Free Reply Brief - District Court of Delaware - Delaware

Case 1:07-cv-00239-JJF

Document 66

Filed 04/23/2008

Page 1 of 7

nJ -mE UN\iE~ sr~t; b\S~C.T COUP-.T
to 9,. \\\~~\~\C.T
)
) )
)

o~~El.A\JARE

V
WIL.LJAM5
e+.t:.1.

}

J
J
)

'be~rJc:.t't~

1
)

J

FI LED
APR 232008

-\-o \-k. de\e~ e--\- b~. :Ye.~er ~I
,no+\o,", ~('c-

V\c..''"\\\'~ \ 'R\c..J"C.l
C.\ G,r-k. 3"(\
(\('\10('\\

l

or yoS' ~Io,,",
f./t!J '"'-

\>,'0
~~h,:\ \eSr0rds

-to

+\..e..

Y\C.lon+. ffr

'~\n-.\"",c:o('~ \h.~v>"c..f.ICln.

.n
~r
C-

Of'\. (Y\c..r-d\

I~\ 7.co~, Ylc..u,+,f{
ufO''''

h'd'/""''-''

~\-'I\&-"~ \Nvc.J..ol'"\ ~ ~e.J

Ue.\(~
f6'.. ~

/l'\'

~ d,~'(\psec) bi

4nJ f5eJc.rt.-f o';'J..er meC'/'c<./ I ffC/d , lie-+ e;.."J or btLI"~ fj.../ /"rl?(r,r1I", ..:/e- /.j$" ~~
c...\(:~c.\.\ .... ~ Sc-f. ~,,+.....

Ie !-her

<.tCA::/b/

~, .... ~

.bf' B'N\''''''.
""'eel-

d,.C4..K1.

rf"olfC-

~~ ..c! vf~ +~c. Y/c:.I"~IHS ~cvfY'c.1 er..J~, .. s &..II..cJ.....
,>"'\ t~IY'C>{.,o""
5'0
50

~ I \ H.~


,I--

I

S hkc~

fk.llc.li" t,{}(


""If

~'C(.uJ 0,... ~"'~~4- ~-'It\ .

f~/s ~;',,,,.... 5'kd be r~r/.


Case 1:07-cv-00239-JJF

Document 66

Filed 04/23/2008

Page 2 of 7

a\
uj/c/....

~\:. .\.1"-\,"\\';) \ we.r .\UN;.-\'~
feol

e..N- ,......

y\or"",~1 ~~'~l'" hocJe."c.r
l/,rl-I /o_.lS
/f'

~+ ~~I __ h(' ~ln"ICl'"

IS .J.CJ

/~O/( c..-I- IJe- f.I~P .. I-II-'5 B

:J-~,,,e \,c>+\.~

+f'e-llY'e,...+ {S

t./~('el'kcJ. 7J., r
I'"

r-kk_... r /
.J.k

~4".r6':::i +k.. ,...4'c!C.-"-/··I''- d't:''".>4<'-Se.. d-Aor- ~ \'e.s·Ps
,..,..,(!J(~f -r.,~ \>Ic.,.-J(~' /s I tI
~/c./,..+,~.c.r

,

I- 5Vc~t::ed or

-{.J,.eS'c.

A!'c,.,fj. ~~

+~=> ~(D'"

h'1v')-!

6~ ~r----krJ.

-;;.+ \ ZOO~, AV{'c.lC)?tc-\,...4,(:.( 'S--J d- t.Jc~ kesJ.J -l~+ 1{'u+h>ou-t t/~'S t./~('(' 4~J,
.....

~. A~ o+- ~rc.."

~ 'bt!.V'~ c-

H4

~ Ge.I'-cJ~lpe
IS

u,..",::>

o,..do.p.J

--J o..{<)~
r'oc./.


0....

l'll~rh/ors'j

CJl..~c..\... +~ 'lc.,,,~.Ct-

u..,.r-,-J(~ a.4'c.,"'~ k
Vh'c.l

I\- u.. ~ cJ.Sc.vss~cJ
)...0, ~CJ

4\.-\.

{.J\~\-. \..L~

lcc.J f\<:>\~ +k-l-

+rcc-f-.-t


(,../cNIJ be.. he5~ .J.c. s4-r'\,. rJO'J
I"....

i.e.

~o\J~k 1~ls c.11-" ....,
\ \ '/&/'" .c.I"...e-r
I')

fe

(/J..c.."'"

{,./ov,J
0 ......

Svt"c..I~

c.c.o/S<...

0-/ ~r
I"

hvV" d"~"H , \c.s4J
f"\t'J.t:-l ~\\(.... .
Crt

+k..

~ Ute.""I"::> l"~(...l~

clou.-1__.J.eJ
0'"

~'s

\-\.c.. ~1c;.''''~1~~
/Y'v'

-f.o Svcc-eJ

~J,.,,~~ ""erl f5

J J.... S
'-/').

~~, eo~
v'~

+- 6 c- <1 ".'....Ic...d.
hQ&.l'c.v-

~c.",\-~~ \~ JI<:'~__S#J UJ,..+",- H'-t~-t,~,S B
(\0

l~t.I......h.

/l"'1-$i

~.....

cJ('c....If'

le5S

fl.c.,....

"rno~-4-~

-l-

11"D'~1-k.,...

I'Ve/

(v"e.-!-tonY

~ +k ~~c..tllv~ VI~I i... e..J. ~ v".-.. . t {-.J a..lc,,~ l~ t.JJ.-I. \'e"ckrs
('c;.-\~

t\..L.

I

~ ~O("~ -k, ~t{'..I"+ ~r'~~-I-I"'\.Cr'~. T~ [c.b

J./or(<..

e-/

(\V\es,

c,.\";x) \('(:.-C)Ct'1

Y-+I~~.cr

leJ,s orcJtU'e.J b~ br B,,,I\.'ore/Ct"t"J

c..leu(~
e:/!'c.

Sk./
!.e.('r

fU tt+
c.le,..c.

O(\~

$f";lc

V(,.~I I",~ t./-s

b~ j,{~, Itt:'-

fJ..c..l(c'~+f5 Ics-J. 146 or../~./ 67
/74rhr'.J.c., 01' o/'e-.r

04,,,.,... Uu:.J.... lJ&~ 1,,~,c.oI 1c-.61... .J J.'.?~
/.,..{S- ..
/Je.-/

..f /~'-/ vI? o

ay-';:?tf>,,.../. le...vt ""5 br kt:'rc1-J1

10 \'cW fY''--

.J.~ {.k. \~4(.A·,c.. ...s. ~I"'~c- .. ~ ~D<."G.r 5",,_ Cf ~/l1t.5 ~N.

GIVe-.. +k

e-b-:- c,..J e;..Nc.~c-J..eJ /-l..tS ""e;,/.,~ ""'-ff6~ ~1'4"'ho/

Case 1:07-cv-00239-JJF

Document 66

Filed 04/23/2008

Page 3 of 7

\JHERt: f09..t
~,c..\..oeJ £. c.\cz.t-K. ~

I

~ -Jk~ -rt>('£~O\M~ ~U~6~. ~\.... ,,41.(!.f
\'e."1 ve s-k

'~,ec.-+\v)\~
+10'1'\.-

f~ .. +

A. ~

/Ylof;c"

fo r ~ ~ \ ~ \"'"....~ \ '" ~ U~

~e.. ~('c:.i'-~ ed.

,.

x-aa;d
> ,

)\\c:..\""C.~J f" C.\c:.f'k ~('
~-o ~~ 95"(;/
lJ
I \

("t\ \ "'::::'

~ ,~e....
\q~.

-if'" I ().I, 122,'6:
~....-\-c..

Case 1:07-cv-00239-JJF

Document 66

Filed 04/23/2008

Page 4 of 7

IN l'Ht; UN\TEb srATEs

'b\S~\ct COURT


FO~ 1\-\'C ~\~ ~\cr- oF' ttLA VARS


RIC.HA~~ E CLA~KI -.ro..
~~'t\·hH
V
W'rUJAf'\":) e.~.~ \

~

)
)

)

, )

CA. r-.b.. 07'2.1ct nF" .

,

} )

AFFlt)AV\T OF ~\(.'r\A~~ £ CLARK S"R.

\N ~~s~tJc..E 'To bR.~\t.Jr"J\oN~ o\>?OS\T\ON To WE PlAINTIFFS MoTioN Fo~ PRELltt1vJARY lNllJr/ct\QN
5TATE Or 1>ELAL./AQl:~
CCvNT'"l OF d~cA5rLe '"'

J...) 11f:."'" Ovet' )~ '-jt!.crs
~) \.c.._ c..V~eG('\t'~
~~\ ,,\

0.('

a~e .

In. ..J.hlS

.(', .

?<'o Se'

",.,~.#e.r- c."c! ~~ +~~


s), l. \¥.v'~ ~ee.t'- d'~'f\O":.e.J bCo( ~r. VeJer Bl""I17" of
t../' 4-\.... .H..~ H~~-I,-t's P.> VIN~, ~IJ dlc.~(\Os~~

'bc.\t'~ \~c:.c:..{c..J
A~f'll. ~ I 2co7.
HC-t)lfl-l.1 S

&.I~'S.

I"Y"ccle.-

L/)' ~~s

0+

.\ok. \,<~v\-t~

0+ be.A"'~ \,(,re.c)+eJ UI-4...
/)'\Co.

lS f

b~. ~\t\t'\CJ""" o'bt....\t"\/!'d f~"" ~vbSe9uc:("-\- *'-s-/.I"'~ I c..f.J.c.r- ike... d,Q,~'f'O~

or U~~l{.IJ,.I~

~ ~ ~lt"'t'IO_ cskoJIJ ~c.~ \'~~r-e.j

I~ -IJ...~

l(\~dlov'" dl~~sc... e::.be..4c.r. be' fY'c.obf'G.IJ

Case 1:07-cv-00239-JJF

Document 66

Filed 04/23/2008

Page 5 of 7

5:). 70 .f{,r+k" ~e("~~4.vG-~c. 'r-.\ ~ \",c..o"-'Vc.~c:."c..e.... I....... i \..'S rnt:.+le.1", Of"l ~~l""\b4tr-- ~\ 2.c.o'1- \ L.)A-, 'See\'" b" ~(" ~e:l-cr\61"'{\IO"'- 0,..,
c::::..
(..1('-

n:.\cAeJ ~"'I"'ne.r-

c.rd ke... ~ S~u('cJ
,\

,."...e....

,.,.,~ Hepdodo'S
b

)3

'-/e5
1/

~CI('\e. h.,~ e'!-ce-+ /../Drd5

t./CI'C...

he:... L.lc."';)

oVe.-r j.J,..e.. "'~~

\n.

Av~v')+ I

\ ~"e... £f"\V~~\c::..' evealo.. . c ~ o~ +\..1 ~ '~('o~

(\oSe$ .

,). \ \- \c::, eo,...."s',de.re..J cs+c.~ . . ,..J ~{"Q\oC-4\ onc.c:. a....
I
I

rc...\l e.,...~

I

~

cJlC.~ 'f'.c'~LJ t./I Jh. ~Ic..~ \..~. ~ ~ -k, r\cr~. Of'l,:\ \ '"'~ ~ ,4- V\('c..\

\oc..J +e~+~ .forc..""/~I~"""'- O+c;/7'"IO(\'fJ..~
~ ~ 51f'
..)o,h'lc;nrler

I/..e.

/1l/tu·..{'.... ~..J Ie:.'"

r .... ~~f"'t>'."s....

I-~ l/I{'c./

IOAci j..e~ 1-$.

+~ S+ S I

h- ~-\e,,- ~'''''\O" "e~)~+~ J -/.0 +c:.k~ +~ Vll'c.l l o~eI 0 '" ~ \ \ v4a.r -C",r-C.J, ~ tJC-rC- 0 roIet'e 0'. (c k.-. d-'-( -ff'S-I) .
eo...

7)

A.r(X"+~C"

d\":>'~\~
\"t:..ccu·"

c..ro('e.. meA +1 OtH' J \ Y'
{)e~\ec....+t!J

b, ~e..te('" ~'f''''O'''~ \ ~""Vc..\-c.",c.e. ~~ I\VIY' bel'"" ~. ,,,,- +k c::.hovc:... br- \611''''' Ie. .....
,."c..

0+

+0 (2.1lc.r

1-0 +J..fl...

I,",.ree-.f.,ov~ oIteSe... SC!.. cloc.-f.o,;'

(~IC.\ I c; f ), (Y")c.+-le..r- 0
/Y\e...

+' fc.c +- 'hi'

'EI/J 5

ke... . .J \~ 'e.~j

1-0

IJ..-<=..

1",..('ec..I,~s oIt~Sees~ Spe.Ctc.! J S I- CY\ .::r(j~, 2~(1 Zoo';! ,.

4~~rc)<. \{hc.+l~ L/'&.,. ""Df"'·H..~ c:..~.,l~ br ~\I'\t"\lo",
ieS'iej ~O~l~'\k- .for

kY'e-J

t

'r.c.J

He.y, ~,4-, 5 ~

{=.c.cAe... I)cr'/"J.,

5

~ c:.,....J W"c:. S
earJ101o\1 '5-t

/>~ee:/t!!J I~ 6e. ?1t&cIJ"" -II-- ~rt::.- a-t I/..~ /"",re..J.,~e,,:) ~~Se.. S
~e-4r. ;:::'r../-J..cr,vlc<'f!,., br ~\I"'I'\IC:>"'" ,~ c.. t./ho I~ lccG.f"G.e.J +01 ~ ('c...J.Ic:..et. m~04c(,.e.t /1v+
"3~~C.1 c..l. "'>

1Vc-!((leJ
Co.

/;''''(?(!c.-I,a-vs

o1esec.~c

+,

Case 1:07-cv-00239-JJF

Document 66

Filed 04/23/2008

Page 6 of 7

or-.

SLJoR!J /d AND SLJ/sCSC-f2./13Ei':::> ~~~ /ne /-J.,,,, ~ ~o-C' IJpr ;:)..oo:?j

Ka,~,..,~

Case 1:07-cv-00239-JJF

Document 66

Filed 04/23/2008

Page 7 of 7

{;,";

K\c..k."J £.- c..L.c.r-Y"

~);'~f.-'t9£/~'~ ~ " '~ U

~~'i"

\ ~ "~

:Y\'o

'i

lAu ~ ~ .. ..\1\ ~ ..., .~ -. , I,' ,to " l.l\i'~~ t u

O~~\cL of n~ C/~rk V(\/fed'S-fr./e..s "":::::,'-;,-H---1C+ Covi'LT c:eqL/ N k'5 GT. tocJe.;60f.. I?

till '3f-o 11
fV\

I'\:::, e-

I '1'00 I
I