 onlt JCer11U8I: ,11l. oooÌit'~6. ~:~~Jit~ki11~Î~~"";":' ,..;\ ~',' ' ,

8Btii oantor l1nt ot ROU~aQ ontor1~-:p1Î1d'~J¡Ì'ìii~;i~iii"it,:iiiirârieor BUiiOD9i p11l
G9. 8 PQ1nt on thtl "lilt lJounda¡':f I1no,o;:jlÌ1~:rs~.,:iJ~\:t%1Ìl:Ù~i~iirúl 9:79 teet ~ Ill

:;otlit:ciii OOl'nlil' fit Hald ReoUon; thèiioe',iMilW::SOu,tb, ~;;dë'~ee. ,56 ',minute. But so .
Brlr;1nOl)i' 8taUon 126 pIli

. . .'. ."~' '" ..... I' .;. .... \r.~~: J,: ..(.:: ," - ...

II ~J p~1nt ore 'dClir¡;¡jè~:~k~~'i.w~lf~\~'i;~':~ii1d cune, t¿ ,~ lot to Init1noers St8tion 137 PIUB 18 .. _' i ;"~"l:-~~.,),:;.:~.::.~t~.i...:.:~~.~.'j~:~:~;i.:;'::'" ,~. '. '... '.' .po1ni:"~t~:tj.;~iì;: ¡ri~$~,íl~~~~~'l' 4'IiOOI If IilmiC'1
Pítl1!: ~"tent llol'lh:i_n.~

Bon. orolll1~ tllo ill8t boundii-i 1.no' 'ot, .ii1a .8ëön:on~;iT. ât',.ä :

. . : ~. . ",.~ :~~:. j'......;. ~-':!(¿", ~.: '.~ . . .' . tOolt ti'OlI tlla 80uthøaiit corliOl or 8BOt1ol1,:i7-,øiiì,:¡ioiÍt¡Utü1iUr ttil,ii'ID'OOll1'80 to' ~inGOI

Otiiti'lll ?,Q2 /lJ.1i 05, II PQtnt on thQ,e8S¡:~O~~~:~~:¡1h~':::~;':¡eit:i~~"i6t ll18tønt 8,¡~L1ii7~~
l'lu.q !l t'Ðot tr.1m tho 11oi'tliil/;lt~ ~o¡"mir ~t ä¡¡i'ir:~~'~iiiri:;:¡6::Ç'.:,:,.'/':,:'.. ::: .

'¡'Iill party ot tllu 811oton l'art to llok~:and '~~i~~~i~ :~1' ~~ :~1'8/l11'RØ "nen anUhell
i'C1iu6stoi 1n Y/'1tlM bY Piirty ot tlie J'1¡'8t'.~~rt':.. :,':;:'\'!,',;:.:',',~, ,:,('J,: .
All li1tulite. ;lYlnA lind bll111 in, iIlIHlå\ltv(ot: 000'1110,' l'erritow ot AI'1:0na, aø II

" ".'". -." ..,. . ....,'. . d

fQr 1I r1aiit or W3)'. toi' tllO (l1)nlltl'ot1.~nl . ¡'i~tri~~o~'~iu :.òP~l'~i.1.~ri ol 0 .111lO or 111109 ot

t'Ollraili1, ivitb 11011 branoh ~1nlS, IIPur~~ '8i~i~~~~:.,~;~'.'t;~:i:~t~~1II1nd toliljlli' øi~
'.:,¡1 l1nllD, IHlit1cJI ¡¡l'ouiiili, 1'IiiircndYii1'~~'~:~~~~k:.~~~~.~;~~~iiu'l~ or ot:iOI' Atruoiuro'"
rlUY bOlicioOßAOr!l Z"All1l1I1i..O 01' 1no1d.Ont.tQ"tbe'p~~ii~"~"lItil.-;8:0r'G ~aiii'OO' or 40.e

o iu' .'1c,r. ':: ' ':':.:~,' .;::': ;;~~~~:?,~',~::~jt~::'t::- " " . ,
'JU ItA\'g :,im TO l('l¡D tilQ IIIiQV,ci.II'~ilõ~i ti.:',-li~ï.,"àj¡if.,åi¡';:tÖi'; NOb 1'11:1it opa: .Ao' ,

l'lll'OØOI, lI1'h 811 ønd R1nIN1Ilrl",&ló:~ïkb~~ri.~~~i~J."'."'''' ';~j~ë~oi~,~ ii.1I0,~o1!t~:. "
unto Lli.: add 11 1'880 i! 8~utliö~ió~diiii~~~~d.$~= '~\í~~'~'lÒ~8 nnd DSII;I to"

, ", :" ,'," ;.~~...' .il,l,'!"\1l"'Ä11'" ~~i';,~",: . t iiolr iiad'
IN ll'lIIIOS 1lI1RROJ'. thO .814 ,PIi~,~~~~:,,~tr~~:':~,l.~~~C.....,::.*~~~~~~to 1111

~ DEFENDANT'S

i
l

If

E~IBIT
,...

--

'l\u day und '.Onl' t'1rAt niion Wl"ltt\'n.' ,',..::,'; ;;:,.:.::.::...,~" ..:'!.i'.;~itkOì. .
", ,; :~,! /.',;',~~;~~~:11~~i~ ~.~~~i\?.~:~~~;.,

: ~:,

,~. . ~.;;~~'-;.~.nv.;~..~~::.:\:.~..:~~~~::~.......i:I"-.;. :.~.. ..

Case 1:07-cv-002