Free Answering Brief in Opposition - District Court of Delaware - Delaware

Case 1:06-cv—OOOO2-G|\/IS Document 11-12 Filed O2/14/2006 Page 1 014

Case 1 :06-cv—OOOO2-GIVIS Document 11-12 Fnled O2/14/2006 Page 2 014
``'`'```'``'`nvvnn`''“'''''`'`''''`’````'```''`'`”'`'`''`''`'''''''''` * .. `W M W`?W% 1;»¢i:V 111 V1»;:: 2 »V1·» .·
Q g °é E:1 ·1‘‘’ ‘
i/é ., { 0 > ‘ ig VVv‘V 5* »V—‘ V2.? ».. lrZ·.¥»s’=f·¤i§Z¢;@·"-* .·.~ ix? ;A’ ’r=V’-v· é-ij? ` 1
§ 0* .41 Q; , i =;;“,~·¢§2:¢· . ;‘.¤‘;=;r_:·.;=é.j“=¤; ,·'· .’·= ‘ .;,’·_ ,.,: . ~ .-»-. `6 ,&”·* g *5 i€:‘:s.5 ‘:1=; e.:·::··:<.J. ‘11~~ iz ‘-1-:· L ‘ ‘’v, Q ·. w
; 1 2 -~,/,··{}<» *4- y .:,.,:4;.-»·-;,.·.;»;’ 1: ~ an ; *·) ;.,;. · -, ,·-/’ v · , ·
;% *1 L {Q ‘$g~ ’ 2 ;’r L ··,··v’,. r cx v-._=v— v.’’v.v vi A ‘ ’.v’=’»v
'`Vv * (D " W § iii}? ;*‘·. ;¢1·f"2.?:[ ·v`'·‘, I ··;. 2 ;;~: . ,, ""·¥" ”· , - ,
: 1 *4-* * A _Q ·¤ .;:·:,zw;:·:,:.;·::;.;:.·./ (3 Q kt : e 1 .;:·:.·· ,··’:» · ,>·4_. »· ., · · 1. ,-¢
, *3] +· 4*3 Q {iz ··‘;‘· 1 ·;,v . ,·=‘,·‘ #1 ‘·,· , ‘·‘,, .-·=‘2£-Z; M » ,,,, .‘ · ,
'/7 5 Li; Qi Q '-I W4, w .’‘-=i YV ’·’vvV··=‘ “ ik ·’‘‘ .
4 Q?-· e ¤- ¥ :,‘ i O :v .‘‘, ···— — wg ·f ’ ·’”"?‘**"*, ;’ ·· _,·‘
sz E 11· - cg 1i··=’‘.·‘ 2 a2 .».1Vv~V f .--—1i »·~·v 5 T 1f‘’ . *;:12
3 V 111‘ ~·1 11111-·. 1¤*v
Qi E *1 v'·: ‘``` ’~,’ .—`~` 2 `'V·;; V - = `'»' . Q ‘” 5 ’~11 1*; ``··1v 2 I V'‘‘ · v’v‘'’ X? ’v'v V ,,,“ ‘ A ..
Q (D »..:‘; ? ‘‘1·¥'·· ; 3 · · ¤ ;*g";.;j ,;.vv ·v·. ;’ `* · . · J
“’*"` , . ·.1. , _ ~r " "
1 3 » v·,‘‘» ’`“` j
, §»»· TZ.; 55:5% ,—,=§ ai ’:vv V, [ vvvv ‘ Q J;1 ‘ M ·
' ’ 1’V· f M .,,4 J .
§ · »----——----»- ·11‘ " ¤-1 ·· ivv *
'‘‘‘‘‘‘‘‘‘‘‘’ '· ·» ,·,- " ==*· 1
.,’;'l < V·;- V, ··‘.‘ , A A
6 . -
{ sz - —’Vv v‘‘‘‘ ‘ ‘ ’/,, U
* {Vi E *¥?*T G t * 1v·’'· . V Z ’`,, f VF; >’`' ‘ , '’ '' ,.
2 °` 8. ,vVV` ’ V V-v‘ " 1 _,_` ‘
5 z » ; Y M z wi cu H ‘ ‘‘’, V ’v,v ;; “ · ,.. ‘ ,_.
~2 » g g ,2% KK 1. Z — vvv’vv 2* 1; E ., -;v=,.
é · ‘ z —-F ‘ ·‘ ·‘ ‘ QI "e* ’.,
1 Eg i .¤.. E _ Q Q-; 2 3 » V ~ V V`V# * _.;. ‘ ;; ,`,; ~ ._
g i cg °§ .~ V `' ’y·‘ 1
1 .3 § @ 11/, . 11,/ A ‘:. . _.; .·,J.VV A ,VV.V ___V _ , »;V‘‘ :--; =~· ·*;a· . . —V`.
1 “ F ’ he? § Ci
» -121 W- s ; (D: - Q "" C
# $1 4 ‘’’‘‘’’ ze; *·~ i E? ¤> -*: O ‘·· " =-
* gr Qi {i ~E'_ E . 2 E E E °’ `° ··— “’ g V,
t? * ¤ 2 gg 1: 1 3 ru Lg az 5 Q O °§, 3 E
: V T ? : - ·*·’ -
Q ‘*’?—* ¤* S E E ‘* G fg gj U, E E E °’ E W E
5 ,, 1a; E W < E $2 ¤ ·- ¤ -9 ‘*’ 9 .0 .92 5
,, m..;..» ; < lu : O = ·· - -5 *5 E .c: C w: Q,
‘f ; ·‘- V" ·-· (U ·· E — *"' *·’ >
s; O I *¤. m q; _Q *•·· q; Q, : _Q m GJ .- cn
E' q, '···v· mi w if "" °° T6 ’: E *5 N *;*2 2 R: T5 '¤
E? ‘*’ *0 8 5 CZ (D <1> Z va *‘ "‘ 2 *“ ¤>
an 111 2 si? .¤. 2 = 3 $3 E 9 `6 3 E `°6 E Eg
=— GE'? §+· 'U cu O 07 C
,•··» `E .....j ig C; 3 $5} g *1-* 2 3 V9 N g 5 ig E 3 .9 g
* *7 - mz? ;‘‘ 1 *‘·‘‘‘= mi = " > -- .- ··
1 CD ' ggzi Z 'g E 3 E é E `§ U *3 52 g 3 %
1 ,§¤ ‘-<~ ·’·’—’ '’’· Q * I N C |··· 0 3 ‘
¤ 5- 111.1 E § } .2 "$ m g E ·§ T; E g @2 @3 8
’ ./éx, ,``» ¤> 0 ·—·
Q" <¤ 3 ¤ 6 g, **5 5 9 9 *5 5 8 `¤ 5
lf O §¤>% S m '1 ¤¤ ¤ 1; N 0 E 5 m -¤ C ,,,
-- "” §?»‘¤§~ 9 vn if 5 T =¤ E *" 2 w c <: § °° G
§ ;; ‘**"ig`“- qj {H =<>§ =- ·— · ¤7 qq fl W 0 0 E CD N ‘°" 3 .... *7* qq
¤ ·- %~-E; Q §-¤z.$2 3 s: ¤>-K L. ~•·· 0 ‘“ — C _;
Lu ;,.~ > =t]J§€€w $5* =5Eg.EEg5g€—9v$2f§¤
, , i. ’v·v G) Q1 :3 * *1** é *3;, "" m E E 'U (U V7 ·E "" KU E
_ · — ;.·:§•S_.·:=a Q. gl; O G > O C Q) O G) Q) .,.7 3 G)
Q .. "J I Z5 °’ I U 75 ·; *·‘ ‘¤ ··· > :
i ¢·W#<- N " U) 3 N ,¤ '” -— 'O C U) C '*
ci ” ¢E= '*;E;Eg£, E U) > 0
ii >, "’ Q .5%.*2 E B SEE 2 up 8 2 3 % $ E ·§ LE
222 . vi ·~ 9 5 ¤· E =¤ 3 -6 cn W ¤ 8 °> -5 ¤
1. ‘ *1* ... O O .9 W ¤> (U 0 3 0 E U, _; m
*-*-* x ...,..,,...,. - ....,... J` V D O N D GS E .C 'O 5 53 > KU Q. Q.
& E . ,................., . ...................... .... .......... ...
·-*¤·· ''’— Ev 5*% ;. ¤— 3
- ~ .=*· .‘· ‘7 Z
g * E
$5-5;;;;-:;,;.M¤§e;.&{;§\?¢4z§z=·=¤·=s»M% E;1 C -> Q ¢;:¢;·;:¢.-£»...=:.5:;.-.·&;*,54z:;=¤;1p;=.$zwz€·,&·=:;=;=:&=:=¤ e = € -+-* In V) JB C
‘’-*·'-‘ ‘ .9 N E as § S 0
Lu E1‘ ·‘‘*1i P1? % $ .,, g EZ $*.3 Q gg § 3
=·-··— 2 ** *‘’*:*’**’:*E ‘ ’ <» ¤¤ -= :; <» <¤ ¤» ia GJ u
I" gis? 9 § (5 Q 5 Z E i <`5 E 2
·==‘ {V '¤ "’ * 3 0 °5 E E ‘*’ T; Tu °° VJ
. 1* mas LL x e 9 E m **6 vn M .- .- E
5 ·Z, S ag _ _ @>;g*·:¢·>=::*¢=¢{rj; ; m g °h » ~-— C U) m 5. Q) (U Q th (_) L- V}
$5, ,,, *6 yr, $2 2 2 .9 -: E 8 Q °~ x = ¤ ¤ <> 9
ul - -»- g g i 2.3 1 8 g g E- § E2 g Q? § E E § E § fg
` 2 - ·-»-· · ·»·· · -··- -··· ”: E , u. u.
m .% Z E E 5 *7*

Case 1 :06-cv—OOOO2-GIVIS Document 11-12 Filed O2/14/2006 Page 3 014
.. U ` s. 2
2 E ·.» 0 W c
·— C `— G, ,_, *,;,' cn g an 0 W ax ».. W ··· E
¤ ¤ U ‘¤ g :3 ¤¤ 3 .9 5 ¤
=j E .9 Q ¤_ N `J U E ,_. .9
g>§€G‘°;_‘ U, 5 g..‘E?'¤ cu §_ 9
0 3 0 : ·¤ · 3 5 C E 0 °’
c U) H- ... (D @ C >• C G
0 C ·¤ ,=. - cu qa g ¤1- >_
¤= 5 9 E g s: EE E 0 0 '° ,,; ¤¤
q Engg ¤¤ D§g¤>5 cn wg ,.
, . ¤_ 0 E db q; .C ·¤ C .- :2
V 9 3 .. 2 ¤¤ .5 § 2 ;- < 9; 2
i ¤ > S 8 ts ¤ u :2* -¤ 8 . 5 5 E *°
A Q · ·-· s: · ·— c ~¤ as 9 c E vn 5
$7;-6`¤m " E20 .... -I-_ qg 5 ·- .... _•__ O CD E m 5 U E q)
E ·· 0 __ 'U Q .,. Q ; E up C/J 3 .1
,,_. ¤ C : °’ ¤. O *-2: ¤¤ ,_, cu ».. U »·-
¤> " 3 -¤ E E ;~—"’ `E Q <¤ r: 2 w
$8:.,; .9 g_gB:*;,§ 3, =§
w8§$ ¤ mziégs - gv
q; 2 >, 0 JQ .5 3 .9 U 2 U, x: O g
Eeéz 2 2aE&9¤ % E-
L. __ \•T· gg U
U tig? 6 Qmgggé “ EE
·9‘6°<»> ¤¤ -=¤.§<¤*as¤ -5 2m
O -
· ¤> c E 5 6 c eu <¤ ¤. Q c L.- .9
"’1{g‘;T; ·¤ •;'Z'i'>9¤-0 .9 ME
8 1. 6 B 1 U ¤> .9 *~ U *5 E <¤
· ¤> G . w °’ .c c: Q C C
; C Q, E` I u E *-· as ... °> E #= >·
“ =5c¤v>g E `§.'2‘:€§°¤.E E *5%
,‘Q ¤ Z 3 ¤ E M O 5 - 2 ·¤ qa 5 E:
°’ as 0 C ·»-· ‘¤ 0 E :
-¤ ‘•· - O- gp G9 O O >» VJ U): q, up '¤
mg O m gj¢n>.;EGJ D.E-5***.:3 UT SQ:
2* 5 -4-,; ,;’=2¤"’ _,_, .Q<¤mE¤-.: 'Q CE
¤3~§ S E5 i$E$·% 2 ‘é’%E’Ee`§ U sg
.5% ‘>'2 2 .;*3 °;¤>5*: T6 <&°UG. C 1.: 0 g '— as I .9 ¤- Q U1 *·’ m •* . :/1 "’ ns C Q-
@3 Z 2. ··°> ‘¤E°’€°‘·‘. ( 2;§¤>>-<¤ 5 ‘°'E
-**3 vs "“§ uFu'·»-· gm§'G§'¤ 4.. *·‘¤g·9$¤> E 68
‘ wg ·¤ an GJ ·¤ " > 1:
$<¤ gx mm O§.,9·!-’-¤ E mggwmgg 3 -.5 A
Gm U o1- ...¢¤·— -— ,,,Eq; 5.; :93 5% 25% ¤§»=.·2;9 ¤. 5*5-1».%“’ ,,, m-E é
@*6 3: og :g.,,< “5¤gji,<3g E ¤—6<¤3gS»g &¤» 3
gf; JB E9 tug gjwggg 8 §;~zE’§>§ iv, gg at
“· 0 . ¤>... ···.<:0E<¤ wg EE ui- E-j°§ Yg__*;5¤·»;; ua o¤$_g.9E 5.9508 3
98 -¤- E; c'g~ §_¤<¤-‘g»—_g E .E¤>¤»-¤&.¤ .*5'¤.£... za
-·¤ E'-*“& - <>"’-¤¤eE... 3 ‘*§.—"§§*¤s 2’m»¤%g U
<¤>.-E. -->°¤¤¤ "’.9¤- ¤><¤¤>¤=¤¤¤,¤ -- °¤·¤ `°'“‘?’¢=6£ E¤°— ¢<5¤¤2&¤; E ‘>%%»;··¤>¤¤ U§**%3» $
EOE EENEGS Ogg v-·OgOE_§_d.: I6 °°E3§E‘5·,§ EE‘j·6: `L
$§£ IEEIQ `§—<¤§2{2E2·U3¤22 §.z·°?I8¤*$§°’ I,‘;‘,$I?§ g
·— ‘¤ ·· ~ ‘ ‘” ·- -· >~ M ... .9
§S’¤ ¤·€£€%’. §P*.s£#§€&%z§~‘1 %E£=5g‘6%·"‘5-3 $5*3€~ ;
¤‘§#2 égegae =352£'E~%S°&§ `$=?`¤8E¥E‘5»$¤>2 §¤8E$ 5
zeé a$2§2 3$$$e£¥§2$2 §€e£§&§§2 aéeéé V
1 g 3 2 é ”“”‘“"“”””““`“"””“"“““““”“““““““”`““'““““‘°§
g ¥ 1 `‘<. §
2 1 i i é i..:. . =V.
· .’’.v z
°° g -¤ E E § 1 .= i Qi iiiiféf ..: 3 .
E .9 E ; ; é g 2 i -- ;-E i
°‘ ° 16 =¤ 2 * % 2 ¤ ¤ =.= i .42;; ‘._@ -·-;
.E I U GJ § 5 2 rn 2 5 4; i Q} a ’
U — 1: "* z ; ¤> 5 i we ; 9.* i ..... i
E E Q w ¤> § . FE $ , Q ° {3
’Z .2 2 % § E V. i E S ws ... ‘” .2 ... ..... 1
¤> U < >~ m ¤ E 5 w i ¤ *’* °° 1E
U :•: E O — é i a e 5 ¤> >» 2 .=s·· z··a · G4: a
.-...<.-¤m —¤.m.,9. .·¤.._ ...w. .... ge . . ..... ..... ,
~> vw .2 *6 ¤> c s : u. ·-· 2 E 2 ¤ ·- <¤ S g Ni Eizi 3 ..·. ; =
E E Bf LU ff < § E E 8- 8 E 5 § 5 _¤ re .g;§»..£.. . .... . .... W,. V I

Case1:O6-cv-00002-GIVIS D0cument11-12 Fnled O2/14/2006 Page40f4
2 i
za
if-
231

gm:
2 22:: 25
>~ =r> E Z
2 3 g 2,,
E E 2 2%
M rv cv 2 _..,,...
~·¤22:sm ~ “‘ t E 25
2 Q 2 = 2 ·; Q. 2- 2‘°
!*~··&¤‘5 2 22, 2 2: ¤< é 23
§ .: 2,2 2 2;
2 2g S 2* 2L
2 222 ¤;· 5 23
2 % i 9 21 2%
2 M 26 2 221.
2 _ mg ........ ,
2 >. u 2*% iw 2
2 . 1. 2 vn- 2C ZZ
2 2¤ Wg 225 222 3
E FU gi g
V E ` HE 2,; E
2 2 2 ¤ if 2 wi 2g E
5 2 "’ ¤ §5 20 =;
E Tu g 5 =u ....,... E
¤ ¤¤ -; 3% .&
2 · 2 C W 2<¤ E
2 2 >~ (D 2 CQ 2
2 ; 2 M 4.4 ;,_ 2 R1 G2
éé 5 ¤— $2 222 ;
2 — “<€ $2 E zi %
2 C " *' 2 2
2 U! O 2 W 2.C .1*2
i 2 @172 > Zg 2=
z 2 ‘>· 2*- 'U
2 2 B-?-`G, 2: ,*6222 £¤ 23 ¤
2-MSE z i-UC; 5s 2
§ 2 mmc 2;. "‘2 5.2 iw .2
i 2 ¤J Ei q; Em ......,, E,
= 3 M E Gm &" Q
2 mu? .2, S32 N5 2***
5 T M50 ·-= ,_1f2 EE EE 2
°’-E ¢¤ mm2 SE 2LF ¤
§ 2 Emu E »,—;°~2 ;<> 2 .=
E 2.....,...2`, , ,,..,.,.,,,, . ,,,..,.,,.,. , § L: (5*6 S
$ moz U :52 gm 5 2Q ,,, 53
M i *5-·-¤ 0%% vi E *5
° `ZEQ 5 gu? &·; ig 2~> $2 §
E ¤> g Ec? wm c 5 —
2% -¤ »—·¤*52.. ;2~2 $5 2i img; 5
wg Q Hyg;} gi? LEAE2 ij; .2. ;—2§ 2»222 2 g
¤‘“ tv cw M ¤2·- T6 22< us
2 1k+ Vi > **0 ·•·· 2 ........ Q x
222, .22, 2 _.22222,,2, 0 50E <:;: moi °¤ = G ¤
$ 2 w 2..¤¤g *-*6 -95:2 5*% Q 25M .2
2 ua 2 gmk -— L w > X24 2222 2. ¤
(E .,.,. .,.,..,,, . 2 1. ·2—~ q) C
3 Z Li$I\c¤¤ (QQQ2 LLK Q SUE E
g z .,.. ¤ 3;, c2 4 Em v -2
22-2 z$2;222‘T ¤?¤g2 <2 2 2¤>9 3
`°“'”"”‘”“””°” 2 >· § 2;.22*2 mg 5 H-=2 §2¤ & % E
i =¤ ·¤.2‘·`6E Qi QES2 3 s
¤ *3:1*2;; mu. MZZ2 #*5 59 2,2 »~
< Z m 2 >~m cu 2*6 (D 5
égg §
2<>~>
w `E
2.22*6 $
22-6% %`
22-E Q
2E Q T5
cv §
2°‘5 E
2** ¤> g
2§“ 2
g
2§§ ·?-E
2DC< ac