Free Declaration - District Court of Delaware - Delaware

Case 1:88-cv-00263-SLR

Document 371-11

Filed 11/06/2007

Page 1 of 8

Exhibit 9

Case 1:88-cv-00263-SLR

Document 371-11

Filed 11/06/2007

Page 2 of 8

Fees and Costs for Dr. Robert Livingston
EXPERT FEES Description Date Hours Spent Hourly Rate Work on review of the Motiva 5/22/2000 Study Plan 4.5 $185.00 Work on review of the Motiva 5/23/2000 Study Plan 5.1 $185.00 Work on review of the Motiva 4.6 $185.00 5/25/2000 Study Plan Work on review of the Motiva 3.8 $185.00 5/26/2000 Study Plan Work on review of the Motiva 5/28/2000 Study Plan 5.9 $185.00 Work on review of the Motiva 5/29/2000 Study Plan 2.9 $185.00 Work on review of the Motiva 6/1/2000 Study Plan 3.3 $185.00 8/18/2000 Data review, trip preparation 4.1 $185.00 8/19/2000 Trip to Delaware, Review data 8/20/2000 Review data Meeting with study team, field 8/21/2000 preparations Field trip, meeting with field 8/22/2000 personnel and L. Hall 8/23/2000 Meeting and data analysis 8/27/2000 Travel back from Delaware 8/30/2000 Data analysis, written report 8.5 7.8 9.2 9.0 5.5 8.0 5.2 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00

Amount $832.50 $943.50 $851.00 $703.00 $1,091.50 $536.50 $610.50 $758.50 $1,572.50 $1,443.00 $1,702.00 $1,665.00 $1,017.50 $1,480.00 $962.00

Page 1

Case 1:88-cv-00263-SLR

Document 371-11

Filed 11/06/2007

Page 3 of 8

8/31/2000 Data analysis, written report 9/1/2000 Data analysis, written report 9/2/2000 Data analysis, written report Review of Motiva Project and 4/29/2001 report preparation Review of Motiva Project and 4/30/2001 report preparation Review of Motiva Project and 5/1/2001 report preparation Review of Motiva Project and 5/2/2001 report preparation 3/9/2004 Review Motiva Report 3/16/2004 Review Motiva Report 3/17/2004 Review Motiva Report 3/18/2004 Review Motiva Report 3/20/2004 Review Motiva Report 3/21/2004 Review Motiva Report 3/22/2004 Review Motiva Report Analyze data and write re3/23/2004 evaluation report Analyze data and write re3/27/2004 evaluation report Analyze data and write re3/28/2004 evaluation report Analyze data and write re3/29/2004 evaluation report Analyze data and write re5/1/2004 evaluation report Analyze data and write re5/2/2004 evaluation report

4.2 5.5 2.1 6.2 4.1 7.1 1.2 4.5 8.6 4.8 2.2 8.3 10.2 8.1 5.1 6.6 7.1 6.2 7.1 6.1

$185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00

$777.00 $1,017.50 $388.50 $1,147.00 $758.50 $1,313.50 $222.00 $832.50 $1,591.00 $888.00 $407.00 $1,535.50 $1,887.00 $1,498.50 $943.50 $1,221.00 $1,313.50 $1,147.00 $1,313.50 $1,128.50

Page 2

Case 1:88-cv-00263-SLR

Document 371-11

Filed 11/06/2007

Page 4 of 8

Analyze data and write re5/3/2004 evaluation report Analyze data and write re5/4/2004 evaluation report Analyze data and write re5/5/2004 evaluation report Analyze data and write re5/6/2004 evaluation report Analyze data and write re5/8/2004 evaluation report Analyze data and write re5/9/2004 evaluation report Analyze data and write re5/10/2004 evaluation report Analyze data and write re5/11/2004 evaluation report Analyze data and write re5/12/2004 evaluation report Analyze data and write re5/14/2004 evaluation report Analyze data and write re5/16/2004 evaluation report Analyze data and write re5/17/2004 evaluation report Analyze data and write re5/18/2004 evaluation report Analyze data and write re5/19/2004 evaluation report 2/12/2007 Review Means Report 2/13/2007 Tel. call Mitchell Bernard

8.4 6.2 8.1 3.2 8.2 8.5 8.3 9.1 4.5 4.5 9.2 2.4 9.6 4.5 10.2 1.3

$185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00

$1,554.00 $1,147.00 $1,498.50 $592.00 $1,517.00 $1,572.50 $1,535.50 $1,683.50 $832.50 $832.50 $1,702.00 $444.00 $1,776.00 $832.50 $1,887.00 $240.50

Page 3

Case 1:88-cv-00263-SLR

Document 371-11

Filed 11/06/2007

Page 5 of 8

3/27/2007 Review Texaco records Review Texaco records, write 3/28/2007 report Review Texaco records, write 3/29/2007 report Review Texaco records, finish 3/30/2007 and send report Review Documents for Means 4/23/2007 Deposition 4/24/2007 Means Deposition 4/24/2007 Case Preparation 4/25/2007 Means Deposition 4/26/2007 Means Deposition Review and document 4/26/2007 development Document development and 4/29/2007 data analysis 5/21/2007 Analysis of data for the report 5/22/2007 Analysis of data for the report 5/23/2007 Analysis of data for the report 5/24/2007 Analysis of data for the report 5/25/2007 Analysis of data for the report 5/26/2007 Analysis of data for the report Analysis of data and write 5/27/2007 report Analysis of data and write 5/28/2007 report Analysis of data and write 5/29/2007 report

2.7 4.8 8.2 3.1 4.8 8.5 1.2 9.1 4.0 4.9 2.8 5.8 6.8 6.2 7.8 8.9 3.8 8.8 8.2 8.1

$185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00

$499.50 $888.00 $1,517.00 $573.50 $888.00 $1,572.50 $222.00 $1,683.50 $740.00 $906.50 $518.00 $1,073.00 $1,258.00 $1,147.00 $1,443.00 $1,646.50 $703.00 $1,628.00 $1,517.00 $1,498.50

Page 4

Case 1:88-cv-00263-SLR

Document 371-11

Filed 11/06/2007

Page 6 of 8

Analysis of data and write 5/30/2007 report Prepare and send report to 5/31/2007 NRDC 6/13/2007 Corrections to statement 6/14/2007 Corrections to statement 6/17/2007 Review depositions 6/21/2007 Response to Kampman letter 6/22/2007 Response to Kampman letter Preparation for August 8/1/2007 deposition Preparation for August 8/2/2007 deposition Preparation for August 8/3/2007 deposition Preparation for August 8/4/2007 deposition Preparation for August 8/5/2007 deposition Preparation for August 8/6/2007 deposition Preparation for August 8/7/2007 deposition 8/7/2007 Work with NRDC lawyers 8/8/2007 Work with NRDC lawyers 8/9/2007 Deposition 8/10/2007 Deposition Review of our data and 2005 8/11/2007 Report

7.8 2.9 3.6 1.2 2.5 6.4 4.6 5.1 8.5 6.8 9.1 8.6 8.2 4.5 5.0 7.2 8.2 7.0 8.2

$185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $185.00 $250.00 $250.00 $185.00

$1,443.00 $536.50 $666.00 $222.00 $462.50 $1,184.00 $851.00 $943.50 $1,572.50 $1,258.00 $1,683.50 $1,591.00 $1,517.00 $832.50 $925.00 $1,332.00 $2,050.00 $1,750.00 $1,517.00

Page 5

Case 1:88-cv-00263-SLR

Document 371-11

Filed 11/06/2007

Page 7 of 8

Review of our data and 2005 8/19/2007 Report Review of our data and 2005 8/20/2007 Report Review of our data and 2005 8/21/2007 Report TOTAL: EXPERT COSTS Description Date Trip to Delaware to review 8/19/2000 data, air fare Trip to Delaware to review 8/19/2000 data, car rental Trip to Delaware to review 8/19/2000 data, motel Trip to Delaware to review 8/19/2000 data, tolls Trip to Delaware to review 8/27/2000 data, airport parking Trip to Delaware to review 8/27/2000 data, gas Trip to Delaware to review 8/27/2000 data, total food costs Motiva Project Report, copy of 5/2/2001 report Motiva Project Report, mail 5/2/2001 costs 3/27/2004 Phillip Homann assistant 4/11/2004 Phillip Homann assistant

8.3 8.7 7.2 567.0

$185.00 $185.00 $185.00

$1,535.50 $1,609.50 $1,332.00 $105,883.00

Amount $382.00 $258.64 $133.50 $12.20 $26.00 $21.25 $139.95 $10.19 $3.45 $162.47 $213.64

Page 6

Case 1:88-cv-00263-SLR

Document 371-11

Filed 11/06/2007

Page 8 of 8

5/15/2004 Phillip Homann assistant Means Deposition, taxi from 4/23/2007 airport to hotel 4/23/2007 Means Deposition, dinner 4/24/2007 Means Deposition, breakfast 4/25/2007 Means Deposition, hotel Means Deposition, airport 4/26/2007 parking 4/26/2007 Means Deposition, lunch 4/26/2007 Means Deposition, dinner Means Deposition, hotel (3 4/26/2007 nights) Means Deposition, air plane 4/26/2007 ticket for Livingston 8/7/2007 Livingston Deposition, air fare Livingston Deposition, hotel (4 8/7/2007 nights) Livingston Deposition, total 8/10/2007 food costs Livingston Deposition, total 8/10/2007 taxi costs Livingston Deposition, airport 8/10/2007 parking TOTAL TOTAL FEES TOTAL COSTS TOTAL EXPERT FEES AND COSTS

$444.00 $24.00 $6.41 $2.19 $455.72 $32.00 $10.80 $7.25 $889.68 $659.60 $579.60 $1,752.69 $178.45 $81.30 $40.00 $6,526.98 $105,883.00 $6,526.98 $112,409.98

Page 7