Free Motion to Dismiss - Rule 12(b)(1) - District Court of Federal Claims - federal

t-:Case 1:00-cv-00512-FMA Document 53-2 Case 5:00-cv-00303-DEW-KLH Document 228Filed 09/02/2008 Page 1 of 34 Filed 12/07/2005 Page 1 of 34

RECEIVED D~C 07 ~005 ~
RORT H. SlUWELL CLfRk
WE51RI l)$lRltT Of L6uSIAIiA
SHMV£PORT, LOUISIAIA

UNTED STATES DISTCT COURT
WESTERN DISTRICT OF LOUISIANA

PETRO-HU, L.L.C.; HUT
PETROLEUM CORPORATION AN
KIGFISHER RESOURCES, INC.
VERSUS

.
'*

CIACTION
NO. CVOO-0303 "S"

..
* *

JUE WALTER

*

UND STATE OF AMRICA AN *'
ASPECT REOURCES, LLC,; BAYOU * MAGISTRTE JUGE HAYES

PETROLEUM COMPAN; *
OIL & GAS CO.; JUSTISS OIL ·
NORTHSTAR

CATÃWBA ENERGY, INc. FIT *

TEXA HYROCARÓNS, INC.; *
OSCAR C. FORLAN; GULF COAS *

COMPAN, INC.; MATR ENERGY, * INC.;MB EXPLORATION LLC; ·

ENERGY, LLC; *

PALMER PETOLEUM INC; RICE & *

ASSOCITES, LLC; SNER On. ..
CORPORATION; HOWELL R. SPEAR *'

JOHN P. STRG; TECO *
EXPLORATION AN PRODUClION, '* INC.; TM EXLORATION, INC.; * UMC PETROLEUM CORPORATION; *

AN WHLES TDL EXPLORATION *
******.*******************.*************

CO?LLC *

JUDGMENT

Before the cour is plaitis' PETRO-HUN, L.L.C., HU PETROLEUM
CORPORATION an KIGFIHER RESOURCES, INC., Alteative Motion for
Summ Judgment peining to minem sertudes which ar held by dnllig or pructon,
and which have not prescòed, puuat to Louisiana mieral law. Afer considering the
t i I
L i . ~

motion and suppng memorda and affdavits and notg tbtthe government has not

Case 1:00-cv-00512-FMA Document 53-2 Case 5:00-cv-00303-DEW-KLH Document 228 Filed 09/02/2008 Page 2 of 34 Filed 12/07/2005 Page 2 of 34

opposed the motion, the Cour fids plaintiff' Motion to be well founed and it is hereby

GRAED;
IT is THEREFORE ORDERED, ADJUGED AN DECREED that

judgment be

and is herby enter in favor of plaitiffs, Pet-Hunt, LL.C., Hunt Petleum Corpration

and Kigfsher Resures, Inc., and agamt defendats, Unite Sta of Amerca; Ast
Resoures, L.L.C.; Justiss Oil Compy; MB Exploraon, L.L.C.; Palmer Petroleu Inc.;

Snyder Oil Corportion, a/a Santa Fe Snyder ai Devon SFS; John P. Strg; UMC
Petrleum Cor. and its succesor Ocan Energy Resour; Whles TDL Exploration Co.,

Ltd.; Bayou Petrleum Company; Firt Texas Hydrcarbos, Inc.; Oscar C. Forland;
Nort Energy, L.L.C.; Howell R. Spe Gulf

Coast Oil & Gas Co.; J. Braey Jeffys

and Energy Arow Exploration, L.L.C., declarg that th five nùer sedes desòe in
Exhbit "A," ar owned by plaintiff and, at ths tie, re in full fore and effect and have

not precribed becuse of inteption of prscrption by drlling or prduction of minerls,
pursuant to the Louisian rues of precription of mineral setudes; cosequently

ths cour

fids that plaintiff ar the owner in indivision of the five miner sertude decnbed on

Exbit "A," as follows:

PE1RQ.HUNT, L.L.C.: 64.28572%
HUNT PETROLEUM CORPORATION: 16.806720/0
KINGFISHR RESOURCES, INC. : 18.90756%
IT is FUTHER ORDERED, ADJUED AN DECREED that al mieral leas

-2-

Case 1:00-cv-00512-FMA Document 53-2 Case 5:00-cv-00303-DEW-KLH Document 228Filed 09/02/2008 Page 3 of 34 Filed 12/07/2005 Page 3 of 34

issued by the Unite States of Amerca on the five mineral seitude descnbed in Exhbit

"A" ar herby cancelled and set aside as null and void and the UND STATES OF

AMRICA sha cause the cacellation of al Oil Gas or Miner Leases which it ha
grte to any third par, tht intide onto the miner sertude descrbed in Exhbit "A,"
and that such cacellation sha be fied in the rerds oftb appprat Parsh of

the

situs of

such lands and tht a rerded copy of such cacellation shal be provided to plaintiff.
IT is FUTHR ORDERE, ADJUED

AN DECRE th Plaintiffs herby

resere the right to pure any and al clai for dages, caused by or as a result of the

isce of all intrsive leaes and any other clai they have agai the United State of

Amerca in the U.S. Cour of

Fedl CI' .

Orered ths

7

day

of

2005.

J) l0.J
UND STATE DISTRCT JUGE

-3-

Case 1:00-cv-00512-FMA Document 53-2 Case 5:00-cv-00303-DEW-KLH Document 228Filed 09/02/2008 Page 4 of 34 Filed 12/07/2005 Page 4 of 34

Approved as to Form and Content:

DONAL w. WASHIGTON Unite State Attrney

Asisnt Uni State Attrney
Unite States Courhouse
800 Lafayett Street Suite i200

KAN J. KIG (#23508)

Lafayette, Louisiana 70501-62 Telephone: (337) 262-1S
AttorBeys for the Vatted States

and

J. RAPH WH (#13425)
STELL SHACKLFORD (#27876)

FRELA & FREELAN, LAWYRS
P.O. BOX

269

1013 JACKON AVENU
OXFORD, MS 3855 Teleplione: (662) 234-3414

W. MICHL ADAM (#2338) BLANCHA, WALKER, O"QUI & ROBERTS
(A Profesional Law Corporation)
400 Texas Street, Suite 1400

P.O. Drawer 1126 ShrevePort LA 711631126 Telepbone: (318) 221..SS

Attorneys for Petro-Hunt, L.L.C.
aDd

-4-

Document 53-2 . .Case 1:00-cv-00512-FMA çase 5:00-cv-00303-DEW-KLH . Document 228 Filed 09/02/2008 Filed 12/07/2005 Page 5 of 34 Page 50f 34

JOHN M. McCOLLAM (#7117)

MATIBEW J. RAAZ, m (#14340) AIE WIIA HEERT (#25935)
GORDON, ARTA, McCLLAM,

DUPLAS" EAGAN, LL.P.
210 St. Charles Avenue, 8alfe 4000 New Orleans, Louisiana 70115
Telephone: (504) 582-1111

Attorneys for Hunt Petroleum Corpration and Kigfsher Resources

-5-

i
¡

i
í

i

Case 1:00-cv-00512-FMA Document 53-2 Case 5:00-cv-00303-DEW-KLH Document 228Filed 09/02/2008 Page 6 of 34 Filed 12/07/2005 Page 6 of 34

CERTICATE OF SERVICE
I HEBY CERTIFY tht I have OD ths 30th day ofNovembe~ 2005, sered a copy
. proposed Judgment on aU counsel of rerd by depting a copy of same in the Unted States

mail, propely addres and firs-class poste prepd.

lsi W. Michael Ada

-6-

Case 1:00-cv-00512-FMA Document 53-2 Case 5:00-cv-00303-DEW-KLH Document 228Filed 09/02/2008 Page 70f 34. Filed 12/07/2005 Page 7 of 34
t ~

-!t

EXHIT "A" ATI ACHD HERETO AN MAE PART HEREOF
SERVITUE

1

KISATCH NAnONAL FOREST LANDS

SUBCT TO PETRO HU MIRA SERVIES
WlCH AR HELD BY DRILING
AS OF JU 1, ZOOS

TOWNSHI 13 NORTH RAGE 7 WEST, LOmSIAA PM
S~tlOD
Is" Decription

Approi:. Acreage

E2E, W2NB, NW, NEW, SWSW, W2ESW, 360.61
NWS~

2 N2N2, S2NW,SW, 82SB 475.03
10 N2SWN SESWN, SEN, E2SWSB, E2E 169.23

-l Al 638.76
12 FJ4. SW/4NE4, WI2 NW/4, SFJ4 NW/4, 485.79
SWf4, Wn. SFJ4

13 FJ NE4, SW/4 NW/4, WI2 SW/4, NF4 SEl4 282.19
14 W2B2, SEN NW, N2SW less and excet aprox. 7 ac 518.99
being th par of

the NWSW lyig South of right-of-way for

L & A Raad SFSW les an except aprox. 3 ac being
th par of SBSW lying South of righ-of-way for L & A

Ralrad; NEE

15 E2NE les an except approx. 5 acre being that par 73.68
of NE less and excet aprox. 35.76 ac beg that par of

right-of-way for L & A Raiad the NEE lyig South of rigbt~of-way for L & A Ralrad.
the SENE lyig South of

23 N2NE, E2NW les and excep aprox. 67.22 ac be th par 92.61 ofthc B2NW lyig South ofrlgh-of-way for L & A Ralrad.

Case 1:00-cv-00512-FMA Document 53-2 Case 5:00-cv-003.03-DEW-KLH Document 228 Filed 09/02/2008 Page 88of 34 Filed 12/07/2005 Page of 34

SERVITUEl
KlSATCH NATIONAL FOREST LAN

SUBCT TO PETRO HU MIRA SERVIUDES
WHCH AR HELD BY DRDLING AS OF JU 1,2005
TOWNSHI 13 NORTH RAGE 6 WEST, LOUISIAA PM
SeeOD
6

Leal DesriptiOD Acreae
16 ac in a squar in theNW comer of

Approx.

the ~ 431.48

2 ac in the SE comer of

the SWN, W2. E2NWSE,

SWSE, SWSE
7
8

NE4. WI2. NF4 SFl4 559.94
in a sqUB in the Norwes come, and les 3 ac descnbed
as begi at a point 295 feet South of

NW.N2SW 239.78
NB less 30 ac OD th South side, N2NW, SENW less 2 acre 224.87

18

the Nortwes comer

of said fort acre ni thence Eat 210 yas, thence South 70

ya, thene West 210 ya thence nort 70 ya to the point
of

begig; NWSW, NEW les 4 ac in a squa in the

Southeat come
TOTAL ACREAGE FOR SERVITUDE 1:
4,552.96

-Filed 09/02/2008 Page 9 of 34 . . ...Case 1:00-cv-00512-FMA Document 53-2 228 Filed 12/07/2005 Page 9 of 34 Case 5:0Q-cv-00303-DEW-KLH Document
..: SERVITUDE

2

SUBCT TO PETRO HUT MIRA SERVIES
WHCH ARE HELD BY DRILING AS OF JU 1,2005

KlATCHI NATIONAL FOREST LAS

TOWNSH 13 NORTH RAGE 5 WEST, Louisiana PM
SecOD
1

LgaI DesrltiOD

Approx. Acreage
39.14
453.33

NWSW
E2E2, SW, NW. S2S2SW, S2NWSE, SWSB

2
3

Al
All

629.68

4
5

630.80
516.91 .

E2.B2W2, NW
B2NE
NE, Tht par of the S2SW lyig

6
7

81.00

East oCSale

153.70
f

Bayo~ SWSFJ4
8

E2 NW NE, SWSE
All

159.17

I .
j

9
10

638.20
601.13
i
l l
i

N2. SW. N2SE, SWSE

i

l
i

i
f

i

I
i

Case 1:00-cv-00512-FMA Document 53-2 Case 5:00:cv-00303-DEW-KLH Document 228 Filed 09/02/2008 Page 10 of 34 Filed 12/07/2005 Page 10 of 34

SERVIUDE

2

SUBCT TO PETO BUN MIRA SERVIES
WHCH AR HED BY DRILING
AS OF JUN 1, 2005

KlSATCB NATIONAL FOREST LANS

TOWNSHI 13 NORTH RAGE 5 WEST, Louisiana PM (continued)
Section
11

Approx. Legal Descrition Acrege

S2NE less 2 acr in a sq in th NE comer, E2W2, W2NW~ 517.5 i NWSW. E2SWSW, NW, S2NESE W2SEE, SESESE.
W2SE less 2.005 ac desribe as follows: Commencing at the
concree monument locate at the NW comer of

the NEESE

of Secon i i, T13N, RSW; thence prcee S 84° 13' W, a

distace of 1,269.8 feet, to a 2" alumum pipe with a ca stpe with La Reg. No. 447 set at the nort right-or-way
'orLa Hwy. 126t also bei the Point of

Begig;

The N 8~ 29' W along sad right-of':way. a ditace of 300.00 feet. to a W' diamet iron rod in the centelin of th Parsh road;

Thence N 01022' W along sad centerlin~ a distance of 122.93 fee, to a %" diameter irn rod;
Thence N 10° 44' W along said centerline. a dist of 177 .07 feet

to a W' diameter iron rod;

Thence S 89" 40' E a diste of 300.00 feet to a 2" alumm pipe with
a ca stpe with La Reg. No. 447;

12 SESW, 8WSE 79.68
13 W2NE. SE E2NW. SW, NEE, N2SESB. W2SE less 472.63
and except 24.82 ac in the NWSE, beig th sae 24.82 acres
acquied by

Thence S 06° 52' E a

distance of

300.00 feet to the Point of

Begig.

th U.S. in Civil Acton 2732, dated Janua 28,1937.

14 82NE. E2NW, SWN, E2SW, NWSW, SB, 480.27

Filed 09/02/2008 Page 11 of 34 . ...Case 1:00-cv-00512-FMA Document 53-2 228 Filed 12/07/2005 Page 11 of 34 C;:.se 5:00-cy-0030:3-()EW-l(LH Document

SERVIE

2

KISATCB NATIONAL FORE LANS SUBCT TO PETRO HU MIRA SERVITUDES
WHCH AR HELD BY DRILING AS OF JU 1,2005
TOWNSmp 13 NORTH, RAGE S WE, Louisiana PM (continued)
Section
15

Lea DesritioD
S2NE W2NW, S2
E2 NW, N2SW, E2ESW
NE, W2NW less i acre in SW comer of

Appro:!. Acreage
480.33

16
17

517.72

th NE, SW,

491.74

N2NESE~ NWSE, SWSE les 5 acre in a sq in the

SWcomer
18
W2NE NEE, Th par of W2SE, SESE lyig Eas of

th NW, NENW, SENW,

299.32

Salie Bayo
Sale Bayou

19

Th pa of the E2 lyg Ea of

15.00

20

W2NW, NE less ànd except a str on the West side, beg 120 yars wide and contag 10.90 ac, SWSB les 8.00 acres
in a squa in the NE comer, SESE
148.78

21

E2 E2NW, E2SWN, EZW2SWN, SW

589.59

22

NB les 3 ac in a squa in th Soutea comer,
W2~ SEN, W2, SE
634.78
599.82
519.16

23

E2, E2~.~, SW
S2NE, E2NW, NW, 82
W2NE less 15 acre off

24
25

the wes side dcsòe as follows:
beginng., E2NW
135.00

BEGING at the Southwes comer ofNW ru thence
due Eas 10 cha, thence Nort 15 chs, thence Wes 10
chans, thence South 15 cha, to the point of

26

All

64.00

Case 1:00-cv-00512-FMA Document 53-2 . Case 5:00-cv-00303-PEW-KLH Document 228 Filed 09/02/2008 Page 12 of 34 Filed 12/07/2005 Page 12 of 34

SERVIE

2

SUBCT TO PETRO HUN MIRA SERVIES WICH AR HELD BY DRIG
AS OF JU 1, 200S
TOWNSHI 13 NORTH RAGE 5 WEST, Loul~laa PM (continued)

KlATCHE NATIONAL FORET LANS

Secon
27

Le DeeriptioD

ApproL Acreage

. NE, W2NE N2SB, NE, W2NW, 5 ac in a squar
in the Southea comer of the SWSW, S2SESW, NENEE, S2NESE, W2~S~ S2SE
403.31

28

NE, E2NW, NW, N2NESW, NWSW les 10 ac in a
squa in the Nortwest comer, W2SWSW. SWSB. N2SESE

410.05

29

NENE, W2NE Th par of the W2 lyig Eat of Saline Bayou conta 212.02 ac. SE,
Th par of scction lyig East of Sale Bayou

492.47

32

421.50

33

S~ NW, N2SWN, SWSWN, SENE, E2NW,
SWN. SW. N2SE, SESE less 5.5 acre in the Southeat comer, desbed as follows; BEGI at the Soutea comer of the section, an nm thence West along the South lie of
setion 40 ros, thence at right angles eaterly 40 rod, to the
Ea lie of

the setion, thence sotherly along the East lie
begg.

of the setion to the place of

484.50

34

E2, NE. NW less 2.0 acs desc'bed as follows;
BEGIN at the Nortwest comer of

the setion ro thence

South 70 ya, thence Eas 140 ya, thence Nort
70 ya to the Nort boundar of i 40 ya to the point of

the setion, thene West

beg., S2NW, SW

637.76
639.12

35

ALL

Case 5:00-cv-00303-DEW-KLH Document 228 Filed 12/07/2005 Page

Case 1:00-cv-00512-FMA

Document 53-2

Filed 09/02/2008

Page 13 of 34 130f 34
T.

SERVITUE

2

KlATCH NATIONAL FOREST LAS

SUBCT TO PETRO HU MIRA SERVITUES
WIeH AR HELD BY DRILING AS OF JU i, 2005
TOWNSmp 13 NORTH RAGE 5 WEST, Louisiana PM (contlnued)
ApproL

Secon
36

l.a. DeICriDtiOD

Acree

S2NE W2NW, E2NW, NW les 2 ac in the
Nortwes comer more parcularly described as follows:
BEGlNG at the NOJwcs comer of

seon an ru

thence due Ea 209 feet; thence South 418 fee thene
Wes 209 feet; then Nort 4 i 8 fet to poin of

begig,

SWN, SESW, SE

457.91

TOWNSmP 12 NORTH, RAGE 5 WEST

Secon
I

Leal DesmptioD

Approx. Acreage
638.12
614.40
472.93 468.13

All

2 3

Al
H2, B2NW, S2SW

4
5

SE.W2
That par oftbe E2 of

the Section lyig Ea of Salie Bayou

224.00 361.80
619.76 641.80
1 ,

10
11

N2,SBSB
All
All

12
13

Al
E2. NW, N2SW, N2SWSW, SESW

641.96
604.55
T

14

,

Case 1:00-cv-00512-FMA Document 53-2 Case 5:00-cv-00303-DEW-KLH Document 228 Filed 09/02/2008 Page 14 of 34 Filed 12/07/2005 Page 14 of 34

SERVITIE 2

SUBCl TO PETRO HUN MIRA SERVIES
WHCH AR HELD BY DRILING
AS OF JU 1, 200

KISATCH NATIONAL FOREST LANS

TOWNSIDP 12 NORTH RAGE 5 WEST, Louisiana PM (continued)
Section
15

Approx. Legal DeritiOD Acreage
E2NB SWN les and except the Nort 24 ac

S2SW les an excet the Nort 28 acre (N.4S7.04'). SE 309.57
16
Th par of the Setion lyg East of

Sale Bayou 365.00

22

W2NENE, NW NE. W2W2. SEN less and except
5 ac in a squae in the Southeat comer. NBW les and except

3 ac in a sqe Norteas comer an les and except 2 aces
desbed as follows: BEGING at the Southwe come of

the
begig, thence Nort 140

for. ro then Nort along the Wes lie oflhe fort 110 yas.
then Ea 154 ya to th point of ya~ thce Eas 70 ya. thence 70 ya to point of

23

24
2S

MI ~~~ All 635.65
E2, E2NW4, SWN. SW 586.76
NE N2SEN. W2E2. W2 529.16
Th par of

beging. 330.79

South 140 ya. thence Wes

26
27
28

E2. NW. E2SW 560.14
the S2SW lyig Eas of Sale Bayou, SWSE i 15.35

Case 1:00-cv-00512-FMA Document 53-2 Case 5:00-cv-:Q03Q3-DEW-KLH __ Document 228 Filed 09/02/2008 Page 15 of 34 Filed 12/07/2005 Page 15 of 34
,,
; ¡

1.
~

SERVIE

2

KlATCl NATIONAL FORET LAN

SUBCT TO PETRO HU MIRA SERVITUES
WHCH AR HELD BY DRILING
AS OF JU 1,200

TOWNSHI 12 NORTH, RAGE 5 WEST, Louisiana PM (continued)
Section
29
33

Leg DecriedoD

ApproL Acreage
79.15

E2SE
Th par

of Section lyig Ea of Salie Bayou

400.00

34 W2NE, W2SEN, Tht par of follows: BEGING at the Nortwest coer of

th NE desõe as
the section

an ru ihence Nor 88° 16 Ba 1,298 fee to point of thence contie on

begg,

same coure Nort 88° 16' East 1,298 fee thene

due South 860 feet thence Nort 58° West 1,530 fee along Nort
side of right-of-way ofL & A Ralway, thence due Nort 10 fee to
poin of

35 NW, E2SWN 58.92
TOWNSHI 11 NORTH RAGE 5 WEST, Louisiana PM
Setion
i
2
3

SWN, 8282, NWSW. NEE 413.30

begnn, sad trt cotanig 12.96 ac, S2NW.

Leal Descrtion
W2NW

Approx. Acreage
80.39

NENE. W2NE, NW. NW8W

318.72

N2. N2SW, SWSW. NEE

485.10

Case 1:00-cv-00512-FMA Document 53-2 Case 5:00-cy-:00303~DEW-KLH Document 228Filed 09/02/2008 Page 16 of 34 Filed 12/07/2005 Page 16 of 34

SERVIE

2

SUBCl TO PETRO HUN MIRA SERVIUDES
WHCH AR HELD BY DRILING AS OF JU 1,2005
TOWNSHI 11 NORTH RAGE 5 WET, Louisiana PM (continued
Seeon
4
10

KIATCHIE NATIONAL FOREST LANS

Leal Deseritin
Th par lyig East of the SaJíne Bayou

Appro". Acreage
324.14 320.00

W2B2. N2NW. SESW, SESE

TOWNSIDP 13 NORm, RAGE 4 WET, Louisiana PM
Section
18

Legal DesriUon
SWN. NWSW. W2SWSW

I. Acreage
Appro

100.01

TOWNSHI 12 NORTH, RANGE 4 WEST, Loulsl8D8 PM
ApproL
Section
6

Legal Deription
N2NW, SWN less and excet 77.05 aces lyi in the N2NW

Acreage

and the SWN whch wer exchaned to Wilie Glen
Emet and Barar Louie Webb Emmett by deed daed

Janua 1 i ~ i 994. Exhbit I. Exchange Dee, FS Trat C- i 74. SW, W2SE, SESE
7
8

325.70

Al
SW les and excet the Nort 35 acre of

636.80
the SW lyig Eat

LAHwy.SOi.
17
18 19

125.27

S2NW SWN, S2NE, W2NW, SEN. SW, SWSE
All
All

400.67

637.56
637.72

"Case 5:00-cv-00303-DEW-KLH Document 228 Filed 12/07/2005 Page 17

Case 1:00-cv-00512-FMA

Document 53-2

Filed 09/02/2008

Page 17 of 34 of 34

SERVIE

2

SUBCT TO PEO HU MIRA SERVIES
WHm AR HELD BY DRILING
AS OF JUN 1, ZOOS
TOWNSHI 12 NORTH, RAGE 4 WE~ Louisiana PM

KlSATCHE NATIONAL FOREST LADS

(contiDued)

Secdon
20
21

ApproL
Leal Descrption

A~reag
601.24
40.03

NE) W2NE, W2, SE
SWSW

26

the S2SW an the 82SB lyig South of LAHwy1232
Th par of

111.2
119.95

28 29 30
33

W2N. S2SW. W2SE8E,

Al
NI2

638.92 317.78
558.53

E2NEt SWN. NB, W2NW, 82
NE, E2NW, 8WN, S2NW, N2SESW) W2SW, N2SE

34

478.92

35

NB W2N, NEW, W2SW, S2NESE, NWSE
N2SESE
B2NE, SWN, SEN. W2NW, N2SW, NWSE

380.02

36

359.84

TOTAL ACREAGE FOR SERVIE 2:

32,840.54

Case 1:00-cv-00512-FMA Document 53-2 Case.5:00-cv-00303-DEV\LK.LH Document 228Filed 09/02/2008 Page 18 of 34 Filed 12/07/2005 Page 18 of 34

SERVIE

3

K1SATCH NATIONAL FOREST LAN

SUBCT TO PETRO HUN MIRA SERVIUDES
WHCH AR HELD BY DRILING
AS OF MAY i, 2005

TOWNSHI 11 NORTH, RAGE 5 WEST, Louisiana PM
ApproL
SecOD
13

Legal Descrtion
S2

Aereage
317.04

14

SEN, Fration SWN. SENW, NEW,
Fraona NWSW, E2SE, SWSE

290.82 260.20

15

Fractiona SWN. W2NW4. Frational SENW.
Fractona 82

21

Frationa NE
E2. NE, S2NEW. E2SWSW. SESW. an th par of

29.18

22

the S2NW. N2NW, NWW. AN W2SWSW lyi Ea
of

the Mon-Natchitoches Road.

531.70 479.55

23

NE,W2

24
25

Al
Al
NENE. W2NW. N2SWN, NENW, W2NW,

634.40
632.80

26

N2NEEN. W2SEN. E2SE, SWSE
27
28

345.11

N2, SW, W2SE, W2SESE

580.36

EI
to the SaIco Corpration by dee date July 15, 1997. and desbed

320.00

33 B2NE. SWN, SE, W2 less and except 163.17 acre exchanged

in Exbit 1. Exchage Deed FS Trat C-169. 44.83

Case 1:00-cv-00512-FMA Document 53-2 Case.5:00-cv-00303-0EW-KLH Document 228Filed 09/02/2008 Page 190f 34 Filed 12/07/2005 Page 19 of 34

SERVITUE

3

SUBCT TO PETO HU MI SERVIES
wmCH AR HELD BY DRILING
AS OF MAY I, :iOO

IaATCBI NATIONAL FORET LAN

TOWNSmp 11 NORTH, RAGE 5 WEST, Louisiana PM (continued)
Section
34
35

Leal Desctin
All

Approx. Acreaie
640.00

E2, E2NW. SWN. SW
NENE. W2NE, W2, SB,
1ñt par of ingular Section 37, otherise knwn as the

60.00
596.02

36 37

Eman Prmme entr with the lits of Setions 14
_ and is

269.75

TOWNSHI 10 NORTH, RAGE 5 WEST, Louisiau. PM

Seon
I

Leal Desriptin
W2NE,W2
S2NB, N2NW, S2SW. SE

Approx. Acreage
405.72
398.75

2

3 NE NE les and except 6 acre more parcularly
desri~ as follows: COMMCIG at a point 5 chai Sout
of the Nortes comer of the NE. ru the Ea 4 chai, th Sout i S cha. thence Wes 4 çha~ thene Nort is chai to the point of

benng; NW. W2SE, SESENW 303.61

4 N2NW. W2E2NW. W2N, SW. NWSB. 340.21
10 NE. NB less 12 acres in a squar in the Nortwest comer. and les 2.19 ac desbed as follows; BEGING at the
Nortea comer of Nortwes comer of

the Wyatt 12 ac tract located in the

the NB; then Sout i 0.95 chais to

star thence South 2 chas; thce West 10.95 chas, thence
Nor 2 cha; thene Eat 10.95 chas to the point of

begig;

SBN. E2SW. NWSW, SWSW les 4 acre in a squar in the Southea comer W2SE less 1 acre in a squ in the Norwest

comer. 461.41

Case 1:00-cv-00512-FMA Document 53-2 Case 5:00-cv-:00303-DEW-KLH Document 228 Filed 09/02/2008 Page 20 of 34 Filed 12/07/2005 Page 20 of 34

SERVITUE

3

KlSATCH NATIONAL FOREST LANDS

SUBCT TO PETRO HUT MIRA SERVIUDES
WlCH AR HELD BY DRILLING
AS OF MAY 1,2005

TOWNSHI 10 NORTH, RANGE 5 WEST, Louisiana PM (continued)
ApproL Section Legal Description Acreage
11 Al less and excet 2.71 acre locaed in the SWSB, which were

qutclaied to Couley Double Chui an Cemete Commttee

by dee date Novem 2, 1988. 639.49

14W2NE E2NW. NW 198.86 N2NW 80.05 15
12 W2NE NW. N2SW. W2SWSW, N2SESW, 3SS.l4

16 NE les and except 1.62 ac described as follows: 158.42
Commencig at the Norteat comer of said Setion 16, thene S 350 42' 13" W, a dista of 699.88 feet, to the Poin of Begng.
Thence S 41045' 42" E,a distace of230.21 feet;
Thence S 19° is' 00" W, a distae of238.34 feet to the centelin

of an existing grvel road;
Thence N 4io 4412211 W along sad ceterline, a distace of fee to the centerlie or

329.47

U.S. Hw. 84;

Thence N 320 II' 08" E along sad centerlie, a distance of 252.75 fee; Thene S 41045' 4211 H, a distace of52.03 feet,
to the Point of

Beginng.

TOWNSIDP 11 NORTH RANGE 4 WEST, Louisiana PM
Seetion
8

LeaJ Descrition
S2NB, SWN. SW, E2SE, W2W2SEt

Appro:i.

Acrege

398.07

9

SENW,S2

358.52

Case 1:00-cv-00512-FMA Document 53-2 Case 5:00-cv-00303-DEW-KLH Document 228Filed 09/02/2008 Page 21 of 34 Filed 12/07/2005 Page 21 of 34

SERVITUE

3

KIATC NATIONAL FORE LANS

SUBCT TO PETRO HUN MI SERVIUDES
WHCH AR HE BY DRILLIG
AS OF MAY 1,200

TOWNSHI 11 NORTH, RAGE 4 WEST, Louisiana PM (continued)
SedioD

Legal Del:rJtiOD

Approx. Acreage

10

SWN, S2NW, SWW, SE les and excet 2.88 acs descnòed 314.52 as follows: Begi at the Eat one quaer comer of sad Secon 10, From sad FOB ru: S 00 36' 08 u W.40.S3 fee to a point in the
cetelin of LA Hwy 501, thence with therneaer of

the center-

line of sad highway Oie lies:
N S8° 16.28'. W, 310.24 fee

N 54° 23' 24" W. 211.04 fe;

N 50°31' sr W. 191.28 fee thence
S 89° is' 00" E. 588.70 fee to the point of beginnin.

11

N2N. SWN SENE les 2 ac desn"b as follows: the SEN, then ro Nor along Ea line of sae 121-28/47 ya to the point of
Commenin at the South comer of

396.00

begig; thence Due Nort 98-19/47 yads; thence Due West
98-19/47 ya; thence Due South 98- 19/47 yars; thence Due
Eas 98-19/47 ya to the point of

begig; E2SW. NEE,

W2SE. SESE les .80 ac desòed as follows: Begig at

th SW comer of SESE, thoe ru Nort 3.50 çhais; thence
Due Ea 2.28 chains; thence Due South 3.50 cha; thence
Due Wes 2.28 chas to the point of beginng.

13

W2W2

159.88

14

NW E2NW, SWN. SW/4. SWSE less 10 acr
off the Ea side.

348.74

15

W~ SENE, NW. NESW, SE

477.60
278.35 637.80

16 17

E2, SWN. NE, W2NW, NEE

Al

Case 1:00-cv-00512-FMA Document 53-2 Case 5:00-cv-00303-DEW-KLH Document 228 Filed 09/02/2008 Page 22 of 34 Filed 12/07/2005 Page 22 of 34

SERVITUE

3

KISATCH NATIONAL FOREST LANDS

SUBCT TO PETRO BU MIRA SERVIUDES
WHCH AR HELD BY DRILING
AS OF MAY 1, 1005

TOWNSWP 11 NORTH RAGE 4 WET, Louisiana PM (eontinued)
Approx.
SecdOD
18
19

Le Desrlption
NE,SW
All

Acrege
316.18
631.77

20
21

Al
W2NE W2.SE

638.64
555.87

22

N2NENE. SWNNE, W2NE, W2SEN, sri

448.96

23

NW, E2NW, NW. N2SWN, SESWN,
SW

349.34

24
25

W2N.SW
W2.SE

239.11

477.27
404.33

26

NW, N2SWN. N2SEN, NE, SEN les 5 acres
Qtrthe Ea si~ SW. W2NSE, NWSWSE, SZSWSE, SESE

27 28
29 30
31

All
All

639.64

635.24 637.92 414.73

All

E2NE, N2NW NW, NESW, S2SW, SE
E2NE NW. NENW, W2NW, NWSW. SESW,
E2SE. NWSE les 12 acre in a squar in the SW corner,

SWSE less 10 ac in a squae in the Nortwest comer

453.62

Case 5:00-cv~OQ303~PEW-KLH Document 228 Filed 12/07/2005 Page 23

Case 1:00-cv-00512-FMA

Document 53-2

Filed 09/02/2008

Page 23 of 34 of 34

SERVIE

3

SUBCl TO PETRO HU MIRA SERVIES
WlCH AR HELD BY

K1ATCl NATIONAL FOREST LAS

DRILING

AS OF MAY I, 200

TOWNSID 11 NORTI RAGE 4 WEST, Louisiana PM (continued)

Secon Legal Deription A.creage
32
33

Approx.

Al
All All

638.00
634.20

34
35

639.68

E2NE-NW. W2. NE
Al

477.72
635.88

36

TOWNSHI 10 NORTH, RAGE 4 WEST, Louisiana PM
Appro:r.
§ectiOD
1

Legl Deription
All

Acrge
645.76
158.18

2
3

W2NE.E2NW
All

649.45 643.40

5

Al
E2. E2NW. SWN les and except 1.474 ac desbe as
, follows: Coenin at the Nortwest corner of sad SW.

6

608.24

thence N 890 55' E along the Nort lie of said SW. a dice
of 482.58 fee to the centene oru.s. Hwy. 84; thence
S 610 07' W along sad cetere. a diste of 552.46 feet. to
the Wes li of

sad SW. thence N 00° 15' E along sad Wes

lie. a ditace of266.1S fet to the point ofbegg; SW
7

All

627.92

TOTAL ACREAGE FOR SERVITUDE 3:

16,885.95

Case 1:00-cv-00512-FMA Document 53-2 Case 5:00-cv-00303-DEW-KLH Document 228Filed 09/02/2008 Page 24 of 34 Filed 12/07/2005 Page 24 of 34

SERVIE

4

KISATCHI NATIONAL FOREST LANS

SUBCT TO PETRO HU MINERA SERVIES
WHCH AR HELD BY DRILIG AS OF JU 1, 2005
TOWNsmp 10 NORTH RAGE 3 WE, LOUISIAA PM
Approx.

Sedon
25

Legal Description
All
E2NE

Acrge
635.76
79.95
357.01

26
36

E2,SESW

TOWNSmP 9 NORm RAGE 3 WEST, LOUISIA PM
1

W2NE, W2,SB

555.35

2
11

82SE

79.67

Frationa E2E2, NW, E2NW, SESW, SWSE

253.34
566.37
174.00

37
12
13

Al
All

Al
NE, N2SE, SESE
SENE, S2SW les 15.12 acre as desnbed in
dee betwee Grant Timber & Manufactug Copany of

638.64 280.74

14

22

LA, Inc. and the U.S. dated Janua 28, 1934, and rerded in

Bok zz Page 359 of Grant Parsh; E2SE, NWSE less i i .80 ac as descrbed in above referced dee SWSE
23

S~. E2~, S~, 82

481.98

Case 5:00-cv-00303:DEW-KLH.. . Document 228 Filed 12/07/2005 Page 25

Case 1:00-cv-00512-FMA

Document 53-2

Filed 09/02/2008

Page 25 'of 34 of 34
~ ..

i

SERVlE4
KISATCBI NATIONAL FORET LAS

SUBJECT TO PETRO HU llRA SERVIES
WHCH AR HELD BY DRILLIG AS OF JU 1, 2005
TOWNsmp 9 NORTH, RAGE

3 WEST, LOUISIAA PM (eoDtiDUed)

Section
24

Leal DesptioD
Begi at the Nortwes çomer of

ApproL Acreage

m. B2NW, NW less 2~S3 ac descnDe as follows: the section, thence ro Ba
along the Nort bounda lie 113 yads, thence South 85 yas to
th trt for a point of

th Nortwest comer of

begig, thce

South 175 yar. thence Ea 70 yars. then Nort 175 yas.
thence Wes 10 yar to the point of beginng.

637.2
642.00
f"

2S

Al
62. NE les i acre descnòe as follows: Begi at the
Nortwest comer of the SENW and ru due Nort 200 feet to
to a point ofbegig. ru thence due eat 210 feet; thene due

26

nort 2 i 0 feè~ thence due Wes 210 fee thence due South 210 feet to the point of begig. W2NW. 82
27 34
3S

600.88

W2,SE
All
W2NE, W2.SB

481.92
641.20
560.49 280.13

36

NE, NE, W2SW

l
j
1

oj
. i
I

I

Case 1:00-cv-00512-FMA Document 53-2 Case 5:00-cv-00303-DEW-KLH Document 228 Filed 09/02/2008 Page 26 of 34 Filed 12/07/2005 Page 26 of 34

SERVIE

4

; KISATCIl NATIONAL FOREST LAS

SUBCT TO PETRO HU MIRA SERVIUDES
WHCH AR HELD BY DRILING AS OF JU 1,2005
TOWNsmp 10 NORTH, RAGE i WE, LOUIIAA PM
Secton
29

Approx.

LeBl DemtiOD
SWN, W2. W2SE. SESE excepti frm thes lands

Acrege

the Rock Island Aran and Louisiana Raad Coany nght-of-way
10.07 ac of

469.69
554.58

31

NENE. S2N2, NW. 82

32
33

E2E2. E2VV, SVf
SWN les 3.31 ac of

354.19

the Rock Islan Aianas
115.98

and Louiiana Ralrad rMo-w, W2SW

TOTAL ACREAGE FOR SERVIE 4:

9,441.10

Case 1:00-cv-00512-FMA Document 53-2 Filed 12/07/2005 Page 27 of 34 Case 5:00-cv-00303-DEW-:KLH Document 228 Filed09/02/2008 Page Zrof 34

SERVIES
SUBCT TO PETRO HU MIRA smVIES
winCH AR HELD BY DRIING
AS OF JU i~ zos

KIATCHNATIONAL FORET LAS

TOWNsmp 9 NORTH, RAGE i WET, LOUISIANA PM

Secon
3

Le Derition
Al
SEN B2NW~ S2Nt SWN, NEW, S2SWt SE
N2NB less 3.18 ac in NW quitclaied to Zion Bati

Acrege
634.44 450.27

ApproL

4
5

Churh, by dee dated December 20, i 972, W2NW,
S2NW, SW, S2SB
6 7
8
9 All

407.03

N2, N2SW, N2SWSWt SESWSW, SESW, SE

614.25

All
W2W2NW, NWSW

638.24
79.38

less one ace desbed as follows: Commencig at a the NWt being the POB. Thence ru Wes along the nort bounar lie of sad sectiòn, i 96.2 feet to a ste, thene South 204 feet to the nort bounda lie oftb ROW of the L& Ralway Company,. thene Southeaerly
stake at the norteast comer of alon sad ROW line to the ea lie of the Nort along sai east lie 240 fee to the point of the NW of

Secon 9,

begg. 635.20
417.69 638.76

10
11

NW, N2SW, W2SWSW, SE
AU

14

NB, N2NWt B2, SBSW, N2SE less 2 acre in the southwes corn of the NEEas descnòed in dee daed
Septeber 5, 1901, an recorded in CB "K", page 438 of rerds of

the
400.01

Grant Parh., W2SWSE

Case 1:00-cv-00512-FMA Document 53-2 Case 5:00-cv-00303-DEW-KLH Document 228 Filed 09/02/2008 Page 28 of 34 Filed 12/07/2005 Page 28 of 34

SERVIES
KlSATCI NATIONAL FOREST LAS
SUBCT TO PETO HUNT MINERA SERVIUDES

WleH AR HED BY DRILIG
AS OF JU i,200

TOWNSHI 9 NORT, RAGE 1 WEST, LOUISIAA PM (continued)
Section
15

Le DeseptiOD

Approi:. Acreage
479.25

N2,N2S2
All
E2E2. S2S2NE. W2SWt SESW. SWSE

16 17
18 19

637.20 328.10
224.55
639.96 636.56 639.12

NENW, South 5/8 ofNWSW, 82S2
All

20
21

Al
All

22

S2S2NW. SWN. 82SBN. NESEN, NW,
S2NE, NW. S2NW,52
548.11

23

li, ~, S2~. 82
SWSW

601.20

24
25 26
27 28 29 30

40.09
560.11

NE, NW, S2N2. 82
All All All
AIl

640.24 637.20 640.32 637.88
360.22

~t N2~. S~. ~SE. SESE

Case 1:00-cv-00512-FMA Document 53-2 Filed 12/07/2005 Page29'of 34 Page 29 of 34 Case 5:00-cv-00303-QEVV-KLH Document 228 Filed09/02/2008

SERVITUES
KlSATCH NATIONAL FORET LANS

SUBCT TO PETRO HU MIRA SERVIUDES
WHCH AR HELD BY DRIING
AS OF JU I, 2005
TOWNSHIP 9 NORTH, RAGE i WET, LOUISIAA PM (COllUIIlIed
Approx.
~CtiOD
31

Leal DeptfOD
Al
82NB. B2NW, 82

Acrege
641.76

32
33

479.67

N2NE, SWN. NE. S2N. SW

400.50
109.74

34
3S

NE. N2N, SE NE
N2N2.SEN
EI, NI2 NW/4. FJ SW/4

220.00 479.79

36

TOWNSWP 8 NORm, RAGE i WEST, LOUIIAA PM
Section

Lg:aI Descrition

ApproL Acreage
606.44

4
6

E2. E2W2. NW, W2SW
NE. SBN, N2SW, SWSW les 2 acre in the southeat comer desbe as fonows: Begg in the southea comer of said

.l

4( ac. thence ru Nort 20 ro, thence Wes i 6 ro
then South 20 ro, then Bas 16 rods to the point of

,

i

N28E. SWSE 438.30
beginning,
18

;

NWSW

39.76

I :

I i
I

l

,
j
¡ f ¡

!

Case 1:00-cv-00512-FMA Document 53-2 Case 5:00-cv-00303-DEW-KLH Document 228Filed 09/02/2008 Page 30 of 34 Filed 12/07/2005 Page 30 of 34

SERVITUDES
KlSATCHIE NATIONAL FOREST LAS

SUBcr TO PEO HU MI SERVITUES
WHCH AR HELD BY DRILLIG
AS OF JU 1,200

TOWNSHI 9 NORTH, RAGE:i WEST, LOmSIANA PM
Section
1

Lel Decription

Approx. Acreage
627.21
225.65 513.09
117.39
the

Al
NE. N2NWSW, N2S2NWSW, S282

2
3

N2,NESW.SE

4
5

NE,S2SE
N2NW, SWN, SW less 19.57 acre on the eat side of

8Was shown on ExJbit 1 Map, being those lands conveyed to B. E. Meltn by deed datd Augu 21,1970.
6

354.99

E2 les 0.76 aces in SENE quitclaied to Tyson Cemeter
Commttee by dee dated August 23, 1988 as descbe in

Exhibit 2, NEW
7
8 Fraonal 82S2

343.34
163.18

E2. S2SW, SWSE

280.26

37

Par of of

Frationa Section 37, otherise described as the N2S2
Section 8

Section 7 and the W2NE. NW, N2SW, NWSE of

496.76
595.91

9
10
11

NW. 82NE W2, SE
S2NW,82
N2NE, NENW, N2SENW, NWSW, 8282. NWSE

399.57 382.64 361.30
521.46

12
13

NE E2NW, N2SE SESE

NENE W2,SE

Case 5:00-cv-00303-DEW-KLH Document 228Filed 09/02/2008 Page 31 of 34 Filed 12/07/2005 Page 31 of 34 Case 1:00-cv-00512-FMA Document 53-2

SERVIES
KlATCH NATIONAL FOREST LAS
SUBJECT TO PETRO BU MINERA SERVIUDES

WHCH AR HE BY DRILING
AS OF JU 1,2005
TOWNsmp 9 NORTH, RAGE i WET, WUJSIAA PM (eotiued)
Section
14
15
16
i7

Leal Deption
Al
Al Al
All
N2, N2S2, 82SB

ApproL

Acreae
645.24 637.52

638.00

638.20
526.12
414.15

18

19

W2, W2SE, SESE

20
21

Al
All

637.60 638.00 637.34

22
23 24 25

All

Al
All
All

64.00
642.20
642.60

26
27
28

All
AD

642.80
638.32

N2, SW, N2SE, SWSB
All

598.50
636.80
226,52

29

30

S2NW, NEW. N2SE. SESE

Case 1:00-cv-00512-FMA Document 53-2 Case 5:00-cv-00303-DEW-KLH . Document 228Filed 09/02/2008 Page 32 of 34 Filed 12/07/2005 Page 32 of 34

SERVITUES
KlSATCHIE NATIONAL FOREST LADS

SUBCl TO PETRO HUN MIRA SERVITUDES WHCH AR HELD BY DRILIG
AS OF JU 1,200

TOWNSHIP 9 NORTH, RAGE 2 WET, LOlJSIAA PM (eoDtiued)
Secton
31

Legal DespUOD
E2NB, NW, S2NW. N2SW. SESW. SE

Approx. Acreage
454.35
518.70

32 33

N2. N2S2. SWSE
N2, NWSW, SESE

399.62
599.30

34
35

NI2. Fl2 8W/4, SEl4
All

641.20

36

NW. S2NE NW, 82

60.94

TOWNSHI 8 NORm, RAGE 2 WEST, LOUISIAA PM

Secon
i
2
3

Leal Descripdon

Approx. Acreage
635.75

All All

645.44 640.40
397.46 596.30

All
E2E2, SWN, W2W2, SESW

4
5

E2, E2W2, SWN. W2SW
NW. S2NE. E2NW. NESW, N2SE, SESE

6

435.50 618.20
600.84
557.02

7
8

Al
N2. SW, ~8E, 82SB

9

N2. NEW, SWSW, SE

Cas.e 1:00-cv-00512-FMA Document 53-2228Filed 09/02/2008 Page 33 of 34 Filed 12/07/2005 Page 33 of 34 Case 5:00-cv-00303-DEW-KLH Document

SERVIUDES

SUBcr TO PETO BU MIRA SERVIDES
WHCH AR HELD BY DRILING
AS OF JUNE I, 2005

KlATci NATIONA FORE LAS

TOWNSIDP 8 NORTH, RAGE i WE, LOUISIANA PM (eoDtiued)

Seeon
10

Legal Decription

Approx. Acreage
309.28

NB, NE~ N2NW, E2EN, E2W2SENW,
S2NEE, SESE

11

NE N2SW. SWSW, mSE
N2NE, SWN, W2, W2SB, SESE

361.43

12

553.80

13

NB, E2NW, SWN. SW, N2SE, SWSE, and tht par of
th SES lyig nort ofFish Creek

586.91

14

E2N W2N, SW les 10 ac in the NWSW desbe as
follows; Beginning at the norteat comer of

th sad NWSW,

nm South alon the eas line therf 50 rods, thene Wes 32 rods.
thence Nort 50 ros, thence Ea 32 ro, to the plae of

beginnng, SE
16 17 18

473.72
521.46

N2,SW,NEE
N2, SW, W2SB, SESE
NB less 1 ac beg near the nortwest comer of said NE,
as desbe in de to Whte Chael Churh, by dee reorded

603.30

in CD "M" Page 10, S2NW. SW. N2SE
19

465.28 612.00 515.16 317.92

All

20

Nf2. NE4 SW/4, SBl4
WI2 NE4, NW/4, NI2 SW/4
00, W/2 NW/4, NI2 SW/4, SEl4 SW/4

29
30

499.34

Case 5:00-cv-00303:DEW-KL.H Document 228 Filed 12/07/2005 Page 34 of 3-4 Case 1:00-cv-00512-FMA Document 53-2 Filed 09/02/2008 Page 34 of 34

SERVITUES

SUBCl TO PETRO HU MIRA SERVIES
WHCH AR HELD BY DRILING AS OF JU 1,2005
TOWNSHI 8 NORTH RAGE 3 WEST, LOUISIAA PM
SectioD
1

KlSATCB NATIONAL FORE LANS

Legal Deserdon

ApproL
515.55
632.28
599.77

Acree

SWN, W2,SE
All

2
11

N2, N2SW, SESW. SE

12

N2,N2SB
SESE

397.85
39.78

13
14

NW
S2NE S2SW, SE

40.05 318.04 536.76

24
25

NE SlNW, SW, N2SE, SWSE, W2SESE

TOTAL ACREGE FOR SERVITUDE S:

36,123.98