Case 3:02-cv-01302-JCH
Document 449-2
Filed 08/15/2005
Page 1 of 4
SHAWN POULIOT V. ARPIN VAN LINES 3:02 CV 1302 (JCH) DEFENDANTS' SUPPLEMENTAL OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBITS
EXHIBIT # 1a.1bbb.
DESCRIPTION MRI films dated October 23, 2001 and October 30, 2001 Pharmacy records
OBJECTION
2
Relevance; foundation; authentication
3a.
American Medical Response records Waterbury Hospital records Hearsay; foundation; authentication Hearsay; foundation; authentication Hearsay; foundation; authentication Hearsay; foundation; authentication Hearsay; foundation; authentication Hearsay; foundation; authentication Hearsay; foundation; authentication Hearsay; foundation; authentication Hearsay; foundation; authentication Hearsay; foundation; authentication
3b.
3c.
Shaw Rehabilitation records
3d.
Consultation and notes from Cremer and Tharp Offices notes from Johnston, Dankoff and Cremer Summa Health System Admission records Office notes from Cremer 01/29/04-06/22/04 Office notes from Slezak
3e.
3f.
3g.
3h.
3i.
Notes from Dankoff and Johnston
3j.
Emergency records of Tharp
3k.
EMS report
Case 3:02-cv-01302-JCH
Document 449-2
Filed 08/15/2005
Page 2 of 4
EXHIBIT # 3l.
DESCRIPTION Summa Health System Discharge Summary Office notes of Dellinger
OBJECTION Hearsay; foundation; authentication Hearsay; foundation; authentication Hearsay; foundation; authentication Hearsay; foundation; authentication Hearsay; foundation; authentication Relevance; foundation (as to Plaintiff's life expectancy in view of injury); hearsay Relevance; foundation (date uncertain) Relevance; foundation (date uncertain) Hearsay; not sworn; foundation; authentication Relevance; foundation; prejudice Foundation (not an accurate representation)
3m.
3n.
Surgical/office notes
3o.
Surgical/office notes of Dellinger
3p.
Cuyahoga Falls admission records
4.
Life Expectancy Chart
5.
Arpin Corporate Overview
6.
Arpin Corporate Brochure
7.
William Tweedy Statement
8a.
Ruhl Forensics-Arpin Inspection Photos from Ruhl Ruhl Forensics-AutoCAD from Ruhl Photos of Learnline Unit Invoice Manifest Shipment Booking Orders Bills of Lading Invoices and Orders
8b.
9a.-9c. 10. 11. 12. 13.
Case 3:02-cv-01302-JCH
Document 449-2
Filed 08/15/2005
Page 3 of 4
EXHIBIT # 14. 15. 16.
DESCRIPTION Computer Inputs Computer Outputs Emails re: Shipment
OBJECTION Foundation Foundation Relevance; foundation (as to some) Prejudicial (as to 17a.) Relevance; foundation; authentication (as to 18c and one-half of 18g) Relevance; foundation
17a.-17j. 18a.-18p.
Photos at Scene Blalock Investigative Photos
19. 20.
Ruhl Angles When Loaded
Liftgate with Cart Retention System Relevance; foundation; hearsay Blalock Diagram of Site Maxon Warnings re: Maintenance Relevance; foundation; hearsay; authentication Prejudice Prejudice; relevance Relevance (as to date) Relevance; foundation; hearsay Relevance; foundation; hearsay Foundation; hearsay Relevance; foundation; hearsay Relevance; foundation; hearsay; privilege
21. 22.
23. 24. 25. 26.
Photos of Ulcer Day in the Life Video Arpin Corporate Facts Liftgate Warning
27.
Liftgate Warning 2
28. 29.
72-25A Installation Notice of Duty to Preserve
30.
Arpin's Admission dated August 7, 2003
Case 3:02-cv-01302-JCH
Document 449-2
Filed 08/15/2005
Page 4 of 4
EXHIBIT # 31.
DESCRIPTION Arpin's Special Defense dated October 6, 2004 Arpin's Admissions dated December 15, 2004
OBJECTION Relevance; foundation; hearsay; privilege Foundation; hearsay; (from Summary Judgment papers; Plaintiff put to his proof at trial) Relevance; foundation; hearsay; improper expert opinion (R. 702)
32.
33.
Pouliot Videotape