ta ‘ *· ‘e ‘ www
.-, `rrxfaw l
'·‘‘ . tl-
4 United States Court of Alppeals 03+ I
{J - Fon rm: A — _
sacorm cmcurr l CDU el O
l JUDGMENT
l
“ At a stated Term of the United States Court of Appeals for the‘Second Circuit, held at the
Thurgood Marshall United States Courthouse, Foley Square, in the City of New York, on the
l9"‘ day of May, two thousand and six. _ i
l
l l
Before: Hon. Dennis Jacobs, QAQHHT U;____,:_& {
Hon, Bargrmgton D. P&1'l<€I`, l Qlala U lll: dl“°°··° l
Circuit Judges y é` _ _ A _
Erm. David N. Hwa, , ° HAY 19 zumi ta ,
District Judge* l "·i¤~,%B A. 6ga%
Docket No. 04-4783-cv ·S‘ ‘ll"‘ll“l"“` ` 1 .
SC¤Nio C\F\G°\ . i
l
KELLY PHANEUF, , ,___
· l ::2
Pzamwappezzam, i §‘¥igf‘ p §# t ,.
V. { ~ {_ ` ·
. l Fx {
DORENE M. FRAIKIN, KATHLEEN BINKOWSKI, PLA1NVH.LE Bi). OF ED., TOWN OF PLAINVILLE
· AND ROSEMARIE CIPRIANO, i ‘ U ·
Defendrmts—AppeIlees. Y- i ‘
. Appeal from the United States District Court for the Dis `ct of Comiecticut. l
This cause came on to be heard on the transcript of reco d from the United States District
_ Court for the District of Comiecticut and was argued by counsel
On consideration whereot§ it is hereby ORDERED, AD GED and DECREED that the
judgment ofthe district court is REVERSED, and this case is RE ANDED for further proceedings
in accordance with the opinion of this Court.
· ‘ FOR THEC URT:
a * *2* ROSEANN .MAc1
. nm -
. __ r 1»l`§
E Cf`f'*'T" JAY?. Arthur M. H iter
` . . A Motions Sta Attorney
* The Honorable David N. Hurd ofthe United States District és for the Northem District of New l
i York, sitting by designation. I I l
;
ISSLIC BS Man HICZ l
t — IO [ I5/o 6 " Y
— ·e 3 - ,- A g fi yi é.iiii`;`QQ, _ `i`i‘ s i· ‘~ ·=
€,gE,g;g· _ e-e-.-.-........ ‘ . Q . j , g , _· g _· _- - at A - .~= .¤¤·Z·¢=t · sl
r · A
. _ _- _ , » , F * ~ es
[,__,:;,_,_,,__i Q _i , ‘o·s·e-e-e-.-.. I . I . .` . f . Q o Q , ED ·`s‘ · E ·" - ET *5 ii
{;¥:‘¢’=€-`°'é‘?"=‘:!‘€·(?;‘·1·;‘:‘=T*.=**:·::7 - D · - rr-"···-—-~—