Free Sur-Reply - District Court of Federal Claims - federal

Case 1:03-cv-00178-CCM

Document 70-7

Filed 10/12/2006

Page 1 of 5

Wharton Property
Sale Creek, TN
Assumption for In-place Coal Density: 80 lbs/cu-ft Recovery assumptions Surface Underground 90% 50% Recoverable Reserves (tons) Surface Underground 49,167 86,805 62,882 41,123 54,300 8,813 16,771 210,849 735,591 96,948 44,880 57,062 6,380 170,429 177,561 52,493 144,544 145,269 133,344 191,471 163,490 101,796 154,274 80,716 88,316 123,334 88,488 84,838 685,677 154,127 24,154 749,267 869,982 926,964 4,235,892 2,546,213 1,811,415 Rock Creek Watershed Boundary 1,007,009,857 sq. feet 23,118 Acres Recoverable Coal Contained within Rock Creek Watershed Boundary (tons) Surface Underground After Removal of the Watershed The following areas are still viable for permiting and mining Mineable Reserves Remaining After Watershed Removal (tons) Surface Underground 49,167 86,805 62,882 41,123 54,300 8,813 16,771 210,849 735,591 96,948 44,880 57,062 170,429 177,561 52,493 144,544 145,269 133,344 191,471 163,490 101,796 154,274 80,716 88,316 123,334 88,488 84,838 685,677 154,127 24,154 749,267 869,982 926,964 749,267 2,418,097 1,796,946

Morgan Springs & Richey Ridge Seams
Map Location Mo1 Mo2 Mo3 Mo4 Mo5a Mo5b Mo6 Mo7 Mo8 Mo9 Mo10 Mo11a Mo11b Mo12a Mo12b Mo13 Mo14 Mo15 Mo16 Mo17 Mo18 Mo19 Mo20 Mo21 Mo22a Mo22b Mo23 Mo24 Mo25a Mo25b Mo26a Mo26b Mo27 Mo28 Mo29 Area (sq feet) Surface Underground Surface 1,365,737 2,411,241 1,746,732 571,152 65,945 754,160 122,409 232,924 2,928,460 8,173,229 2,693,013 415,558 528,354 88,606 2,367,073 2,466,129 729,068 2,007,553 2,017,626 1,851,998 2,659,313 1,816,557 1,885,118 1,714,150 2,690,544 1,226,617 2,283,966 1,228,996 942,647 10,389,040 2,854,209 447,295 12,487,790 14,499,695 15,449,402 Area (acres) Underground 31 55 40 13 2 17 3 5 67 188 62 10 12 2 54 57 17 46 46 43 61 42 43 39 62 28 52 28 22 238 66 10 287 333 355 1,462 974 Coal Thickness 1.0 1.0 1.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.5 1.0 3.0 3.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.5 1.5 2.5 0.8 2.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 1.8 1.5 1.5 3.0 3.0 3.0 In-Place Resources (tons) Surface Underground 54,629 96,450 69,869 45,692 out side of property 60,333 9,793 18,634 234,277 817,323 107,721 49,867 63,402 7,088 189,366 197,290 58,325 160,604 161,410 148,160 212,745 181,656 113,107 171,415 89,685 98,129 137,038 98,320 94,265 761,863 171,253 26,838 1,498,535 1,739,963 1,853,928 4,706,546 5,092,426

Total Morgan Springs & Richey Ridge

Case 1:03-cv-00178-CCM

Document 70-7

Filed 10/12/2006

Page 2 of 5

Wharton Property
Sale Creek, TN Lantana Seam
Map Location La1 La2 La3 La4a La4b La5 La6 La7 La8 La9 La10 La11 La12 La13 La14 La15a La15b La16a La16b La17 La18 La19 La20 La21 La22 La23 La24 La25a La25b La26 La27 La28 La29 Area (sq feet) Surface Underground 336,649 1,163,930 1,799,298 1,633,979 336,709 1,175,065 982,466 666,038 1,426,386 2,928,765 869,045 1,306,881 533,038 1,011,861 896,105 493,157 413,636 548,993 753,849 795,939 784,713 5,916,054 1,277,864 5,165,980 397,422 265,661 6,491,915 5,561,288 4,353,468 1,234,213 927,225 2,164,174 3,221,667 Surface Area (acres) Underground 8 27 41 38 8 27 23 15 33 67 20 30 12 23 21 11 9 13 17 18 18 136 29 119 9 6 149 128 100 28 21 50 74 778 550 Coal Thickness 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 2.0 2.0 1.5 1.5 1.5 1.5 1.5 1.5 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 1.5 1.5 1.5 2.0 2.0 3.8 3.8 3.8 4.2 4.2 4.2 4.2 In-Place Resources (tons) Surface Underground 13,466 46,557 71,972 65,359 out side of property 47,003 78,597 53,283 85,583 175,726 52,143 78,413 31,982 60,712 71,688 39,453 33,091 43,919 60,308 63,675 62,777 354,963 76,672 309,959 31,794 21,253 995,427 852,731 667,532 205,702 154,538 360,696 out side of property 2,030,348 3,236,625 Recoverable Reserves (tons) Surface Underground 12,119 41,901 64,775 58,823 42,302 70,738 47,955 77,025 158,153 46,928 70,572 28,784 54,640 64,520 35,507 29,782 39,527 54,277 57,308 56,499 319,467 69,005 278,963 28,614 19,128 497,713 426,365 333,766 102,851 77,269 180,348 1,827,313 1,618,312 694,349 Rock Creek Watershed Boundary (tons) Surface Underground After Watershed Removal (tons) Surface Underground 12,119 41,901 64,775 58,823 42,302 70,738 47,955 77,025 158,153 46,928 70,572 28,784 54,640 64,520 35,507 29,782 39,527 54,277 57,308 56,499 319,467 69,005 278,963

497,713 426,365

Total Lantana

426,365

1,085,222

497,713

Sewanee Seam
Map Location Se1 Se2a Se2b Se2c Se2d Se3 Se4 Se5 Se6a Se6b Se6c Area (sq feet) Surface Underground 52,031,542 955,195 6,643,465 937,175 76,679 6,794,145 3,566,584 1,373,861 580,154 1,563,819 1,716,111 Surface Area (acres) Underground 1,194 22 153 22 2 156 82 32 13 36 39 1,750 Coal Thickness 2.1 2.1 2.1 2.1 2.1 2.1 2.1 2.1 2.1 2.1 2.1 In-Place Resources (tons) Surface Underground 4,387,993 80,555 560,266 79,035 6,467 572,973 300,782 115,862 48,926 131,882 144,725 6,429,466 Recoverable Reserves (tons) Surface Underground 3,949,194 72,499 504,239 71,132 5,820 515,676 270,704 104,276 44,034 118,694 130,253 5,786,519 Rock Creek Watershed Boundary (tons) Surface Underground 3,949,194 504,239 After Watershed Removal (tons) Surface Underground

515,676 270,704 104,276 44,034

Total Sewanee

5,388,122

-

-

Case 1:03-cv-00178-CCM

Document 70-7
Sale Creek, TN

Filed 10/12/2006

Page 3 of 5

Wharton Property
Richland Seam
Map Location Ri1 Ri2 Ri3 Ri4 Ri5 Ri6 Ri7 Ri8a Ri8b Ri9 Ri10 Ri11 Ri12a Ri12b Ri12c Ri13 Ri14 Ri15 Ri16 Ri17 Ri18 Ri19 Ri20 Ri21 Ri22 Ri23 Ri24 Ri25 Ri26a Ri26b Ri27a Ri27b Ri27c Ri27d Ri28a Ri28b Ri29a Ri29b Ri30a Ri30b Ri31 Ri32 Ri33 Ri34a Ri34b Ri35 Ri36a Ri36b Ri37 Ri38 Ri39 Ri40 Ri41 Ri42 Ri43 Ri44 Ri45 Ri46 Ri47 Ri48 Ri49 Ri50 Ri51 Ri52 Ri53 Area (sq feet) Surface Underground Surface 742,742 743,590 762,852 839,570 417,894 1,435,576 4,223,331 1,182,604 232,348 1,058,234 453,284 849,515 490,784 218,953 126,213 1,330,599 2,349,511 1,208,073 1,858,132 1,031,585 2,198,774 1,158,025 1,130,572 2,864,680 1,148,897 1,549,591 1,139,171 244,466 175,889 2,565,153 1,339,555 722,189 261,261 99,053 8,253,745 485,147 8,885,682 21,122,607 11,137,184 1,213,734 11,429,321 16,853,668 10,332,647 49,875,668 95,895,870 27,298,040 out side of property out side of property 100,929,268 7,180,633 4,592,962 8,279,950 2,965,522 3,621,331 599,407 4,190,541 5,301,702 8,926,071 out side of property 4,407,811 8,407,756 50,133,336 out side of property out side of property out side of property Area (acres) Underground 17 17 18 19 10 33 97 27 5 24 10 20 11 5 3 31 54 28 43 24 50 27 26 66 26 36 26 6 4 59 31 17 6 2 189 11 204 485 256 28 262 387 237 1,145 2,201 627 Coal Thickness 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 In-Place Resources (tons) Surface Underground 89,129 89,231 91,542 100,748 50,147 172,269 506,800 141,913 27,882 126,988 54,394 101,942 39,263 17,516 10,097 106,448 187,961 96,646 222,976 123,790 263,853 138,963 135,669 343,762 137,868 185,951 136,700 29,336 21,107 307,818 160,747 86,663 31,351 11,886 990,449 58,218 1,066,282 2,534,713 1,336,462 145,648 1,371,518 2,022,440 1,239,918 5,985,080 11,507,504 3,275,765 Recoverable Reserves (tons) Surface Underground 80,216 80,308 82,388 90,674 45,133 155,042 456,120 127,721 25,094 114,289 48,955 91,748 35,336 15,765 9,087 95,803 169,165 86,981 200,678 111,411 237,468 125,067 122,102 309,385 124,081 167,356 123,030 26,402 18,996 277,036 144,672 77,996 28,216 10,698 891,404 52,396 533,141 1,267,356 668,231 72,824 685,759 1,011,220 619,959 2,992,540 5,753,752 1,637,882 Rock Creek Watershed Boundary (tons) Surface Underground After Watershed Removal (tons) Surface Underground 80,216 80,308 82,388 90,674 45,133 155,042

456,120 127,721 25,094 114,289 48,955 91,748 35,336 15,765 9,087 95,803 169,165 86,981 200,678 111,411 237,468 125,067 122,102 309,385 124,081 167,356 123,030

277,036 144,672

891,404

1,267,356 668,231 685,759 1,011,220 619,959 2,992,540 5,753,752 1,637,882

2,317 165 105 190 68 83 14 96 122 205 101 193 1,151

3.0 2.3 2.3 2.3 2.3 2.3 2.3 2.3 2.3 2.3 2.0 3.0 3.0

12,111,512 646,257 413,367 745,196 266,897 325,920 53,947 377,149 477,153 803,346 352,625 1,008,931 6,016,000

6,055,756 323,128 206,683 372,598 133,448 162,960 26,973 188,574 238,577 401,673 176,312 504,465 3,008,000

6,055,756 323,128 206,683 372,598 162,960 26,973 188,574 238,577 401,673 176,312 3,008,000

Case 1:03-cv-00178-CCM

Document 70-7

Filed 10/12/2006

Page 4 of 5

Total Richland

1,076

10,642

5,398,021

54,083,629

4,858,219

27,041,815

2,901,266

13,056,943

1,742,249

12,740,993

Case 1:03-cv-00178-CCM

Document 70-7

Filed 10/12/2006

Page 5 of 5

Nelson Seam
Map Location Ne1 Ne2a Ne2b Ne2c Ne2d Ne2e Ne2f Ne2g Ne 2h Ne2i Ne2j Ne2k Ne3a Ne3b Ne3c Ne4 Ne5a Ne5b Ne6 Ne7 Ne8 Ne9 Ne10 Ne11 Surface Area (sq feet) Underground Surface 36,482,957 1,086,538 30,865,886 145,127 513,650 101,556,646 1,803,175 443,490 253,876,076 13,855,854 property not controlled 2,028,136 74,562,452 37,480,570 81,944,968 2,870,715 234,275 410,532 854,410 1,569,866 1,126,455 690,545 477,483 992,691 Area (acres) Underground 838 25 709 3 12 2,331 41 10 5,828 318 47 1,712 860 1,881 Coal Thickness 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 1.9 3.0 3.0 1.9 1.9 1.9 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 In-Place Resources (tons) Surface Underground 4,377,955 out side of property 3,703,906 out side of property 61,638 12,186,798 out side of property out side of property 30,465,129 1,062,282 243,376 5,716,455 2,873,510 6,282,448 344,486 28,113 49,264 102,529 188,384 135,175 82,865 57,298 119,123 1,107,237 310,037 25,302 44,337 92,276 169,545 121,657 74,579 51,568 107,211 996,513 Recoverable Reserves (tons) Surface Underground 2,188,977 1,851,953 30,819 6,093,399 Rock Creek Watershed Boundary (tons) Surface Underground After Watershed Removal (tons) Surface Underground 2,188,977 1,851,953

6,093,399

15,232,565 531,141 121,688 2,858,227 1,436,755 3,141,224 25,302

15,232,565 531,141

1,436,755 3,141,224 310,037 44,337 92,276 169,545 121,657 74,579 51,568 107,211 971,211

Total Nelson

-

14,615

66,973,497

33,486,748

25,302

17,200,461

13,275,553

Reserve Summary
Surface Total Morgan Springs & Richey Ridge Total Lantana Total Sewanee Total Richland Total Nelson

Area (acres) Underground 1,462 974 778 550 1,750 1,076 10,642 14,615 14,615

Coal Thickness

-

In-Place Resources (tons) Surface Underground 4,706,546 5,092,426 2,030,348 3,236,625 6,429,466 5,398,021 54,083,629 1,107,237 66,973,497

Recoverable Reserves (tons) Surface Underground 4,235,892 2,546,213 1,827,313 1,618,312 5,786,519 4,858,219 27,041,815 996,513 33,486,748

Rock Creek Watershed Boundary (tons) Surface Underground 1,811,415 749,267 694,349 426,365 5,388,122 2,901,266 13,056,943 25,302 17,200,461

After Watershed Removal (tons) Surface Underground 2,418,097 1,796,946 1,085,222 497,713 1,742,249 12,740,993 971,211 13,275,553

Total reserves

19,682

26,782

19,671,618

129,386,178

17,704,456

64,693,089

10,820,454

31,433,036

6,216,778

28,311,206