Case 1:93-cv-00531-LAS
Document 253
Filed 01/22/2008
Page 1 of 236
IN THE UNITED STATES COURT OF FEDERAL CLAIMS __________________________________________ ) AMBASE CORPORATION ) AND CARTERET BANCORP, INC. ) ) Plaintiffs, ) ) and ) ) FEDERAL DEPOSIT INSURANCE ) CORPORATION, ) Plaintiff-Intervenor, ) ) v. ) ) THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, ) ) Defendant. ) __________________________________________)
Case No. 93-531C (Senior Judge Loren Smith)
DEFENDANT'S FINAL EXHIBIT LIST Defendant, the United States, respectfully submits the attached final list of exhibits to be used at trial, other than those to be used for impeachment or rebuttal. We hereby reserve the right to offer any exhibit listed on the exhibit lists filed by plaintiffs and plaintiff-intervenor, which we incorporate by reference, and to supplement or amend this list in accordance with the Rules and Orders of this Court, by stipulation, or to rebut or address testimony offered by plaintiffs or plaintiff-intervenor.
Case 1:93-cv-00531-LAS
Document 253
Filed 01/22/2008
Page 2 of 236
Respectfully submitted,
MICHAEL F. HERTZ Deputy Assistant Attorney General
JEANNE E. DAVIDSON Director s/Kenneth M. Dintzer KENNETH M. DINTZER Assistant Director TAREK SAWI Senior Trial Counsel s/David A. Levitt by Arlene Groner DAVID A. LEVITT ARLENE PIANKO GRONER ELIZABETH M. HOSFORD F. JEFFERSON HUGHES DELISA SANCHEZ AMANDA TANTUM Trial Attorney Commercial Litigation Branch Civil Division U.S. Department of Justice 1100 L Street, NW Washington, DC 20005 Tel: (202) 307-0309 Fax: (202) 514-7969 January 22, 2008 Attorneys for Defendant
Case 1:93-cv-00531-LAS
Document 253
Filed 01/22/2008
Page 3 of 236 Page 1 of 233
AMBASE V. UNITED STATES Case No. 93-531C TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST (DXs) BY EXHIBIT ORDER
as of 1/22/08
Exhibit # DX 4
Date 03/17/1992
Bates Range
ADIIS Range WOQ679 1376 - 1376
Description MEMO FROM ROBERT ALBANESE TO FILE RE CARTERET RECAPITALIZATION, CARTERET SAVINGS BANK FA, 3/17/1992 MEMO FROM BRENT BEESLEY TO FHLBB RE FSLIC ASSISTED MERGER OF BARTON S&LA AND UNASSISTED SUPERVISORY MERGER OF FIRST FS&LA OF DELRAY BEACH INTO CARTERET S&LA, FA, 9/30/1982 CARTERET SAVINGS BANK, FA V. OTS, FHLBB, T. TIMOTHY RYAN, JR. , FDIC AND FSLIC, OPINION, 04/25/1991
DX 19
09/30/1982
WOB011 0390 - 0402
DX 21
04/25/1991
C-AM-A-0403574 -0403627 WOP763 1843 - 1846
DX 22
03/01/1991
LTR FROM WILLIAM PURCELL TO CHARLES O'TOOLE, RE RESPONSE TO 2/27/1991 OTS LETTER, 3/1/1991 MEMO FROM ROBERT O'BRIEN TO ROBERT WALSH RE TELEPHONE CALL FROM RICHARD KALIKOW, 4/22/1991 TIMETABLE FOR COMPLIANCE WITH SUPERVISORY AGREEMENT DATED APRIL 29, 1991 BETWEEN CARTERET SAVINGS BANK, FA AND OTS, 4/29/1991
DX 24
04/22/1991
AMB069603 - -069603
PAM009 0643 - 0643
DX 25
04/29/1991
WOQ653 0406 - 0411
to Appendix A, Paragraph 16 of the Rules of the Court of Federal Claims, this exhibit list identifies with asterisks those documents Defendant expects to introduce into evidence. Defendant may seek to introduce into evidence other documents on this exhibit list if the need arises as well as exhibits on the exhibit list of plaintiff and plaintiff-intervenor, which are incorporated by reference.
1 Pursuant
Case 1:93-cv-00531-LAS
Document 253
Filed 01/22/2008
Page 4 of 236 Page 2 of 233
AMBASE V. UNITED STATES Case No. 93-531C TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST (DXs) BY EXHIBIT ORDER
as of 1/22/08 Exhibit # DX 26 Date 05/21/1991 Bates Range AM00064684 -0064684 ADIIS Range RAM004 0005 - 0005 Description
LTR FROM ANGELO VIGNA, TO BOARD OF DIRECTORS CARTERET BANCORP, INC. AND CARTERET SAVINGS BANK, FA RE NOTICE OF NOMINATIONS OF RICHARD BIANCO, RONALD BURNS AND DONALD KRAMER AS DIRECTORS OF CARTERET BANCORP, INC. AND CARTERET SAVINGS BANK, FA, 5/21/1991 FAX OF LETTER FROM ROBERT WALSH TO ANGELO VIGNA, RE NOTICE PURSUANT TO SECTION 914 OF FIRREA, CARTERET SAVINGS FA, 5/22/1991 MEMO OF ORAL COMMUNICATION, OTS NO. 4702, BY MICHAEL FINN, OF NOTES FROM MEETING WITH WITH RICHARD BIANCO, CARTERET SAVINGS FA AND VIGNA/ALBANESE/SIMONE, OTS-NE, RE GENERAL DISCUSSION, CARTERET SAVINGS BANK, FA, 5/31/1991 EXECUTED EMPLOYMENT AGREEMENT DATED JUNE 1, 1991 BETWEEN AMBASE CORPORATION AND RICHARD A. BIANCO, AMBASE CORPORATION, 6/1/1991
DX 27
05/22/1991
WOQ685 0274 - 0274
DX 29
05/31/1991
WOQ685 1769 - 1769
DX 30
06/01/1991
WOQ642 1815 - 1822
1 Pursuant
to Appendix A, Paragraph 16 of the Rules of the Court of Federal Claims, this exhibit list identifies with asterisks those documents Defendant expects to introduce into evidence. Defendant may seek to introduce into evidence other documents on this exhibit list if the need arises as well as exhibits on the exhibit list of plaintiff and plaintiff-intervenor, which are incorporated by reference.
Case 1:93-cv-00531-LAS
Document 253
Filed 01/22/2008
Page 5 of 236 Page 3 of 233
AMBASE V. UNITED STATES Case No. 93-531C TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST (DXs) BY EXHIBIT ORDER
as of 1/22/08 Exhibit # DX 32 Date 06/05/1991 Bates Range AMB33494 AMB33495 ADIIS Range PAM010 1186 - 1187 Description
FAX OF LTR FROM RANDOLPH ELKINS TO RICHARD BIANCO AND ROBERT WALSH RE SUPERVISORY DIRECTIVE ON BONUSES AND OTHER COMPENSATION ARRANGEMENTS, ONGOING BONUS/INCENTIVES/SEVERENCE ARRANGEMENTS, 6/5/1991 MEMO FROM ROBERT CYCON TO RICHARD BIANCO RE POTENTIAL SALE OF IMPERIAL PREMIUM FINANCE, INC., IMPERIAL PREMIUM, 6/20/1991 LTR FROM GEO. T. SCHARFFENBERGER TO MR. RICHARD BIANCO, RE RESTRICTED STOCK AWARD, 6/25/1991 LTR FROM RICHARD BIANCO TO WILLIAM PURCELL RE AGREEMENT TO RENDER FINANCIAL ADVISORY SERVICES TO AMBASE CORPORATION, 6/25/1991 LTR FROM DONALD KRAMER TO MICHAEL SIMONE RE EMPLOYMENT AGREEMENT WITH RICHARD BIANCO, KCP HOLDING COMPANY, 7/10/1991
DX 36
06/20/1991
AMB069903 - -069903
PAM009 0685 - 0685
DX 37
06/25/1991
WOQ690 0873 - 0874
DX 38
06/25/1991
WOQ642 1827 - 1828
DX 39
07/10/1991
WOQ674 2036 - 2037
to Appendix A, Paragraph 16 of the Rules of the Court of Federal Claims, this exhibit list identifies with asterisks those documents Defendant expects to introduce into evidence. Defendant may seek to introduce into evidence other documents on this exhibit list if the need arises as well as exhibits on the exhibit list of plaintiff and plaintiff-intervenor, which are incorporated by reference.
1 Pursuant
Case 1:93-cv-00531-LAS
Document 253
Filed 01/22/2008
Page 6 of 236 Page 4 of 233
AMBASE V. UNITED STATES Case No. 93-531C TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST (DXs) BY EXHIBIT ORDER
as of 1/22/08 Exhibit # *DX 40 Date 07/20/1992 Bates Range ADIIS Range WOP332 0803 - 0804 Description
FAX AMBASE CORP. NEWS RELEASE ANNOUNCING "AMBASE AND KOHLBERG & CO. SIGN LETTER OF INTENT FOR CARTERET SAVINGS BANK RECAPITALIZATION, 7/20/1992 MEMO FROM WILLIAM PURCELL TO RICHARD BIANCO RE SUMMARY REPORT OF ATTEMPT TO SELL IMPERIAL PREMIUM FINANCE ("IPF"), CARTERET SAVINGS FA, 7/22/1991 MEMO FROM WAYNE MOOR TO RICHARD BIANCO RE PORTFOLIO ANALYSIS, CARTERET SAVINGS BANK FA, 8/8/91 LTR FROM VAUGHN BLAKE AND JOHN QUIRK TO RICHARD BIANCO RE PROGRESS IN THE FINANCING ARRANGEMENTS FOR AMBASE CORPORATION TO PURCHASE THE COMMON STOCK OF IMPERIAL PREMIUM FINANCE, INC. FOR $65.0 MILLION, AMBASE CORPORATION, 8/9/1991 LTR FROM VAUGHN BLAKE TO RICHARD BIANCO RE REVISED FEE ARRANGEMENT, AMBASE CORPORATION, 8/12/91
DX 41
07/22/1991
WOQ692 2227 - 2232
*DX 44
08/08/1991
WOQ666 1770 - 1772
DX 45
08/09/1991
WOQ674 1899 - 1900
DX 46
08/12/1991
AM00047287 -00047288
RAM002 2843 - 2844
to Appendix A, Paragraph 16 of the Rules of the Court of Federal Claims, this exhibit list identifies with asterisks those documents Defendant expects to introduce into evidence. Defendant may seek to introduce into evidence other documents on this exhibit list if the need arises as well as exhibits on the exhibit list of plaintiff and plaintiff-intervenor, which are incorporated by reference.
1 Pursuant
Case 1:93-cv-00531-LAS
Document 253
Filed 01/22/2008
Page 7 of 236 Page 5 of 233
AMBASE V. UNITED STATES Case No. 93-531C TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST (DXs) BY EXHIBIT ORDER
as of 1/22/08 Exhibit # DX 47 Date 08/16/1991 Bates Range ADIIS Range WOQ690 2385 - 2386 Description
MEMO FROM GEORGE HERGER TO THE FILE RE 8/13/91 MEETING WITH NEW MANAGEMENT, CARTERET SAVINGS BANK FA, 8/16/91 LTR FROM DAVID MAUGHAN TO RICHARD BIANCO RE KIDDER PEABODY'S FINANCIAL AND MARKETING PROPOSAL FOR RECAPITALIZATION, CARTERET SAVINGS BANK FA, 10/22/91 LTR FROM NGAIRE CUNEO TO RICHARD BIANCO RE GE CAPITAL REQUEST TO BE CONSIDERED AS A CARTERET SAVINGS BANK POTENTIAL INVESTOR, CARTERET SAVINGS BANK FA, 11/12/91 MEMO FROM MICHAEL SIMONE TO FILE RE 11/19/91 CONFERENCE CALL TO DISCUSS AMERICAN STOCK TRANSFER AND TRUST COMPANY'S INTEREST IN INFUSING CAPITAL INTO CARTERET FEDERAL SAVINGS BANK, CARTERET SAVINGS BANK FA, 12/16/91
DX 49
10/22/1991
WOT692 1486 - 1487
*DX 51
11/12/1991
WOQ653 0672 - 0672
DX 52
12/16/1991
WOQ653 2330 - 2331
1 Pursuant
to Appendix A, Paragraph 16 of the Rules of the Court of Federal Claims, this exhibit list identifies with asterisks those documents Defendant expects to introduce into evidence. Defendant may seek to introduce into evidence other documents on this exhibit list if the need arises as well as exhibits on the exhibit list of plaintiff and plaintiff-intervenor, which are incorporated by reference.
Case 1:93-cv-00531-LAS
Document 253
Filed 01/22/2008
Page 8 of 236 Page 6 of 233
AMBASE V. UNITED STATES Case No. 93-531C TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST (DXs) BY EXHIBIT ORDER
as of 1/22/08 Exhibit # DX 53 Date 12/23/1991 Bates Range AMB0010598 AMB0010599 ADIIS Range PAM002 3131 - 3132 Description
LTR FROM STEVEN GOULART TO RICHARD BIANCO RE SUMMATION OF 12/20/1991 TELEPHONE CONVERSATION CONCERNING MERRILL LYNCH'S FINANCIAL PROPOSAL FOR THE MERGER OF CARTERET AND AMERICAN STOCK TRANSFER AND RAISING CAPITAL, CARTERET SAVINGS BANK FA, 12/23/1991 LTR FROM MICHAEL KARFUNKEL TO AMBASE CORPORATION, ATTENTION RICHARD BIANCO, RE CONFIRMATION OF RECENT DISCUSSIONS REGARDING CONTINUING INTEREST IN MERGING WITH CARTERET, CARTERET SAVINGS BANK, 12/20/91 ARTICLE FROM THE RECORD 2/19/1992 REPORTING ON CARTERET'S QUEST FOR AN ADDITIONAL $150-200 MILLION IN NEW CAPITAL, CARTERET SAVINGS BANK FA, 2/19/99 MEMO FROM RICHARD BIANCO TO AMBASE DIRECTORS, SENIOR OFFICERS AND ADVISORS RE CONTACT WITH OTS AND FDIC, CARTERET SAVINGS BANK FA, 3/9/92
DX 54
12/20/1991
AMB0010593 -0010593
PAM002 3126 - 3126
DX 55
02/19/1992
WOP332 2016 - 2017
DX 56
03/09/1992
AMB068452 - -068452
PAM007 0351 - 0351
to Appendix A, Paragraph 16 of the Rules of the Court of Federal Claims, this exhibit list identifies with asterisks those documents Defendant expects to introduce into evidence. Defendant may seek to introduce into evidence other documents on this exhibit list if the need arises as well as exhibits on the exhibit list of plaintiff and plaintiff-intervenor, which are incorporated by reference.
1 Pursuant
Case 1:93-cv-00531-LAS
Document 253
Filed 01/22/2008
Page 9 of 236 Page 7 of 233
AMBASE V. UNITED STATES Case No. 93-531C TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST (DXs) BY EXHIBIT ORDER
as of 1/22/08 Exhibit # DX 57 Date 05/29/1992 Bates Range C-AM-A-0323526 -0323526 ADIIS Range CAM244 0036 - 0036 Description
MEMO FROM JOHN FLEMING TO RICHARD BIANCO RE WESTERN FEDERAL SAVINGS AND LOAN, CARTERET SAVINGS BANK FA, 5/29/92 FAX TRANSMITTAL FROM MERRILL LYNCH TO DICK BIANCO AND NEIL COHEN, K. ALBERT RE DRAFT OF PRESENTATION TO THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS, AMBASE CORPORATION 7/15/92 LTR OF INTENT FROM KOHLBERG & COMPANY TO AMBASE CORPORATION RE PURCHASE OF CARTERET SAVINGS BANK FA BY NEWCO, AMBASE CORPORATION, 7/17/92 MEMO FROM PURCELL TO BIANCO AND COHEN RE LISTING OF LARGE AMBASE COMMON SHAREHOLDERS, AMBASE, 7/29/99 MEMO FROM TOM O'ROURKE TO JOHN GRIFFIN, SCOTT SMITH, AND EXAMINATION/SUPERVISORY FILES RE 8/24/1992 MEETING RECAP, CARTERET SAVINGS BANK FA, 8/27/92 LTR FROM MICHAEL ZAMORSKI RE CARTERET SAVINGS BANK, F.A., 8/28/92
DX 61
07/15/1992
C-AM-A-0178726 -0178733
CAM132 0921 - 0928
*DX 62
07/17/1992
AMB071894 - -071897
PAM007 1765 - 1768
DX 63
07/29/1992
AMB071861 - -071862
PAM009 1735 - 1736
DX 64
08/27/1992
WOQ679 0692 - 0695
DX 65
08/28/1992
FAM002 1081 - 1085
to Appendix A, Paragraph 16 of the Rules of the Court of Federal Claims, this exhibit list identifies with asterisks those documents Defendant expects to introduce into evidence. Defendant may seek to introduce into evidence other documents on this exhibit list if the need arises as well as exhibits on the exhibit list of plaintiff and plaintiff-intervenor, which are incorporated by reference.
1 Pursuant
Case 1:93-cv-00531-LAS
Document 253
Filed 01/22/2008
Page 10 of 236 Page 8 of 233
AMBASE V. UNITED STATES Case No. 93-531C TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST (DXs) BY EXHIBIT ORDER
as of 1/22/08 Exhibit # DX 69 DX 70 Date 11/09/1990 08/11/1992 Bates Range ADIIS Range WOR648 0235 - 0245 WOQ642 1831 - 1831 Description SEC SCHEDULE 13D, AMBASE CORPORATION, 11/9/90
LISTING OF SHARES OWNED BY OFFICERS, DIRECTORS UNDER PLANS OF THE COMPANY AND MAJOR STOCKHOLDERS AS OF 6/30/1992, AMBASE CORPORATION, 8/11/92 LTR FROM KPMG PEAT MARWICK TO CARTERET SAVINGS BANK, FA RE AUDIT OF THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS OF CARTERET SAVINGS BANK, FA AND SUBSIDIARIES FOR THE YEAR ENDED DECEMBER 31, 1990, CARTERET SAVINGS BANK, FA, 7/8/91 CONFIDENTIAL REPORT OF FINDINGS RE CARTERET SAVINGS BANK SUBMITTED TO KOHLBERG & CO BY LYONS, ZOMBACK & OSTROWSKI, INC., CARTERET SAVINGS BANK, 8/21/99 ASSISTANCE AGREEMENT BETWEEN FSLIC AND CARTERET SAVINGS BANK, F.A., DATED JUNE 6, 1986
DX 84
07/08/1991
FAM002 2361 - 2365
*DX 95
08/21/1992
K000001 - -000056
WOP338 1374 - 1392 WOQ628 1397 - 1432
DX 110
06/06/1986
WOR064 0001 - 0097
to Appendix A, Paragraph 16 of the Rules of the Court of Federal Claims, this exhibit list identifies with asterisks those documents Defendant expects to introduce into evidence. Defendant may seek to introduce into evidence other documents on this exhibit list if the need arises as well as exhibits on the exhibit list of plaintiff and plaintiff-intervenor, which are incorporated by reference.
1 Pursuant
Case 1:93-cv-00531-LAS
Document 253
Filed 01/22/2008
Page 11 of 236 Page 9 of 233
AMBASE V. UNITED STATES Case No. 93-531C TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST (DXs) BY EXHIBIT ORDER
as of 1/22/08 Exhibit # DX 112 Date 02/13/1990 Bates Range AM001423 - -001426 ADIIS Range Description
CARTERET SAVINGS BANK, F.A., AGENDA FOR SPECIAL BOARD OF DIRECTORS MEETING, FEBRUARY 13, 1990 WOQ682 1050 - 1054 MEMO: FROM CLAIRE M. CHADWICK, MANAGER-EXTERNAL REPORTING, TO WILLIAM J. DAY, FDIC EXAMINER-IN-CHARGE, RE: CARTERET SAVINGS BANK AND SUBSIDIARIES FINANCIAL STATEMENTS, JUNE 30, 1989 MEMO: FROM CLAIRE M. CHADWICK, MANAGER- EXTERNAL REPORTING, TO WILLIAM J. DAY, FDIC EXAMINER-IN-CHARGE, RE: CARTERET SAVINGS BANK AND SUBSIDIARIES FINANCIAL STATEMENTS AUGUST 31, 1989 MEMO: FROM WILLIAM J. DAY, JR., EXAMINER, TO THE FILES RE: CARTERET SAVINGS BANK REGARDING GENERAL DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION AND POSSIBLE INSIDER INVOLVEMENT WITH PRINCIPALS OF AMBASE VIA PREVIOUS RELATIONSHIP WITH CITY INVESTING COMPANY
DX 113
10/03/1989
DX 114
10/13/1989
WOQ682 1047 - 1049
DX 115
08/01/1990
WOT692 1148 - 1152
to Appendix A, Paragraph 16 of the Rules of the Court of Federal Claims, this exhibit list identifies with asterisks those documents Defendant expects to introduce into evidence. Defendant may seek to introduce into evidence other documents on this exhibit list if the need arises as well as exhibits on the exhibit list of plaintiff and plaintiff-intervenor, which are incorporated by reference.
1 Pursuant
Case 1:93-cv-00531-LAS
Document 253
Filed 01/22/2008
Page 12 of 236 Page 10 of 233
AMBASE V. UNITED STATES Case No. 93-531C TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST (DXs) BY EXHIBIT ORDER
as of 1/22/08 Exhibit # DX 116 Date 08/06/1990 Bates Range ADIIS Range WOQ682 1471 - 1471 Description
MEMO: FROM WILLIAM J. DAY, JR., EXAMINER, TO NICHOLAS J. KETCHA, JR., REGIONAL DIRECTOR RE: CARTERET SAVINGS BANK INTERIM REPORT MEMO: FROM WILLIAM J. DAY, JR. TO NICHOLAS J. KETCHA, JR. RE: CARTERET SAVINGS BANK MEMO: FROM WILLIAM J. DAY, JR., EXAMINER, TO "THE FILES" RE: CARTERET SAVINGS BANK MEMO: FROM WILLIAM J. DAY, JR., EXAMINER, TO LEE SMITH, CONTROLLER, RE: CAPITAL (REGULATORY CAPITAL COMPUTATION) MEMO: FROM JEFFREY J. CARFORA, VICE PRESIDENT / ASSISTANT CONTROLLER, TO WILLIAM J. DAY, JR., FDIC EXAMINER, RE: CAPITAL (REGULATORY CAPITAL COMPUTATION)
DX 117
08/13/1990
WOQ682 1467 - 1467
DX 118
09/06/1990
WOQ682 1446 - 1446
DX 119
09/11/1990
WOQ682 1445 - 1445
DX 120
09/25/1990
AM018960 - -018965
to Appendix A, Paragraph 16 of the Rules of the Court of Federal Claims, this exhibit list identifies with asterisks those documents Defendant expects to introduce into evidence. Defendant may seek to introduce into evidence other documents on this exhibit list if the need arises as well as exhibits on the exhibit list of plaintiff and plaintiff-intervenor, which are incorporated by reference.
1 Pursuant
Case 1:93-cv-00531-LAS
Document 253
Filed 01/22/2008
Page 13 of 236 Page 11 of 233
AMBASE V. UNITED STATES Case No. 93-531C TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST (DXs) BY EXHIBIT ORDER
as of 1/22/08 Exhibit # DX 122 Date 04/10/1991 Bates Range AM048913 - -048915 ADIIS Range Description
LTR: FROM CARTERET SAVINGS BANK TO DANIEL DIONNE, ASSISTANT REGIONAL DIRECTOR, FDIC RE: BOARD OF DIRECTORS MEETING FOR FDIC PRESENTATION OF ITS 1990 EXAMINATION REPORT CAM387 0216 - 0217 LTR: FROM JOHN MCGRORY, COMPLIANCE EXAMINATION MANAGER, TO THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS OF CARTERET SAVINGS BANK RE: COMMENTS AND SUGGESTIONS BASED ON REPORT OF COMPLIANCE EXAMINATION AS OF DECEMBER 10, 1990 LTR: FROM NICHOLAS J. KETCHA, JR., REGIONAL DIRECTOR FOR FDIC, TO ANGELO A. VIGNA RE: MEETING WITH BOARD OF DIRECTORS HELD ON APRIL 22, 1991 LTR: FROM NICHOLAS J. KETCHA, JR., REGIONAL DIRECTOR FOR FDIC TO ANGELO A. VIGNA, REGIONAL DIRECTOR, OTS AND CARTERET BOARD OF DIRECTORS RE: CARTERET SAVINGS BANK, FA
DX 129
07/31/1991
DX 130
04/29/1991
WOT671 0671 - 0672
DX 131
06/28/1991
WOQ698 1429 - 1431
to Appendix A, Paragraph 16 of the Rules of the Court of Federal Claims, this exhibit list identifies with asterisks those documents Defendant expects to introduce into evidence. Defendant may seek to introduce into evidence other documents on this exhibit list if the need arises as well as exhibits on the exhibit list of plaintiff and plaintiff-intervenor, which are incorporated by reference.
1 Pursuant
Case 1:93-cv-00531-LAS
Document 253
Filed 01/22/2008
Page 14 of 236 Page 12 of 233
AMBASE V. UNITED STATES Case No. 93-531C TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST (DXs) BY EXHIBIT ORDER
as of 1/22/08 Exhibit # DX 135 Date 11/27/1991 Bates Range ADIIS Range WOQ653 0053 - 0058 Description
LTR: FROM DONALD KRAMER TO RICHARD L. BRAUN, ARTHUR E. GILGAR, CHARLES J. MCCABE, LEO O. MCCABE, ROBERT E. MCCARTHY AND ROBERT C. WALSH RE: REPAYMENT OF BONUSES FOR THE FISCAL YEAR ENDED DECEMBER 31, 1990 LTR: FROM A. PATRICK DOYLE TO OFFICE OF THE SECRETARY AT FHLBB CC: BRIAN D DITTENHAFER, PRINCIPAL SUPERVISORY AGENT FOR THE FHLBB OF NEW YORK RE: APPLICATION OF THE HOME GROUP, INC TO ACQUIRE CARTERET BANCORP AND ITS WHOLLY OWNED SUBSIDIARY CARTERET SAVINGS BANK, FA INTEROFFICE MEMO: FROM PAMELA BISHOP TO BRIAN DITTENHAFER, ANGELO VIGNA, BILL DURBIN, ROY N. JENSEN, MICHAEL SIMONE AND DAVID DORGAN RE: CARTERET SAVINGS BANK INFORMATIONAL REPORT MEMO: FROM DARREL W DOCHOW TO PROFESSIONAL STAFF- EXAMINATIONS AND SUPERVISION
DX 140
12/04/1987
WOR060 2467 - 2469
DX 147
07/19/1989
WOQ652 2120 - 2123
DX 153
06/17/1988
GF0028472 - -0028487
to Appendix A, Paragraph 16 of the Rules of the Court of Federal Claims, this exhibit list identifies with asterisks those documents Defendant expects to introduce into evidence. Defendant may seek to introduce into evidence other documents on this exhibit list if the need arises as well as exhibits on the exhibit list of plaintiff and plaintiff-intervenor, which are incorporated by reference.
1 Pursuant
Case 1:93-cv-00531-LAS
Document 253
Filed 01/22/2008
Page 15 of 236 Page 13 of 233
AMBASE V. UNITED STATES Case No. 93-531C TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST (DXs) BY EXHIBIT ORDER
as of 1/22/08 Exhibit # DX 156 Date 11/09/1988 Bates Range ADIIS Range OGC006 1478 - 1479 Description
MEMO: FROM JONATHAN L FIECHTER TO DIRECTORS OF AGENCY FUNCTIONS RE: PROPOSED RISK-BASED CAPITAL RULE: IMPACT BY DISTRICT BANK MEMO: FROM JONATHAN L. FIECHTER, DEPUTY EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR TO CHAIRMAN WALL RE: THRIFT INDUSTRY LIQUIDITY STATISTICS THRIFT BULLETIN,TB 36A, SECTION 320 SUBJECT: CAPITAL ADEQUACY; HANDBOOK: THRIFT ACTIVITIES RE: GUIDELINES FOR FIRREA CAPITAL PLANS, EXEMPTIONS AND EXCEPTIONS MEMO: FROM JOHN F. ROBINSON TO DARREL W. DOCHOW THROUGH JONATHAN FIECHTER RE: POLICY STATEMENT ON REGULATORY CAPITAL MAINTENANCE OBLIGATIONS OF SAVINGS AND LOAN HOLDING COMPANIES FSLIC AMENDMENT NO. 1 TO APPLICATION H-(D)2 WITH A COPY TO DOUGLAS P. FAUCETTE, ESQ, MULDOON, MURPHY & FAUCETTE
DX 159
02/06/1989
OGC061 0346 - 0347
*DX 164
11/06/1989
GF0024673 - -0024680
DX 166
05/XX/1988
SMO170343 - -O170345
DX 169
05/11/1988
AMB046218 - -046248
to Appendix A, Paragraph 16 of the Rules of the Court of Federal Claims, this exhibit list identifies with asterisks those documents Defendant expects to introduce into evidence. Defendant may seek to introduce into evidence other documents on this exhibit list if the need arises as well as exhibits on the exhibit list of plaintiff and plaintiff-intervenor, which are incorporated by reference.
1 Pursuant
Case 1:93-cv-00531-LAS
Document 253
Filed 01/22/2008
Page 16 of 236 Page 14 of 233
AMBASE V. UNITED STATES Case No. 93-531C TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST (DXs) BY EXHIBIT ORDER
as of 1/22/08 Exhibit # DX 174 DX 191 Date 06/30/1988 11/17/1992 Bates Range AMB019591 - -019600 WOP334 0685 - 0686 ADIIS Range Description
THRIFT FINANCIAL REPORT, CARTERET SAVINGS BANK, FA, AS OF JUNE 30, 1988 INTEROFFICE MEMO: FROM ROBERT C. ALBANESE TO "THE FILE" RE: CARTERET SAVINGS BANK, FSB, CONFERENCE CALL WITH JONATHAN FIECHTER, DEPUTY DIRECTOR FOR WASHINGTON OPERATIONS LTR: FROM JOHN F. DOWNEY, DEPUTY DIRECTOR FOR REGIONAL OPERATIONS, TO JOHN W. HARSHAW, PRESIDENT OF AMERICAN LEAGUE OF FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS, CC: JOHNNIE BOOKER RE: RESPONSE TO LETTER OF MAY 16 ADDRESSED TO MS. JOHNNIE BOOKER, VICE PRESIDENT FOR THE DIVISION OF MINORITY AND WOMEN'S PROGRAMS AT THE RESOLUTION TRUST CORPORATION INTEROFFICE MEMO: FROM MICHAEL E. FINN TO JOHN F. DOWNEY, SHANNON E. PRITCHARD CC: STEPHEN E. HART, ANGELO A. VIGNA, ROBERT C. ALBANESE, MICHAEL L. SIMONE AND JOHN C. GRIFFIN RE: CARTERET VIABILITY ANALYSIS
DX 197
05/26/1994
WOP299 1684 - 1686
DX 201
03/08/1991
WOP326 0177 - 0186
to Appendix A, Paragraph 16 of the Rules of the Court of Federal Claims, this exhibit list identifies with asterisks those documents Defendant expects to introduce into evidence. Defendant may seek to introduce into evidence other documents on this exhibit list if the need arises as well as exhibits on the exhibit list of plaintiff and plaintiff-intervenor, which are incorporated by reference.
1 Pursuant
Case 1:93-cv-00531-LAS
Document 253
Filed 01/22/2008
Page 17 of 236 Page 15 of 233
AMBASE V. UNITED STATES Case No. 93-531C TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST (DXs) BY EXHIBIT ORDER
as of 1/22/08 Exhibit # DX 210 Date 04/04/1990 Bates Range ADIIS Range WOQ685 0115 - 0116 Description
MEMO: OF ORAL COMMUNICATION BY MICHAEL FINN WITH LEE SMITH, CONTROLLER, JEFF CARFORA, ASSISTANT CONTROLLER AND HENRY KEIZER, KPMG AUDIT MANAGER ORIGINATOR, JOHN GRIFFIN/MICHAEL FINN RE: IMPACT OF OTS ACCOUNTING ISSUES ON KPMG'S AUDIT REPORT OF CARTERET AS OF 12/31/90; SUMMARY OF 3/28/91 MEETING MINUTES BUSINESS PLAN - CAPITAL GROWTH; CARTERET SAVINGS BANK, FA, JUNE 04,1990 INTERNAL MEMO: FROM MICHAEL FINN, OPERATIONS, AND ELAINE KILLOUGH, OPERATIONS, TO JOSEPH LONGINO, CORP. ACTIVITIES, RE: OPERATIONS REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION: CARTERET APPLICATION TO OFFER BROKERAGE SERVICES THROUGH A WHOLLY-OWNED SUBSIDIARY REGULATORY PLAN REPORT
DX 211 DX 214
06/04/1990 11/19/1990
WOQ682 1555 - 1557 WOT671 0260 - 0262
DX 215
01/03/1991
WOP326 0341 - 0374
1 Pursuant
to Appendix A, Paragraph 16 of the Rules of the Court of Federal Claims, this exhibit list identifies with asterisks those documents Defendant expects to introduce into evidence. Defendant may seek to introduce into evidence other documents on this exhibit list if the need arises as well as exhibits on the exhibit list of plaintiff and plaintiff-intervenor, which are incorporated by reference.
Case 1:93-cv-00531-LAS
Document 253
Filed 01/22/2008
Page 18 of 236 Page 16 of 233
AMBASE V. UNITED STATES Case No. 93-531C TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST (DXs) BY EXHIBIT ORDER
as of 1/22/08 Exhibit # DX 217 Date 02/13/1991 Bates Range ADIIS Range WOQ678 0058 - 0058 Description
INTERNAL MEMO: FROM MICHAEL FINN TO "THE FILE" RE: CARTERET SAVINGS BANK, FA USE OF A CAPITAL DIRECTIVE IN LIEU OF RB3A-1 "GREATER RESTRICTIONS" LTR FROM JOHN C. GRIFFIN TO BOARD OF DIRECTORS, CARTERET SAVINGS BANK, FA CC: NANCY HALL, FDIC REGIONAL OFFICE RE: REPORT OF EXAMINATION CONDUCTED ON JUNE 15, 1992 FHLBB MEMO FROM STEVEN DAVIDSON, CARLOS FIOL, REGIONAL DIRECTORS, AED TO JACK REID, DIRECTOR, AED RE: PROPOSED APPROACH FOR PROVIDING RANGES ON COST ESTIMATES
DX 222
08/20/1992
AMBNP029157 -029199
DX 225
05/11/1987
SM0066112 - -0066212
DX 229
01/13/1989
WSJ048 2357 - 2358
INTEROFFICE MEMO: FROM CARLOS FIOL TO STUART ROOT CC: MITCHELL STANLEY, JIM WILLIAMS, DENNIS M. PITTMAN AND JAY EARLE RE: COST OF FSLIC CASE SOLUTION COMPARISONS.
to Appendix A, Paragraph 16 of the Rules of the Court of Federal Claims, this exhibit list identifies with asterisks those documents Defendant expects to introduce into evidence. Defendant may seek to introduce into evidence other documents on this exhibit list if the need arises as well as exhibits on the exhibit list of plaintiff and plaintiff-intervenor, which are incorporated by reference.
1 Pursuant
Case 1:93-cv-00531-LAS
Document 253
Filed 01/22/2008
Page 19 of 236 Page 17 of 233
AMBASE V. UNITED STATES Case No. 93-531C TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST (DXs) BY EXHIBIT ORDER
as of 1/22/08 Exhibit # DX 233 Date 05/30/1986 Bates Range ADIIS Range WFZ015 1501 - 1501 Description
FHLBB MEMO: FROM CARLOS M. FIOL, FINANCIAL ANALYST, AED TO TONY SAMSON, FINANCIAL ANALYST, MAD RE: FIRST FS&LA OF MONTGOMERY COUNTY BLACKSBURG, VA FHLBB NO 1210 VIABILITY ANALYSIS. MEMO: FROM ALVIN W. JAMES TO CARLOS M. FIOL AND ELENA Y. JOHNSON RE: CARTERET NON-CONFORMING BIDS MEMO: FROM ALVIN W. JAMES TO JAY A. JUPITER, SHARON DUNN YORE, CARLOS M. FIOL AND ELENA Y. JOHNSON RE: CARTERET ADDENDUM - ASSET VALUATION REVIEW CARTERET FSB, PARSIPPANY, NJ, DECEMBER 31,1993 RTC MEMO: FROM JAY A. JUPITER, ASSISTANT DIRECTOR, MAJOR RESOLUTION TO J.PAUL RAMEY, VICE PRESIDENT, DIVISION OF RESOLUTION THRU: HERBERT J. HELD, DIRECTOR, MAJOR RESOLUTION RE: CARTERET FSB, FAILING THRIFT CASE.
DX 236
09/01/1994
C-AM-A-0088916 -0088916 C-AM-A-0014333 -0014333 C-AM-A-0131815 -0131815 C-AM-A-0088034 -0088039
DX 237
09/02/1994
DX 240
12/31/1993
DX 245
10/31/1994
to Appendix A, Paragraph 16 of the Rules of the Court of Federal Claims, this exhibit list identifies with asterisks those documents Defendant expects to introduce into evidence. Defendant may seek to introduce into evidence other documents on this exhibit list if the need arises as well as exhibits on the exhibit list of plaintiff and plaintiff-intervenor, which are incorporated by reference.
1 Pursuant
Case 1:93-cv-00531-LAS
Document 253
Filed 01/22/2008
Page 20 of 236 Page 18 of 233
AMBASE V. UNITED STATES Case No. 93-531C TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST (DXs) BY EXHIBIT ORDER
as of 1/22/08 Exhibit # DX 253 Date 11/20/1991 Bates Range C-AM-A-0213904 -0213911 C-AM-A-0181314 -0181326 AM00081250 -00081266 ADIIS Range CAM152 1282 - 1289 Description
MEETING MINUTES, CARTERET SAVINGS BANK BOARD OF DIRECTORS, OTS 1991 EXAMINATION PRESENTATION MEETING MINUTES, BOARD OF DIRECTORS MEETING; CARTERET SAVINGS BANK, FA MEMO: FROM JOHN F. FLEMING, SENIOR VICE PRESIDENT AND AUDITOR, TO THE CARTERET SAVINGS BANK AUDIT COMMITTEE, MESSRS. BEAN, BURNS AND MS. FITTS RE: LOAN REVIEW - WESTERN FEDERAL SAVINGS AND LOAN PRELIMINARY REPORT TO BOARD OF DIRECTORS REGARDING INVESTIGATION OF FORMER OFFICERS AND DIRECTORS EXAMINER MEMO: FROM THOMAS J. O'ROURKE TO ANGELO A. VIGNA, REGIONAL DIRECTOR, ROBERT C. ALBANESE, REGIONAL DEPUTY DIRECTOR, MICHAEL L. SIMONE, ASSISTANT DIRECTOR II, JOHN C. GRIFFIN, ASSISTANT DIRECTOR I, SCOTT B. SMITH, FIELD MANAGER AND SUPERVISORY FILES RE: RESOLUTION CERTIFICATION
DX 261 DX 264
07/29/1992 05/29/1992
CAM134 0669 - 0681 RAM037 0078 - 0094
DX 266
05/19/1992
C-AM-A-0361954 CAMA0361987
CAM279 0001 - 0034
DX 279
10/16/1992
WOP325 0265 - 0267
to Appendix A, Paragraph 16 of the Rules of the Court of Federal Claims, this exhibit list identifies with asterisks those documents Defendant expects to introduce into evidence. Defendant may seek to introduce into evidence other documents on this exhibit list if the need arises as well as exhibits on the exhibit list of plaintiff and plaintiff-intervenor, which are incorporated by reference.
1 Pursuant
Case 1:93-cv-00531-LAS
Document 253
Filed 01/22/2008
Page 21 of 236 Page 19 of 233
AMBASE V. UNITED STATES Case No. 93-531C TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST (DXs) BY EXHIBIT ORDER
as of 1/22/08 Exhibit # DX 287 Date 03/01/1991 Bates Range AMB025923 AMB025932 ADIIS Range Description
LTR: FROM CARTERET, S.B. TO JOHN C. GRIFFIN RE: EXAMINATION COMMENT STATUS REPORT UPDATE DATED MARCH 1, 1991. WOQ685 0034 - 0036 INTERNAL MEMO: FROM MICHAEL FINN TO MICHAEL SIMONE RE: CARTERET OPERATING EXPENSE ANALYSIS EXAMINER MEMO: FROM TOM O'ROURKE, EXAMINER III, TO JOHN GRIFFIN, ASSISTANT DIRECTOR, RE: INTERIM REPORT NO. 1 LTR: FROM JOHN C. GRIFFIN, ASSISTANT DIRECTOR TO THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS, CARTERET SAVINGS BANK RE: EMPLOYMENT CONTRACT AND ADVANCE OF ROBERT O'BRIEN WOP338 1268 - 1270 INTEROFFICE MEMO: FROM MICHAEL FINN TO RICHARD RIESE RE: CARTERET BACKGROUND CONCERNING SPECIAL COMP ISSUES
DX 292
04/19/1991
DX 295
05/16/1991
C-AM-A-0018987 -0018988 C-AM-A-0388695 -0388696
DX 296
06/14/1991
DX 298
07/10/1991
to Appendix A, Paragraph 16 of the Rules of the Court of Federal Claims, this exhibit list identifies with asterisks those documents Defendant expects to introduce into evidence. Defendant may seek to introduce into evidence other documents on this exhibit list if the need arises as well as exhibits on the exhibit list of plaintiff and plaintiff-intervenor, which are incorporated by reference.
1 Pursuant
Case 1:93-cv-00531-LAS
Document 253
Filed 01/22/2008
Page 22 of 236 Page 20 of 233
AMBASE V. UNITED STATES Case No. 93-531C TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST (DXs) BY EXHIBIT ORDER
as of 1/22/08 Exhibit # DX 300 Date 08/27/1991 Bates Range KH017780 - -017781 ADIIS Range Description
LETTER FROM JOHN C. GRIFFIN TO THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS, CARTERET SAVINGS BANK, FA RE: APPRAISAL OF IMPERIAL PREMIUM FINANCE, INC. DATED JULY 25, 1991 LETTER FROM DONALD KRAMER TO JOHN C. GRIFFIN RE: OFFICIAL PROPOSAL MADE BY AMBASE CORPORATION TO PURCHASE IMPERIAL PREMIUM FINANCE FROM CARTERET FOR A NET CASH CONSIDERATION OF $45 MILLION WOP332 0455 - 0456 INTEROFFICE MEMORANDUM FROM TOM O'ROURKE TO JOHN C. GRIFFIN, SCOTT B. SMITH AND MICHAEL E. FINN RE: NEW IPF SALE OFFER LETTER FROM JOHN C. GRIFFIN, ASSISTANT DIRECTOR TO THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS, CARTERET SAVINGS BANK, FA RE: COMMENTS AND RECOMMENDATIONS BASED ON REPORT OF EXAMINATION AS OF JUNE 17, 1991
DX 303
03/26/1992
C-AM-A-0402058 -0402059
DX 304
03/30/1992
DX 305
11/12/1991
AMBNP001194 -001246
1 Pursuant
to Appendix A, Paragraph 16 of the Rules of the Court of Federal Claims, this exhibit list identifies with asterisks those documents Defendant expects to introduce into evidence. Defendant may seek to introduce into evidence other documents on this exhibit list if the need arises as well as exhibits on the exhibit list of plaintiff and plaintiff-intervenor, which are incorporated by reference.
Case 1:93-cv-00531-LAS
Document 253
Filed 01/22/2008
Page 23 of 236 Page 21 of 233
AMBASE V. UNITED STATES Case No. 93-531C TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST (DXs) BY EXHIBIT ORDER
as of 1/22/08 Exhibit # DX 307 Date 12/26/1991 Bates Range ADIIS Range WOP333 0623 - 0623 Description
MEMORANDUM FROM MICHAEL E. FINN TO JOHN C. GRIFFIN RE: REVIEW OF CARTERET'S RESPONSE TO OTS'S REPORT OF EXAMINATION AND COMMENT STATUS REPORT LETTER FROM STANLEY MOHR, SENIOR VICE PRESIDENT TO JOHN C GRIFFIN, ASSISTANT DIRECTOR RE: CARTERET SAVINGS BANK CAPITAL DIRECTIVE (SALES - $5 MILLION OR MORE); INTENDED SALE OF PROPERTY COMMONLY REFERRED TO AS FOXMOOR LETTER FROM JOHN C. GRIFFIN TO THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS, CARTERET SAVINGS BANK, FA RE: MULTI-FAMILY LOAN PURCHASE
DX 310
07/01/1992
C-AM-A-0300436 -0300437
*DX 311
03/18/1992
KH010410 - -010410
to Appendix A, Paragraph 16 of the Rules of the Court of Federal Claims, this exhibit list identifies with asterisks those documents Defendant expects to introduce into evidence. Defendant may seek to introduce into evidence other documents on this exhibit list if the need arises as well as exhibits on the exhibit list of plaintiff and plaintiff-intervenor, which are incorporated by reference.
1 Pursuant
Case 1:93-cv-00531-LAS
Document 253
Filed 01/22/2008
Page 24 of 236 Page 22 of 233
AMBASE V. UNITED STATES Case No. 93-531C TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST (DXs) BY EXHIBIT ORDER
as of 1/22/08 Exhibit # DX 312 Date 05/20/1992 Bates Range ADIIS Range WOT707 1014 - 1014 WOP333 0450 - 0450 Description
INTEROFFICE MEMORANDUM FROM: THOMAS J. O'ROURKE TO: JOHN C. GRIFFIN, DONALD S. HOM, WALTER E. AMEND, SONIA J. CALLAHAN, STEPHEN D. ROHRS, RUTH ANN ESPOSITO, TIMOTHY P. MURPHY AND KATHLEEN A. SCHAUER RE: STATUS UPDATE ON MULTI-FAMILY LOAN PORTFOLIO PURCHASED FROM WESTERN FS&LA, CARTERET SB, FA. INTEROFFICE MEMORANDUM FROM TOM O'ROURKE TO JOHN C. GRIFFIN, SCOTT B. SMITH, MICHAEL L. SIMONE, AND DONALD S. HOM RE: CSB PROFITABILITY ANALYSIS EXAMINER MEMORANDUM FROM THOMAS J. O'ROURKE, EXAMINER TO ANGELO A. VIGNA, REGIONAL DIRECTOR, ROBERT ALBANESE, REGIONAL DEPUTY DIRECTOR, MIKE SIMONE, ASSISTANT DIRECTOR II, JOHN C. GRIFFIN, ASSISTANT DIRECTOR I, SCOTT B. SMITH, FIELD MANAGER, MIKE FINN, EXAMINER AND SUPERVISORY FILESCARTERET SAVINGS BANK, FA RE: STATUS REPORT - COMMERCIAL ASSETS DIVISION 6/30/92 RESULTS-PRELIMINARY
DX 314
06/02/1992
WOP333 0462 - 0466
DX 316
07/07/1992
WOP317 1640 - 1641
to Appendix A, Paragraph 16 of the Rules of the Court of Federal Claims, this exhibit list identifies with asterisks those documents Defendant expects to introduce into evidence. Defendant may seek to introduce into evidence other documents on this exhibit list if the need arises as well as exhibits on the exhibit list of plaintiff and plaintiff-intervenor, which are incorporated by reference.
1 Pursuant
Case 1:93-cv-00531-LAS
Document 253
Filed 01/22/2008
Page 25 of 236 Page 23 of 233
AMBASE V. UNITED STATES Case No. 93-531C TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST (DXs) BY EXHIBIT ORDER
as of 1/22/08 Exhibit # DX 332 Date 03/22/1983 Bates Range C-AM-A-0212578 -0212582 ADIIS Range Description
CARTERET SAVINGS AND LOAN ASSOCIATION, FA AND SUBSIDIARIES, NEWARK, NJ CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS, SEPTEMBER 30, 1980, 1981 AND 1982 (WITH ACCOUNTANTS' REPORT THEREON) FHLBB MEMO FROM GENE HALL, PROBLEM AND REHABILITATION DIVISION TO SUPERVISORY AGENTS RE: PURCHASE ACCOUNTING IN FSLIC-ASSISTED MERGERS AND ACQUISITIONS WOR432 0199 - 0207 FHLBB MEMO FROM EDWARD J. O'CONNELL, III TO D. JAMES CROFT, DIRECTOR RE: FORBEARANCES LETTER FROM DOUGLAS P. FAUCETTE TO GENE L. HALL, CHIEF PROBLEM AND REHABILITATION DIVISION, FSLIC RE: BID OF CARTERET SAVINGS AND LOAN ASSOCIATION FA TO ACQUIRE FIRST FEDERAL SAVINGS AND LOAN ASSOCIATION OF DELRAY BEACH
DX 336
03/28/1983
SMO129226 - -129226
DX 337
03/02/1983
DX 342
08/24/1982
AMB000001 - -000002
PAM001 0080 - 0081
to Appendix A, Paragraph 16 of the Rules of the Court of Federal Claims, this exhibit list identifies with asterisks those documents Defendant expects to introduce into evidence. Defendant may seek to introduce into evidence other documents on this exhibit list if the need arises as well as exhibits on the exhibit list of plaintiff and plaintiff-intervenor, which are incorporated by reference.
1 Pursuant
Case 1:93-cv-00531-LAS
Document 253
Filed 01/22/2008
Page 26 of 236 Page 24 of 233
AMBASE V. UNITED STATES Case No. 93-531C TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST (DXs) BY EXHIBIT ORDER
as of 1/22/08 Exhibit # DX 361 Date 03/05/1990 Bates Range ADIIS Range OAM004 0068 - 0069 Description
LETTER FROM JOSEPH P. KEHOE, ASSISTANT DIRECTOR TO BOARD OF DIRECTORS, CARTERET SAVINGS BANK RE: DECEMBER 31, 1989 CLASSIFIED ASSETS AND LOSS RESERVE ANALYSIS PREPARED BY CARTERET SAVINGS BANK LETTER FROM: JOSEPH P. KEHOE, ASSISTANT DIRECTOR TO: BOARD OF DIRECTORS CARTERET SAVINGS BANK RE: LETTER OF MARCH 5, 1990 REQUESTING THAT CARTERET INCREASE ITS GENERAL VALUATION ALLOWANCE; AND LETTER FROM: DOUGLAS J. CESTONE OF OTS TO ROBERT MCCARTHY EXEC. VICE PRESIDENT CARTERET RE: APPOINTMENT OF ROBERT L. WOODRUM TO THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS. LETTER FROM JOSEPH P. KEHOE TO BRUCE BEAN, AMBASE CORPORATION RE: LETTER DATED FEBRUARY 9, 1990 REGARDING CASH CONTRIBUTION MADE BY AMBASE CORPORATION INTO CARTERET SAVINGS BANK
DX 362
04/25/1990
WOT671 0401 - 0403
DX 363
03/22/1990
OAM004 0077 - 0077
to Appendix A, Paragraph 16 of the Rules of the Court of Federal Claims, this exhibit list identifies with asterisks those documents Defendant expects to introduce into evidence. Defendant may seek to introduce into evidence other documents on this exhibit list if the need arises as well as exhibits on the exhibit list of plaintiff and plaintiff-intervenor, which are incorporated by reference.
1 Pursuant
Case 1:93-cv-00531-LAS
Document 253
Filed 01/22/2008
Page 27 of 236 Page 25 of 233
AMBASE V. UNITED STATES Case No. 93-531C TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST (DXs) BY EXHIBIT ORDER
as of 1/22/08 Exhibit # DX 365 Date 06/11/1990 Bates Range AMBNP024187 -024190 ADIIS Range Description
FAX MEMORANDUM FROM ROBERT E. MCCARTHY TO BOARD OF DIRECTORS, CARTERET SAVINGS BANK, FA RE: OTSMANAGEMENT FEES PAID TO AMBASE CORPORATION WOP334 0451 - 0455 EMAIL MESSAGE FROM ED MCQUOWN, OTS/WDC TO JOE KEHOE OTS/NEW YORK RE: CARTERET INFORMATION UPDATES INTEROFFICE MEMORANDUM FROM JOSEPH P. KEHOE TO MICHAEL E. FINN CC: MICHAEL L. SIMONE, DAVID R. DORGAN, ROBERT C. ALBANESE AND ANGELO VIGNA RE: WASHDC REQUEST FOR UPDATE ON CARTERET INTEROFFICE MEMORANDUM FROM ED MCQUOWN TO KEHOEJF@A1@EAST CC: JAMES CATON AND ALVIN W. SMUZYNSKI RE: NEED MORE INFORMATION ON CARTERET/AMBASE INTEROFFICE MEMORANDUM FROM DAVID R. DORGAN TO JOSEPH P. KEHOE, ELAINE R. KILLOUGH, SCOTT B. SMITH, RUSSELL J. MEYER AND MICHAEL E. FINN RE: CARTERET $30MM OTS "CALL"
DX 368
08/08/1990
DX 369
08/10/1990
WOT692 1174 - 1179
DX 370
08/15/1990
WOQ620 2328 - 2329
DX 374
09/27/1990
WOP343 1015 - 1015
to Appendix A, Paragraph 16 of the Rules of the Court of Federal Claims, this exhibit list identifies with asterisks those documents Defendant expects to introduce into evidence. Defendant may seek to introduce into evidence other documents on this exhibit list if the need arises as well as exhibits on the exhibit list of plaintiff and plaintiff-intervenor, which are incorporated by reference.
1 Pursuant
Case 1:93-cv-00531-LAS
Document 253
Filed 01/22/2008
Page 28 of 236 Page 26 of 233
AMBASE V. UNITED STATES Case No. 93-531C TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST (DXs) BY EXHIBIT ORDER
as of 1/22/08 Exhibit # DX 376 Date 10/03/1990 Bates Range ADIIS Range WOP334 0479 - 0480 Description
INTEROFFICE MEMORANDUM FROM MICHAEL E. FINN TO ANGELO A. VIGNA, ROBERT C. ALBANESE, MICHAEL L. SIMONE, DAVID R. DORGAN, JOSEPH P. KEHOE, SCOTT B. SMITH, ELAINE R. KILLOUGH AND RUSSELL J. MEYER RE: AMBASE SALE OF HOME INSURANCE TO VIK BROTHERS. LETTER FROM JOSEPH P. KEHOE, ASSISTANT DIRECTOR TO BRUCE BEAN, EXECUTIVE VICE PRESIDENT AND GENERAL COUNSEL, AMBASE CORPORATION RE: AMBASE CAPITAL INFUSION
DX 377
10/03/1990
AM00014702 -0014702
DX 378
10/11/1990
WOP334 0465 - 0468
INTEROFFICE MEMORANDUM FROM JOSEPH P. KEHOE TO MICHAEL L. SIMONE, DAVID R. DORGAN CC: ROBERT C. ALBANESE AND ANGELO A. VIGNA RE: CARTERET UPDATE INTEROFFICE MEMORANDUM FROM JOSEPH P. KEHOE TO DAVID R. DORGAN RE: AMBASE/CARTERET
DX 379
10/26/1990
WOP343 1017 - 1018
to Appendix A, Paragraph 16 of the Rules of the Court of Federal Claims, this exhibit list identifies with asterisks those documents Defendant expects to introduce into evidence. Defendant may seek to introduce into evidence other documents on this exhibit list if the need arises as well as exhibits on the exhibit list of plaintiff and plaintiff-intervenor, which are incorporated by reference.
1 Pursuant
Case 1:93-cv-00531-LAS
Document 253
Filed 01/22/2008
Page 29 of 236 Page 27 of 233
AMBASE V. UNITED STATES Case No. 93-531C TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST (DXs) BY EXHIBIT ORDER
as of 1/22/08 Exhibit # DX 380 Date 10/26/1990 Bates Range ADIIS Range WOP334 0464 - 0464 Description
INTEROFFICE MEMORANDUM FROM JAMES M. PORRECA TO DAVID R. DORGAN CC: MICHAEL E. FINN, JOSEPH P. KEHOE, ELAINE R. KILLOUGH, ROBERT C. ALBANESE, ANGELO A. VIGNA, FAITH S. HOCHBERG AND MICHAEL L. SIMONE RE: AMBASE $30MM ?? CAPITAL DEFICIENCIES HAND WRITTEN NOTES FROM BRUCE BEAN TO GARY AND DAVE; ALSO LETTER FROM JOSEPH P. KEHOE TO THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS, AMBASE CORPORATION RE: COMMENTS AND RECOMMENDATIONS BASED ON REPORT OF EXAMINATION AS OF JUNE 4, 1990; REPORT OF EXAMINATION, AMBASE CORPORATION, DATE OF EXAMINATION JUNE 4, 1990
DX 382
03/07/1991
AMB010074 - -010108
DX 383
10/10/1990
AMBNP03043 AMBNP030844
WOT 671 0315 - 0315
LETTER FROM JOSEPH P. KEHOE TO THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS, CARTERET SAVINGS BANK, FA RE: REGULATORY BULLETIN 3A-1 WITH COPIES OF THE BULLETIN ATTACHED. LETTER FROM JOSEPH P. KEHOE, ASSISTANT DIRECTOR TO BOARD OF DIRECTORS, CARTERET SAVINGS BANK RE: CLASSIFICATION ADJUSTMENTS
DX 384
09/20/1990
AMBNP030822 -030839
to Appendix A, Paragraph 16 of the Rules of the Court of Federal Claims, this exhibit list identifies with asterisks those documents Defendant expects to introduce into evidence. Defendant may seek to introduce into evidence other documents on this exhibit list if the need arises as well as exhibits on the exhibit list of plaintiff and plaintiff-intervenor, which are incorporated by reference.
1 Pursuant
Case 1:93-cv-00531-LAS
Document 253
Filed 01/22/2008
Page 30 of 236 Page 28 of 233
AMBASE V. UNITED STATES Case No. 93-531C TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST (DXs) BY EXHIBIT ORDER
as of 1/22/08 Exhibit # DX 391 Date 12/20/1990 Bates Range C-AM-A-0274283 -0274284 ADIIS Range Description
LETTER FROM RANDOLPH H. ELKINS TO ANGELO VIGNA, DISTRICT DIRECTOR, OTS NY RE: CARTERET SAVINGS BANK, FA REQUEST INFORMAL REVIEW OF REPORT OF EXAM. LETTER FROM JOSEPH P. KEHOE TO THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS, CARTERET SAVINGS BANK, FA RE: RESPONSE TO JANUARY 25, 1991 LETTER AND REQUEST FOR ADJUSTMENTS TO RECORD PROVISIONS OTS RESOLUTION NO. 91-1 DATED 02/14/91 "TEMPORARY ORDER TO CEASE AND DESIST" WOP333 0214 - 0216 LETTER FROM ANGELO A. VIGNA, REGIONAL DIRECTOR TO NICHOLAS J. KETCHA, JR, REGIONAL DIRECTOR, FDIC RE: QUESTIONS, CONCERNS AND ISSUES NOTES WITH RESPECT TO THE PROPOSAL BY AMBASE TO ISSUE A $30 MILLION NOTE TO SATISFY ITS OBLIGATION TO CARTERET SAVINGS BANK, FA
DX 393
01/29/1991
C-AM-A-0274415 -0274415
*DX 394
02/14/1991
AM014786 - -014795
DX 396
12/05/1990
1 Pursuant
to Appendix A, Paragraph 16 of the Rules of the Court of Federal Claims, this exhibit list identifies with asterisks those documents Defendant expects to introduce into evidence. Defendant may seek to introduce into evidence other documents on this exhibit list if the need arises as well as exhibits on the exhibit list of plaintiff and plaintiff-intervenor, which are incorporated by reference.
Case 1:93-cv-00531-LAS
Document 253
Filed 01/22/2008
Page 31 of 236 Page 29 of 233
AMBASE V. UNITED STATES Case No. 93-531C TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST (DXs) BY EXHIBIT ORDER
as of 1/22/08 Exhibit # DX 398 Date 01/29/1991 Bates Range ADIIS Range WOQ699 0465 - 0467 Description
LETTER FROM NICHOLAS J. KETCHA, JR, REGIONAL DIRECTOR, FDIC TO ANGELO A. VIGNA, REGIONAL DIRECTOR, OTS RE: CARTERET SAVINGS BANK, FA, MORRISTOWN, NJ LEGAL DRAFT, NOTICE OF INTENTION TO TERMINATE INSURED STATUS FINDINGS, AND ORDER SETTING HEARING FDIC -91, IN THE MATTER OF CARTERET SAVINGS BANK, FEDERAL ASSOCIATION, MORRISTOWN, NJ LETTER FROM NICHOLAS J. KETCHA JR., REGIONAL DIRECTOR, FDIC TO ANGELO A. VIGNA, REGIONAL DIRECTOR, OTS RE: CARTERET SAVINGS BANK FA REQUEST TO EXTEND APPROVED CAPITAL PLAN FOR 90 DAYS PAST THE SCHEDULED MAY 27, 1992 EXPIRATION DATE LETTER FROM NICHOLAS J. KETCHA, JR, REGIONAL DIRECTOR, FDIC TO ANGELO A. VIGNA, REGIONAL DIRECTOR, OTS RE: REQUEST TO EXTEND THE RECAPITALIZATION DEADLINE TO OCTOBER 15, 1992
DX 405
XX/XX/1991
WOR659 0031 - 0041
DX 407
05/21/1992
WOP332 0712 - 0712
DX 408
07/02/1992
WOP332 0758 - 0759
1 Pursuant
to Appendix A, Paragraph 16 of the Rules of the Court of Federal Claims, this exhibit list identifies with asterisks those documents Defendant expects to introduce into evidence. Defendant may seek to introduce into evidence other documents on this exhibit list if the need arises as well as exhibits on the exhibit list of plaintiff and plaintiff-intervenor, which are incorporated by reference.
Case 1:93-cv-00531-LAS
Document 253
Filed 01/22/2008
Page 32 of 236 Page 30 of 233
AMBASE V. UNITED STATES Case No. 93-531C TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST (DXs) BY EXHIBIT ORDER
as of 1/22/08 Exhibit # DX 412 Date 11/02/1992 Bates Range ADIIS Range WOP334 0703 - 0706 Description
LETTER FROM NICHOLAS J. KETCHA JR., REGIONAL DIRECTOR TO ANGELO A. VIGNA, REGIONAL DIRECTOR, OTS RE: CARTERET SAVINGS BANK FA, CONCERN OVER CONTINUING UNSAFE AND UNSOUND CONDITION OF CARTERET LETTER FROM DONALD KRAMER TO BRUCE W. BEAN, EXECUTIVE VICE PRESIDENT AND GENERAL COUNSEL, AMBASE CORPORATION RE: CARTERET ANALYSIS PRESS RELEASE; CARTERET BOOSTS RESERVES IMPERIAL PREMIUM FINANCE SALE EVALUATION PREPARED FOR OTS MEETING MINUTES (DRAFT) CARTERET SAVINGS BANK, FA BOARD OF DIRECTORS MEETING TRANSCRIPT, OTS 1991 EXAMINATION PRESENTATION INTERNAL MEMORANDUM FROM JOHN C. GRIFFIN, ASSISTANT DIRECTOR I TO FILE RE: SUMMARY OF MEETING WITH CARTERET SAVINGS BANK FA, OTS-DOCKET #04702
DX 414
05/21/1990
AMB0011044 -B0011066
PAM002 3577 - 3599
DX 418 DX 419 DX 426
XX/XX/XXXX 07/26/1991 11/20/1991 AM00065167 -00065174 C-AM-A-0213912 -A0213965
WOP291 0518 - 0521 WOQ692 2182 - 2188 RAM004 0491 - 0498
DX 427 DX 429
11/20/1991 11/06/1991
CAM152 1290 - 1343 WOQ653 0277 - 0280
1 Pursuant
to Appendix A, Paragraph 16 of the Rules of the Court of Federal Claims, this exhibit list identifies with asterisks those documents Defendant expects to introduce into evidence. Defendant may seek to introduce into evidence other documents on this exhibit list if the need arises as well as exhibits on the exhibit list of plaintiff and plaintiff-intervenor, which are incorporated by reference.
Case 1:93-cv-00531-LAS
Document 253
Filed 01/22/2008
Page 33 of 236 Page 31 of 233
AMBASE V. UNITED STATES Case No. 93-531C TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST (DXs) BY EXHIBIT ORDER
as of 1/22/08 Exhibit # DX 430 Date 01/14/1992 Bates Range AM00048418 - -48424 ADIIS Range RAM009 1750 - 1756 Description
LETTER FROM RICHARD A. BIANCO, CHAIRMAN AND CEO AND DONALD KRAMER, VICE CHAIRMAN AND CFO TO NICHOLAS J. KETCHA, JR., REGIONAL DIRECTOR, FDIC RE: RESPONSE TO PREVIOUS LETTER DATED DECEMBER 10, 1991. LETTER FROM DONALD KRAMER TO DAVID DUPREE, PRINCIPAL, CARLYLE GROUP RE: BANK DATA AND FORECAST MEMORANDUM FROM KEVIN ALBERT TO DICK BIANCO RE: PENNSYLVANIA TEACHERS MEMORANDUM FROM ROBERT B. O'BRIEN, JR., CHAIRMAN TO ROBERT D. PIERSON, VICE CHAIRMAN AND ROBERT J. MUELLER, PRESIDENT RE: BUDGET CONSIDERATIONS MEMO FROM JACK R. PLAXE TO M. MANLEY, B.W.BEAN, J.J. MCHUGH, R.L. BRAUN, T.A. BABCOCK, WITH EXECUTIVE SUMMARY REPORT ON REVIEW PROCEDURES CARTERET SAVINGS BANK, FA AND SUBSIDIARIES
DX 432
09/30/1992
C-AM-A-0178322 -0178323 AMB070649 - -070649
CAM132 0505 - 0506
DX 435
08/10/1992
RAM023 0951 - 0951
DX 440
08/12/1987
C-AM-A-0383394 -0383396
CAM330 1125 - 1127
DX 441
10/12/1987
AMB034833 - -034833 AMB027706 - -B027714
PAM010 0976 - 0984
1 Pursuant
to Appendix A, Paragraph 16 of the Rules of the Court of Federal Claims, this exhibit list identifies with asterisks those documents Defendant expects to introduce into evidence. Defendant may seek to introduce into evidence other documents on this exhibit list if the need arises as well as exhibits on the exhibit list of plaintiff and plaintiff-intervenor, which are incorporated by reference.
Case 1:93-cv-00531-LAS
Document 253
Filed 01/22/2008
Page 34 of 236 Page 32 of 233
AMBASE V. UNITED STATES Case No. 93-531C TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST (DXs) BY EXHIBIT ORDER
as of 1/22/08 Exhibit # DX 443 Date 10/22/1987 Bates Range KH013674 - -13674 ADIIS Range RAM020 0289 - 0289 Description
LETTER FROM ROBERT B. O'BRIEN, JR. CHAIRMAN, CARTERET SAVINGS BANK TO MARSHALL MANLEY, PRESIDENT AND CEO, THE HOME GROUP INC. RE: HOME GROUP CONTRACTUAL OBLIGATIONS UNDER THE AGREEMENT AND PLAN OF REORGANIZATION DATED AUGUST 4, 1987 LETTER FROM MARSHALL MANLEY TO ROBERT B. O'BRIEN, JR., CHAIRMAN CARTERET BANCORP INC. RE: RESPONSE TO LETTER OF OCTOBER 22, 1987 LETTER FROM BRUCE BEAN, SENIOR VICE PRESIDENT AND GENERAL COUNSEL TO ROBERT B. O'BRIEN, JR. RE: RESPONSE TO OCTOBER 22 LETTER TO MARSHALL MANLEY NEWSPAPER ARTICLE FROM MIAMI REVIEW, THURSDAY NOVEMBER 19, 1987 VOL. 62 NO. 113 LETTER FROM MARSHALL MANLEY TO HOME GROUP SHAREHOLDERS RE: STATUS REPORT ON THE CARTERET ACQUISITION
DX 444
10/28/1987
KH013677 - -13677
RAM020 0292 - 0292
DX 445
10/28/1987
AMB0004106 -0004108
PAM004 0233 - 0235
DX 446
11/19/1987
AMB044355 - -044356
PAM008 0421 - 0422
DX 447
12/14/1987
AMB0005220 -0005221
PAM004 1347 - 1348
to Appendix A, Paragraph 16 of the Rules of the Court of Federal Claims, this exhibit list identifies with asterisks those documents Defendant expects to introduce into evidence. Defendant may seek to introduce into evidence other documents on this exhibit list if the need arises as well as exhibits on the exhibit list of plaintiff and plaintiff-intervenor, which are incorporated by reference.
1 Pursuant
Case 1:93-cv-00531-LAS
Document 253
Filed 01/22/2008
Page 35 of 236 Page 33 of 233
AMBASE V. UNITED STATES Case No. 93-531C TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST (DXs) BY EXHIBIT ORDER
as of 1/22/08 Exhibit # DX 453 Date 09/12/1989 Bates Range AMB048178 - -048179 ADIIS Range PAM008 0900 - 0901 Description
AMBASE NEWS RELEASE: "CARTERET MEETS NEW FEDERAL CAPITAL STANDARDS" NEWS PAPER ARTICLE, FINANCIAL WORLD SECTION ARTICLE BY ALEXANDRIA BIESADA "WHAT EVER MANLEY TAKES, MANLEY BREAKS AND LITTLE AMBASE MANLEY BROKE YOU..." LETTER FROM AMBASE CORPORATION TO MARSHALL MANLEY RE: AGREEMENT LETTER REGARDING RESIGNATION AS A DIRECTOR AND EMPLOYEE OF AMBASE SPECIAL REPORT AMBASE CORPORATION FHLBB MEMORANDUM FROM WALTER B. MASON, ASSISTANT REGIONAL DIRECTOR TO BERNIE MCKEE, REGIONAL DIRECTOR, FSLIC RE: FIRST FS&LA DELRAY BEACH, FL FHLBB NO. 5403
DX 454
04/17/1990
WOP326 2553 - 2555
DX 455
01/31/1991
WOP343 0032 - 0044
DX 457 DX 462
XX/XX/XXXX 09/29/1982
WOQ678 1293 - 1364 WOR059 0377 - 0377
to Appendix A, Paragraph 16 of the Rules of the Court of Federal Claims, this exhibit list identifies with asterisks those documents Defendant expects to introduce into evidence. Defendant may seek to introduce into evidence other documents on this exhibit list if the need arises as well as exhibits on the exhibit list of plaintiff and plaintiff-intervenor, which are incorporated by reference.
1 Pursuant
Case 1:93-cv-00531-LAS
Document 253
Filed 01/22/2008
Page 36 of 236 Page 34 of 233
AMBASE V. UNITED STATES Case No. 93-531C TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST (DXs) BY EXHIBIT ORDER
as of 1/22/08 Exhibit # DX 463 Date 09/30/1982 Bates Range ADIIS Range WOF011 1801 - 1801 Description
MEMORANDUM FROM WILLIAM E. CHALKER, SUPERVISORY AGENT TO BERNIE MCKEE, REGIONAL DIRECTOR, FSLIC RE: FIRST FEDERAL SAVINGS AND LOAN ASSOCIATION, DELRAY BEACH, FL MERGER SHOPPING - OVERBID FHLBB MEMO FROM EDWARD J. O'CONNELL, III TO BERNARD MCKEE, REGIONAL DIRECTOR, FSLIC RE: PROPOSED ACQUISITION FIRST FS&LA OF MONTGOMERY COUNTY AND MOUNTAIN SECURITY SAVINGS BANK INTO CARTERET SAVINGS BANK, FA LETTER FROM CARLA M. O'CONNOR, ASSISTANT SECRETARY TO JOHN GRIFFIN, ASSISTANT DIRECTOR, OTS RE: AMENDED THRIFT FINANCIAL REPORTS FOR CARTERET SAVINGS BANK FOR THE QUARTERS-ENDED DECEMBER 31, 1989 THROUGH DECEMBER 31, 1990
DX 469
06/02/1986
AM030676 - -030678
DX 475
06/04/1990
AM046267 - -046326
DX 476
07/12/1989
WOT692 1351 - 1353
EXAMINATION DIVISION, INFORMATIONAL REPORT FROM RUSSELL J. MEYER, EXAMINER-IN-CHARGE TO ROBERT ALBANESE, DISTRICT DIRECTOR
to Appendix A, Paragraph 16 of the Rules of the Court of Federal Claims, this exhibit list identifies with asterisks those documents Defendant expects to introduce into evidence. Defendant may seek to introduce into evidence other documents on this exhibit list if the need arises as well as exhibits on the exhibit list of plaintiff and plaintiff-intervenor, which are incorporated by reference.
1 Pursuant
Case 1:93-cv-00531-LAS
Document 253
Filed 01/22/2008
Page 37 of 236 Page 35 of 233
AMBASE V. UNITED STATES Case No. 93-531C TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST (DXs) BY EXHIBIT ORDER
as of 1/22/08 Exhibit # DX 479 Date 10/04/1989 Bates Range ADIIS Range WOT692 1327 - 1328 Description
MEMORANDUM OF ORAL COMMUNICATION WITH RUSS MEYER, EIC RE: INTERIM MEETINGS INTERIM REPORT FROM RJ MEYER, EIC TO DAVID DORGAN, SADD, JOSEPH KEHOE, AD, SCOTT B. SMITH, FS AND ROSA SMITH RE: CARTERET SAVING SBANK, FA EXAM DATE JUNE 4, 1990 REPORT OF EXAMINATION, HOLDING COMPANY JUNE 4, 1990
DX 482
08/17/1990
WOP343 1027 - 1030
DX 484 DX 485
06/04/1990 08/15/1990
C-AM-A-0054335 -0054366 WOQ620 2293 - 2304
INTEROFFICE MEMORANDUM FROM MICHAEL E. FINN TO ANGELO A. VIGNA, ROBERT C. ALBANESE, MICHAEL L. SIMONE, DAVID R. DORGAN, ELAINE R. KILLOUGH, SCOTT B. SMITH AND RUSSELL J. MEYER RE: RESPONSE TO WASH INFORMATION REQUEST REGARDING CARTERET SB MEMORANDUM FROM JOHN MUDD, WORKOUT COUNSEL TO: DISTRIBUTION RE: CREDIT COMMITTEE - APPROVALS BOARD OF DIRECTORS - APPROVALS/NOTICE OTS APPROVALS/NOTICE
DX 494
10/23/1991
AMB033821 - -033822
PAM010 1225 - 1226
1 Pursuant
to Appendix A, Paragraph 16 of the Rules of the Court of Federal Claims, this exhibit list identifies with asterisks those documents Defendant expects to introduce into evidence. Defendant may seek to introduce into evidence other documents on this exhibit list if the need arises as well as exhibits on the exhibit list of plaintiff and plaintiff-intervenor, which are incorporated by reference.
Case 1:93-cv-00531-LAS
Document 253
Filed 01/22/2008
Page 38 of 236 Page 36 of 233
AMBASE V. UNITED STATES Case No. 93-531C TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST (DXs) BY EXHIBIT ORDER
as of 1/22/08 Exhibit # DX 497 Date 06/11/1992 Bates Range ADIIS Range WOQ673 0954 - 0954 Description
MEMORANDUM FROM CRAIG M. ROSEN TO WAYNE MOOR RE: LA MIRADA SHOPPING CENTER LETTER FROM DONALD KRAMER TO KEVIN ALBERT, MERRILL LYNCH AND COMPANY RE: RESPONSE TO QUESTIONS TRIAL BALANCE OF LOANS, REO AND RESERVES AS OF MAY 31,1992, CARTERET SAVINGS BANK, COMMERCIAL ASSETS DIVISION COMMERCIAL ASSET PORTFOLIO ANALYSIS, NOVEMBER 30, 1992 MEETING MINUTES, SPECIAL BOARD OF DIRECTORS MEETING, AUGUST 4, 1987 (DRAFT) LETTER FROM ELEONORE B. MCCABE TO ROBERT J. MUELLER RE: ROBERT J. MUELLER CURRENT AND AMENDED EMPLOYMENT AGREEMENTS
DX 505
12/16/1991
C-AM-A-0178890 -0178892 KH058520 - -059095
CAM132 1086 - 1088
DX 506
06/22/1992
RAM034 0714 - 1289
DX 507 DX 537
11/30/1992 08/04/1987
C-AM-A-0103662 -0103687
CAM089 0287 - 0312 WOQ654 0491 - 0527
DX 540
01/22/1988
WOQ654 0035 - 0036
to Appendix A, Paragraph 16 of the Rules of the Court of Federal Claims, this exhibit list identifies with asterisks those documents Defendant expects to introduce into evidence. Defendant may seek to introduce into evidence other documents on this exhibit list if the need arises as well as exhibits on the exhibit list of plaintiff and plaintiff-intervenor, which are incorporated by reference.
1 Pursuant
Case 1:93-cv-00531-LAS
Document 253
Filed 01/22/2008
Page 39 of 236 Page 37 of 233
AMBASE V. UNITED STATES Case No. 93-531C TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST (DXs) BY EXHIBIT ORDER
as of 1/22/08 Exhibit # DX 541 Date 01/22/1988 Bates Range ADIIS Range WOQ654 0034 - 0034 Description
LETTER FROM ELEONORE B. MCCABE TO ROBERT J. MUELER RE: REVISED SCHEDULE OF BENEFITS UNDER CURRENT AND AMENDED CARTERET EMPLOYMENT AGREEMENTS LETTER FROM ROBERT J. MUELLER, PRESIDENT TO MICHAEL SIMONE, VICE PRESIDENT, FHLBB RE: OUTSTANDING ISSUES CLASSIFIED ASSETS MEMORANDUM FROM GEOFFREY M, CONNOR, SENIOR VICE PRESIDENT TO ROBERT D. PIERSON, VICE CHAIRMAN RE: MONTHLY REPORT
DX 542
06/06/1988
OAM004 1062 - 1063
DX 545
11/01/1988
AMB0008431 -0008432
DX 546
11/08/1988
WOQ654 0047 - 0047
LETTER FROM ROBERT B. O'BRIEN, CHAIRMAN TO ROBERT J. MUELLER RE: CONFIRMATION OF TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT WITH CARTERET SAVINGS BANK, FA EFFECTIVE JAN.
to Appendix A, Paragraph 16 of the Rules of the Court of Federal Claims, this exhibit list identifies with asterisks those documents Defendant expects to introduce into evidence. Defendant may seek to introduce into evidence other documents on this exhibit list if the need arises as well as exhibits on the exhibit list of plaintiff and plaintiff-intervenor, which are incorporated by reference.
1 Pursuant
Case 1:93-cv-00531-LAS
Document 253
Filed 01/22/2008
Page 40 of 236 Page 38 of 233
AMBASE V. UNITED STATES Case No. 93-531C TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST (DXs) BY EXHIBIT ORDER
as of 1/22/08 Exhibit # *DX 547 Date 05/20/1992 Bates Range C-AM-A-0057163 -0057165 ADIIS Range WOQ673 0200 - 0203 CAM051 0014 - 0016 Description
STIPULATION AND CONSENT TO ISSUANCE OF ORDER TO CEASE AND DESIST IN THE MATTER OF ROBERT J. MUELLER, FORMER DIRECTOR AND PRESIDENT, CARTERET SAVINGS BANK; RESOLUTION NO, NE92-52; ALSO ORDER TO CEASE AND DESIST AND DIRECTION TO MAKE RESTITUTION AND TO TAKE OTHER AFFIRMATIVE ACTION IN THE MATTER OF ROBERT J, MUELLER RESOLUTION NO. NE-92-52 LETTER FROM LAWRENCE W. HAYES, SENIOR ASSOCIATE GENERAL COUNSEL TO ROBERT B. O'BRIEN JR., CHAIRMAN, PRESIDENT AND CEO, CARTERET SAVINGS AND LOAN ASSOCIATION, FA RE: SEPTEMBER 30, 1982 FORBEARANCE LETTER EMPLOYMENT CONTRACT BETWEEN CARTERET SAVINGS AND LOAN ASSOCIATION, FA AND ROBERT B. O'BRIEN, JR.
*DX 558
10/12/1982
AMB000020 - -000020
PAM001 0099 - 0099
DX 560
05/11/1983
WOT692 2021 - 2049
to Appendix A, Paragraph 16 of the Rules of the Court of Federal Claims, this exhibit list identifies with asterisks those documents Defendant expects to introduce into evidence. Defendant may seek to introduce into evidence other documents on this exhibit list if the need arises as well as exhibits on the exhibit list of plaintiff and plaintiff-intervenor, which are incorporated by reference.
1 Pursuant
Case 1:93-cv-00531-LAS
Document 253
Filed 01/22/2008
Page 41 of 236 Page 39 of 233
AMBASE V. UNITED STATES Case No. 93-531C TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST (DXs) BY EXHIBIT ORDER
as of 1/22/08 Exhibit # DX 563 Date XX/XX/XXXX Bates Range ADIIS Range WOT682 0770 - 0777 Description
LETTER FROM ROBERT B. O'BRIEN JR. TO MICHAEL SIMONE, SUPERVISORY AGENT FHLB OF NEW YORK RE: REQUEST FOR FORBEARANCE AND AMENDMENT TO THE PROPOSED ACQUISITION BY CARTERET SAVINGS BANK, FA OF FIRST FEDERAL SAVINGS AND LOAN ASSOCIATION OF MONTGOMERY COUNTY AND MOUNTAIN SECURITY SAVINGS BANK AND ADMIRAL-BUILDERS SAVINGS AND LOAN NEWSPAPER ARTICLE" WELL-ESTABLISHED IN JERSEY AND FLORIDA CARTERET LOOKS AT THE STATES IN-BETWEEN" BY MARK BASCH DOCUMENTATION RE: MESSRS. O'BRIEN, PIERSON AND MUELLER INCENTIVES, PERQUISITES AND BENEFITS MEMORANDUM FROM ROBERT B. O'BRIEN, JR. TO ALL OFFICERS AND DEPARTMENT HEADS RE: CHANGES IN MANAGEMENT STRUCTURE MEMORANDUM FROM ROBERT B. O'BRIEN, JR., CHAIRMAN TO FILE -N821BJ RE: SALE OF AIRPLANE
DX 564
XX/XX/XXXX
OAM004 1260 - 1262
DX 566
07/07/1987
WOQ654 0109 - 0112
DX 573
11/03/1989
WOQ645 1674 - 1674
DX 574
12/21/1989
WOQ628 0408 - 0408
1 Pursuant
to Appendix A, Paragraph 16 of the Rules of the Court of Federal Claims, this exhibit list identifies with asterisks those documents Defendant expects to introduce into evidence. Defendant may seek to introduce into evidence other documents on this exhibit list if the need arises as well as exhibits on the exhibit list of plaintiff and plaintiff-intervenor, which are incorporated by reference.
Case 1:93-cv-00531-LAS
Document 253
Filed 01/22/2008
Page 42 of 236 Page 40 of 233
AMBASE V. UNITED STATES Case No. 93-531C TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST (DXs) BY EXHIBIT ORDER
as of 1/22/08 Exhibit # DX 575 Date 12/22/1989 Bates Range ADIIS Range WOQ628 0367 - 0367 Description
LETTER FROM BRUCE W. BEAN, ON BEHALF OF ROBERT O'BRIEN RE: SECURING A SHORT TERM LOAN; CONFIRMATION OF MR. O'BRIEN INCENTIVE BONUS FOR 1989 MEMORANDUM FROM ROBERT B. O'BRIEN, JR., CHAIRMAN TO ROBERT C. WALSH, PRESIDENT RE: MEETINGS WITH MARSHALL MANLEY LETTER FROM ROBERT B. O'BRIEN TO GEORGE T. SCHARFFENBERGER, CHAIRMAN AND CEO, AMBASE CORPORATION RE: EMPLOYMENT CONTRACT PAYOUTS LETTER FROM ROBERT B. O'BRIEN TO GEORGE T. SCHARFFENBERGER, CHAIRMAN, PRESIDENT AND CEO, AMBASE CORPORATION RE: ONGOING COOPERATION WITH AMBASE MEMORANDUM FROM ROBERT E. MCCARTHY TO BOARD OF DIRECTORS, OF CARTERET SAVINGS BANK, FA RE: PROPOSED AGREEMENT WITH GREAT WESTERN BANK
DX 576
02/23/1990
WOQ600 2155 - 2156
DX 579
03/23/1990
WOQ604 0003 - 0003
DX 580
04/05/1990
WOP338 0773 - 0773
DX 581
06/04/1990
WOQ682 1487 - 1488
to Appendix A, Paragraph 16 of the Rules of the Court of Federal Claims, this exhibit list identifies with asterisks those documents Defendant expects to introduce into evidence. Defendant may seek to introduce into evidence other documents on this exhibit list if the need arises as well as exhibits on the exhibit list of plaintiff and plaintiff-intervenor, which are incorporated by reference.
1 Pursuant
Case 1:93-cv-00531-LAS
Document 253
Filed 01/22/2008
Page 43 of 236 Page 41 of 233
AMBASE V. UNITED STATES Case No. 93-531C TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST (DXs) BY EXHIBIT ORDER
as of 1/22/08 Exhibit # DX 585 Date 04/01/1991 Bates Range ADIIS Range WOQ674 0947 - 0950 Description
MEMORANDUM FROM ROBERT O'BRIEN TO GEORGE SCHARFFENBERGER AND ROBERT WALSH RE: RETIREMENT MEMORANDUM FROM THOMAS J. O'ROURKE, SENIOR EXAMINER TO LEO O. MCCABE, EVP CARTERET SB FA RE: GDV FINANCIAL (GDVFC) $55 MILLION LOAN PORTFOLIO REPORT OF EXAMINATION, CARTERET SAVINGS BANK, FA DATE OF EXAMINATION JUNE 4, 1990
DX 593
08/30/1990
AMB066569 - -066569
DX 595
06/04/1990
AMBNP028465 -028508 WOQ685 0366 - 0366
DX 597
05/14/1991
MEMORANDUM OF ORAL COMMUNICATION BY MICHAEL FINN WITH TOM O'ROURKE RE: CSB 1990 BONUSES/ARBITRATION LETTER FROM MR. KRAMER, VICE CHAIRMAN TO ROBERT B. O'BRIEN, JR RE: NICKERSON LOAN DEFAULT AND REPAYMENT OF ADVANCES EXHIBIT "A" SUMMARY-- CRIMINAL REFERRAL DUE TO ACTIONS BY FORMER CARTERET EMPLOYEE RICHARD C. TAPPEN
DX 600
11/22/1991
C-AM-A-0383427 -0383427
DX 602
XX/XX/XXXX
KH090916 - -90925
to Appendix A, Paragraph 16 of the Rules of the Court of Federal Claims, this exhibit list identifies with asterisks those documents Defendant expects to introduce into evidence. Defendant may seek to introduce into evidence other documents on this exhibit list if the need arises as well as exhibits on the exhibit list of plaintiff and plaintiff-intervenor, which are incorporated by reference.
1 Pursuant
Case 1:93-cv-00531-LAS
Document 253
Filed 01/22/2008
Page 44 of 236 Page 42 of 233
AMBASE V. UNITED STATES Case No. 93-531C TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST (DXs) BY EXHIBIT ORDER
as of 1/22/08 Exhibit # DX 625 Date 12/18/1990 Bates Range ADIIS Range WOP763 1005 - 1005 Description
LETTER TO CHARLES O'TOOLE, MANAGER OF CORPORATE ACTIVITIES RE: SALE OF FIVE CARTERET BRANCHES TO BANKERS LETTER FROM SCOTT D. SAMLIN TO CHARLES P. O'TOOLE, MANAGER CORPORATE ACTIVITIES, OTS RE: RESPONSE TO COMMENTS OF NOVEMBER 20, 1990 OFFICE OF THRIFT SUPERVISION/ NORTHEAST REGION COMMENTS ON SALE OF FIVE BRANCHES. INTERNAL MEMORANDUM FROM JOSEPH P. KEHOE TO CHARLES O'TOOLE RE: OPERATIONS DENIAL OF CARTERET SB'S BRANCH SALE APPLICATION TO SELL FIVE NEW JERSEY BRANCHES TO SUMMIT TRUST AND SOMERSET TRUST INTEROFFICE MEMORANDUM FROM DAVID DORGAN TO CHARLES O'TOOLE RE: CARTERET APPLICATION TO PURCHASE IBF LETTER FROM CHARLES P. O'TOOLE TO ROBERT B. HUNTER, ESQ, THE HOME GROUP INCORPORATED RE: REGULATORY CAPITAL MAINTENANCE/DIVIDEND AGREEMENT
DX 628
12/03/1990
WOP763 1395 - 1398
DX 630
12/04/1990
WOP763 0700 - 0701
DX 631
02/05/1991
WOP326 0618 - 0621
DX 639
04/11/1988
WOR060 2499 - 2501
DX 640
11/28/1988
C-AM-A-0367000 -0367000
1 Pursuant
to Appendix A, Paragraph 16 of the Rules of the Court of Federal Claims, this exhibit list identifies with asterisks those documents Defendant expects to introduce into evidence. Defendant may seek to introduce into evidence other documents on this exhibit list if the need arises as well as exhibits on the exhibit list of plaintiff and plaintiff-intervenor, which are incorpo