Free Memorandum in Opposition to Motion - District Court of Connecticut - Connecticut

I Case 3:03-cv-00671-DJS Document 44 Filed 12/22/2003 Page 1 of 2
I · .!1, I
. UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT ““' _r__
I DISTRICT OF CONNECTICUT `
ROBERT KALMAN, PRO SE : PRISONER IIE 52 ID 2r 50
I Plainrgif II, I I _ 5
I V. : Civil Action No. 3:03Eid6Q71=, I- J "
I (DJS) (TPS) ‘ " “ I I ‘ _
ROBERT BERGER, et al., :
1 Dwndants, December 12, 2003 I
I I
I PLAINTIFF’S MOTION IN OPPOSITION AND OBJECTION I
TO QFENDANTS MOTION TO DISMISS 1
The plaintiff hereby objects to the defendants Motion To Dismiss the I
1
complaint pursuant to Rule l2(b)(l) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure on the basis I
of abstention. Plaintiff asserts before the Court that abstention is inappropriate because I
defendants’ argument is unsupported and fails to mention many of the undisputed facts, I
and repeatedly mischaracterize the statutory tiamework of the Psychiatric Security I
Review Board.
Moreover, plaintiff asserts before the Court that abstention is inappropriate because I
he is not seeking to enjoin pending state proceedings, abstention does not apply to this
case, the legal issues in the State proceedings are distinct. The reasons therefore are set
forth in the plaintiff s Declaration and Memorandum of Law in Opposition to defendants
1
Motion to Dismiss.
R0BERrKA1.MAN I
Pao SE, PLAINTIFF I
Respectfully submitted,
’®¢Qeo-EI 1
Robert Kalman, Pro Se I
Whiting Forensic Institute I
P. O. Box 70 O’ Brien Dr
Middletown, CT 06457
Tel: (860) 346 9408
I
‘ 1
. --. I . I _ __ _ ___ _, _ __ j T`i""""""i’*’é’“""i*"’3*
4 I I I I iiii‘i·eseseeeee-
?'E5—`£iT=‘I5'é¥e’;=;’-;e·r1=y-_- - —» . _- _ _ __ _ if if I —_ I _ - -`-M-;£`:<-3-1%k>sg42JS;t:5¥_·g=
»- I I I I iiii·iieseeeeeee

,, Case 3:03-cv—0O671—DJS Document 44 Filed 12/22/2003 Page 2 of 2 I
!
U 1
CERTIFICATION 1
I hereby certify that a copy of the forgoing Objection To Defendants Motion To
Dismiss & Exhibit’s were mailed in accordance with Rule 5 (b) ofthe Federal Rules of Q
Civil Procedure on this 16, day of December 2003 to:
Richard J. Lynch
Assistant Attorney General
Henry A. Salton 1
Assistant Attorney General 1
Kerry Anne Colson
Assistant Attorney General `
55 Elm Street, P. O. Box 120 1
Hartford, CT 06141 — 0120
Robert Kalman, Pro se,
Whiting Forensic Institute
1

I
1
1

1
2 1
`*__""—"1"|1 i